20 ms·
EY gets banned from new audit business in Germany
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- morsch 4y ago(for two years)
- jll29 4y agoIf a CEO mismanages and goes bankrupt, they cannot start another company for 5 years; a two-year ban seems mild, but better than nothing, as the reputational damage is substantial (why would any non-criminal pick EY afterwards in good faith if there are others?).
- helsinkiandrew 4y agoAs well as a €500K fine, five employees were also fined between €23,000 and €300,000. And seven others escaped punishment by handing back their auditor’s licences. I’m not sure many reputable public companies will be queuing up to use their services in 2 years time
- hef19898 4y agoIf a certified and liscenced auditor in Germany returns his liscence, well, that person just ended their professional career. So the alternativr seems to have been considerable worse. Rightly so, Wirecard was a fuck up of epic proportions.
- ck45 4y agoIt would be an interesting idea to make auditors fully accountable like bankruptcy advisors. I know, this is never going to happen.
- angus-prune 4y agoThe current problem is that the insentives are all wrong. It is the company being audited that gives the auditers the business. Its not in the interests of a dodgy company to appoint a good auditor, and its not actually in the auditors (short term) interest to uncover wrongdoing as it just means they'd lose a client. My proposal is that you require every company to have insurance to cover the risks, making the insurers fully liable for fraud (and any other business risk that audits protect against). Companies then don't appoint their own auditors, but the insurers do. Its in the insurers interest to make sure that any audit is effective as they're on the hook for any liability the audit misses. This way the insentives for the auditors are aligned with the interests of the people relying on the audit (shareholders, customers, suppliers).
- bradleyjg 4y agoThere was something like this with bonds pre 2008 but it didn’t work out like you suggest. Rating agencies were, and are, paid by bond issuers are rated a bunch of synthetic real estate backed bonds as very safe. But then on top of that, certain of these bonds were insured—-notably by AIG. However, AIG just rubber stamped the ratings and ended up going bankrupt when the crisis hit. The real mismatch of incentives is one layer deeper than your comment suggests. An insurance company CEO can do very well for himself underpricing insurance. The business grows as premiums roll in and he collects a bunch of bonuses. When the SHTF he could just resign and collect his golden parachute.
- mjevans 4y agoWho audits the auditors? The insurance company also needs it's risks assessed independently.
- bostik 4y agoThe Maltese gambling regulator did something like this back in 2016. While the idea is good (and I support the practice in principle), it was a dismal failure in aggregate. Devil's in the details. The regulator pre-negotiated approved rates and vetted a bunch of companies, all of which had to had presence in Malta. The audit reports have to be turned by mid-June, IIRC, and they can't really start until the accounts for the previous year have been finalised. So in practice the audits must take place between late February and mid-May. At the time the entire nation of Malta had about 450k people in total, and each audit blocks two accredited people for approximately three weeks. Turns out there are a lot of gambling companies registered in Malta, and each pair of auditors could only process 5-6 companies within the allotted time. The country would have run out of auditors ... so they licensed a whole lot of local smaller shops as accredited gambling auditors to make up the numbers. Many of whom did not have the technical knowledge to actually even assess, let alone understand the businesses they were assigned to. And I can say this from painful experience: there is real value having the same team of auditors for 2-3 years running. They will get to know how your company operates, and any good ones will figure out entirely new questions to ask you from year to year. By all means, be an adversarial assessor, but at least please be clued in. Disclosure: on the receiving end as a key person in technical audits since 2015.
- shortrounddev 4y agoReally? 5 years? That seems really harsh. Is it all business failures or does it have to be due to mismanagement? I've heard the climate is very hostile to businesses in Germany; my sister in law was trying to sell art on etsy and apparently she had to get a business license to do so in Germany. She's now back in the USA where she can just sell stuff online and the only thing she needs to do is file her taxes correctly
- charlieyu1 4y agoYou know, all regulations only hurt small sellers, people at the “top” always get away from all the crap they are directly responsible for, no matter they are hurting their own business or the society as a whole
- Timon3 4y agoIt's the wrong take-away to say all regulations only hurt small sellers. Do you want to give up regulations on child labor, or worker safety, or foods and drugs? If not, how come, considering it all hurts only small sellers? The problem isn't the concept of regulation, but the follow-through on loopholes. By doing away with regulations you'll decrease quality of life for most people. Instead we have to find ways to react to loopholes in a fair way. It's not impossible, we've done it before, see the previously-mentioned examples!
- charlieyu1 4y agoI don't think small sellers have anything to do with child labour. And since you mentioned loopholes, it is always the big players who get away with loopholes that small business owners do not
- akiselev 4y agoSmall sellers aren’t worth even going after until they reach a certain size for huge swaths of the regulatory regime. See, for example, UL/CE and FCC regulations - unless they burn something down or interfere with emergency services, businesses can usually defer the regulatory cost till they can afford it. Or the FAA, which gives out slaps on the wrist like its going out of style, as long as the offender is not an airline. Case in point: many countries allows underage family members to work for family businesses and even the ones that don’t, barely enforce it. A factory hiring dozens of kids? That’s a lot less likely to go unnoticed.
- brookst 4y agoSo as a super talented CEO, would you take any jobs trying to save a failing company?
- helsinkiandrew 4y agohttps://archive.is/RiaMV https://archive.is/RiaMV
- docheinestages 4y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 4y agoIf you don't have a reason to link a thread to ChatGPT maybe don't make them up?
- ck45 4y agoThe wirecard scandal on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirecard_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirecard_scandal
- wjnc 4y agoLook, these sentences are probably more than just and even on the light sight. Handing in your auditing license is a pretty severe punishment, at least career changing. But will the risk and audit professionals at BaFin face the same penalties?
- everybodyknows 4y agoIf they do, they'll be tempted to rat out the political overlords who dictated the "see no evil, hear no evil" policy.
- BonoboIO 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- BonoboIO 4y agoI acknowledge that my comments in the last time where short and bold/flamebaiting, because i was on my phone. I will be explaining my views more thoroughly.
- dang 4y agoAppreciated! If you explain them more thoroughly while sticking to the site guidelines (e.g. curious, respectful conversation, without swipes or snark), all should be fine.
- lima 4y agoThe head of BaFin and their deputy were forced out over it and the agency is undergoing significant restructuring[1], and a new agency was formed specifically for investigating financial crimes[2]. In terms of actual liability - no, at least not yet. A number of lawsuits by individual investors were thrown out[3] but it's possible there will be public prosecution: > Criminal prosecutors in Frankfurt are assessing whether BaFin employees obstructed justice by not properly investigating fraud warnings. In the end, it's a regulator, they have to rely on auditors to some point. If Wirecard lies and EY doesn't catch it, that's on the criminal and the auditor. Still, it's hard to understate just how badly the agency fucked this one up... Hopefully, it'll serve as a true wake-up call. Certainly seems like it - they have been more aggressive recently with other problem companies like N26, Solaris Bank, Coinbase, Deutsche and others. [1]: https://www.ft.com/content/4f948457-678e-485c-92f7-2837064a5010 https://www.ft.com/content/4f948457-678e-485c-92f7-2837064a5... [2]: https://www.ft.com/content/587b6c52-c93e-4b2c-949a-53f6a166719d https://www.ft.com/content/587b6c52-c93e-4b2c-949a-53f6a1667... [3]: https://www.ft.com/content/9fab6842-4ee6-4114-a35c-09bf9c62a94a https://www.ft.com/content/9fab6842-4ee6-4114-a35c-09bf9c62a...
- rvba 4y agoAudits in general are such a joke. Rubber stamping and checks done by students or graduates who barely understand what they are doing. And even if they detect something, it is considered as not material and ignored. From business perspective the auditors are clueless. I dont claim that audits are bad, they are very needed. But the execution in many ways is so poor.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoAll audits should be disclosed in giant black letter on the front “PAID FOR BY THE AUDITED COMPANY” The conflict of interest in external audit is absurd. It’s similar to securities rated rating agencies paid to rate the instruments by the issuing company.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoThe audited company often buys consulting services from the auditors which in effect is an extra incentive on top of the moneys paid for the auditing service. The mechanism that allows this is the ‘Chinese wall’ but that is a total joke. What really need to happen is to separate out consulting from auditing. That’s not going to happen though as there is just so much money is consulting.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoWhat should happen is audit becomes a public trust financed by a tax on all public companies.
- heisenbit 4y agoWhich in turn creates the issue of how to keep this trust truly independent. There have been successful long term campaigns to wrest control of supposedly independent bodies and align them with special interest groups.
- fnordpiglet 4y ago
- hestefisk 4y agoWill be interesting to see if Everest moves ahead after this.
- Havoc 4y agoHeadline seems a little overdramatic. >listed >new >in Germany >two years ...that's gonna be like one or two clients max. Very bad PR but complete non-issue from a biz pov
- _the_inflator 4y agoHonorable mention here for Arthur Andersen and their role in the Enron audit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Andersen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Andersen
- crazygringo 4y ago> Auditors insist that their services cannot be treated as a guarantee that accounts are truthful, and note that sophisticated frauds are by their nature difficult to spot. As someone who knows nothing about this area, I don't understand why audits won't always detect fraud. I would naively assume that auditors have access to all financial accounts and records of cash flows and they make sure they all add up and are categorized correctly. And that if fraud is happening, there will necessarily be numbers that don't add up. So what am I missing? Do they not have access to all accounts and statements? Is it just a top-level glance at the numbers because there isn't enough time/money to scrutinize everything? Or can the numbers all add up but there's still fraud? Is there anyone here who can give an example of something fraudulent that is hard to catch?
- ejb999 4y ago>>Is there anyone here who can give an example of something fraudulent that is hard to catch? Someone in control of the checkbook at a medical facility who starts a shell company with some innocuous sounding name (i.e. Smith's Medical Supply) and and regularly submits bills in low enough amounts that they don't raise concerns - which of course is relative to the size of the company - but say you run a practice that has $50M in annual revenues, it would be quite easy to send in bills for supplies that only amount to 1-2K per invoice over a long period of time. This kind of thing happens a lot, and without actually contacting every single vendor, verifying they are real, and verifying every thing that was purchased, can be very difficult to root out - especially with supplies that get used up, as opposed to hard assets they are supposed to be around for a while. When the numbers are small enough, nobody even bothers to verify them - even though over years they can add up to a significant amount of losses. I hear about stories like this all the time - it is pretty common.
- jsmith99 4y agoThat would hopefully be caught by internal controls and internal audit but would be of relatively little interest to an external auditor like EY. The figures are small enough to be immaterial, meaning they don't significantly affect the accounts. The external auditors would be more likely to scrutinise big contracts and related party transactions involving senior management.
- sega_sai 4y agoAnd then there is also this https://www.ft.com/content/5e6f15ce-9eda-4b04-883d-686617020a0b https://www.ft.com/content/5e6f15ce-9eda-4b04-883d-686617020... -- cheating on ethics exams by EY. It's all very funny that the whole system is built on assumption where the supposedly knowledgeable, ethical experts audit companies, but in reality, it nowhere close to that.
- catchnear4321 4y agoif only this were limited to ethics and compliance. expertise is a virtue in modern society. signaling it well is often easier and more successful than developing and maintaining it. damn lucrative, too. this is why we can’t have nice things.
- version_five 4y ago"Cheating on ethics exam" sounds bad but it amounts to not taking some boring corporate CYA compliance training seriously, it's not actually unethical in my opinion. If anything it speaks to how bad corporate training is generally, not the ethics of the people "cheating".
- appleiigs 4y agoProbably similar to you, I couldn't read the FT article because it's behind a paywall; however, I'm familiar with the general story. It's not some corporate training. They, plus many other accounting firms, cheated on professional licensing exams. Egregious because the accounting firms are doing the opposite of their sole purpose - add trust to the financial system.
- EarthIsHome 4y agoThis is still fallout from the wirecard debacle.
- Giorgi 4y agoNo worries, ChatGPT will eleminate ALL audit business in year or two anyways.
- TheRealPomax 4y ago"The accounting-and-consulting giant is being sued for $2.7bn by the administrators of NMC, a London-listed hospital operator it had audited and which went into administration after understating debts by $4bn." would be cool if the article could say why. I hear that's something good journalists do.
- mkl95 4y agoI wonder how many bn the EU economy would save every year if Big Four companies were banned everywhere.
- sealeck 4y agoThat's part of the issue. Another big part is that we should put a whole load more money into investigating financial crime (so funding white collar crime investigatory units as well as tax authorities).
- Aeolun 4y agoTBH, I don’t understand why anyone would be naive enough to hire EY and then actually trust them.
- smugma 4y agoAs a publicly traded company, you have to hire auditors. If you don’t like EY you can go to PwC, KPMG or Deloitte, but what’s the difference?
- allendoerfer 4y agoThe others might be bad, but they are not Enron (EY Germany = former Arthur Andersen Germany) and Wirecard bad.
- Aperocky 4y agothe incentives are misaligned. Publicly traded company should pay a small fee to SEC each year and they be responsible to hire auditors, for everyone. Or even better, market bid for auditors with incentives for finding irregularities. With the current line up of incentives, auditors merely ensures any fraud are slightly better hidden.
- hef19898 4y agoSOX is such a well thought of law. It requires any public company listed in thr US to have one auditing company and one "consulting" company supporting the set up internal controls and processes, prepare the books and so on. Those comoanies have to br changed every couple of years (if memory serves well every four years), and you cannot simply switch roles and stay with the same two. Hence a market demand for the big four: A prepares the books, B audits them. Then C replaces A and D replaces B. Read up on regulations, it helps!
- Aperocky 4y ago> SOX is such a well thought of law. Is it? The incentives are not going to be aligned so far as the auditing companies are hired by the company being audited. It doesn't matter how many auditing company there is and the division of labor within. Think of lobbyists, there are many different flavor of lobbyists, some might even be against the others. They distribute events, campaign finances and other things to legislators and as we know recently even certain members of judiciary. A bad idea in general in terms of the incentives at play.
- wouldbecouldbe 4y agoEY, Mckinsey, Accenture, BCG all of them should be banned. They were the big proponent of the the just in time management principles in the hospitals in the Netherlands. Then when covid came they were the first the market on twitter & linkedin for advice how to improve your health inventory & deal with covid challenges. Serious impact with zero skin in the game. These consultants are parasites. They are mainly used as proxies to make decisions managers dont want to be responsible for.
- Cantinflas 4y agoAgree about the proxy part for the consultancy business, it should be common knowledge and those manager should be fired
- version_five 4y agoThis article is about auditing, your comments appear to be about consulting / advisory businesses. Otherwise, I mostly agree, though I don't support a ban. It's a complex topic - companies are free to waste money how they want, and even governments do need real advice. It's just too bad they pick such shitty advisors to support decisions they've already made instead of actually seeking good advice.
- oxfordmale 4y agoYes, companies should be free to waste their money as they want. However, auditors serve a purpose and that is to identify any fraudulent activities. In the case of Wirecard, EY failed at this.
- theK 4y agoCorrect and that is why they should be made accountable for this. I'm with gp that this particular ban is a bit harsh but nonetheless it is the state determining accountabilities and it seems to have been a thorough investigation. OTOH, the monetary penalties where a bit on the light side so maybe that also balances out the rather harsh ban.
- 4y ago
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- odiroot 4y agoNow do McKinsey. Probably would work out even better.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0xDEF 4y agoWhen GDPR was introduced I was hoping it was technical people who would audit software for GDPR compliance. Instead it is lawyers and accountants working for these big auditing companies. GDPR is good but the absolute insanity of how GDPR is being applied cannot be understated.
- SilverBirch 4y agoI don't know if I have just enough knowledge to be dangerous, but it seems to me that auditors don't really do what people think they do. Auditors seem mainly to just double check the numbers they're handed. This serves a purpose, it provides some level of guarantee that companies that are acting in good faith are generally reporting correct numbers. Auditors don't do what people seem to think they should do - investigate and uncover fraud. If a company wants to commit fraud, the auditors simply aren't resourced in a way that would allow them to uncover it because there's not really that much incentive to uncover the fraud, the fraudster is extremely motivated, and if you wanted that level of hostile investigative work it would be much more expensive for every company. Also, from a dynamics perspective, this is a lot like the insurance industry. In the insurance industry you can underestimate risk during the good times, take profits, and then go bankrupt in the bad times. In auditing you can spend a lot of money being extremely thorough - you'll lose all your customers because you're expensive and painful. So instead you lower your standards, you're cheap, you're easy to work with, and it's easy for a fraudster to slip through, in the 1 in a 1000 chance that happens the regulator comes down on you like a tonne of bricks. Well ok, but was EY less competent than McKinsey or did they just get unlucky that they're the poor bastards who stepped on the landmine? Well, maybe in this case we should learn from the insurance industry and institute some sort of fund that all auditors pay into that pays out in the case that fraud is discovered.
- krn 4y ago> Well ok, but was EY less competent than McKinsey or did they just get unlucky that they're the poor bastards who stepped on the landmine? I have asked myself the same question, before I noticed that EY is basically the Credit Suisse and the SoftBank of the audit world[1]: > EY has been involved in many accounting scandals: Bank of Credit and Commerce International (1991), Informix Corporation (1996), Sybase (1997), Cendant (1998), One.Tel (2001), AOL (2002), HealthSouth Corporation (2003), Chiquita Brands International (2004), Lehman Brothers (2010), Sino-Forest Corporation (2011), Olympus Corporation (2011), Stagecoach Group (2017), Wirecard (2020), Luckin Coffee (2020) and NMC Health (2020). In fact, Wirecard managed to partner with EY, Credit Suisse, and SoftBank simultaneously just before going bankrupt. Maybe because no reputable companies wanted to touch it? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernst_%26_Young#Accounting_scandals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernst_%26_Young#Accounting_sca...
- 23B1 4y agoI worked at Accenture as an MD for several years, primarily on innovation and transformation programs. I have plenty to say about them, but I think the key driving factor for all of the grift and awful performance has a lot to do with how they operate, which is to sell in a big program, then pull a switcheroo and try and pack a project with as many low-paid MBAs as possible – kids straight out of college tasked with a (thin slice) of a major strategic program, or find some sub to farm it out to at a really low price. Since going out on my own as a consultant – focused on the same sort of growth programs, as opposed to audit – I generally find that I can achieve the same outcomes for a client with a handful of people on a a reasonable budget. I left primarily because it's just bonkers how much pork these big consultancies manage to get away with packing on, to the point where it was a major reputation risk to me. I'd encourage any CXOs out there seeking to outsource major strategic initiatives to consider hiring individuals or smaller entrepreneurs with experience inside the bigs, but without the downward pressure to get as many butts in seats as possible.
- chinabot 4y agoLets face it, the answer from chatGPT would be almost identical to what these consultants say, however the main reason for consultants is to CYA so if the decision is bad, you can blame someone else.
- number6 4y agoChatGPT is not that old. So someone had to do the writing
- sizzle 4y agoTheir consultants are probably utilizing ChatGPT now to 10x their buzzword bingo outputs
- 23B1 4y agoI won't deny that I've been using it as a research assistant to investigate a lot market forces and conditions, but as always I have to support it with quality data and citations if it's gonna play in the board room and with savvy institutional investors.
- expertentipp 4y agoStill beter than one-off few million EUR fine... billion worth of fraud here, billion worth of fraud there, and pretty soon we'll be talking about real consequences.
- lakomen 4y ago[flagged]
- pwpw 4y agoAs a CPA and now software engineer, I'm observing quite a bit of confidently incorrect or misguided takes in here. For starters, people are comparing EY to McKinsey and other consultancy firms, but this article is discussing EY's auditing practice, which begs for comparison to the other members of the Big 4: PwC, Deloitte, and KPMG. I do think the incentives are entirely wrong for auditing. Auditors should be paid for by shareholders. Even if it decreases your dividends, you _want_ to pay for an auditor to provide reasonable assurance that there is no funny business going on with your money. In fact, that's how auditing began. The current system provides for conflicts of interest where partners are incentivized to please the board of directors that hire them and pay them large sums of money. However, this doesn't lead straight to all auditors covering up fraud, and I feel that many people in these comments are overly critical. Having skepticism of the process is great (and auditors emphasize professional skepticism themselves), but I don't think we should throw the baby out with the bathwater as the current system does still provide a lot value. I also think many people here believe auditors at Big 4 firms are forensic accountants, which they are not. In the US, the FBI employs the forensic auditors many here may be thinking of. The auditors that EY employs are there to provide an audit opinion that expresses reasonable assurance that the financial statements are fairly presented. It's a very tough job that cannot be performed perfectly in its current form yet works remarkably well, all things considered. Finally, EY is a very large company that's really made up of many individual pieces that share a larger name but are structurally different, particularly between regions such as the US and Europe. EY in Germany certainly deserves the negativity they're receiving here, but that shouldn't necessarily be applied to all employees of EY all over the world. It's an accounting firm made up of thousands partners who are CPAs (in the US at least). The exciting thing is that given the nature of accountancy, the industry is extremely conservative and open to disruption. However, that disruption has to adhere to numerous rules and regulations that would probably frustrate many entrepreneurs here. Most auditors are working with Excel and PDFs and do mindless work at the lower levels. A lot of this is getting off-shored, which is lessening the quality of the work. If a new technology was able to be designed that could overcome the shortcomings of humans manually using Excel and PDF markup tools while providing a higher quality of work than the off-shore work many in the industry are using, there would be a great opportunity to replace jobs at the lower level - boy I don't like saying that out loud. Hopefully it would allow for new employees to focus more on judgement based decisions using their expertise gained from obtaining the difficult to attain CPA license. They say that every year at a Big 4 accounting firm is equal to two years in industry, and I certainly believe that. Based on my experience, I strongly believe that licensed CPAs that come from auditing firms know far more about the ins and outs of businesses than the MBAs at consulting firms like McKinsey that many here seem to be conflating them with. Perhaps I should join an accounting software company. It can be easy to forgot how much expertise I have as a CPA when I was surrounded by them in my previous career. Yet I have found that the software companies I have reached out to undervalue my CPA and overemphasize leetcode skills, which is truly a shame. If anyone is interested in a decent software engineer with a CPA to add, I'm open to talking!
- amai 4y agoThis is capitalism failing again because of an unchallenged oligopoly/monopoly. The obvious solution would be to break the oligopoly down. Instead we see mild punishments like this. This will not change anything.