14 ms·
The vertical farming bubble is finally popping
- h2odragon 4y ago"sea of green" works if you get $1/gram for your produce. few crops command that price.
- miguelazo 4y agoAnyone know how to get in on that AppHarvest fraud lawsuit?
- physicsguy 4y agoIt’s not that complicated, you can only easily grow calorie low food like lettuce in these conditions, and when energy prices rise it is no longer cost effective.
- uberman 4y ago"how did investors think that they could find Silicon Valley-style returns in . . . lettuce?" That made me laugh
- ilamont 4y agoGreater fool theory at work until the music stops. A story as old as the concept of investing.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoNot without proper carbon taxing and land use taxing. In a sane world, if vertical farming got even close to traditional farming without taxing in soil destruction, water table destruction, pesticide impacts, and habitat removal from nature, we'd transition rapidly to vertical farming. Politics is not reality. Neither is economics.
- Ekaros 4y agoHow do you supply enough power to vertical farms without those same externalities? And then how green is it to build and run them? Considering all the equipment, infra and inputs. It is not like that stuff magically comes from thin air with vertical farming.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoRenewables, but then you might as well farm on farmland and haul to urban areas with electric trucks. Vertical farms are another solution looking for a problem (unless you’re truly land constrained, like the Maldives)
- vanattab 4y agoI mean traditional farming and photosynthesis from the sun is the original form of renewable solar power we have had since the birth of civilization.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoTrue! But you can do some fun acts like using heat pumps in certain climates (the Netherlands, for example) to extend growing seasons or create them (if they don’t exist) all year long. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/article/holland-agriculture-sustainable-farming https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/article/holland-...
- pwthornton 4y agoThe biggest argument for vertical farms is that you'd be able to bring high-quality year around produce to more places. We do have most produce year around, but the quality of it varies wildly depending on the time of year. Most produce shipped from California and Mexico during growing off seasons is quite subpar. But this is an argument for quality, of which people would have to be willing to pay a premium for. I could see high-end restaurants and others wiling to pay for this. Greenhouses already extend the growing season. This would ideally be able to do that further.
- 4y ago
- Hypocritelefty 4y ago[dead]
- ilyt 4y agoThat's suggesting vertical farming is desirable outcome where it really isn't under most constraints. "Just" moving to hydroponics gives you most of the benefits (less pesticide/water usage, higher yield per area) and with birth rates stagnating "just" converting some of current fields would free up the area for mode wild nature.
- seizethecheese 4y agoReminds me of East of Eden.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoFor some reason that part of the story crosses my mind every now and then. The factor of ingenuity requiring appropriate timing, how misfortunate can make otherwise good ideas seem terrible, how things which once seemed bizarre are commonplace today, etc. I really enjoyed that book.
- FlyingSnake 4y agoJust like how they thought they could find returns in Juicero.
- LatteLazy 4y agoBy spending enormous amounts on tech, construction, energy and labour, we can free up agricultural land, which we already have enormous amounts of and has no actual value 99% of the time...
- blackbear_ 4y agoIf land is not needed for agriculture then can be used for something else, such as, you know, housing?
- runsWphotons 4y agoyes the famous housing crisis in rural Nebraska
- pphysch 4y agoFinding housing 100 miles away in Farmville has never been a challenge. The problem is most people don't want to live 100 miles away in Farmville and commute that distance.
- paxys 4y agoThere is unlimited land available for housing in the USA. The housing crisis stems from the fact that everyone wants to live in the same few square miles in every state. Converting agricultural land isn't going to fix the problem unless the farm is in downtown Manhattan.
- bombcar 4y agoExactly. Replace part of Central Park with a skyscraper apartment and it'll sell out instantly. Build the exact same building in East Palestine, Ohio and it'll sit empty for decades.
- Ekaros 4y agoOr solar panels to well run those vertical farms... The energy going into food has to come from somewhere. And I still don't believe the equation is net positive in natural vs. artificial light.
- mc32 4y agoMulti-story vertical farming doesn't make much sense unless we're living underground after a thermonuclear exchange of some sort with wide implications. What may make sense is enabling farming of locally out of season crops from "annuals". This already happens but it's not as cost competitive as importing from far-away (hemisphere away). Working on that makes more sense than trying to farm on multi-floor indoor facilities.
- Ekaros 4y agoAlso, if transport is really the big concern, shouldn't we work on optimizing that? Multiple solutions, from automation, to electric vehicles in many ways or even trains. It is not like the cargo is that time sensitive and distances that big.
- dredmorbius 4y agoTransportation cost is far less a concern in agriculture than transportation time, and that really only for time-sensitive crops which cannot be feasibly frozen, refrigerated, or processed. The other exception is goods which are consumed in quantity but cannot be light-weighted, most notably fresh dairy. Previously this might have included eggs, but their production has been hugely upscaled (with corresponding problems evidence presently in the form of bird-flu pandemics, flock culls, and consequent high prices for eggs and poultry). For bulk agricultural commodities, that is, staple grains, time-sensitivity is measured in months to years, and shipping is virtually a non-issue. For anything that can survive freezing, once a cold-chain is established, there's similarly little issue. This includes a great deal of meat, including much of what's served as "fresh" or uncooked, such as restaurant sushi (salmon sushi is in fact flash-frozen then thawed, in large part to kill parasites). Some fish and shellfish is best consumed fresh, though much is not and may be frozen or otherwise preserved (e.g., canned or pickled fish). Many non-frozen commodities can be refrigerated, notably apples and bananas, though there may be some cosmetic defects which occur, or mealiness for apples stored from the end of one harvest season to the beginning of the next. Transport is most critical in fresh fruits and some vegetables, though there are frequently alternatives (with some slight decrease in texture, though usually not in nutrition which may in fact be superior to unfrozen alternatives). These are generally not staples, and most households or food-service organisations can make do with substitutes. Much greater concerns for food generally are overall affordability, access, "food deserts" in which traditional grocery stores don't exist --- a problem previously largely applicable to blighted urban areas but not increasingly experienced in rural regions and some suburbs. This has also long been an issue with native communities such as reservations in the US and elsewhere. General nutritional balance is another issue, as is access to either food storage and preparation (particularly as housing becomes an increasingly fraught issue in more developed countries) or foodservice (commercial and noncommercial meal and food preparation). Vertical farming is ... very much a solution in search of a problem. The challenges are interesting, I'll grant, but not especially relevant. And largely, transportation pales relative to distribution, particularly in conjunction with other inequality factors. As for meal prep, it's interesting to reflect that the concept of equipping every single residence with full food storage and preparation facilities is a recent development (20th century, often surprisingly late) even in much of the developed world, and is compounded by the tendency to both "nuclear family" and small household (1--2 members) residences. In the late 19th century, individual apartments would have lacked food-preparation with residents eating shared meals in rooming houses, restaurants, pubs, or at work, and many households were both multi-generational and included (and fed) a significant service class. There were exceptions, but the modern 1--4 person household in which multiple meals had to be prepped and served daily is quite modern.
- uoaei 4y agoAre there examples of vertical farming facilities that are designed to use the natural sunlight when it is available? I'm imagining basically walls of well-placed mirrors. That would take care of quite a bit of the lighting costs, at least.
- temp12192021 4y ago> I'm imagining basically walls of well-placed mirrors. That would take care of quite a bit of the lighting costs, at least. ... or windows. We could call the building housing these green things "greenhouses."
- Ekaros 4y agoIf you are going to use land for mirrors. Couldn't you build well horizontally? And it would probably be quite a bit cheaper option.
- mjhay 4y agoYou need a lot of area for that - incident sunlight is proportional to land area. To get the same amount of sunlight, you'd need to cover around the same square footage of land as there is area in the vertical farm with mirrors, and then cleverly redirect that back into the vertical farm - kind of like a solar power tower. What would be even cleverer is to just plant the crops where the sun falls in the first place, and just do one layer of crops directly in the soil already present in that location. This would obviate the need for the multi-story tower, mirrors, soil transportation, etc. A "non-vertical farm," if you will. I think it could be a real money spinner!
- bombcar 4y agoThis is the thing - even if your vertical wall gets sunlight, it's just "stealing" it from whatever is now in its shadow.
- ianburrell 4y agoInstead of mirrors, I wonder if it would make sense to have greenhouses with artificial lights for winter and night. The original vertical farming idea was farms in buildings in the city. It has changed to focus on premium greens year round. To solve the year round garden problem, it would be better to grow them in enhanced greenhouses. Then could use sunlight when available and LEDs the rest of the time for decrease in costs and increase in efficiency. There would be no improvement in land usage but even big cities have empty land nearby. I sort of think current vertical farming pivoted when original idea didn't work, but there is better way to do the pivot.
- jagtstronaut 4y agoI majored in Ag for my bachelors and can confirm that all the research at the time was pointing to that this is not a good idea. It is many times more energy inefficient that just growing things in soil. Kinda like biofuels, sounds really cool, but in practice it just creates more waste then the alternatives. Only time this actually works and makes money is for high end restaurants in massive metroplexes. They are willing to pay high dollar for extremely fresh lettuce. At one point the containers company was turning a decent profit in NYC. I’m assuming it didn’t scale like they were hoping.
- dontlaugh 4y agoSome biofuels can be efficient to produce, especially oils for diesel engines. Some paths for producing ethanol for petrol engines can be efficient too, but that’s a bit harder. It’s definitely often a scam to continue fossil fuel dependence, though.
- legitster 4y agoAny project that "reuses" shipping containers is a big red flag for me. Used shipping containers are not actually particularly cheap and already have plenty of demand. And for the purpose of building or construction projects they provide next to no value.
- jonathankoren 4y agoYeah. I got fascinated with tiny houses and vertical farms because I liked the potential modularity and transportability, but when you actually look into, you don't really need containerization (let alone actually reused shipping containers) at all. The houses, farms, whatever, are rarely transported anywhere. Instead you're left with 12 metal posts, and an aesthetic.
- tonyarkles 4y agoYeah, I did the math at one point on using seacans for a few different projects and at least around here they weren’t at all competitive against stick-built structures. They’re easy to transport multi-modal. That’s what they’ve got going for them. If they didn’t need to be lifted by cranes and stacked, they could be cheaper (structurally weaker), but then they’d be useless for their intended use. I do see them used a fair bit around here for job-site offices though, but that’s again using them roughly for their intended use: put it on an 18-wheeler, work out of it for a few months, and then pick it up and take it to the next place
- madsbuch 4y agoVertical farming makes sense when energy is cheaper than what we get from the sun. That will also unlock growing other crops than lettuce, for which energy is the biggest hurdle. The main value propositions are that we don't occupy land as we do with conventional farming and that automation is easier in a controlled setting. IMHO, vertical farming is a part of the next wave of industrialisation together with real AI, space travel for the masses, etc. But this requires that we fix an energy sourcing problem and does it without externalities.
- legitster 4y ago> Vertical farming makes sense when energy is cheaper than what we get from the sun. Uhhh, is there any energy cheaper than what we get from the sun?
- bell-cot 4y ago6 months every year, at the South Pole Station. Or 12 months per year...until you run out of gullible VC's.
- goda90 4y agoHigh latitudes where there sun might disappear for months. For example, in Iceland, geothermal powered greenhouses are quite successful. Geothermal is plentiful, and it's expensive to ship fresh produce to such a small island nation.
- legitster 4y agoThat's fair. Although I suspect these types of ventures are already profitable without any tech VC money.
- madsbuch 4y agoThe word "when" indicates a future tense. This is limited, as you can hear from the other responses ridiculing this comment. However, it should probably be expected that this will happen in the future more broadly.
- legitster 4y ago> More traditional greenhouses already grow a large percentage of the tomatoes eaten in the United States, for example (most come from Mexico and Canada). In the Netherlands, greenhouses grow nearly a million tons of tomatoes a year, along with other crops, making the country a major food exporter despite its tiny size. It boggles my mind - the technology already exists and is profitable in the form of a hydroponic greenhouse. So what you paid for as an investor was a bunch of R&D research on how to replace natural and free sunlight with LEDs. (The fact that there are investor decks out there pitching that energy costs could be offset by investments in solar panels is laughably hilarious.). Even your average field farmer is no slouch. I was just having a conversation with our neighbor, an orchardist who manages over 200 acres of trees. He currently pays $60k a year in just in SaaS fees to cover all of the technology on his farm. Your average (productive) farm is already a miracle of modern automation.
- orangeoxidation 4y ago> So what you paid for as an investor was a bunch of R&D research on how to replace natural and free sunlight with LEDs. (The fact that there are investor decks out there pitching that energy costs could be offset by investments in solar panels is laughably hilarious.). Some of those already existing greenhouses are using LEDs to augment natural sunlight. [0] So it doesn't seem too far fetched to me. The gamble wasn't to replace (free) sunlight with (paid) LEDs. The core idea is stacking farms on top each other, hoping the reduced land (area) requirement vs increased energy cost might pay off. Turns out land isn't that short, transportation not too expensive and energy not that cheap. [0] https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/glowing-dutch-greenhouse-photos https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/glowing-dutch-greenhou...
- mediaman 4y agoWhat's crazy is that all these variables were known ahead of time. What is the cost of real estate in rural upstate New York? It's really not that bad! (About $10k per acre, based on a brief search, for land about 280 miles away from Manhattan. A truck could make a delivery in six hours or so.) So why spend millions in capital expenditures on fancy stacked farms with high tech intense lighting, in order to cut a few tens of thousands of dollars in real estate costs? The argument was that logistics costs were high. That's kind of true if you're on the east coast, and your alternative is importing from Mexico or California. It's not true at all if you can get produce from a conventional hydroponic operation six hours away by truck. Moreover, it's not like conventional hydroponic operations didn't exist, and this was some sort of tail risk that was unexpected. The conventional hydroponic operations already existed! They've been in business for years. All the founders or investors had to do was drive a few hours to go visit them. Or pick up the phone.
- AlexandrB 4y agoI wonder what the net efficiency of operating LED lighting from solar power would be. The obvious advantage of traditional farms is that some inputs, most notably light, are free. But if you consider solar panel efficiency, the cost of mining raw materials and manufacturing panels, LEDs, and power components, I wonder how much worse indoor farming is. Is it 10% efficient? 50% efficient?
- SAI_Peregrinus 4y agoWith an solar cell with an infinite number of layers the maximum efficiency for normal sunlight is 68.7% to go from light->electricity[1]. Real cells don't have infinite numbers of layers, so conversion efficiency is around 25% for single-layer monocrystalline silicon cells. Those have a maximum possible efficiency of 32%. Current LEDs are around 40-50% efficient. So 45% efficient LED * 25% efficient solar = about 12% total efficiency. [1] A. De Vos & H. Pauwels (1981). "On the Thermodynamic Limit of Photovoltaic Energy Conversion". Appl. Phys. 25 (2): 119–125. Bibcode:1981ApPhy..25..119D. doi:10.1007/BF00901283. S2CID 119693148.
- londons_explore 4y agoHowever, you also get the uplift in efficiency from the fact plants prefer certain wavelengths of light, and have nearly no use for others (eg. green). And LED's are good at producing certain wavelengths of light. Not sure how to calculate that...
- neatze 4y agoThis seems to be not the case, most recent LED's grow lights are full spectrum.
- londons_explore 4y agoI think that's just because full spectrum LED's are cheaper because they're made in massive quantities for lighting homes and offices. If you were designing a set of LED's purely for plant growth, and making them in sufficient quantities that you can design your own dopant concentrations etc, then you probably wouldn't end up with full spectrum LED's.
- killjoywashere 4y agoHaving spent some of my time in high school (in Nebraska) working in a greenhouse, I'm scratching my head trying to figure out the value proposition for most of these companies. I kind of wonder if this was all motivated by that movie "The Martian" where Matt Damon was growing potatoes on Mars with hydrazine.
- ausbah 4y ago"In theory, there are enormous benefits to indoor farms. They often use 90% less water than traditional farms; right now, most lettuce in the country is grown in drought-stricken California and Arizona. Growing inside can avoid outbreaks of E. coli and diseases like a plant virus that recently devastated lettuce grown in California’s Salinas Valley, pushing up prices. Indoor farming also eliminates pesticides and reduces fertilizer and keeps it out of rivers. Lettuce grown near Boston or New York City can avoid traveling thousands of miles from Western fields, saving gas and staying fresh longer. It’s possible to grow delicate, flavorful foods that otherwise wouldn’t survive a long trip through the supply chain. And as climate change makes extreme heat, drought, and flooding more likely, growing inside could become a necessity for some crops."
- ambientenv 4y agoIt feels, to me anyway, that until the incentives are less about making a (short-term and relatively immediate) profit for a select and limited number of people/eintities and more about the long term health of the planet and its inhabitants, these endeavours will ultimately fail. Which is possibly a shame as we should pursue technical solutions to our challenges, along with economic and behavioural. It comes down to what we value - we, being the human population and independent of what we are instructed, coerced or manipulated to value.
- abledon 4y agoI'm guessing AgTech in general still has a bright future? e.g. outside drones and farming robots?
- college_physics 4y agoAll bubbles have something wasteful about them as they do not represent calculated risk-taking but rather a suspension of healthy skepticism that is driven by informational echo chambers, ultra-cheap money and other such degenerate macro phenomena. This leads to more widespread failures than what is warranted for a given quantum of risk because they are all copycat failures. It will be interesting to see which of the countless tech-related bubbles of the last decade will grow roots. Vertical farming is not the worst offender, hopefully something has been learned in the process.
- ulnarkressty 4y agoInterviewed a couple of years ago at a vertical farming startup. All the usual talk about making the world a better place through technology (and machine learning for some reason). I asked where the electricity came from, turns out they were literally burning coal to grow some salad not very efficiently. Hydroponic farms have been studied for decades, they are super optimized but they have their limits as well - see the 10 GBP bell peppers in supermarkets today. I would really like to know how the numbers look like when comparing traditional hydroponic with these hyper-local vertical farms.
- beambot 4y agoI'm confused. This is an article purports to be about vertical farming, but then calls out AppHarvest -- a company building heavily automated (aquaponic?) traditional greenhouses. There are at least a half-dozen AppHarvest-esque greenhouse companies, and they almost all have positive farm economics (positive EBITDA). Same is true for many of the greenhouse-based fruit & veg outfits.
- outworlder 4y agoI wonder if those startups would have better luck by focusing on research and getting a contract from NASA or similar. On Earth vertical farms only make sense in very specific niches. But, if you are not on Earth, then it becomes more interesting. Research grants wouldn't rise to the crazy VC valuations though. Maybe that's why they don't bother.
- julienchastang 4y agoSlightly off topic, but I saw this video [0] about a retired postal worker in Nebraska who grows citrus fruit in an ingeniously designed greenhouse heated with geothermal. (Not magma geothermal, but earth tubes geothermal that treats the ground as an infinite thermodynamic reservoir. Works in the same way as a refrigerator.) Can anyone here comment on if this could be done at scale? Could the economics be feasible? [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZD_3_gsgsnk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZD_3_gsgsnk
- Topgamer7 4y agoI recall that video. I wonder how the math compares of their costs during the summer, vs the cost of transportation.
- smileysteve 4y agoSure, you need to avoid frost in the greenhouse; which there is an insulation factor from the walls and glass; and that's only 37 degree f; a lot less than human habitable spaces. Does it scale? Profitably, no, because transportation of oranges from California and Florida to Nebraska is currently quick and cheap.
- julienchastang 4y agoThe issue of temperature control is covered extensively in the video as are some economic concerns (he sells oranges at NE farmer's markets!). What I wonder is if this could be a viable business. Land and possibly water could be cheap in that part of the country. Energy costs are negligible due to the design. Of course, there would have to be a big upfront capital expenditure and some time to get something like this going.
- cmonagle 4y agoI think this has come up on HN before, but Low Tech Magazine has a great piece about citrus production in the Soviet Union: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2020/04/fruit-trenches-cultivating-subtropical-plants-in-freezing-temperatures.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2020/04/fruit-trenches-cul...
- steponlego 4y agoIt was a stupid idea in the first place. In fact it's so mind-bendingly stupid that the classice British comedy show Brass Eye parodied it like 30 years ago.
- dpflan 4y agoThe Netherlands is mentioned once with a link another article. If its greenhouse technology is so good, were there any viable innovations building upon their success? There seems to be a lot of informed, quality discussion by HNers, are any knowledge of the Netherlands situation?
- fleddr 4y agoIt appears to me that Silicon Valley is unaware that there's such a thing as Food Valley. Which does exactly what you ask for. Food Valley centers around the Dutch University of Wageningen, the pinnacle of agricultural research, teamed up with a network of innovative food companies and experts.
- dpflan 4y agoThank you, this is awesome. Here is a link: https://www.wur.nl/en/article/Foodvalley-2.htm https://www.wur.nl/en/article/Foodvalley-2.htm
- tomrod 4y agoI think the place for this would be on colonies off Earth.
- 1970-01-01 4y ago1. Secure indoor farming tech 2. Establish lunar colony 3. Import fresh moon lettuce 4. Charge restaurants $$$$ per leaf There seems to be a big gap between step 1 and 2.
- tomrod 4y agoLunar restaurants are the gap :>
- dymk 4y agoWhy did these companies start with boring stuff like lettuce? The article says that indoor growing like this could allow growing delicate plants which don't travel well - why wouldn't they start with that?
- jethro_tell 4y agoBecause lettuces has a short growing cycle. One of the best cases for artificial light is that it can be used in times when natural light is not enough. If you have a crop like lettuces, that you can only grow 2x per year and now you can grow 12x per year in the same space it's easier to make the case than something like garlic that can be in the ground up to 8-9 months. If you can only turn the 'ground' or pod over once/year just like normal than you're only getting the stacking, but you could just use shelves in a greenhouse then and skip most of the tech. Strawberries are another good one, you can only double your production in beds with a 6 month growing cycle, (granted, you can stagger your growing cycles in an artificial environment). An awful lot of small scale farming is about turning over the resources you have as fast as possible to put product on the market and that is the same for flat land farming and vertical farming. It's not unlike other kinds of startups where you aim for an mvp maybe even a profitable mvp before you move on to the complex stuff for the big customers. Lettuces is a small farming MVP regardless of the tech used for farming (vertical, greenhost, flatland).
- mentalpiracy 4y agoin addition to the very good sibling comment: lettuce is also a cold-tolerant crop that can grow well at 50F, whereas other popular consumer produce like tomatoes or peppers require minimum soil temperatures of 75-85F for optimal growth. Managing that optimal growing environment gets costly quick. Another important factor: lettuce grows uniformly, and the whole plant is harvested at once. There is no pollination required, no trellis-training for production vines, or fruiting bodies that must be plucked when ripe. Lettuce is about as straightforward as you can get in terms of mass production.
- Depurator 4y agoIn the emergence of new sectors backed by technology focused venture capital this scenario is to be expected though. Often these bubbles are depicted as hype cycles, where you have inflated expectations of a particular technology, which show disappointing real world performance leading to a dip in confidence where ultimately a long term productive solution emerges. Another way to think about this process is to take an evolutionary approach to technolgy development. Initially there's a lot variation of various firms trying to solve a particular problem, each with their own solution based on more or less novel technology. The issue is the selection phase where the technolgy competes in the real world and compete not only against other technological solutions but in a sociotechnical system including e.g. regional institutions such as local culture, regulations, politics, markets that are often aligned with the existing industry. Ultimately one or a few solutions are retained and integrated into our collective infrastructure and provide a consistant solution to the original problem, and in a capitalistic model - profitable returns.
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm still not clear from the article, though. Is this just a normal bubble popping, where out of 20 companies trying, 18 go out of business but the final 2 succeed and take over the market and will produce a bunch of profit over the next couple of decades? And if so, do we have an idea which companies? Or is the very premise economically flawed, where it turns out it can't be profitable ever, at least not with current energy and produce prices? And if so, how did these startups get their models so wrong -- what did we learn that couldn't be foreseen?
- lorepieri 4y agoAll of them going bust, as the economics are wildly off vs the status quo.
- thinkharderbro 4y agonot all, some are geographically diversified and will continue to operate as long as the oil bucks from the middle east continue to flow
- rmason 4y agoI've called out most of the vertical farming stories on HN because the numbers simply weren't there. The growing cost was simply too high even if you were growing the highest value crops possible to ever make a return for investors. However if in the future the price of electricity becomes almost free then it may be possible. I grew up in the sixties when the nuclear power industry promised power, 'too cheap to meter'. We may see it from either geothermal or fusion in the next twenty five years and it will be a true game changer.
- steve_adams_86 4y ago> if in the future the price of electricity becomes almost free I think about this sometimes. If you could eventually throw a fusion reactor somewhere and build some crazy huge vertical farms around it, regulate their temperature with geothermal energy, maybe even produce your own nitrogen since the energy is so cheap and you're going to use a heap of the stuff, etc... You could probably make it cheaper, faster, and more efficient in the long term than regular farming. Outputs could be so fast, reliable, and high quality that over say, 25 years you'd never skip a beat due to environmental conditions (barring serious disasters), your automation investments would pay off like crazy, and your outputs would scale so much better than traditional farms that you'd outsell them significantly. But that's an insane requirement. At this point it's like saying "Imagine if we had magic, and we could use it to make a business that's physically impossible at the moment". Cool, but... Why?
- ynab4 4y ago[dead]
- cushychicken 4y agoFormer AppHarvest employee (by acquisition). That place was an unqualified fuckshow. Not surprising they’re being sued for fraud. “There are many reasons why they’re doing it, but one of the reasons is because they know that Silicon Valley investors won’t invest in a farm, but they’ll invest in a tech company,” says Henry Gordon-Smith, founder of Agritecture, a firm that consults on urban farming projects. “In reality, these companies overspend on R&D by crazy amounts, and then say, ‘Oh, shit, that didn’t work.'” This could have been taken from internal communications almost verbatim. The CEO straight up cited my former employer’s acquisition was significantly motivated to position AppHarvest as a tech company, rather than an ag company, for the purpose of propping up the valuation.
- Melatonic 4y agoNot surprised but this also misses some of the big wins of vertical farms - big increases in sustainability. Money is not everything - and if it can be profitable (even if it is less profitable than outside) it could potentially still make sense. Realistically though I think this will not see bigger use until we actually get fusion power working and/or it becomes more useful on places like the Moon or in environments where there is far less natural sunlight (like very northern latitudes)
- a1371 4y ago> Money is not everything I don't think that's true for the VC-funded startups. I actually expect to hear that from the farmers I have known in my life. With the margins I saw, they were not in it for money. They would pride themselves in being self-sufficient, living off the land, and co-living with the nature. ABF -- Always Be Farming -- they say. I have yet to see an actual environmental lifecycle analysis of these "disruptive" vertical farms. That amount of steel, precious metal, and plastic that goes into making a facility has high upfront Embodied Carbon. Can that really have a pay back compared to when you use the sun and the land? How many acres of land can you really replace with a farm on top of an abandoned parking lot? What they say about vertical farms is way too rosy. They must compare their methods with borderline medieval farming techniques to calculate some 99% efficiency improvement. Farmers today care as much about biodiversity, ecology, and sustainability as anybody else, if not more.
- Decabytes 4y agoI don't see this as damning for the concept of vertical farms. It sounds more like a damning of tech companies trying to pass themselves off as farming companies, riding the wave of venture capital money, and spending it all on in house tech stacks, bloated salaries, buildings, and solar panels without having a proper business plan to pay it all back
- pcthrowaway 4y agoAnd people were saying it was going to up forever
- notyourday 4y agoWait. You folks think they are investing it to grow lettuce or tomatoes?! It is not. It is grow pot! The reason they are folding is that it is taking too long to pass the legislation allowing it on both state and federal level. They were just too early.
- unlikelymordant 4y agoHow does pot change the economics? If it becomes legal, it will be cheaper to grow it in greenhouses just like its cheaper to grow lettuce in greenhouses.
- notyourday 4y agoVertical integration right next to consumers.
- nicd 4y agoWhat benefit is there to growing pot next to consumers? Compared to salads, for example, isn't pot easily stored and transported?