16 ms·
Let Teenagers Sleep
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago[dead]
- exfatloss 4y agoCan't stress enough how important this is. People's circadian rhythms shift with age, and during teenage years, they are the latest (or most "night owl"-like). Current school times practically guarantee that teenagers will be too tired and sleep-deprived to learn much.
- juve1996 4y agoAnd yet many teenagers do just fine and end up learning a lot. How do they manage? Are they tired? Do they have magical circadian rhythms?
- exfatloss 4y agoChronotypes are a spectrum, probably roughly normal distribution. So ~25% are going to be in the left (early) quartile and will be fine. And of course, even I as a pretty severe nightowl learned some things in school. It was just that I was constantly falling asleep and always sleep deprived and had to catch up on sleep every single weekend. I likely would've done much better had school started 2h later.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoIdeal support at home in some cases. Being allowed to rest and sleep as needed, good food around, transportation to help minimize commute times, etc. Having this makes it much easier to meet the demands. Not in all cases. But there are absolutely logistical advantages some kids have and others don’t, and some kids suffer significantly for that disadvantage. Always exceptions to rules of course. And humans can still do impressive things under duress. Maybe the question is not how do they manage, but how much better could they manage under more ideal schedules, and how many more kids would do better as well?
- kingbirdy 4y agoYes, high-achieving teenagers are mostly tired all the time
- lr4444lr 4y agoI've gotta ask: is this really such a big problem in other countries? If not, are they starting school later? How are the successful ones dealing with it if not that way?
- witheld 4y agoThe scientific consensus is that children need more sleep than theyre getting, and that waking up later is healthier. I assume this problem is the same in most parts of the world.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoCan solve that by going to bed earlier too, but I doubt my teenager self would have listened to that.
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoIts more than just rebelliousness. Teens' circadian rhythms are naturally shifted towards falling asleep later in the evening and waking up later in the morning.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoThe cicadian rhytm doesn't actually know what the clock on your wall says, only when you eat and get daylight. A late cicadian rhytm is functionally equivalent with poor sleep hyhiene.
- jltsiren 4y agoAnd when other people are active. It seems to be fairly common that night owls need an hour or two of their own time after most other people have gone to sleep, or at least have stopped bothering them.
- jenadine 4y agoWhy not going to sleep earlier?
- rahidz 4y agoSorry teens, school isn't about your wellbeing. It's about glorified childcare (if we let out later, who will watch the younger kids? Before it may have been a parent, but now both parents are away at work) and athletics (later start times means your kid will come back from sports practice when it's dark).
- tptacek 4y agoOne big reason this shift isn't happening is that it creates coordination problems: for many families, everyone leaves for school at the same time, so if you move grade 9 forward an hour, you have to do the same with grade 4 to get any benefit; the 9th grader is taking the 4th grader to school. That problem stopped this shift dead recently where I live.
- Analemma_ 4y agoYeah, IIRC Boston actually tried this, and the uproar from parents whose schedules were thrown into disarray was so intense it had to immediately be walked back. It sucks, but there are broader considerations at play.
- autoexec 4y agoIt's odd that parents consider broader considerations like their 9-5 schedule more important than the health and well-being of their own children. With all the resources and technology we have it's not as if we don't have the ability to find solutions to problems like "How to move a child from point A to point B at time C", so I guess this is more of a lack of will than a lack of capability.
- Merad 4y ago> It's odd that parents consider broader considerations like their 9-5 schedule more important than the health and well-being of their own children. Why are you blaming the parents? Most people in the world don't have the benefit of flexible tech jobs that allow them to work 10-6 or to come and go as needed during the work day.
- autoexec 4y ago> Why are you blaming the parents? Because when Boston tried this, uproar from parents was sufficient to cause meaningful change, but that uproar was directed at their schools and not their workplaces. They used their collective power to defend their work schedules at the expense of their children. Why not insist on more flexibility in their work schedules, or for additional transportation solutions to assist in getting teens to/from schools? Is this really an insurmountable problem?
- agomez314 4y agoIs smartphone/digital screen attributable to some degree to teenager's late-night habits, and therefore a need for later school times?
- n4r9 4y agoResearch into teenagers' shifted body clocks has been going on since well before smartphones and even laptops, if I recall.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoAnecdotally, as sometime who was a teenager in the pre-smartphone era I stayed up late plenty without any personal portable screens. I’d just be staying up to watch TV or read a book instead.
- at-fates-hands 4y agoYou are correct. I think research started into the effects of TV screens on teenagers sleeping patterns. Research has indicated that extensive television viewing tends to be associated with sleep problems among children, adolescents, and adults.1-6 However, few studies of risk for sleep problems have assessed television viewing.1 Only 2 studies have investigated the sequencing of the association between television viewing and the development of sleep problems during childhood or early adolescence.2,5 The findings of both studies suggested that television viewing was associated with increased risk for sleep problems during the next 9 to 12 months. However, no prospective longitudinal study has investigated the long-term association of television viewing with the development of sleep problems from early adolescence through early adulthood. Thus, little is known about the nature and direction of the association between television viewing and sleep problems during adolescence and early adulthood. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/485728 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/...
- steve_adams_86 4y agoI read about it several times in Discover magazine as an early tween/teen. I had a subscription, haha. So, it was a recurring topic 20+ years ago in a fairly popular magazine. This was well before kids commonly had phones, and while I owned a palm pilot, it didn’t keep me up at night and it was… atypical at best for kids to have or perhaps even want them, haha. Around the time I turned 18 most kids my age had cell (not smart) phones and computers had become common in households, but I don’t recall them being a major sleep disturber yet. I would stay up on mine learning to program and playing StarCraft around 20 years ago, but again, I don’t think this was nearly as typical as kids watching tv in their rooms back then, let alone using phones or tablets today.
- heisenbit 4y agoWhen I went to school I had to be there at 7:20 which meant leaving home at 7:00. It sucked but it also meant I had most afternoons free to play with friends. When looking how schools today for various reasons swallow whole days I wonder whether I did not grow up in a golden age.
- fdgsdfogijq 4y agoAs a teenager I was diagnosed with "ADD". Very intelligent, but unable to focus or complete assignments. My life habits were carb heavy unhealthy food (from the cafeteria), soda, lack of sleep due to long school commute, not much exercise As an adult, I eat no carbs, all meat and vegetables, I work from home and sleep in as far as I need every night. My thinking is laser sharp. They tried to medicate me with all sorts of anti depression drugs and amphetamines. Turns out I was just very unhealthy, from a basic lifestyle perspective. And the school was pushing that lifestyle. My guidance counseler suggested I dont attend college, just a community college (despite the fact that I got admitted to a decent state school), or maybe go into the "trades". These large scale school systems treat students like cattle, with zero regard for the long term effects. Many mental health concerns would disappear if people were actually healthy in the most basic sense.
- solveit 4y ago> My guidance counseler suggested I dont attend college, just a community college (despite the fact that I got admitted to a decent state school) What's wrong with guidance counselors in American high schools? Why do I keep hearing about them giving kids incredibly stupid advice?
- bigbillheck 4y agoI think I talked to guidance counselors twice during my entire high school career, and neither time came away satisfied, but had friends who were in and out of their offices on the regular without complaint beyond the usual ones you'd expect from teenage boys.
- screye 4y agoMy cynical take is that someone who cannot figure out what career to be in themselves ends up a guidance counselor. The job isn't well paid. And anyone who can do large scale talent identification will likely be paid a lot more in the corporate world. So you end up with the least competent ones in public schools.
- vlunkr 4y ago
- Zetice 4y agoMaybe just schedule the not-intellectually-heavy stuff earlier in the day, if we can't screw up the parents' schedules with a later start time. For example, start school with a study hall (that you can miss if you're so able e.g. if you can drive yourself to school), and let the kids nap. Honestly that would have been a game changer for me, as I never did my homework until the last second.
- trgn 4y agoYeah, a few hours of optional study hall before or after school would be so good. It gives some buffer for the studious kids. Plus, 50% of class time is wasted anyway. Just teach essentials. Getting on my soap box: most important buildings in an educational institution are the library and the sports hall. Healthy mind in healthy body. Dial in formal instruction tactfully. That's really it.
- syntheweave 4y agoThere are definitely tons of ways to satisfy this issue that we seem to be predisposed against because it would introduce slack in the system, and at multiple layers, the school system is designed to be a "precision engineered watch" - the staff never has time, the parents never have time, the kids never have time, and the measures of success are built around bureaucratic elements and adversarial dynamics. Thus every homework assignment I had came with a pit of anxiety about formal structure: "Am I following the exact format? Or will it come back with a zero because I didn't correctly read the teacher's mind about what's being asked for?" That kind of thing is resolved if there's slack, but in many schools it isn't there: it's just pushed downwards until it hits the students and they get marked late, absent, failing on their work, and blamed for being irresponsible. I once had a band teacher in high school that wanted us to do an "optional" practice session after school. I did not show up, and the next day she gave me an earful in front of the class because by optional, she meant you had to attend unless you were excused. I explained that that is not the definition of optional, and she should find a different word for it, but she was uninterested in using correct nomenclature.
- Jun8 4y agoThis post on the front page was SO timely for us! My son (16) was feeling very sleepy and tired the past week. On Friday he took a brief nap at 5pm, but woke up next morning, after 15 hours. This morning when I went to wake him up at 6am he just couldn’t make it so I let him stay at home. This never happened before.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoPlease have him do a sleep study. It turned out that I had undiagnosed narcolepsy for decades. Sleeping 15 hours is exactly what I used to do. It's a low cost high return kind of thing. If I'd had early diagnosis, I wouldn't have been fired due to getting jobs that really, really wanted my butt in a chair at exactly 9am. (https://twitter.com/theshawwn/status/1392213804684038150 https://twitter.com/theshawwn/status/1392213804684038150) That said, the rate of narcolepsy is extremely small, so there's probably nothing to worry about. But hey, it happened to me, so maybe worry a teensy tiny bit.
- jaggederest 4y agoAdd sleep apnea to that. I don't have it myself, but some of my friends had a night-and-day difference in their life as a result of getting their obstructive sleep apnea treated. Significant weight loss, depression gone, no headaches, doing well in life instead of struggling every day.
- kimixa 4y agoOne of my friends effectively dropped out of university due to sleep apnea. He just wouldn't be able to get up for lectures or engineering labs, or be so out of it he had difficulty absorbing the material. A shame as he was a sharp guy, and has struggled with things in the decade since due to various knock-on reasons. We used to laugh about how loud he snored echoing through the house - but looking back this was more a symptom of a medical issue than a joke. It's a failure of modern western society IMHO where we see people actually needing sleep as "lazy", rather than a requirement to actually be their best.
- corbulo 4y agoWe seem to be approaching enough chaos where major entrenched systems changes like this will start to become possible. There are no lobbying groups on behalf of 9am school start times. You have to break the national teachers unions to get this kind of change, which parents appear the right amount of pissed off to do at this point.
- tmpz22 4y agoAs a teenager I used to stay up until 2-3am watching movies on my ipod touch - which had a ludicrously small screen by todays standards. I'm in favor of moving back start times but we should also better study and educate on the consequences of bad personal habits.
- dobbysfirstsock 4y agoI 100% agree. I'm unfortunately not an expert in the field but over the years I've seen "studies" that are very flawed or impossible to replicate. I'm all for some experiments for those willing... perhaps it would overall increase the amount of sleep students get... but for some I feel it would completely wreck their schedules. This is anecdotal but when I went to live with my grandparents for a summer, I hated every minute of it. They lived on a farm with no wifi. By the last week or two though, I realized I sorta enjoyed it. I was out like a light by 10 pm every day. I was getting more exercise etc. I had no reliable reason to stay up past 10 pm and my body seemed to adjust to what felt natural. As an adult, I can say that if school started later, I would have just stayed up later. There was even a time in college that I would stay up till 4-5 am. Sometimes you would know a snow day the night before and I would tell my friends on the west coast that I could stay up even later. It was awful but I couldn't see it at the time. It took me years to fix. I now sleep around 1 AM which I still wish I could sleep earlier but I'll take it.
- xyzelement 4y ago// should also better study and educate on the consequences of bad personal habits. Yeah - and you can get away with bad habits until you can't. An ex of mine was very successful through her early 30s despite being out and partying late quite often. Then she joined Goldman Sachs where the bar is higher, and all of a sudden she was like "shit, I gotta go to bed early if I need to keep up."
- RheingoldRiver 4y agoIs it "bad personal habits" though? If I wasn't staying up to 1-2am reading, I was lying in bed waiting to fall asleep until 1-2am with my eyes closed, bored to tears and completely miserable. So you tell me which I should have been doing.
- burlesona 4y agoMy high school in Texas started at 9:05 am. Sample size of 1, but my experience was: (a) It still felt “early” to me at the time, but not “difficult” to be up for. (b) I don’t remember anyone complaining about school starting early or people being generally sleep deprived - if someone was exhausted in school we were all amused and curious what adventures they’d been having to stay out way too late. (c) I do recall that there was an optional “early period” that started at 7:30 and some people took classes then or had sports stuff at that time, and I specifically remembering thinking that you had to be out of your mind to participate in anything requiring you to be up that early. By contrast my wife, who is much more the “go to bed on time” type than I ever was, had band at 6am and school at 7:30, and describes her high school as a blur that she slept through half of. So the article’s recommendation for a 9am start time seems pretty logical to me.
- hdctambien 4y agoI taught in a Texas district that starts high school at 9:05. I appreciated that over the 6:50 start I had in Massachusetts... but it didn't really change much for the students. I would get up at 5am so I could run before school and I would still be getting emails from students that hadn't gone to bed yet. I don't think any of my students in TX were getting any more sleep than the students I taught in MA. They were just staying up later. But maybe on average, the student body is getting more sleep in TX than in MA ... but no way they are getting 9 hours on school nights.
- yurishimo 4y agoThis was also my experience in Texas (DFW). Elementary school started and ended about 90 minutes before HS. This allowed the bus drivers to work from 2pm~ until 5pm. I would have liked it to start a bit later, or at least ramp up with a homeroom for 30-45 minutes. When I started HS in 2008, we didn't have homeroom classes anymore. Some days I would start bright eyed and bushy tailed doing Calculus at 9am. Bleh. I took some dual credit classes in my later years. I remember a few of them happened _before_ school started. Those sucked too, but they didn't cost me anything and I graduated with an associates degree so I can't complain too much.
- ArchOversight 4y ago> This shift reverses at adulthood. The biological nature of this daily rhythm means that sending a teenager to bed earlier won’t necessarily mean they fall asleep earlier. No, this shift does not reverse in adulthood for some people... I am in my 30's and I still fall asleep midnight to 1 AM, and wake up "late" by most adult standards at around 8/9 AM. I can not shift my sleep schedule to earlier, I've tried many times, it's just not how I am wired.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agodo you consume any caffeine after 12:00 noon? Caffeine's half life is 6 hours. So if you consume at 3pm, you still have 1/2 that caffeine in your body at 9 pm. 1/4 of it at 3am.
- alar44 4y ago[dead]
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoI have similar sleeping habits, and I generally have caffeine only at breakfast.
- thebigspacefuck 4y agoI stop drinking caffeine at 5pm and I can fall asleep at 10pm or 11pm. Sometimes it feels like if I don’t drink enough caffeine during the day I can’t fall asleep.
- ArchOversight 4y agoDo you have ADHD? For me caffeine helps calm my mind, and I can fall asleep having had caffeine without any issues.
- fknorangesite 4y agoI'm in the exact same boat as the commenter you're responding to: I'm in my 40s, been a night owl my whole life. I very, very rarely fall asleep before 1am, despite decades of trying. I usually (but not even always) have a cup of coffee when I get up in the morning, but that's it. Why is it so difficult to imagine that people have different sleep schedules? Like, we do not blink at the thought that, say, height exists on a bell curve. Why wouldn't a circadian rhythm? God save me from the early-riser moralists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gabereiser 4y agoThe real blame for early high school is extra-curricular sports. Basketball, Football, etc. For those sports to thrive, teams need to practice, in order for practice to be efficient, it needs to be at least an hour. So 2 hours are allocated (suit up, practice, suit down). In order for children to be able to commit to 2 hours extra of their time BEFORE their parents get home (5pm), class would have to end by 3pm. Now, pair that with the fact that most school districts don't have enough bus drivers for every school, they pair up. A single bus driver will start their day bussing high school, then will bus elementary school (which starts later in the day). So high school ends a little earlier so the bus drivers can bus the elementary school kids home after they bus the high school kids. In order for the kids in high school to end at 2:15pm for sports and to save money on bus driver employment and bus fleet, they have to start 2:15pm - 8hr: 6:15am. It's crazy. It was like that when I went to high school in the early 90s, it's still the same today.
- hgsgm 4y agoHuh? Sports can practice before school. And high school athletes don't need parental supervision. School hours are set by transportation needs, as you already observed.
- deanCommie 4y ago> Sports can practice before school Hilarious, given the original thread. School already starts far too early.
- sidibe 4y agoNo such thing as too early. Our public HS swim team used to do the water part at 6am then cross training (running or weight room) after school. Probably because of pool availability
- SoftTalker 4y agoSwimming seems to have a tradition of pre-dawn practice times. I never understood that. Nobody uses the high school pool after school (unless there's a meet).
- legitster 4y ago> And around puberty, their circadian clocks shift by a couple of hours, meaning they get tired later at night than before and wake up later in the morning than they used to. This shift reverses at adulthood. The biological nature of this daily rhythm means that sending a teenager to bed earlier won’t necessarily mean they fall asleep earlier. It's not clear to me that this shift is actually biological in nature, or trained in from years of habit. I still have friends who never got jobs or careers after high school. Now into their 30s they are staying up regularly to 3-4am. If anything, their circadian rhythm has further extended. If this is the case, "letting teenagers sleep in" might just offset that habit correction into the college years, or the early career years, or etc. Or constitute a permanent change in circadian rhythm for that generation.
- Eumenes 4y agoKids can also go to bed earlier. When they leave the protected confines of public education, the world won't bend to your schedule (maybe with the rise of the 4 day work week being talked about on linkedin every other day). Every teen in my family is up till 2/3am on weekends, playing video games with friends, streaming something. All good, but best not for a school night. I'd be pretty tired too if I stayed up every work night till 2/3am. Perhaps try to read before bed, or go for a walk.
- robg 4y agoReally amazing that two key bugs in schools work actively hurt the brain’s ability to learn, remember, focus, and make decisions: 1. Long school days mean brains are overworked and so don’t function well 2. Multi month summer breaks actively overwrite what was learned the prior year When will schooling be built to best optimize brain power?
- Levitz 4y agoTo your second point, that's just a testament of the failure of schooling. If anything, the only things kids learn are those that they still know after summer break, or better yet, a couple of years afterwards. The current model is based on memorizing a whole lot of stuff and then later forgetting it. very little is learned at schools and high-schools. The relationship between invested time and knowledge returned is appalling, but it makes sense once you accept that, like others in the thread have said, school and high school are essentially grown-up childcare.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoSummer vacation was awesome though. I don't mean that flippantly. Especially in grader 8/9/10 when summer jobs weren't as common. There are things you don't learn in school, and time for the sake of time is a precious gift.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- avgcorrection 4y agoPet peeve of mine: some older adults are proud that they get up early. And that’s OK in isolation. The problem though is that older adults rule society moreso than younger adults, and certainly compared to teenagers. So for many older adults it feels natural to go to bed early and to get up early. But then we as a society confuse that with universal “good behavior”/good character, so everyone has to dance to that tune.[1] And we do get up to things so that we aren’t expelled from school or fired from our jobs. But some of us do it at the cost of our health and well-being. [1] Or maybe the cause of our early starts is completely different. It’s not like I have any proof.
- rcpt 4y agoWe have ceded far too much power to the morning people.
- providedotemacs 4y agoWe change our clocks every year for the night owls.
- anthomtb 4y agoFirst mover advantage.
- bee_rider 4y agoBack in caveman times, somebody had to stay up to tend the fire and keep watch. Unfortunately in the world of houses and locks, the daytime people don’t need us anymore, and since they get up first they set the agenda. Should have let the leopards eat them.
- asciii 4y agoI feel like you're onto something. Growing up, I was always told "The early bird gets the morning worm." In my opinion, I did not want to be the worm waking up early.
- xyzelement 4y agoI do think there's actual correlation between getting up earlier and achievement. I don't know many successful people who get up super late. Don't know if that's correlation or causation, just that there's something to getting up early to crush it.
- graycat 4y agoNaw: Not all but much of the unwritten but standard rule of all of education from K-Ph.D. is (A) to exercise the standard drive people, the teachers and their bureaucracies, have to control and direct other people, the students, and (B) to make those under the control to knuckle down, put their nose to the grindstone, shoulder to the wheel, burn the midnight oil, be disciplined, prove themselves, be obedient, stimulate the metabolism to be able to work while sleep deprived, .... One way to see this -- as I did twice in grad school and once in high school -- is to take a filter, flunk out course when already know the material very well and easily and effortlessly make As and lead the class -- the prof can become really angry that he was not able to intimidate the student, lower the student's self-esteem, show the student that they, the prof, know more than the student could hope to know, etc. In this case, the 3Rs, the STEM fields, the term papers, etc. are not really the preparation for life but merely the packaging while the real preparation is (B).
- harry8 4y agoWhat time does school start in the USA? I assumed it would be the same as here but apparently not, never heard of a school formal lesson starting before 8:30 here and 9am start is the norm for all school and always(?) has been. Separate to that how cynical should we be about these psychology studies? As a science it seems hell bent on demonstrating that it is closer to poetry or religion which means we should start with an extremely sceptical prior before closely examining evidence /especially/ when it is telling us something to which we're sympathetic. Stats is hard, sure. Get it wrong by all means, repeatedly wrong even. There is no excuse for not owning that and correcting it rather than doubling down when that comes out if you're claiming to be a science. None. No excuse for not clearly identifying it every time it happens and publicly noting it. [1] No excuse that every first year, university level psych textbook seems to contain the completely discredited [2] "Stanford Prison Experiment" as though it was anything other than gross scientific fraud. It is still being taught to first year as though it were science. How? Seriously. Is everyone in psychology a fraud? Surely not. [1] https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2016/03/05/29195/ https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2016/03/05/29195/ [2] https://www.nine.com.au/entertainment/viral/stanford-prison-experiment-faked-say-people-involved/4a1833c2-ff70-4813-8727-7458d4652b8e#:~:text=One%20of%20the%20most%20renowned,by%20people%20involved%20in%20it https://www.nine.com.au/entertainment/viral/stanford-prison-.... edit: links backing it up for those who haven't yet heard how bad it is or just want it to go away. It won't.
- kesslern 4y agoMy school bus arrived at the school at 7:05 every morning. We were allowed in the building at 7:15. At 7:28 we were allowed to go to our lockers. Classes began at 7:30. My bus time varied by year, but the earliest pickup time I had was 6:20.
- harry8 4y agoOk. Deeply surprised by that info. I basically never woke before 7am (and that was too early!)
- giantg2 4y agoMaybe schedule and school choice would be better. I even went to earlier classes before the official start of school and did fine. One size does not fit all, and pushing a universal change in start time will hurt some students.
- _yb2s 4y agoI was a nerdy, awkward kid with a lot of social anxiety, that experienced a lot of bullying and hazing at school. I would stay up all night playing on the computer, and just sleep in class during school. At home I would draw the blinds and stay in my messy room alone, in the dark. I was overweight, had bad acne, and had no energy. I was in a lot of pain, and felt like absolute shit, but nobody seemed to understand or care. They would tell me I needed to stop being "lazy" and clean my room, and do my homework. I wanted to really bad... but didn't know why I couldn't focus. I felt an enormous amount of guilt, like I was a total failure. As an adult, I was able to turn all of that around by focusing on basic health things- exercise, sleep, diet, and processing emotions. It seems like I was just extra sensitive to those issues, more so than most people. As a father, I hope I can help my son from going through the same.
- nsxwolf 4y agoWeird did I write this?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIts a common misconception that the goal of Education System is to educate. It's not, and the system will never accept 'improvements' that run contrary to it's purpose. In actuality education system serves four purposes: One: make both parents avaliable for the job market. For that it must supervise children during work hours, to make sure they aren't getting in trouble, drugs, or worst of all, into politics and protest Two - They must habituate little wild chimps into highly unnatural behaviour. Wake up early, commute into arbitrary location, sit in one place for hours on end, stare into paper, whiteboard or screen, perform meaningless tasts tasks that have no meaning to your life. Thats your whole life. If you don't ease people into this gradually, you run out of psycaotrists. Three - grade people into quality batches, based off their punctuality and ability to perform meaningless tasks to arbitrary and meaningless quality standards Four - because the management has gone trhough the same system of educations, the pupils must learn to read through poorly worded vague instructions and understand what their superior actually wants to see, even though they are not capable of expressing it clearly. Poorly worded exam papers serve as good training.
- mc32 4y agoIf the above is all true, that would prepare pupils for future jobs --whether self-employed or working a corporate job. One cannot run (successfully) a corner bakery without being able to handle routine and carry out mundane tasks or without getting up early and doing basic chores as well as being able to interact with others, keep track of your finances, etc. Corp job is much of the same. You're getting moulded to have the potential to be a productive human being. The alternative is to have people find out what works and not on their own. Even drugs dealers and macs know the importance of all the above. Now, sure some people for various reasons cannot conform and revert to more "chimp self" and don't do well in civilization. But even if they became foragers and lived off the land, they'd have to learn routines, have attention to detail, patience and so on.
- andy_ppp 4y agoI dunno man, pre-civilisation and education wasn't exactly much fun either. I'd rather be a part of the system that basically gives us everything from food to iPhones and the Internet than fight against it (while avoiding predators in the wild). This is not to say that education, especially for boys and young men couldn't be made considerably better.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bookstore-romeo 4y agoA teenager myself, I agree schools should start later. To my surprise, the gym teacher is allowed to make some students wake up at 5 A.M. to run laps. There's also no reason why classes starts so early at my specific school, as sport teams and extracurriculars are basically inexistant. The bureaucracy behind all of this must be such a nightmare in Canada too...
- rr888 4y agoThe problem is if you start later, you'll end school later which means you'll start activities/dinner/homework later and go to bed later and there wont be much difference.
- DangitBobby 4y agoDoes the research bear that out?
- blurbleblurble 4y agoAdults too please.
- hintymad 4y agoIsn't it that most of the elite high-school students in the bay area will not have the luxury of going to be bed before midnight? 10+ APs, multiple ECs, at least one sports team, perfect GPAs... Even smart kids have to sleep less to achieve more. I personally don't think it's worth it, but it is what it is.
- mcv 4y ago> Teenagers need about nine hours of sleep a night—but they get closer to seven. Mine isn't doing too badly then, I guess. He usually goes to bed way too late in my opinion, after 10 pm, sometimes 11 pm. But he comes out of bed just before 8, so that still adds up to 9-10 hours of sleep. 8:30 is the normal school start time around here, and he can bike there in about 15 minutes. The article doesn't go into what the starting times of the offending schools are, but if it's before 8, then I would definitely agree that's way too early and irresponsible.
- nerdponx 4y agoI remember by high school bus always picked me up before 7. I think my first class started a little before 8.
- iamleppert 4y agoWe need to start running these schools like a tech company. Institute a performance management system like OKRs, and put students on a PiP if they need it. If students still fail to perform, punish the parents. Student achievement should be individual but also partly tied to the performance of the school. Work should be managed via Agile manifesto, with students having stand ups and participating in planning poker. Velocity should be monitored and getting done as many tasks as possible should be encouraged. Also I think all student work should be done via git. Just think of the possibilities! We would already have a legion of workers right out of high school! This would put downward pressure on tech salaries, making the workers far less costly!
- crazygringo 4y agoI seriously don't understand why schools don't simply swap elementary and high school schedules. When I grew up, and what seems to still be the common pattern, is that the buses go out first for high schoolers to start school early, then do a second route to pick up the elementary schoolers who start school later. Can't we just swap those? Elementary school kids wake up earlier naturally, and this helps the parents who need to get their young kids off in order to get to work. While high schoolers are perfectly capable of waking up and catching the bus on their own, even if their parent left for work two hours ago. It seems like it's better for parents' logistics. Am I missing something here?
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoThis is what my high school did and it worked great. That extra hour of sleep in the morning as a high-schooler was crucial to me getting 7-8 hours a night. It's better for students and for parents. You just need to have adequate afterschool programs for grade school kids until their parents get off work.
- kingbirdy 4y agoYou're missing two things, one for each age group: For the younger kids, each hour earlier they start is an hour earlier they finish, which means parents need to either finish work earlier (not possible for most people), or pay for an additional hour of after-school child care (expensive). Having free child care to cover the gap between school finishing and work finishing is extremely rare, and the acceptable age to leave your child unattended after school is going up due to over protective parenting (for example, I was a latchkey kid starting in the 3rd grade, but nowadays that seems almost unheard of until middle school). For the older kids, starting later means sports / extracurriculars finish later, potentially after dark or after the parents are done working and expect kids to be coming home.
- crazygringo 4y agoDefinitely can see what you mean about the younger kids in the afternoon, thanks -- I'd definitely been missing that in my thinking. Funny I never thought about it till now -- in my public elementary school back in the day, the (minority of) kids who didn't have a parent at home in the afternoon, stayed an extra 2-3 hours at school for the rest of the afternoon at no charge, mainly doing art activities like finger painting etc, and they even provided snacks. I remember joining a few times just because I wanted to hang out with my friends there. It was very minimally structured/supervised -- just something to do to maintain interest but not be rowdy, not intended to be "educational" or anything. I've never heard of that kind of thing since though. But it sure makes a lot of sense for that to be provided standard by elementary schools, now that 2 working parents is the norm.
- nazgulnarsil 4y agoWe're abusing kids to service a completely unworkable subsidized childcare solution with an incoherent pedagogical model. The future will not forgive us.
- uzername 4y agoI've seen this for many years, I think it's even been tries here in Twin Cities MN schools. Bus driver shortage and route consolidation of the last few years probably didn't help, but perhaps the "take the city bus" routine for high school students has changed the behaviors a bit. Getting off the school provided dependency could help shift the timings to what works best and not necessarily need to account for sports students.
- dkqmduems 4y agoHow about we let everyone sleep?
- freework 4y agoMy high school started at I think 6:45. I would set my alarm for 6:00, but would hit the snooze button a few times until about I think something like 6:20 when I had to absolutely get up. I knew that if I got out of bed at 6:21 or 6:22, I would have to rush to get to school on time. 6:20 was the exact latest time I could wake up without rushing. I had the times down to the minute. Every morning was a struggle to get out of bed. I never got used to it. Now as an adult, I work from home, so I wake up and go to sleep whenever I want. If I want to wake up at 3PM and go to bed at 5AM, I can do that with no consequence. It's amazing. These days I occasionally have to wake up early, but when I do, I have no problem doing so. I think it's because if I'm waking up early these days, it's because I'm doing something special that I want to do, like traveling. This makes be think think the reason why I had such trouble waking up as a teenager was because I just hated school so much.
- TurkishPoptart 4y agoI hope to pilot a unique sort of homeschooling cooperative with other participating parents. It would be open to those adults who have demonstrated ability to teach a class/subject decently well enough. On Tuesdsays and Thursdays, kids would learn government, on Mondays and Wednesdays, math or foreign language. Parents would teach groups of children of hopefully similar age groups. I'm not sure if this is even possible or likely, but it sounds better than subjecting them to the hell that is public school, with the increase of suicide risk and the recent obsession with exposure to transgenderism among very young children in some school districts, anything seems better than the public school status quo.
- pmarreck 4y agoTheir parents have to work though
- Nifty3929 4y agoSchools schedules are at the convenience of teachers and parents.
- ramijames 4y agoMy high school in Virginia started classes at 7:20am. It meant I had to be at the bus stop at 6:50am, and that meant getting up at 6am if I wanted to eat breakfast. As someone who had a night owl tendency and a distinct interest in computers, I ended up staying up late most nights. I'd get 4 or 5 hours of sleep and it was never enough. In 10th grade I just gave up on school because I saw no value in the torture of getting up that early for classes I learned nothing in anyway.
- HeavyStorm 4y agoHell, yes! I've been saying this all my life. At one point I was forced to wake at 5.30 because we lived too far from school. I'm can't say it caused depression, but it surely made me feel like crap every day, almost all day. And this is not particular to the US. I live in South America and it's the same here. With one benefit - we don't engage in as many extra curricular activities, so that won't be a problem.
- eezing 4y agoLess sleep is correlated with more device, tobacco, and drug usage. Weird. But yes, school shouldn’t start before 9AM.