15 ms·
For the first time, renewable energy generation beat out coal in the US
- jokoon 4y agoIt doesn't really matter if renewable generated more energy than coal for 1 day. What matters is annual generation. Renewables generates 5 times less than coal annually and still peak for a short period of time, so this is not a big progress. Wind turbines can have big energy peaks when it's very windy, but there is no cheap way to store that energy for a long period of time, WHICH IS WHY NUCLEAR IS THE GREENEST BASELOAD ELECTRICITY. And solar also requires a lot of copper and steel, which makes it carbon cycle much worse than nuclear.
- llukas 4y agoArticle is about annual production share.
- colinsane 4y ago> combined wind and solar generation increased from 12 percent of national power production in 2021 to 14 percent in 2022. Hydropower, biomass, and geothermal added another 7 percent — for a total share of 21 percent renewables last year. The figure narrowly exceeded coal’s 20 percent share of electricity generation, which fell from 23 percent in 2021. the article is speaking about average power, not peak power. how do you and the article present such different figures?
- Shaggy2000 4y ago[dead]
- kuhewa 4y ago> how do you and the article present such different figures? My friend, let me introduce you to the wonderful world of "not reading the article".
- audunw 4y ago> but there is no cheap way to store that energy for a long period of time It's getting close to the point that wind+storage can compete with nuclear, and even gas, on price. With the way cost has been developing on renewables and energy storage sulitons it's more or less inevitable. You're also starting to see off-shore wind, even floating off-shore, come rapidly down in cost, and those have more stable generation and require less energy storage. The problem of storage is also exaggerated by people who haven't looked at the big picture. We need to replace oil/gas in lots of areas where you need to store and transform energy anyway. Like cars. Think about it.. if you buy an EV you'll generally have enough storage there to power your house for 1-3 days. In a world where all cars are BEVs we'll be well within an order of magnititude of having the manufacturing capacity to have energy storage for all homes. You can even feed electricity from BEVs back into the grid, and I already have my BEV set to only charge in the hours where electricity is cheapest right now. We're also starting to see people use smart controllers to exploit the storage capacity in hot water tanks. Green metal production will also be a huge source of flexible load. Somewhat related to that, there's even molten metal batteries that can provide extremely cheap grid storage. > WHICH IS WHY NUCLEAR IS THE GREENEST BASELOAD ELECTRICITY. If you need to shout I'm just led to expect you don't have much meat behind your opinion. Anyway, the problem is just this: what we really need isn't baseload. You can't solve the worlds energy crisis without lots and lots of renewables. Going all nuclear would be too expensive, too slow, and would probably generate enough heat to slow recovery after climate change. Thermal power plants in general have a whole range of issue that makes it a bad idea to go all-in on it. Nuclear can certainly supplement with a bit of baseload capacity. But what we need is load following and peaker plants. We need a replacement to gas power plants. Because those are what works well when combining with renewables. And without lots of renewables we have zero hope of combatting climate change. > And solar also requires a lot of copper and steel, which makes it carbon cycle much worse than nuclear. At least copper and steel is easily recycled, with low carbon impact. Nuclear power plants use a lot of concrete and the sustainability of that is far more uncertain.
- martyvis 4y agoHere is a pumped hydro project which will be able to store maybe ¼ of Australia's electricity needed for a week. https://www.snowyhydro.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/SH1764_Updated-fact-sheets_Snowy-2.0_website.pdf https://www.snowyhydro.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/SH1...
- kuhewa 4y agoToo bad the capital requirements upfront are so expensive for nuclear and literally no one wants to fund a project that will cost at least $8 billion, won't be online for a decade, and the power it be will produce is already more expensive than that of smaller renewable projects. Who knows maybe once renewable market penetration is nearly maxed out and if storage tech somehow hasn't caught up enough despite the great strides being made, the economics won't be so terrible for the GREENEST BASELOAD. Who
- Intox 4y agoNuclear is not offering the best price per Mwh now (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source), but it will certainly in the next decades. Solar and wind power sources requires an absurd amount of metal (sometimes rare metals) to build the generators (solar panels, wind turbines, etc). This metal is extracted today with an enourmous consumption of fossil fuels, and it will be difficult to have a greener alternative for this extraction (anything running on batteries will require even MORE metal). The prices per Mwh of renewable energy sources are heavily linked to the prices of fossil fuels, which are quite "low" compared to what will probably happen in the next decades. Moreover, most metals are getting harder and harder to extract (it's likely that we met the peak of copper extraction already), which means that we'll have to dig deeper and deeper to get metal. I'm not saying we should not invest in renewables, but it will be probably be 10x to 50x more expensive to maintain a renewable parc of solar panels or wind turbines without relying on fossil fuels at all, which will cause the prices per mwh to explode. Countries that try to go 100% renewable without a healthy dose of nuclear energy will probably end up either burning fossil fuels or buying raw materials from countries that does, at a very heavy price.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoyou realize nuclear plants also require a lot of metal to produce?
- jokoon 4y agomuch much less per unit of power please look at this, I'm tired of having to remind people that nuclear is the best on ALL fronts except cost https://i.imgur.com/qKzwxuj.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/qKzwxuj.jpeg
- agentgumshoe 4y agoAnd wind requires immense use of rare metals that are often acquired through slave labour and create massive radioactive pools of waste. It is interesting to see the responses to Nuclear of 'too much up front/takes too long' while simultaneously patiently waiting out solar/wind 'it's getting there.' Interesting they also included biomass here as it is certainly not a carbon friendly process nor renewable. Too much 'we've picked our winners and won't hear a negative word' in this space now, and it's getting worse.
- thehappypm 4y agoWind turbines are mostly aluminum, no? And the magnets in the turbines are not required to be rare earth.
- agentgumshoe 4y agoThey're not, with the trade-off of being expensive and requiring expensive ongoing maintenance instead (or even an external power source!) That's not including the ongoing gearbox maintenance requirements.
- tnel77 4y agoNuclear is obviously an amazing source of energy, but the stigma is insane. In high school, my Chem II class had an assignment where pairs of kids had to present on why nuclear was good or bad. Of 16 or so kids, only my friend and I presented on why nuclear energy was good. Even the chemistry teacher was against nuclear energy. Edit: This was in rural USA.
- goatlover 4y agoIt's wild how bad the reputation of nuclear energy has been, when the alternative has largely been fossil fuels. It's really not that dangerous relative to source for 80% of energy production the world still relies on.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe division of electricity production into baseload, load-following and peaker categories is just a historical anachronism. Coal and nuclear plants have poor abilities to ramp power production up and down in response to fluctuating demand, so they were called 'baseload'. Various versions of natural gas power plants could respond more rapidly, so they were typically placed in the other other two categories. This is all irrelevant if you have distributed wind/solar production coupled to efficient storage systems that manage the distribution using technology that doesn't have those limitations. Practically that means short term storage of power in batteries (daily), long-term storage in synthetic fuels (seasonal).
- pyrale 4y ago> The division of electricity production into baseload, load-following and peaker categories is just a historical anachronism. Since you're obviously some time traveler, would you mind sharing winning lottery numbers with us?
- adrianN 4y agoNice. The economics of renewables are really hard to beat. I hope we speed up the construction speed and at the same time electrify more sectors.
- verisimi 4y agoReally? Solar gives lots of electricity in the summer. But you have light and warmth then. In the winter when you need the electricity, you get maybe 1/10 of whatever the solar array is capable of. Wind is not generally viable, except in very windy locations. Biogas (eg anaerobic digestors) seems much more possible - but even these need warmth to run well - so aren't as good in the winter. And when you think that yes - you can pay several thousands for a battery to store your electricity (for a day or so), but that the battery will only last a few years - how people think the economics make sense is a mystery to me. I'm fast coming to the conclusion that all renewable tech is about allowing the government to have deep control over your energy, and to put you in a situation where you are forced to buy very expensive gear from mega-corps. PS - the battery thing also applies to cars. Old electric cars are basically not worth keeping after 10 years. Who would replace the old battery that costs as much as the car? Esp when the battery slots are incompatible with the latest advances - ie you can't upgrade to a better battery, but only install yesterday's tech.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"But you have light and warmth then. " Yes, but often too much of it, so lots of people use AC, which uses a LOT of power. Electricity is needed all the year. "Wind is not generally viable, except in very windy locations." And there is wind everywhere, but only if you build high enough. So yes, there are places where it makes no sense to build them, but there are a lot more other places, where it does. "I'm fast coming to the conclusion that all renewable tech is about allowing the government to have deep control over your energy" So a solar + battery powered off grid home is deep controlled by the government? May you explain how that works? "And when you think that yes - you can pay several thousands for a battery to store your electricity (for a day or so)," Have you looked up any actual numbers? Maybe do so. Also maybe that part, that tracks how the battery prices are changing. They are constantly getting cheaper. Also maybe you are aware, that the whole industry that was and is fossil based needs to change. Your criticism comes from an angle, that assumes that should be for free? Burning fossil fuels is cheap. But only if you ignore the external costs of climate change and air pollution.
- anovikov 4y agoIt's so funny to read discussions of "whether or not renewables are viable for replacement of all or most of electricity needs in the U.S.". Here in Europe, we have it figured many years ago and are replacing fossil-fueled generation at a crazy rate, will probably push it to a niche use (gas peakers to fill void when there's neither sun or wind and before enough electrolyzers are put online), in less than 10 years.
- adrianN 4y ago"A crazy rate" that is unfortunately still much too slow to limit warming to 2° or below.
- anovikov 4y agoForget global warming. Of course it will not be stopped. All fossil fuels will be burnt till full exhaustion of reserves, until the remainder is completely uneconomical to extract. But then the nations that were the last to start switching will find their economies too inefficient and expensive to run with the fossil fuels while everyone else is using much cheaper renewables, and will probably no longer have money for the switch, ending up in a major predicament.
- zeckalpha 4y agoAs climate risk increases demand for renewables, we may actually see a decline in price for fossil fuels, at least for a time, resulting in prolonged bimodal consumption. I think we've been in this artificially low fossil fuel price environment since the beginning though: the externalities aren't priced in.
- maxerickson 4y agoIt's more or less a tautology that extraction will continue until it isn't worth doing. The thing is, abundant cheap energy will make it less and less worth doing.
- staunton 4y ago> Of course it will not be stopped One way or another, it will definitely be stopped. At some point, civilization collapse would end the burning of fossil fuels at scale. The question is at what point it will stop and whether any tipping points are passed which accelerate the process out of control. It's far from obvious that all efforts to limit carbon emissions will fail and to say otherwise is deeply cynical. Measures are being taken already. They are not enough to reach the claimed goals and the claimed goals will probably not be reached, but that's very different from saying warming will not be stopped at all, let alone "of course". More measures will follow once the adverse effects get worse in industrialized countries (e.g. deaths and economic damage due to changing climate and weather events).
- tjbiddle 4y agoMy comment isn't directly related to the OP, but figured it'd be an interesting insight to share as it's very recent for me. Just finished a motorbike trip in Laos. Fun fact, their largest export is electricity. Would've never guessed that, right? 90% of the electricity they generate is exported to neighboring countries - mostly Thailand. 80% is renewable - Go Laos! But wait, it may be renewable... but turns out the government is corrupt and constantly sells rights to the highest bidder wanting to build a dam for hydroelectric wherever they want, and usually without any sort of environmental survey - oops. It's the driest country I've been to in a while, many villages had their water access completely destroyed due to upstream dams. Just a cautionary tale as "renewable" doesn't necessarily mean better - green-washing is absolutely still a thing out there and we should be sure to thoroughly vet information before assuming it's more viable solution for us.
- revertmean 4y agoIt's also worth noting that dams aren't just built for electricity. They're also built to control flooding and to control water supply. I'm not saying that's the case in Laos, but it does happen. People can live without electricity, but it's difficult to live without water.
- throwaway2037 4y agoI cringe each time that I hear a foreigner complain about China's Three Gorges Dam as an "environmental damage". The number of people who have died from floods on those rivers in the last 2000 years in mind-boggling. Yes, it generates a lot of electricity, but it is dual purpose to also control flooding. People can live without electricity, but it's difficult to live without water. This part is also interesting. While traveling in developing countries in East/South/Southeast Asia, the driest places and always the poorest. The only way to overcome is irrigation. The wealthiest places find a way to move water from wet lands to dry lands.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> While traveling in developing countries in East/South/Southeast Asia, the driest places and [sic] always the poorest s:East/South/Southeast Asia:the United States:
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis would have happened a bit earlier if the most efficient and long-lasting solar panels, monocrystalline silicon, had been developed by US manufacturers instead of by Chinese ones. All the tariffs applied by state and federal regulators on the import of these panels have been about slowing the rate of solar PV production in the USA on behalf of the fossil fuel and investor-owned utility sectors. https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/04/14/the-weekend-read-chinas-monocrystalline-boom/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/04/14/the-weekend-read-chin... Claims that these tariffs have some human rights motivations are nonsensical, would the US block imports of Saudi oil over human rights abuses there? Of course not - but silicon solar panels, oh my! https://www.reuters.com/world/china/exclusive-us-blocks-more-than-1000-solar-shipments-over-chinese-slave-labor-2022-11-11/ https://www.reuters.com/world/china/exclusive-us-blocks-more... It's no surprise that the pushback by politicians owned by investors in fossil fuels and utilities has been so intense - energy is one of the most lucrative investments, and it's rather difficult to control and meter the flow of sunlight to homes, in comparison to natural gas or crude oil. Notably, the USA has no R & D programs or subsidy programs like the CHIPS act (for semiconductors for computation, not for power production) aimed at rapidly expanding monocrystalline silicon production.
- nroets 4y agoWhy should the US try to lead solar panel technology ? China has many talented engineers and plenty of venture capital. I'd prefer them to invest it in solar panel manufacturing and power electronics rather than social media, ai or Telco technology.
- rainsford 4y agoRelying on a non-friendly country for something so crucial as energy is generally not a great position to be in, particularly if that country has rival world power ambitions. Europe and Russia have provided a great recent example of why you don't want to be reliant on potential enemies for your energy needs, and while the situation between the US and China is not the same and solar is different than fossil fuels, it's still a factor worth thinking about. The US would be a lot more secure being able to rely on a domestic solar industry as solar becomes more and more important.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoVery encouraging! Including hydro in the renewables column made the math work. Makes it seem like we've made more progress than perhaps we have. Hydro and wind are the biggest chunks in their pie chart. And much of hydro is decades, if not centuries old infrastructure. But still! Lots of progress.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoThis would be better news if coal wasn't also being replaced by new fossil gas plants like crazy. If you look at coal vs fossil gas in the US it's a lot more depressing. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=48896 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=48896 The fraction of energy that comes from low carbon sources is what matters.
- kragen 4y agoi have the impression that gas produces something like 40 percent less co₂ per joule than coal? in some sense that's 'low carbon'
- acidburnNSA 4y agoOn paper that is sometimes true, and gas companies try to lean in hard on that. Gas can do 480 gCO2/kWh vs. coal's 800+. But when you include wellhead and pipeline losses of methane they end up looking almost exactly equal, according to many studies. So it's not really progress. Also, half the CO2 of coal is nowhere even close to acceptable. We need things that do about 1/20th the carbon of coal or less, so wind, solar, nuclear, hydro, geothermal, tidal only. Gas is out.
- kragen 4y agoamusing units √(kilowatt hour / 480 g) = 2700 m/s √(kilowatt hour / 800 g) = 2100 m/s 480 g is 60% of 800 g so i guess my vaguely remembered percentage was about right wrt co₂ reduction i think carbon capture is probably going to be necessary
- acidburnNSA 4y agoGrams CO₂-equiv emitted per kWh of electricity generated are the units used by everyone, e.g. the IPCC to quantify the carbon intensity of energy sources. E.g. for a graph of data from IPCC, see [1]. Again, 480 is not all-inclusive. If you look at the whole system, gas is no better than coal, due to wellhead and pipeline leaks of methane, a potent greenhouse gas. [1] https://whatisnuclear.com/img/lifecycle-carbon-emissions-nolabel.png https://whatisnuclear.com/img/lifecycle-carbon-emissions-nol...
- kmax12 4y agoLong-term trends clearly demonstrate the energy grid’s transition to renewable energy sources. However, renewables like solar and wind come with unique challenges due to their intermittent nature. They are more variable, harder to forecast, have location constraints, and can benefit from battery storage. These factors lead to a more dynamic grid than before. For instance, several regions in the country provide five-minute updates on their energy generation mix, enabling near real-time observations of renewable energy effects throughout the day For example, numerous regions across the country provide updates on their energy generation mix at five-minute intervals, allowing for close to real time observations of these effect of renewables throughout the day. To help those involved in the energy transition, I created an open-source project called Grid Status (https://github.com/kmax12/gridstatus https://github.com/kmax12/gridstatus) that provides fuel mix, wholesale pricing, load, load forecasts, and more. Additionally, I've developed real-time visualizations to make this data more accessible and easier to comprehend: https://www.gridstatus.io https://www.gridstatus.io I hope making this data more accessible and understandable will accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoIt demonstrates, quite clearly, that energy cost is not a concern. We can just barrel through to the electric revolution without a single care to cost, availability, or reliability.
- olddustytrail 4y agoNot a concern for whom? It's a market. If you can produce electricity cheaper, go ahead and make a fortune.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- starkd 4y ago>> And even when projects are approved, developers often discover they need to pay for new transmission lines to deliver power to residents and businesses. Those transmission lines often face further permitting delays. Just discovering this? Yeah, this has not been well planned.
- robomartin 4y agoThis article is a mess. Energy is NOT power. Reporting on energy (which is what the original publication does; and even they confuse it) is almost pointless. We need power. Not energy. Let me explain. There is no such thing as a useful measure of energy reliability. Energy is the accumulation of power over time. Here's a super simplistic example to illustrate the point: You spend all day walking through the desert. Your water bottle is empty. You drank it all. You really need water, yet there's none to be found. You nearly die a few times, yet manage to make it out to a settlement by nightfall. Someone there fills your bottle with water. A reporter says your bottle, over that 24 hour period, was full. That's the way you compute energy. You can have zero power for 12 hours and then have some for another 12. Energy just adds-up all the bits of power you had over 24 hours and reports it as one number. Energy comparisons are useless. Here's reality: Solar is, nominally, about 50% reliable (if this term isn't comfortable, think "available"). No? It turns off at night. Roughly 50% of the time...it does not work. Wind, on the other hand, does not suffer from this issue. It is much more reliable. With the addition of a nominal amount of storage wind can easily get up to 95% reliability. Solar, with the same amount of storage, runs about 70% reliability. This is about power delivery. Consistent. Water bottle in the desert, to use when you need water. Ignoring all other factors (environmental, wildlife, NIMBY, noise, etc.), wind is a far better technology than solar. Yet, again, to pull this back into the realm of what we should discussing: We need to talk about power, not energy. When you go to charge your electric car at the same time a million other people want to do the same thing, you need power.
- danhor 4y agoBoth are great, since while the daily cycle is a problem with solar, the seasonal variations are a far larger issue (since much mobe energy storage is needed). But both complement each other. Wind is stronger in the winter and solar is strong in the summer. The best consistency is achieved when both are used, not one or the other.
- robomartin 4y agoNo, not really. That's the impression most people have. For example, solar, in the northern hemisphere, is --to use your term-- stronger in March/April, not the summer. This is due to the panel negative temperature coefficient. > The best consistency is achieved when both are used, not one or the other. No. Wind with approximately three hours of storage is about 95% reliable. Once again, it's about power, not energy.
- Forestessential 4y agobut you got these not included: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_natural_gas_power_stations_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_natural_gas_power_stat... and for how it compares to coal, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_coal-fired_power_stations_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_coal-fired_power_stati... you have like 60-65% coal fired in the States. 40% of the corn produced in US is used for ethanol which is a energy intensive process which uses fossil fuels.
- gwright 4y agoYet another article and discussion that mostly ignores the fact that intermittent energy sources are not viable mechanisms for base-load generation. This is a basic physics problem that no amount of legislation or green-virtue signaling is going to make the problem go away. Until we find a reasonable way to store energy at grid scale, a continued shift to intermittent energy generation will result in dramatically higher prices and dramatically lower reliability.
- egberts1 4y agoGood for renewable energy. Now, make it a 24/7 steady supply of renewable energy. We’ll wait.
- rstuart4133 4y ago> We’ll wait. You can stop waiting now. https://reneweconomy.com.au/south-australia-hits-stunning-new-high-in-race-to-renewables-only-grid/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/south-australia-hits-stunning-ne... OECD ecomony, averaging 80% renewables (wind, solar primarily). The other 20% is gas. They have enough generation now. To rid of that 20% (I'm not sure the economics makes sense) they need to build pumped storage. Oh, and now they've made the transition, electricity prices are cheaper than non-renewable generation of 5 years ago.
- egberts1 4y agoNo data center will ever be 100% renewable ... unless that ocean wave generator pans out successfully.