38 ms·
U.S. pedestrian deaths reach a 40-year high
- Madmallard 3y agoI feel like drivers have gotten exceedingly bad at awareness and it then absolutely baffles me that Byrd and other similar products are mandated to be on the road.
- FollowingTheDao 3y agoThe southern states, which I travel often, i loaded with trucks with front ends that are higher than the top edge of the driver side window of my minivan. And also, they drive like Grand Theft Auto - Work Edition. The greed, ego and selfishness in this country is depressing and frightening.
- xvilka 3y agoMore public transport - less pedestrian deaths.
- TSiege 3y agoAlso stop making giant cars with low visibility
- systems_glitch 3y agoWhat, you don't like looking out the view slit in a tank as you try and drive down the road?! I know it's supposed to be for increased impact performance, but surely being able to see out also reduces the incidence of accidents...right?
- esteth 3y agoStop inviting so many cars to everything - less pedestrian deaths. So much USA urban and suburban land use is dedicated to cars. Massive wide stroads, enormous car parks etc. It makes it so difficult to get anywhere without a motor vehicle, and it means there's way more cars on the road than there needs to be because lots of people just can't realistically do basic tasks without driving.
- Tiktaalik 3y agoSeriously this. If we assume that people are flawed and will fuck up and make random deadly mistakes, one of the most effective ways to make the deaths go down is to remove the cars from the road. You might have the same mistake rate, but the total amount of cars going down will mean the deaths drop.
- cde-v 3y ago[flagged]
- foxyv 3y agoI think Ford and Chevy have contributed more. The proliferation of high profile vehicles has made accidents that would normally be a broken leg into a crushed chest cavity.
- wil421 3y agoWhat if people are walking more often than 40 years ago?
- JoeJonathan 3y agoEven if that were responsible for greater pedestrian deaths--and I doubt it is--the US nonetheless has a disgustingly high pedestrian death rate.
- foxyv 3y agoI doubt it's the sole problem. But it definitely is a big problem. https://www.valuepenguin.com/top-deadliest-vehicles https://www.valuepenguin.com/top-deadliest-vehicles Edit: Sorry wrong link here's the one I meant to share. https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-suvs-are-more-lethal-to-pedestrians-than-cars https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-s...
- agilob 3y agoDoes that also imply that fewer people are in cars, so those who are in cars are more likely to cause a fatal accident?
- zubiaur 3y agoIntuitively I would agree. Modern pickup trucks have such high, long hoods nowadays. There is a big blind spot on the front of the vehicle, especially pronounced with short objects, kids and pets. Wonder if there is data that to run a hypothesis test?
- luxurytent 3y agoI guess pickup trucks fall under the category of SUVs? It's wild how we've lost access to our streets and neighbourhoods for the convenience of mostly suburban vehicle users. Actually not wild, but disgraceful. The majority of roads are too wide and with little options for alternative modes of transport, drivers are growingly frustrated and angry on the road. We continue to make the mistake of thinking the solution is wider roads. An incredible policy and prioritization failure. That said, it would take very little work and money to fix the problems. Road diets (as pointed out by the article) and tactical infrastructure is cheap and the solutions are well known. The spend will be a drop in the bucket compared to most other budgets.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIn many areas, it would take a ton of work in the effort of making destinations closer to each other. Huge parking lots, setbacks, wide roads, and detached houses on their own quarter, or even eighth, of an acre lot make it so the choice between walking/bicycling and using a personal car is not much of a choice. Public transportation is also not an option due to how inconvenient it is due to how infrequently it would run, and the cost of missed or missing buses/trains, which again, run infrequently due to lack of density of people. Plus the separation of commercial zones and residential zones mean public transport is always going to one specific area, and so if you have any interest in traveling outside the central core, you are once again depending on a personal car.
- luxurytent 3y agoYes, some areas in particular the big box developments are almost a lost cause. What needs to happen to those first is large, dense development within the plazas. Build residential on top of the mall, remove parking lots (or move them underground), and densify first. Once you move that needle, you can focus on active transport options. The type of development I describe is happening (two examples in my Canadian city). Ultimately the evolution of a poorly built model.
- mytailorisrich 3y ago
- WillPostForFood 3y agoArticle ignores it, but looking at the source data you can see pedestrian deaths were flat, then a large spike in 2020 during Covid, and now we are at a new higher plateau. Cause is not a change in roads, or cars, or more SUVs. Covid/lockdowns changed the way people drive. Less civility, less police enforcement, more chaos. Driving is noticeably worse and more stressful than pre-Covid.
- themitigating 3y ago[flagged]
- ethanbond 3y agoWhy would COVID/lockdowns have “changed the way people drive?” Any proposed mechanism? Seems more likely you had a lot of shifting around of people’s driving (e.g. city dwellers moving to suburbs)
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9342743/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9342743/ https://www.google.com/search?q=people+driving+more+aggressive+after+Covid https://www.google.com/search?q=people+driving+more+aggressi...
- ethanbond 3y agoThis doesn’t answer my question. It just says people claim [other] drivers are more aggressive than before.
- leroman 3y agoThe post COVID era is more stressful for sure.. (pandemic, inflation, war,?)
- mywittyname 3y agoIt coincides with the general rise in anti-social behavior that happened during and after lockdowns. There's definitely a lot of people reporting a change in driving attitudes. During covid, people went fucking nuts. There for a while, it was a source of local news articles.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoThe size of cars (trucks really... SUVs are trucks) in the US makes me feel like we're slowly making Mad Max a reality. I've walked by trucks in parking lots that I can't see over the hood of... and I'm an adult man. We need some kind of regulation or tax on consumer vehicle sizes a decade ago.
- mech7654 3y agoA pillars are getting wider, and the bottoms of windows are getting higher. These changes are being made for crashworthiness, the effects of visibility on accidents are understudied.
- underbluewaters 3y agoI just purchased a 2018 F-150 and was concerned about being able to drive it safely after reading threads like these. Surprisingly, I can be much more aware of my surroundings and have fewer blind spots in the truck than my CR-V. Even directly in front of the tall hood I can see fine. There are a lot of valid criticisms of big trucks but most of the discussion around them is pretty ignorant.
- avelis 3y agoIt would appear Vision Zero in the US is not working. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vision_Zero https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vision_Zero
- beatboxrevival 3y agoLargely because it's still not seen as favorable by the public to prioritize pedestrian safety over vehicular parking/speed - even in liberal areas where this should be easy. We are a car-centric society, and I'm not sure when that'll change (unfortunately).
- micromacrofoot 3y agoit's barely implemented in the US, and typically only in large cities... far too early to call it a failure, and I strongly suspect that the problem is that it doesn't go far enough (it does nothing to regulate the vehicles themselves or driving skills, for example... road design can't fix everything)
- avelis 3y agoTo add to this, many US cities adopted Vision Zero in the 2010s with resolutions to end all fatalities involving vehicular traffic in 10 years. Some as soon as 2024. Yet, I don't see any progress showing they have gone to zero for any of those cities.
- hef19898 3y agoMeanwhile road deaths per million inhabitants drastically decreased across the EU27. https://etsc.eu/euroadsafetydata/ https://etsc.eu/euroadsafetydata/
- jefftk 3y agoTo make progress on answering that I think you'd want to compare the trajectory of traffic deaths in areas that adopted the Vision Zero approach to ones that didn't?
- jmclnx 3y agoWell in my opinion, "Vision Zero" in the US will apply only to the peons. If you are connected with Law Enforcement or Politicians, you get a free pass unless you kill someone in such a manner that it cannot be brushed under the carpet.
- last_responder 3y agoTexting and driving have to be behind some large portion of this increase.
- luxurytent 3y agoThe hands-free law was IMO, a failure. What used to be people staring at their phones while holding them up at the steering wheel now has people trying to be more discreet and placing phones between their legs or near the cup holders. Hands-free! But also doubly dangerous.
- donatj 3y agoThis is my exact experience! People used to text with their phone in front of them, which is dangerous but at least they had peripheral vision. Now they hide their phone while they do it. You see it so often, someone not everyone looking vaguely at the road.
- xnx 3y agoI thought this was a problem at first, but I don't see anyone trying to hide it anymore. "Driving" is just an app that people glance at while using their phones.
- retrac 3y agoWalking and on their phones, too. In recent years I've seen people step into intersections while on their phone without even looking up. Edit: anyone who disagrees and has downvoted me care to explain why? I wrote the comment from the perspective a pedestrian. I don't even drive! Some cities consider it such problem they've talked about making it illegal to walk around in the street looking at your phone: https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/20/us/new-york-walking-while-texting-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/20/us/new-york-walking-while-tex...
- wnolens 3y agoIt's blaming the victim? I see this very often as well, but you're not operating a several ton vehicle. At worst you run into some kid and knock his ice cream over. It's the presence of cars, their prioritization in our infrastructure, and unenforced laws surrounding them that are the problem.
- apsec112 3y agoI'm not even slightly surprised by this, sadly. Cops need to start ticketing people who drive like maniacs. I drive in DC, and every week I almost get hit by some loon going 30+ over the limit who doesn't care that I'm in the lane they're merging into. I've never seen anyone get ticketed. The roads have become something out of Mad Max, just pure developing-world anarchy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- poly_morphis 3y agoThe merging and the lane etiquette are the two biggest for me, though I do a lot more driving now than a few years ago. People going below the speed limit in the leftmost lanes regularly back up the freeway since no one can pass. Also is way more dangerous since some weave in the middle lanes (or right) to make the pass.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoYeah that is a weird one because no one is going to get ticketed for going the speed limit or 5 over in the passing/leftmost lane and technically they are doing nothing wrong. It just makes driving more difficult for everyone else. The rightmost lane is somewhat similar. You really shouldnt travel in it. It's for getting on and off the road. If you are in it you're making it harder for other to merge on/off the road. But again you're not going to get a ticket for pulling into that right lane and staying as long as you'd like. Some people are actually not even aware of these, "rules". I had a friend who at 25 still drove in the right lane all the time and would get mad when people were always slowing down to get off the highway. How do we pass on this knowledge that, while fairly important, is not actually law?
- Toutouxc 3y agoIt's funny how "going the speed limit or 5 over in the leftmost lane" and "actually using the rightmost lane" are exactly the things I wish more people were doing in this country in Europe.
- carimura 3y agoevery time I'm in the car I'm astonished by the number of people looking down at phones while driving. Is my experience unique? Is anyone else surprised about metrics like these?
- luxurytent 3y agoNope. Anecdotal to me of course, but I did a little activity where I stood on a pedestrian island off a busy stretch of road near me. I did this a handful of times. Over each 5 minute stretch, I'd observe at least 1/10 drivers staring down at their phones while driving through intersection It's nuts. We are a distracted population.
- shsbdncudx 3y agoIt could also be the pedestrians looking at their phone, not where they’re going. Or both combined
- carimura 3y agoya you're right it's not the 2-ton hunk of metal hurling through space with teenager addicted to tik tok behind the wheel where a wrist movement of an inch is life vs death.
- sokoloff 3y agoI was in Canada last week for work and it was shocking how few drivers were distracted by phones. I came to expect cars to drive away when their light turned green rather than waiting for the “wake up, dumbass!” honk from the car one to three cars behind. It was nice and immediately upon return to the US, I saw the red light scrollers back in force.
- notacoward 3y ago> Is my experience unique? Not at all. When my wife and I go on longer trips, e.g. north to ski or west to where my daughter was at college, she likes to do most of the driving. Sometimes I amuse myself by counting how many of the drivers around us are using their phones while driving. It's often well over 50% and that's counting conservatively - e.g. phone actually visible in their hand, not on the dash or in their lap. If police would just enforce that one law with hefty fines and loss of license, I think safety would be significantly improved.
- injb 3y ago>>> Norton said installing speeding and red light cameras can also be effective if they work properly. Adding bike lanes can also keep drivers more alert on the road. You know what else works? Making learning how to drive a requirement for getting a drivers license. Other countries that have tried this have had good success.
- jacquesm 3y agoAnd consistently revoking driving privileges from those that fail to observe the rules.
- vuln 3y ago> You know what else works? Making learning how to drive a requirement for getting a drivers license. Other countries that have tried this have had good success. Where is “learning how to drive” not a requirement?
- injb 3y agoEverywhere I have lived in the US.
- vuln 3y agoWeird. Everywhere in the US I’ve lived one must obtain a permit, behind the wheel hours, a driving school (private or public school). Then there is a test for permit, and then another 2 part test before a drivers license is obtained. I’ve lived all over the US and it appears to me to the be standard. Where have you lived within the US that deviated from this standard?
- jdalgetty 3y agoI live in a subdivision full of young families with kids. I'm also a runner, an avid dog walker and someone who walks his kids to and from school every day. As someone out on foot on a daily basis I am constantly blown away by the amount of people speeding on residential streets and not stopping at stop signs. I don't get it! These are clearly people who live in these neighbourhoods yet they don't care enough about their own community to drive safely or responsibly. If people aren't willing to at least drive carefully in their own neighbourhoods, imagine how they drive when they don't have to worry about running over their neighbours kids.
- Eumenes 3y agoTransition to trail running if you can. Ive stopped taking chances with road running because of the insane drivers. Same with biking. Added benefits of being in nature and getting off pavement helps your joints a bit.
- carimura 3y ago+1. my favorite loops both have some streets though including ones without sidewalks. I run against traffic and it's basically a game of "does that driver see me" for decent stretches.
- Velofellow 3y agoI understand why runners do this (asphalt is softer than concrete, no sidewalk in a given stretch) but as a cyclist I've had inattentive or aggressive(?) runners force me into traffic lanes by running contra-flow in a bike lane with painted directional arrows. Am not in your running shoes, so I won't judge where you need to run to feels safest, but please be on the lookout!
- carimura 3y agogood point. I'm in the suburbs so no [explicitly] directional lanes but agreed runners should almost always yield nevertheless.
- rcme 3y agoA large issue in the US is that local communities have very little control over many of the roads in their communities. In addition to locally controlled roads, there are county roads, state roads, and interstates. As a result, even if a community wants to make their road safer, they have no power to do so. There is a county road in my town. The crosswalks make no sense and the road needs to be narrowed to force traffic to slow down. People have been complain about this for a long time. A teenager was stuck and killed a few months ago. Still nothing has been done because the town has almost no power over the county. And if this was a state road, there would be no hope.
- kibwen 3y ago> As a result, even if a community wants to make their road safer, they have no power to do so. Visions of black-clad infrastructure guerillas working at night to install speed bumps on residential roads.
- mbauman 3y agoPerfect example here is that Indiana has just created a law that explicitly forbids a singular targeted city from adding _any_ new restrictions against turning right on red in _any_ intersection. https://legiscan.com/IN/bill/HB1050/2023 https://legiscan.com/IN/bill/HB1050/2023
- injb 3y agoIn Europe the view is that bigger vehicle = bigger responsibility. In the US the attitude seems to be bigger vehicle = bigger right of way. The party who stands to lose the most is expected to yield the right of way.
- SoftTalker 3y agoAre trains required to stop at level crossings in Europe, because they have the bigger responsibility?
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoNo. There's a big song and dance here (one country) every time someone is foolish enough to cross when the barrier is down. So much that the govt and rail network want to eliminate them when it is just a handful of people a year. Now road vehicles getting hit is dangerous to train and track but I am talking about pedestrians.
- Symbiote 3y agoThe railway's responsibility is having a ten-nines reliable (or whatever it is) signalling system, to be practically certain that the lights, alarms and barriers of the level crossing work correctly every time. (Or fail safe, i.e. fail to the barriers lowering.)
- hermannj314 3y agoIn many states you are required to stop if a pedestrian is crossing the street. What has happened a lot is I will stop to let a pedestrian cross the street at a legal cross walk and the person behind me will assume I am an idiot, honk, and speed around me. My intuition is this is the cause of a significant amount of pedestrian deaths: impatient drivers that assume every stopped car is just an obstacle to zip around. We had an 8 year old boy die in my hometown to this exact scenario and I have witnessed too many near collisions to count. I would support making passing like this automatic jail time, equivalent in severity to drunk driving.
- i80and 3y agoThis happened to me and it left me with lasting anxiety. I stopped in town at a crosswalk for a pedestrian waiting to cross, and the car a couple seconds behind me went around and tore through the crosswalk. I don't know what the answer is. Drivers make mistakes -- they don't see things, they might be preoccupied, etc. etc. And yeah, all too often they're negligent to the point of malice. But urban landscapes are almost explicitly designed to force those misjudgements to have literally life-ending consequences, and I haven't seen any large-scale societal acknowledgement of that.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe thing to do is NOT do the unexpected. Being excessively courteous and letting an oncoming car turn left, or stopping for a pedestrian who is not already in the crosswalk but is waiting for a gap in traffic, is unexpected. It surprises other drivers and they get annoyed and then do something stupid like zooming around you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- michaelmrose 3y agoIf you are required by law to stop for them once they are in the crosswalk then cars should expect to find people stopped some of the time and stop themselves. If nobody expects to stop then pedestrians either must always wait for a big enough gap that they hope to cross unimpeded or step out knowing you are coming to force you to stop. The first is frequently impossible and the second is dangerous. It also creates the "dangerous" situation of having a car stopped at an intersection. Older folks especially likely to have a hard time doing A or B due to decreasing mobility and vision. Personally I think if you can't handle such a scenario safely you have no business being in charge of a car.
- blindriver 3y agoIsn't it obvious? Distracted drivers and distracted pedestrians from cell phones. I was just rear-ended last week by a distracted driver, luckily I wasn't injured. There needs to be a measure as to how distracting a car's interface is, and there needs to be regulations around this. Tesla's interface for example, takes far too much time and attention to do simply things like change the fan speed or temperature. I think we need a way to quantify this, and enforce regulations so that our 2023 mini-Batmobiles don't cause more problems than they solve. In terms of pedestrians, that's a harder problem to solve because I've come across so many pedestrians that just walk out onto the street without looking, or even thinking of looking because they're on their phones.
- michaelsshaw 3y agoThere are a few more factors that drive this number up. First is the absolute reliance on cars for basically everything; anyone not in a car is a second-class citizen that can be killed at any time without much thought given by the public other than the typical "It's just unavoidable, these things happen. What can you do?" Another factor driving this number up is the massive increase in average car size, as SUVs and pickup trucks are pushed harder on average citizens by car companies so they can skirt taxes and make more profits. Add on top of this huge roads and extremely anti-pedestrian laws and you have successfully created a death trap for people walking.
- Tiktaalik 3y agoPeople in Europe have iPhones too, but their pedestrian death rate is plunging in compared to the USA. USA is an outlier and there's something else going on. It's likely SUV related given that the most popular cars in the EU are small hatchbacks.
- blindriver 3y agoI think American drivers are much more selfish and more glued to their phones than Europeans. However I think your point about SUVs make sense too. I guess we could tell the difference between pedestrian accidents vs pedestrian deaths to see how similar they are between Europe and the US.
- alexb_ 3y agoIIRC police enforcement of traffic laws is at an all time low. That might be a huge factor into why this happens.
- Apreche 3y ago[flagged]
- johnea 3y agoIn this analysis, pickup trucks and SUVs are identical, in that they have high vertical grills that obstruct the driver's view of the area immediately in front of the vehicle. This vehicle configuration is the major cause of the increase in pedistrian accidents. However I was surprised the article didn't mention pedestrian behavior at all, which is clearly increasing the risk of pedistrian accidents in recent years. My experiences with pedistrian near misses have been when people step in front of my car while staring at their phone. The worst cases being mid-block, at night, while the pedestrian was wearing all black. Walkable cities are awesome! Unfortunately in the US the overwhelming majority of places offer very poor, or no, mass transit and cars are still the only practiucal means of transportation.
- robswc 3y agoHere's a thread where residents of Albuquerque, the city with the highest rate of pedestrian deaths in the US. https://www.reddit.com/r/Albuquerque/comments/123uyd3/pedestrians_get_no_respect_in_abq/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Albuquerque/comments/123uyd3/pedest... It seems that's mostly the consensus. A combination of bad design and distracted drivers/pedestrians. It seems J-walking is a real issue and I've driven through there and the speeds are pretty fast (which should be fine in theory but ofc not fine if people are J-walking). Also seems to be a fair amount of people on drugs wandering into the street. Seems like a perfect storm.
- noodlesUK 3y agoI’d be interested to see if there is any breakdown in these statistics between the types of vehicles involved (truck vs car vs SUV) and the number of fatalities per mile driven. Road safety seems like it’s just not an issue that captures much public attention. People seem to care in theory, but get mad every time someone actually wants to do something to make somewhere safer (like introducing traffic calming hardware).
- FigurativeVoid 3y agoI’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. The amount of just reckless driving I see on a daily basis is staggering. People patently don’t pay attention. One hand on the phone and another eating. Even without phones, speeding is basically expected in the US.
- tristor 3y agoJust one more evidence point for why crossovers, SUVs, and trucks are stupid passenger vehicles. There are way too many of these behemoths on our roadways, many lifted, making it worse for pedestrians, anyone driving a normal decent car, and the environment. We have an arms race of stupidity with everyone trying to get a bigger vehicle than everybody else so they can drive more aggressively, see past the other stupidly large boxes, and feed their false egotistical ideas about safety in size. When will we get regulations that get us back to actual cars on the road instead of a sea of “bimbo boxes” as predicted in Snow Crash?
- intotheabyss 3y agoIs it really stupid to participate in this arms race? The data suggests that you are much safer in an SUV or truck when it comes to vehicle on vehicle accidents. In fact, the average deaths per 10 billion miles for cars and light vehicles is roughly 40, which is almost twice as many deaths as compared to trucks or SUVs. It's even worse for mini 4 door cars, at around 80 deaths per 10 billion miles. The only thing safer than a truck or SUV is a minivan. The correct choice for individuals is to participate in the arms race, unfortunately. You are correct that the only way around this is though regulations, but a lot of people aren't going to hold their breath. If you can't beat em, join em. https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-model https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-...
- saiya-jin 3y agoGood point. This can be trivially tackled to have ie vehicle tax based on some formula with horse power, weight, category of vehicle etc. Ie Switzerland has it, each canton their own rules. You wanna destroy roads and environment more with your poor car choices? Pay up and go ahead if you want. Use earned money to road repairs, cleanup of pollution etc.
- ouid 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- yboris 3y agoAlso related, one of my favorite philosophy papers: Vehicles and Crashes: Why is this Moral Issue Overlooked? by Douglas Husak Argues that SUVs are immoral because of the high crash incompatibility. They cause more damage to others (disproportionally), and ironically don't provide more safety for drivers due to higher rollover instances. https://www.jstor.org/stable/23562447 https://www.jstor.org/stable/23562447
- tristor 3y agoThis is also one of my favorite papers. It's utterly ridiculous how the "normal"/"average" vehicle in the US is now a huge crossover that drives like a beached whale, most of which have 4 occupants or less from manufacture to when they end up in a junkyard. It's utterly ridiculous. Nearly anything a crossover or SUV can do, an AWD hatchback can do better while being safer for pedestrians, other drivers, better for the environment, and generally less of a nuisance. Americans have become pathologically selfish when it comes to driving.
- some_random 3y agoEveryone seems to really want to blame cars being too big or whatever, but since cops stopped enforcing traffic violations in many places over covid some drivers have gone absolutely crazy. I'm the last person to ask for _more_ policing but something has to be done here. I also suspect that more and more people are walking in general, although I don't have any evidence for that.
- 1Y3 3y agoIn a functioning built environment more walking should result in exactly 0 more pedestrian deaths, but alas it's the people who are to blame for killing each other.
- bbsimonbb 3y agoThere were 488 Pedestrian deaths in France in 2022, (pop. 57 million, 3 times less likely) There were 57 in holland (pop 17 million, 6 times less likely)
- pizzafeelsright 3y agoI would be most curious to see the data. From my reading of the news in my surrounding 30 miles the details are almost always: 1. downtown or country road late/nighttime driver hits transient 2. daytime freeway driver hits transient 3. rural biker/runner gets hit by drunk or early morning commuter
- cactusplant7374 3y agoWe need cameras that enforce actually stopping at stop signs. It would force more people to pay attention.
- vel0city 3y agoToo many people push back against cameras with arguments like "how do they know who was driving at the time?!" I don't care. The car has a registered owner. The registered owner needs to be responsible for the actions of whoever they delegate access to the car. Start sending tickets, send that information to the insurance companies, let their rates skyrocket. Be responsible for your shit!
- parineum 3y agoThat's the argument after someone is ticketed. That's not the argument before they are installed.
- Kalanos 3y agoi like how the chose sun belt instead of bible belt
- AlbertCory 3y ago"Walking without looking where you're going" needs to be a ticketable offense. Extra fines if you walk into a street. Sometimes I'll see someone heading right towards me, not looking, and I shout "Hello!" Frequently there isn't even an apology.
- michaelsshaw 3y agoMakes sense: as pedestrians you are at much greater risk so it is your responsibility to make sure psychopaths driving dangerous lifted trucks don't kill you at every turn.
- Cupertino95014 3y ago> psychopaths driving dangerous lifted trucks whoa. You got some anger issues there, pal.
- michaelsshaw 3y agoYou might be projecting a little bit. There's a reason we say that people with trucks like that are compensating; it's because they are.
- Cupertino95014 3y ago> projecting a little bit way to turn it around! But you're the one with the psychobabble rhetoric.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoDoes nobody else find it weird that in most of suburban America there are still no sidewalks? I was just driving around US1 in Connecticut and there were no sidewalks. Lots of people walking on grass beside the road to get to a bus stop. I guess if you're handicapped you just move.
- christophilus 3y agoI find it sad, but not weird, at least, not if weird means "unexpected". Sidewalks cost money, and urban sprawl is full of the kinds of cost-cutting decisions that cause long-term problems but look good on short-term accounting spreadsheets.
- roflyear 3y agoThere are sidewalks on much of US1, but no, it isn't surprising that more highway-like roads do not have sidewalks.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoThe speed limit is 35mph, there are 1-2 two lanes, plus an occasional middle turn lane, there are street lights, the roadway isn't elevated, and connects directly to businesses and homes. I don't think there's a less highway-like road, other than dirt ones.
- roflyear 3y agoI'm almost certain people do more than 35 on that road :)
- acuozzo 3y agoTHIS is why so many parents in the USA are afraid to let their children play outside alone. Seeing a BMW fly down a sleepy suburban street is enough to scare the shit out of you as a parent, especially if your children are inattentive.
- somenameforme 3y agoThis article seems to be based on a butchery of statistics, for the sake of a headline. It's referring to total deaths, not per capita, let alone per pedestrian. The article breathlessly claims that, "...more than 7,500 pedestrians were killed by drivers last year — the highest number since 1981." Not only has the population increased by more than 100 million people since 1981, but the number of pedestrians has increased even faster than the number of people has, with ever more people going carless - especially in some of the largest and most densely packed cities, like NYC. That these values are staying so low seems to be the real story, as it would seem to indicate that cities are doing a great job of adjusting to an increasing pedestrian population. But, if it bleeds - it leads, I suppose. Perhaps with the modern addendum that if it doesn't bleed, then just splash some ketchup on it.
- actionablefiber 3y agoThe number was 4,109 in 2009[1]. In 2022 the number is 7,509, per TFA. We are in the middle of an alarming rebound that has significantly outpaced population growth. [1]https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/07/us/pedestrian-deaths.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/07/us/pedestrian-deaths.html
- somenameforme 3y agoLike mentioned it's not just population growth. It's population growth alongside the fact that there's more pedestrians than ever. And unfortunately I missed probably also perhaps the single biggest factor: smart phones. Not only do you have more pedestrians than ever, they're also now going to be walking around with their faces shoved into a smart phone instead of paying attention to their surroundings. That pedestrian deaths were higher at some point in the past is what's the real story here.
- actionablefiber 3y ago> That pedestrian deaths were higher at some point in the past is what's the real story here. I deeply disagree with this take. I am living in a world in which boxes of metal fly around my unprotected flesh at high speeds, and "will I make it home safe today" is not only a dice roll for my life, but one in which the odds are getting worse by the day. One thing that keeps these numbers comparatively low is a pervasive culture of fear among people who walk, since they need to keep their head on a swivel and be prepared to save their lives at a moment's notice from someone else's negligent behavior in a motor vehicle. Another thing that keeps these numbers comparatively low is that many people in more walkable areas choose to walk less, or not at all, due to that danger. Another thing that keeps these numbers comparatively low is the proliferation of exurban developments in the past four decades in which walking anywhere is an absolute nonstarter. It is interesting, perhaps, that pedestrian deaths used to be worse. It is not a consolation, nor is it the "real story." I would say the "real story" is that pedestrian deaths are rebounding in the U.S. even though in European nations pedestrian deaths continued falling significantly after 2009.[1] [1]https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/10/10/exactly-how-far-u-s-street-safety-has-fallen-behind-europe-in-four-bombshell-charts https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/10/10/exactly-how-far-u-s-s... (one of the images appears to have had an image link break, so refer to https://web.archive.org/web/20201101012509/https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/10/10/exactly-how-far-u-s-street-safety-has-fallen-behind-europe-in-four-bombshell-charts/ https://web.archive.org/web/20201101012509/https://usa.stree...)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoAre roads/drivers actually worse? Or is this a heatmap of pedestrian frequency.
- egberts1 3y agoJust a few moments ago, two pedestrians just jumped out in middle of a four-lane residential street that has no crosswalk for at least 400yd in either direction from behind a hedgerow. Didn't see it but lucky i was traveling 10 below speed limit (in a 40mph speed limit) My "S"pecially "H"igh "I"ntensity "T"ooter emitted a 142 dB sound and the glee of watching both pedies startled and scurrying faster across the street barely brought a small measure of satisfaction. But it is a sobering reminder that i need to get a dashcam because one of these days, I may not be able to have the response time to press the bullhorn (or worse, to brake) in a timely manner for a later court trial is not going to be a pleasant thing to go thru, death or not.
- mbauman 3y agoI see that anecdote as a sobering reminder of the state of our roads and drivers. That sounds like inappropriate infrastructure (a 4-lane residential stroad?) combined with a person who prioritizes their ability to drive as they wish over others' lives, and who takes glee at their ability to dominate others, and a legal framework that empowers them to do so.
- egberts1 3y agoNah, the reaction time for drivers are getting shorter as pedestrians are getting bolder. Must get a dashcam, due to increasing legal burden and riskier pedestrians being placed on the driver.
- p_j_w 3y agoNot only do you have a 4 lane residential road but there's no crosswalk for 400 yards in either direction and you think the problem is your ability to drive uninhibited is at risk. Not only that, but you think the worst part about your potentially hitting someone with your car is not serious injury or death, but that you might have to deal with it legally. Good fucking god, there's so much wrong here.
- fargle 3y agoWe've definitely seen a lot more pedestrian deaths in our area in the last couple years. But it's not the prevalence or size of the cars, SUVs, trucks. What's happening here is that there's an explosion of homeless living and walking in and around the very fast two-lane roads and one highway in particular. They are drugged out of their mind and oblivious. Just about every couple weeks there's a fatality where someone wanders into the road or crosses unsafely in the night and the car or often 18-wheeler can't see to avoid them. At highway speeds it wouldn't matter if it was a Honda, and sometimes is. This isn't a suburban or urban area where it's people getting mowed down in the crosswalks. This is out in the desert. Just another way that fentanyl kills. Since 5 years ago, it seems to have increased almost an order of magnitude. So as captivating as the SUV story is, at least here it's nothing to do with it. But might not be like that everywhere. But the article doesn't address this at all.
- roflyear 3y agoIf you are making claims you have to back them up somewhat.
- fargle 3y agodoesn't that go for the "experts" (especially Martin) in this article, too? while unsatisfying, the evidence that i put out is from first-hand experience and is at least better than the hand-waving correlation/causation. especially when it's easy to point to at least one obvious factor that isn't mentioned. I found this which does goes into it partially: http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/phcommon/public/media/mediapubhpdetail.cfm?prid=4384 http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/phcommon/public/media/media...
- roflyear 3y agoWell, sort of. If a professor of finance writes an article about how options work I'll trust it, but if he starts saying "historically options were used to xyz abc political thing whatever" then sure he should back up his argument.
- kpennell 3y ago
- roflyear 3y agoMost roads don't need through traffic, at least in densely populated areas. We should focus on making it so cars do not drive where people want to be walking. In my small town, there are a lot of aggressive drivers. Of course there are many ways to get where they are going, they just end up on a street where there are people crossing the road. Then they are super aggressive about it.
- briandear 3y agoI wish we could have these discussions with actual data instead of emotions. The top four cars involved in fatal accidents in the US (not exclusive to pedestrians) but all fatal accidents. Chevy Silverado. Ford F-150. Honda Accord. Toyota Camry. The first SUV on the list, the Ford Explorer is in 10th place. The Silverado and F150 are also the most popular work trucks, so those drivers are on the roads more miles per day, I don’t have that data specifically but my point is that the data isn’t simply about “big trucks are more dangerous.” The Ford Focus kills more people than a Chevy Tahoe. In California the number one killer is the Honda Civic. In New York, it’s the Accord. https://www.titlemax.com/discovery-center/planes-trains-and-automobiles/vehicles-that-are-involved-in-the-most-fatal-accidents-in-the-u-s/ https://www.titlemax.com/discovery-center/planes-trains-and-...
- dhbradshaw 3y agoNeed basic stats to make sense of this. The most hopeful interpretation is that there are more pedestrians than ever. Alternatively maybe there are just too many big vehicles or maybe people are bad drivers. Or maybe both. But without more granular data it's all just-so stories.
- janitor61 3y agoone variable to take into consideration that I hardly see mentioned, ever - legalization of marijuana in California and other states: there's been a few times on my commute to work where I drive through distinct smell cloud of someone's exhaled pot smoke, and this is in the morning! People might be thinking weed is 'ok' to use while driving and that it's better than alcohol or something...
- parineum 3y agoI have my own opinions that I don't want to share because I would rather comment that both the content of this article and the top comments found here are a Rorschach test. There's practically zero data provided beyond "pedestrian deaths up" yet the article and each comment seem to be confidently stating (various) different primary causes.
- CalRobert 3y agoNot only do we kill thousands of people a year with our vehicles, and get away with it, we stole the outdoors from our children. For every child a driver kills, hundreds — thousands — more are told to stay away from the road, to play in the backyard, not the front, and that no, they can't walk or bike to school, maybe when they're older (but of course "older" basically means "when you can drive"). Then we wonder why kids seem so insecure, anxious, and to lack independence. And why adults are so lonely. Where we used to have humans we now have steel beasts hurtling along at terrifying speeds. Our streets are places of violence. We're moving the the Netherlands this summer because the US has gone absolutely, mind-bendingly insane. Mechs slaughter our children and far too many think the kids are the problem.
- faefox 3y agoAmericans are slaves to cars. We treat the ability to drive a monster truck to the grocery store as a sacred right and anyone who would dare impede our progress for a handful of seconds (pedestrians, yes, but ESPECIALLY those rotten tree-hugging cyclists) are to be scorned and intimidated at best, summarily executed at worst. We've hollowed out our cities for parking lots and leveled neighborhoods and green spaces to make room for ever-expanding freeways, but god forbid we invest in public transportation - the domain of socialists and poor people. And so many of us have effectively brainwashed ourselves into believing that all of this is right and good and not, in fact, utterly insane.
- c_crank 3y ago[flagged]
- tiny_ta 3y agoInteresting, because I have a theory that less dependence on cars would actually lead to fewer crazy, homeless people and more vibrant neighbourhoods: the reason being that lower income folks wouldn't have to spend so much time and money on cars. As tempting as it is to look away, we're only fracturing our society more by drawing lines between different income classes, if we don't invest in things like walkable neighbourhoods and public transport.
- c_crank 3y agoGangs and homeless camps are generally endemic to urban areas, not rural ones, despite rural low income groups having a far greater need to rely on cars to get around.
- tiny_ta 3y agoHuh, this is even more interesting because I always thought that homeless folk gravitate towards city centers and not that urban areas cause homelessness. I'm not looking to contradict you, just saying it's funny how we look at the same things and completely reverse the cause and effects in our heads :) My thinking is that homeless folks tend to move towards city centers because they are more noticed, have more footfalls go past them and hence is easier for them to get food/change etc. They would not be likely to go to the suburbs because they are harder to get around, there are fewer people around to help, and it's very easy to get the police called on you for loitering around someone's lawn.
- jscipione 3y agoNPR presents, speculation but little facts. Can I get a racial demographic of the drivers and pedestrians? It says that the largest increase of accidents was in the Sun Belt and Florida, could the large influx of new Hispanic drivers since 2020 be the cause? I have no idea there’s not enough data presented to make a determination one way or the other.
- Moldoteck 3y agoPicachu face oh wow, making an suv the among the most popular cars in a country and designing 80+% of that country for car use exclusively ignoring a lot of research related to pedestrian safety can lead to this??? Truly surprised!
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWe only spend $50B on infrastructure related to roads. Double or triple that on safety measures and making it 100x more enjoyable to walk (bridges, art, etc.) would be a huge ROI.
- chmod600 3y agoThr article lacks numerical context, or at least makes it more difficult to find than necessary. Is this a 1% increase over 10 years or a 10% increase over 1 year? Is it normalized by population or an absolute number?
- wcarron 3y agoIt's not just pedestrians. I think I'll never ride motorcycles on public roads again. I just don't trust drivers. They're all talking, texting, watching a fucking YouTube video or TikTok reel. I've seen people eating spaghetti with a fork and knife while driving! It's insane how selfish and unaware drivers are, and it got way worse after Covid. Lax licensing standards and the average U.S adults abysmal literacy levels (read: the average driver neither knows nor can they comprehend the very basic laws governing driving) contribute to turning streets into a chaotic carnival. Combined with the massive size of vehicles, ridiculous amount of illegal modifications, and nonexistent enforcement of traffic/vehicle laws, there is absolutely nothing surprising about this news.
- lsllc 3y agoIt's Phones ... everywhere I go I see people using their phones while driving. Source: as an avid runner, whenever I cross streets I make eye contact with drivers to ensure they see me.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAren't bikers considered "liberal elite woke". And in places like Texas, it is considered just good sport to run them off the road?
- manzanarama 3y agoHas anyone looked to see if there are more or less pedestrians?
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoAnd why? TEXTING. Until states make texting while driving a DUI-level offense, with the same penalties, this isn't going to get better. I'm so tired of seeing people bellyaching about "speeding" when in fact the real problem is texting. Whining about "speed" lets politicians and law enforcement off the hook for not addressing the glaringly obvious threat to everyone on the road. And instead of cracking down on it, they waste taxpayers' money to destroy taxpayers' roads with ridiculous third-world impediments, stealing from 100% of drivers 100% of the time.
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoLove how someone actually down-modded that. Yeah, up with stealing from others and putting their lives at risk! Incredible.
- bluescrn 3y agoIt's easy to blame the drivers, but in the era of the smartphone, I suspect that there's a massive decrease in the ability of pedestrians to actually look where they're going...
- lusus_naturae 3y agoI am not a fan of people needlessly dying. I guess I don't understand why automotive deaths are such a focus on internet boards. I am guessing because there's desire to push public sentiment towards self-driving vehicles? Self-driving vehicles would be interesting to implement/have regardless of anti-car/anti-human driving agendas; the demise of one does not necessitate the acceptance of the other. Or if we care so much about people dying in some manner, then why not focus on preventable deaths from falls, or accidental poisonings, or other reasons? If the idea is to prevent unnecessary, accidental death then it makes sense to sort the data based on numbers of deaths caused annually by category. Otherwise the pearl cluthing is just that, inauthentic and disingenuous. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/accidental-injury.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/accidental-injury.htm
- hermannj314 3y agoThe constitution does talk about freedom of movement. I think being able to walk from one State to another (or within) without being killed by a semi is a reasonable and compelling interest of the government that promises such freedom. If someone dies from cutting down a tree on their property or falls down a staircase in their own home, I am not sure there is as strong of an interest from the government to correct that situation. That is my hot take. I think a prosperous society should move in the direction of being safer in all regards, but pedestrians dying from licensed motor vehicle operators seems like the government's problem to take seriously and not pearl clutching.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> I guess I don't understand why automotive deaths are such a focus on internet boards. I don't know if it's the international nature of online discussion, or just that online discussion favors a certain type of personality, but there is a huge divergence between what appears to be a popular belief online, and what people are like in the real world.
- rootusrootus 3y agoSomething happened around 2010, it seems. Followed by another big jump in 2020. We've had big SUVs and trucks a lot longer than 2010, so my thought is that something else changed. Smartphones maybe. And we all know what happened in 2020. Many people still haven't relearned how to drive sanely after that fiasco, though I'm not sure why.
- refurb 3y agoThis number is adjusted for population, right? Oh wait it wasn't.
- mattlondon 3y agoI see the thing about "Oh it is SUVs" holds up to any level of scrutiny when compared against other places? In London at least there are a lot of SUVs now. Granted they are not all as huge as your quintessential escalade or Tahoe (which incidentally you do see the odd imported one) but there are more larger cars on the roads these days. Are pedestrian deaths also increasing as a result too?
- lykahb 3y agoIt is weird that the sidewalks are built right next to the road, with no green space between them. That makes it much more stressful and unsafe to walk in North America. The older communities still have the divider.
- lost_tourist 3y agoDo these numbers make any sense unless they are put in perspective of "deaths as a percentage of population" ?
- silexia 3y agoThe article states the cause as more SUV's without real evidence... My guess is the real cause is simply people using cell phones while driving. Or the great reduction in law enforcement the last two years.
- aimor 3y agoI don't understand the claim that SUVs are the cause of increased pedestrian deaths. I understand that SUVs are more damaging to pedestrians when hit, but it doesn't look like SUVs are contributing to pedestrian deaths any more than other vehicles. From 2012 to 2021 the percent of pedestrian deaths caused by SUVs went from 17% to 24%, but the production share of SUVs also jumped from 21% to 45%. The share of SUVs on the road will lag production, so it would be better to compare number of vehicles or miles driven, but it's difficult to find that data. I did a few estimates and I keep getting the surprising result that fewer pedestrians are killed per registered SUV than registered sedan, pickup, van, or truck. There's a lot of other good data. Deaths are largely increasing in adult populations (20-69 years) while children are safer than ever. (Pedestrian deaths per 100,000 people by age, 1975-2021: https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedestrians https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedes... ) Deaths are most likely to happen when it's dark (77% from 9 pm to 6 am, more deaths in winter than summer), and from 2010 to 2021 deaths during the day increased 30% but deaths at night increased 86%. Increasingly deaths are occurring in urban areas (84%). And most of those killed are men (75%). https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/813458 https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/... https://www.epa.gov/automotive-trends/explore-automotive-trends-data https://www.epa.gov/automotive-trends/explore-automotive-tre... https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedestrians https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedes... https://www.bts.gov/nts/50th https://www.bts.gov/nts/50th https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policyinformation/statistics/2020/mv1.cfm https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policyinformation/statistics/2020/m...
- alexleeds 3y agoThe U.S. population is also at a 40-year high, so this was fairly likely.