23 ms·
Moviemaking and gamemaking are converging
- Dalewyn 4y agoYou don't say; I honestly can't tell the difference between most AAA titles and Hollywood films nowadays. No, I don't buy either.
- aosaigh 4y agoWhy not?
- Dalewyn 4y agoCheap, vapid stereotypes all the way down. CoD games from the past decade or so are particularly egregious examples, among many others. You could market them as Hollywood action thrillers and most people wouldn't notice a difference.
- flappyeagle 4y ago> No, I don't buy either. If you don't partake, maybe that's why you can't tell the difference.
- pipo234 4y agoSame here, but I'm curious what you think causes this mediocrity? I'm assuming the AAA game studios and Holywood know what they're doing, and money is definitely an objective. But why do they not succeed in telling an interesting story? Is it the focus on production quality? Is that the result of compromise between too many middle managers? Or simply: too much money, no one cares?
- Dalewyn 4y agoI think it's very simple: In a bid to satisfy everyone, they end up satisfying noone. If you try to create a product for everyone, you will end up with a product so bland and void of character that noone will want it. A good product has its fair shares of fans and detractors, a bad product either has only fans or detractors.
- pipo234 4y agoSo are you saying it's simply bad marketing research? Ie. if they would be able to narrow the target audience from "everyone" to a proper niche (say 18+ or teen age girls) they might succeed? That is: target a smaller market but server them better? I feel that somehow, even with all those dedicated, inspired (and underpaid) creatives working insane hours, organizational structures (middle managers?) unintentionally prevent all that creativity from bubbling up. (I'm saying unintentionally here to suppress sarcasm but also because obviously a successful product is in the organization's best interest.)
- Dalewyn 4y ago>So are you saying it's simply bad marketing research? Ie. if they would be able to narrow the target audience from "everyone" to a proper niche (say 18+ or teen age girls) they might succeed? That is: target a smaller market but server them better? Yes. Consider games like Octopath Traveller which aim for and sell to a specific audience (fans of jRPGs from the 90s), they succeed where the likes of CoD don't. Successful products begin by knowing who you want to sell to and why. Developing and selling a one-size-fits-all product to everyone, that is "the Average Man", simply won't work because the Average Man doesn't exist. The US Air Force will be happy to educate anyone on this. Noone wants a bland, vapid, sanitary product "for everyone".
- qersist3nce 4y ago>No, I don't buy either. Nothing of value is lost. Nowadays games are manufactured dopamine-gamifying cashgrabs and movies are propaganda outlets for whatever care-free non-STEM academics have brewed up as "current thing". 2000s was the golden era of gaming. Just compare remakes of RE2 and RE3 with the original PS1 ones. Or the new Wolfenstein series with Castle Wolfenstein.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoI'm sorry but _holy shit what a bad take_. >whatever care-free non-STEM academics have brewed up as "current thing". Ah nevermind you're one of these people that think that not being in STEM is a crime, my bad, I thought we could have a rational discussion. >Or the new Wolfenstein series with Castle Wolfenstein. So, better in every possible way, with more brutal and satisfying fighting than Castle Wolfenstein ever had, still killing nazis (something that everyone ought to be happy with) ? I sure hope you're not angry about the fact that your crew is made up of a polish man, a jew, a mentally ill man and other kinds of people the nazis called undesirables making it a fun clap back at them. Right ? That's definitely not what your problem is, _right_ ? I'm sure that you have no problems with games now including deeper themes like death and being a father (God of War), vengeance (The Last of Us Part 2), atonement (The Last of Us), paranormal activities (Control), or just being straight up absolutely great games with good stories like Prey, RDR2, Divinity, Outer Wilds, Disco Elysium, Octopath Traveler being varied and relaxing like Stardew, Terraria, being better metroidvanias than anything that came out before like Hollow Knight, Ori, amazing roguelikes like Hades, Dead Cells, Returnal, or just an infinite variety if I just go even in the last ten years.
- MattRix 4y agoAgreed completely, the parent comment is completely out of touch with the actual state of the game industry.
- Arkhaine_kupo 4y ago> 2000s was the golden era of gaming. Things weren't better, you were just younger. I was a teen in the 2000s and I had free time and every game felt new and exciting. There is 0 chance the landscape for media isn't a trillion times better now though.
- hackernewds 4y ago> No I don't buy either Do you steal them?
- Dalewyn 4y agoHilariously, no. Those games aren't even worth pirating, let alone purchasing.
- lizardking 4y agoIt’s been this way for awhile. AAA games have felt more like universal studios rides than games for the the last decade or so. I mostly stick to indie games or games from smaller studios at this point.
- unixhero 4y agoUnreal Engine 5
- em500 4y agoFor those who missed the Matrix tech demo from last year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WU0gvPcc3jQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WU0gvPcc3jQ
- doomlaser 4y agoIt's an exciting time. Unreal Engine is being used to great effect in things like The Mandalorian: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUnxzVOs3rk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUnxzVOs3rk The latest developments in large language models are another area interesting to me personally as a developer. Since the beginning of the video game medium, limitations in programming game AI have left video games stuck in a corner, where they use violence as the primary means of driving immersion, simply because it's just too complicated to model human-like behavior outside the domain of simple carnival games. Some games try and brute force their way around this by explicitly picking from a set of predetermined branching paths at predetermined critical moments. But the latest AI tools, first seen in stuff like the GPT-3 powered AI Dungeon, reveal that there will soon be new methods of maintaining a coherent story in a simulated game. We won't have to always resort to violence and fancy carnival games for much longer.
- localplume 4y ago[dead]
- hackernewds 4y agoExactly! I'm excited for NPC to act like AI, and have full fledged conversations. Now, if they're allowed to have previous memories of their interactions of not could be interesting, since that is currently banned by ClosedAI
- atchoo 4y agoI fear how buggy that could make future games. Some essential NPC interaction gets stuck in a weird loop / starts speaking Chinese / gets triggered into a Tay like paranoid Nazi rant while adamently denying the existence of the key it is holding that it's meant to give to the player to progress.
- x-complexity 4y agoAt worst, it's going to lead to a "is this a good NPC response" pipeline, where the model spits out lines based on its given prompt, and each one is approved by a proofreader. The minutes of time spending on thinking up what an NPC would say is now (about 10 seconds of speedreading 5 lines of generated results + 5 seconds in clicking either the 'approve' or 'reject' button): That in of itself is at least a 10x increase in available topic queries for NPCs.
- bkq 4y agoArchived link: https://archive.is/xzPtR https://archive.is/xzPtR The article says that there are similarities between the two industries, I see these similarities too between how the workforces are treated. Whereby Hollywood VFX workers are overworked and underpaid, and some even end up going under, and the Academy is always there to stomp out their protest during the few minutes they get at the Oscars [1]. Much like with game development, where waves of contractors are hired, then subsequently fired [2], or being just subjected to endless crunch [3]. I think it's fair to say that game dev companies are the sweatshops of the tech industry, and I feel for anyone who wants to break into what otherwise could be a creative industry. [1] - https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/la-xpm-2013-feb-25-la-et-ct-visual-effects-protest-20130225-story.html https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/la-xpm-2013-f... [2] - https://www.washingtonpost.com/video-games/2021/12/03/raven-software-layoffs/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/video-games/2021/12/03/raven-... [3] - https://www.polygon.com/2019/4/23/18507750/fortnite-work-crunch-epic-games https://www.polygon.com/2019/4/23/18507750/fortnite-work-cru...
- 3pt14159 4y agoWell that may be true, but they get to work on stuff that is legitimately cool. I know a guy that worked on StarTrek for years as a VR architect and general 3D modelling type of work. He worked longer hours than your average Torontonian, but nothing absolutely crazy. I've worked longer weeks. He loved his job. I'm not saying it is this way for everyone, but part of life is deciding if you want to work hard, have impact on things that matter, work on cool stuff, earn a lot of money, etc. There are places where it truly gets exploitative, but in my humble opinion that's usually places where the people involved have almost no options other than to move to another town or country. I'm not against industries or companies where the up front expectation is hard work. Some people want that, at least some of the time.
- bkq 4y ago>I'm not saying it is this way for everyone, but part of life is deciding if you want to work hard, have impact on things that matter, work on cool stuff, earn a lot of money, etc. VFX people in Hollywoord are some of the most underpaid workers in the industry. Sure, it's cool that you can be a part of a team that helps make a movie. No doubt it must be pretty cool to see your work on the big screen, or even the small screen, and know that you played a part in bringing it there. But I think something the workers would also value is having some autonomy over their work, and being paid for it. I'm not easily convinced by the argument of, "you get to work on cool stuff", working on cool stuff doesn't make up for risking povery, debt, or unemployment when you're underpaid. Furthermore, there's a difference between hard work, and exhausting working. And being put under crunch is exhausting work, not hard work.
- KineticLensman 4y agoIt's not mentioned in TFA, but Unreal Engine is also used by the BBC to create real time virtual studios for its various football punditry programmes [0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1N-XVHqUUOY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1N-XVHqUUOY
- zirgs 4y agoGambling industry has been using it for a while now.
- christkv 4y agoHow many years until a small team of less than 10 people can produce a full feature film with generative tooling?. I'm pretty exited about the potential of powerful storytelling being in the hand over everyone without needing massive amounts of capital, especially if it shatters the entertainment semi-monopolies.
- bsenftner 4y agoYou'll still need massive amounts of capital to market the film, and that is where they The Industry That Demands The Same Same captures you. If the product is not just like all the others, the marketers have 0 idea how to sell it. I've been there: made a Mario style game for the original PSX during the 90's with a major animation studio... and no marketing firm could sell it, because at that time all PSX titles were "teen targeted" and they literally did not want to market the game because they themselves were not interested in playing it.
- silvestrov 4y agoI think this has changed with Netflix and other streamning services: if you can get Netflix to buy it then the only marketing needed for Netflix is to put the movie online. You no longer need to convince 1000s of cinemas and journalists that this movie is worth seeing.
- DeathArrow 4y agoI am glad I moved from game industry some time ago. The company I worked for wasn't bad, but it went bankrupt. Staying in the industry meant they I had to deal with less than great employers at some point, being overworked, having a smaller salary and my future growth perspectives to be limited. That being said, I've enjoyed the years I worked as a game programmer, I had fun and I've learned interesting stuff.
- enbugger 4y agoOverall, game development feels much better when it is a hobby unlike a full-time job. You can experiment, without deadlines, but no money back on the other hand.
- NayamAmarshe 4y agoBeing a solo indie dev isn't that fun either. You're looking for an investment of 1-4 years, without pay and without a guarantee that you're going to get it shipped and that it's going to pay you back. Game development can be risky, especially if you've got bigger ambitions for your game. It all sounds great in your head, but progress is much slower. I spent 8 months on Unreal Engine, 8 months that I'm never going to get back, and I was never able to ship anything. Game development takes time and if you're someone who doesn't already have an expertise in asset creation, it's going to be even harder. Speaking from a 3D game developer perspective, It also requires investment, not just hundreds of dollars but sometimes thousands because you can't do everything on your own. It's more than just 3d models, it involves animations, sound design, texture work, putting it all together and presentation and story and voice acting. So much stuff for a single person to handle. It's great when you do not mind failure and putting 2–3 years into void, terrible when you expect something better than mediocrity. Regular software development (web apps and apps) imho is much more rewarding. It takes less time to build an MVP, you can do it almost everything for $0 these days.
- reidjs 4y agoIt's only risky if you feel a need to ship and profit from it. If you treat the game development process as an artistic endeavor, you can enjoy the time you are spending on it. Like an amateur painter creating a piece, just for something to put up in your own mantle, only for their friends and family to see. If you feel that you have to ship and monetize, then the process loses its magic. This approach also requires that you work a day job, unfortunately.
- raincole 4y agoAnd is it a good thing or not? Both industries are notoriously for overtime and underpayment.
- coldacid 4y agoHaven't I heard this one before? Multiple times? Over the past 20+ years? What's different this time?
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoThey are not. The gamedesigners who are all "Show" not "play" are the worst. Same as authors who wan to "tell" and not "show" in movies. Those who have "cool" scenes in there heads, which they want to make into a game, make for the worst, cause not interactive game experiences. Stop conflating a passive medium and a active medium. Its even worse, if they glue singleplayer "movies" into multiplayer without gameplay considerations. As if the the ten other players want to wait for that cool "finnish" him cinematic to play the 100 time over. The technology base might be merging, but god safe us from the merging of the creator bases. I wish this myth would die, once and for all.
- Dah00n 4y agoA lot of people enjoy games that are basically interactive movies. Hell, there's a whole market for people that want a game to progress all the way through while all they do is click the same button over and over again. Saying they have nothing in common is no different from trying to keep digital artists down because it is not “real art” like a painting or sculpture. Unless you are a purist that only want completely analog movies and completely digital games then the creators and tools are already merged. Look at the direction of Unreal Engine for a great example and how movie producers are joining game studios.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe first Uncharted game is a great example.
- TheUndead96 4y agoI have increasingly become disinterested in CGI-heavy movies. I have taken to watching more foreign-language films, which seem to still be more interpersonal and grounded in reality. I say this as a person who would usually prefer sci-fi and fantasy over other genres, which are the genres which are historically the most heavy in CGI and VFX.
- onion2k 4y agoI have increasingly become disinterested in CGI-heavy movies. Most of the writing talent for Hollywood has moved on to writing for TV. There's more money, more scope, and they can write things that don't need to be 'spectacular' enough to get people to pay $20 to see. They have enough scope to actually build plots and give characters interesting lives rather than the 2.5 hours a film affords them. TV shows are getting better at the same pace that films are getting worse.
- dandellion 4y agoThe problem I have with TV is that most of these stories with interesting characters drag on until they get cancelled, depriving me of my favourite part of any story: the ending. Most movies on the other hand have an ending, even if it's open.
- UncleEntity 4y agoYeah, that’s a problem now a days. I’ve pretty much taken to waiting for a series to end and then binge watching because too many I’ve been interested in just get canceled in the middle of the story. Probably part of the problem since I don’t show up in the weekly viewing stats but, oh well.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoThe production quality of TV has exploded. The writing quality, on the other hand, has taken a notable nosedive in the last decade. A notable recent example are things like the newest Lord of the Rings show, or the Foundations series. Incredible production values hampered by awful writing. Dialogue in the last years, in particular, has been awful in 90% of TV. Basic dialogue rules (like don't say exactly what the character is thinking or feeling) are broken for the sake of expediency and simplifying for the lowest denominator. The golden age of TV was a fairly distinct moment in prestige television making where a showrunner and some writers had enormous control over the show's direction and tone. Nowadays, most shows, like most hollywood movies, have a stupid amount of producers and the writing feels like a committee of YA-book authors put together the season's scripts in a weekend. A lot of modern TV is the sausage meat in the content factory of streaming services.
- tonyoconnell 4y agoMoviemaking, gamemaking and education are converging. I can see the day when blockbuster education games/apps are built with the budget of a Hollywood movie.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoThat's mostly because filmmaking is ceasing to be filmmaking, at least for big movies and TV shows. I tend to ignore new TV shows these days. Why? I just know they're gonna be great for a few seasons at best then start sucking, and I don't feel like wasting my time in the meantime. I can count on one hand non-episodic TV shows in the last 25 years that have maintained their high quality throughout. The Wire The Sopranos Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul Mr. Robot Honourable mention for Twin Peaks: The Return, although Twin Peaks didn't exactly maintain its quality throughout season 2 even if Lynch swooped back in to save it near the end. All cases where one person or a couple people had strong creative control of the project throughout. I could sit here all day listing shows that started out really good but then it became clear the writers had no idea what they were doing, or the writers who did left. These shows are all written by committee now. All these garbage Star Trek shows. Westworld has really neat sci fi premises for each season but other than season 1 they always devolve into action schlock because the writers don't understand how to actually write good sci fi. As for big movies, they feel like they're written by marketing people not writers. They're optimised for getting people into the theatre and everything else is an afterthought. There's still a handful of auteurs making great movies you could think of as big. People like Tarantino, Scorsese, the Coen brother. Christopher Nolan gets lucky sometimes, but most of his sci fi is ruined by sloppy writing for me(Interstellar...) One thing is certain for me though. I can't think of a single recent movie I've enjoyed that had lots of CGI in it. The movies with the best writing are pretty much never the ones with huge effects budgets. The true art of filmmaking lies in the writing. You can have all the effects in the world, the best actors and directors. Doesn't matter one bit if the script is terrible.
- censor_me 4y agoTarantino is about to stop making movies by his own account - "a director should never make more than 10 movies". I'm slightly vexed that you did not mention Villeneuve, who made Blade Runner 2049 and recently Dune. Blade Runner 2049 is already a cult classic and Dune felt like a fresh air of mature sci-fi in the age of Marvel. He is about the only one I truly look forward to see his next movie, right now being Dune 2.
- citizenkeen 4y ago
- kristianpaul 4y agoEverything its a remix (look for the documentary)
- citizenkeen 4y agoAnecdata: My wife was addicted to the story in God of War Ragnarok. She walked through the living room during the opening cut scene and exclaimed "Is that Toby Ziegler ZEUS?" She ended up hanging out in the living room crafting, reading, playing on her phone, or watching her own shows while I ran around smashing and killing, and then would pay attention whenever a cut scene happened. Movies and games are not the same thing. But blockbuster amusement park movies and AAA video games increasingly are.
- bullen 4y agoThey have to diverge for the medium/media specific traits to emerge. The 3D action MMO is the final medium/media. Nobody is working on that.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoIt has tried and failed more than once in the past. I guarantee someone is working on it now again, and eventually one of them will stick.
- bullen 4y agoI am: http://talk.binarytask.com/task?id=5959519327505901449 http://talk.binarytask.com/task?id=5959519327505901449
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI got this strange feeling that this article is behind the Times. The gaming industry has been getting progressively closer to the movie industry for about 20 years. I think they already have converged
- TOMDM 4y agoAgreed, games like God of War, and the sequel Ragnarok cemented this for me.
- the_af 4y agoBesides the article being a bit behind the times ("Blizzard has turned World of Warcraft into a subscriber service", really, The Economist? You just discovered WoW?), most of the games it mentions are the kinds of games I find uninteresting. WoW, PUBG, "games that retain players", no thank you. For me, it's all about self-contained single-player games with no subscription or DLC (which I ignore), and no grandiose longterm plans. I hate "seasons" in games or DLC or any attempt at retaining me. I vastly prefer small, innovative indie games.
- andy_ppp 4y agoI think them not understanding Gaming as well as the Hacker News audience is expected. This is true of loads of fields; football presenters for example make statements about clubs that their fans find to be regularly incorrect, but then how can one person stay updated to the same level of detail for all clubs that a fan does for one club? This happens everywhere.
- strken 4y agoFootball presenters are often former players, and they're seldom wrong on the same level as not knowing how the consumer fundamentals of how an MMO takes money from players. That seems like an error comparable to a presenter not knowing that football stadiums sell food.
- rco8786 4y agoI was chatting about this with a friend as we were watching John Wick (2, I think) Straight up 3rd person Shooter but as a movie. And similarly, watching The Last of Us you can see how they broke down the screenplay into “levels” or “missions”. Maybe a bad example since it’s explicitly a video game crossover though.
- Arrath 4y agoWatching the Mandalorian straight up felt like watching someone live an Open World game, complete with sidequests (his bounties) and quest rewards and gear upgrades (here, for turning in that bounty you get another ingot of beskar steel and bam! new breastplate) The only thing missing was Mando landing on a new planet and climbing the comms tower at the Spaceport to highlight all nearby Points of Interest.
- bioemerl 4y agoI am tempted to argue that this has been in the process of happening ever since the first episode of Red versus Blue back in the early (mid or late?) 2000s
- ChoGGi 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diary_of_a_Camper https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diary_of_a_Camper
- not_enoch_wise 4y agoFinally, the gameplay of a Michael Bay movie combined with the story of Super Mario
- sophacles 4y agoWell there's a headline ive been reading since the 90s. What seems to have changed is that the stories were presented back then as a way for video game makers to tap into larger audiences, and to benefit from being in the good graces of the film industry. These days it seems to be a story about a Hollywood past its prime seeking to maintain relevance by partnering with game studios.
- qwery 4y agoThat's what I thought, but what's different now is that someone's about to make a photo-realistic gaming simulation and shoot a movie in it. From the article: > “somebody’s going to invest in a [gaming] simulation that’s photo-realistic. And then they’re going to shoot a movie in it,” says one Hollywood executive. “It will happen. And it’s probably not too far away.”
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoAnd that's awesome because its going to basically democratize film making the way radio and TV were democratized by podcasts and youtube.
- JohnFen 4y agoHmm.. that would be pretty great, actually. podcasts and youtubers do radio and TV far better than radio and TV companies do.
- xdavidliu 4y ago> One is that labour markets and production techniques for gaming converge with those of the film business, to the point where some envisage a single production process. Seriously? "envisage"? Is that word really necessary to express this point?
- pleb_nz 4y agoThey have been good decades.
- qwery 4y agoWith the torrent of live service games failing spectacularly over the last several years, the Economist is here to tell you about why making good games is bad for business, that single-player is dead, what a 'live service' is (now and looking ahead to 2017), and the infinite money circle powering some of the sexual predators at Ubisoft. Also, > Developers used to finish making a game and go on holiday. Citation needed? Maybe they meant: "holiday" /s/s/s I assume 'developers' refers to the people who make the game, as the company can't really "go on holiday". With that in mind, developers used to, and still do, after (nearly dying) shipping a game, get laid off.
- Aardwolf 4y agoMaybe for AAA games - granted, of which some are good. But the type of games I sink most time in (like factorio, satisfactory, stardew valley, terraria, ...) are not
- doe88 4y agoIt might be countertuive but I've developped a sort of claustrophobia watching heavy cgi/vfx movies, I can't stand layers and layers of fake peoples, cities, ships, cars... It might not be aligned with my political views and might be sad to disclose but I kind of find relaxing watching the true cows, horses and landscapes of Montana in Yellowstone.
- bmitc 4y agoIt has never been clear to me why people want movies and games to be the same thing. Most AAA games that are "cinematic" are just bad or mediocre movies that wouldn't get made or have already been made. For example, even some very famous video game designers have mentioned that they would rather make movies. Why don't they then? I think it's because the threshold to make a story good enough for a movie is a bit higher than a video game, even with the bar falling a bit in modern times for movies. There's even a question as to why gamers want movies made out of their favorite game. There's a reason why these usually fail, and it's usually because the underlying story is just not that interesting. In my opinion, a video game should be a game and not a larping simulator for movies. Games like Journey, The Witness, The Last Guardian, Shadow of the Collossus, Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice, Mirror's Edge, etc. should be the standard for video game designers.
- imbnwa 4y agoWould add Whatever Happened to Edith Finch?, Abzü to that list
- 7373737373 4y agoI've seen some impressive audiovisual experiences in VR