14 ms·
Reduced cancer mortality with daily Vitamin D intake
- hannob 4y ago"When all 14 studies were pooled, no statistically significant results emerged. However, when the studies were divided according to whether vitamin D3 was taken daily in a low dose* or in higher doses administered at longer intervals*, a large difference was seen." This sounds fishy. Sounds like their primary result was nothing, and then they looked for something else. Would require some checking if they had a preregistration, if this was registered as a secondary resuld and if they had done a proper statistica analysis of multiple outocmes.
- mholm 4y agoThat's what's confusing me: 105,000 participants in a study should have resulted in thousands of cancer deaths, a 12% drop should be pretty noticeable even with 10% of the data.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoHow exactly are you getting "should have resulted in thousands of cancer deaths"? A population of 100,000 should expect to see 144.1 deaths[1]. If you evenly divide the study group into two 52,500-sized groups(treatment + control), each group should expect to see 72 deaths. A 12% drop in one of the groups is 8.6 deaths. As a colleague would say, that's very few clams from which to make a chowder. Perhaps the researchers are using more advanced tools than I am, but even assuming a 12% difference between treatment and control does not result in a chi-squared test with any reasonable significance. ie: the null-hypothesis(there is no difference between groups) cannot be rejected. 1. https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-deaths/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-de...
- mholm 4y ago144.1 deaths per year. Presumably these studies lasted multiple years. Though I'll admit this was less than I expected, which would explain the differing results.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThank you! Yes, the time frame is important, d'uh lol.
- cypress66 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- amatecha 4y agoYeah, in addition to the XKCD comic it also reminds me of "Spurious Correlations" lol https://tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations https://tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations
- CodeWriter23 4y agoD3 (animal-based) > D2 (plant-based) > D1 (synthetic), at least in humans if you read the literature, that is. The fishy thing is how actual scientists do whole studies using only D1 and then draw conclusions.
- Filligree 4y agoMy takeaway is to keep eating fish.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoOverfishing is serious enough at this point that I'd rather take a small health risk than contribute to it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bt4u 4y ago[dead]
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoDoes aquaponic tilapia not have D3?
- candiddevmike 4y agoNot sure why you are being downvoted. Salmon (mentioned in other siblings) is a perfect example of over fishing, and the farmed stuff tends to be of terrible quality and fed absolute garbage/treated terribly.
- tablarasa 4y agoSalmon is found in high-latitude systems around the globe in both hemispheres. Overfishing is something that occurs to populations, not species. Most of the salmon populations that I am familiar with are not over-fished, but have suffered from spawning habitat loss due to dams and logging. Those are major issues and they continue to negatively affect those populations; you are doing the loggers and dam builders a favor by blaming fishing, which is far easier (and more politically palatable) to regulate.
- phkahler 4y ago>> This sounds fishy. Sounds like their primary result was nothing If you combine results from a bunch of studies that really didn't do anything, it's going to mask the results from the ones that did.
- mlyle 4y agoSure... but conversely, if you keep dividing up and analyzing in different ways, eventually you'll get a p<0.05 result. This is why you "call your shot" before beginning the analysis. Otherwise, people will be suspicious you just jiggered things around until you found something.
- oldgradstudent 4y agoMaybe, but with 14 studies you have ~2^14 ways to split the studies into two groups. If you test multiple hypotheses, you have too adjust the p-value accordingly. Have the authors disclosed how many alternative hypotheses were tested until the result in the article was found to be significant?
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoP-values don't prove anything about whether an effect is real or not. They, at most, provide some degree of confidence with the presumption that the independent and dependent variables are indeed independent and dependent. P-values should, at most, be used to direct further mechanistic studies (if possible). Only use them on their lonesome if this hasn't yet been done, or isn't possible. And if that's the case, reverify them independently (such as by doing another meta-analysis using different data).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tuukkah 4y ago> This systematic review was registered in PROSPERO before data collection to preclude data-driven analyses and selective reporting (CRD42020185566). In addition, the methods, including the selection criteria, the statistical analysis, outcomes, and subgroup and sensitivity analyses, were published in advance in a study protocol (Schöttker et al., 2021). EDIT: And in the protocol, the first subgroup analysis they list is relevant: > Daily dose versus weekly/monthly bolus dose versus bolus dose at the beginning of the trial followed by a daily dose https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/11/1/e041607 https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/11/1/e041607
- cscheid 4y agoYes, exactly. There's a real-life example of an author group who got sufficiently annoyed at a reviewer requesting an inappropriate subgroup analysis: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(00)02031-6/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... Reviewers asked for the subgroup analysis; authors said "no, this is statistically nonsense"; reviewers said "yes, but we'll reject the paper otherwise"; reviewers said "ok, but only if you let us also split on astrological sign". Result: paper reports that aspirin has an effect, but only if you're not a Gemini or Libra. Too good.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThe two signs bracketing the summer months (I presume this was in the northern hemisphere?). That's a potentially interesting finding. > inappropriate subgroup analysis No subgroup is inappropriate unless you know all of the values of all of the parameters. But sure, the intent they tried to demonstrate (take all sub-group analyses with a grain of salt) is a good thing to remember. Edit: To whoever downvoted me, time of year of birth does have real-world effects. https://www.livescience.com/13958-birth-month-health-effects.html https://www.livescience.com/13958-birth-month-health-effects... > Previous studies have found similar links between spring births and various disorders, including schizophrenia, multiple sclerosis and even Type 1 diabetes. It's possible these diseases are linked to some environmental influence during gestation or the first few months of life, though researchers aren't sure what that could be. > The leading candidates including vitamin D levels, infections that come and go seasonally, changes in nutrition, and even possibly weather fluctuations, Handunnetthi told LiveScience. Now perhaps all of this is just bad science and these correlations are just statistical anomalies. But perhaps they aren't.
- cscheid 4y ago> No subgroup is inappropriate unless you know all of the values of all of the parameters I don't know how to put it less bluntly: you're incorrect. > But sure, the intent they tried to demonstrate (take all sub-group analyses with a grain of salt) That's not what they intended to demonstrate. They intended to demonstrate that you need a _reason_ to want to split, and that reason needs to be given _ahead_ of the analysis. If you see the results _and then choose_ a new data analysis (that includes new subgroup analyses), your procedure is no longer statistically sound. This is a specifically bad statistical practice called HARKing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HARKing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HARKing
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Would require some checking if they had a preregistration, if this was registered as a secondary resuld and if they had done a proper statistica analysis of multiple outocmes. You should do that. Meanwhile, I'm going to (continue to) take a daily vitamin D, because I recognize not everything can be confirmed by a double-blind experiment, and the cost is low.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pella 4y ago> "I'm going to (continue to) take a daily vitamin D, because I recognize not everything can be confirmed by a double-blind experiment, and the cost is low." Or it may be possible to prove the opposite, as with the parachute. bmj: "Parachute use to prevent death and major trauma when jumping from aircraft: randomized controlled trial" https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094 https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094 Results: Parachute use did not significantly reduce death or major injury (0% for parachute v 0% for control; P>0.9). This finding was consistent across multiple subgroups. Compared with individuals screened but not enrolled, participants included in the study were on aircraft at significantly lower altitude (mean of 0.6 m for participants v mean of 9146 m for non-participants; P<0.001) and lower velocity (mean of 0 km/h v mean of 800 km/h; P<0.001). "Conclusions: Parachute use did not reduce death or major traumatic injury when jumping from aircraft in the first randomized evaluation of this intervention. However, the trial was only able to enroll participants on small stationary aircraft on the ground, suggesting cautious extrapolation to high altitude jumps. When beliefs regarding the effectiveness of an intervention exist in the community, randomized trials might selectively enroll individuals with a lower perceived likelihood of benefit, thus diminishing the applicability of the results to clinical practice." disclaimer: I am pro-Parachute! I believe 100% in the effectiveness of the parachute!
- bitL 4y agoSimpson's paradox is well known - aggregate often has different statistical properties than individual parts.
- trevorkoob 4y ago15 minutes of full-body UV exposure from the sun is estimated to provide the equivalent of 20-30,000 IU Vitamin D3. There is a definite need for studies that better determine the effective dose for D3. My research led me to the conclusion that studies should be done based not on standardized supplementation, but instead supplementation to a standardized blood serum level.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI've been taking a daily vitamin D supplement since COVID-19 broke out in the USA. I believe there's a lot of evidence that many people are deficient in vitamin D. I don't know if supplements are the best way to attack that but it's one of the easiest ways. Getting daily sun exposure isn't always convenient and not really possible for a good chunk of the year since we have real winter here.
- oppositelock 4y agoI have some hard numbers on this in my own health. I'm a pasty north European living in California and I get plenty of sunshine, as I enjoy the outdoors. As I got older, I got increasingly more viral infections and strep throat was a twice a year affair. It didn't occur to me that I could be vitamin-D deficient, but I was, severely. For some reason, 10+ hours of sunshine a week isn't enough for me to make my own. Over months, I tracked my blood vitamin D levels as I took supplements, and now I know that the 2500IU dose is enough to keep me at nominal levels - the higher doses cause it to build up too much and would eventually cause liver issues. I know it's anecdotal, but in the few years since I did this, those recurrent sicknesses have vanished. I'm also taking vitamin B, which is another one you get less efficient at absorbing as you age.
- jghn 4y ago> Over months, I tracked my blood vitamin D levels OOC what did you use to do this?
- oppositelock 4y agoMonthly blood tests prescribed by a doctor at a local bloodwork lab.
- jghn 4y agoDid you have a challenge getting them to initiate that? I'd imagine once you're shown to be severely deficient it's easier, but there's a chicken & egg.
- craig_s_bell 4y agoIn that circumstance, I've heard that vitamins and supplements can be tricky; the additional nutrition may feed the cancer, before it feeds you. Just one more factor to consider.
- ramoz 4y ago> However, when the studies were divided according to whether vitamin D3 was taken daily in a low dose* or in higher doses administered at longer intervals*, a large difference was seen. In the four studies with the infrequent hogher doses, there was no effect on cancer mortality. In contrast, in the summary of the ten studies with daily dosing, the researchers determined a statistically significant twelve percent reduction in cancer mortality. What exactly is the recommendation here, low or higher doses? or something else because Im struggling to understand this
- Filligree 4y agoDid they test "high dose taken frequently" at all? Bearing in mind that the guideline vitamin-D daily dose target is set at just about the lowest possible value that doesn't cause obvious deficiencies.
- nanofortnight 4y agoVitamin D is fat soluble, and thus you can overdose on it. High dose frequently is not recommended, and most high dose supplements will have warning labels about vitaminosis.
- ramoz 4y agoI've also been told to be careful with any vitamin supplements while on chemo, and to consult a cancer dietician before conducting you're own science... the reason, as I understand it as a patient, is that high oxidation can actually keep cancer cells strong and healthy enough to create chemoresistance.
- ben7799 4y agoYou need to take extreme amounts of it for months to overdose. Something like 40,000-100,000IU/day for several months. That's 8-20 pills per day of the most potent D3 commonly available.
- tuukkah 4y agoFrom the footnotes: > In the studies, daily low doses were 400 to 4000 IU per day, and higher-doses administered at longer intervals were 60,000 to 120,000 IU once per month or less.
- chasil 4y agoMy local grocer offered free Vitamin D tests early this year, and it was my first. It was quite low. My physician recommended 5,000 IU for 90 days, then 1,500 after. I'll test again next year for my physical.
- ekianjo 4y agoNot new results. It's been known for a long time.
- kstrauser 4y agoGiven that D3 is dirt cheap and lots of us are low in it, is there any downside to taking a reasonable daily dose?
- funnym0nk3y 4y agoBesides unneccessary expenses? I don't think so. 2000 IE should be fine, and thats with a safety margin of 2.
- icedchai 4y agoI was taking 3000 IU of D3 for years. When COVID hit, I upped that to 5000 and have kept it there since.
- reducesuffering 4y agoDepends on the definition of reasonable. D3 is fat soluble and if you take too much for years it can accumulate too much in your body. I'd say 2,500 IU is max to take daily without infrequent blood tests to calibrate the optimum.
- atombender 4y agoYour skin releases around 10,000 IU if you spend an hour outside in full sun in the summer. So that, at least, should be quite safe. This article from the Mayo Clinic argues that vitamin D toxicity has been vastly overstated. [1] [1] https://www.mayoclinicproceedings.org/article/S0025-6196%2815%2900244-X/fulltext https://www.mayoclinicproceedings.org/article/S0025-6196%281...
- interestica 4y agoWhere's that 10000 iu data point from? And what colour is "your skin"?
- generalenvelope 4y agoIt costs money and won't necessarily do anything about the levels / the things that were causing the levels to be low in the first place. Highly recommend this deep dive: https://soundcloud.com/user-344313169/vitamin-d-mixdown-1 https://soundcloud.com/user-344313169/vitamin-d-mixdown-1
- ck2 4y agoLast century they insisted Vitamin C prevents/cures cancer. This century it's Vitamin D with the same level of insistence. Don't hold your breath. Abstract says it all: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20799507/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20799507/
- reducesuffering 4y agoYou know that both of these are called "Vitamins" because they are essential to human health? You will have increased risk of many health problems with deficiencies.
- bregma 4y agoNot enough is bad so more than enough must be better?
- reducesuffering 4y agoTFA starts with "Vitamin D deficiency is widespread worldwide and is particularly common among cancer patients." and concludes "in the summary of the ten studies with daily dosing, the researchers determined a statistically significant twelve percent reduction in cancer mortality." So yes, not enough is bad, and many require supplementation to get to an ideal level. Nowhere was anyone proposing overdosing.
- thenerdhead 4y agoAbstract literally says vitamin C has potential as a cancer-fighting agent and protective against certain types of cancers too.
- frickinLasers 4y agoIt's maybe a good time to re-post this in-depth series on vitamin D supplementation. You don't want to take too much. https://www.devaboone.com/post/vitamin-d-part-2-shannon-s-story https://www.devaboone.com/post/vitamin-d-part-2-shannon-s-st...
- ntonozzi 4y agoThat article is so weird: > Of course, there is a selection bias in who comes to me. There are people out there doing just fine on 5000 units of Vitamin D daily. I only see the ones who develop high calcium levels. But I see enough of them to know that this is not an exceptionally rare occurrence. I have been to lectures in which physicians have claimed that Vitamin D toxicity almost never occurs. In my experience, this is false. I have seen many cases of Vitamin D toxicity in people who were taking the recommended dose from an over-the-counter bottle. She is an extremely specialized professional who is referred and treats people with this condition. Of course it's not rare in her experience! For all we know, she could be one of a hundred parathyroid specialists in the country, and only 1 in 100000 people who take Vitamin D get Vitamin D toxicity. The author should really provide some evidence on how common this is.
- frickinLasers 4y agoThe point is it's a hormone--not, like, ascorbic acid or something. It's good to be aware that it can poison you, especially when the "vitamin" label can make it seem harmless.
- atombender 4y agoThe Mayo Clinic thinks otherwise: https://www.mayoclinicproceedings.org/article/S0025-6196%2815%2900244-X/fulltext https://www.mayoclinicproceedings.org/article/S0025-6196%281... Another article about the findings: https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/vitamin-d-toxicity-rare-in-people-who-take-supplements-mayo-clinic-study-finds/ https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/vitamin-d-toxi...
- frickinLasers 4y ago
- dboreham 4y agoWouldn't we know this already if populations in sunny areas had less cancer (controlled for genetics)?
- atwebb 4y agoWould especially sunny areas not produce people with more cancer (or certain types)?
- kpw94 4y agohttps://mediad.publicbroadcasting.net/p/kuow/files/styles/x_large/public/201407/skin-cancer-by-state.JPG https://mediad.publicbroadcasting.net/p/kuow/files/styles/x_... Sunnier areas have less skin cancers, if that's what you were wondering. Now is it because of the Vitamin D, or because of a more systemic application of sunscreen?
- throw_pm23 4y ago..or something else entirely
- atwebb 4y agoLate reply, I was wondering that but also, at least in the US, they tend to have older folks and retirees so that it may skew the stats. I really don't have any data on it, just speculating.
- francisofascii 4y agoMaybe. Some studies have shown people in sunnier areas have less risk of certain types of cancer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vharuck 4y agoIt'd be hard to control for everything relevant. Diet would be indirectly affected by sunlight (sunny areas would naturally have different crops). Amount of exercise, too. Genetics play a large role in some cancers, but behaviors and choices are strongly linked to many common cancers like lung or colorectal. Breast cancer has been linked to a woman's history of pregnancy (higher risk for those who were pregnant when very young or never had been pregnant past middle age). mini-rant Even if we could design an experiment to know how much sunlight affects cancer mortality, it might not be worth the time and money. We already know ways to reduce cancer incidence in a population: less tobacco, less alcohol, less obesity, more exercise, sunscreen if you have light skin. We could further reduce cancer mortality by getting people to follow screening guidelines. We've reached a point where public policy and outreach are the most valuable efforts to preventing cancer incidence and mortality. Quitting bad habits is hard. Going to the doctor for screening can be scary, expensive, or logistically difficult. /mini-rant
- beefman 4y agoAs usual the abstract of the source paper is clearer, easier to read, and more detailed https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37004841/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37004841/
- nabla9 4y agoTL;DR Vitamin D *deficiency* is cancer risk and relatively common. High doses don't work. >When all 14 studies were pooled, no statistically significant results emerged. However, when the studies were divided according to whether vitamin D3 was taken daily in a low dose* or in higher doses administered at longer intervals*, a large difference was seen. In the four studies with the infrequent hogher doses, there was no effect on cancer mortality. In contrast, in the summary of the ten studies with daily dosing, the researchers determined a statistically significant twelve percent reduction in cancer mortality. >"We observed this twelve percent reduction in cancer mortality after untargeted vitamin D3 administration to individuals with and without vitamin D deficiency. We can therefore assume that the effect is significantly higher for those people who are actually vitamin D deficient,"
- alejohausner 4y agoThe global distribution of many types of cancer is strongly related to latitude. The farther you are from the equator, the higher the rate of disease. The more sun you get, the less cancer. It's hard not to infer that sun exposure and thus synthesis of vitamin D helps prevent many cancers. We've been urged to avoid sun exposure because it can cause skin cancer. But those cancers are squamous and basal cell carcinomas. Those carcinomas are easily cured, and don't usually kill you. Melanoma, the truly deadly skin cancer, is more prevalent in populations with less sun exposure. There are lots of interesting graphs on Jeff Bowles' site [^1]. He's an absolute fan of vitamin D. ^1:https://jefftbowles.com/vitamin-d3-deficiency-causes-most-human-disease/ https://jefftbowles.com/vitamin-d3-deficiency-causes-most-hu...
- sateesh 4y agoCan you be specific about what kind of Cancer incidences is related to the latitude ? In general I don't think there is a good correlation between Cancer incidences and latitude, for example India gets plenty of sunshine year around, but Cancer incidences are no less.
- konschubert 4y agoThe statistics you are presenting - have they been corrected for life expectancy? Do they also hold across North America , eg comparing Florida to Boston?
- subsubzero 4y agoAs someone who spends alot of time outside(as much as I can while still working!) and also takes 5000iu of vitamin D, I just wanted to say there is moderation in everything. Getting too much sun can lead to skin cancer so make sure you are wearing sunscreen.
- dagw 4y agoI worked on a project related to modelling UV and skin cancer rates. And what I learnt there is that that big thing that causes skin cancer isn't so much total UV exposure over a year, but a sudden switch for long periods of no sun to a period of intense sun. You see this especially in the Nordic countries where it isn't uncommon to go from 4 month of getting essentially no sun to 10 days of spending 10 hours a day in a bathing suit on a beach in Thailand or Bali.
- felixg3 4y agoNice to see a publication of my literal neighbours posted here. Yeah, it's important to mention that this of course only applies to people suffering from deficiency, which in Europe is quite prevalent.
- lynx23 4y agoIt took me a long time, and virtually no help from outside, to discover that vitamin D effectively cures my winter depression. I was never really feeling good around that time of the year, but it wasn't problematic enough to actually do something about it. But when my gut started to revolt around that time too, I started to feel distinctly unwell. So I went to my doctor, who gave me an approintment with a nutrition specialist. That chat was totally and wholy unhelpful, and the sympoms persisted. Out of sheer luck, I insisted on having my vitamin D tested. It turns out I was truly hitting bottom. Even that didn't make my doctor say heureka. No, he kind of casually brushed the test result away, but casually said I could take some D, ideally from october to easter... Next hurdle was the dose. Most things I could get at the pharmacy without prescription are actually very low dose, and then there is this fresh panic going about, "vitamin D users overdose" or something. But with luck, I found dekristolmin. 20k i.e. in a single small pill. I take one every sunday since two years, and my mental health couldn't be better. Also, most of the gut irritation is also gone. Why I type this here? I found it interesting that I had to discover this cure on my own. The medical system wuldn't have figured that out on their own, let alone accept that it was the single solution.
- kerkeslager 4y agoI had a fairly similar experience with winter depression being cured by 10,000IU Vitamin D3 daily. I wouldn't say it's the single solution, which might be because my depression wasn't limited by season. I'm speaking in the past tense because my depression is largely managed by diet and exercise (rock climbing). The diet aspect is basically covered by the AFS in Table 2 here[1], with some additional natural probiotics (frequent yogurt and occasional kombucha). Like you, I basically figured this out with some luck in stumbling across information, some self-experimentation, and little help from medical professionals. What little help I did receive was in NY. In TN where I currently reside, I likely would not have received even that help, because medical care is unaffordable for most people. Additionally, there are an inordinate number of horror stories here about prescribers getting people onto a huge number of medications--this seems to particularly happen to young women who aren't comfortable advocating for themselves. I suspect this is due to pharmaceutical kickbacks, but haven't found any data to back that hypothesis up. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6147775/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6147775/
- thijser 4y agoThere have been many vit D studies before, e.g., this one with 25K participants in the USA, which found no effect: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1809944 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1809944 It's best to look at a meta analysis of all existing data/trials instead of focusing on one trial that happens to be positive.
- D13Fd 4y agoYeah. I don't know why people seem so invested in pushing Vitamin D as a cure for everything.
- tric 4y agoI think vitamin D deficiency explains moderate hair loss in some people. Just based on my own experience. I don't think enough people mention it.
- mattchew 4y agoOur family started taking Vitamin D at the start of the pandemic. We've all gotten sick a lot less than we used to, despite one of us working at a drugstore constantly exposed to sick people. Of course I don't know for sure that the Vitamin D is causal here, but it's my best guess. I suspect a lot of people are D deficient and just don't know it.
- tpoacher 4y agoThe article seems to imply that lots of p-hacking took place before they found a "positive" result worth reporting. Not sure how to feel about that. Also, why on earth would one talk about mortality "from cancer" and not mention overall mortality from all causes? This is classic "smoking cures most diseases of old age" statistical thinking...
- evo_9 4y agoD3 + MK7 if you really want to amplify its effectiveness.
- unethical_ban 4y agoWhat's the source of this? I've seen a lot of D3+k2 caps now.
- nicenewtemp84 4y agoWe were told that almost everyone that had a covid death was either obese or had a vitamin D deficiency, by the CDC itself, and yet people will argue if it's important or not to get enough.
- ddlutz 4y agoAnybody vitamin D deficient even after supplementation? I had mine checked September of last year, it was low even when taking 2000 IU a day, so DR gave me a 50,000 IU pill to take once a week. It's still considered deficient, but not as deficient. I live in Seattle, so not much sun has been out the past 6 months, not sure if that's skewing numbers lower than they are in the summer.
- antimora 4y agoYou could try with vitamin K2 mixed. It helps with absorption. I tried this: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ECH40MQ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ECH40MQ
- generalenvelope 4y agoLots of people here are assuming that supplementing vitamin D will "treat" a low level of it, which isn't necessarily true. The level might not change, but you also might care a lot less than you think about the level specifically. Many problems can cause the level to be low, and won't be affected by raising it. Highly recommend the Barbell Medicine podcast on Vitamin D: https://soundcloud.com/user-344313169/vitamin-d-mixdown-1 https://soundcloud.com/user-344313169/vitamin-d-mixdown-1
- dennis_jeeves1 4y agoYour's is the correct answer, in this case there is confusion between causation and correlation. To make matters more confusing, vitamin D indeed produce positive results for the affiliation in the short term, for some cases.
- kypro 4y agoA few thoughts from an autistic bro scientist... Not being deficient in Vitamin D is not the same as having optimal levels of Vitamin D. Optimal levels of Vitamin D are probably around 60-70ng/ml, with a bias to upper end of that range (in my opinion anyway). I say this because individuals with a lot of sun exposure will typically have Vitamin D levels around 70ng/ml so this is in my opinion is likely closer to the levels of our ancestors. However, a lot of experts would argue 50ng/ml is optimal, but I disagree with this primarily because the number is based on population averages in populations that are largely Vitamin D deficient. In comparison, to be considered deficient you would generally need levels below 20ng/ml which less than a third of what I suspect is optimal (and natural). Again, I'm just an autistic bro scientist, but my understanding is that low levels of Vitamin D are strongly associated to higher levels of inflammation in the body. We also know that higher levels of inflammation in the body are linked to various negative health outcomes like depression, impaired immune function, and increased cancer risk. If I were to guess most individuals who develop cancer are older and generally less healthy. Given that most people in the West don't have optimal levels of Vitamin D in the first place we can only assume that those with cancer have even less optimal levels. Therefore the idea that supplementing Vitamin D in a population highly likely to have suboptimal levels of Vitamin D would reduce cancer mortality should not be surprising at all. If you live in the West you really should consider taking 1,000 - 2,000 IU of Vitamin D a day – and perhaps more if you're able to monitor your levels to ensure you're not taking too much. I'm really not a fan of taking supplements in general, but Vitamin D is one of the few most people in the West probably would benefit from taking at a low dose.
- monkey_monkey 4y agoWhat's an autistic bro scientist and why is that relevant?
- scottlamb 4y agoFor the purposes of this discussion, I interpret it as similar to the common "I am not a lawyer/doctor/scientist/... but" disclaimer. More specifically, I might paraphrase as "unusually intense spectator/armchair scientist"—someone who's read about the topic in depth but isn't a researcher/practitioner, so the commenter's understanding is indirect or anecdotal and hasn't been reinforced/validated by writing research papers and subjecting them to peer review.
- lez 4y agoFor the overcautious theoretic thinkers here, I recommend reading about Coimbra protocol, where 50,000 IU daily is not rare. It can go up to 300,000 IU per day. At levels above 10,000 IU per day you should take precautions to prevent calcification of the soft tissues: Take Vitamin K (100-200ug), Boron (10-20mg) to prevent calcification. Vitamin A should be dosaged at a ration 1:1 - 1:4 compared to Vit D (same amount or 4 times more of vitamin A) because A and D are anthagonists. Below 10,000 IU there's only benefits of better health and no risk or precautions needed.
- ufo 4y agoI'm not sure if a quack doctor's miracle cure "protocol" is a good point of comparison... https://veja.abril.com.br/saude/medicos-questionam-tratamento-de-esclerose-multipla-a-base-de-vitamina-d/ https://veja.abril.com.br/saude/medicos-questionam-tratament...
- qingcharles 4y agoI didn't get to go outside for 10 years as I was locked in a cell. Does anyone know if this length of sunlight deprivation has a long-term nonreversible effect? (I also had no window, no access to supplements, or any choice of nutrition)
- counterpartyrsk 4y agoLike others, I discovered my mood is significantly increased when consistently taking vitamin D
- andsoitis 4y ago> Vitamin D deficiency is widespread worldwide Even in the Southern Hemisphere?
- pookha 4y agoI'm on board with Vitamin D but I've learned from experience that if you over-do it with a D3 supplement (being ill) you'll have some interesting heart palpitations. Which case buckle up.
- dylanzhangdev 4y agoI wonder if there are cheap and readily available fruits or vegetables that provide vitamin D in large quantities through food that can meet the daily required dose
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mawadev 4y agoCan I just point out how nearly every website tells a different story about whether daily Vitamin D intake is either good, necessary or toxic? It's so confusing to read so much text that contradicts itself, contradicts other sources or outright paints a bad image.