16 ms·
Can the West’s perplexing employment miracle continue?
- rsynnott 4y ago'miracle', from the dictionary: > an extraordinary event manifesting divine intervention in human affairs OR > an extremely outstanding or unusual event, thing, or accomplishment 'miracle' from an economist: > Something slightly unexpected happened. They really do overuse the term shamelessly.
- ftyers 4y agohttps://archive.ph/UwJLv https://archive.ph/UwJLv
- pfisch 4y agohttps://archive.is/ZXp0o#selection-697.216-705.56 https://archive.is/ZXp0o#selection-697.216-705.56
- mountainriver 4y agoEventually we’ll run through all the money we dumped into the economy.
- mjhay 4y agoIf you are talking about monetary stimulus/low interest rates, you have a point, but if you are talking about expanded unemployment or Berniebucks, that's been gone from the economy for quite some time.
- derstander 4y agoWhat are “Berniebucks”? A cursory google search suggests that they are either Safari Ltd’s reward program or Bernie Sanders fundraising for his 2016 run for President, but neither of those seem germane to this conversation. Is the notion that Bernie Sanders is somehow responsible for all of the economic stimulus given to US citizens during the pandemic?
- rprospero 4y agoI believe that they’re referring to Ben Bernanke and the policy of giving money directly to the populous, bypassing other intermediary institutions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_money
- danaris 4y agoGiven the context, they seem to be using it to refer to direct-to-the-people stimulus payments, because Sanders is a Socialist and advocates for more such payments. (Though oddly non-pejoratively, based on their phrasing.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whitemary 4y agoBerniebucks refers to the greatly expanded unemployment insurance distributed during the pandemic, which resulted from an amendment by Bernie Sanders. Bernie heavily criticized the unamended bill, especially the bipartisan giveaways to Wall Street, and refused to support it without his amendment.
- refurb 4y agoYou don't really “run through it” since the money is still there (unless the central bank pulls it out). But you are right that eventually the economy would grow enough to “soak up” the extra money and it wouldnt be so inflationary.
- jedberg 4y agoYou run through it by having it move to the top, where it sits. $100 in the bank account of someone who only has $200 will be far more active in the economy than someone who has $2,000,000. Or $2B.
- refurb 4y agoUnless you're putting money under a mattress, money in the bank or investments still circulates and creates inflationary pressures.
- yasp 4y ago> A more intriguing possibility concerns the labour force. According to our estimates the rich world is “missing” 10m workers, or roughly 1.5% of the total workforce, relative to pre-pandemic trends (see chart 3). In Britain and Italy the workforce has actually shrunk. Early retirements and an increasingly elderly population explain some of the deficit. Covid may have pushed people to reassess their priorities, prompting them to drop out. Some even speculate that long covid is forcing people to stay on the economic sidelines. Whatever the explanation, falling participation has wreaked havoc with companies’ plans. Many fired staff when the pandemic struck, only to struggle to rehire them in 2021. That year vacancies across the oecd hit an all-time high of 30m. Why not ask them?
- jameshart 4y agoAsk whom? The missing 10m? Might be hard. What with them being ‘missing’.
- yasp 4y agoOstensibly they are missing from the labor force, not from the planet.
- easythrees 4y agoHow many are dead or permanently disabled because of Covid, I wonder.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoCOVID has killed hundreds of thousands, but overwhelmingly older or weaker folks, the kinds who are retired, semi-retired, or on disability. This would have had an impact, but not 10 million
- Swizec 4y agoConsidering almost 7m people died from covid officially … Yeah they’re pretty missing https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-death-toll/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-death-... The Economist puts excess deaths at 20m https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-deaths-estimates https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-...
- lr4444lr 4y agoIsn't this the long arc of the sub replacement birthrates?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoExactly. COVID deaths and retirements pulled the demographic curve forward. “It’s the demographics stupid,” with apologies to James Carville.
- Gibbon1 4y agoAlso immigration is slowing and we're about to see the decline in births after the 2008 recession show up four years from now.
- vuln 4y agoImmigration is not slowing it could be peaking but we're seeing double even triple the number of monthly encounters at the southern border alone. https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/southwest-land-border-encounters https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/southwest-land-border-enc...
- ceejayoz 4y agoImmigration encompasses a lot more activity than just illegal crossings of the southern border. The Fed uses the term "slowing": https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/publications/economic-letter/2023/february/role-of-immigration-in-us-labor-market-tightness/ https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/publications/economi...
- vuln 4y agoYes they do say it slowed 2017-2020 and during the pandemic. The following line states: "More recent data show immigration has rebounded strongly, helping to close the shortfall in foreign-born labor and ease tight labor markets."
- jackcosgrove 4y ago
- mkl95 4y agoWe have gone from a zero interest rate economy to a high interest one within months. Whoever claims to accurately predict what's going to happen in the next few years is talking out of their ass. We know inflation should start decreasing within a year or so, but you cannot predict how millions of people will react to suddenly not being able to afford stuff.
- pjc50 4y agoThere has been a lot of argument over whether the inflation was transitory or not, and the theory that it was caused by the massive energy price spike in Europe caused by sanctioning Russian gas seems to have won. And the rate spikes were relatively modest. (Energy prices were much less affected in the US, but the economies are linked by trade)
- mschuster91 4y ago> We know inflation should start decreasing within a year or so That is assuming the Russians eventually pull out of Ukraine, are completely beaten militarily and their assets will be used to fund Ukrainian reconstruction, and it assumes that China does not increase tensions with Taiwan or, heaven forbid, actually invade. Should the war drag on, the situation will grow completely unpredictable - eventually, governments (no matter their political orientation or prior campaign promises) will have to raise taxes to pay for Ukraine aid and especially new arms projects, which means price hikes for the masses as companies will just pass through tax increases instead of accepting lower dividends for the capitalist owner class. > but you cannot predict how millions of people will react to suddenly not being able to afford stuff. IMO: Riots are inevitable IMO unless politicians invest money into at least filling the gaps for the lowest rungs of the societal ladder, the French are blazing the trail here - and it's only a matter of time until at least the UK population has enough of empty supermarket shelves. In the US, it depends if Biden will be able to secure a second term.
- lizardking 4y agoSupport for funding the war could just as easily become an electoral liability in the west, in which case Ukraine loses some territory and the rest of the world moves on as they did when Russia seized Crimea. Either outcome is better for global economic stability than a protracted multi year war.
- thoweiruo3i4 4y ago[flagged]
- sillybov3456 4y agoI'm sorry but I'm not entirely sure who or what you are responding to with this. Could you explain a little bit of the context so that we can understand the point that is being made?
- bobberkarl 4y agoSame. Curious. Can he reinstates what he just said?
- noirbot 4y agoSeriously, this feels like reading leftist madlibs. Maybe I'm out of the loop, but half of the words in that specific order make no sense to me. It's all inside references to... something?
- sillybov3456 4y agoI think it can but I wouldn't call it a miracle. The "boomer bulge" in the workforce is in the process of entering retirement en masse. The generations replacing them are smaller. This will contribute to higher inflation (lots of money that was sitting in real estate and 401ks being withdrawn to compete over a limited supply of basic goods and services like healthcare), and also to lower unemployment. It doesn't necessarily mean we are experiencing a miracle and will have higher living standards, I promise it is quite possible for a nation to banish unemployment but still have a majority of people struggling to get by. That being said, I think we haven't seen the full effect of higher interest rates yet, we are just getting started with that.
- gabythenerd 4y ago> I promise it is quite possible for a nation to banish unemployment but still have a majority of people struggling to get by. You can always end up having a bunch of low paying jobs that don't allow for a good standard of living. Everyone will be employed but I'm sure no one will end up enjoying that.
- acuozzo 4y ago> You can always end up having a bunch of low paying jobs that don't allow for a good standard of living. Indeed, but this will gradually kill all but the most essential industries. "Consumers" won't have the funds to "consume" and the 21M US citizens with a net worth of $1M or more won't pick up the slack. 21M people don't purchase 15 Gameboys each when they go to the store. If it gets bad enough, then the risk is that mutual aid networks will enable "opting out" en masse like during the depression: tents and washboards by the river. Once things at that point, getting the opt-outs back to play the game requires big promises ala The New Deal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jackcosgrove 4y agoYou can also have a workforce so small that infrastructure starts to decay and you have to triage what services are staffed.
- VincentEvans 4y agoI imagine the thinking goes - we could easily employ twice as many people at half the pay.
- opportune 4y agoI think what we’re seeing is that the NAIRU (non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment) model continues to be correct in some cases but fall apart in others. This model has traditionally been based more on empirical data than a strong theoretical basis (although anybody could tell you that is reasonable for low unemployment to lead to wage inflation) and, most notably, is an aggregate measure. Certainly you can argue that Japan proves an exception to this rule, or that the current low unemployment is simply a lagging indicator of our previously dovish monetary policy that will eventually normalize. But I think that NAIRU simply needs to be refined: wage inflation occurs not during low unemployment but during times of increasing employment. That is to say, an economy may arrive at a steady state of employment at a variety of employment rates, which needn’t cause wage inflation, but when employers in aggregate are creating new jobs and attempting to fill them even if they have to raise compensation, you do get wage inflation. This also doesn’t necessarily need to be done in aggregate: you can argue that wage inflation in the technology industry during the 2010s is partially what created the localized inflation in the Bay Area during that time, while in the rest of the country without heavy tech presence, this didn’t happen. There are of course many other wrinkles: for example, the size of the workforce has a degree of elasticity, where higher wages or lower hiring standards may draw some people not considering participating to again participate. There is also elasticity to hiring: depending on any individual employer’s demand for workers they may be more or less willing to raise compensation vs only partially meeting hiring goals. And of course there is stickiness to employment on both the employer and employed. The elasticity and stickiness of these things seems like it can have tons of factors that influence their magnitude: from culture norms (like in Japan where job hopping is less common), to employment regulations (how hard is it to hire-fire), ageism and other *isms (if a culture discriminates against X group, they may be more inclined to drop out of the labor force, but happy to rejoin it if employers need to hire so badly that discrimination gets lessened), to the size of the social safety net. Plus, unemployment is a very coarse metric for skilled workers. Skilled workers are less likely to simply become “unemployed” and more likely to switch directly from one job to the other. During a broad hiring binge you could see large wage growth with little change in unemployment. Anyway, I think basically economics has the tools to explain everything we are seeing already - it’s only perplexing when reasoning based on very simplified models like NAIRU. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAIRU https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAIRU
- jongjong 4y agoMy theory is that bullshit jobs are one of the mechanisms by which large corporations maintain a protective anti-competitive moat around their businesses; instead of letting unused labor roam freely in the markets to potentially compete against their interests, corporations provide as many jobs as required in order to keep as many people's time fully occupied in order to minimize the number of people who can compete against them. These jobs are of extremely marginal (or even sometimes slightly negative) value to the corporation in terms of profitably servicing customers, but their value in anti-competitive moat-making justifies the costs. Of course, this only works at scale if most big corporations act in unison. As corporations find other, more effective ways to maintain their oligopolies, the reliance on this strategy diminishes... That may explain recent layoffs in the US? Maybe we've reached such point due to media monopolization and regulatory capture providing a more robust moat? The ability of free labor to compete against corporate interests is now so insignificant (odds are so bad for indie startups) that it no longer poses a threat to corporate interests, even in large numbers.
- jongjong 4y agoI think this theory may also explain why larger companies often appear to hold people down instead of trying to grow them. Beyond a certain threshold of monopolization, the primary role of the mega-corporation may be to deplete talent (e.g. employee burnout, disillusionment, overspecialization in proprietary tools and processes leading to a career dead end) in order to neutralize its future competitive potential, more so than to leverage its immediate productive potential for their own immediate use.
- creato 4y agoI can't believe this theory is so widespread. There's no high level conspiracy to hire people to keep them away from competitors, such a thing could not be kept secret, and it's a ridiculously expensive thing to do (even for a FAANG) for extremely dubious value that might be realized a decade down the road and no real way to know if it's working. Bullshit jobs exist because mid level managers are very averse to killing projects or firing low performers, because that would shrink their fiefdom. That basically only ever happens when there is extreme pressure (e.g. layoffs). Layoffs happen in clusters because even a few layoffs greatly increase the leverage employers have, and as soon as they have a little leverage, a layoff looks better than it would otherwise, so it's a positive feedback loop. This is a much, much simpler and realistic explanation than "a grand conspiracy of media monopolies and regulatory capture is cheaper than hungry hungry hippoing all the engineers".
- golemiprague 4y ago[dead]
- lvl102 4y agoRates are still well below what we had leading up to the dotcom bust. And corporate leverage is still conservative. It’s a very similar backdrop with AI leading the narrative this time around.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI thought this was a bizarre (OK, I'll be honest, shitty) article. The beginning starts out by seemingly making the point that Japan has low unemployment because it has a lot of inefficient, "make-work" jobs, e.g. "smartly dressed women help you use the lifts" (subtext being who needs help using an elevator) and "a team of four people was involved in the preparation of your correspondent’s gin martini". OK, fair enough. But then it starts making the argument that employment in the West is going to look more like Japan. Except places where I'm aware where there are acute labor shortages (e.g. businesses like restaurants, child care, nursing, home services like plumber, electrician, etc.) look nothing like the picture the author tried to paint with his Japan vignettes. I.e. there aren't tons of spare waiters standing around waiting to make your drink where I live. More like you're happy just to get seated in the first place because places are so understaffed. The current and coming labor shortages in the West are not a surprise - it's simple demographics, with nearly every 1st world country having a fertility rate that is well below replacement level. I think the pandemic did cause some folks to re-evaluate their priorities, but I think even there a lot of explanations are given for people "re-evaluating their priorities", but the reality is that labor shortages are causing some people to leave the workforce because the value of their "labor at home" is now relatively much more. For example, childcare in the US in many urban areas is extremely expensive. It's expensive to the point where if one member of a couple has a relatively low earning potential, it makes more sense for them to stay at home to raise their kids, rather than putting them in childcare, because the economics of it are no longer that favorable.
- 5448346438 4y agoTo be honest make-work type jobs are shitty examples anyway unless their existence is mandated through governance (looking at you Oregon gas stations). Otherwise, whether those jobs seem important or necessary or neither, their existence is a cultural one that's at least as significant as any job related to entertainment or hospitality.
- rsynnott 4y agoI'd wonder how true it is in Japan, either; all feels a bit anecdotal. My impression was that Japan had ~0 unemployment largely due to an increasingly small number of people of working age; per-employee productivity is actually pretty high in Japan. And yeah, certainly around here a lot of stuff is just reducing hours because they can't staff at previous levels.
- geuis 4y agoIt's difficult to take serious any article that tries to apply Japanese customs to other western (Euro/US/Aus/NZ) cultures. We are deeply entangled, but JP is a different beast. Aside from the aging population and low birth rate, it's still a distinctly different culture than say, New York or London. What the author describes are long term artifacts of Japanese culture. It's a service culture (dunno if that's a term) in which I mean extra levels of service are given to guests and customers. Again, sorry if "service culture" is incorrect. I highly respect JP culture. So, I'm not sure how that pertains to jobs in the rest of the western world. Also, the article is behind a paywall. So boo.
- Aeolun 4y agoThe difference is that people in Japan feel like it is normal to work hard (and long) for a pittance. People in Europe feel like their boss is being unreasonable if they ask them to come in 35 hours a week. And think 4 days, or even better, 3 days is optimal. Then since they’re not being paid a lot, they feel it’s fair to just not give a rats ass about anything they’re doing. I think there might be some balance in between that I’d like best.
- FranzFerdiNaN 4y agoAs a European this is just as dumb a comment as me saying Americans expect a work lunch consisting of cheeseburgers and will shoot up a place if it runs out of cheese.
- throwswaydollar 4y agoAs a global citizen, I'm worse off using the dolar. Sooner it's gone the better.
- pjc50 4y agoAnd replace it with what? How old are the Bretton Woods fanboys, anyway?
- throwswaydollar 4y agoGold
- refurb 4y agoIt's the opposite. If the US keeps raising rates and other countries don't (like it appears Canada will do), then USD will appreciate in value. Smart to be holding USD right now.
- throwswaydollar 4y agoI want all nations to ditch dollar based trading. It's nothing but indirect tax on the non Americans. High interest rates is once in a decade thing btw. America printed 4 trillon dollars since COVID. I am not finding America at fault or anything like that. Everyone puts their interests first after all
- rjbwork 4y agoThe US has been subsidizing global trade for the better part of a century, while not actually getting all that much out of it economically - geopolitically, sure, it's been great, but economically it mostly just decimated domestic low-end manufacturing and resource extraction. Let's see how happy you'll be once the US turns entirely inwards and the rest of the world has to secure their global trade routes. The US will be fine. It can be largely self sufficient, despite the hysteria over our inability to manufacture things, we can redevelop the low end stuff fairly easily, and we're re-shoring the ultra-high end with even TSMC making chip plants here. It'll be a bumpy road, but all indicators are that the US is re-shoring manufacturing, developing energy independence, and turning inwards.
- rayiner 4y agoNobody wants to admit it but Trump’s immigration policies, which Biden continued, actually had the intended effect. Inflation was a predictable consequence of ramping down on the influx of cheap workers, but that’s fine. Americans don’t need cheap stuff as much as they need workers to have bargaining power.
- astrange 4y agoThat's Trump's interest rate policies, not his immigration policies. (Biden is continuing both of them by keeping JPowell on the job.) Immigrants are good for the economy and good for workers. They are your customers! Don't be a Malthusian.
- rayiner 4y agoNo, because we had low interest rates before Trump and didn’t have the same low end job growth. “Good for the economy” isn’t the relevant concept. Immigration can grow the economy overall, while putting lower end workers in a relatively worse position.
- astrange 4y agoThe job numbers got that good because of an uninterrupted rate of job growth from 2008 on. JPowell helped by keeping rates low instead of sticking to the previous NAIRU wisdom which says the correct interest rate is the one that reproduces the unemployment rate of 2008. > Immigration can grow the economy overall, while putting lower end workers in a relatively worse position. They don't really do that either! Immigrants mainly compete with each other.
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s not the job numbers. It’s the labor shortage and wage growth at the bottom end. My local Dunkin’ Donuts is staffed with teenagers and was paying $16 in 2020 (exurban MD). Immigrants compete with those low end workers.
- ETH_start 4y agoWild armchair economist guess: Efficient market theory predicts that in a free market, all labor will be utilized, irrespective of demand dips due to interest rate hikes. With the gig economy providing a route around regulatory regimentation of the labor market and inflation having driven down the real minimum wage to below the market value of the vast majority of labor, the labor market has been able to adjust to every economic turn and produce effectively full employment. Going even further out in a limb: I think in a sense, political gridlock has prevented the government from instituting disastrous measures that in the 1930s produced so much unnecessary unemployment, like the FDR Administration trying to fight deflation by imposing very high industry-specific minimum wages that caused the unemployment rate to exceed 20 percent.
- Taniwha 4y agoIs it really an employment miracle? or just the expected result of the baby boomers retiring
- skee8383 4y agoThere's plenty of jobs out there, but what the MSM doesn't tell is, they ain't the kind of jobs most people want.
- supercucumber 4y agothere's a solid chance said jobs don't pay equitably either
- ec109685 4y agoMeanwhile in third world countries, people are selling their kid’s organs: https://www.wionews.com/south-asia/from-organ-trade-to-sedatives-how-afghanistan-is-coping-with-economic-crisis-537127 https://www.wionews.com/south-asia/from-organ-trade-to-sedat... If only there was a way for people to emigrate to opportunity.
- favaq 4y agoI'm happy that people who sell their kids' organs are not allowed to enter my country.
- diceduckmonk 4y agoCredibility of the author is out the door when they are using strawman comparisons with Japan (Tokyo) indicative of someone who spent a week there as a tourist and had to shoehorn this experience in. It's like a foreigner traveling to America, and by that I mean LA or NYC, and talk about how fashionable people in SoHo were or how vibrant Time Square is, meanwhile 99% of Americans aren't in this way of life. I'm almost certain "in one of Tokyo’s best bars, a team of four people was involved in the preparation of your correspondent’s gin martini" refers to The SG Club, an overpriced tourist trap for tourists who want to feel refined, sophisticated, edgy. As economists say, there are four types of economies: developed, undeveloped, Argentina, and Japan. Not having a permanent place to be during the 9-5PM, whether that is school or work, is a badge of shame in Japanese society. If you read crime reports in Japan, they will almost always mention the persons state of employment. Even the tragedy of the commons / prisoner's dilemma is thwarted in Japan, atleast in a public context. On microeconomics, people are not making decisions that would be deemed economically optimal or even rational from an American lens. The example with the airport and malls being overstaffed. The first part is that both the government and people would rather that people work, rather than rely on government/society, even if it means the enterprise is not operating optimally. This is one reason why, quantitatively atleast, Japan has one of the lowest productivity rates of developed countries. Everyone has to appear working diligently, regardless if they've past the point of productivity or not. For the second part, the mall, in this time and age you can order stuff online. The value proposition of retail is that people want and value human services. Especially if it for higher end products and luxury products, where the retail and customer experience is part of the purchase, which is likely the case for a mall in Japan. Even Uniqlo is a splurge for people to be honest. Furthermore, Japanese people trust humans not computers, and there is an expectation that service be 1:1 and available. Just wait into the author sees the staff ratio in the electronics store, especially in the appliance section. They are dozens of tables where they go through a step by step process with customers, explaining the appliance, delivery process, etc. Part of this is also a desire for human interaction which is relatively limited compared to America where you have no shortage of small talk with randos.
- misja111 4y ago> The example with the airport and malls being overstaffed. The first part is that both the government and people would rather that people work, rather than rely on government/society, even if it means the enterprise is not operating optimally. This. In many EU countries, airports are currently severely -under-staffed. So much so that in several airports scheduled flights had to be canceled. Whatever the cause for low unemployment in Western countries is, it is definitely not the abundance of 'nonsense jobs' like in Japan.
- happyjack 4y agoI think the honest reality is that the game is rigged and dependent on a perpetual 7% growth type cycle. We have indebted future generations so much that it's going to crumble or the next 200 years of western civilization will be held to debt service. Millennials in western countries aren't having kids, and are stuck paying student loans (and other debt) while a 2 bedroom home in some suburbs that doesn't have a rotten foundation is $400k. How does the western world grow 7% (or whatever rate needed after taxes, inflation, and profit) perpetually with stagnating birth rates, lowering carbon footprints, and shrinking real wages? I'm not sure it can.
- epolanski 4y agoStudent loans are an American thing. I paid 500€s/year to graduate in chemistry in Italy and have not incurred any debt.
- c-fe 4y agoAnecdotal, I also thought they were just an american thing, but they are also common otherplaces such as UK and even the Netherlands
- m000 4y ago> Student loans are an American thing. Unfortunately, they're also becoming an "American export". E.g. Netherlands granted a study grant to all students up until 2015, when it was converted to a student loan [1]. The required amount is still lower and the terms are better than US, but the ball has started rolling. We are now waiting for the next wave of neoliberal policies to see average student debt surging. [1] https://www.wittenborg.eu/new-dutch-student-loans-system-start-2015.htm https://www.wittenborg.eu/new-dutch-student-loans-system-sta...
- nebula8804 4y agoWhy would you guys even allow this poison to infect your culture? We never had these benefits in the US so there was nothing to take away and many Americans are too poor to ever travel overseas and don't realize how things are done elsewhere. In fact even conservatives fight to maintain what we do have (eg. Social Security, Medicare) But Europe? You guys already have the benefits, aren't you going to get pissed off if they get taken away?
- christkv 4y agoThere are lags in the system. A massive amount of people for example have locked in mortgages at super low rates and until those reset will not be hit with the full effect of the inflation on their monthly payments.