9 ms·
These EV recumbents are too low to be safe in traffic, but at least they are trikes and so a bit more stable than two wheeled recumbents. There are a couple of
by jacquesm 3y ago
These EV recumbents are too low to be safe in traffic, but at least they are trikes and so a bit more stable than two wheeled recumbents. There are a couple of them riding around here where I live and while fast they are a huge nuisance on the bike paths because they're faster than everybody else and the people riding them believe that the rest of the population on the bike path are 'moving obstacles' that they have to overtake, even if it isn't possible (in that sense they are quite similar to the packs of racing bikes that always appear in the summer).
Normal recumbents are also bloody dangerous. I'm a pretty experienced cyclist, have taken many experimental bikes out for a spin. Finally, a recumbent got me, a simple traffic obstacle took the front wheel off the ground and that was that. Ambulance ride, complex double fracture and a 7 hour operation later I can walk so I got very lucky. This was 6 years ago. There isn't a day that I think 'why did I have to try that particular bike, it felt dangerous from the first moment'. Recumbents are not stable like normal bikes are. Anything goes wrong, you fall, there is no recovery. If the circumstances are bad enough that will do you in, if you're lucky, like me, you end up with a daily reminder. Don't ride recumbents in traffic, even if it feels like a great idea, they're fast as can be and you have next to no wind resistance. The failure modes are inherent in the way the bike works and there is absolutely nothing that can be done about it (leg suck, balancing by steering) and they're invisible from inside a car.
Another problem with these is that they have a bad turning radius and don't mix well with other traffic on a bike path because of their width.
Regular e-bikes are also 80% (or even more) efficient than electric cars and don't have the disadvantages.
- jjtheblunt 3y agocars give you an exoskeleton, but e-bikes of whatever sort leave you exposed to the maniacs fumbling with their cellphones, which i see incessantly.
- fnimick 3y agoThat's a policy failure. We can't have people getting into bigger and bigger cars to protect themselves from other people in big cars. Having road designs that leave non-car users vulnerable is a problem.
- Aeolun 3y agoThe only thing I feel save going out in now is a tank.
- jacquesm 3y ago'Drive defensively, drive a Sherman' (seen in the USA on a bumper sticker a long time ago).
- jjtheblunt 3y agoi DO wonder if that sort of mindset is why i see (Arizona) so many 40ish year old moms with huge Escalades or Tahoes (and who are often the ones driving incompetently, distracted).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- megablast 3y agoAgreed, cars should be nowhere near people.
- tbrownaw 3y agoYes, and they should have dedicated infrastructure to help keep them away from people. We could call this infrastructure "roads".
- fnimick 3y agoSure, and then when people need to get places without cars, we just put the bikes and the people on the same road and call it a day. Brilliant!
- Steltek 3y agoCertainly in the US these days, anything that isn't an SUV is unsafe (for the occupants) in traffic. It's a deadly arms race to get as big as you can. The little Fiat's don't even come up to the door handles on an F-150. > they are quite similar to the packs of racing bikes that always appear in the summer Yes! I have to point this out every time people complain about e-bikes on the local path. It's not the type of bike, it's the mindset and the behavior that is the real problem. Regardless, the police here would never bother doing any enforcement on the path anyway so debates about rules or proposed rules is moot. I don't own an e-bike but I'd love to see more e-bikes around. It's more support for bike infrastructure, parking, etc.
- fnimick 3y ago> It's a deadly arms race to get as big as you can. SUVs too - I'm 3x more likely to die in the same crash if I'm hit by one rather than by a passenger sedan. Of course, the real people hurt are the pedestrians and cyclists who can't participate in the arms race at all. Not to mention that leading everyone to use heavy cars for safety every time they leave the house is catastrophically bad for the environment.
- gruez 3y ago>Not to mention that leading everyone to use heavy cars for safety every time they leave the house is catastrophically bad for the environment. It's worse, but hardly "catastrophically bad". >According to Consumer Reports, the three top-selling crossovers in the US in 2018 (Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, and Nissan Rogue) return an average of 10% less fuel economy than the top three selling sedan equivalents in the mid-size segment (Toyota Camry, Honda Accord, Nissan Altima), but provide almost 1.5 times the cargo space. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossover_(automobile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossover_(automobile)
- fnimick 3y agoIt's a lot worse than no car at all - which people understandably don't feel comfortable doing when they're surrounded by vehicles with bumpers as high as their chest. I get hit by a sedan, I break my legs, it sucks. I get hit by a crossover, I'm thrown forward from my center of mass and likely under the vehicle. I get hit by an F-150, the hood is at head height and I die.
- megablast 3y ago> huge nuisance on the bike paths because they're faster than everybody else I doubt this, there is a huge range of people traveling at different speeds, from road bike users, to ebike users, to kids and parents. Why pretend everyone is doing the same speed?
- murderfs 3y ago"Have you ever noticed that anybody driving slower than you is an idiot, and anyone going faster than you is a maniac?" - George Carlin
- crote 3y agoI think you are seriously underestimating how fast recumbent bikes go. They can reach 40-50 km/h without too much effort, compared to the average cyclist going about 20 km/h. In Europe e-bikes are separated into two categories. My country has a "regular" e-bike which provides assistance up to 25 km/h, and is treated like any other bike. A "speed pedelec", on the other hand, goes up to 45 km/h and is treated like a moped. It often isn't allowed on bike paths due to the danger the speed difference poses, and it is even required to have a license plate! So no, just because they are all bicycles doesn't mean they can safely be mixed - just like having a tractor going 40 km/h on a motorway where the rest of the traffic goes 120 km/h is not a great idea.
- tcfhgj 3y agoYet cars being able to drive 200km/h are supposed to drive in zones restricted to 50km/h or even less. How's that even possible?
- crote 3y agoEasy: you make it physically uncomfortable or even impossible to drive any faster than 50 km/h. Simply putting up a speed sign doesn't work, we have known that for decades - you need to actually design the road for the speed you want people to drive. You're not going to drive 200 km/h down a narrow alleyway, for example, you're going to drive through there at walking pace.
- epage 3y ago> Normal recumbents are also bloody dangerous I've normally been saying the opposite. Been riding a (2 wheel) recumbent for 15 years or so. I'm pretty much never going to endo. My biggest risk is falling sideways and I'm low enough to the ground that it is natural to just put my leg down and catch myself. I even surprised myself when I caught myself when sliding on a sharp turn going fast. I can only think of one time I hit pavement (went into a slide with just minor scrapes to show). It had rained recently and my back tire slid out from underneath me during a turn.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's precisely how I looked at it before I got snagged. It's very tricky: you feel safer, but you're not.
- bunabhucan 3y agoDo the thought experiment where you grow up riding a recumbent and you "try" a regular road bike and crash. Your head is higher and likely the first thing to hit an obstacle - concussion. A pretzeled front wheel or flat tyre or collision can catapult you onto the road - concussion plus broken collarbone/arm plus who knows what else. Those aren't injuries you'll get as easily on a recumbent. Instead (as you found) your legs, out in front, take the hit. That can help - unclipping and getting feet out to stabilize (a front flat) or brace for an impact isn't something you can do on an upright. On an upright you use your head and your arms to break the fall/impact. I don't think either is inherently safer, it's just the diamond frame is the qwerty of push bikes because the UCI said so 100 years ago. I've probably ridden dozens of recumbents. Some have an excellent turning circle but they tend not to be as fun bombing down a hill. Some (LWB with USS) can't u-turn on a US 2 lane road but would be the ideal bike to collide with something (wheel->fork->frame->feet taking the impact.) I've also let dozens of people try my bike and no disrespect but "experienced cyclists" are the ones that scare me. Strong, fast, confident, they are definitely the run-before-you-walk folks. Recumbents, tricycles, bmxes etc. all handle differently, especially at speed. They are all just as easy to get up to speed but most people won't try that first. I ride both and don't pretend the extra visibility of the upright makes me any safer. You have to ride like you are invisible because to cars you just are.
- jacquesm 3y agoI've had three different recumbents and you're going to have to take my word for it that I know how to ride them. You feel a lot safer because you're closer to the ground but that's part of the problem: leg suck has a feed-forward mechanism that you can not overcome at speed. I'm fortunate that there were no cars nearby or I probably wouldn't be writing this at all, it was over and done with in a split second, like that you're riding comfortably and like that you're out of control. Of course I'm not going to convince you, just like nobody would have been able to convince me prior to my accident. That's fine. I hope that if and when you do fall you end up with just a scare so you'll realize I wasn't kidding: the illusion of safety and control is just that, you have neither.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoThat thought experiment is worthless junk. The differences in dynamics of the two designs are not just different but equivalent. There are countless ways in which a standard diamond frame is practical and handles a given situation that a recumbent can't. And I love recumbents because I love weird things. I have both 2 wheel and tadpole trike recumbents. They are the only bikes I ever ride given any choice. But they are actually quite unsafe for both myself and everyone else, and quite, even ridiculously, comically impractical. You can't do the simplest thing like just hop a curb or a tree root, because you can't pull up on the front wheel. There is no amount of life long 'grew up used to it' that magics that away, nor about 100 other similar typical situations. Climbing hills is ridiculously difficult, even with highly practiced spinning technique, because simply standing up on the pedals one at a time is just far simpler, and preserves your momentum better,with no special expert technique. The simple fact that you are already upright makes crashing on a DF infinitely more navigable. There is no such thing as just hopping off a crashing recumbent and landing on your feet. That happens all the time on a df. There is just not even remotely a comparison, not even in the same universe when it comes to either safety or practicality all day every day in all the infinite random situations from parking, storing, threading through narrow pathways and gaps anywhere a pedestrian could go, bringing on a train/bus, up the stairs to your appartment or office, wearing a backpack and not needing any other on-bike cargo space... Recumbents are great in a few particular ways, but they are neither safe nor practical.