9 ms·
SVB depositors, investors tried to pull $42B Thursday
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoSo the VC thinkbois basically created a run on SVB. Nice job guys! Anyway, the only rational voice I've been hearing so far is Bob Elliott (used to be on the IC at Bridgewater/advisor to Ray Dalio and taught multiple courses on the banking system) - https://twitter.com/BobEUnlimited https://twitter.com/BobEUnlimited Probably a good idea to just ignore all the moronic VC threads and fintwit influencers. It seems like the most likely scenario is that depositors will be made whole quickly and equity holders will get fucked since SVB's balance sheet looks pretty strong. Matt Levine came to the same conclusion.
- xuki 4y agoSVB created a run on themselves by betting against rising interest rate.
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoNope, wrong. Their balance sheet is strong and they are fully solvent. This is completely different from an FTX situation. They DID make a bad bet, but they were still solvent as a bank. The liquidity crisis was caused due to poor communication on SVB's part and typical VC herd mentality. Read the full article by Matt Levine for a breakdown.
- Jensson 4y agoThey weren't solvent, 100 billion in 2033 dollars doesn't equal 100 billions in 2023 dollars.
- timy2shoes 4y agoSolvency and liquidity are two different things.
- Jensson 4y ago2033 dollars lost a lot of value due to interest rate increases. Higher interest rates means that 2023 dollars would convert to more 2033 dollars, so now if you want to sell 2033 dollars for 2023 dollars you would get less back. If the interest rates weren't increased they would just have sold their 2033 dollars and everything would be fine, a bank doesn't go under just because it takes a while to get billions of dollars, the whole issue is that they ran out of assets due to their assets having lost value.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gruez 4y agoThat might be true, but it's got me thinking. Suppose you owe $100M and had $80M of cash. That would be considered both involvent and illiquid, correct? Now suppose you go out and buy $80M worth of 10 year treasuries with the cash you have. At current rates you will have $115M in 10 years, plenty of money to pay of your liabilities of $100M. Does that mean that if you're "insolvent" you can magically make yourself "solvent" by buying a bunch of bonds?
- nickff 4y agoNo, because you need to value the bonds at their current market value, which would presumably be 80 MM. The fact that you believe an asset will get you a certain amount of money doesn’t mean it’s worth that now.
- tedunangst 4y agoIf the debt is due in ten years, it won't be worth $100m, and you can presumably just pay it off with the cash.
- 4y ago
- bagels 4y agoMatt Levine article: https://archive.is/GafKl https://archive.is/GafKl
- eru 4y agoI read Matt Levine's write-up: as always, a delight! However it didn't strike me as him making a case that SVB is solvent.
- bagels 4y agoHis thesis is that they'll bail out the depositors to avoid other runs.
- eru 4y agoYes, that's my reading as well. Which sounds rather different to me than 'Their balance sheet is strong and they are fully solvent.' Their balance sheet is weak, but they kept going because some accounting tricks allowed them to defer mark-to-market on their losses.
- xuki 4y agoI’m not saying they are insolvent. Their bet led them to having to raise money, and that gave enough signal for their depositors to pull money. Don’t blame VCs, their reactions were rational in this situation.
- ummonk 4y agoOnly inasmuch as they knew other VCs and depositors would be panicking in response to the signal. There's another possible stable equilibrium where no one panics because they know no one else will panic and that the bank is solvent.
- caddemon 4y agoWell SVB can't raise the interest rate they pay to depositors much without taking a bath, and I don't see why someone would want to keep their money in the bank once it is paying a notably lower interest rate than most other banks. Maybe some more time or wider spread of people wanting to withdraw would've kept them alive long enough to salvage something. But they put a huge amount of their money into this bond that they will be stuck with for a long amount of time. I dunno bank run almost just seems inevitable here.
- theli0nheart 4y agoNo, the bank is actually insolvent. > On March 8, 2023, the Bank announced a loss of approximately $1.8 billion from a sale of investments (U.S. treasuries and mortgage-backed securities). On March 8, 2023, the Bank's holding company announced it was conducting a capital raise. Despite the bank being in sound financial condition prior to March 9, 2023, investors and depositors reacted by initiating withdrawals of $42 billion in deposits from the Bank on March 9, 2023, causing a run on the Bank. As of the close of business on March 9, the bank had a negative cash balance of approximately $958 million. Despite attempts from the Bank, with the assistance of regulators, to transfer collateral from various sources, the Bank did not meet its cash letter with the Federal Reserve. The precipitous deposit withdrawal has caused the Bank to be incapable of paying its obligations as they come due, and the bank is now insolvent. Source: https://dfpi.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/337/2023/03/DFPI-Orders-Silicon-Valley-Bank-03102023.pdf?emrc=bedc09 https://dfpi.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/337/2023/03/DFP...
- chollida1 4y ago> Nope, wrong. Their balance sheet is strong and they are fully solvent. The fact that they sold assets for a loss indicates that they are not. The fact that the FDIC took over the bank indicates that they are not. The fact that the bank is winding down with no other bank willing to buy them indicates that they are not. What fact would you put forward to support your assertion that the bank is fully solvent. Because right now you are saying the opposite of the market, the FDIC and the banks competitors. If they were fully solvent it would be pretty trivial to find a buyer to keep the bank to Silicon Valley startups going. The fact that no one will take on their liabilities is very damning.
- mgfist 4y agoI think what they meant to say is they were solvent, till the run.
- KerryJones 4y agoI partially agree with you... except "The fact that they sold assets for a loss indicates that they are not." is not true. Firms sell assets at losses all the time -- that doesn't mean they are not solvent. That means they had a loss, but their assets were still greatly in excess of their liabilities (as reported by the FDIC 211b vs 195b). What they were not able to do was have enough cash on hand to deal with a bank run.
- ZiiS 4y agoThe assests they sold recovering as soon as intrest rates drop is as close to a sure thing as you get in finance. The only reason to realise the loss is they needed the money now.
- DebtDeflation 4y ago>as soon as intrest rates drop Which could take a lot longer than people seem to expect. If you look at the past 100+ years of economic history, 2009-2021 is a complete anomaly. ZIRP is not the normal state of affairs, nor are negative real rates. There was an attempt at returning to normalcy from 2017-2019 but then Covid hit. Starting last year the Fed is attempting once again to return to a normal monetary environment. Rates are likely headed higher than people think and will remain there longer than people think.
- g42gregory 4y agoWhat were they supposed to do? They knew the clock is ticking. Whoever bailed first will be Ok and the last will be left hiding the bag. That goes for their portfolio companies as well. This is game-theoretic decision making. I am a bit rusty on Nash equilibrium, so I am not sure if this was inevitable outcome.
- Natsu 4y agoIf you map 'pull all your money' as defect and 'leave your deposits in the bank' as cooperate, you can make a case for it being a prisoner's dilemma, though I don't claim to know if everything would be okay if people didn't pull out. The Nash is to defect in the prisoner's dilemma. That's not the whole story, mind you, because there's a case for tit-for-tat and similar strategies in repeated games, but this looks like a one-shot game from what I know, so... yeah.
- zamnos 4y agoPrisoner's dilemma doesn't have a part where they take all the prisoners from the Silicon Valley Jail and move them to the First Republic jail with a bunch of other prisoners and ask them the same question, do they?
- startupsfail 4y agoBut it is never a one-shot game. It is now a fact that “capital firms Peter Thiel’s Founders Fund, Coatue Management, Union Square Ventures and Founder Collective all advised their startups to pull their cash from the bank”. Valley is small. There is real loss of wealth now, because SVB is no more. And there’d be likely a ripple effect.
- g42gregory 4y agoI suspect, there will be a bailout. Silicon Valley has very good relationship with the current White House. It would not be a stretch to make the case for a bailout. All the Government has to do is to provide $10-$30B (?) worth of liquidity of the next 2 - 3 years, until the rates will go down. Then, they could sell the whole fixed income portfolio.
- guelo 4y agoHow is a bank spunoff back again after a fed takeover?
- eru 4y agoThe FDIC will probably sell the carcass to another bank in the next few days.
- dylan604 4y agoThe fact that a bank can be sold off in "the next few days" yet it takes the average person 30 days minimum to close on a house...
- eru 4y agoIf you are willing to sell at a discount, you can sell faster. But more importantly, you probably don't have as many highly paid bankers, lawyers, accountants and regulators trying to push the deal through. Nobody could afford that.
- Scoundreller 4y agoThey’ve also created new banks in the past (presumably when they can’t facilitate a shotgun marriage). E.g. the first big bank failure in 2008, and the 3rd largest failure ever (after WaMu and now SVB), IndyMac became OneWest https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_failures_in_the_United_States_(2008%E2%80%93present) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_failures_in_the... > On March 19, 2009, a seven-member investor group, IMB Holdco, led by Steven Mnuchin—which included billionaire Christopher Flowers, John Paulson, Michael Dell, and George Soros—purchased Independent National Mortgage Corporation (IndyMac Bank) of Pasadena, California for $13.65 billion from the FDIC and created OneWest from the remains of IndyMac https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OneWest_Bank https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OneWest_Bank
- bostik 4y agoIn this case they created a new bank. From an outsider's perspective, it implies the bank run was either too sudden, or SVB would have been too expensive, for FDIC to be able to run an expedited auction. In one of the earlier two threads a poster linked to this segment of 60 Minutes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAE8i40A5uI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAE8i40A5uI . (I would link to the comment directly but I can't find it right now. Apologies to the poster.) In case of a relatively small bank, the FDIC had run a secret auction a few days earlier, and had an acquirer ready on the day. SVB was pretty big. Lining up a buyer that can absorb and handle a balance of ~$200B might take a while, and interestingly there may be political reasons to discourage depositor haircuts. Buying at firesale prices favours those with deep enough pockets. Buying at par (or near enough) needs more than just money - it gives advantage to those who can do extensive diligence really fast.
- eru 4y ago> So the VC thinkbois basically created a run on SVB. Nice job guys! You say it like that absolves SVB.
- bhouston 4y agoSVB has around $200B under management. The bank run on Thursday pulled $41B out of it. That is 20% of their total AUM. That is an insane bank run. No bank is setup for that kind of bank run.
- eru 4y ago> No bank is setup for that kind of bank run. Banks in Scotland's free banking era used to have a capital cushion of around 1/3 of their balance sheet. Not saying that this kind of capital cushion is viable in today's regulatory environment. Just to give an example of existing real world banks that were set up for that kind of bank run. In any case, I agree that scarcely any bank today would be set up for that kind of run. That still doesn't absolve SVB. They put themselves in a position where it's rational for their depositors to run.
- shawabawa3 4y agoAre you sure about that? I would make me very nervous if every single bank had ~50% of it's balance sheet in rock bottom rate 10Y bonds that have dropped in value 30+% in the last year I'm pretty sure most banks have assets > liabilities even after rate hikes, which is the root cause with SVB, not the bank run
- bhouston 4y ago> I would make me very nervous if every single bank had ~50% of it's balance sheet in rock bottom rate 10Y bonds that have dropped in value 30+% in the last year This is a separate issue. SVB is likely insolvent because of their MBS issue. But their liquidity available last week is significantly less than their assets.
- gizmondo 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but nowadays any (sufficiently large?) solvent bank can just borrow from the Fed and survive such a run.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoWait should I buy SVB?
- eru 4y agoTrading in their shares is halted. However, in principle, if you believe in the efficient market hypothesis, and if SVB shares would still be traded, they would be traded at a (low enough) price that makes buying their shares reasonably thing to do.
- KerryJones 4y agoCurious what the efficient market hypothesis has to do with this? Seems pretty opposite to me -- I would think if you are a value investor then the price may have dropped low.
- eru 4y ago> Curious what the efficient market hypothesis has to do with this? Let's back away from SVB, because it's not currently traded. In 2020 the car rental company Hertz went bankrupt. Nevertheless, the stock traded a low but non-zero price. You can either say that people were crazy, or if you take the efficient market hypothesis to heart, you can see it as an indication that there was a positive probability that Hertz stock would be worth something after the bankruptcy. As for the value investor perspective: for SVB you would try to come up with your own valuation, compare that to the market price (and thus market capitalisation), and if the latter was low enough, you'd buy. As an efficient market guy, you'd skip the first step, and just assume that the market price is probably fair enough; and just buy an index fund that includes a small fraction of SVB. (SVB used to be in the S&P 500.)
- KerryJones 4y agoIf you're an efficient market hypothesis, you don't believe there is any value that can be had because it's completely built into the market, so there's no reason to pay attention to the news and just buy a fund in the first place. This likely depends on which version of EMH you're referring to, and what information is "efficient", but typically speaking you don't care if things drop or rise because you believe that it's efficiently priced. Can you help me understand where you and I differ?
- ummonk 4y agoTo be fair if there's a run on a bank happening you want to be following the people creating the run so you can be one of the first ones out the door. Incidentally there's a major moral hazard problem for bank runs in that unlike e.g. stock market or commodities panics, there isn't any ability to "buy the dip" or hold through the panic.
- startupsfail 4y ago“Becker held the roughly 10-minute call with investors at about 11:30 a.m. San Francisco time. He asked the bank’s clients, including venture capital investors, to support the bank the way it has supported its customers over the past 40 years, the person said.” The above was the right answer that would have maximized the wealth generating machine.
- ummonk 4y agoAgreed. I wish the VC community had come together and financed a stock purchase with SVB to recapitalize it instead of running for the hills. Unfortunately, VCs aren't exactly known for their community-oriented mindset.
- startupsfail 4y agoSad thing is that the defectors are clearly the short-term winners in that case. Long term, the purchasing power of the Valley will be diminished and financial services disrupted. This might result in substantial disruption of businesses and cascades of business failures. Which may in turn affect defectors. But this seems to be the only negative feedback loop.
- dang 4y agoCan you please make your substantive points without snark and name-calling? The latter break the site guidelines and your account looks to have been making a habit of that. We ban such accounts and I don't want to ban you because you've clearly got some good points—so if you'd please review the rules and stick to them, we'd be grateful. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- LewisVerstappen 4y agowill do. Thanks!
- dang 4y agoAppreciated!
- chewz 4y ago> So the VC thinkbois basically created a run on SVB. Nice job guys! On purpose. Billions of their wealth depended on FED's easy monetary policy (ZIRP, NIRP, QE infinite) for last 30 years or so. For likes of Gary Tan, Peter Thiel and Cathie Wood (and Ray Dalio) creating moral panic and trying to force FED's hand to reverse normalising monetary policy is the only possible way to keep status quo and their wealth. Is The Fed Listening? | ITK with Cathie Wood - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jvL2Q0cJLyo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jvL2Q0cJLyo 30% of YC companies exposed through SVB can’t make payroll in the next 30 days - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35100743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35100743 Peter Thiel’s Founders Fund Advises Companies to Withdraw Money From SVB - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-09/founders-fund-advises-companies-to-withdraw-money-from-svb#xj4y7vzkg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-09/founders-...
- sidibe 4y agoIt definitely seems to be done on purpose, but they didn't tell all their friends (David Sacks for example). For Thiel this was a win-win thing, his companies are all fine while hurting the competition and he gets to whine about government from new angles. Also quite in keeping with his soulless character
- DebtDeflation 4y ago>the most likely scenario is that depositors will be made whole quickly Insured depositors (up to $250K) will absolutely be made whole quickly. They'll get their money on Monday. Uninsured depositors, up to some multiple of the $250K, will probably be made whole, but it will likely take a couple of weeks. Uninsured depositors beyond whatever multiple the FDIC decides to accommodate (likely somewhere in the millions to tens of millions of $), will probably get some fraction of their deposits back, but it could take several months. This talking point that all depositors will be made whole quickly is dangerous and almost certainly false. The FDIC needs to liquidate or find a buyer for SVB and the value of the assets isn't enough to make everyone whole, beyond that there is the FDIC insurance fund but it's likely insufficient, beyond that requires Congress passing a law to enable a further bailout.
- ororroro 4y agoI've been trying to figure out what SVB's reserve requirements were and found (https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/reservereq.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/reservereq.htm): "As announced on March 15, 2020, the Board reduced reserve requirement ratios to zero percent effective March 26, 2020. This action eliminated reserve requirements for all depository institutions." Wat?
- gruez 4y agoThey removed reserve requirements (ie. cash you need to keep on hand) but there's still capital requirements (ie. assets you need to keep on hand).
- eru 4y agoYes. Though as a small nitpick, I wouldn't describe capital requirements as 'assets you need to keep on hand'. No matter your capital structure, all your liabilities will be matched by assets. What matters is that after your accounting for your fixed liabilities, like deposits, you still have plenty of total assets left over to have a thick equity cushion to absorb losses. In accounting terms, equity is also a liability. But it's a very benign one, as your shareholders can't demand their money back. There are other forms of liabilities that act like equity in their ability to absorb losses. But equity is the simplest and generally the most import one.
- helsontaveras18 4y agoWow, I never thought of / heard anyone explain equity as a liability to pay to shareholders. It’s brilliant!
- eru 4y agoYou might like to read up on the very basics of accounting. There's lots of other interesting concepts there. See https://martin.kleppmann.com/2011/03/07/accounting-for-computer-scientists.html https://martin.kleppmann.com/2011/03/07/accounting-for-compu... for an intro. Accounting might sound rather boring, but at its core its about understanding businesses (and economies) with numbers. It can be as varied and interesting as companies are. Of course, in practice there's lots of cruft build on top of relatively simple concepts. But the simple underlying concepts are still fascinating. The link above explains double entry book keeping in terms of graph theory and network flows. The basics of deprecation are also quite interesting (to me, at least).
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/LNI2e https://archive.ph/LNI2e
- tootie 4y agoWhat happens to their employees? Do they work for the FDIC now? Laid off?
- mixdup 4y agoFriday, they became FDIC employees. How long they remain FDIC employees is probably an open question, depending on role and the ultimate disposition of the bank
- paxys 4y ago"FDIC employees" doesn't sound accurate. They are still employees of the same bank, just that the bank is now run by the FDIC. They are not all suddenly Federal government employees.
- mixdup 4y agoNo, the bank they worked for is no longer in business. The FDIC created a new bank, the Deposit Insurance National Bank of Santa Clara, and transferred all of SIVB's deposits to the DINB. On Monday, all of the physical branches of SIVB will open as branches of DINB https://www.fdic.gov/news/press-releases/2023/pr23016.html https://www.fdic.gov/news/press-releases/2023/pr23016.html
- NordSteve 4y agoTo clarify: The new bank "Deposit Insurance National Bank of Santa Clara" (DINB) received "all _insured_ deposits of Silicon Valley Bank", and is intended to open for business on Monday. The remainder of SVB (including loans and uninsured deposits) are now held by FDIC as conservator/receiver of the failed bank.
- mixdup 4y agoFair, I should've clarified that DINB does not have every penny that SIVB had. However, the point still stands: The tellers at the window on Monday will be working for DINB (which is owned by the FDIC) not SIVB Even beyond that point, though, the FDIC now owns Silicon Valley Bank so even everyone else who worked for the bank that didn't transfer to DINB still now works for the FDIC (as long as they're still employed--which is probably a rapidly shrinking amount of time) https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/719739/000119312523067777/d450664d8k.htm https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/719739/00011... >On March 10, 2023, SVB Financial Group’s (the “Company”) wholly owned subsidiary, Silicon Valley Bank (the “Bank”) was closed by the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation was appointed as receiver. The Company is no longer the parent company of the Bank. Even if someone remains on the payroll of Silicon Valley Bank, they are an employee of the FDIC since it now owns Silicon Valley Bank SIVB did have a holding company, so not every single employee of the company moved to the FDIC. Those at the holding company, not the actual bank, most certainly didn't transfer to the FDIC
- Waterluvian 4y agoI have the most esoteric financial law trivia question. If I deposit a dollar in my bank account. Do I legally own that money? Or do I have a legal contract with the bank that they’ll give me back that money?
- paxys 4y agohttps://www.sgrlaw.com/does-the-money-in-your-bank-account-really-belong-to-you/ https://www.sgrlaw.com/does-the-money-in-your-bank-account-r... > At the moment of deposit, the funds become the property of the depository bank. > Thus, as a depositor, you are in essence a creditor of the bank. Once the bank accepts your deposit, it agrees to refund the same amount, or any part thereof, on demand. At least in New York state, the answer to the first question is no. I imagine it's the same everywhere else.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jbverschoor 4y agoYup. you just have a claim on that institution. It not like holding stock or bonds
- ProllyInfamous 4y agoFurther, the FDIC (a US insurance agency with sweeping banking powers) guarantees that you will be able to redeem AT MOST AND UP TO $250,000, per account; guaranteed by the "legitimacy" of the USDollar (aka Taxpayers and US Debt holders).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deepGem 4y agoYou have a legal contract with FDIC which insures all deposits upto $250K is what I know. If the bank goes bust FDIC owes you your money under 250K.
- nabla9 4y ago-- two causes -- (1) SVB assumed low interest rates would continue, took risk. (2) 94% of SVB's deposits are uninsured by FDIC (40-50% is typical), meaning there are big sum deposits that go past $250,000. Customers took some counterparty risk. After the letter came in 1 + 2 -> bank run. -- what happens -- Everyone gets the insured $250k quickly. Rest is stuck for possibly long time. Most of it will be recovered eventually, but some small percentage might be lost. There will be local liquidity crisis in the valley in the order of $50 billion at least, but other banks can give emergency bridge loans against assets stuck in SVB once they figure out how much they are worth. "The mood" of the market is ruined. Risk analysis tightens. Some other wheels may drop.
- 411111111111111 4y agoWouldn't this be attempted insider trading then? Doesn't that come with jail time at that scale?
- pgwhalen 4y agoCan you elaborate? Nothing about this situation is at all related to insider trading.
- 411111111111111 4y agoYou're completely correct. They likely got inside information which triggered their action, but insider trading would probably only apply to stock trades because of this information. I was just a little confused.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mixdup 4y agoThis explains why the FDIC couldn't find a buyer of the distressed assets and also seized the bank in the middle of the day. They always wait until after the close of business on Friday (or, at the very least end of business of whatever day) to avoid a panic Out of 563 previous bank failures going back to October 2000, only 31 did not have an acquiring institution lined up (https://www.fdic.gov/resources/resolutions/bank-failures/failed-bank-list/ https://www.fdic.gov/resources/resolutions/bank-failures/fai...) Usually the FDIC will sell the assets and liabilities of the failed bank to a healthy bank, sometimes at a negative value (paying the acquiring bank to receive the assets) and then also making the acquiring bank whole on losses of the assets SIVB is upside down on various interest bearing assets like MBS and US Treasuries. In a normal case, it'd be cheaper for the FDIC to just make up those losses than directly make depositors whole, so they do that In this case, given how little of SIVB's deposits are actually insured, the scale of the run before they got the doors closed, and the amount of losses they are going to take in the assets, the FDIC obviously wasn't willing to backstop the losses and no one was willing to take the risk Depositors are definitely taking a haircut on this one
- searealist 4y ago> Depositors are definitely taking a haircut on this one That's not clear at all and many people disagree with you.
- koolba 4y agoMoney doesn’t magically appear out of nowhere. SVB does not have assets on its books to pay its short term liabilities. Unless a government agency swoops in to bail out the difference between their short term liabilities and the net present value of their long term assets, somebody is going to be taking a haircut. The equity of the bank itself isn’t enough to cover the losses so it’s going to be depositors.
- polio 4y agoWhat if the FDIC or someone pays all depositors and then takes over the long-term bond portfolio, intending to hold to maturity?