18 ms·
LED lighting badly suppresses human melatonin production at night
- karlkloss 4y agoThe author should really rethink the idea of using kerosene lamps in his home. They produce tons of particulate matter, so you're trading one potential cancer risk with another confirmed cancer risk.
- xupybd 4y agoI have had led lights for over a decade. Come 10:30pm every night I'm falling asleep with no problem.
- gopalv 4y ago> Come 10:30pm every night I'm falling asleep with no problem. I'd have said N=1 vs the study out there, but I too work with screens & LED lighting all the time & the "light spectrum" that affects me is not exactly the indoor component. My personal theory is that the daytime to nightime being about the same lighting is what sucks. When the total range of lighting varies a lot, I don't feel as bad. A lot of my troubles have gone away with a sun room in my house, where I can get bright light without being exactly outdoor. You might just have enough contrast in your day/night lighting for it to not matter to your perception. Unlike a lot of the people who are either indoors all the time or just switch from an LED lit office to an LED lit living room after work. Improving those with a proper sunlamp might be a good way around it, but they're expensive & sometimes feels like overkill.
- xupybd 4y ago>I'd have said N=1 vs the study out there, but I too work with screens & LED lighting all the time & the "light spectrum" that affects me is not exactly the indoor component. Yeah my anecdote proves nothing. But for what ever reason they don't seem to impact my sleep. Just throwing my data point out there. Also my wife hates the sharp white light so we always go for the warm yellow LEDs.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoI’ve spent protracted periods of time with pretty consistent lighting all day and never had trouble sleeping. LEDs seem to have no effect on me, and I’ve slept till noon outside with bright Caribbean sun shining on my face. I know a lot of people like that. My theory is that being obsessed with sleeping makes it hard to come by. Good luck applying that though.
- etaioinshrdlu 4y agoThis is a very long article and I didn't read it all, but I'm completely sure we can make LED bulbs which approximate the spectrum of incandescent if we want.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Eisenstein 4y agoThat is really the 'holy grail' of LED manufacturing, and we have not been able to do it yet. See: CRI. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_rendering_index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_rendering_index
- Syonyk 4y agoI would indeed appreciate you reading the whole thing... I did write it to be read, and while it's long, I promise I don't blather on pointlessly. At least by my standards. But I agree with you. I think we absolutely can make multi-emitter LED bulbs that reproduce the spectrum of incandescent bulbs, being low in the blue, etc. I know people who have looked into exactly that sort of thing, have researched relevant LEDs, good dimmers, etc. They run into the problem that to do something like that, you're looking at a BOM north of $100 (implying a far higher retail price), which is rather at odds with "anyone actually buying the thing." So I have to ask, "Why are you sure?" I've explained how our current white LEDs work (blue pumped is the most efficient, violet pumped is somewhat better but less efficient), and the work involved in blue and white LEDs literally led to a Nobel Prize (https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2014/press-release/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2014/press-release...). Physics doesn't have to grant us what we want, and if your goal is "cheap white LEDs that reproduce incandescent spectrums," nobody, so far, has come up with such a thing.
- 000ooo000 4y agoAndrew Huberman of Huberman Lab podcast discusses this in the first 4-5 episodes of the podcast. The takeaway is: it's late-night bright light, rather than blue light, that has effects on the circadian rhythm. It's an appeal to authority but I think I'll go with the professor of neurobiology and opthalmology on this one.
- zachruss92 4y agoHe also did an interview with a person from the NIMH who personally only uses candle light past dark. It makes sense when you think about it. Also apparently overhead lights are worse- the angle makes a difference.
- adammarples 4y agoCandles also supposedly awful for PM 2.5
- Syonyk 4y agoThey are. Any sort of "open flame burner" is likely to emit an awful lot of PM 2.5. However, most of the lanterns (think your standard "hurricane lantern" or "cold blast lantern") are quite clean burning. I've been using lanterns for a while now, and I have the equipment to measure PM2.5 and PM10 (post author here, you can find reviews of my lanterns and my particulate sensors elsewhere on my blog). The lanterns are "basically zero" in terms of PM2.5 and PM10 in the exhaust stream, and when you dig into papers talking about kerosene lighting and particulates, they come to the same conclusions - most of the particulate is from the open flame kerosene burners, not the actual lanterns. I use lanterns in my office in the winter for some extra heat (I'm the "solar shed" guy, winter sucks during inversions), and I see a fairly rapid rise in CO2 levels (about like another 2-3 people in my space), but I don't see high PM2.5 unless I've got an actual open flame candle going.
- ianai 4y agoHow about the fake candles? I went through a period where as soon as I got home and out of the shower I’d go dark. I had a battery powered lamp that I used exclusively. I’d wear an eye mask with something to listen to playing. It definitely helped. I can definitely feel blue light waking me up much more easily than red. (Worked swing shift until midnight at that point.)
- snshn 4y agoThis is why OLED lights is the future: http://www.ioledlight.com/ http://www.ioledlight.com/ and https://www.oledworks.com/ https://www.oledworks.com/
- mouth 4y agoI have been following OLED lights for a while and they seem to have fizzled out from a consumer perspective. Unfortunate as I would love to install them in my house.
- rdsubhas 4y agoDoesn't OLED tech (in TVs, screens) also works by having a blue emitter with filters for white/ colors (which is what the article covers) ?
- maximus-decimus 4y agoJust the QD-OLED I think.
- snshn 4y agoThis is different. Those OLEDs are transparent, only have one emitter.
- xoa 4y ago>find "r9" >no results >find "cri" >no results in post :/. This is definitely an important and I think unappreciated issue right now, and I'm normally all for long form investigations too. But I don't think this piece structured it very well. It started losing me right at the beginning with what felt like an outdated description of technology applied too broadly, and then not actually bothering to cover the very real improvements changing things until the very end, and even then putting off concrete coverage of who deserves kudos until later. It goes >They’re internally blue LEDs with a phosphor coating that shifts some of the energy from blue over to the rest of the spectrum - the reds, yellows, and greens. >They look white to the eye, but they’re actually three separate peaks of light, and they don’t do a very good job rendering colors. But this seems unnecessarily hand-wavey. We have actual specific measures for this in the form of CRI (color rendering index, 0-100 with natural outdoor light being 100) and R9 (a measure of strong red rendering, which most people tend to like, incandescents tend to be in the 90s). It's definitely true that lots of common cheap LED bulbs have poor CRI and R9, and even these aren't necessarily linked either. But it's also perfectly possible to get decent bulbs that do both ok or focus well on things like helping sleep. The plain old Ikea Tradfri E27 White (like $12) has a CRI of 90 and an R9 of 91. There is a specific sleep focused "bedtimebulb" that has a CRI all the way up at 95 and a respectable R9 in the mid-80s. The Ketra line of lighting gets specific about this as well. This isn't some impossible problem. Which the article does kind of acknowledge, but only at the very end. If more people knew to look for and ask for these measures, then the market could better respond accordingly. It could be worked into various lighting standards as well for work and government. But "LED lights and screens are killing you" from the beginning doesn't strike me as a good approach. Basically, the lede should have been the "future reviews" bit and the author should have waited on doing them first because otherwise it's just defeatist. Give people something that is actually actionable, not a "well you're screwed and that's that" because nobody is giving up their screens. Structure should be "these things matter and are in fact being done with more to come, but most don't know to look for these measures and they are far too hard to find, this is something that action should be taken on." Then get into the nitty gritty of why. The goal should be something people can take with them, like at a schoolboard meeting parents being able to ask about the CRI/R9 and general quality of their children's lighting.
- 4y ago
- karmaMeansCool 4y agoThere are also probably very personal and biological variables involved too that the post doesn't mention. I stare into monitors and phones all day long. Every light in the house is full-blown LED. I can't help but fall asleep at 20:00 in an led lit room watching led TVs, while my led phone drops onto the floor after I've fallen asleep. I've been in an extreme LED environment for over a decade and never have problems waking up at 6:30 and falling asleep in bed at 22:00. I totally agree with concern raised by the article, but I also think it lacks the whole picture of someone's lifestyle. People have struggled with sleep issues well before LEDs.
- jahsome 4y agoI've battled the opposite in the form of clinical, anxiety-driven insomnia my whole life. I've found it utterly debilitating at times and have quite literally struggled since birth, long before electronics and LEDs were common. I can confidently say you're so right about the number (and type) of variables. Sleep hygiene as we say in the biz is a very complex and personal issue. I've tried everything under the sun from strict routine, screen avoidance, both abstinence from and ample sex, more reading, less reading, zero caffeine, limited caffeine, ALL THE CAFFEINE, changes to diet, fasting, supplements, and even medication. There are usually relatively minor, short lived improvements but it's only a matter of time before I'm spending my nights once again staring at the ceiling, mind at full-tilt. Whenever sleep comes up in conversation, and I mention my struggles, I feel like invariably I'm met with a response along the lines of "you _just_ have to...", and "have you ever tried ...?" followed by some arbitrary rule or herbal remedy. Since about the the introduction of the first iPad, consensus seems to have formed the root of all sleep evil is screentime. Sleep (for some) is an incredibly sensitive and personal struggle. Alarmist "mankind is doomed!" make it even harder to understand the greater picture. It's closely related to diet. There's always some fad trending, and a number of people who find success in choosing a "better" diet almost always have a system they'll fervently claim is The Way. The science is relatively clear on light though. I just appear to be some form of mutant.
- piazz 4y agoYou sound like me (unfortunately). Did you ever find anything that helped?
- jakedata 4y agoI am a big fan of LEDs but the strobe effect is maddening and it only gets worse as they are dimmed. AC power crosses zero volts with every cycle so you need a driver circuit that can compensate. Most don't do a good job and I have replaced bulbs and dimmers multiple times to come up with something acceptable. At the family camp, I retired my kerosene and propane mantle lamps in favor of solar battery powered LEDs many years ago. It was a matter of safety and convenience at the time, especially with children everywhere. The LEDs are powered directly from DC and I have no problem at all with them. https://imgur.com/gallery/bqS6uSV https://imgur.com/gallery/bqS6uSV https://imgur.com/gallery/YEa3V63 https://imgur.com/gallery/YEa3V63
- grvdrm 4y agoInteresting comment. I have a number of MR16 bulbs in my house that were previously halogen and are now mostly LED. They are a near constant source of frustration with bulbs burning out way too soon, some with what seems like wiring issues, a mix of incompatible switches, etc. Curious to hear what acceptable solution you derived?
- Paianni 4y agoAre they low-voltage lamps? (usually have a GU5.3 base). If they are powered by old transformers intended for halogen lamps it might be worth changing the transformers to ones meant for LEDs. Incidentally if there are dimmer switches in the circuits then those might have to be changed too.
- grvdrm 4y agoYea, 5.3 base. Any thoughts on how to check the transformers? Is it as annoying as I assume because the transformer is hiding somewhere in the ceiling? I've otherwise tried switch changes, but as you point out with the transformer, it might be that more than one component needs a change. And maybe it's worth changing everything back to halogen!?
- jakedata 4y agohttps://www.lamps-on-line.com/leading-trailing-edge-led-dimmers https://www.lamps-on-line.com/leading-trailing-edge-led-dimm... Good dimmable LED bulbs from quality manufacturers like Philips dim very well with many incandescent (leading edge) dimmers. Usually these bulbs are larger and have space in the base for a driver circuit that derives a brightness signal from the waveform rather than passing through the chopped current. Smaller bulbs with no built-in driver are much more suited to dimming using a trailing edge dimmer or dedicated LED driver. These strobe like mad on a traditional dimmer switch but may benefit from having a single incandescent bulb on the same circuit to round off the waveform a bit. For one difficult circuit I put a 5w ceramic resistor in parallel with the lighting to smooth out the dimming response between two different fixtures.
- adamwong246 4y agoPeople think I am weird for cranking the Night Shift setting on my mac to the max but it really helps. Sure wish we had better e-ink screens.
- Syonyk 4y agoIt helps, certainly. At least with my experience (post author), it doesn't actually fix the problem. There are a variety of e-ink HDMI displays out there, though. They're simply "very, very expensive."
- econonut 4y agoOn a recent renovation of our home, my wife and I decided to upgrade all of our lighting to LEDs with adjustable color temperatures. In the morning, and during the day, our house is illuminated with 5000k, but in the evening when we're preparing dinner the color temp is lowered down to 3500k and then down further to 2700k after dinner. It's much easier on our eyes and it feels like it's made a difference, but after reading through this it seems we likely still have some of the blue light coming through at night. Could you recommend a (inexpensive) spectrometer for testing our lights?
- Syonyk 4y agoCheck the previous post about my spectrometer. You're doing the right thing, but I have a bunch of "smart bulb LED" posts coming up, and even the color shifting ones blat out an awful lot of blue compared to an incandescent, and they don't dim worth a damn.
- colordrops 4y agoAnd what reflected light would you use with your e-ink display?
- Syonyk 4y agoLanterns (incandescent kerosene), or incandescent lights. The Kobo Clara HD is rather easier to read in low light than my aging Kobo Aura. It also has warm glow, but I'm not sure it matters, and the better reflectance on the display is the major win.
- mhb 4y agoI don't understand the graph of Irradiance vs. Wavelength for an ebook vs. print book. It looks like the print book was read in the dark? Help.
- Syonyk 4y agoIt looks at the emitted energy from the screen. The ebook emits directly, a foot from your face. The paper book is reflected energy, at a rather higher reflectance and a rather lower energy. It's amazing how dim a light you can read a paper book in vs an e-ink ereader.
- coldtea 4y agoPhotons are photons, reflected or not. So what prevents the ebook to lower the brightness of backlight to match the energy of the reflected light from a paper book? (For e-ink ebook readers, can't they just be read without backlight, with just reflected light?)
- Syonyk 4y agoShort answer is "They don't go that dim." I don't know if there's a technical limitation or it's just not done, but the "1%" frontlight (most e-ink displays are frontlights, LCDs are just awful for every aspect of reading) is quite a bit brighter than reflected. E-ink readers absolutely can be read without backlight, and I've experimented with that vs the frontlight for the past few months. The older ones (my Kobo Aura) require a lot of light to be readable, but are readable without much trouble by kerosene lantern. The newer ones (Kobo Clara HD) are better, and require less light, but all of them require an awful lot more light than a paper book.
- seba_dos1 4y ago> (For e-ink ebook readers, can't they just be read without backlight, with just reflected light?) Usually you need more reflected light to read from e-paper because of worse contrast.
- MavisBacon 4y ago
- api 4y agoOne thing I haven’t seen mentioned is all the supplementation with melatonin people are doing. Does ingested melatonin still have the same protective effects?
- moozilla 4y agoI was also surprised to not see this discussed in the article. Melatonin supplementation seems like the obvious solution given how cheap and easily available it is. It can also go hand-in-hand with interventions the author suggests like f.lux or using dimmer lights. Lots of good discussion and links to studies about efficacy here: https://gwern.net/melatonin https://gwern.net/melatonin tl;dr - yes it works and is much easier/cheaper than other things
- Syonyk 4y agoI've not looked into it that much (yet). Short answer, from my view, is that if we've screwed up lighting enough that we need supplements, the easier option is to fix lighting.
- kelnos 4y agoI was thinking about this too, and I'm not sure I agree. Last year I replaced the last of the incandescent lighting in my house with LED. Most of the LED blubs I've bought are 2700K, but it sounds like from what your blog post says, they may still have too much blue light in them? The savings on my utility bill were immediate and more significant than I expected, and the bulbs themselves were not cheap. So I'm a bit hesitant to switch back. I've already taken melatonin supplements on and off for years with positive results: I've had sleep issues since I was a kid, definitely before I was in front of LED-lit screens all the time, and well before home LED lighting was a thing. I may be suffering from some sort of sunk-cost fallacy, but especially given that I've always had (probably non-light-related) sleep issues, it feels "simpler" to just leave my lighting as is, and take some melatonin a few hours before bed. Obviously I'd prefer LED lighting that has better spectrum emissions, but as you note elsewhere, that product would be significantly more expensive. I do agree with you that it seems perverse to break ourselves with our technology and rely on supplements to fix it, but I think wholesale going back to incandescent lighting just isn't going to fly from an energy policy perspective. And I don't think burning fossil fuels in our home (kerosene lanterns) is a great idea; that's just trading one health problem for another. I think at this point our realistic choices are: a) finding a way to make efficient, cheap "white" LEDs that don't blast out blue light, or b) some new yet-to-be-invented technology that has similar power consumption as LEDs, but healthier emission spectra. I just don't see incandescent lighting (or kerosene lanterns) as serious, realistic contenders for the future. Edit: it seems OLED is actually quite a bit better when it comes to blue light emissions? (https://www.oledworks.com/news/blog/the-hazards-of-blue-light-from-leds/ https://www.oledworks.com/news/blog/the-hazards-of-blue-ligh...) I wonder what is holding OLED back from consumer lighting. Perhaps cost?
- walterbell 4y agoComparison of sub-$20 LED Light Bulbs with low Kelvin, 90+ CRI and low flicker, https://gembared.com/blogs/musings/the-best-daytime-white-light-bulbs-for-health-enthusiasts https://gembared.com/blogs/musings/the-best-daytime-white-li...
- Syonyk 4y agoThanks, I'll order some of those and put them through my spectrometer!
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoIf you're willing, it would also be interesting to hear how the Bedtime Bulb from a past Show HN fares: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18011075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18011075
- Syonyk 4y agoDo you know how to order one without Amazon? I'm... rather opposed to them. In every possible way one could consider. I would love to poke with one, but if the only way to buy one is through Amazon, I'm quite unlikely to actually obtain one. I genuinely don't care if I have to pay a bit more, I hate what Amazon has done to retail.
- yeutterg 4y agoHi there, if you're interested, you can pick one up from here: https://shop.bedtimebulb.com/products/restful-bedtime-bulb https://shop.bedtimebulb.com/products/restful-bedtime-bulb Thanks! Greg, Bedtime Bulb founder
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- grrdotcloud 4y agoI have found if I work hard, exercise my mind and body, I can fall asleep in about seven minutes and sleep for a solid six. I go to bed at Ten. Up at 4:30am. My sleep score averages 81.
- chrisco255 4y agoYeah, for me exercise is always the key. When you exhaust your body with strength training and cardio, you can sleep in any environment, and it's good for you.
- e12e 4y agoInteresting article - but I'm left to wonder how it applies to where I live - we have a two month polar day in summer - but AFAIK no increased incidence of cancer. Some people certainly struggle with polar day (and night in winter) - but 10 000 plus years of human habitation seem to indicate white nights aren't such a big deal? There's a lot of research going on effects in humans - but admittedly I'm not really up to date. I do recall this one that's tangentially releated: "A circadian clock is not required in an arctic mammal" https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20226667/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20226667/
- Psychlist 4y agoThe ebook reader part is kind of disturbing, I have a warm mode on mine that I always use, and the brightness set as low as it'll go (I find it too bright, but they seem to use a linear scale so there's not much range of adjustment). I have a red LED striplight above my bed for reading paper books so I will try using that for the ebook reader and see if I notice a difference. My main issue is that interesting ebooks keep me awake longer than interesting paper books, I have a "no screens after 8pm" rule but wasn't counting the ebook reader as a screen.
- mft_ 4y agoThe "eBook" study should be treated with caution, since it was conducted using an iPad, not a typical eBook reader like a Kobo or a Kindle.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoIf you are using all red then it shouldn't be the light affecting you, only the content and the interactiveness that ereader provides.
- otherme123 4y agoI recommend you to re-read the e-reader part but paying special attention to the scales of the graphs. They are all different. Kobo Aura peaks at 4000 counts in the blue spectrum, while the incandescent also emits about 4000 counts. The Kobo Clara only emits 2500 counts when full warm.
- Psychlist 4y agoThe key thing IMO is that the paper book was 0.9 lux but they cranked the ebook up to 30 lux. I missed that the first time. They also had the ebook set to "harsh blue", which my ebook reader can do but it also has a "warm" setting as well as the obvious ability to turn the brightness down from "glare of a thousand suns" to "candlelight"
- Syonyk 4y ago... in response to the headline change from my title, which I think I adequately defended in the post: You're rather missing the whole "screws with sleep," which we know is a human health hazard in a range of metrics.
- alwayslikethis 4y agohttps://polysleep.org/wiki/Dark_period https://polysleep.org/wiki/Dark_period
- unrealp 4y agoI have tried going back to incandescent for the spectrum part. The main issue I faced was the number of light bulbs required to get sufficient enough lighting. At least the incandescents we get in my area, mostly werent bright enough. The suggestion about low lighting in the article, I recently read that reading in low light is associated with myopia/nearsightedness in children so there is that angle too.
- Syonyk 4y agoLow lighting... when? My kids are mostly in bed by the time this matters to me, at least in the winter months. And I'd like to think they get plenty of lighting during the day, as we kick them outside for some period of time every day, regardless of weather (bundle up in the winter). We have a well windowed house (just not in the OS sense), so it's rather bright in there - when the sun is up. And I don' think LEDs matter when the sun is up. I think they do matter after the sun is down, when I'm careful about light. So if you've got some studies arguing that "bright light indoors, after the sun has gone down, is important to children," please - link them so I can read them.
- unrealp 4y agoI cant find the link sorry. Also what I could find, the results were inconclusive with new research. So probably doesnt matter yes.
- jackvalentine 4y agoAre there any light fittings that contain a filter for blue light? Edit: or why don’t manufacturers put ‘blue light filters’ in to the plastic diffuser many LED bulbs have?
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThey sell 2700k warm bulbs instead. There’s also the Bedtime Bulb here that is even warmer and reduces flicker.
- jackvalentine 4y agoFrom the article, spectrum and colour temperature are related but not 1:1 matches to each other. A “2700K” light can apparently have quite a lot of blue in it still. > If you go to a hardware store, you’ll almost certainly see a demo of light color temperatures in the bulb aisle (typically around 2700K for “warm” light, around 5000K for “cool” light). You can get to those average light warmths a wide range of ways, though, and so two different bulbs with the same color temperature may have very different spectrum plots to get to the same visible end result. Without running them through a spectrometer, you can’t tell the difference - our eyes simply don’t work like that.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThen go with the Bedtime bulb, it is made specifically to reduce that. Creator is in the thread answering questions.
- jackvalentine 4y agoI think I’d prefer fittings that let me use commodity LED bulbs that cost 20% of a bedtime bulb. Also, I think the bedtime bulb is not available in 240v.
- fy20 4y agoIKEA sell a Tradfri bulb (304.413.80 in Europe) which has a 2200K colour temperature and 250 lumens output, which I've been using as a bedside lamp for the past year. At the brightest setting it is more than enough to read a book (usually we use it at around 50%), and it dims enough that we use it as a night light for kids. The new EU light labelling requires a spectrum to be posted online. This bulb still has a blue peak, but it is mainly red: https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/lightsources/847380 https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/lightsources/84738... The bulb dims well without flickering, but my only complaint is it doesn't dim that much. This seems to be the case with all ZigBee bulbs I've tried. A Philips Warmglow with a separate dimmer can be dimmer smoothly from off. Does anyone know why ZigBee bulbs don't do the same?
- vanderZwan 4y agoThere are a number of factors involved in LED lighting quality, and annoyingly not all are tested for in reviews or shown on specs. Think of an LED as a capacitor designed to leak electricity that emits light whenever it leaks in one particular direction. It's a bit handwavy but it works here. Depending on the design it might require more or less charge or voltage before the electrons jump over the diode (the light-emitting leaking step), and those characteristics affect how it behaves under different inputs. One really common thing that affects the quality is the AC/DC conversion is handled. LEDs are DC. A common cheap solution is to use a half-wave rectifier, meaning half of the time the LED is "off". Technically it's more like "half of the time there is no charge build-up so the electrons won't always jump over the LED and the amount of on/off time varies based on specifics" (again, being a bit hand-wavy). The result is mostly the same: with a HWR the LED isn't always emitting light. Normally these flicker too fast to directly see the flickering itself when looking at the lamp, due to afterimages (the frequency depends on the frequency of the AC input, so typically 50-60 Hz). But you can see it when looking at anything illuminated by the lighting and it drives me absolutely bonkers because it increases my eye-strain. Example: with solutions that don't throw away half of the AC input waving your hands will result in smooth "motion blur", and with a HWR you'll see a stroboscopic effect. Another common example is cheap Christmas lights: if you move your eyes quickly they'll look like dashed lines, not smooth ones. Now I hope that no dimmable LEDs use HWRs, because dimming will amplify the relative time the light is off. That will make the flickering worse. But we can't tell ahead of time because reviewers don't test for it! In fact, since there are no specs we can't even tell if any brand changes things between production batches. So I honestly can't say if this applies to Philips or Zigbee.
- marcell 4y agoThere is always a time lag between the introduction of a cool new technology, and the discovery of its negative effects on human health. DDT was invented in the 1940's, and it wasn't until twenty years later that people discovered its negative effects through bioaccumulation. Teflon was invented in the 1930's, and it again took decades to discover its negative effects on human health, apparently under high heat. Cigarettes: decades until we knew scientifically they were bad. Just a couple days ago there was a thread on HN about low sperm counts, with a lot of hemming and hawing about whether or not the effect is real. Here we have a claim that LED affects sleep cycles and melatonin production. We know testosterone production is related to sleep quality. Are these two related? We also have observed early puberty in girls. It went up during the Covid pandemic, when screentime increased for all school age kids in America. Is there a link between early puberty, LED screens on computers, and dropping sperm counts and testosterone levels? We don't know scientifically. Expect to find out in two decades, when its too late for you to do anything about it!
- treeman79 4y agoBanning ddt has lead to the death of many millions of people
- oblio 4y agoHow?
- Eisenstein 4y agoI think they are referring to the fact that it was used to eradicate malaria in a lot of places by destroying mosquitos and can't be used in that way now that it is banned.
- MrVandemar 4y agoI suspect that (some types of) plastics are going to be a big contributer to some of these problems. They contain a number of endocrine disrupting chemicals, and we're typing on them, mousing with them, steering our cars with them, walking on them (most carpet is plastic these days), wearing them, eating off them, drinking from them, washing outselves with them ... But yeah, the time-lag is a real problem, and coupled with lack of regulation with these technologies and novel compounds that are often introduced into our lives with little or no testing. Very much a "better to seek forgiveness than seek permission" scenario, except in an irresponsible and reckless way that's focused on profit, not safety.
- pier25 4y agoThe ebook reader part is a bit weird since the paper doesn't state which model they used. Many readers these days have warm LED lights. IIRC the Kindle Oasis can even adapt the temperature of the light.
- perihelions 4y agoKobo readers have adjustable light temperature as well. I think their entire lineup, barring the one cheapest model, has that now. https://help.kobo.com/hc/en-us/articles/360017481174-Adjust-ComfortLight-PRO-on-your-Kobo-eReader https://help.kobo.com/hc/en-us/articles/360017481174-Adjust-...
- mft_ 4y agoIt does state that it's an iPad (!) - see the Materials and Methods section, specifically page 1235.
- pier25 4y agoLol that's not an ebook reader
- amluto 4y agoOne can buy LEDs (actual LEDs as opposed to light bulbs with LEDs in them) without a blue peak. For example: https://bridgelux.com/products/thrive https://bridgelux.com/products/thrive Digikey carries them, and they’re not terribly expensive. They’re a bit less efficient than the normal 90 CRI versions. One downside: you get to build your own light fixture! But it will be a really nice one. :)
- ggm 4y agoFor the "just take melatonin" crowd: some of us can't. Its contraindicated for high blood pressure. and, for some people causes florid dreams (not always welcome) and "restless legs"
- latch 4y agoIs "florid dreams" a thing (Google didn't come up with anything meaningful)? Did you mean lucid dreams (though for the life of me, I can't understand why that wouldn't be welcomed).
- nick123567 4y agoHappens for me. Not lucid. Never thought about it but florid seems like a good word for it (I'd guess at adjectives like vivid, emotional, confusing)
- vikingerik 4y agoI don't know the term either, but I experience what the parent poster said. I've tried melatonin, and it gives me crazy vivid dreams that keep up the feeling of stress. It doesn't rest the brain, it's more like being knocked out by concussion, and it takes hours to reset and wake up and get back to functioning.
- ggm 4y agoNo, it's not a thing, its a term my partner used. Lucid dreams you have (within limits) control over the narrative, florid dreams she described as hyper-real, disturbing and unwelcome. "vivid dream melatonin" had heaps of hits. "melatonin nightmares" might be another way of putting it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- koverda 4y agoRegarding the quoted e-book study: > Third, in the present study, the LE-eBook was set to maximum brightness throughout the 4-h reading session, whereas, by comparison, the print-book condition consisted of reflected exposure to very dim light. Yeah, max brightness is probably going to make an impact. I bet if you were in a room with a bright light reading a book, with an equivalent amount of lumens going into your eyeballs, you'd probably have a tough time sleeping. This study seems like it was set up to generate a certain set of results. I wonder how it would look if the quantity of light was controlled for. Additionally, the comparisons to the incandescent spectrum and the freaking out about the blue peaks (which seem pretty small) was over the top. The incandescent spectrum contains blue, and the "peak" of the other spectra would contain an equivalent integral of blue light as compared to a slightly brighter incandescent light. Just turn the lights down low at night and get some warm spectrum bulbs and you'll be okay.
- behringer 4y agoBut then you can't sell blue blocking products.
- UberFly 4y agoYes, thank you for being rational. "Yorg, turn down the campfire or we'll never get to sleep!"
- nindalf 4y agoYorg need to finish treatise on wheel. Barg turn other side.
- hutzlibu 4y agoSleeping next to a bright fire though, is way more easy and cozy, than sleeping next to a bright LED flashlight. The red light (and sound) of the fire has a very soothing effect, which has probably something to do that our ancestors slept next to it since ~1 mio years. (it is still fun, just don't use a new sleeping bag, as it might get holes)
- 4y ago
- yumraj 4y agoAre there any LED bulbs that are better, bulb light colors that are better?
- xyst 4y agoWhat's the scientific opinion on blue blockers for prescription eyeglasses? There are some claims that suggest the health benefits are over stated. But my optometrist continues to recommend them given my profession and exposure to blue light. Anecdotally, it appears it has helped but not sure if it's related to other factors.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoI saw a study which said you can get the same effect by using clear glass and telling people it absorbs the important wavelengths. Also that blue light deprivation leads to depression in animal models. These kinds of things are hard to double blind for obvious reasons, but ruling out psychosomatic causes is really difficult.
- loaph 4y agoI think it's been debunked and they provide no benefit. Check out https://youtu.be/NkJY9bgLyBE https://youtu.be/NkJY9bgLyBE. That includes interviews with and MD who's high up in the American Academy of Opthalmology. At one point it's pointed out that you get orders of magnitude more blue light from the sky than any screen and humans have been encountering the sky forever.
- 7373737373 4y agoI'm still surprised these natural daylight lamps aren't widely commercialized yet https://youtu.be/aJ4TJ4-kkDw https://youtu.be/aJ4TJ4-kkDw
- no1groyp 4y agoPlasmas are incandescent, conveniently killed off by the environmentalists and their energy star bullshit
- lynx23 4y agoInteresting, this correlates to some of my blind friends acquiring non-24 sleeping disorder in the past few years. I wonder if that has anything to do with the banning of classical lightbulbs in the EU...
- shmerl 4y agoWhat about amber LED lightbulbs that are rated 2200K? Do they filter out blue enough or they are also a problem? I saw this one: https://www.amazon.com/Emotionlite-Dimmable-Vintage-Tubular-Equivalent/dp/B076PGFJDF https://www.amazon.com/Emotionlite-Dimmable-Vintage-Tubular-...
- fwlr 4y agoThose “color vision correcting” glasses (e.g. EnChroma) use an optical technology called notch filtering: “EnChroma glasses are spectral notch filters that remove light from two regions of the visible spectrum: from the region near 480 to 490 nm (in the blue–green part of the spectrum) and from the region near 580 to 590 nm (in the orange–yellow part of the spectrum).” https://www.practiceupdate.com/content/the-effects-of-enchroma-glasses-on-color-discrimination/108324 https://www.practiceupdate.com/content/the-effects-of-enchro... This article states the conclusion of the research is the problematic light has “a peak around 477nm, with the 50% sensitivity level from 438-493nm”, and from looking at the graph it seems 420-500nm covers it down to 20% sensitivity. It seems like a set of glasses with a spectral notch filter blocking out that chunk of the wavelength spectrum could do an end-run around all these issues. Put them on when the sun goes down and it doesn’t matter if your LEDs are leaking blue light, your dimmers don’t go low enough, or you can’t stop yourself going on your phone in bed. From other comments here it seems “light from above” has a particular importance for physiological reasons, so the glasses should incorporate a shroud from the top of the frame to your eyebrows to block out all light from above as well. I’m no expert on optics but it seems spectral filters aren’t hard to buy. Something with a center wavelength of 475nm and a full-width half-max between 60nm and 100nm should do the trick.
- Tade0 4y agoI did some digging and notch/bandpass filters are on the expensive side, but you can buy sheets of lowpass filters for a reasonable price: https://www.ocushield.com/products/anti-blue-light-filter-laptop-computer-screen https://www.ocushield.com/products/anti-blue-light-filter-la... I would just form a cylindrical lampshade out of such a sheet and call it a day. My bedroom has a dimmable, multi-colored LED in a cloth lampshade that definitely filters some blue light and it's possible to sleep with it on, so I guess the inexpensive, low-tech solution, as it's often the case, works just as well.
- fwlr 4y agoYeah, it looks like off-the-shelf spectral notch filters are aimed at laser laboratories. Around 800 usd per lens so 1600 for my glasses, bit steep. You’d get some pretty awesome looking Doc Ock style goggles out of it, though
- steponlego 4y agoI bought several cases of long life incandescent bulbs because they are so much better. Looks like they will be illegal soon. I dare anybody to come take them from me.
- SeanAnderson 4y agoSo if my only light at night is a huge projector screen, but it runs flux and I trim out all the blue light, is my melatonin production impaired? It seems like the answer is no, it's fine, but I guess I am curious if it's just that easy. It feels like it shouldn't be given how serious the author writes.
- ChuckMcM 4y agohttps://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/will-blue-light-from-electronic-devices-increase-my-risk-of-macular-degeneration-and-blindness-2019040816365 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/will-blue-light-from-ele...
- orbit7 4y agoThinking how good would sunglasses be in solving this problem vs changing the light source?
- emsign 4y agoI strongly advise against buying and using lanterns, they release a lot of toxic soot. Probably negating any health benefits you get from normalizing your melatonin levels by a large amount. Technology Connnections of YouTube made a series of in depth videos about lanterns, how they work, how they can spill and set you and your home ablaze and just how much soot they produce. Don't use them, unless you're outside camping. It's an inconspicuously dangerous technology that has more risks and downsides which will surprise you in very unhappy ways when it's used in inproper ways. Like using it for reading inside your home so you get tired more easily thus more careless in handling them. The use case for these is VERY narrow and you need to know what you are doing. As much as I enjoyed the blog post, the tiny bit with the lanterns was stupid. I wish they had dug into the downsides of those with the same interest and rigor as they demystified white LEDs. That was such an oversight. Lanterns are more risky than white LEDs that leak blue light. Yes, there are "clean burning" lanterns, but the innocent casual reader might just not buy the best type but some cheapo fuming, leaking one from Amazon. I think mentioning them is irresponsible especially after they've established themselves as someone who's an expert in blue light emitting LEDs (argument from false authority). But even with those clean burning lanterns I don't buy into how clean they are. There is no sootless lantern.
- eternityforest 4y agoI think what we need is to understand exactly how the spectra is different and use optical filters to get an exact match, assuming current high CRI and warm white lamps aren't enough. We could even use a dichroic filter to send part of the blue peak back for another trip through the phosphor. We should probably be doing that already for a little more efficiency if that's a real idea and not nonsense I just made up.
- emsign 4y agoI think there are multiple practical ways to mitigate this issue. Blue light filtering adhesive tape could be a viable solution in some cases. You can buy those UV filtering adhesive sheets for your window for protecting your precious light sensitive knick-knacks, but I don't know if they filter the spectrum between 450 and 480 nm though. In other cases another helpful tool would be a portable light sprectrum analyser, with which you can simply weed out the bad lights before you buy them, or return them immediately after buying in case you can't test them before hand. Then the blue light filtering function in devices is probably the most accessible self-defense mechanism for the average consumer in most cases. Or just go to bed when the sun goes down or change your job/shift. Behavioral adjustments, they cost nothing except some brain energy. As a last resort melatonin supplements come to mind. In combination with Vitamin D supplements for the winter time, they don't seem that bad. Even though I've heard that you will have trouble falling asleep if you stop taking melatonin. Or perhaps... use incandescent lights! They still produce less CO2 than lanterns and they don't stink. Also they are almost as convenient as LEDs. And you can still get them from some sources. The solution I would prefer is for manufacturers to just build safer products and speaking from experience government regulation is the only sure way to get the manufacturers to actually commit to it. Marketing wank doesn't work because people can't test it and there's too many factors that play into sleep quality and (decades later) cancer, so the manufacturers cannot be held responsible for the effect. They can only be held responsible if their products fail measurable tests, like how much blue light they actually emit.
- rwnspace 4y agoThe council replaced the warm halogen bulb streetlights in our area with extremely bright LEDs that have no shielding towards houses. I slept in a ground floor bedroom with a bay window directly beneath such a light for a year. Despite installing blackout blinds as best I could, the ambient light in my room was about the same level as mid-dawn the entire time. My mental health suffered intensely almost to the point of psychosis. LED lighting should be tightly regulated. At the moment they just appear to be getting brighter and brighter and more prevalent. I absolutely despise them.
- derda 4y agoIt sometimes helps to call the council about this. Many streetlamps have the option for shading in certain directions to prevent your problem, but the guys installing it might not set it correctly. My parents had the exact problem. Called up the city and actually a few days later a cherry picker appeared and there was no more light glaring into their windows.
- oblio 4y ago> cherry picker appeared Oh, so that's what those things are called :-))
- therealdrag0 4y agoDon’t sleep on eyemasks. Get one that is domed for the eyes.
- entropicgravity 4y agoI had sleep problems that I recently fixed. Nothing to do with lights it turned out but everything to do with feathers. To my knowledge I've never been allergic to anything before but somehow an allergy to feathers crept into my life. Pillow and duvet, both feathered and were killing my sleep. Synthetic stuffing for the pillow and hypoallergenic wool for the duvet and my sleep life is much better. Might be worth a try.
- _def 4y agoRecently I got two tips for working against this kind of problems in the evening: - melatonin spray - staring into a candle for some time Thoughts? Subjectively speaking both seemed to make me more sleepy, but I don't know about the scientific background.
- audunw 4y agoI'm using Philips Hue color LED bulbs in all our bedrooms, the hallway outside them, and the toilet. Since it can switch to using red+green LEDs in color mode, if you configure them with orange light dimmed to low/minimum at night, there should be essentially zero blue light. Works really well. With smart LED bulbs you can also set them up on a schedule to light up the room very brightly in the morning and have motion sensors to turn on the light elsewhere, which is also very important for health. Even though we've done this, I'm a bit skeptical of how terrible blue light is supposed to be. Just dim your lights lower and you should get most of the benefits. The natural light outside at night is quite blue, so I don't think it's blue light in itself that's the problem.. it's how much light there is in general and the body is just using the blue light to measure the general light level. He's complaining about real-world LED bulb lifetime, but I've never had any of them fail on me for 8+ years, except for some specific IKEA Trådfri GU10 bulbs that had bad thermal design which they've obviously fixed, and they were replaced free of charge no question asked. It may depend on the quality of power where you live though.
- logimus 4y agoA hack would be to buy edge filter glasses with greater than 550nm. These are used by people with makula degeneration. Use any device but without harm to melatonin production.
- kzrdude 4y agoThere's a lot of talk about bright light, but for me it seems like there is actually something else at play that's worse. For me, it's the incessant stimulation from social media, youtube, internet, etc that keeps me awake. It's this "just want more" loop in the brain. If I just read a book the last hour when I want to fall asleep, then I usually do, while if I would stay on a loop with the computer or phone then I can't sleep. If something is sufficiently stimulating (like an unfinished programming problem or playing factorio can be), it can somehow put my brain in a high gear where it refuses to calm down for hours, so these two hobbies are very detrimental to sleep as well. I hope I'm not exaggerating: it seems like this focus on light could be useful, but in a way it is a distraction from some even bigger problems. If only it was as easy as toggling for dim light!
- DarkNova6 4y agoactually, there are visual receptors in the eye which are directly tied to the hormonal center of the brain. Red/Infrared light is stimulating Melatonin and blue/bright light triggers Cortisol production. Arguably, this is linked to the circle of the sun and a lifestyle that is heavily bound to sunlight.
- nashalo 4y agoFor those of you who have an iPhone, a handy feature that helps with phone lighting at night is "Reduce White Point" in accessibility features. It is different than night mode and reducing luminosity to the minimim and I find it's a nice addition. You can put it in the control center for fast enable/disable should you need it. I have trouble sleeping and I found this helped, albeit marginally.
- ricksunny 4y agoI find that nighttime alertness is artificially (and undesirably) propped up by having the sum total of the world's knowledge at my fingertips. The LED brightness exacerbates. I haven't RCT'd tbis, but my best guess is that excessive nighttime alertness is 2/3 due to content availability, 1/3 screen (and perhaps ambient) brightness. I take active steps to have both passively cut off after a certain time.
- aj_g 4y agoGreat point, I feel often the same. The brain so often goes into a mode of "ah yeah, now is the time to google that one thing I was wondering earlier today", or "I just want to confirm this one small detail about thing X", and then my phone is pointed straight into the eyeballs again.
- sandos 4y agoI find my kindle paperwhite at 4 or 5 brightness is perfect, and seems to almost get me more tired than not reading. It is very dim.
- bilekas 4y ago> This peak also corresponds to the “clear blue sky” peak in normal daylight, amazingly enough! This is my favourite fact from this write up and makes so much sense. Overall though the article now has me anxious about my screens etc.
- moduspol 4y agoI'm curious if some of the downsides of evening blue light could be mitigated with an increase in daytime blue light. It's all about the rhythm, right? I work from home and got one of these monsters [1] to have on in my office during the day to help avoid the winter / darker time slump, and I think it's helped. I only run it during daytime working hours, in my office. I avoid staring at my phone around bedtime and my sleep patterns are fine--I'd just hate to shift away from LEDs. I'm careful about choosing virtually only "warm white" ones, though as the article notes, that's not as bulletproof as I originally thought. Is the increased blue light spectrum fundamental to LEDs? Or something we could potentially solve with a film or filter (at manufacturing time or later)? [1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08DY1GCC6/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08DY1GCC6/
- manmal 4y agoSince this topic is related to the circadian rhythm, here’s my understanding of optimizing that (aside from lighting): - No coffee 6-8h before sleeping. I try to keep it to before noon. Having a strong coffee at 3PM often means I stay up til 2AM. - Digestion should be done-ish before sleeping. A rule of thumb seems to be not eating no heavy meals past 3PM. Or at least 6PM. For me, a big amount of protein for breakfast helps keeping hunger in the evening down. (You can find great discussions and small studies if you search for „eTRF“ on Reddit) - Breakfast resets the circadian clock. Some people can’t eat before 10AM which is probably ok. I‘ve found that I can train myself to eat earlier, it’s a process. - A bit out there - Creatine has been found to help sleep deprived people - not sure why that is, but I‘ve been testing this lately. Maybe it helps with circadian rhythm, maybe not. - More about sleep than CR: An air filter near the bed improved my sleep quality by so much. I got a big one from Coway but it probably doesn’t matter much which one.
- salawat 4y agoMost LED based dimmer circuits work by converting the extra current that would otherwise be creating light into heat; i.e. every dimmable LED is functionally a space heater. There is no "feed it less energy". It's "convert more and more of what would be light into heat that has to be thermally rejected". Was a bit of an eye opener when I realized that while working on some dimmable LED track lighting once.
- bobsoap 4y agoFor reading at night, I got an "amber book light" @1800K that basically looks like a 5" clip that you stick on the book. You charge it with a USB connector on one end that's hidden under a cap, and it claims to emit no blue light (though I don't have a spectrometer to test this claim). The warm light makes reading a true pleasure and doesn't light up the whole room, just the book, which is much appreciated by my partner, who usually falls asleep before me. I find I get sleepy faster than before with this thing. Of course, that means I read a bit less. Best $10 I ever spent. https://www.amazon.com/DEWENWILS-Rechargeable-Brightness-Blocking-Bookworms/dp/B0899RHLRP/ https://www.amazon.com/DEWENWILS-Rechargeable-Brightness-Blo...
- User23 4y agoI noticed the purple streetlight phenomenon after the big freeze last December. I wonder if it's not just heat, but extreme cold also damages the phosphors.
- gcanyon 4y agoAnother alternative would be red LED lights. Not an affiliate link, just an example: https://www.amazon.com/AmazonBasics-Equivalent-Non-Dimmable-Light-2-Pack/dp/B07PYCNS7Z https://www.amazon.com/AmazonBasics-Equivalent-Non-Dimmable-...
- 6510 4y agoI really like the idea to extend life span of incandescent bulbs by lowering voltage: The easiest way is to put them in series. (daisy chain them)
- iainctduncan 4y agoAnyone who is skeptical about how different LED lighting is need only talk to a migraineur. They are SO much worse for triggering migraines for me than incandescents, it's night and day.
- NoPicklez 4y agoI don't mean to sound like a grump. I was taught this back in highschool in my 2010 psychology class. How is this different from the long standing understanding we already had that blue light inhibits melatonin? This isn't some groundbreaking new development. Blue light therapy has been around for over a decade to help people correct their circadian rhythms. It's why the Kindle claims that it shines a warm light across the screen rather than directly at you. It's why mobile phones have begun to incorporate a night mode that can warm the backlight on the screen from a blue white light to warmer oranges.
- unethical_ban 4y agoSeveral things the article claims, which I was unaware of: The content of blue wavelengths in seemingly "white" LEDs; the content of blue light even in 'warm' LEDs (more minor but still present vs incandescent); and the impact of light position relative to the "horizon".
- sublinear 4y agoAm I the only person completely unaffected by lighting when it comes to sleep? Sounds crazy, but when I close my eyes most of the light goes away and I can easily sleep.