8 ms·
> that means that many companies can potentially produce 10 times as many products/services and make more things that will enrich peoples' lives. This has been
by pavel_lishin 4y ago
> that means that many companies can potentially produce 10 times as many products/services and make more things that will enrich peoples' lives.
This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure?
> Though some people in some companies might be laid off, it doesn't necessarily mean that more people will be laid off than new jobs are created.
It doesn't mean the opposite, either.
> 2) Chaudry ignores that you need a human in the loop to check an AI's work. You don't know that an AI's answer is always right. Even if it's perfect in 99% of cases, the answer could be jaw-droppingly destructive in that 1% of cases and make errors that even the dumbest human wouldn't make. Being grossly wrong even a small percentage of the time is far worse than a human making minor errors sometimes, and being slow all of the time.
Companies have shown time and time again that they're willing to make this trade-off.
- transcoderx 4y agoHow much do you think you would have had to pay for an iPhone 200 years ago? Are you sure society hasn't benefitted from productivity increases?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chii 4y agoPeople who claim that modern industrial tech and advancements have not benefited society is arguing that they are not being disproportionately benefited. Industrial automation did create the 2hr weeks - only that it's the people who paid capital and and invested in their creation that got those 2hr weeks. But everybody else got the benefit as the general access and availability of many more goods and services than otherwise would've been possible.
- AndrewKemendo 4y ago>many more goods and services than otherwise would've been possible Why is More stuff =/= a better life not blatantly obvious at this point Having an iPhone doesn't make your life better
- throwaway173738 4y agoYeah it’s like saying that if only we all had 800 hammers we’d all live like kings. Technology does not automatically make life better, only different. Better is a value judgement.
- transcoderx 4y agoIf you have cancer and a doctor can cure it, it is not just a value judgement.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHere are some of the ways in which a smartphone + mobile broadband has made my life better: Having a communications device that lets me contact whoever I want, whenever I want, and share media immediately. A mapping solution to ensure I am never lost. Access to the world’s largest repository of information so I can look up information or how to do something at a moment’s notice. Reminder system to help me keep track of tasks. Access to whichever books/music/videos/games I want at anytime in any place. Ability to manage money and pay (An additional way at least, without the need to carry cards). Health tracking and alert benefits of a watch paired with a phone. Ability to take high quality photos and videos at anytime.
- weatherlite 4y agoI'm not denying any of these improvements but there is also evidence that walking with this constant distraction and being bombarded by social media / news is bad for mental health and our ability to focus.
- chii 4y ago
- phpisthebest 4y agoThat depends on you believe society has actually benefited (on the whole) from iPhone, internet, social media etc Which is a different question from productivity
- vc8f6vVV 4y agoIt depends largely on your definition of "benefit".
- croes 4y agoAnd the cost of making China powerful, how this turns out has yet to come
- ihatepython 4y ago> How much do you think you would have had to pay for an iPhone 200 years ago? Are you sure society hasn't benefitted from productivity increases? The world would be a much better place without the iPhone[1]. [1] with the exception of all iPhones running iOS 6 or earlier
- transcoderx 4y agoIf you don't want any of the modern amenities, you may be able to get by on a 2 hour work week.
- birdyrooster 4y agoPeople are ditching their phones which to me proves their value isn't universal and probably isn't that great of a benefit to anyone other than business.
- luckylion 4y ago> Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? It's here, you're living in it, most likely. You just have to lower your wants to the standards of whenever that prediction was made.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoNot possible because you don't set the prices or structure for obtaining goods and shelter It's not like there's unclaimed habitable territory that anyone can just go be subsistence farmers on - someone has laid claim to that land and it's not you So, no this isn't an option either as you're forced to interact with the rest of the world that demands your input
- luckylion 4y agoA few hundred years ago, you would've lived in a shed with 6 people on 10sqm. I'm sure you can get that kind of accommodation today for very little money. If you want 2023-level housing, you'll need to put in 2023-level work, unfortunately.
- OvidNaso 4y agoBut that's not true fir the class that extracted the majority of productivity gains. Why doesn't this apply to them!
- luckylion 4y agoIt's true for them, too. A rich guy's life in 1800 sucks compared to the average person's life in 2023. There's a reason why there's no rush to emulate the Amish, and they're not even that extreme.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoNo, it's some intentional decision of a suburban family in Kansas to not go be Amish. That's not how societies work. And no, life is worse for millions of people around the world than it was in 1800 if for not other reason This idea that things MUST be better just isn't supported with data. All the "data" about how great the world is is bad statistics - it's looking at averages only, not the distribution. You can't point to the richest areas and claim "look see how great things are?" Find the most destitute among us and see how they fare
- satvikpendem 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. You are working the same number of hours as before (40 ish) because companies are producing 10x as much goods in the same amount of time. If they produced only the same amount, ie 1x, you'd have your 2 hour work day (or more likely be out of a job). It is because companies are producing more stuff that you have a job at all currently. You are complaining about the very thing you benefit from now.
- nemothekid 4y ago>You are complaining about the very thing you benefit from now. It's dubious that anyone except the most wealthy benefits from this. Even though productivity has exploded, wages hasn't followed and the rewards of productivity has gone to a small few. I don't know how anyone can look at wealth inequality today and think most people should be "grateful". It's more likely to me that rest of America will start to look like San Francisco.
- brookst 4y agoYou really don’t think you live with any of the benefits from productivity gains? You don’t have a smartphone, don’t use wireless networking and telecom, have no flat screen TV, don’t use the internet, and so on? None of those things would exist if productivity was at the same level as the 1800’s.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoAll you’re saying (by implication), besides not discussing numbers (which can show widening gap), is that you believe capital and state are necessary and exclusively capable of a productive and innovative society, that populations are otherwise inherently lazy or impossibly conflicted. I don’t think modern anthro research agrees with this. Catch up on Graeber & Wengrow
- satvikpendem 4y ago> you believe capital and state are necessary and exclusively capable of a productive and innovative society, that populations are otherwise inherently lazy or impossibly conflicted. Where did the parent say anything like this at all? I believe you're attacking a strawman.
- wruza 4y agoThis promise had to be fulfilled by those whose salary depends on not doing it (us). Do you really believe that automation is at its peak availability now? I think we diverge from it more and more. Even as a programmer you meet a bunch of barriers to automate yourself or your home, office, etc. Every little thing is complex af. The society that automates everything is coming, I hope, bypassing the heap of nonsense we’ve built.
- felipemnoa 4y ago>>This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? << I personally would hate to spend all my time on leisure activities. I would still be working as hard but on my passion projects. No offense but who wants to spend most of their time on leisure activities. That gets old fast. It is a lot more fun being productive. Maybe I'm just weird. A person on minimum wage in the USA today can enjoy a higher quality of life than kings of a few hundred years ago. My point being that automation has brought huge benefits to society, even if we are blind to them.
- whiddershins 4y agoI second this. Leisure is not all it is cracked up to be.
- xedrac 4y agoNo, but having a good balance of leisure and work makes both of them better.
- pavel_lishin 4y ago> I personally would hate to spend all my time on leisure activities. I would still be working as hard but on my passion projects. I would count that as leisure, why wouldn't that count? Leisure isn't laying on a couch eating grapes; leisure is the freedom of deciding what to do with your time,.
- mort96 4y agoIn this context, "leisure" is used to mean the stuff you do outside of work and chores essentially. If you want to work on a side project, that would fall under leisure time.
- pbhjpbhj 4y ago>I would still be working as hard but on my passion projects. That's called leisure, being able to direct your actions without worry about them paying the bills, leisure. Of course you could choose to vegetate in front of a screen, but you're also free to walk the hills, create art, create machines, write software or poetry, or whatever.
- simple-thoughts 4y agoWho even wants to work just 2 hours per day. Sounds extremely boring. Work is a great way to exercise your mind and body while simultaneously earning funds to purchase luxuries.
- whiddershins 4y agoMany people can easily create a similar quality of life to 70 years ago while working 2 hours a day. It turns out people would rather work more and have more stuff.
- beedeebeedee 4y ago> Many people can easily create a similar quality of life to 70 years ago while working 2 hours a day. Please explain. I think you're underestimating how much things have changed, and are making a lot of assumptions about what you mean by "quality of life .. 70 years ago" and "working 2 hours a day" that would not be obvious (or available) to other people.
- mort96 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? The extra value has gone to enrich the oligarchs rather than to the people. Maybe that should change.
- pydry 4y agoHow do you deprive an oligarch of their ill gotten wealth without violence?
- mistermann 4y agoWhy apply constraints before we've even gotten started?
- commandlinefan 4y agoHow do you do it even with violence? How would you seize and “redistribute” Jeff Bezos’s (for example) wealth? It’s mostly in stocks that would start to lose value if you tried to cash them all out at once.
- maeil 4y agoThis is a non-issue; the stock will temporarily lose a bit of value through the increase of supply and that's it. Amazon as a company would still intrinsically be valued at hundreds of billions if not 1+ trillion, even if Bezos were to die tomorrow and his will would say that all of his shares should be sold on the market within a day. The fact that you might only end up redistributing $70 billion instead of the $80 billion he was worth when alive doesn't matter, it's still $70 billion being redistributed.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoYou disable his AWS account and badge and stop inviting him to meetings, likewise for any other hands that that stock falls into. It's not valuable if it doesn't give the holder enough power to make changes happen.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again And over and over again, we've underestimated and then normalized the capacity of our institutions, made of otherwise decent people, to achieve outcomes that we would call abhorrent if they were carried out by an individual. So the door closes on that opportunity because we fail to act. If we're ever going to walk through that door, companies need to fear us, because they sure as hell aren't going to share with us out of the goodness of their hearts. I'm not sure what the right move would be re: Priya. Maybe it's a strike for retraining benefits. Maybe it's a wave of resignation letters that mention her. Maybe it's an act of sabotage. But whatever it is, it has to be an existential threat because that's the only language besides money that our institutions understand.
- carapace 4y ago> they sure as hell aren't going to share with us out of the goodness of their hearts You know you can buy stock, right? And, as a shareholder, those companies will give you the profit?
- saulpw 4y agoWhere do I go to buy stock in OpenAI?
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoThat might be an option for you and me, but it's not an option for Priya. And that's a problem for you and me because our system has shown to be very effective at concentrating wealth at the top. Most likely it'll later find a different way to transition us from have to have-not, but even if it doesnt we'll end up retiring into a world mostly populated by people who have more to gain by turning their back on our system than participating in it. Squabbling over ownership of abstractions is a lose-lose scenario without some degree of solidarity keeping the zero sum games in check.
- sigstoat 4y ago> Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? if you'd like the standard of living of a few centuries ago, you can probably fund that by programming for a couple hours a week. instead you want entertainments, medicines and foods that take correspondingly more effort to produce.
- dkqmduems 4y agoEggs are still eggs no?
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoNo. I remember eggs 50 years ago, they tasted better, as did many other foods. Extrapolating, centuries ago, eggs were like divine ambrosia.
- causality0 4y agoHuman taste degrades as we age. Everybody will remember food being better when they were younger.
- sterlind 4y agobut produce really has gotten blander. I've never been a fan of regular Roma tomatoes, and even grocery store heirloom tomatoes mostly just taste sour. but I recently had the opportunity to eat a pizza with heirloom tomatoes from a friend's garden, and it tasted like the second coming of Jesus Christ in my mouth. like, not exaggerating, I was briefly moved to tears by how flavorful it was.
- selimthegrim 4y agoYou might want to reword that sentence unless you’re like that nun in Sweden who had some very detailed visions of feast of the circumcision, let’s leave it at that.
- photochemsyn 4y agoWhy not use AI to automate away the board of directors and the shareholders? It should be entirely possible. We just need an AI capable of generating its own capital, then the investor class can be removed from the loop.
- hnfong 4y agoThis sounds horrible. You’re basically saying you want everyone to work for companies controlled by AI.
- XorNot 4y agoWhy? An AI when told "follow local labor laws" is actually going to do it perfectly. Whereas those boards of executives are very happy not doing it. A workers co-op owned company headed by an AI decisioning board would be able to maintain constant, real time feedback and coordination with all workers, and would be faster and more maneuverable then human headed companies.
- photochemsyn 4y agoWell, perhaps the AI could itself be controlled by the employees to some extent via a democratic decision-making process, i.e. voting?
- jart 4y agoImagine having to go to the DMV to reset your Twitter password and realize that's the opposite of a world controlled by AI.
- jart 4y agoThere's a CEO that's an AI: https://www.analyticsinsight.net/chinese-game-company-appointed-an-ai-to-be-the-ceo/ https://www.analyticsinsight.net/chinese-game-company-appoin... Shareholders??? Capital generating AIs would be the things running on advertising and stock exchanges.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoProductivity metrics have gone up dramatically. Surplus from automation goes to owners (or the state). Worker gains are a market - in other words, capital and state organize and aim to minimize those gains as a negotiated cost
- klibertp 4y ago> Companies have shown time and time again that they're willing to make this trade-off. Maybe they wouldn't, but then the insurers come. Not all of the 1% of errors from an AI will be disastrous - if it happens to be "jaw-droppingly destructive" rarely enough for the insurance to make sense economically, that AI will be used.
- rdedev 4y agoI have a hard time believing that more jobs would be created. Like what a prompt engineer? As far as LLMs go, only companies that can afford the compute seem to be building one from scratch. So I don't think any new ML engineer jobs are going to get created
- randallsquared 4y ago> > that means that many companies can potentially produce 10 times as many products/services and make more things that will enrich peoples' lives. > This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? Is the promise you're referring to that work will be so valuable that people need only work less than a quarter as much to live a material lifestyle equivalent to CE 1823 or 1923, or that there will be so much work to be done that there's no unemployment to speak of in 2023? Both of those seem to be true...
- sl8r 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? In the “Sad Irons” chapter of Caro’s LBJ biography, he talks about the pre-electrification lives of Texas farmers. In comparison with that, our whole day is leisure. Similarly: As late as 1900, the poor in Europe were so severely malnourished that growth stunting was common. Look at Our World in Data’s charts of height over time. Or Robert Fogel’s “The Escape from Hunger and Premature Death.” Etc. Etc.
- ineedasername 4y ago>Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? That’s not the fault of automation. As a society we’ve chosen to increase our population and level of consumption instead and automation is simply the engine for it.
- jvanderbot 4y agoWhat part of "a company can produce 10x more goods" translates necessarily to "they decide to not grow and instead let people go home at 10am." They're going to try to grow and get rich off the increased productivity.
- ip26 4y agoThat isn’t just motivated by greed. In a competitive industry, if you take your foot off the gas, a hungrier competitor who is willing to go home at 5pm or 6pm will eat your lunch. It’s partly a product of capitalism within a nation, but also a product of the basic struggle for wealth and power at the international level. This is a common discussion in my chosen industry; we have well paying jobs and good working conditions, but only because we are (significantly) ahead. Our lead, and by extension the good life, could completely vanish in five to ten years if we stop pushing forward.
- jszymborski 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? Not to be that guy, but income inequality in the US has continued to increase [0], so it's not that automation isn't making people richer, it's just that it isn't being distributed fairly. If it were, then perhaps we'd be closer to our two hour work days. I think the automation of grocery store check-out is a great example of this sort of thing. Grocery store cashiers are busy spending their time worrying about their shifts getting cut in favour of self-checkout while grocery stores are profiteering (esp. in Canada) [1]. A more equitable system would have those profits lining the pockets of the same people who are now on reduced hours. Turns out that, like most people have realised by now, trick-down economics isn't really enough. [0] https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/01/09/trends-in-income-and-wealth-inequality/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/01/09/trends-... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/05/galen-weston-loblaw-companies-raise-grocery-prices https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/05/galen-weston-l...
- n0tahacker 4y agoI agree, but less profits mean more consumption and less investment in capital.
- ml_basics 4y ago> Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? Others have already commented on the fact that quality of life has generally increased. I think it's also worth realizing that over the course of a lifetime people today spend a much smaller fraction of their waking hours engaged in work than before. 100 years ago a typical man in a developed country might have started work aged 14 and then stopped working a few years before death if they were lucky to not die before. Nowadays even someone "uneducated" would start working at 18, while others might start aged 22 or older. And a common expectation is to have a retirement of 15+ years. So averaging over a lifetime we do work a lot less as a fraction of our lives than in earlier times. Edit: numbers were plucked from thin air based on my experiences of my own country, but i guess the general point applies to most developed countries
- qudat 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day, and spend the rest at leisure? The end result of creative destruction is not so we can all work less, it's so things that we value become cheaper, allowing us to reallocate resources to things that are equally or more valuable. It gives rise to new companies and industries that either a) could not work without the new tech, or b) were prohibitively expensive. The classic example is the fridge. Before it existed there was an entire industry that revolved around transporting blocks of ice. Now imagine all the industries, technological advancements, scientific advancements that would not exist if we didn't have the ability to make a box really really cold, relatively cheaply. Creative destruction leads to economic growth (increasing the pie), not a society that doesn't have to work 40hours a week.
- DennisP 4y ago> This has been the promise over and over again, for centuries, and it has consistently not paid off. Where's the predicted society where automation allows us all to work for two hours a day That's the opposite of what GP predicted: that people would be more productive and produce more, not work less. Programmers are way more productive than the were sixty years ago. We don't have fewer programmers, or part-time programmers, but we do have vastly more and better software.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]