11 ms·
The U.S. cracked a $3.4B crypto heist and Bitcoin’s anonymity
- phyzome 4y agoSay it with me: "Bitcoin is not, and never was, anonymous."
- fsckboy 4y agobetter if you could go back and time and have said it early on with the early crypto enthusiasts
- berkle4455 4y agothey didn’t listen then and they don’t listen now. waste of effort.
- hailwren 4y agoI think you are projecting your beliefs onto them. Mixers, privacy chains, and ZK privacy schemes have all been implemented because everyone in crypto acknowledges the lack of privacy. The WSJ on the other hand…
- bluGill 4y agoYou are confusing the enthusiasts with the people who understand crypto. Both groups existed, but the enthusiasts group made many claims that anyone who had even minimal understanding didn't believe.
- twelve40 4y ago> Mixers, privacy chains, and ZK privacy schemes Does any of this stuff actually help bypass KYC requirements for legal offramps in developed countries?
- msm_ 4y agoSatoshi (and many other OG members of bitcointalk) knew, and tried to improve the protocol. BTC was not set in stone at the beginning. It's just at some point Satoshi disappeared, and moonfags[1] who controlled the capital (miners and exchanges) weren't interested in any technical improvements that may make regulators more angry, causing the end of most innovation in the cryptocurrency space. [1]Sorry for the very colloquial term, I don't know a better one. I mean people who care about cryptocurrencies only as a speculative "investment".
- overthrow 4y agoBitcoin chose a certain set of tradeoffs, and other coins choose differently. It has its advantages. There's no need to project such negativity onto other projects for making different design choices.
- nr2x 4y agoYeah that’s super offensive, I would avoid it altogether.
- thewildginger 4y agoJust say crypto bros. We all know someone who treats crypto like it's CrossFit. We'll get what you mean. Even a miner and exchanger is a crypto bro, even if they don't want to admit it. They're in it for the money.
- SahAssar 4y agoBut used as intended (not via a KYC exchange) it is pseudonymous, right?
- Lerc 4y agoUntil you buy something you can touch.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoAnd then all transactions up steam can get unraveled.
- noduerme 4y agoIf you trade in and out for cash, in person with a counterparty, from a self-hosted wallet that you never use to send or receive from any other wallet that's connected to an exchange... then yes. The use case for this is mainly moving money over borders.
- funstuff007 4y agoexcept that person(s) you gave and received the cash from know who you are.
- marksmith2996 4y agoonly if they're still alive
- 8note 4y agoOr if they brought their phone with them
- alex_young 4y agoIn this scenario the person transacting the bitcoin murdered their counterparty but the cellphone is still intact?
- carabiner 4y agoBitcoin is not, and never was, anonymous.
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agoIn general maybe, but if you were selling something online and received bitcoin on a wallet not associated with your irl identity you can be anonymous, its just not practical because you need to de-anonymize to get that into actual cash unless you really know what you are doing. Monero is better.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoBetter only in that it's untraceable, but unfortunately due to bad actors that makes it a dodgy or morally indefensible thing to use.
- jancsika 4y agoSo what? It's still decentralized and waits ten minutes waits ten minutes waits ten minutes waits ten minutes waits ten minutes waits ten minutes secure.
- wesapien 4y agoCan you be specific on what are you alluding to?
- pazimzadeh 4y agoI think he's talking about doing the laundry or something to clean his money. he puts in on the quick wash cycle multiple times?
- dsr_ 4y agoI took it to be a reference to slow transaction rates.
- jtsiskin 4y agoThe target block time is 10 minutes, and you need to wait multiple blocks to be confident you’re really on the longest chain
- user3939382 4y agoSomething something tornado cash?
- artdigital 4y agoTornado cash is a smart contract on ethereum Mixers on Bitcoin are usually centralized and operated by a person, so they get (and have been) cracked way more easily
- from 4y agoIt's a felony to use Tornado Cash now. And the government interprets sanctions law extraterritorially so you're not safe in other countries either.
- ETH_start 4y agoThe sanctions are being challenged in court. A federal agency prohibiting use of what is nothing but software is totally unconstitutional, and amounts to a total abrogation of internet freedom, done without any public process like legislation. It also amounts to a general criminalization of financial privacy. So hopefully the legal challenge succeeds.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- inlined 4y agoWhat part of the constitution prohibits banning software?
- ETH_start 4y agoThe First Amendment.
- acdha 4y agoThat covers you publishing software. It doesn’t cover providing a service to criminals and personally profiting from it, and the constitution definitely gives the government authority to police that so it’s going to come down to how well they can prove that those guys were going more than just releasing code.
- senectus1 4y agoI know right?!? The WHOLE PREMISE of it was that it is an OPEN LEDGER...! I'm not sure how this persistent myth of it being a way to secretly make payments got around and stuck so well... maybe the "crypto" in the name?
- acdha 4y agoI put it back to the inherent conflict of interest in such a weak fiat currency: the people who hold it must convince you to buy in to see any value from otherwise valueless tokens. Over the years you could watch the Bitcoin sales crew trying tons of marketing pitches trying to find which sold the best – accuracy didn’t matter as long as prospective buyers found it appealing.
- dist1ll 4y ago"Open" is a heavily overloaded term. One of the main premises of Bitcoin is tamperproofness and permissionless participation. That in itself does not equate to lack of anonymity. Just have a look at Zcash[0] or Monero[1]. In general, the idea that openness and anonymity are in conflict with each other has not been true for at least 40 years. There's entire field of mathematics dedicated to solving this problem known as secure multi-party computation. [0] https://z.cash/technology/ https://z.cash/technology/ [1] https://www.getmonero.org/resources/about/ https://www.getmonero.org/resources/about/
- senectus1 4y agoyeah but zcash and monero are not bitcoin. and again, your transaction and back into bitcoin are completely open and trackable by anyone.
- dist1ll 4y agoSure, but that's due to Bitcoins implementation. There's nothing inherent to "open" ledgers that prevent them from providing anonymity. My point is: dunk on Bitcoin all you want. Just don't drag the general idea of permissionless, open ledgers into this mud fight.
- olalonde 4y agoYeah like email is not anonymous.
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- _fizz_buzz_ 4y agoThat is not true. The original Satoshi paper has a whole section about it. So the intention of privacy was - at least in theory - there from the beginning.
- sfmike 4y agoIntention is ontogically nonexistant besides ideally bending the unravelling of time, does not render the idea manifested.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoAnd it is private, in that the blockchain is a ledger of IDs and transactions with no information about the people behind them. The blockchain is anonymous enough, it's just that all transactions are public (forever) and conversion to real money requires identity.
- rahen 4y agoPeople should see Bitcoin, the L1 protocol, as a public ledger. Anonymity is solved with a L2 protocol like Lightning, or an anonymous currency like Monero, although it has shortcomings that Bitcoin doesn't have.
- ziml77 4y agoThe idea of using Bitcoin or Ethereum to pay for anything always seemed insane to me. I don't want my info about payments I've made to be public, espcially not in a form where, by design, it will never disappear!
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI mean bank and CC transactions are remembered, but due to them being privacy-sensitive information, this is tightly secured and (depending on where you are and probably a load of other factors), deleted after a mandatory retaining period.
- lostmsu 4y agoTell it to the coffee shops you visit for the first time that send you an email receipt.
- Anon84 4y agohttps://archive.is/U7dSU https://archive.is/U7dSU
- RadixDLT 4y agodoes wsj think anybody is going to read their articles if they block people from reading
- boeingUH60 4y agoWell, it costs money to produce well-researched pieces like this, and they have nearly 3 million paying digital subscribers [1]. 1- https://www.adweek.com/media/the-wall-street-journal-grew-digital-subscriptions/ https://www.adweek.com/media/the-wall-street-journal-grew-di...
- j45 4y agoEven though I might not agree with it, paywalls are around for this long for a reason.
- theturtletalks 4y agoGo to Archive.to, paste in any paywalled article, use reader mode on mobile and you can read it. As long as these websites keep pushing the content to the client (for SEO of course), it’s fine for us to take it. If they truly want to be paywalled, DRM that text and stop reaping the benefits of Google search.
- paulpauper 4y agoZhong was caught because he made basic operational security errors, like address reuse (which is how he was caught by linking fraud wallet to exchange wallet) , static IP, using a KYC exchange in 2017 to convert BCH into BTC, etc. Not because Bitcoin was cracked. After being caught, Zhong voluntarily relinquished his passwords to encrypted wallets and other bitcoin, not that the crypto was cracked. I wonder how the feds bypassed the statute of limitations on this. He was not identified until almost a decade after the theft. I am guessing his attempts at laundering the money and spending, reset the clock.
- Scoundreller 4y agoIf he just hodled like everyone said to, he’d be free!
- labster 4y agoFeds can’t take crypto from your grasp if you have diamond hands.
- iudqnolq 4y agoVery broadly speaking if you're hiding and law enforcement is actively looking for you the statute of limitations pauses, because the delay is morally your fault. (And actively looking has a generous definition) That could be what happened here.
- drsnow 4y agoHow are you/authorities defining hiding? Is it hiding if he wasn't trying to evade anything and LE were just too slow in identifying him?
- pas 4y ago18 USC 3290 ("No statute of limitations shall extend to any person fleeing from justice") but it not clear, see this thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35548508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35548508 that's where case law comes in, probably there's some test for it made up by a few judges (like was there an active warrant, or named as person of interest in an active case, etc..)
- psd1 4y ago[flagged]
- Cardinal7167 4y agoThe internet never forgets
- bdcravens 4y agoMore like "WAS short for". Yes, Mark Karpales bought it from the original owner, and like PHP and GEICO, things have a way of moving away from their original meaning. The original Bitcoin client also contained the beginnings of an online poker game, though that was quickly removed.
- atdrummond 4y agoThe US invested so much effort into this because they were worried that their own agents were involved with the theft. This was all part of their effort to clean up the massive corruption post-Silk Road seizure.
- nwah1 4y agoOn what basis do you make this statement?
- kenbaylor 4y agoLikely on this basis: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35038971.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35038971.amp
- cma 4y agoNon-amp link https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35038971 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35038971
- nwah1 4y agoSo, one agent was caught and convicted of theft, on an unrelated matter, and this is evidence of corruption? Wouldn't that, in fact, be evidence of a system that is successfully punishing corruption? And since the transaction history is traceable, you cannot posit mysterious other transactions that are unaccounted for. Those would be quickly revealed.
- msm_ 4y agoInteresting twitter thread about the corruption in the Silk Road case: https://twitter.com/tayvano_/status/1641927617216655360 https://twitter.com/tayvano_/status/1641927617216655360 > Wouldn't that, in fact, be evidence of a system that is successfully punishing corruption? I think that's the OP's point? The system (successfully) invested a lot of effort tot punish the corruption.
- ricochet11 4y ago
- frank_bb 4y ago[dead]
- ucha 4y agoThe statute of limitation for wire fraud is 5 years. How did he get charged under that statute when he stole funds from Silk Road in 2012? Did they charge him for converting BCH into BTC in 2017? I tried to look up the case but couldn't find anything that shed a light on that.
- epgui 4y agoProbably because of discoverability or something like that?
- Waterluvian 4y agoI’ve wondered about how crimes can seemingly be an instantaneous event with no duration, or can be ongoing for a while. Crime as an event. Crime as a state. ;) Is it perhaps that by continuing to act on the proceeds from crime, the individual(s) are prolonging or tacking on additional crimes?
- aaronmdjones 4y ago> The statute of limitation for wire fraud is 5 years. How did he get charged under that statute when he stole funds from Silk Road in 2012? This is a very simplistic view and this mistake is made a lot. There are several reasons why the statute of limitations could either be longer than 5 years or not yet expired even though it is 5 years: - Tolling. This is when the suspect exits your jurisdiction, preventing you from apprehending them. If the statute of limitations really is 5 years, and you leave the country 4 years after the act; even if you stay abroad for a year, or 5 years, or 20 years, the clock only resumes when you return. You can still be charged 24 years after committing the offense. - Furtherance. Put simply, if you continue to engage in the activity, the statute of limitations is reset. For example, this article describes his repeated moving of the assets after the initial theft in order to avoid detection. - Special Circumstances. In this case, there are exceptions that mean that the statute of limitations is not actually 5 years. It's not clear which of these apply. I would definitely bet on option #2. If he spent any time outside of the country, also apply option #1. If any of the special circumstances defined in the law apply, also apply option #3.
- 4y ago
- mikevm 4y ago> But by the time he was in college, he converted some of his digital wealth into $700,000 in cash. He wanted to have a “case full of money like in the movies,” Mr. Zhong said, according to a psychological assessment filed with the court. “He hoped the visual appeal of the cash would impress a female into having sexual relations with him. He stated his plan did not work.” Hilarious.
- overthrow 4y agoYep, nobody cares if you have money unless you spend it.
- msm_ 4y agoI know this battle is already lost, but https://www.cryptoisnotcryptocurrency.com/ https://www.cryptoisnotcryptocurrency.com/
- cvoss 4y agoIn some of the supplementary documentation for this press release, you can see the government's case for seizing Zhang's assets on the grounds that they are traceable to a different convicted criminal (Ulbricht, who is the victim of Zhang's fraud), whose assets were already forfeited due to Ulbricht's conviction. I'm curious though, if Zhang had not plead guilty and the government had not succeeded in getting a wire fraud conviction for Zhang, would their argument that the assets are forfeitable under Ulbricht's conviction have failed also? In other words, was it necessary to convict Zhang to finish seizing Ulbricht's assets, or could they have won a case for seizure without a conviction for Zhang?
- msantama 4y agoWhat is the crime he committed, exactly? Wasn't he simply using a "feature" of Silk Road, ie. if you double-click "withdraw" it prints you money?
- rippercushions 4y agoIf you have $5000 in a bank account, and a bug in the bank UI lets you withdraw $10000, the bank can and will come after you to get their money back. And if you intentionally exploit this bug to create 100 accounts with $5000 and withdraw a million, you've definitely committed a crime.
- jen729w 4y agoI once had money deposited in to my account, repeatedly, that wasn't mine. It was a pain in the ass. I didn't want it. I asked my gf's dad, a lawyer, if I could spend it. He said no: it's like someone parking their car on your driveway. It's annoying, sure. But it doesn't make it your car.
- notch898b 4y ago[dead]
- Gigachad 4y agoJust keep stacking it in a savings account and collect the interest. If you wanted to take some risk you could also invest some of it in index funds.
- nobody9999 4y ago>Just keep stacking it in a savings account and collect the interest. If you wanted to take some risk you could also invest some of it in index funds. A friend of mine is addressing a similar situation right now. After her mother passed away (nearly 20 years ago) and left no will, her primary bank account was still active and the Social Security Administration[0] kept sending her checks every month. She was notified a few weeks ago of the existence of this account (which now has several hundred thousand dollars in it). Since Social Security benefits (except in specific circumstances[1]) are not collectible by surviving relatives, the moneys paid into that account since her mother's death are not hers (she and her siblings are the only surviving next-of-kin). Rather those funds are the property of the US Government. In such a circumstance, the funds deposited, as well as any interest on those funds belong to the government. Transferring those funds or spending any of the interest is a crime. As such, if you find yourself in a similar situation, I'd think twice before doing something like that. [0] https://www.ssa.gov/ https://www.ssa.gov/ [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/16/heres-what-happens-to-social-security-payments-when-you-die.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/16/heres-what-happens-to-social...
- rldjbpin 4y agoanother reminder that a motivated third party can thwart all the measures towards digital anonymity. can't wait for a similar case but with xmr "cracked" using quantum computers.
- timbit42 4y agothat problem can be solved and they are working on fixing it.
- imtringued 4y agoWhy does someone who produced nothing get to be a billionaire? I mean this is a clear case of deflation rewarding corruption. If the money goes up in value, steal it from someone to get it as early as possible.
- thunkshift1 4y agoWhats the big deal here? Aren’t all btc transaction public record??
- cko 4y ago> federal agents surprised Mr. Zhong with a search warrant and found the digital keys to his crypto fortune hidden in a basement floor safe and a popcorn tin in the bathroom How? Do they rip everything apart?