10 ms·
Tech jobs remain a good bet despite mass layoffs in Silicon Valley
- jasoneckert 4y agoBig news headlines seem to be positioned in a way to scare people away from tech jobs right now, but the hard reality is that every organization relies tech people, not just those few big tech companies in Silicon Valley that over-hired during the pandemic.
- Mordisquitos 4y agoPlus, I would argue that any argument trying to scare people away from tech jobs based on the current economic circumstances is worthless if it does not suggest a more promising alternative. Will an individual who has the appropriate qualifications and experience find that tech jobs are harder to find, less stable, and less well compensated than they were 5 years ago? Yes, absolutely! But will that same individual find that tech jobs are harder to find, less stable, and less well compensated than jobs in another industry right now? If so, which industry?
- phreack 4y agoAbsolutely, it feels like every industry is having a hard time, so focusing on tech seems to be nothing more than clickbait.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoPeople focus on tech because it was previously seen as immune to such drama, a sure thing, the safe bet. When even "the rich people" with "all the right stuff" can get laid off, people have Big Feels.
- Clubber 4y ago>People focus on tech because it was previously seen as immune to such drama, a sure thing, the safe bet. Whoever thought that didn't work during 2001 or 2008, or has a short memory.
- DoreenMichele 4y ago"Recession is when your neighbor loses his job. Depression is when you lose your job." Lots of people have skewed perspectives.
- blitzar 4y agoThe only thing they position for is clicks, the only real agenda is clicks. Industry / Company / Place where people make lots of money firing people = lots of clicks.
- 007asdflkjsfd 4y agogood systems have disconnected incentives and connected outcomes. the same way advertisement upholds political correctness and same-thinking and make criticism harder, based solely on self interest and "not being demonetized by youtube", a journalist having clicks as the only metric will benefit whoever can spend money not caring for clicks to push an agenda to select the click-driving crisis du jour.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIf you were an average engineer destined to work in cookie-cutter roles in tech consultancies, would you still pursue a tech career, knowing that your job will sooner or later be taken over by AI? Remember that careers last 30 years, and if you're the average engineer, you're more likely to fall into the 80% of the pareto half than the 20%. Can you be confident that AI won't displace you in 10, 15, or even 20 years? This doesn't apply to Stanford grads destined for high-tech roles in FAANG tier companies. I'm taling about the Idaho State grads who will work for IBM and Accenture and likely won't make the $500k salaries to retire from their tech roles in 10 years.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> Can you be confident that AI won't displace you in 10, 15, or even 20 years? 1) No, but I am nonetheless skeptical of AI-takeover in general — I'm in the wait-and-see camp and so wouldn't be put off by the might-happens. 2) If one were AI-alarmist, is there any profession you can be confident will not be displaced by AI in 10, 15, or even 20 years? 3) Confession: I'm retired and no longer have any skin in the game.
- m_a_g 4y ago> 2) If one were AI-alarmist, is there any profession you can be confident will not be displaced by AI in 10, 15, or even 20 years? Many; Dentists, people that fix your AC, electricians, etc, etc.
- post-it 4y agoIf AI becomes capable of replacing the bulk of software developers, many trades will be replaced by a guy earning a little over minimum wage wearing AR goggles with an AI showing+telling them what to do and correcting their mistakes.
- VLM 4y agoNo need for the AR goggles, just hire day labor to work for a skilled tradesman as a labor multiplier, or try the old fashioned "here's a mobile phone do what your boss says" In the trades themselves, we've been doing this for centuries... have a master mason supervise the journeyman masons supervising the manual day labor. AI will not be able to compete with experienced personnel. In that field they've already dumbed down the entry level requirement to "pick up a brick and move it there" and it can't go much lower. On the other hand, if I were manufacturing survey equipment I'd worry about AR goggles as the competition.
- KoftaBob 4y ago"Big news headlines seem to be positioned in a way to scare people" regardless of the topic.
- Chocobean 4y agoThis articles reads more like a student recruitment brochure than an actual article
- wil421 4y agoIt seems like promo for some Call Center (IT Tech Support) boot camp.
- Maclennan 4y ago[dead]
- reset-password 4y agoI am convinced that the mass layoffs are occurring because forward-thinking executives can see that AI agents are coming to replace employees faster than most people expect. By doing layoffs early they can cut staff before public opinion shifts to questioning AI as the motive, as opposed to "the economy".
- phpnode 4y agoThat’s a level of confidence, preparation and forward thinking that would be uncharacteristic. The reality is that everyone else is cutting staff so it’s become expected. And because it’s expected and happening throughout the industry it’s a lot easier to do a layoff or two now than it was a year ago
- sclarisse 4y agoIt’s not because it’s “expected” in the abstract. It’s because everyone is competing for money with the US Treasury, and the rates on those Treasury bills are looking better than they have in a long long while. Did you have a growth business that’s going to be 50% bigger in 10 years? A few years ago that would sound not-amazing but reasonable. Today that’s nothing. You can get that kind of returns from bonds with like zero risk. Firms therefore prioritize savings like they haven’t done in years.
- lhnz 4y agoWhy are you convinced of this? From what I can see, GPT-4 is incredibly useful but you have to be very careful to lead it in the correct direction otherwise it produces bad outputs. I say this as somebody that probably uses it every 10 minutes. Do you think that it will stop making errors of judgment and be able to behave as an agent soon? I've not encountered anything yet that gives me faith in that, other than hype about it increasing in ability exponentially which seems unlikely.
- tarruda 4y ago> I say this as somebody that probably uses it every 10 minutes Do you feel like your ability to produce correct output with GPT improved with practice? If so, then eventually you might reach a point where you get 99.99% accuracy with it, and this can easily 10x your productivity.
- Joeboy 4y agoI'm not sure what would be a better bet? It's not like automation / the economy / capitalism aren't also coming for other workers. Maybe a good time to retrain as a bailiff?
- spaceman_2020 4y agoGiven the capabilities of our current set of AI tools, I have zero doubt that almost every white collar job will be affected within a 10-15 years. Before you say that's not possible, remember that chatGPT (GPT-3.5) went live in November 2022, and GPT-4 went live in March 2023. 10-15 years is a long time in tech. The iPhone is barely 15 years old.
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoChatGPT was based on GPT3, which was released in 2020. The fundamental advance appears to have been InstructGPT which was 2022. GPT4 was 2023, three years after version 3. Id expect to see GPT5 sometime in 2026.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThis thing is out in the public now and has massive mindshare. Funding and intellectual talent is flowing in at a much faster pace. The big incumbents are now under pressure from their shareholders to come up with competitors. I'll be very, very surprised if the growth rate doesn't accelerate from here.
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoMaybe, maybe not? It depends on what improved GPT-4 relative to 3. If it was adding more data, then we'd expect progress to speed up in the short-term and then come to a screeching halt as we run out of text. If it was algorithmic/model improvements then it could be much quicker to improve or much slower. I think the big problem is that nobody (except Open-AI) knows what GPT-4 does and how it does it, so it's hard to predict. I'm generally a fan of a naive model given the uncertainties around this, hence my prediction of three years.
- JCM9 4y agoTech is a rare industry where you can easily pivot into it later in your career, start at an entry level position, work your way very high up the ladder and get paid very well along the way. I know folks without a college degree that started as tech support reps who worked their way up to senior roles in big tech that make multiples more than most physicians I know or others that had to go down a rigid path to get to where they are. The industry favors eager people who are hungry to continually learn and grow. While there can be short term bumps in the road, those that fit these characteristics have and will continue to do extremely well.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> I know folks without a college degree that started as tech support reps I know a few as well ... but that was decade(s) ago. I'm not sure the industry is still as hurdle-able as it once was.
- AdamN 4y agoYeah I think the drawbridge is getting pulled up on that one. This won't be as common in the future and from the other side we're at the point where most new hires went to college to get a degree specifically to get a tech job. This creates another problem where the new crop isn't curious about tech for it's own sake - it's just a respectable career option :-/
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y ago> This creates another problem where the new crop isn't curious about tech for it's own sake This is not a problem and has never been a problem. Some of the best developers that I've worked with have absolutely no interest in turning on a computer when they leave work.
- triihart 4y agoI know a guy who started as Java developer in some entrylevel company. No education, on previous job he used to drive trucks. He already has more job-specific knowledge than I do, though lacks some fundamentals.
- mansilladev 4y agoI listened to the article yesterday when it was broadcast on NPR, and noticed it was largely focused on starter IT roles and not software engineering.
- roflyear 4y agoSV is really failing their community lately. First with SVB and now with the job market. People outside the valley are largely still hiring developers. East coast is pretty hot still.
- jwie 4y agoThe pandemic hiring blitz was more like seasonal hiring in a sector that doesn’t normally do that, and nobody had the vocabulary to describe the phenomenon. Combined with talent hoarding the whole thing became a luxury companies can’t afford without free money from either investors or the fed. Even with all this cutting, headcount is still growing. But it’s harder than ever for the entry level guys. Painting a rosy picture here is wrong.
- epolanski 4y agoI don't think people that come to HN are nowhere near worried about not finding a job, especially the technical ones. I think we're mostly worried about not finding jobs that were as lucrative as they have been in the last years.
- nytesky 4y agoExactly, we hire a ton of technical Fed contractors, but the pay range capps out at $150k and starts at a level most of HN would find insulting. But it’s considered “tech” at least by NPR.
- giantg2 4y agoIt's insulting that people think most of HN are highly paid. I dont really fit in anywhere. I suppose I don't even fit in on here. $150k would be a very nice raise for me, one that I'm not capable of abtaining.
- monsieurgaufre 4y agoJust wanted to tell you that you’re not alone. Obscene salaries compensating for societal failures should not be seen as the way to go. That said, i dont advocate for lowering salaries in general.
- greenthrow 4y agoHe said it caps out at $150k. Starts much lower.
- giantg2 4y agoYes, and their point was that people on HN wouldn't even be interested at the $150k cap because they make more in the private sector.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI guess the idea is that HN is mainly tech and much of that demographic makes higher than the societal median.
- vaxman 4y agoNPR? How would this all go if it is necessary to start rationing access to AWS, Azure and GCP, driving up the cost of hosting applications on them to the point that only well funded organizations can continue doing so? What percentage of "Tech jobs" are in companies that exist at the whim of a couple shareholders or poorly funded organizations that are unlikely to withstand 3000% cloud price increases? (Spoiler: MOST.) Was any of this discussed by NPR? What could cause such a black swan event? Does NPR want us to even think about the possibility of the sudden "closure" of certain fabs in Taiwan and Shenzen (making the chip shortage a semi-permanent event)? https://nypost.com/2023/04/26/us-to-send-nuclear-submarine-to-south-korea-as-part-of-deterrence/ https://nypost.com/2023/04/26/us-to-send-nuclear-submarine-t... Nobody in Tech has time for NPR, there are a million YouTube videos to watch, websites, podcasts and Safari books to read, plus management of your personal life and ACTUAL Sphere of Influence. The best you can do is vote for someone who you (not NPR, not Communist-controlled social media platforms or the revolving door of bloviators on TV) think is able to effectively manage issues in a way that will bring about the best economic outcome for you and everyone you know. https://youtu.be/bPpcfH_HHH8 https://youtu.be/bPpcfH_HHH8
- epups 4y agoMy perception is that at least in Europe, mass layoffs have had almost no impact on the tech sector. I would say there is still a shortage of people for desired roles and therefore job offers and salaries are still high. Not talking about FAANG positions (or salaries) of course, more run-of-the-mill roles that companies struggle to fulfill.
- sveme 4y agoI‘m currently on the market and the situation is definitely very different from the same time last year. Companies are hesitant/waiting to see where the economy is heading, a lot if startups ran out of money. It‘s not that easy anymore, at least in my bubble.
- Sugimot0 4y agoYeah last year my inbox was flooded with recruiters, but I had a rough round of technical interviews back to back and succumbed to imposter syndrome. I postponed interviewing to learn and prep and try to add more to my resume. Now a year later, I'm trying for a new job again and I hardly hear from recruiters, and I actually have to apply for jobs. It's a huge contrast from this time last year and it makes me regret waiting. Side Note: Having seen other coworkers move on and knowing what I know now, I've realized I was more than ready to get a new job a year ago, I just lacked the confidence to keep trying. Hopefully this serves to motivate others paralyzed by imposter syndrome.
- dragonelite 4y agoWell there's more to tech than big tech or silicon valley. The rest of the market has to fight over scrap or leftover from big tech.