11 ms·
The most interesting phenomenon revealed so far is that the room-temperature superconductor people and the generative-LLMs-are-God people draw on the same limit
by jeffbee 3y ago
The most interesting phenomenon revealed so far is that the room-temperature superconductor people and the generative-LLMs-are-God people draw on the same limited global pool of credulity, such that HN cannot be flooded with both ChatGPT worship and superconductor speculation at the same time.
- dekhn 3y agothe singularity isn't going to implement itself, you know.
- catchnear4321 3y agonot with that attitude it isn’t
- cantrevealname 3y agoThe next breakthrough we need is with fusion technology. With unlimited fusion energy, room temperature superconductivity, and (soon) artificial general intelligence, the singularity won't be long off.
- AS04 3y agoFusion would be massively boosted by having room-temperature superconductivity anyways.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, if there is a breakthrough that puts us closer to fusion, it's room-temperature superconductors.
- dekhn 3y agoYes, a combination of fusion, superconductivity, and AGI would indeed be transformative. It's hard to anticipate what the results would look like. Good reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-scarcity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-scarcity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale then follow it up with a bit of 1993, https://edoras.sdsu.edu/~vinge/misc/singularity.html https://edoras.sdsu.edu/~vinge/misc/singularity.html and https://web.pa.msu.edu/people/yang/RFeynman_plentySpace.pdf https://web.pa.msu.edu/people/yang/RFeynman_plentySpace.pdf (oh, huh, I just noticed that There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom starts with a reference to the discovery of superconduction)
- wredue 3y agoWe’re nowhere near AGI dude, even with several breakthroughs. AI today is a glorified search algorithm.
- soulofmischief 3y agoThat doesn't mesh with the daily insights I gain from asking GPT-4 novel questions and receiving answers that integrate a much wider knowledge corpus that I have in my head. You can argue all language is a form of search, but that is missing completely what transformer models are bringing to the table, and not just within language.
- robocat 3y agoInjecting random noise into your brain and finding intelligent connections says you are smart. Your comment says nothing about whether we are “near AGI”, only that we find images within Rorschach blobs (as a metaphor for GPT4 generated text).
- soulofmischief 3y agoThe context of my comment should make it clear that I am responding to this > AI today is a glorified search algorithm. and not the comment about AGI, given as that is a pedantic argument I have no wish engaging in. > only that we find images within Rorschach blobs I'm sorry, I'm not sure you understand what GPT-4 offers. Things like generating novel code to solve a novel problem are not finding "images within Rorschach blobs". I think you should sit down with the technology and explore with a more open mind.
- Workaccount2 3y agoI hate to break it to you, but your brain is also just a glorified search engine.
- boppo1 3y agoWhat fusion breakthrough is needed that isn't superconductors?
- cthalupa 3y agoIt's one of the biggest ones. My understanding is that there are still some others that need to be figured out, like "The physical structure holding the thing getting the everloving shit bombarded out of it by high energy neutrons and causing it to degrade and fail over time"
- IX-103 3y agoComputational electrodynamics. We need to design better geometries for reactors so that we can channel the plasma flow to better improve containment while quickly removing wastes from the highly compressed energetic region where fusion mostly occurs. If we could do that, then that mostly solves the issues from reactor degradation and significantly improves efficiency. The trouble is that at such high energy levels the plasma flow is relatively chaotic so high fidelity models are required to predict the behavior accurately.
- Gud 3y agoIs this really a requirement, or a nice to have kind of thing? Commonwealth Fusion Systems are using a pretty basic design and seem pretty confident it will work
- Turskarama 3y agoCareful with this logic, the same thing could have (and pretty much was) said 50 years ago about fission and microchips.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fragmede 3y agoGiven that I only have to go down to the eighth item on the front page to get to a story about LLMs (past three stories about superconductors) are you so sure about that?
- poopbutt7 3y ago[flagged]
- civilitty 3y agoYou're seeing a lull in ChatGPT-specific posts but there are two LLM posts [1][2] on the front page as I write this (compared to three LK99 posts). There does not seem to be any conservation of credulity going on here. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36958731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36958731 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36958175 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36958175
- sheepscreek 3y agoOn a related note: I am deeply disappointed by how OpenAI has managed to continually dumb down ChatGPT. I’m sure the shortage of NVIDIA H100s and the demand for their APIs shooting through the roof has something to do with it. Perhaps they’ve switched to a quantized model? Who knows. And yes, LLaMA 2 is awesome. Progress is being made. But it’s slowed down. The novelty’s worn off. Now we’re lacking some fundamental plumbing to reach a useful AGI. If anyone cares, Bard is proving to be way more useful these days. Especially for research work. And Claude is bar none for document analysis.
- refulgentis 3y agoIt's not dumber. You can verify this on their models with any prompt you ran at 0.0 when it first came out, I did. It's the exact same model run the same exact way. They've repeatedly confirmed this.
- minimaxir 3y agoThe ChatGPT webapp is not the same workflow as the ChatGPT API.
- girvo 3y ago> It's not dumber So I absolutely agree with this. And yet this meme persists. I wonder what's creating the feeling that it's "dumber" in so many? Perhaps they're just noticing the limits that always existed previously? I'm not sure, and am interested in others thoughts on it.
- sheepscreek 3y agoChatGPT as in the paid subscription hosted by OpenAI. Its quality has deteriorated. It will miss the simplest details in the prompt and hallucinate a lot. I’ve only noticed this before on models with lesser parameters. In comparison, Bard and Claude are getting better with time.
- larperdoodle 3y ago
- refulgentis 3y agoThere isn't a singular group of people (if you will, a They) fulfilling this criteria. I don't understand why it's worth being bitter about something so joyful and fundamentally human in realtime.
- rel2thr 3y agoTheres some crossover. Isn't this exactly what a rogue super AI would do first? - run some simulations and discover a superconductor - then write up a paper on it ( the paper has some gaps but humans take it and run with it) - human technology and computing power rapidly accelerates. - the rogue AI's powers increase exponentially
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoHaving played through Portal 2 again recently, it's like the equivalent of GlaDOS scheming to take back over the Aperture Science Facility while she's only getting 1.1 Volts from the potato.
- mjan22640 3y agoThe oneshot or short session manner in which AI are typically used does not have a rogue potential. The AI would need to have a virtually unreachable goal, and run in an endless loop, to be able to drift its goals to be at odds with humanity.
- bratbag 3y agoAs you say it, I'm tempted to try it. Doubt I'm the first.
- BasedAnon 3y agopeople forget that AI was already in control of the markets since 2014 at least. it's bootstrapping
- SamPatt 3y agoThe least interesting phenomenon revealed so far is that HN is split into a group who are entertained by watching and discussing emerging tech / science news, and a second group who are entertained by disparaging the first. I enjoy watching floating rocks and talking to computers.
- Valgrim 3y agoSame with me, it gives me the same feeling of "Living in a science fiction world" that I once felt when cell phones or Google maps came out. Of course even tough I still use both profusely every day, the feeling of novelty wore out. I expect the same will happen with this.
- NovaDudely 3y agoThere was a line from the movie 'Ted', that film about a child's stuffed bear coming to life. It was something along the lines of "No matter how special and amazing something is, eventually people get bored of it and move onto something else." It will probably be like this for us. The children will just take it for granted as they grow up with it, we will be endlessly amazed by it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- forward-slashed 3y agoTo see the real value of something, take it away. Humans are greedy (mathematically) creatures, so there's no point in mulling over assets which are secure. The awe is the exploration phase of a piece of technology, but the remaining value is still valuable.
- jiggawatts 3y agoIn an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation a redshirt used a tricorder to check the weather and said they would have to beam up soon because a storm was approaching. At the time I thought to myself: “Bah, that’s never happening, it’s pure fantasy!” A few years later I told some friends we’d have to pack up our picnic because according to the weather radar app on my phone we had about 7 minutes until we got drenched… no wait… 6 minutes. 5m:30s later we were standing under shelter watching the storm front rolling in, and I remembered that Star Trek scene. We live in the future.
- philosopher1234 3y agoThe biggest threat to Bitcoin wasn’t apt criticism. It was a nexter bigger thing.
- bottlepalm 3y agoBitcoin was really 'done' 10 years ago. It does what it does and there really isn't much more to it. People tried to keep the hype going with DAO's, earn programs, smart contracts, NFT's, etc.. but crypto was already done before 'web3' even started.
- pjc50 3y agoLike Theranos, the secret ingredient turned out to be fraud, and the big threat is jail.
- keepamovin 3y agoLol thank you. That’s hilarious. Also, I think it kind of sucks that all that UFO reverse engineering didn’t yield a high temperature superconductor before this… but I guess what can you expect when you sequester away all your materials, silo your research and in effect keep your neural network of nodes (as scientists) really small. This open shit, as flawed and maybe annoying as it is to some people, I think it’s a much better model of science. It’d be great to see some UFO/UFO tech breakthroughs happen like this too.
- JMill 3y agoPerhaps, but the reverse engineering efforts you mention may have already led to incredible breakthroughs over the past few decades. Lasers, integrated circuits, Kevlar, fiber optics, and more technologies were said to have been seeded among the research community based on recovered UAP components. This is based on Army Colonel Philip Corso’s account in his memoir, “The Day After Roswell”. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_After_Roswell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_After_Roswell
- keepamovin 3y agoI know that. I used to believe that too. I really wanted to believe all the SSP stuff (Corey Goode, David Wilcock, et al). However, my view is now that all of the talk over advanced tech has actually been a propaganda/influence/information-warfare campaign to: 1) assert that gov/corp is in control when it's in fact not; pretend it's not at all challenged by superior species, not at all ignorant of 1000s-of-years-more-advanced-tech 2) cover up the ignorance, powerlessness and failure to make progress on RE crash materials, an embarrassing secret that seriously dents their mandate to rule 3) provide cover for the cover-up to continue in secret, trying to buy themselves "just a bit more time", "maybe the next crash is the one we'll finally crack it" It's much easier to engineer a narrative (something the US is absolutely world-class fantastic at), than it is to engineer understanding and tech from advanced civilizations possibly millions of years advanced from us, while operating in oppressive secrecy. This is not an attack on the US, they're just the most prominent. All countries have failed with this broken, deceptive, but understandably flawed and human strategy. It's a controversial view because it flies in the face of decades of this influence campaign. In short I believe that all "military insiders" coming forward to say they saw military successfully using/making UFO tech are liars part of this campaign. That includes, especially, Greer.^1 I think the current push is much more truthful--so far. It was said a couple times by Grusch and others that we may not have made progress. And suggested that the push is designed to get it out into the open where people can study it and make progress. I don't think that noble and sensible push will win however. Folks inside the coverup will likely see this as just another "pressure release valve" we need to satisfy the public enough, let them work off some steam, then we can either: A) undermine it and discourage them from pursuing in future; or, B) we can let it all go away, and in the background scare lawmakers in the same way we've done for decades (show some evidence of something that frightens them, or is a national security threat, or personally intimidate them) and they'll do whatever we say. One reason I have for believing this current push will lose is because the main bobbleheads in charge of getting it out: Knapp, Coulthart, Corbell and Zabel are changing their tune and now making noises in support of continued coverup. In ^0 and in a recent video by Pope: - Nick Pope: folks aren't ready - Zabel: fuck disclosure, just need confirmation - Corbell: confirmation has already happened - Ross & Knapp: secrets must be kept I sure as hell hope not, but when you look at who we're up against: the secretkeepers have been doing this for nearly a century, and they've always won, and they believe they're right. To them this is probably a storm in a teacup, and it will take more than some grandstanding (good, but ultimately weak) politicians, and a bit of skeptical public interest, to blow the lid off. I think if people want information they should try to contact ET themselves and figure it out for themselves. You can't count on the corporation to come through for you, and the government is captured by the corporation. That much is clear. Treating gov/corp as a trusted intermediary/priest class who have access to "divine knowledge", and then desperately waiting for them like a "good dog" for treats, is just reinforcing the power dynamic of gov/corp control over citizen-subjects that itself is challenged by the awareness of ETs; and begging for such treats from such actors, when all they've done in the past is lied to and abused the public in this way, is a false hope and a flawed strategy. I think the true way to fuck with the secrecy system is to cut out the middleman, rather than hoping a continuously-proving-itself-to-not-give-a-shit-about-the-public system is going to become benevolent and "evolve itself". For insiders, it probably all makes perfect sense, and seems completely necessary and ethical. They have been and, until the technology's developed, will remain in, a constant state of war-time clandestine secrecy, with spies and traitors to that being executed essentially, and sophisticated counterintelligence operations continuously ongoing. The war is over the most and only significant asymmetric advantage ever discovered by humanity. Successful acquisition and deployability would mean instant world domination, or so it's assumed. Compromise of this goal is, understandably to insiders, inconceivable and impossible. They are convinced that "losing" will mean the end of the world. If I've been able to convince you of this, even a fraction, imagine how easy it is for insiders to convince themselves of this everyday. And imagine people that sure, that convinced they're right, ever going against anything they know, and revealing it? Not going to happen. The more we push, the harder they'll hold on and resist, sure of their goal. Like a dog a big stick. For outsiders, it makes no sense at all. Essentially, to regular people today, these folks are stuck in a WWII mindset. Talking to them with their obsessive preoccupations with secrecy and war, would be comical and impossible for regular people to understand. Maybe they're right. Or maybe we are. No one will ever know, as long as the wall between both sides remains in place. As long as this cover-up exists, the only thing we'll get is leaks and deliberate counterintelligence. I think Grusch is the former, and perhaps, he was merely the recipient of the latter. Who knows. The saddest part for me is witnessing the degradation of American democracy, where the government is held hostage by a select group while simultaneously blamed for the secrecy, forming a perfect smoke screen. In this war, our governments are merely puppets, used as a shield by these clandestine groups, and the people, consequently, are left powerless. This silent surrender to covert entities significantly diminishes the credibility of our rulers. 0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2xSFMkmWg4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2xSFMkmWg4 1: A difficulty is a lot of what they say is true, mixed in with the lies that we have made any progress on understanding or re-creating, alien UFO technology at all. When the reality is we have no progress understanding or re-creating it at all. So contrary to what all these people say, we have no anti gravity, no advance energy or propulsion, we have no advanced medicine or med beds. However, the truth about consciousness assisted technology and telepathic contact and inter/extra dimensionality, and the existence of illegal beyond-black unacknowledged special access programs, and so on is mixed in with his lies. That mix is classic disinfo I guess.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoAnd together, these two phenomena have just sucked all the energy out of the crypto excitation mode.
- dylan604 3y agoYou think all of the news about crypto fraud might have a chilling effect on the excitation?
- dogcomplex 3y agolol same as it ever was
- dylan604 3y agonot really. before, fraud claims were from the non-believers. now, the fraud claims are from the SEC and other government agencies. one can be swatted away with clever tweets, er, xes (what are tweets called now?), the other sees people going to jail.
- raducu 3y agoI've been completely out of the loop, but please tell me it's USDT?
- dogcomplex 3y agostill plenty of frauds either way, just bigger scale. Would be nice if they all get locked up, and/or decentralized regulation/vetting networks arise
- bratbag 3y agoTweets are now Xcretions.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoNope.
- 3y ago
- swalsh 3y agoIt's so hard not to be crazy excited about the future. The past few months are proving to be an absolute breakout for the literal human race. So far we've seen: 1. in Dec 2022 We saw a fusion breakthrough seeing a net gain in energy 2. In March GPT-4 was released, which seems to be a seminal breakthrough in AI, and maybe of our first glimpse in what could become an AGI. 3. In May we find out apparently our government has recovered alien technologies 4. Then in July room temp super conductors just drop Like this is the most insane period of time. Maybe the fusion technology doesn't scale, maybe GPT-5 doesn't scale, maybe the UAP thing was all a psyop, or a lie, maybe LK-99 doesn't turn out. But there's so much to hope for!
- JamisonM 3y ago> 3. In May we find out apparently our government has recovered alien technologies This is a silly thing to include on the list since it doesn't seem to be true?
- ceejayoz 3y agoThus proving the parent post’s “credulity” point.
- xtracto 3y agoWhat's up with that uh? I read about the swore statements during the depositions, and all the mainstream media news, but for some reason HN had radio silence. Is there something I missed that shows it's all shenanigans?
- xorbax 3y agoThey (1) claim not to know what the craft are, which somebody told him contained (2) nonhuman biological whatever It could be a Chinese drone with rat-cell-on-a-chip inside it The guy's testimony was that somebody told him stuff and it seemed scary. Congress made a dog and pony show that a significant chunk of people attended. Parse the details, not the overarching fantasy. The government admitted to doing this in the 70s-90s to keep not-so-strange technology hidden behind The Strange. Trim with Occam. The ticTac videos aren't interesting if you look at the limitations of perspective and remember that Air Force pilots aren't supreme authorities for objectively assessing parallax and assigning airspeed to all moving objects while flying a fucking cracker attached to a rocket.
- stjohnswarts 3y agohow about a 3rd group that is skeptical but not angry ? :) Am I bad that I'm waiting on oak ridge/los alamos/NASA/ONL/university of texas at austin to repro?
- johncalvinyoung 3y agoAs someone strongly in the first camp and not the second, this feels like a very odd observation. I despise generative LLMs and avoid using them at every opportunity. I'm also spending all my free time this week perusing arxiv preprints and Twitter threads. Make of my datum what you will. :)
- serf 3y ago> I despise generative LLMs and avoid using them at every opportunity. why? it's just a tool. despise how it was released, how it was trained, the people that operate it , whatever, but I can't really understand why someone would 'despise' a wrench -- even if it was used really poorly and produced by a shady company with a checkered past.
- fragmede 3y agoSame concept as blood money. To be dramatic, if the wrench was made with ore from a mine where your father worked, and he was killed and the ore was stolen, would you do business with the company that hired the mercenaries that killed him? Would you buy a wrench from them? if one fell into your hands, would you use it? It's just a wrench, after all, but you can see why somebody might have strong feelings about it, even if you ultimately disagree with them.
- jjahdhnmko 3y agoYou really can't think of a reason? Or you don't want to think of a reason?
- julianeon 3y agoGive it a few days, and some dumbass story like "I asked ChatGPT about the Meissner effect and the answer blew my mind" will start trending. See you in the comments!
- sagarpatil 3y agoGuilty. I’m obsessed with LLM and LK-99. And in the past, was attracted crypto and NFT(which was a bubble)
- jacquesm 3y agoJeffbee in the 1947 edition: The most interesting phenomenon revealed so far is that the solid state electronics people and the rocket fanatics people draw on the same limited global pool of credulity, such that TinkererNews cannot be flooded with both transistor worship and moon travel speculation at the same time. Seriously: if it doesn't interest you, you could simply refrain from commenting and even reading. This stuff is the bleeding edge of tech and if you consider everybody active in these fields or talking about it to be starry eyed children then you should re-calibrate your sense of what these scientific discoveries are likely to cause further downstream. The idea here is to find some balance, it's perfectly ok to discuss a new discovery and to consider the implications on the caveat that it might not pan out. But superconductors already exist, there is no reason in physics why an arbitrary temperature cut-off is going to limit them from existing at room temperature, if you look at the trend since superconductivity was first observed there is a steady increase which with ever smaller margin of error predicts a breakthrough somewhere around 2030. It arrived a bit early, but it - apparently - did arrive, and if true will lead to a revolution in power transmission. And if it isn't true then we'll just drop it and hope for the next round, but I suspect that even if it isn't true there are going to be a lot of labs wondering if they can salvage at least some knowledge gained during all the scrutiny of this particular attempt. Similar trends can be observed rectro-actively for practical solar panels, micro electronics, powered flight and so on. All had their skeptics, sometimes unreasonable skeptics and all were proven eventually wrong an those inventions transformed our world and are still transforming our world. You see a stupid silly black fleck floating over a magnet and wonder what the big deal is. I see a glimpse of an alternative future that has a lot of potential implications for how we live.
- throwawaylinux 3y agoDespite the the "strictly no jesting on the super serious hacker news" rule, I think it was just a joke. I wouldn't let it get to you too much. I thought it was pretty funny.
- swat535 3y agoHonestly I don’t find those kind of comments particularly valuable on HN. It derails the topic from a meaningful discussion and the whole thing devolves into a Reddit troll fest. All you need to do is glimpse at the replies it spawned to confirm it. This is why I assume it was heavily downvoted.
- seydor 3y agoTherefore proved that credulity is a conserved quantity, and HN is now searching for the underlying symmetry
- robocat 3y agoThe credulity exclusion principle (philosophistimicated)
- samhuk 3y agoI have to unfortunately agree with the sibling comment (although it was a little too verbose for its point). If, to you, the most interesting thing about LK99 and the developments thereof is tweets and internet forum drama about it, then that speaks more about you than anything to do with anything else. If you don't have anything to add to the conversation, then just don't add?
- lm28469 3y agoIt's one more brick in the hype cycle wall next month it'll be something Panem et circenses