13 ms·
Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from taking customers in Titan
- jacquesm 3y agoThis is also a very good article: https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersibles-under-pressure-in-deep-deep-waters https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersib...
- mpenick 3y agoInteresting find! Lots of information about the winding and the materials used. I wish there was more information about the epoxy used to adhere the titanium endcaps to the hull. I also wonder what changed between the Cyclops 2 and the Titan.
- mpenick 3y agoI also wonder what changed between the Cyclops 2 and the Titan.
- nimbleplum40 3y agoNothing. Cyclops 2 is the Titan.
- pvaldes 3y agoI assume that just the name. Cyclops was a monster that lost his one eye in battle. The submarine had one window and the name suggests that window being damaged at some point. Titan suggests a more positive and strong image without suggesting the bad parts. In any case the submarine couldn't avoid the cyclops destiny and cyclopsioned entirely.
- jacquesm 3y agoTitan is simply short for Titanic...
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe titanium endcaps weren't connected with epoxy, but bolts. https://twitter.com/Alphafox78/status/1671872409861869568 https://twitter.com/Alphafox78/status/1671872409861869568
- SirSourdough 3y agoI believe it’s both really. My understanding is the end caps are bolted to a titanium flange, not the carbon fibre hull directly. The titanium flange the caps are bolted to is epoxied to the hull.
- nickpinkston 3y agoYea, you generally try to avoid drilling holes or even casting threaded bosses into carbon or other composites, especially this extreme pressure rig, because it really reduces the strength versus an strong adhesive that evenly applies pressure without breaking/disrupting the composite material.
- SkyMarshal 3y agoThey use some sort of glue to seal the titanium rings to the CF hull, then the Titanium hemisphere end caps are bolted to the rings. Here’s their own YT vid showing the construction process: https://youtu.be/WK99kBS1AfE https://youtu.be/WK99kBS1AfE
- daxuak 3y agoI suppose the article meant cap itself was a carbon fiber/epoxy build, implying nothing about the connection? On a separate note, although the submarine failed catastrophically, that doesn't mean every decision it took was wrong. I wonder if the bolts actually make sense under high water pressure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bambax 3y agoNot really. There were titanium rings at each end of the cylinder, fixed with glue, and then the caps were bolted onto said rings.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SkyMarshal 3y agoI believe Cyclops 2 is Titan, just renamed. Cyclops 1 is a smaller steel-hulled submersible.
- ubermonkey 3y agoWhat little I know about composites/carbon fiber STRONGLY suggest it's a terrible approach for a submersible. Am I wrong?
- pvaldes 3y agoThe results speak loudly by themselves. This is not the first submarine build and many of the other are still on duty after decades.
- dan_quixote 3y agoNot necessarily. CFRP is plenty strong to handle the task. But it's a complicated material - though not necessarily new. I think one complication people underestimate when comparing to steel or titanium is that CFRP is NOT isotropic - meaning that its physical properties are NOT the same regardless of orientation. Another is that CFRP has so many dimensions to its strength (e.g. orientation of resolved force vs fiver orientation, fiber diameter, fiber length, fiber material, epoxy material, etc). Yet another is the concept of fatigue life. Steel is very forgiving in this regard - as long as you don't strain it enough to reach plastic deformation, you're good almost forever. CFRP (and even aluminum) have a lifetime no matter what. In that case, you need decent non-destructive testing techniques of which I'm certainly not an expert. I have one major unanswered question about it though...is there any reason they needed the weight savings one gets from CFRP? Every sub I've ever heard of requires additional ballast to dive even when using tried-and-true steel hull. If they didn't need the weight savings, it was completely absurd to use CFRP.
- jcalvinowens 3y agoThe metal pressure vessels are very negatively buoyant. The bathyscaphe Trieste used 32000 gallons of gasoline to achieve positive buoyancy. Modern DSVs use incredibly expensive and fragile syntactic foam. A CFRP pressure vessel can be naturally positively buoyant, or much closer to it. Titan's dry weight was less than DSV Limiting Factor, despite having much greater internal volume and carrying 3 more people. Also, being able to load and launch in the water, rather than loading on the deck and needing a human rated crane to launch as most DSVs do, probably saved a lot of money operating Titan.
- everybodyknows 3y ago> Length, 2,540 mm; outside diameter, 1,676 mm; service pressure, 6,600 psi; pressure safety factor, 2.25. “They basically said, ‘This is the pressure we have to meet, this is the factor of safety, this is the basic envelope. Go design and build it,’” Spencer reports. And he was given six weeks in which to do it. Six weeks. Classic checkbox-driven Technical Program Mismanagement (TPM) by whim of pseudo-technical overreaching hucksters.
- dtagames 3y agoI don't think it's wrong to take yourself down in a crazy unproven sub, even if you die. But taking paying tourists (not explorers; tourists) who are not experts and cannot vet the safety of your device -- that's unconscionable and probably criminal had the perpetrators survived.
- bombcar 3y agoA huge part of maturity is realizing that you can’t be an expert capable of evaluating all risk in your life, so outside forces/standards are necessary. Untrained smart people can be really bad at risk - a good shorthand is: can you get insurance for it and what is the price?
- MichaelZuo 3y agoHuh the insurance test does sound pretty smart. Though I imagine some insurance products might not be quoted at all to any random person?
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s not perfect, but it at least gets you thinking. Because the adjusters have to price the risk objectively - house burn down? Risk relatively low. Submarine go pop? Probably not insurable at any price - either because risk is too high or they can’t evaluate it. And if they can’t, you likely can’t, unless you’re Cameron or someone similar. That doesn’t mean uninsurable risks aren’t worth taking sometimes. Just be aware and realistic.
- CharlesW 3y ago> Probably not insurable at any price - either because risk is too high or they can’t evaluate it. FWIW, fatal experimental submarine accidents aren't the weirdest thing insurers have insured. https://havenlife.com/blog/craziest-things-insured-lloyds-london/ https://havenlife.com/blog/craziest-things-insured-lloyds-lo...
- mikece 3y agoThere seems to be pretty clear consensus that the OceanGate CEO was impervious to good advice.
- mc32 3y agoThe guy seemed to believe his own dogma. He was both sincere in his belief but also blinded by it. He was also a tenacious salesman —looks like he would lean on his (potential) customers pretty hard.
- jacquesm 3y agoThis combination is pretty common in start-up founders as well. Separating the ones who believe their own bs from the ones that have done their homework can sometimes be quite hard.
- Ajedi32 3y agoIt's interesting to imagine how different the narrative might be if he'd been equally convinced the sub was safe but just didn't happen to be on that particular mission by sheer luck.
- eldritch_4ier 3y agoYou could say the same about Elon Musk or Nokola Tesla or many others. Just sounds like pure survivorship bias to me. "This crazy innovator died so clearly future innovators should listen to the experts!".
- sokoloff 3y agoThere does seem to be a lot of poor choices made along the way here, but it’s also worth noting that you can find an expert who gave (or was willing to give) any innovator the advice to not create their product. If every innovator listened to expert advice to stop, we’d have a lot less new things in the world.
- api 3y agoTrue, but there is a way to prove the detractors wrong without killing people: lots of testing. They just put people on this thing way too soon. Take space launch for example. Every significant part of a rocket is tested to destruction multiple times unless it’s already flight proven, then the whole rocket is flown many times before we consider putting people on it. Still dangerous, but this makes it not totally insane.
- mjhay 3y agoThey didn't innovate anything. Submersibles have been around for a long time. The technology is mature. Their innovation was using completely inappropriate materials and cheaping out on safety.
- rtkwe 3y agoExcept generally those innovators were making a new app or company not a machine responsible for protecting people in an environment arguably less hospitable to exploration than outer space.
- _fat_santa 3y agoThere's a big difference between: "that app won't ever succeed" and "this submarine is dangerous and can kill people".
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoWhat's the innovation? Carbon fiber specifically is known to be bad for subs.
- drc500free 3y agoI think there are two different kinds of innovation: doing new things, and finding cheaper ways to do existing things. The latter case tends to be about either interesting insights about the actual value that let you find a better point on the cost curve, or entirely new manufacturing technologies that let you bend the cost curve entirely. Trading away safety for cost isn't usually an innovative trade-off by itself, and making that trade-off without any interest in quantifying it is a red flag.
- numpad0 3y ago> Rush sought to reassure Stanley that the issue with the noises was being looked at and suggested that it was improving, albeit with a caveat: "Our analysis of the past dives shows a definite reduction in acoustic events, but only having data from ... Am I just too uninformed or is this actual nonsense?
- rwmj 3y agoIt's not nonsense to use acoustic events to detect slow failures in engineering structures. In fact this is somewhat common, for example to detect failing steel inside reinforced concrete structures.[1] It's definitely nonsense to assume that because the boat didn't immediately implode after a big cracking sound was heard that you're all good. [1] https://www.newcivilengineer.com/latest/acoustic-monitoring-saved-hammersmith-flyover-from-polcevera-like-collapse-28-11-2019/ https://www.newcivilengineer.com/latest/acoustic-monitoring-...
- numpad0 3y agoI mean, if I were jumping on a wooden board and it started reducing in snapping noises, I'd probably feel the board weakening, not hardening and improving. The logic in above quoted sentence seems to be drawing a completely opposite conclusion from intuition.
- AlexandrB 3y agoIt probably depends on all kinds of things - like the materials involved and the nature of the overall structure. I could see there being "settling" events where a structure is stronger overall after a bunch of noises but I suspect that doesn't apply to a carbon fibre cylinder.
- LanceH 3y agoI keep seeing articles being pushed that the victim's families have no case. But with the whistleblower lawsuit, the conversations and tweets, the CEO seems to have just skipped engineering warnings and worked harder at convincing people. He convinced people that dangers he knew of weren't dangers. I don't think that can get waivered. Then one of the articles has a sub-title saying that the families will have a hard time finding a lawyer to take the case. I'm pretty sure the billionaires can find a lawyer for this if they choose. They could have lawyers lined up around the block working on contingent for the high profile nature of this and the possibility of getting work with billionaires. The only thing holding back lawsuits would be the lack of potential payoff.
- ramesh31 3y ago>I keep seeing articles being pushed that the victim's families have no case. But with the whistleblower lawsuit, the conversations and tweets, the CEO seems to have just skipped engineering warnings and worked harder at convincing people. He convinced people that dangers he knew of weren't dangers. I don't think that can get waivered Liability waivers have approximately zero standing in court. It's just something the defense can hold up and say "look, they were warned!". It doesn't legally absolve you of any liability whatsoever, and any jury is highly unlikely to be sympathetic to the defendant here. OceanGate as a company effectively ceased to exist the moment this happened. Most likely their assets will be liquidated, and whatever's left will be a court battle with insurance companies for years to come.
- voxic11 3y agoLiability waivers have a lot of standing in court, they just aren't a blanket exemption from liability like some believe. Under the law of tort, prior to injury, the specific risk must have been known to and appreciated by the plaintiff in order for primary assumption of risk to apply. Liability waivers serve to establish that the risk was known and appreciated. For instance in CA > Releases and waivers of liability are usually enforced in California. They are considered contracts that, if properly drafted and executed, are recognized as valid agreements that limit your rights. > There are four ways to challenge the validity and binding effects of a release or waiver of liability: > ... Gross negligence or recklessness: The California Supreme Court recently held that releases are valid only to protect defendants from being sued for negligence. They are invalid if you can prove that the other party's conduct was more than negligent, e.g., gross negligence or recklessness. https://archive.ph/20120911003148/http://www.sports-injury-lawyer.com/PracticeAreas/Attacking-Waiver-of-Liability.asp#selection-230.0-230.2 https://archive.ph/20120911003148/http://www.sports-injury-l...
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoAll 5 of them are now world famous. That is worth something I imagine.
- brnt 3y agoCarbon fibers have great tensile strength. Why would they be a good choice when a sub faces compressive forces?
- _yid9 3y agoExactly my thought. But, then I’m a 50+ year old white guy, so unqualified to speak. In my personal experience w/ carbon fiber overwound tanks for compressed natural gas — my very first thought when I first heard they used a carbon fiber “pressure vessel” was: “Wow, ballsy; carbon fiber composite is great in tension, worthless in compression”.
- pjkundert 3y agoFunny, the downvotes from people who (like the CEO, apparently) … don’t have a clue. When you hear a “pop” or a “crunch” from a carbon-fiber wound composite tank: it means some part of the fiber/resin matrix has delaminated, or allowed intrusion of gas/fluid into its matrix. This means that this layer of the vessel now allows relative motion under torsion or compression. If the intruding material is higher pressure than the average within the matrix — it will push the matrix apart, causing more delaminating, at ever deeper levels (now exposed to the intrusion). At the massive pressure differentials in this situation (800 bar), failure of this vessel once compromised would predictably happen in milliseconds. As it turns out… There was a time people came to HN because of the interesting comments by subject-matter experts. Now, it’s a woke smack down. Sad.
- kllrnohj 3y agoThe downvotes might be from people that don't realize that "But, then I’m a 50+ year old white guy, so unqualified to speak." is a reference to something else the OceanGate CEO said
- timeon 3y agoI have not downvoted you but not relevant to topic you seems to be pushing some kind of agenda for no obvious reasons: > But, then I’m a 50+ year old white guy, so unqualified to speak. > Now, it’s a woke smack down. Sad. Why?
- b0sk 3y agoMove fast and break things
- noodlesUK 3y agoIANAL: I regularly see articles about how the passengers who were killed signed various liability waivers and therefore how their families have no case to sue OceanGate and others into oblivion. Liability waivers generally only exclude ordinary negligence, if that. In general, you can't waive your legal rights protecting you from gross negligence or wilful misconduct (definitions may vary -- the UK doesn't have gross negligence as such, but you can't waive the risk of death in most cases). The people who were on the sub were very much wealthy enough (and now are high profile enough) to afford the kinds of legal teams that probably won't worry too much about liability waivers in these kinds of suits. I hope they extract every penny from OceanGate and any related entities.
- jacquesm 3y agoOceanGate is probably going to be slim pickings but Spencer is wide open.
- time0ut 3y agoIf I picture myself in this CEO's shoes (wanting to innovate in the materials/approach to DSVs), I imagine instructing my team to design a system that can perform test dives autonomously and then use that to gather data over many duty cycles. Of course, I have no idea what I am talking about, so maybe that is simply impossible or impossibly expensive. It does seem cheaper than just YOLOing it and getting yourself and four other people killed though.
- maweki 3y ago> so maybe that is simply impossible or impossibly expensive Sorry for swearing, but I too can't believe that there's a problem in setting this thing to auto-dive 3 or 4 kilometers and then pulling it up via an f-ing tether. I understand why you wouldn't tether the sub when floating into the titanic wreck. But test-diving? come on...
- marcosdumay 3y agoHow much market is there for unmanned trips? The amount of equipment you could fit inside this sub is incredible. Probably unparalleled. I can't believe there isn't enough market to be profitable while you test the experimental hull.
- amanj41 3y agoWhat exactly would they bring though? Anything inside the sub could not be dropped off anywhere. Maybe they could have collected research data to sell to certain scientific institutes, but that doesn't sound like it would recoup much of the costs
- marcosdumay 3y agoProbably, lights and a good camera. The goal is just to run on the blue, so that they are not pressured to finish their testing earlier. I can't imagine there isn't enough to film at that depth so that they can't find people willing to pay for the operational costs.
- mcpackieh 3y ago
- idoubtit 3y agoSorry, but I intend to raise a bit of guilty conscience. I know it's unpopular and useless, but I feel I have to, once in a while... A week before this submarine exploded, a boat capsized near Greece. Between 400 and 500 persons died. In both cases, it's a tragedy, but I have much more empathy for those who fled (mostly from Pakistan and Afghanistan), struggled for weeks or months on a very dangerous path, and hoped for a better life in Europe. Their deaths were probably much more painful than the crash that suddenly ended the lives of the Titanic tourists. There is still a mist of mystery around the refugees deaths: the Greek coastal guards had been cruising near the boat, and they have changed many times their story of it. They finally admitted that they tried to tow her, but deny other claims from reporters, NGOs and even the European coast guards. There's a suspicion of unintended mass-murder, or at least (racist?) negligence. Shouldn't that draw as much focus as the failures of a submarine company? I know that news coverage is unfair. I believe that most people don't even realize that they're biased on this — we all are in different ways. It's the same with Russia: I think most people are sincere when they say that this war is unprecedented, that our human values are at stake in this war, and that UN and international justice should act against Poutine. Ever heard of the mote and the beam? In a near past, USA invaded Iraq. And today, our country leaders lick the boots of MBS, the dictator of Saudi Arabia that started a war in Yemen which killed 380,000 persons, and who ordered thousands of bombings on mostly civilians targets. The irony is that MBS' order of chainsawing an opponent brought him trouble, while this bloody war and the regular decapitation of dozens of opponents went almost unnoticed.
- criddell 3y ago> When the number of victims in a tragedy increases, our empathy decreases. https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2018/11/27/18103071/psychic-numbing-mass-suffering-psychology https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2018/11/27/18103071/psych...
- xoxxala 3y ago"The death of one man is a tragedy, the death of millions is a statistic." - Kurt Tucholsky (usually misattributed to Joseph Stalin)
- 3y ago
- stcredzero 3y agoMultiple submarine experts gave him advice that the Titan was unsafe. I just saw a submarine expert in Alameda who was interviewed by the local ABC station. She gave the same advice!
- dehrmann 3y agoIt was clearly unsafe, but an expert saying it's unsafe after the accident means nothing. News orgs won't find an opposing view for this, and a "submarine expert" might not be a structures expert.
- jacquesm 3y agoExcept that multiple experts are on the record saying that prior to the accident.
- jandrese 3y agoIt's clear why it is so easy to find quotes from this guy complaining about safety experts harshing his buzz. He was hearing so called experts telling him it was unsafe all the time and it was clearly getting to him. He specified a safety factor and everything so what could possibly go wrong? He rounded up from 4.75" hull to 5" on the design. What more could they want? It's made out of carbon fiber, the wondermaterial of the future that all of the best stuff is made from.
- toss1 3y ago>> "I think it was General MacArthur who said: 'You're remembered for the rules you break,'" Rush told the Mexican YouTuber alanxelmundo. The problem with this approach is that the CEO failed to distinguish between human rules (to which MacArthur was referring) vs. laws of physics. Laws of physics do not know about, care about, or yield to any human action or intention. They are absolute, and will kill you if you get on the wrong side of them. If he wanted to go himself on this device, that is fine, but the way he was actively selling this as safe is just fraud. He got what he deserved, his passengers were fooled to their deaths. Owning a carbon fiber composites design & fabrication business which builds both aerospace and subsea components, nearly everything I've read and viewed about this CEO's practices ranges from creep-me-out to 'looks criminal'. Compiling just references to the bad practices and failings would fill many pages, but perhaps the worst is the assumption that "hey, it went down there once, so it's good to go as many times as we want.", and refusal to even get any kind of ultrasonic or radiological testing of the carbon fiber hull. Plus, to think that you can with acoustics, outrun the cascading failure at those kinds of pressures is nothing less than hard stupidity. The core function of carbon fiber composites is to spread the loads through the matrix with the extremely light and high-tensile-strength carbon fiber. This works great until it doesn't, so the failures are well known to be nearly explosive in rate and catastrophic, unlike metals which tend to deform first. When the load is exceeding the maximum — especially in a well-designed & well-fabricated part — it is spread throughout the material. When it exceeds the maximum, either by fracturing the matrix between layers, or by fracturing some fibers, the load is now borne by proportionally less material, so is more focused, that material breaks, etc.. Even at normal pressures, this happens in microseconds. See the standard open hole compression test at about 1:46+ [0]. The pressures at that depth, would only increase the failure speed. The tech guy got fired from the Titan project (w/10min to clean out his desk) for pointing out that the acoustic flaw-detection method the CEO wanted to use would not work, and would give them only milliseconds of warning. He was right. What I do find a bit surprising is that James Cameron (himself a very accomplished depth explorer) says he heard from his sources that the Titan had dropped its weights and was ascending trying to manage an emergency, which indicates they actually had seconds or maybe even minutes of warning. Could mean that it just took longer with the 5in thick hull. So, it'll be really interesting to see the final reports... [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1gHxCt-qv0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1gHxCt-qv0
- ramesh31 3y agoSimilar article with quotes from Patrick Lahey, the Triton Subs CEO, essentially calling Rush a con man: https://www.insider.com/titanic-sub-ceo-was-on-predatory-hunt-for-supporters-expert-2023-6 https://www.insider.com/titanic-sub-ceo-was-on-predatory-hun... Lahey is the real deal though. If you want to see how an actual (certified) full ocean depth submersible is built, can't recommend enough this documentary they made about the design and construction of DSV Limiting Factor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pb5j9oeZCm0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pb5j9oeZCm0
- jacquesm 3y agoThe Limiting Factor is one hell of a piece of engineering. It is exactly the kind of engineering rigor that you would expect for a device like this.
- mwsfc 3y agoFor the physicists here I would greatly like to hear an opinion on what presents the greater physics challenge: keeping the ocean out at the depth of 13K feet or containing a spacecraft's atmosphere in the vacuum of space. I suspect it's the former but don't have the "mathy maths" to back it up.
- wongarsu 3y agoObviously there's a difference between pressure vessels that have to keep pressure in (like a spacecraft) vs one that has to keep pressure out (like a submersible). I believe keeping pressure in is generally easier. But the much bigger factor is the pressure difference we are talking about here: At 13k feet you have about 1 atmosphere of pressure in the sub, and about 400 atmospheres of pressure outside, for a difference of about 400. In a spacecraft you have about 1 atmosphere inside and about 0 outside, for a difference of 1. 1 bar of pressure is much easier to deal with than 400. This also changes your emergency procedures: In a spacecraft, losing pressure means you need a pressure suit and a breathing apparatus. Because you still have the spacecraft for general shielding these can be pretty sleek suits like [1] that you can just wear the entire time and connect to an oxygen line as needed. In a submarine at these depths your best defense against sudden hull damage is being in a part of the sub that isn't damaged and has a solid bulkhead to the damaged section. Which isn't viable in a small submersible. Spacecraft are challenging for other reasons: you want to go up fast to spend less time fighting gravity, which provides challenges because of aerodynamic loads; and when you come back down all the momentum of your orbit gets converted into heat as you slow down, which necessitates a decent heat shield. On top of that you try to minimize weight of everything, because being heavier means you need more fuel, but more fuel means you need more fuel to carry that fuel up, meaning you need more fuel, etc. 1: https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/8PVWQ6hR7SsGLK9PDoCFdU-1200-80.jpg https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/8PVWQ6hR7SsGLK9PDoCFdU-120...
- milesskorpen 3y agoYou're dealing with a lot more pressure at these depths. You get to 1 atmosphere of additional pressure for every ~30ft when diving. That means 13k feet = 433 atmospheres of pressure.
- 3y ago
- kyleblarson 3y ago"succumbing to the pressure of your own creation" is an apropos choice of words in the headline of the article.
- Seattle3503 3y ago> I don't think if you push forward with dives to the Titantic this season it will be succumbing to financial pressures, I think it will be succumbing to pressures of your own creation in some part dictated by ego to do what people said couldn't be done. This quote really stood out to me. "Doing what they said couldn't be done" is such a powerful narrative in our entrepreneurial culture that it inspired a man to rush recklessly to his own death.
- renewiltord 3y agoThat's the thing with experts. They always tell you not to do things https://www.space.com/12028-private-rocket-launch-spacex-safety-lawsuit.html https://www.space.com/12028-private-rocket-launch-spacex-saf... The year is 2011, an expert has said that SpaceX's Falcon rocket is unsafe. This happens repeatedly. In 2019, will SpaceX's planned Crew Dragon safely transport astronauts?
- jmarneweck 3y agohttps://archive.vn/yW6jl https://archive.vn/yW6jl
- robaato 3y agoThe British documentary maker Ross Kemp turned down the opportunity to film on the Titan submersible, on which five people died this week, after the vessel was deemed unsafe following third-party checks. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/24/ross-kemp-turned-down-trip-titanic-submersible-safety-fears https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/24/ross-kemp-turn...