16 ms·
We just had a conversation the other day about climate change and methane, and some people were saying 20x as strong as CO2, and others were saying and sometime
by hinkley 4y ago
We just had a conversation the other day about climate change and methane, and some people were saying 20x as strong as CO2, and others were saying and sometimes correcting them to 28.
According to this article the correct answer is 20. That’s still over an order of magnitude difference. It still doesn’t change the priorities much, it means you can leak 40% more methane from a system before it’s worse that coal, but we aren’t usually measuring these sorts of problems in 2 decimal points to begin with.
- henearkr 4y agoYes. It doesn't change anything to the problem. But lots of people will say it does (the climate deniers).
- junofan 4y agoAnyone who changes relative priorities for emissions reduction based on new information is a climate denier?
- freedomben 4y agoAs a person who believes man is effecting the climate, and is very worried about sustainability, but also thinks that there are some climate scientists who are off in their estimates (or can be too myopic at times like any other human) and that there is still much for us to learn and discover, yes I can confirm that if you question anything or approach things with skepticism (even though that's the way science is supposed to be done), you are a "climate denier" or often called "a science denier." It's quite depressing. I had hoped by now humanity would be moving deeply into rationality, but we're still just as emotion-driven as ever. We come by it honestly since our neurology is tuned to handle most (or maybe all) decisions subconciously and then have our conscious/rational mind justify the decision after the fact, but I do believe that by understanding our biology and implementing systems/approaches to combat it, we could become a highly logical species. There is still some hope on the horizon. Live long and prosper my friend.
- henearkr 4y agoI don't think the experts are against skepticism, they are just deeply tired to be stuck at the stage "try to convince" when the proofs are already overwhelming and the apocalyptical consequences are already slowly (but not slowly enough) unfolding before our eyes on this planet.
- it_citizen 4y agoThe other big difference is that methane stays only around 12 years in the atmosphere compared to centuries for CO2.
- KAMSPioneer 4y agoMy understanding is that the methane decomposes into CO2 and water, so it ends up doing the same damage as CO2 in addition, anyway.
- Nasrudith 4y agoIt converts to CO2 if I recall correctly, only 19x of it expires effectively.
- orwin 4y agoHalf life is 12 year. It also rise rapidly in the high troposphere (where the magic happen), so the methane we emit today will have an effect in 2-3 year, whereas the carbon we emit today will have an effect in roughly 20 year. Today's climate is caused by 2003 emissions.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoThis is so confusing to me. Iirc decades ago the rationale for methane being worse is that it stayed along longer. Now we know better from isotope studies (there's probably atmospheric bacteria breaking it down). The IR absorption spectrum of methane is way way weaker than CO2. (I have taken one myself in advanced pchem lab. This also makes sense b/c CO2 has a higher interatomic dipole moment and c-infinity symmetry so symmetry breaking rovibrational absorb more). So I don't understand how methane has a stronger forcing function, and I can never get a straight answer from anyone.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoLike TFA says : it doesn't end up in the same place in the atmosphere ? (A little bit like Ozone is bad to have around us, but extremely important in ~high (?) atmosphere?) IIRC (but I am way less certain of this) there's also extra issue with methane degrading into not only CO2, but also water, and in a place where they increase the greenhouse effect rather than reducing it ? P.S.: Also water vapor is an extremely powerful greenhouse gas... but I have no idea which fraction of water ends up in this phase under these conditions, nor how long water lasts there... P.P.S.: Oh, also, I just remembered : CH4 (+X O2) => CO2 + H2O, is just one of many reactions that happen... IIRC this is also where the ozone layer is and all of these ingredients and products all have an effect. But in the end it's all oversimplified into CO2 has this greenhouse effect, and CH4 that one - by the climatologists ? (All of this from climatology 101 that I had to take a decade ago, because there was no other option for a remote physics degree...)
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoMethane naturally turns into CO2 in the atmosphere. Even if it did increase warming more than CO2, once methane emissions reach a steady level, reducing methane emissions won't change a thing, compared to CO2 emissions. This is also similar to meat production emissions. Most of carbon emissions in meat productions are of carbon which was captured from the air as a part of the production cycle, by the plants which feed the cattle. The narrative is extremely misleading.
- djleni 4y agoCould you explain further? How does: > reducing methane emissions won't change a thing, compared to CO2 emissions. Follow from: > once methane emissions reach a steady level
- xyzzyz 4y agoMethane in atmosphere today is at 2 ppm, carbon dioxide is at 420 ppm. If methane is 20 times more potent, this implies that atmospheric methane is equivalent to 40 extra ppm of carbon dioxide. If we removed literally all methane from the atmosphere, this would be equivalent to reducing carbon dioxide concentration to 380 ppm. This would bring us back to climate of 2005. By any reasonable measure, climate in 2023 is not significantly different than the climate in 2005 (eg. you’d hardly be able to observe any difference without making a lot of very careful measurements, you wouldn’t “feel” any difference on your own skin). And that’s if we remove literally all methane. Most of the methane in atmosphere is a result of natural processes, not caused by human activity. Thus, if we stop all methane emissions caused by human activity, we can maybe at best slow down climate change by 10 years. In terms of practical effects as felt by human beings, this is accurately described as “won’t change a thing”. Actually, to be more specific, slowing climate change by 10 years won’t make any difference, but stopping all methane emitting activities would be tremendously negative to human flourishing.
- myshpa 4y ago> climate in 2023 is not significantly different than the climate in 2005 'Devastating' melt of Greenland, Antarctic ice sheets found https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35657570 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35657570 This was here just yesterday. You may not feel it "on your own skin", but Earth does. And what exactly will happen when we'll lose all ice, we simply do not know. We just know it won't be pretty. > stopping all methane emitting activities would be tremendously negative to human flourishing How? I smell bullsh*t.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoThe issue isn't just natural gas leaking out of the distribution system. It's also the enormous methane output of the cattle industry. There are thirty million cows in the US alone. Each is producing 150 to 300lb of methane per year.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoIt is also the fact that both wetlands and melting permafrost emit methane, and both sources seem to be increasing their emissions as the world warms. This is a scary feedback loop, and that’s before we get to things like undersea clathrates.
- zackees 4y ago[dead]
- revelio 4y agoSuch dangerous feedback loops are conjectured but not actually a threat. It can be proven with historical evidence like this paper, which shows that during the Roman times it must have been much hotter than today, like somewhere between 3-7 degrees hotter, based on the discovery of bison fossils in the Alps. This is well beyond the level climatologists claim would cause runaway feedback driven global warming and mass extinction, yet that didn't happen. The historical records don't contain any reference to climate meltdowns around that time, and humanity obviously wasn't wiped out by anything. http://www.museumgolling.at/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/9_Schaer_Wisent_published.pdf http://www.museumgolling.at/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/9_Sch... These wisent remains from alpine caves are all from sites now in the subalpine to alpine zone. From this it can be concluded that the beech limit but also the forest line during the »wisent time« (6,000 to 1,200 years before today) was much higher and the average summer temperature had to be at least 3 to 6 °C higher than today Oaks (Quercus) at an altitude of 1,450 metres around 2,000 years ago also indicate a climate approximately 4 to 7 °C warmer than today There's a lot of evidence pointing in the same direction. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-67281-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-67281-2 This record comparison consistently shows the Roman as the warmest period of the last 2 kyr, about 2 °C warmer than average values for the late centuries for the Sicily and Western Mediterranean regions. Yet according to scientists, "Temperature rises over 2 degrees could bring catastrophic and potentially irreversible impacts, including pushing three billion people into chronic water scarcity." https://edition.cnn.com/2023/01/30/world/global-warming-critical-threshold-climate-intl/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2023/01/30/world/global-warming-crit...
- _the_inflator 4y ago"Compared to what" is a common theme with studies. Thanks for pointing out.
- ulrashida 4y agoHow is 20 vs. 28 vs. 40 an order of magnitude change? This phrase is usually reserved for changes in base-10 order: e.g. 2 vs 20 vs 200 are order of magnitude changes.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoI think they mean 20 is only an ~ 1order of magnitude more than 1
- hinkley 4y agoBetween methane and carbon dioxide.
- gumby 4y agoPer the IPCC’s AR5, the GWP20 (“Global Warming Potential, i.e. relative radiative forcing over 20 years) of methane is about 80X that of CO2, while the GWP100 is 26-32, or about 28X. I have a paper I’m (very slowly) working that argues that these figures may be too low. Our current model of CH4 emissions and natural destruction assume a lifetime of 9-10 years in the atmosphere. The problem is if you do some simple stoichiometry, net emissions are not enough to account for the roughly 4 Gt of excess CH4 in the atmosphere. I’m hoping my math is wrong.
- hinkley 4y agoThe calculus on this is going to be hard because methane can’t absorb photons that have already been absorbed by the atmosphere around it. It’s a bit like calculating if I’ll die of cancer. If you could protect me from everything you might be able to know that I’d die of colon cancer at 75. But here I am breathing weird dust and walking a route that starts on city streets and driving X miles a year and you just don’t know what’s gonna get me.
- gumby 4y agoThe geophysicists and others who model this are aware of these issues. The question I am investigating is an input to such calculations; I am not qualified to estimate the impact.
- himinlomax 4y agoMethane from organic sources is at a steady state since it oxidizes to CO2 over time. In effect, that means that keeping the same number overall of heads of cattle does not increase global warming dues to methane or CO2 since the methane they produce was fixed from atmospheric CO2. There may be global warming caused by CO2 emissions from cattle farming due to fossil fuel use, particularly feed production, but that's a function of the way that farming is done, not cattle itself. Grass-fed cattle on marginal land that's not otherwise suitable for other food production is not the same thing as industrial cattle farms fed from corn.
- hinkley 4y agoIt would be if we didn’t have a billion cattle on the planet and climbing. There’s a cow out there for every 7 people or so and if we make more people they’ll make more cows. Cow methane is on the order of human population, so it matters.
- himinlomax 4y agoThat's not the point. The point is, the methane is constant at number of cows constant. Unlike CO2 from oil.
- WalterBright 4y agoMethane also has a half-life in the atmosphere of 12 years, rather than centuries for CO2.
- hinkley 4y agoCO2 doesn’t have a half-life. It has to be consumed.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt does have a half-life in the atmosphere. I'm not referring to radioactive decay.