21 ms·
Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
- ClarityJones 3y agoThe church had the same complaints when the printing press undermined their monopoly on Truth. However, it's now clear that the technology gave rise to the renaissance, and the greatest discovery and propagation of truth that humanity has ever seen.
- azangru 3y ago[flagged]
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoInvoking the name of another revolution doesn't automatically make this new one equally as beneficial. I don't follow your argument - what monopoly is going to be be undermined here? What information will the AI give people access to that wasn't already available?
- ClarityJones 3y agoI think AI will give broader and more convenient access to much of the same information that is technically already available, but requires additional work to discover. For example, the books printed by the printing press disseminated information that was already known to tutors, scholars, etc. and often existed in handwritten manuscripts. Today, we wouldn't call that accessible, but that was the standard for accessibility (or word of mouth) before the printing press. AI makes it more likely that people will find informaiton because it can do much of the work of searching billions of sources and synthesize the information far more convenient way. That's not to say the information will always be true, just as the information in books is not always true. However, readers currently have far too much faith in authors. People believe claims because they're made using professional-sounding words, and published in a respected newspaper, by a human author, and accompanied by photographs. None of that is particularly good evidence if truth. The last time this happened on this scale, people became more sophisticated consumers of information, with a healthier level of skepticism, and simply came to have less confidence in claims that they did not have personal knowledge of. That was a good thing, and probably will be again.
- tgv 3y agoThe church didn't object to the printing press, AFAIK. Unless you can produce a papal bull forbidding it, I think you've undermined your own argument.
- ClarityJones 3y agoThat's not really relevant to my point, which was that new means of spreading information are capable of spreading both true and false information, and that history has shown that the ability to spread false information does not prevent the positive impact of true information. So instead of a papal bull, how about a stack exchange with links explaining how (even if the church did not oppose the press itself) the church did attack its users for publishing information that the church was opposed to (i.e. claimed was false). https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/42677/why-did-the-church-attack-mainz-for-printing-books https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/42677/why-did-th... Or an article about how Luther was excommunicated for what he did with the printing press. https://www.history.com/news/renaissance-influence-reformation-humanism https://www.history.com/news/renaissance-influence-reformati... Perhaps the Church's complaints were more directed at the dissemination of information that the Church considered to be false... like the Wired article's complaints about AI's potential to spread false information. My point is that free speech is good. Free speech may include lies, but people are smart and even lies help listeners learn.
- tgv 3y agoSo, your point is not the printing press, but it was "the church". Well, in this case, it isn't "the church", so there any analogy already fails. > history has shown that the ability to spread false information does not prevent the positive impact of true information. And that's enough? So we can forget about The protocols of Elders of Zion and the stab-in-the-back myth and the misery they imparted because something else overcame that? Or closer to home: we should simply ignore things like Cambridge Analytica and the meddling in the US elections, even though it moved, and still could be moving, the USA towards a fascist regime? > people are smart No, most aren't, and even what's normally considered smart people can believe in hoaxes and act to the detriment of society. > even lies help listeners learn You lost me there. Learning is not a goal per se. Learning from malicious information can lead to malicious outcomes. If you want to invoke a history lesson, that would be a good one.
- ecmascript 3y agoWe don't need AI for that, people believe all kinds of crap and honestly sometimes rightly so because goverments all over the world have become really unrealiable in the information they give out. As an example of this, my goverment just recently updated the recommended food intake because they want to lower our emissions. Perhaps the goal itself is nice but that shouldn't imo have any effect on whatever foods are healthy or not for you. The result is that their food recommendations cannot be trusted anymore and you start doubting if other communication from the same authority can be trusted? The problem with many AI shops is that they are already biased which has been shown on many occations so I believe many will not trust in their AI-companion. GPS data doesn't try to shove some political opinion down your throat and it has historically worked very well over many years so that is the reason why everyone trusts it.
- throwawayadvsec 3y ago[flagged]
- digitalsushi 3y agoWe may not be ready but we may as well get ready. I would strongly prefer to work with skeptical people again. Skeptics can be convinced, they just need evidence. Although I am genuinely intrigued by AI running out of things to ingest, and moving onto AI generated content. Is the snake starting to eat its tail?
- RobinUS2 3y agoHow are we going to provide that evidence? And make sure that evidence is actually true, instead of AI generated? Send them a link to a wiki page that has been mutated by an AI bot updating it? ;-)
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoEye witness testimony, public key encryption, reputation matters. No more anonymous viral "information".
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoHere's an elaboration of what I mean. Writers should adopt two habits: (1) Sign your statements. If you say something, sign it, so that others know you said it. Cryptography is good at this. (2) Hash your citations. If you cite something, include a hash of it. This way, if the thing you cited is altered, readers can tell that that's not what you were citing. Note that this idea can be applied to audio and video, not just text. The rest of the responsibility falls on readers: (1) Read (i.e. consider) citations. (2) Read (i.e. consider) the sources of evidence you ingest. Don't just find a video and believe it happened. Determine who has claimed to have witnessed those events. For this, a public database of back-references might be helpful. But even without one, a decentralized solution is possible. Writers, whenever they cite something, could simply send their citation (and its context) to the author of the cited material. If the cited author attaches the back-citation to the content that was cited, then anyone who comes across the content can see who has cited it. There is of course the problem that some back-citations will be rejected -- if you cite what I wrote to call it stupid, I am unlikely to want to share that fact with the world. But if what I wrote is sufficiently important, then hopefully someone will waht to host a "nemesis" site, which collects negative citations. A public database of nemesis sites would be helpful. (3) Read (i.e. consider) the reputations of authors you read. This is nearly the reverse of the last point. When deciding whether to believe what someone has said, consider what else they have said. This is of course a hard problem. An author might be qualified in one area and writing about another. An author's reputation might be damaged for extrinsic (e.g. malice) reasons, rather than intrinsic ones. But a statement's author is too important a context to ignore. (4) Do cool graph-traversing investigations. Determine who someone tends to cite. Identify misinformation cliques -- close-knit collections of liars who all cite each other. Identify readership patterns that make people productive. We have seen how social network information can make a corporation money. As a society, I suspect there is a similar amount of value to be extracted from them.
- azangru 3y ago> Michael Graziano, a professor of psychology and neuroscience at Princeton University, says he thinks AI could create a “post-truth world.” He says it will likely make it significantly easier to convince people of false narratives, which will be disruptive in many ways Significantly easier? I would have thought that it would get harder to convince people of anything.
- oatmeal1 3y agoConfirmation bias is one hell of a drug. If people want to believe something, and AI provides somewhat believable fake evidence, they will believe it.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNow, instead of 3 tasty lies to choose from, you're going to have 100 to choose from. Pick your favorite flavor! And, the more flavors of lies there are (and the more they are able to manufacture "evidence" to support the lies), the more effort it takes to figure out what's actually true, and the more people give up. That's the "significantly harder" part - if people have given up, they won't buy a lie, but they won't buy the truth either. In C. S. Lewis's The Last Battle, Aslan says of some dwarves, "They are so afraid of being taken in, that they cannot be taken out." (Quoted from memory, may not be word-for-word.) If people are so afraid of being suckered by a lie that they can't be convinced of the truth either, then those people are at "post truth" in a very real sense. So we're left with either confirmation bias driving you to a comfortable lie, refusing to believe anything, or a huge and increasing amount of work to sort out what's actually true. The path of virtue grows harder...
- Maken 3y agoSometimes I think the fears of extremely convincing AI-generated post-truths influencing public opinion are greatly overblown. People is already brain-washed by poorly made, low resolution JPGs shared by bots in social networks, the entire AI stack is simply wasteful.
- 0xBABAD00C 3y agoAlso, when have people not followed "false narratives"? The entire human civilization sits on a stack of false narratives.
- dale_glass 3y agoI don't think we're mentally ready for social media, even. What something like Twitter can inflict on a person when it goes wrong is absolutely unprecedented, and we still haven't adapted to it. Think that for instance going to the cinema, watching a movie, walking out and venting to a friend "Boy, this one sucked. $ACTOR_NAME did a really bad job with this one" is a perfectly normal thing to do. But move that to Twitter and it can become part of a years-long torrent of hate highly visible to that single person. Even if what you think you're doing is communicating with your 10 friends. A retweet, a hashtag, or just the algorithm can magically make your comment part of an online mob.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoOr give you the illusion that someone's listening, compellingly enough that you neglect the work of making friends in the real world.
- figassis 3y agoI never understood why this makes social media hard. If you leave the theater and then go around town shouting that movie X sucked and actor Y was really bad, you might also get some responses and maybe show up on the news a a crazy person, prejudiced, or some other adjectives. So you don't, you tell your friends, some of which might call you an idiot for not getting it, and other might agree. If you tweet it out, you're potentially asking the entire planet to weigh in, well, have fun with that.
- inanutshellus 3y agoGP says "the consequences of speaking normally are radically different now" and your retort is "I don't get why this is hard, just always perfectly self-censor." Of course one'd have to do so in a way that one'd never offend anyone, ever, across the entire planet. Seems like an unrealistic response.
- oh_sigh 3y agoYou could also send it in an email or text message to a limited set of friends, and then one of them screenshots it and posts it to the wider internet. You could also be caught on a recording or video saying the thing to a limited set of friends, and have it go viral on the internet. In any case, "going around town shouting" is not at all akin to twitter. It is more like having a public board where you write things signed with your name. Anyone can look at it, but it takes zero effort to not look at it, and for most people, no one looks at it except their friends who want to look at it.
- api 3y agoHumans are not mentally ready for anything beyond tribes on the African savanna. Everything else is achieved via complicated brain hacks or social structure hacks that function like cognitive dongles to let a tribal hominid interface with a radically different world. We just need to develop a whole new battery of hacks for this world. It’s happening slowly. I’m not convinced that AI is going to make things qualitatively different from social media. It may allow bad actors to produce a lot more bullshit but it’s not like an environment saturated in bullshit is new.
- m1el 3y agoI am not scared for AI overflowing the news sites with bullshit. We already have a fire hydrant worth of bullshit content produced for consumption. Lies and fakes have coexisted with humans forever. People did rumours, then we had books, press, radio, television, and now the Internet. "But it's easier to produce lies/deepfakes today" -- true. However, the absolute cost of producing a lie per consumer already was negligible, and now it's even smaller. People will recalibrate their level of trust in technology and move on.
- thfuran 3y agoYou don't think that everyone having to "recalibrate their level of trust" in something as pervasive and fundamental to modern society as "technology" is impactful? Even just photos, videos, audio recordings, and phone calls becoming utterly untrustworthy would be pretty significant. The cost of a widely disseminated fake being low per recipient is altogether different from the cost to produce a fake specifically targeted for a single use approaching zero.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoThe cost of producing a lie was not changing very fast, but the cost of pushing it out to lots of people has already plummeted. And now with LLMs even the cost of producing lies has plummeted, too. No matter how bad you think the past was, this problem just got worse.
- fendy3002 3y agoThe "*fakes" are those what really scary. Usually day by day, normal population won't interact much farther than miles / kilometers from their work / home / travel path, the rest of info we got from digital media. Now that if we cannot trust the digital media, our ability to gather information for making decision will get worse. Let's say that nowadays I know that US has gun/ mass shooting problem from the digital news. But how when someday the media reporting that multiple countries, such as some EU countries and Canada also have mass shooting due to the change of gun laws, sooner or later we'll won't know the truth anymore. This is very dangerous because it can be used to manipulate people to accept what's bad as normal, and can argue then provide proof that's generated by AI. Hopefully we won't need to experience that issue.
- nradov 3y agoI am mentally ready for an AI-saturated post-truth world. Bring it on.
- meinheld111 3y ago10 things everybody must read to be ready for the post truth world
- ArnoVW 3y agoWhenever we have invented new mass media (books, radio, television, social media) it has taken a generation or two to manage the impacts, on a societal level. And in many cases, the intervening period was fraught with conflict and discord (religious schisms, rise of fascism, etc). The big problem is not whether you or I are ready. The problem is whether the "average joe" is ready for what's coming. No good in being ready if the rest of society is tearing itself apart and drags you into a war.
- nradov 3y agoAll periods throughout history have been fraught with conflict and discord. So what. Change comes regardless of whether anyone is ready or not. But the average Joes usually muddle through well enough.
- theprincess 3y agoControversial theory, most of the people who claim to be "ready", and seem oddly excited about the possibility of upheaval and turmoil, are already lost down some sort of algorithm induced ideological rabbit hole. Conveniently, one of the symptoms of hosting an internet mind-virus, is that you don't think internet mind-viruses are all that bad.
- willcipriano 3y agoI already live in it. Humans have been lying this entire time, computers lying as well isn't a big difference.
- 3y ago
- miohtama 3y agoAI is unrelated to post truth. We have been living the era of the fake news since 2016, when Russian trolls started to peddle with elections and President Trump created his legendary alternative facts. AI may exaggerate these issues, but not much. Anything AI can do can be done by human liars as well. If humans are not mentally ready then shit has already hit the fan and blaming/pointing the AI and its research or regulation is not constructive.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoAnd any patch of dirt that an airplane can traverse is one that you can traverse on foot.
- Ekaros 3y agoOr going back even before that. When media drove a invasion of different country on entirely lies. And no one involved has been prosecuted for crimes against humanity.
- softbt 3y agoReally don’t like the idea that we will act as interfaces for the AI, I honestly believe it will only many the majority of people lazier and dumber. I’m also incredibly shocked that no one is talking about AI as a friend/companion, that has to not be good for you in the long run. Humans need real human connection, AI is too artificial for that (duh). Having AI friends will be equivalent to consuming fast food instead of healthy home cooked meals growing up. Yes, people that grow up on fast food are still alive, but they are less happy and have more health problems (mental and physical), but it did the “job”, that job was to fuel them. In this case, AI will do its job, make people less “lonely”, but I highly doubt it’s a replacement for human companionship.
- swexbe 3y agoGood comparison. An AI companion will never talk back or tell you that you're wrong. Kind of similar in my mind to how fast food restaurants won't serve you anything that's too "hard to swallow".
- brandall10 3y agoAs shown in the movie Her, they'll just leave you for much more capable AI friends.
- rajamaka 3y agoAn AI companion most definitely could be configured to talk back or adopt any possible personality trait.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoAnd there would definitely be a market for it, just like there's a market for spicy food or BDSM. Indeed those aren't apt comparisons -- an AI that's not a sycophant might be more comparable to food with a little salt?
- digging 3y agoHell, Sydney did it by accident. (Or "accident")
- protontypes 3y agoThe rapid development of AI could lead to people generally being frightened away from digital products. In my own social environment, I see more and more people who used to be very enthusiastic about computers turning away to more analog entertainment and work. Blindly developing technology only as part of the "power play" without solving real problems is no longer justifiable. AI is starting to create significantly more problems than it has actually solved, comparable to the fossil fuel industry.
- anonylizard 3y agoThe sheer audacity to claim that 'fossil fuel industry' has "created significantly more problems than it has actually solved" If you leave the SF bubble for a split second, and think about the foundations of modern industry, you would realize fossil fuels have created tectonic value for society, that's why transitioning away is so so hard. All the 'real problems', like housing costs, medical costs, education costs, occur in the most highly regulated areas of the economy. Not technology.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoWhile I'm with you overall -- cheap transport alone has made our lives easily of times better -- there's at least one giant problem that occurs mostly due to lack of regulation, which is environmental degradation.
- hilbert42 3y ago"The sheer audacity to claim that 'fossil fuel industry' has "created significantly more problems than it has actually solved"" One of the problems of modern discourse is that an idea or meme takes hold and has a life of itself, it becomes the center of attraction without refence past history, past events, etc. I'm not a climate change denier nor do I disagree that using fossil fuels has huge environmental consequences but no rational person could deny that we owe our whole modern life to fossil fuels. The Industrial Revolution absolutely depended on coal, it has been the lifeblood of modern society for at least 300 years. It is simply unimaginable to envisage modern life without its existence. Moreover, what's lost in this debate is that coal is not just a source of energy, it is also the source of a many other useful materials. When I was learning about this decades ago we were taught that coal was the source of so many useful products that we round that number off to '1000' to signal its importance. In fact, coal provides many more than a 1000 useful products, the pharmaceutical couldn't do without it. The previous poster should contemplate the fact that even common old aspirin comes from coal—in fact many pharmaceutical texts place aspirin in a class of drugs known as the coal-tar antipyretics. Wild assertions of this type happen when we stop teaching history, how modern society came about and so on. A dose of philosophical reasoning and logic ought to be taught as well, that way reason may hold back many from uttering and spreading crap.
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoAI is simply a tool, it all depends on how we are going to use it.
- anditherobot 3y agoA very very sharp tool.
- ergonaught 3y agoEverything is simply a tool and it always depends on how the tool is used. The problems are automation and scale, low barriers to entry for "negative outcome" usage, the absence of sociocultural system developments adequate to adapt productively, total lack of forethought/planning regarding consequence in every area, and, well, humans. Falling back to the "it's just a tool" thing is no more useful than saying nuclear weapons are just a tool and it depends on how they're used. It's true but irrelevant.
- ssnistfajen 3y agoThat post-truth world had already arrived ~6-7 years ago. Social media algorithms powered by primitive iterations of weak AI was unleashed upon an unsuspecting world and the effects are...not great.
- jfengel 3y agoStephen Colbert coined the word "truthiness" nearly 20 years ago, providing a name to a trend that had been well underway years before that. "Well, anybody who knows me knows that I'm no fan of dictionaries or reference books. They're elitist. Constantly telling us what is or isn't true, or what did or didn't happen. Who's Britannica to tell me the Panama Canal was finished in 1914?" I see it as a progression from 24-hour news media to social media to a complete abandonment of "truth" in public discourse. Of course the core concept is ancient and had been in play all along, but technology has really amplified it and made it increasingly personal. AI may push it over some kind of edge into the abyss, but only because we've spent three decades willingly readying ourselves for it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imgabe 3y agoTruth has never been that important. Humans spent thousands of years thinking a giant man living on the mountain threw lightning bolts from the sky, or the spirits of their ancestors watch everything they do, or fairies and gremlins and whatnot cause mischief. They still managed.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoLies might be successful, but that doesn't mean people don't care about truth. A lot of mythology served the precise purpose of explaining something that people couldn't otherwise explain, like lightning. Once science provides a more compelling story, it can become hard to go back.
- svachalek 3y ago> Once science provides a more compelling story, it can become hard to go back. I get the feeling you haven't gone out in a while.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoOf course a lot of the stories science tells are difficult enough that most people haven't internalized them. But, for instance, nobody thinks lightning is thrown by a god anymore -- and that's without even understanding the details of meteorology. It just makes more sense to the ordinary person that stuff crashing into stuff in the atmosphere would make electricity. That is, it's a compelling story, and I don't expect us to backpedal from it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 3y agoJust shutting off from the Internet is the likely result, IMO. I'm halfway there already. I think social networks (HN is better, but not great), dating apps, hell even stuff like automatic parking apps or online shopping, are just gradually sucking the joy out of what it is to be a human. For the most part, nowadays, I pretty much just use my phone to organise analogue fun. Once places like HN become obviously just all-bot then there won't be much reason for me to even go online other than phone calls and messaging.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoI don't think you're following the global trend.
- throwaway22032 3y agoI think the point of being offline, for me, is that the global trend is not relevant. What matters to me is my community.
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoPost-truth has already been here for a long time, in fact when AI hits and we start to blame AI for post-truth it'll just be another post-truth lie.
- wccrawford 3y agoI've heard so many people say "that's not my reality" or "that's not my truth" and actually be serious that "truth" can be different for each person... I was horrified each and every time.
- digging 3y agoUsually, when I hear people say that, it's more or less "agree to disagree" when they hear someone else saying falsehoods and don't have the energy to deal with it. Or, when people have a disagreement or argument, each of them have their own "truth", that is, the story of what happened from their point of view. Personally, I've never heard anyone confuse those phrases for "objective reality is whatever I want it to be".
- nathias 3y agoWere we are ready for a "truth world" where ideology was considered an everyday necessity and people willingly paid for it in the forms of newspapers and tv? I welcome this kind of pos-truth, at best it will make people better at evaluating information on its own merit, at worse it will make them better at evaluating its origin.
- Havoc 3y agoThe comment by Yuval Noah Harari seemed insightful to me. If you argue against a bot about a political matter, not knowing it’s a bot - you always lose on a long enough timeline. ie you can never pursuade the bot but it can wear you down / eventually find an argument that works. The only winning move is not to play. So I could see this having a chilling effect on all discourse Aside from the whole skynet thing the above is what spooks me the most
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoFrom a Bayesian perspective, the only way to play and not lose is to not update your priors, at all, forever. (I suppose that "not playing" winds up much the same - you don't have any input on which to falsely update your priors.) But people who absolutely will not update their priors is not likely to work out well in the long run...
- x86x87 3y ago[flagged]
- civilized 3y agoThere are plenty of pushy humans who are prepared to talk you into submission. Check out your local Scientology or Lyndon LaRouche movement office. Would you talk interminably with a pushy human? How is the AI any different?
- mandmandam 3y agoThe differences that jump out at me are in cost, scale and accountability. It's work recruiting people to your cause. It's expensive, and takes time and attention and resources. People have consciences that might flare up, they have loose lips, they need training and guidance and oversight. Letting a bot loose for your cause costs pennies. It can be updated with a few clicks. You can reverse course or fine tune with a few sentences; you can even tailor it to the vulnerabilities of your victims with just a few data points. The brainwashing inflicted on people by advertising and the like has had a tremendous cost to society, and the planet; absolutely incalculable. It would be prudent to be alert to the danger of all that being exacerbated 100- or 1,000-fold.
- jvanderbot 3y agoEach generation will be OK with the tools they grew up with. I think of my now-deceased grandparents. They had to be closely monitored to avoid falling for mail-in scams, of all things. They were old enough that mail was a trusted source of information in their upbringing. I like to think about what will tip us over, as technologists. Venturing into sci-fi a little, I think brain-computer interfaces are going to be impossible for us to adapt to, if they ever arrive. Imagine spam thoughts. We're not trained to ignore intrusive thoughts. But I agree we might just not be able to handle a website that constantly shifts its content to keep us engaged, blurring fact and fiction into the perfect narrative to keep you clicking.
- DaiPlusPlus 3y ago> They were old enough that mail was a trusted source of information in their upbringing. Rose-tinted glasses. The scams we all know-and-love from our e-mail mailboxes today: romance-scams, advance-fee fraud, pyramid-schemes, and more, were all prevalent in the physical mail in decades past.
- 23B1 3y agoThe only way through is to teach information literacy. One of the best (but not the only) way to learn this is by studying the trivium/quadrivium – formal logic, reasoning, rhetoric. Once you see how information can be manipulated, it becomes very clear HOW MUCH of it really is. Initially it can be maddening, but eventually it becomes empowering.
- fullshark 3y agoFormal logic is a great tool for rationalization too, which is ultimately how most people seem to use it in my experience.
- a13o 3y agoUndetectable bots have been spoiling the internet since its birth. First our email, then our blog comments, then the review sites. LLMs will definitely contribute the next phase of this. Not only elevating the level of attack on those previously vulnerable areas, but also bringing social media and search engines far past their breaking point. We need decisive online human verification technology. Nothing else is going to address this. Right now everyone is adding paywalls to everything and leaning on the financial system as a proxy for human verification. However this will not solve the root cause, because some bot activity is worth the price of admission. Internet businesses are fine with this, and will look the other way just like they did when engagement was the lifeblood of the internet economy and bots provided engagement.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoWhen would we ever be ready? A post-truth world is a post-human world so it's no surprise several commenters here seem to be salivating for it. The Demon-Haunted World remains as prescient as ever. Machines that ought to have advanced knowledge will instead kneecap civilization back to a dark age, if we're lucky.
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- helen___keller 3y agoAll you need to be ready is a commitment to not waste your time reading or contributing to online discourse.
- sjkoelle 3y agoREMEMBER THE MAINE!
- fullshark 3y agoMost of the people sounding the alarm on this still seem to me people really alarmed at losing control of the flow of information / narrative.
- more_corn 3y agoWe have always needed to navigate bullshit. We have the tools, we need to formalize them in code. This is an opportunity to improve our identification of bullshit of all types, human and machine generated.
- robviren 3y agoI feel that you could replace "AI-Saturated Post-Truth World" with any number of technological changes over the last 100 years and find a similar article at that time. I am impressed by LLMs and these more powerful AI agents, but I also have confidence that over the course of time their capabilities will become utterly boring and commonplace to my growing kids. In a generation their place in society will be as unspecial as a cell phone. The grander picture of the whole system is that we are building a society utterly incompatible with being a regular human person (The way we existed 3000+ years ago). I have no answer to that other than to identify that we already built a world no one is mentally ready for.
- dcsommer 3y agoSmartphones have dramatically changed the way humans relate to each other, with incredibly profound impact on mental health and social interactions. The negative impact hasn't gone away just because part of the population hasn't seen a different world and can't imagine anything different. The same may be true of LLMs and all the hallucinated information they share. I would respect and listen to what experts in psychology have to say here by default.
- kubectl_h 3y agoAgreed. The argument of "we've always had XYZ and we've done fine" always conveniently ignores acceleration/rate-of-change as a factor -- as if the printing press, radio, tv, internet, computing, mobile revolution, AI etc are distinct events that we "got through" with no relation to each other, when in reality they are just cycles in an ever tightening feedback loop.
- latchkey 3y agoI went to CSUDH many many years ago (early 90's). I had a few interactions with Larry Rosen, mentioned in the article. I started off working in the CS labs and eventually moved onto running the systems for extended ed. He was kind of anti-tech even back then and we butted heads a bit. I was just some punk kid with a big budget to buy all the latest Apple products and having tons of fun. He was kind of an old fart who struggled to make his Windows 3.1 winsock connect to 'the internet'. "I get concerned about the fact that we just blindly believe the GPS." Him coming out with the views like this are no surprise. Fear of GPS? Come on. Wired is really digging to find some people who support their storyline.
- redeeman 3y agoyeah... this is a very old problem, one that was also there when newspapers/media began. Most things people are exposed to are lies, now it is coming into the hands of the ordinary person, instead of the elite, and now its a problem :)
- ccrush 3y agohttps://archive.ph/XPkHV https://archive.ph/XPkHV
- oslac 3y agoThis isn't a new phenomena, and does not differ at all from a normal non-tech person getting their information from Google Search. Hidden motivations for this push left as an exercise for the astute reader.
- notShabu 3y agoAlgorithms wove our pseudo-realities into super plazas of connectedness and mimetic conflict, AI however can create raw strands of pseudo-reality, a previously human-specific ability. The arms race shifts from "i'm more human than you!" to "i'm human, really!"
- KaiserPro 3y agoSo the problem I have with this sentiment is that the entire point of news organisations is to trace the validity of claims. The press have evolved a bunch of mechanisms to prove or disprove points in a story. AI doesn't really change this. Sure there are fakes, and yes you can create thousands of bullshit websites/text. But that was always true. Yes GenAi images are more concerning. But we've had photoshop for a long time, and some very talented people. Yes its slightly harder to spot a genai image, but with the correct tooling, its pretty trivial. The issue is, we have a crisis of funding for good quality news sources. News is a freeby now. Which means that the news you get is now either much more partisan (because "they" whomever you find creepy/shadowy/disagreeable, who are smear all over the political spectrum) or simply doesn't have the time to do basic research (see standard tech journalism, breathlessly re-formulating press releases. See Apple Vision Pro) So AI "propoganda" is a side show, the much bigger risk is a further dropping of standards amongst the assembled ranks of the press.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- adql 3y agoAs if journalists before did a good job on delivering "the truth"... It's just complaining that big media no longer have monopoly on generating wave of bullshit
- goodbyesf 3y ago'Oxford Dictionaries popularly defined it as "relating to and denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief."' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-truth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-truth Since when did objective facts drive or shape public opinion? When did humans ever live in a "truth world"? Take the title and the content of the article itself. Does it aim to arrive at an objective truth or to play on our emotions? When's the last time you consumed media and thought it tried to instill some truth rather than it tried to make me feel someway? We've always lived in a 'post-truth world' because people are moved by emotions rather than truth. Humans weren't mentally ready for the printing press, newspaper, radio, tv, etc saturated post-world either. But here we are. Go read about the history of printing press, newspaper, radio, tv, etc. The same story. Politicians, priests, journalists, academics, etc claimed these new media technologies were a threat to truth. Feelings and emotions rule mankind, not reason and logic. All AI does is make it a more efficient post-truth world.
- gadders 3y agoI don't think political or cultural issues are particularly amenable to objective truth anyway. You can't run randomised control trials for most of the main political or cultural points of contention.
- moojd 3y agoYeah they are tangental concepts. Truth is only useful politically to inform decision making. Political frameworks and decisions are fundamentally subjective and would still vary wildly even if we could all agree on fundamental truths. It's the main reason I'm skeptical of technocracy.
- LogoEthoPatho 3y agoOn that topic, few things bother me more than the phrase "trust the science." I understand the intention, but we should be encouraging skepticism and engagement with the underlying tools and methodology. People will scoff at this but you can find a ton of different "Flat Earthers" either accidentally proving the earth is curved using their own experiments (Eg. Bob Knodel), or even dying trying to prove them (Eg. "Mad" Mike Hughes). Science is not some "pure" pursuit of truth, with no care for politics, economics, social influence, or biases. Technocrats genuinely scare me, as they often combine these two things, by claiming authority via "trust the science" type nonsense, while holding delusions of scientific purity.
- jscipione 3y agoAs if we don’t live in a sea of lies already, they are called advertisements. We are ready, but are you ready for what happens when the information police no longer has control? The anger is growing already as the truth is revealed, and there is no putting this genie back in its bottle. The Internet has given us the truth and the truth has set us free.
- Haugsevje 3y ago[flagged]
- LatteLazy 3y agoPeople don't get "ready" for new things. New things happen, and it takes a generation for people from before that tech to die out. That's what's happening with social media. Boomers cannot learn to live with it, we just have to wait another 30ish years. The same will happen with AI.
- luxuryballs 3y agoI don’t like how they are using AI as an excuse to argue for increased censorship, what difference does it make what type of software the computer is giving information from? This is a potentially sneaky way of getting around freedom of speech, by somehow arguing that if an idea is recycled by a language model it is suddenly OK to censor it, as long as you’re a few degrees of separation from the original blog. What the heck else is post-truth supposed to mean??
- timcavel 3y ago[dead]
- UncleOxidant 3y ago> What the heck else is post-truth supposed to mean?? An environment where it's become difficult to tell what is true and what isn't. You could also phrase it as, what's real and what isn't. An epistemic crisis. I think we crossed into a post-truth world 7 or 8 years ago (it's been in process for at least a couple of decades) so it's not like AI precipitated this crisis, but it will accelerate it to new levels.
- null0pointer 3y agoRight, we already live in a post-truth world where it's politicians and journalists who omit or twist facts to support their agenda. It's not just politicians and journalists who do this, but they tend to have the most reach and influence on average.
- a_wild_dandan 3y agoBy that definition, we've always been in a post-truth world. Yes, access to truth lies on a spectrum. Post-truth references pop up in this moment particularly due to the quantum leap in dis/misinformation. Any layperson, anywhere, can soon convincingly fabricate media of nearly any form: images, video, audio, legit-looking websites, etc. To me, it's justifiable to regard 2023 as an inflection point for truth. My predictions are less catastrophic than many worried folk, but I definitely see why the post-truth moniker is appropriate. Crazy times!
- masswerk 3y agoA somewhat concerning observation: there seems to be an inverse law of probability for a hallucinated answer for a (very) small number of authoritative sources. E.g., if there's something stated in a manufacturer's manual (which has been digitized and is in the corpus), but not quoted anywhere else, the probability of getting hallucinated but convincingly worded "facts" instead is very high. On the other end of the spectrum, where we enter the realm of big numbers and content quoted from quotations, the probability of this yielding a yet popular but not necessarily true answer is also high. There seems to be a clear trajectory: replacing authoritative information by hallucinations and amplifying this to popular doxa, especially, since generated content is much more effective in traversing the contested middle-ground. Also, enter the new discipline of truth engineering optimization (TEO).
- lannisterstark 3y agoAh yes. Only the govt and large companies should have a defacto "monopoly" on "truth" and propaganda, is it?
- burgerzzz 3y agoAre we really currently living in a world saturated with truth?
- guywithahat 3y agoBold of them to assume the truth is currently regarded as sacred. You can go on the front page of r/all any time of day and find news stories that are completely fabricated or graphs using made up data. I don't think AI could realistically make it any worse
- baja_blast 3y agoAI may not make the content much worse, but the engagement artificial. AI bots to astroturf comment sections and twitter to manufacture consent and sentiment to whoever pays for it. I mean we already have that now, but it will be much harder to detect.
- whiddershins 3y agoWe are already in that world.
- pphysch 3y agoEdward Bernays Propaganda (1928) Orson Welles War of the Worlds broadcast (1938) ...etc. Nothing new under the sun. People will get a bit more savvy but also continue to be brainwashed en masse, same as it ever was.
- randomdata 3y agoWe've been living in an I-saturated 'post-truth world' since at least the time the coffeeshop was invented, and likely since the dawn of time. We'll be fine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- taylodl 3y agoHumans weren't and still aren't mentally ready for a 'post-steam engine world', but here we are. BTW, I've used both ChatGPT and Bard enough to know there's a lot they don't know, but boy are they confident in their wrong answers! Reminds me of some people I know!
- mimd 3y ago"Post-truth"? What a bloody insult to all the effort it currently takes to fight past all their "truth" to find truth. Makes me start to think it's a less than sincere. At least due to their new signaling marketing slogan to fans, I can now easily identify their lean and possible motive. Tricks ya know, to deal with "truth". Complaining about google maps and navigation, is a really bad example to say over reliance on technology. What should we be navigating by stars? And most of their quotes aren't even really related to the complexities/strategies to identifying)/reexamining "truth" and dealing with all the unsavory if necessary actors. Larry Rosen is just trying to sell his pop novels to the masses. Michael Graziano's expertise is in cortex and motion, so I don't know what expertise he brings to the table though I suppose it's sincere. Michal Kosinski is at least sorta in the area, but also doesn't support their hypothesis beyond that it's going to have a major effect going forward. Really, I shouldn't have given them a click.
- sircastor 3y agoHumans are never "ready" for the next crazy technological advance. I'm fond of this concept that I heard a while back, that I'm probably going to butcher: If a technology comes out before you were born, or while you're very young, it's always existed. If it comes out when you're in your 20s, it's new and exciting. If it comes out after you're 35, it's scary and is a harbinger of ensuing disaster. We always manage to figure it out. It's a cat & mouse game, and the next generation will probably manage it. I don't mean to be casual about this, but does anyone think of how miraculous it is that in the past 80 years we haven't had a nuclear war?
- k1t 3y agoPretty close: "I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things." - Douglas Adams
- cheekibreeki2 3y agoIt seems to me that we have been living in this world for some time now. Ai explains the sheer amount of political astroturfing we have experienced in recent years, it's just that the cat is out of the box now and there's noone to be held accountable.
- robotburrito 3y agoIt may cause many to just unplug from it all. Assume everything is fake, give up on "truth" and live their own local lives without being plugged into the news cycle 24/7. Maybe it sets us free.
- orasis 3y agoThe best source of truth is found in the here and now, grounded in the body and one’s immediate environment. We socialize with each other to regulate each other - ideally taking that grounded truth and intermingling it with the grounded truth of others. This has always been the healthy way.
- glonq 3y agoTo be fair, humans weren't even ready for the pre-AI post-truth world. But yeah, AI will most likely make things much worse.
- magwa101 3y ago[dead]
- jacobwilliamroy 3y agoAI related question: Why do people think consciousness exists? What is the strongest evidence for consciousness?
- pookha 3y agoWhen I think of "post-truth" I'm thinking of systems that people mistakenly lock themselves into where they're fed simplistic and surface level facts that have to align with the systems goals. classic example being an activist for a political system (1960's Maoist or whatever)... Why can't I use AI to analyze the immense amounts of content I'm being faced with so as to gauge bias and innuendo? Maybe ML could help me parse this article to understand what milieu this author belongs to and what his biases might be?
- stjohnswarts 3y agoI've been goofing off on twitter during down time between contracts and it's truly amazing if you go to a political "discussion" how many blue check "verified" accounts that are AI. I'm sure it's not just regular bots because they've responded to some of my troll remarks to them with a decent level of acuity and context. Going to their feed it's dead obvious that they are AI bots though, because their only reason for existence on there is pure mayhem and misinformation. I don't think Musk was talking about getting rid of bots, he was just talking about getting rid of non-paying bots
- scotty79 3y agoWhen were humans ready for anything?
- meroes 3y agoPeople are just asking to be ruled. Cool talk to your companion AI while actual psychopaths achieve power in the real world. Humans are apparently ready for it. There is so much enthusiasm, and HN is ahead of the curve. This article is 100% wrong. The coming world is not post truth, and people are ready for what’s coming. They want enjoyment rather than freedom. Be my guest.
- zeruch 3y agoThey aren't even ready for a truth world. We're optimized for self-delusion on a good day. The future is going to be a baklava of fast-cut CGI-grade hallucinatory blandishments and threats at scale.
- legendofbrando 3y agoCounter point: sure they are. Humans are highly adaptable and like other changes to information availability in the past they will adapt. This is what societal norms and cultural memes are for. “Don’t believe everything you hear” “Don’t believe what you see on TV” “if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” These are all ways that the human species uses memes and cultural norms to teach ourselves how not to fall victim to false information. Of course some people are going to fall victim. They do so today through common scams. It is the right goal to bring this down to zero. But to say that the human species isn’t capable belies all prior history and shows little faith in the resilience that made us who we are. That’s the broad problem with this AI doom and gloom: it has so little knowledge of and respect for the humanities and humankind that it arrogantly assumes that our species has never faced challenges like this before. It throws up its hands instead of asking what lessons from history we should take and what actions we should be focused on. If I'm being generous, I think that these pieces attempt to stir panic as a means for spurring action for change and investment in these problems. That’s a meaningful goal, but one that also might be more meaningfully achieved if it wasn’t expressing the problem with such gloom.
- systems_glitch 3y agoIt is estimated that between 50% and 70% of folks have no inner monologue.
- interstice 3y agoHow is that an issue?
- mrtranscendence 3y agoThat seems insane to me. I'm always chattering away up there, I can't imagine it otherwise.
- jackjeff 3y agoWow. I had no idea that was a thing. I thought that’s just something they do in movies. But I don’t have a mind’s eye either (aphantasia). So I guess that’s on brand for me. That doesn’t mean I can’t “talk to myself” in a way or think about stuff. I just have no auditory sensation whatsoever. It’s just abstract/immaterial reasoning. I’d wager if I did an FMRI the audio part would not light up but the speech part would.
- gcanyon 3y agoA rough timeline of my list of "what will end humanity" candidates: 1990 -- nanotechnology 2005 -- rogue AI 2015 -- bio-weapons 2022 -- fake news/truth-indeterminability
- pastafarianism 3y agothe article is saying we're not ready for an ai information world, not that it will end humanity. also, all the candidates you've listed are valid we're just not there yet. some things change gradually until they change suddenly.
- gcanyon 3y agoThe years were when I concluded it was possible they would eventually end humanity, not the year I thought it would happen. And regarding fake news/lack of truth determinability -- I'm not summarizing the article, I'm offering my own opinion. In the worst case, we could lose modern humanity if we reach a point where no one can determine the truth.
- jeffreyrogers 3y agoHumans spent thousands of years in a pre-truth world believing all sorts of crazy things, and many of those societies produced great things and had people living normal lives. It's only been the last 100 years or so that people's perception of reality has been anywhere close to accurate. And even then, most people believe plenty of things that are false. So basically people and civilization are going to muddle along as they always have. Deepfakes, etc. will make some things worse, they'll probable have some unrecognized upsides too. John Boyd used to say "People, ideas, machines. In that order." It was true about jets and its still true about modern technology.
- mrtranscendence 3y agoThere may be upsides to the ability to fake video and audio of someone (better CGI effects in films, for example). But in my experience when people refer to a deepfake they seem to mean that the fake has been distributed to confuse or deceive, for which I can't really see any probable upsides. > So basically people and civilization are going to muddle along as they always have. I agree with this, but consider the drawbacks to rampant disinformation and the proliferation of deepfakes (all this is IMO): it will make any video or audio deniable and unusable as evidence. Real images will be denounced as fakes. Fake images will catch on and possibly cause real damage. People will rapidly lose trust in most sources of news, entrenching established known quantities. I feel like if we could reasonably put a stop to this we should. I don't think we can in general, though.
- TheMode 3y agoThe stakes are different. Back in the day they lived more independent life, these crazy things they believed in didn't really matter as only the people from your close geographic area would be affected. Giving conflicting informations to people all around the world expected to interact with each other is a bigger issue.
- Havoc 3y ago>Humans spent thousands of years in a pre-truth world believing all sorts of crazy things, and many of those societies produced great things and had people living normal lives. Also burned a couple of people as witches in the process...
- seydor 3y agoHow do we know that this article wasn't written by an evil AI that wants to stop us from developing a counter-AI
- w_for_wumbo 3y agoI'd argue we've been living already in a post-truth world. It's bizarre to think that you can know the truth on the internet. Because by the very mechanism of language and concepts, you're always abstracted away from truth. Not to mention layers of bias, management, interpretation and re-interpretation. Truth is experience, everything else is a belief. There was an idea that we were unified before the internet, but what that meant was that most people were receiving the same propaganda. The information channels were fractured by the internet, meaning that control across it was impossible. I'm not saying this comment is even truth, it's another opinion biased by my own world-view, beliefs etc. But trying to find truth on the internet is like trying to find a tasty book.
- slowhadoken 3y agoBecause it’s not A.I., that’s how you know they’re not ready for it.
- chrisbrandow 3y agoready or not, it's gonna be exhausting for a while.
- GuB-42 3y agoI hate the term "post-truth". As if lying, rumors and disinformation didn't exist before that. I can't count the amount of bullshit I heard on the news before social media was a thing, and fact checking was much harder. There is no "truth world", just an arms race between truth and fakes. AI tools can generate fakes but also detect them. Social media can be used to spread rumors but also cover an event like never before.
- joebiden2 3y agoI'm soooo tired of bullshit like this. Fear of your job, fake news, yadda yadda, I get it. It is just boring. Almost as if written by an AI. The whole post-truth, fake-news agenda is foreign to me even without AI, I don't know anyone save a few "flat-earth" like freaks who would fall for the classical disinformation trope. No, nothing substantial follows. This was just a rant :) PS: I feel the talk about disinformation, fake-news etc. is doing more of the stated purpose of fake-news and disinformation as disinformation and fake-news itself. I'll try to substantiate that claim in the near future, I promise.
- parineum 3y agoThese articles almost always have a "except for me and my friends" implication. The author always implicitly sees themselves as above all the vulnerable people and they must paternally protect them by restricting their access to the dangerous technology. "We're not ready" isn't a relevant statement because it's here/coming no matter what you do. If you want to say, "here's how we get ready", I'm all ears.
- pelasaco 3y agoProblems that doesnt exist for people living mostly disconnected. Go surf, have a family, friends, do jiu-jitsu, read books and restrict your interaction with AI just for the hours that you have to work. The life is too simple and too short to loose time with such issues.
- pxc 3y agoWe've never been ready! The 'mid-truth' media was already so full of propaganda and misinformation and inaccuracies that there was no hope of sorting through it all reliably. People have been experiencing and complaining about information overload since the invention of the printing press, and then the telegram, and on and on.
- nologic01 3y agoThe online world is getting increasingly dystopic while the offline world is being deprecated at rapid pace. The article is part of that dystopia, the collapsing trust, the lack of honest, down to earth discussion of what is going on. There is no AI, there are algorithms and data and people angling for advantage to both privileged collection of data and unencumbred application of algos to affect people's lives. In sense there is nothing much new just an intensification that has been carefully choreographed into a mass hysteria.
- justbored123 3y ago[dead]
- prng2021 3y agoI’m skeptical about these fears. We already have a disinformation problem. If AI can be used to exacerbate the problem, why can’t that be counterbalanced by using AI to fight against disinformation as well? Just like any other sector, there will be a small handful of leaders in AI and that’s what most users will interact with. Couldn’t Bing/Google modify their models to underweight the content from websites regularly flagged to have disinformation and vice versa?
- syngrog66 3y agoHumans are already great at generating propaganda and lies, in written and spoken speech form. at scale. coordinated. and almost all of it "goes into the can" and becomes static propaganda artifacts which can and are redelivered and re-consumed over and over again, by the target audiences, and at near zero hosting cost. no AI/LLMs needed (Disclaimer/credentials: I've worked for the US State Department on a closely related & overlapping problem in this space.) I do feel that the increasing realism of trained NN-generated photos and video, intended to smear an opposing political candidate, is the biggest "new" threat. I had expected it to be deployed by Trump/GOP/Putin against Biden/Dems in the 2020 election, as an "October surprise." Shocked it was not, not really (IIRC). I do expect they'll deploy it in the 2024 race. Especially in the closing weeks/days (Oct surprise), in order to gain biggest (however small it all adds up) sentiment shift with smallest possible time window for fact-finding efforts to debunk it. As villains they'd be almost comically incompetent if they did not try anyway.
- cqzfalle 3y agoThe Internet afaik is a breakthrough in technology that is potentially powerful enough to break new grounds Instead, people use it as a ignorance amplifier. Now AI can be used to benefit humanity, but I can only trust humanity to use it to pollute the internet with ego and selfish manipulation. Is human nature seriously that wretched?
- plaguepilled 3y agoI would argue humanity can plenty handle truth-ambivalent sources (what is state sponsored media after all?). However, AI sucks on an aesthetic level, and its a real shame that we now have to just put up with it.
- promotedpawn 3y ago[flagged]
- AussieWog93 3y agoI'm just hoping that the bots fuck everything up hard enough that we all go outside again.
- hcfman 3y agoBig surprise. We are already living in a post truth worth. Another surprising fact, people make stuff up as well.
- bimguy 3y agoI think we have already been living in a post-truth world ever since laws started to erode any journalistic accountability for news and media corporations. At least it's like that in Australia, just watch any recent friendlyjordies (yt) investigation to understand how the laws protect even the most incredibly bias and un-factual news stories. Sure, more people might be tricked with the prevalence of AI but those people usually can't read between the lines anyway.
- Borrible 3y agoMost humans aren't mentally ready to face truth and prefer else.