10 ms·
Brian Chesky: Ability to hire from anywhere is more valuable than in-office work
- throwaway22032 4y agoI figure there must just be a personality difference that explains this stuff. I can't fathom it. I do better in the office not at home, I do better in the gym not in my home gym, I do better cycling if I'm with others, I push harder doing basically anything if I'm competing, if I'm in a team, if someone is watching. Particularly if they're attractive, respectable, etc. There's an effect from the setting. My home gym just isn't the same as a proper place with music blazing and guys/girls supporting each other. And the physical - the travel and the location - reinforce in my mind that this is serious time. Every now and then I like to do stuff alone sure. But too much of it and it feels like playing with toys on your own. Family don't understand the work you do in the same way. To me it's about as obvious as the sun rising. But not everyone feels this way, it seems.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoYeah, I feel the polar opposite for each of those. I'm guessing you're an early riser, too?
- namtab00 4y agoFunny, I thought I was the only one anecdotically correlating early birds with opposing full remote employment.
- throwaway22032 4y agoNope, I bloody hate both waking up and going to sleep. Amusingly as with the rest of it, having a friend or partner to match schedules with helps a lot.
- gaza3g 4y agoIt depends on the commuting time though. I used to live 15 mins away from my office and I feel the same way as you. But now, having to commute an hour each way is detrimental to me so working from home is far better.
- throwaway22032 4y agoFair enough. For me, if I spend too much time at home, I rapidly lose interest in everything. I've had 1.5 hour commutes and they sucked. Far less than WFH does for me, or worse, going into the office to then see people doing Zoom calls from their bedrooms. Literally even just seeing that makes me feel down.
- lamontcg 4y agoI think most of these arguments are going to become moot when we really hit the recession and all these CEOs start wanting to slash their rents.
- lgsilver 4y agoHe went on to say in a slightly devious tone, “I have no ulterior motives here and in no way benefit from this statement or its implications.”
- jcn 4y agoA topic that rarely comes up when talking about remote work is where workers are in their career. I can’t imagine being at the start of my career and having to figure out, via Slack, who my mentors are going to be. Or how to get ad hoc advice from someone more senior without feeling like I was “bothering” them. I’ve been remote for the majority of my career now, but definitely got a lot out of in-person interactions when I was younger.
- dmode 4y agoI really don't think he is saying that. There is not quote for him saying anything like this. I think he positioning the trade-off.
- Gaston07 4y ago[dead]
- mdip 4y agoAssuming it's possible for a given function/role/company's product, which is quite common in world of software development, I find the whole trend of moving people back into the office at least a little perplexing and, frankly, short-sighted much of the time. In 2001, I began switching my schedule to full-time remote[0]. I was working for a bankrupt telecom doing about three times the work a person could reasonably be asked to do (while what was being asked for was equally unreasonable given my salary). I had a great boss who -- while recognizing he couldn't do much about my salary -- was willing to do everything else and being at a bankrupt company, there was little in the way of "Corporate Handbook" policy that could get in the way any longer[1]. Over 17 years, about half or more of the company began working from home regularly, many full-time. This happened shortly after we deployed OCS 2008 R2 (what is now "MS Teams") which we did partly because "Cisco license renewal is expensive" and partly because most teams had members in more than one state -- in IT, we had members is several countries. We had these wonderful meeting rooms in every office, and people would take every meeting from their cubicles because "there's only 2 people from my 10-person team here, anyway". If we had a role that could be done from anywhere, we'd routinely hire from a far-flung office. Literally no staff was available to research "what we should pay for this person if they live in Nowhere, Wisconsin." We don't even trust what what we pay current staff in the area because we just assume we underpay all existing staff. And the ones that set those rates often live in expensive places. So we'd make an offer at 30% above the going rate, get these amazing hires that -- maybe they really want to do the work, but they really want to do it if they can drive in to the office in the new car they can now afford. Meanwhile, they're among the lowest paid for the role, so HR thinks we got a deal! Having "distributed teams", necessarily, adds friction to collaboration. Learning to address/be proactive with that friction is something that can bring it back to "the right level of collaboration." I love this assumption that "well, for certain highly collaborative roles", being face-to-face is necessary. Later you'll find that one of these roles involves software developers ... probably deploying to servers they don't have physical access to. I am deeply skeptical of this. What I suspect is happening is that there are a small number of people on the team who are highly-collaborative, a lot who benefit from it, but for whom "a little less talk and a little more heads-down writing code" would be helpful. I've been on highly-collaborative projects, totally remotely -- I literally sat on camera all day/into the evening a few nights in a row on one occasion (with five other people) -- it was equivalent to "coding in a conference room re-labeled 'WAR ROOM'" and taking sleep-breaks under your desk in the early 00s -- except I could cover the camera/nap in my own bed. The list of "difficulties with remote teams" is filled with "reasons" that all have countless examples of "companies that are remote but aren't struggling with that problem." It sounds like a lot of it comes down to combinations of "organizational inertia" -- unwillingness to find/utilize tools which help reduce the friction of being fully remote[4]. Invest in researching the myriad of pros/cons -- the quality-of-life on the employee side means attracting a lot of talent that is missing their COVID-temporary remote status. Being able to hire outside of the difficult urban marketplaces, alone, should be enough of a savings -- even if you stayed "in-state" -- to make it worth the costs of providing high-end laptops/improving VPN gateways/subscribing to a few SaaS tools/cost of more frequent team-building and intentional team "remote shoot-the-sh_t" meetings. Prior to COVID, I worked at a place that was a "no offices/no phones on desks" kind of "in-person" (ironically listing "remote friendly" on their job posting). There were a small number of remote employees, but they were due to extreme circumstances (and the fact that the owners were, honestly, great people), and they were relatively impossible to collaborate with if you were in the office, so they were "on project X or Y" always. We had offices in Seattle, Germany, NY, and India and most of us never talked to any of them. Their projects were almost all geographically near their office. We wrote software! (and, a lot of it, more than once for more than one person, without realizing it). Somehow fates collided and we'd deployed Teams a month before COVID shut-down -- replacing Slack. Two weeks into COVID, all of us remote, and a few things happened. Work, basically, continued about as fervently as it did before. Development started having "informal" weekly meetings and we discovered all of the developers at other offices! Over two months, most projects consisted of teams across time zones (shock of all shocks -- "need" matches up more evenly with "developer availability" when the latter is widely spread out -- we had 4 people knowledgeable in Voice in Seattle doing one small project while we had 4 waiting for "the one voice guy" at our office). It would be impossible for that company to justify to me, today, why I'd have to return to the office. By the time I left, we were doing more business, completing more work, and filling long-open positions more easily. As far as I know, they left the extremely expensive, but incredible office (that attracted me to accept returning to a daily commute in 2016). The company went from "minimally remote" to the point of not even integrating between offices well to "fully remote because the government said so" ... we had an "all employee" call, HR made some rapid adjustments and a lot of good choices and business improved. As an employee, we all just went to IM/Teams and adjusted ... it just meant having more time due to the loss of the commute. Sure, it won't work for every kind of work to be done, but companies who's product is software that is deployed on hardware they no longer maintain -- the vast majority of roles, if not all of them, can be done remotely as effectively as in-person. We all watched it happen in real-time for a year -- some struggled ... we sure didn't -- among my friends, I can't think of one developer/IT/other who's company has requested them back into the office (either flex or full time). Among them, "getting new-hires up to speed" is the biggest stress point, but "it's been a couple of years, now" ... most have figured that out[5]. [0] By 2005, I still had a cubicle, but I came in, at most once a month. [1] By the time I left, I hadn't seen my desk in over a year. At the time, working remotely at my company "officially" required written approval from a C-Level executive, keeping a daily work journal sent to HR and a number of other "we really don't trust you/want you to do this but there will be that one reason some day..." [2] It didn't rank nearly as high with attracting customers -- it was the thing you didn't know you needed until you had it and we didn't know how to market it, apparently. [3] I can't remember the history, but I know the application was designed there -- I think we acquired the company that developed it, originally, and integrated it into everything, but the original reason for hiring in WI was "that's where the team was". Over years, much of that staff was working on projects that had no presence in WI. [4] Actually, it sounds more like companies are interested in tools that allow them to spy on remote workers. My attitude is "these are problems shared by every distributed team, whether those people are in an office or not" so if you wouldn't install that on a desktop in the office, it doesn't go on my work laptop in my home. [5] Usually the "brute force" method is used: get a few people to the same place/derelict office for a two-week boot camp "here's the code, here's how things work, here's the obnoxious process, the time tracking tool, the 5 things we do once a year and can't remember how (and how to get to the page where they're all documented), and what's expected in what meetings" Fully remote doesn't mean you forbid face-to-face; I'd argue it's always optional -- I've done these things fully remote and seen it done well.
- venkat223 4y agoData leakage and transaction details even KYC details will land in potential trouble in sensitive areas.Don't be naive
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- nubinetwork 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35898372 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35898372
- FeistySkink 4y agoYet, most IT work is on-site. At least in EU.
- sofixa 4y agoThe EU is quite vast, and this is untrue at least for France, Netherlands, Bulgaria and from what I can tell Spain and Italy. Even very old school companies (think flag airlines and banks) have at least hybrid with more time remote than not.
- voytec 4y agoNot my experience in over a decade but I'm looking strictly for remote and don't bother with hybrid/onsite.
- FeistySkink 4y agoMind sharing how you approach this?
- prmoustache 4y agoJust responding only to open positions mentionning remote work or stating that you want remote only to the thousands of head hunters in linkedin is enough.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoWhat if no headhunters in your area have jobs that offer remote work?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 4y agoWhat does "in your area" really mean when looking for remote work? Are you referring to speciality or geographic area? For some specialities, if the specialty doesn't have remote work (say it's robotics or biotech or something else with a heavy lab component), you might be out of luck. If it's geographic, well, find headhunters in another geography.
- gonzo41 4y agoI'm surprised Airbnb has't cracked another rental market for the corporate world by renting out spare desks in existing offices for rando workers.
- lordnacho 4y agoWhat about just "come an work in my home office"? Seems like a similar thing. I'd totally do that now and again if it were available in my area.
- barefeg 4y agoThat’s an interesting combination of WeWork and Airbnb. It makes sense; people go to WeWork to not be alone, and remote work forces people to use their spare rooms to create home offices. So now they can’t rent out the spare room in Airbnb but they could rent a shared desk for work.
- quickthrower2 4y agoYou could rent 9-6 office and 8-8 sleeping room to different people. Worker and sightseer for example
- benjaminwootton 4y agoI wish someone would do this. A single permanent desk in a WeWork is surprisingly expensive.
- skeeter2020 4y agoWhy do you think it would be cheaper for any organization to do this on the side, vs. a dedicated specialist like WeWork? The unit economics with fully loaded costs are not very good, and for a company with a little extra capacity it's a huge distraction. They couldn't run it like the residential side where hosts shift huge costs onto thir surrounding ecosystem, or just take big risks with no mitigation.
- 4y ago
- goodenoughx 4y agoMore remote work helps the planet too you know since it reduces ones carbon footprint and more time for people to sleep improves mental health too
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoUnfortunately, it does not seem to. Others have mentioned how heating and cooling a private residence is more energy intensive per person, but even vehicle miles traveled aren’t reduced. It turns out people just drive to more places that aren’t work and move to more auto dependent communities where they overall drive more. During the beginning of COVID, there was a big drop in carbon as more worked from home but it was mostly because people weren’t going anywhere.
- Lacerda69 4y agoWhile I agree I dont think tech execs give a damn about carbon footprint or your mental health.
- benjaminwootton 4y agoA lot of employees not wanting to return to the office have suddenly become more environmentally aware too!
- basisword 4y ago>> it reduces ones carbon footprint Is this proven (it probably can't be proven given the huge variety of commutes, office spaces, heating sources etc.)? It would be my default assumption but I feel like heating one office with 100 people in it is much more efficient than heating 100 homes in winter. And if people are in a location where publish transport is the norm then it might be better in terms of carbon impact to be in office.
- shakow 4y agoBut people will be heating their home in winter in any case, whether they're remote or on-site.
- calciphus 4y agoMore useful == cheaper. Centralize your profits to a major metropolitan area (where your executives and maybe board live) then use global labor markets to suppress the wages of your employees.
- icelancer 4y ago[flagged]
- alanfranz 4y agoDefine “suppress the wages”. If I live in a lower COL area, I get a significantly higher wage than expected in my area, my employer saves money, and I get full remote work that I like, I call that a “win-win”.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI think the previous poster meant hiring people from countries with lower cost of living.
- welshwelsh 4y agoIndeed, but people in countries with lower cost of living are still workers, right? It irritates me when people say things like "suppress worker wages" when they actually mean "pay less money to American workers living in San Francisco" The people being hired in Bangladesh are not having their wages suppressed. On the contrary, they are making more and enjoying a higher quality of life than ever before.
- alanfranz 4y agoMy reasoning holds.
- eeasss 4y agoLet's not forget that the Airbnb CEO has vested interest in expansion of remote work. This means more digital nomads and folks who travel to work from anywhere, which benefits the Airbnb Network.
- propogandist 4y agoprecisely, every single one of these reports is PR to pump Airbnb > Long-term stays, or stays for 28 nights or longer, were 18% of total gross nights booked, a decline from the previous quarter, when they accounted for 21% of total nights booked. via airbnb's latest earnings report from last week https://www.marketwatch.com/story/airbnb-stock-falls-sharply-on-cautious-forecast-and-as-record-nights-booked-misses-estimates-2605f1ca https://www.marketwatch.com/story/airbnb-stock-falls-sharply...
- southwesterly 4y agoI’d be too busy tidying the house to avoid cleaning fees to do any nomadic work.
- dymk 4y agoThat’s not how cleaning fees work
- skeeter2020 4y agothat's right you pay this regardless, it's the quasi-discretionary things like not doing the laundry or turning on the dishwasher that get dinged for extra, just like a hotel.
- slurpmaker 4y agoAt least they put their money where their mouth is. I for one have seen a lot of the productivity hits dissipate with the advent of remote work. It's at the expense of basic human psychology though. You really can't hire jerks, management cannot be "game players", and meetings need to be minimal and ad hoc. Remote work companies avoiding those 3 things eat in person companies lunch every day of the week as far as hours in and product out.
- lordnacho 4y agoIt's a balance, isn't it? - People who work from home have more time, maybe an entire 10 hours a week for some people, measured from when you are able to start work. In high autonomy roles, you feel some ownership over your work and you are happy to share some of that 10 hours with work. - If you are set up to work from home, you can finish off bits and pieces when you find the time. So you're also happy to share some of the other hours with work, eg if something breaks. - With high autonomy, you can also decide to "share" some of the official work hours. What's the big deal if I have my shower after dropping off the kids? Most people wouldn't take the piss but I guess some people do. These are the ones the bosses are scared of having on their team. - Bosses are also aware if their job is low-autonomy, low ownership. It's hard to get someone to just do whatever is needed in these roles, so the boss feels he needs to be able to oversee everyone in the office. Of course there are ways to skive off while sitting in the office too, but the budget is already planned according to that kind of loss. This new kind of loss from someone skiving off completely at home is not something he wants to embarrass him. - There's a distinction between jobs where the output is linearly related to the input and those where it isn't. If you're stacking shelves, being there another hour gets another hour's worth of shelves stacked. If you're writing a complicated program, hanging around an extra hour might do nothing at all to shorten the time to finish it. At the same time a good hour spent coding could reduce the remaining time by 10 hours, weirdly. If you have a linear-output job, your boss wants you on your butt working constantly. If you have a fluctuating output job, he wants you to work just the productive hours. To the point about having more choice vs having everyone in one place: - Once you specify a few skills, it becomes quite rare to find a person with the skills who is open to being hired. How many people in London can do you your average Django stack, with a bit of SQL + React, are currently free, have seen your advert, will pass your silly test, and want to work for you rather than your competitor? Even a pretty broad spec like that does not actually give you a huge number of people. Let people work from home and you gather up several times the number. - Having everyone in one place is more important for socializing than for working. It's actually easy to discuss technical things online. There's a bunch of tools for it, like GitHub, Slack, Zoom, and so on. It's not hard to get across a technical point. "Code doesn't work in this case, let's debug..." - What's harder is getting a rapport with people on an emotional level. Something about being able to see the whole person's body language, being able to eat a meal with them, talk to them about non-work stuff, makes you feel more connected. But think about it, you are not doing this most of the time in the office. You might do drinks once a week, or you might have the occasional teambuilding. You might as well rent a smaller office and fly people in to do your paintballing or whatever.
- ElFitz 4y agoPerhaps he should put his money where his mouth is: https://careers.airbnb.com/positions/ https://careers.airbnb.com/positions/ Because "US, except these states" isn’t exactly hiring "from anywhere".
- yarg 4y agoTime zones and expected levels of education are still significant factors. You generally don't want to be hiring people from regions with a substandard education system - and if they're in another time zone they can spend all night ruining your day before you even start work.
- mkl 4y agoIt's the employee's education (& skill, experience, etc.) that matters, not the region's.
- yarg 4y agoIt's also communication. You can communicate across distance, you cannot communicate across time. > It's the employee's education (& skill, experience, etc.) that matters, not the region's. The quality of educational systems is regionally defined, yes the other aspects are individual, and there's variation in what each individual can get out of the given educational context - but to claim that there's no degree of consistency in the calibre of candidates that come from given regions is ridiculous. There're always exceptions to generalisations - but you seldom want to pick up a single regional employee (except for the smallest of projects), because timely communication is always vital. If the individual is of such an extraordinary calibre that they become a vital hire, it often involves relocation.
- viraptor 4y ago> they can spend all night ruining your day before you even start work. Or they can be saving your service in emergency while you stay in bed. I'm not sure why you'd expect a different time zone to mean lower skills than yours.
- flappyeagle 4y agoThis is just code for outsourcing. Americans who are all-in on remote work should recognize this.
- jasmer 4y agoIt's the biggest cognitive dissonance of the generation. I'm empathetic to rising costs etc. but this remote work thing ... means instantly competing with an audience 10x bigger, many of whom are in remote place with a fraction of cost of living and therefore supply cost, really don't understand how this does not sink in for most people. The next few years are going to be transformative.
- Nasrudith 4y agoThar FUD was tired even before the pandemic, let alone when is being used as an illogical back-to-the-office prod. My attitude towards outsourcing at this point is put up or shut up. Nobody would be doing any threatening if there was anything actually there. We already have heard all of the tales of disastrous failed outsourcing attempts and mediocrity in "success".
- throwaway1777 4y agoYeah except this time we are outsourcing to AI.
- flappyeagle 4y agoIt’s very different to outsource to a giant Indian consulting firm vs offshoring to a network of people working from home across Western Europe. The former is challenging and not likely to succeed in many scenarios. The latter is now the default playbook at places I work
- slt2021 4y agothe key trick is that once you outsource enough of your key competitive advantage - the question arises - what is the company and who creates value - contractors or company management? why shouldn't these contractors open their own company, do the same work and capture entire value they produce, instead of working for fixed salary?
- user6723 4y agoYou don't need to go to the building to use their internet to code stuff for machines that are on the internet or behind a VPN or ZeroTrust gateway that is also on the internet, if you have internet. I worked at an internet-native company a bit over a decade ago, they got more done in two sprints than the "enterprise" places would get done in 3-6 months.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoUnless you have a family back home to spend time with, extended work from home is not goof for your mental health.
- rajamaka 4y agoMaybe not good for yours but it's been great for mine.
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoSame. And I'd much sooner spend time with coworkers than family. ;p
- dymk 4y agoGet a dog and join a club
- nicbou 4y agoI had great coworkers but they were not my friends. Saving 1-2 hour per day of commuting and using my breaks to do chores frees up time to see the people I chose to see.
- jasmer 4y agoColleagues are not 'friends', they are still good for your mental health. Often better than friends since they are forced to behave.
- HPMOR 4y agoI think you may need to re-evaluate your current friendships.
- jasmer 4y agoI have many lifelong friends who are effectively 'kin' aka almost extended family and I don't drop friends because sometimes they might grind a bit, or as we age we see some things (very) differently. Frankly, some of them are a bit odd and have very few friends of their own - they're not going to be 'ejected' because they are not always in support of my sanity. I don't keep 'fairweather friends' who suit my current lifestyle, mood and social status. I enjoy the company of my work colleagues a lot, it's friendly without having to be too intense, and we can talk about 'work stuff' which I enjoy. So you might also want to contemplate a different definition of 'friendship'.
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.md/1w5mR https://archive.md/1w5mR
- jroseattle 4y agoThese remote-vs-office discussions where nobody discusses the actual work involved are fairly pointless. Disregarding the obvious scenarios of presence-required in order to work (i.e. manufacturing), the question applies: what is most productive for "information work"? In my personal experience, I've found collaboration conducted face-to-face far more effective than doing so in a distributed/online way. There is a high level of context in these situations: the topic of discussion, the interactions among attendees, etc. On the flip side, standard administrative operations that require nothing more than a terminal/shell? That's not collaborative, don't make those colleagues commute to a remote workstation. But those employers who "feel their employees aren't so productive" when they aren't in-house -- huge signal they don't know how to really measure productivity. What I've heard from other colleagues in management roles: the concern with remote work isn't about productivity, it's about _dedicated_ productivity coupled with zero trust. In other words, how do we (the employer) ensure our employees aren't moonlighting on our team and only giving the minimum level of effort with us?
- charlie0 4y agoDoes anyone give more than the minimum effort when they find themselves with a 2% to 4% raise, if any, in their yearly reviews, even if they are in the office?
- jasmer 4y agoYes, definitely, for professionals anyone needing to ask the question might consider some introspection.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoIt seems from your answer that you have a self-image as a "professional" and that motivates you to work hard even though it may have minimal impact on your compensation. Have you considered the economic rationality of that stance?
- jasmer 4y ago