15 ms·
Declining sperm count: Much more than you wanted to know
- jl6 4y agoPerhaps historically there was evolutionary selection pressure towards higher sperm counts, and something about modern (as in Holocene) human behavior has eliminated this selection pressure, and thus sperm counts are now varying randomly.
- flakeoil 4y agoProbably, right. The cave men or before that probably only had one or a few chances to mate while in our society we live in couples and can copulate many times per month, year in and year out, and thus a lower sperm count is countered by an increase in the number of tries. I also find it hard to believe that sperm count should be such an important factor, there is still such a huge amount or sperms that have a chance to reach the egg.
- alldayeveryday 4y ago[dead]
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> The cave men or before that probably only had one or a few chances to mate What makes you think that?
- roars 4y agoMaybe so, but the declines have been measured in the last century
- jl6 4y agoBut we haven’t got any observations of a steady baseline prior to the last century. There could have been declines (or rises!) during the previous centuries and millennia.
- patates 4y agoBut then why is it less pronounced in the US? It doesn't seem random.
- jl6 4y agoThe chart from the meta-analysis does actually look very random, and the OP article discusses several confounding factors which might make us doubt the evidence. It’s easy to find patterns in noisy data.
- rysertio 4y agoEven if we have an sperm count decline 100 times worse than this as long as there's few people that can reproduce. Natural selection can reverse it in one generation.
- totetsu 4y agoThere are home test kits you can get that have a little lens that sits on top of a smart phone camera and uses an app to approximate count and mobility from the video stream. I'm not sure how accurate they are, but it's certainly interesting to see the only human cells with flagellum.
- tsol 4y agolink? I'm amazed that would be the cheapest way. I didn't think microscopes for phones worked like that
- totetsu 4y agoI live in Japan sorry. but here is the one I ordered. https://www.shop.rohto.co.jp/category/medicine/dotest/dotest_goods/168576.html https://www.shop.rohto.co.jp/category/medicine/dotest/dotest... and also I saw this kit from the healthcare division of tenga a mens sextoy company. https://tengahealthcare.com/products/mensloupe/ https://tengahealthcare.com/products/mensloupe/
- tsol 4y agoWow that's a really competitive price. I didn't realize phone cameras are so capable with microscopy, either. Impressive
- nonethewiser 4y ago[flagged]
- hknmtt 4y ago[flagged]
- smt88 4y agoWhy do you assume there are increased rates of either? There is no reliable historical data on how prevalent homosexuality or transgenderism were.
- ralfd 4y agoThere is data. We can simply ask boomers if they are gay/trans. Though that doesn’t help in examining if the measurable change in the Zoomer generation is physical (nature) or social (nurture).
- foldr 4y agoThere’s obviously been an increase in self-identification of people as gay/trans as social acceptance has increased, but that doesn’t mean that the number of gay and trans individuals is actually greater than it was historically. We don’t know how many men worldwide were attracted to other men 1000 years ago. Period.
- wkat4242 4y agoYeah killing people for who they are attracted to really seems to make them hide that fact. Who'd have thought. Ps men aren't the only gender that can be gay obviously.
- foldr 4y agoYeah, sorry, should have been clearer that that was just an example. Same obviously applies for women attracted to women, trans people, etc. etc.
- RayVR 4y agoI’ve run a lot of linear regressions. The first thing that jumps out at me are the initial studies conducted, which pull the tail fit up quite a lot. there are a huge number of methods to test for stability of the model. Does anyone see a way to access the model data? Beyond the model, knowing the distribution of sperm counts across men and across men of different races would be immensely informative. increasing sample sizes or simple increasing total observations could actually make it look like a change is occurring when in reality you are simply converging to the global population mean.
- XorNot 4y agoThis article mentions but talks around the idea of their simply being a step-change in sperm counts due to lifestyle factors - i.e. the observation that sitting can reduce sperm count, and more people have office jobs. If you take an average in a population, and then re-arrange the population distribution to the lower-side of the step change, then take another average your result would look exactly like a decline over time, even though there's no actual ongoing component to it - the sitting population, if identified would have a lower normal rate that's not decreasing otherwise. Which would give you a real effect on average, but not an actual trend you can extrapolate since you're just observing two averages for two population groups, where the membership of each is varying. Which again - is alluded to, but I found it weird this mechanism wasn't called out explicitly (except under the "mysteriously stops" conclusion).
- bambax 4y ago> Where are sperm samples coming from? Some people give samples because they are sperm donors, others because they are infertile and want to figure out why. That's about enough to conclude all this doesn't mean much. The only way to have reliable data is to have a great sample selected at random; if the incoming data is not random, but is in fact skewed by factors relevant to the data we're looking for, there's very little value in it. The rest of this (excellent) article explains why the procedures are inconsistent, geographically as well as historically, and poorly documented, etc., and lists many reasons why the various studies could be flawed. It ends without a definitive conclusion, and saying we don't quite know. This prudence is admirable, but IMHO the anxiety about sperm count seems largely overblown. I'm not too worried. Edit: One important thing the article doesn't talk about is how sperm is actually counted. Obviously researchers don't count all 150 to 300 million sperms per sample; they probably count a small (or very small) sub-sample and extrapolate. At least they did when they first started studying this. And maybe today some studies use machines? Or other sophisticated / more precise methods? And others don't? The evolution and diversity of the counting methods is obviously a major factor that needs to be discussed.
- 411111111111111 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoPersonal attacks like this will get you banned here, regardless of how wrong someone is or you feel they are. If you'd please read the rules and stick to them, we'd appreciate it: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. You may not owe erroneous sperm counters better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. Also, "Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." That's in the site guidelines too, because it's reliably a marker of bad comments and worse threads.
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoIn fairness, sometimes studies are done without much intellectual honesty. Like the gender wage gap studies that made headlines everywhere when they didn't control for basic things like profession.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dig1t 4y agoI was concerned about this, so I actually went to a fertility clinic myself and got a semen analysis. My sperm count came out low but "within range" and the motility was low and "out of range". I am a healthy normal guy, I exercise 6/7 days a week, am not obese, don't drink much, and eat pretty healthy generally. My low "in range" count would have been considered extremely low and out of range a generation ago. So anecdotally, I think that something is not right here. Read the book "Countdown". The author goes into great detail all of the reasons that modern life is putting downward pressure on sperm quality and quantity. The author, Dr. Swan, is a leading expert in the field. The book is really good, and pretty scary.
- ralfd 4y ago> Read the book "Countdown". The author goes into great detail all of the reasons that modern life is putting downward pressure on sperm quality and quantity. What reasons would apply to you?
- Dig1t 4y agoEndocrine disrupting chemicals (mostly phthalates), they are present in most food and bathroom packaging. Any plastic that is flexible. https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/features/the-big-3-why-phthalates-should-be-restricted-or-banned-from-consumer-products/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/features/the-big-3-why-pht... "They’ve been shown to be anti-androgenic—in other words, they decrease testosterone. In studies with rats, it’s been shown that if you dose the pregnant mother, the offspring have defects of the male reproductive tract. There have also been studies in humans that have found anti-androgenic effects on development of the male reproductive tract." https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/common-chemicals-may-harm-sperm-and-pregnancies-growing-evidence-shows/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/common-chemicals-... https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/feb/10/phthalates-plastics-chemicals-research-analysis https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/feb/10/phthala... There is a mountain of research on these chemicals. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2873014/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2873014/ "There was also a dose–response relationship between MBzP (the primary hydrolytic metabolite of BBzP) and below WHO reference value sperm concentration. In a recent follow-up study including these 168 men, plus an additional 295 men newly recruited into the study, Hauser et al. (2006) confirmed the associations between MBP and increased odds of below-reference sperm concentration and motility. "
- alexpi 4y agoMaybe evolution just optimizes for having more pleasure without pregnancy, isn't it a goal 99% of time?
- azan_ 4y agoHow would evolution do that?
- Smaug123 4y agoThat's just not the kind of goal natural selection is capable of optimising towards. Natural selection instils the execution of adaptations which on average have historically demonstrated increased reproduction rates. It does nothing else. (Humans, of course, have other goals orthogonal to those of natural selection, and are capable of optimising in favour of them, but natural selection is a blind idiot god that wants precisely one thing and will always aim dumbly at it to the exclusion of all else. We're fortunate that it is so dumb and slow, because it leaves us with plenty of room to do our own optimisation with our brains.) Can you name any other time natural selection has optimised for the pleasure of a mammal at the explicit expense of reproduction?
- alexpi 4y agoYou're right, there is no way evolution can do it, especially within single or two generations. It optimizes for adaption and survival, not a pleasure.
- midoridensha 4y agoHumans haven't been undergoing natural selection for thousands of years, only artificial selection.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoThe germ line doesn't care about the soma's feelings. If the best way for your genes to propagate was for you to be in horrible agony all the time then that would be the case.
- kwhitefoot 4y ago
- fxtentacle 4y agoI think it might be interesting to compare countries with a high rate of obesity (e.g. US) and countries with a low rate of obesity (e.g. Singapore) here, both because it very likely directly affects men's health and testosterone levels and also because it'll likely create a different level of optical stimulation, thereby indirectly affecting testosterone levels. Also, the time range of the diagrams in the article correspond to a time when the weight of an average american roughly 1.5x-ed. I'd guess that diluting the same absolute testosterone amount to 1.5x the volume will also have measurable effects.
- theandrewbailey 4y agoThe article mentions it: > Obesity and bad diets can impact sperm count. But the US, a world center of obesity, seems to be doing better than many less obese countries, and countries like China and France that have maintained relatively low rates of obesity and overweight seem heavily affected. If modern diets are the problem, then it has to be something more insidious than obvious you-are-very-fat obesity - unless you want to use the “all regional comparisons are too low sample size for us to care” card.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoNothing against you, but... > "it'll likely create a different level of optical stimulation" ...is a hilariously politique way of phrasing finding someone hot.
- fxtentacle 4y agoThe article said there might be "missing cues of fertility that would otherwise increase sperm production" which reminded me of "study shows that when men smell T-shirts worn by women while ovulating, it triggers a surge in the sex hormone testosterone" [1] which would be exactly such a cue of fertility. [1] https://www.webmd.com/men/news/20100115/womens-scent-triggers-hormone-surge-in-men https://www.webmd.com/men/news/20100115/womens-scent-trigger...
- CommanderData 4y agoHere's a updated video conversation with Dr Swan released last month. Endocrine Disruptors - Common Chemicals that alter your hormones https://youtu.be/uLxFazLK2Mg https://youtu.be/uLxFazLK2Mg It looks like we're heading for collapse eventually and there's very little we can do about it if it is to believed this is mostly caused by environmental pollution. These types of pollution are everywhere and line our infrastructure is ways most people can't fathom.
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> It looks like we're heading for collapse eventually and there's very little we can do about it if it is to believed this is mostly caused by environmental pollution. So, this was understood in the bio scenes in the mid 2000s, during the financial collapse, my professor in bio-statistics (a class I loathed wit a professor I detested even more for various reasons) and fave me 2 very strong revelations in my sort lived scientific career built on the following premises: statistics are a poor way to prove anything in the Health Sciences (for or against) and just because someone is an absolute reprehensible person doesn't mean they can't offer insight in a much larger problem tat even they don't seem to grasp despite having a PhD. is research was on the effects of BPA was having on local male frogs, production of non-viable eggs, and got lots of grant money for it. This was wen BPA was all the rage and being pulled from containers and china was caught selling poison baby formula. I asked him if the implications were longer lasting and if manufacturing SOPs from the 80-2000s could result in a large shift in cultural norms in a country like Japan, where it had shifted desires in the female population in one generation to want a largely androgynous male--albeit wit heavy feminine features--amongst the young females, making female voyeurism of male homosexuality a massive genre, a large uptick in herbivore men, low fertility rates (they were now starting to show how bad they were after the bubble collapsed). And could that be correlated due Japan having to re-industrialize at all costs post WWII and become a main export economy (and all that entails including contamination). He almost felt offended by my inquiry as I was trying to take credit for is work, and quickly reverted back to showing pictures of the stuff he got from an EPA grant or something. Something most wont know, unless you did sperm based cryogenics during COVID, women were paying large premiums on viable sperm as many sought to have children on their own and even took to advertising it on social media [0]. Its been a crisis for some time, in fact I was born in late 80s and my parents ad many issues back then. Its only gotten worse, and this may be the larger contributor why the population will likely have peaked at 8 billion more than anything else, thou economics plays a large part, too. 0: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/08/business/sperm-donors-facebook-groups.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/08/business/sperm-donors-fac...
- helsinkiandrew 4y ago> So, very speculatively, one might suggest that sperm counts started declining between 1951 and 1974. I hope that's due to lifestyle changes rather than with the start of atmospheric nuclear testing.
- alpaca128 4y agoThe 1950s were the start of our long-term exposure to plastic materials and we've known for a while that some of those substances aren't great for our health. In contrast nuclear tests and power are usually well contained exactly because of the high risks. And if some of the few accidents had any widespread long-term effect there would probably be a visible bump in the statistics.
- helsinkiandrew 4y ago> In contrast nuclear tests and power are usually well contained exactly because of the high risks I was thinking more of the open air tests undertaken around the world - for example Castle Bravo in the Pacific where "The fallout spread traces of radioactive material as far as Australia, India and Japan, and even the United States and parts of Europe". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_Bravo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_Bravo The increase in Carbon-14 in the atmosphere due to nuclear tests is large enough to be detected in all living organisms: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bomb_pulse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bomb_pulse
- tedk-42 4y agoI'd like to see a direct cause of X explaining this. There are lots of things to suggest a correlation (e.g. microplastics) but nothing concrete has ever really been proposed as being the cause. For all we know, we're better hydrated than ever before and that's what's throwing off our sperm 'density' (I hate the word count because it's a per volume thing).
- meindnoch 4y agoThe problem of declining sperm counts will solve itself with the proliferation of polyamorous relationships. If you pool multiple males together, there will be a higher chance of at least one of them having good quality sperm.
- trafficante 4y agoIf polyamorous relationships are indeed getting common enough to affect population surveys, the numbers would suggest an average gender composition far closer to fundamentalist Mormons. Eg: last week’s Pew relationship survey had the “not in a relationship” age <29 cohort breaking roughly 60/30 male/female. Barring an extreme misunderstanding of the definition of “relationship”, this seems to indicate most peak reproductive ability men aren’t even getting on the court to shoot their shot, so to speak.
- xyzelement 4y agoSomething I'd be curious about is the empiric difference between groups. Like religious people seem to have "no problem" having 5-10 kids in the US while seemingly every secular couple is going for fertility treatment. I don't know if this is just how it seems, but it seems that way!
- Veelox 4y agoI think a big part of that is age of child birth. If you start having kids at 22 it's straight forward to end up with 5 before you are 35. If you try to have your first at 35+ you may have to get fertility treatment if you wait longer or want multiple that are spaced out.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThis is it. Evolutionarily, 30-35 is extremely late for procreation in humans. That doesn't give you enough time to raise them before you die at around 45 (around the life expectancy of wild humans).
- nhchris 4y agoEven supposing children are raised communally by the tribe, female fertility rapidly declines post-30, and falls off a cliff post-35: https://www.britishfertilitysociety.org.uk/fei/at-what-age-does-fertility-begin-to-decrease/ https://www.britishfertilitysociety.org.uk/fei/at-what-age-d... So you have very few fertile years left into which to fit multiple healthy children. 2.1 is needed to merely sustain a population (with all the medicine of industrialized society to keep them alive). For "wild" humans, that number would be considerably higher.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoLife expectancy at birth, maybe, but if you lived long enough to reproduce your life expectancy was much longer than that.
- pclmulqdq 4y ago
- lumb63 4y agoIt is disappointing to me that how this issue impacts men is largely brushed aside. It is well documented that testosterone levels have greatly declined in the last 100 years. If you couple these two facts, it seems impossible they are incorrect. And when this topic comes up, the responses are generally, “who cares?” First, attention is diverted from the male to fertility, because the issue must be seen as impacting females negatively to justify any interest by society. Second, the way this impacts boys and men is entirely ignored. Responses exist like, “we just need a way to reproduce without men”, or “everyone can just use IVF and still have children”. I worry very few people respect how being wished out of existence so that females can enjoy plastics and pesticides impacts men. Very few people respect how demeaning it is for men to be infertile and how this would impact their mental health. Very few people respect how being unable to produce the hormones that allow boys to develop correctly or men to perform their biological functions impacts men. It is wholly disheartening. If there were even the slightest indication that something similar impacted women only, I doubt we would be here discussing whether or not the effect was real, but instead, what should we do about it? Instead, since sperm count and testosterone levels are “men’s issues”, nobody cares unless it can be shown to impact the other 50% of society that apparently is the only portion deserving of any care.
- dokem 4y agoI get what your saying but I don't think you actually want what you're asking for. What would this 'caring' even be good for? Because I don't get the impression that it would actually solve anything right now and only serve to infect the male demographic with the all-to-common victim mentality. From an individual perspective if testosterone is such a concern you can do trt and remove yourself from this issue. And while ivf isn't ideal and I'm not currently in the market to have children right now, I don't see that route as causing existential stress in me personally or calling my masculinity into question in any meaningful way.
- mariusor 4y agoYou are right that questioning the testosterone levels should be done, but the way you're framing the issue feels very disingenuous. You could be stuck in a bubble of discourse that matches what you're saying, but consider that maybe looking at the issue with the perspective "this wouldn't happen if women were affected" is not constructive. PS. Also Scott has a good track record of revisiting articles he wrote if new elements come up from readers or specialists. Let's hope that someone out there in his subscribers list will make the same pertinent observation - reading through the comments, there are a couple of mentions already.
- zug_zug 4y agoRegardless of how confident one is about the data -- not collecting drastically more high-quality data immediately seems irrational. I'd go so far as to consider compelling samples - seems shocking but actually much less intrusive than a draft and probably more likely to protect mankind.
- 0xGod 4y agoI am closing the gate. Soon, no more offspring at all for this species. You eat your own and sacrifice them on altars of lies to Baal.
- ultra_nick 4y agoAnytime it looks like we're going extinct, then we should prioritize finding wtf is happening. People should be freaking a lot more given this is trending to kill us before climate change.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- photochemsyn 4y agoIf you read the entire article, which I suspect many commentators haven't bothered to do, you'll find that there are so many confounders in the data that any trend is highly suspect. For example, this one is a bit amusing: > "After ejaculation, sperm count decreases and takes a while to build back up again; if your community’s ejaculation frequency is changing (eg people have gained access to online porn), that will change its average sperm count." If one wanted to, one could claim that the sexually frustrated society of the 1950s was resulted in the high sperm count samples from that era, and that sexual liberation movements of the 1960s and 1970s resulted in people having sex more frequently, hence the lower sperm counts in submitted samples. Of course, there are about a half-dozen other confounders one could cherry-pick so that's not a valid conclusion either. All in all the trend doesn't seem to be very well-supported, compared to other studied trends like the increase of CO2 in the atmosphere due to fossil fuel combustion, the decrease of oxygen in the deep ocean due to warming and fertilizer inputs, an increase in heavy metals in the environment due to centuries of coal combustion, etc.
- Balgair 4y agoI agree here. The graphs showing the trend lines in the bubble graph read to me as pretty much noise. I looked at the paper Scott pulled it from and couldn't find the r2 value. Perhaps someone with a better stats knowledge can help me out here in trying to interpret how the 95% CIs that are presented help relate to something like an r2 value? Is the data presented three dimensional? What's going on here? The authors of the paper state: "These findings strongly suggest a significant decline in male reproductive health, which has serious implications beyond fertility concerns". But because of my limited stats knowledge, I'm seeing the opposite of their conclusion. Help?
- AussieWog93 4y ago>sexually frustrated society of the 1950s Were men sexually frustrated in the 50s? I don't know the stats, but I do know that a lot of the nostalgia about that period comes from high rates of stable marriage and a male-lead household. At least on paper, it sounds like every man basically had an unlimited sex license.
- abledon 4y agoDoesn't like all of Los Angeles drink water out of water bottles? the endocrine disruption explanation here claims phthalates play a big role in sperm count reduction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLxFazLK2Mg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLxFazLK2Mg
- sublinear 4y agoNot mentioned even once in the article: cortisol. Stress messes up EVERYTHING in the body for everyone regardless of race, ethnicity, sex, etc.
- beezlewax 4y agoIn an attempt to avoid harmful plastics mentioned by other users getting into my food I started buying meat in a local butchers instead of the supermarket, only to see them one day unpacking pre-cut meats that were heavily wrapped in plastics. It's extremely difficult to avoid this stuff.
- bigbillheck 4y agoIt's tempting to blame modern environmental factors for sperm counts being lower, but isn't it equally likely that something about the environment of the 1980s was causing sperm counts to be inflated? Like maybe sure the ancients of 1983 had a whole bunch of sperm, but because of all the lead in the gasoline most of them were duds in a way that would not have been understood at the time.
- jscipione 4y agoWe cannot trust our current institutions to solve this problem because they hate white men. If we mean to solve the sperm count deficit we must first replace these institutions with ones that recognize the problem and have the desire to solve it.
- rednerrus 4y agoBigger guns with fewer bullets. Makes sense in a world that is rapidly urbanizing.
- kart23 4y agoI don't know why everyones obsessed about sperm count decreasing. It's definitely not the limiting factor of the US's birth rate, and will probably never be. We should be more worried about our society having less babies and the future effects, where immigration will have to make up for our aging demographics. https://observer.com/2022/05/the-u-s-s-low-birth-rate-means-the-nation-is-headed-for-a-demographic-crisis/ https://observer.com/2022/05/the-u-s-s-low-birth-rate-means-...