11 ms·
Excellent. GitHub is in my opinion crossing a whole pile of lines here that should not have been crossed without the authors explicit permission, regardless of
by jacquesm 4y ago
Excellent. GitHub is in my opinion crossing a whole pile of lines here that should not have been crossed without the authors explicit permission, regardless of the utility of the tool they built. Copyright is not something that can be signed over by a terms-of-use change of a hosting provider, the expectation is that your host does not automatically claim the rights to anything that you store there.
Such projects should always be opt-in, not just because it is the law but also because it is common sense and the right thing to do from an ethical perspective.
- amelius 4y agoI just hope it doesn't end in Microsoft paying some (from their perspective) small fine that is just the cost of doing business.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe range of possible outcomes is enormous, I'll just wait by the sidelines but cherish the thought that moving out of GitHub when Microsoft bought it was the right decision. They can't be trusted, this has been proven over and over again and yet people keep falling for it. It's the fox guarding the chickens. I wrote about my misgivings at the time: https://jacquesmattheij.com/what-is-wrong-with-microsoft-buying-github/ https://jacquesmattheij.com/what-is-wrong-with-microsoft-buy...
- qayxc 4y ago[flagged]
- codetrotter 4y ago> moving out of GitHub when Microsoft bought it was the right decision What do you use instead? The top alternatives in my opinion are: - SourceHut https://sr.ht/ https://sr.ht/ - Codeberg https://codeberg.org/ https://codeberg.org/ - Self-hosted using Forgejo https://forgejo.org/ https://forgejo.org/ (fork of Gitea) I was self-hosting my code with Gitea for a while but currently I’m using GitHub. Planning on setting up a Forgejo instance in the coming weeks. At work we use GitLab, but personally it is one of my least favourite platforms, so I am excluding GitLab from the list above.
- nucleardog 4y agoDepending how big of an install you’re running and exactly what featureset you need if you’re planning on self hosting I’ve been happily using Gitea for years.
- tpxl 4y ago> - Self-hosted using Forgejo https://forgejo.org/ https://forgejo.org/ (fork of Gitlab) Forgejo is a fork of Gitea, not Gitlab.
- codetrotter 4y agoSorry, that was an autocorrect mistake. I meant to write fork of Gitea. Edited it now.
- Beltalowda 4y ago> The range of possible outcomes is enormous The most likely of which – if this lawsuit ends up winning – is that corporations will have new ways to sue everyone and that the world will be a worse place. Copyright expansion has never benefited the "little guy" such as Open Source authors, only large entities with deep pockets who can litigate to no end.
- ralph84 4y agoAgreed. It's quite bemusing how so many people are now copyright maximalists because they somehow think Microsoft will be hurt in such a world.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's not so much copyright expansion as it is copyright re-affirmation. In this case it is especially open source authors whose rights are in play. Keep in mind that all of open source relies on copyright, without that everything is PD from Microsofts point of view, if they hosted it. Think of Copilot as a trial balloon, if they get away with it they will likely use that as the stepping stone to the next level and bit by bit your rights are salamied out of existence. This is the first slice, it should stop right here.
- Beltalowda 4y agoI don't see any rights being taken away from me. CoPilot doesn't copy my code, it just learns from it, just as you can. "Others can learn from this" is one reason I release stuff as open source in the first place. People will quote that John Carmack Doom example where it copies the function verbatim, but as far as I can tell that's a rare thing, and it's a function that's been widely copied around without proper licensing; a human could also get it wrong by copying it from github.com/random-person/mit-project with the wrong license (and since then there's also been work to prevent this kind of thing). Co-pilot isn't unique, or the first AI/ML project to use copyrighted works; all the GPT models use copyrighted works as their input. Some doubts have been raised over the legality of that too, but it's received nowhere near the amount of criticism that Co-Pilot has, certainly not on HN, and I've never seen anyone doubt the morality of it – only the legality. If you were to go through my public open source code I'm sure you can find stuff that's very similar to some code from my previous employers or other open source projects. Not because I copy/pasted anything, but because my brain was trained on that dataset: you see or write something that works, you face a similar problem a few years later, you write a similar solution. "Using existing works as input" is common throughout creative works. As Phil Anselmo once said: "with Pantera we took our five favourite bands and ripped 'em off to hell". People are already getting sued because "that one melody sounds a bit similar to this other melody"; fair use is already widely ignored/disrespected. Much will depend on the exact details, but any win in this lawsuit has a very real chance of empowering that sort of nonsense.
- fhd2 4y agoI agree, I've yet to see any sufficiently large organisation successfully change their DNA. Gates hired people who thought like him, those people hired people who thought like them, and so on. The culture can and does change, but it takes an enormous amount of energy and time to change the course of such a large ship, if it's even possible at all. And I don't really see them trying - I've never even seen them apologise for the stunts they pulled with Netscape and all that. They put on a new coat of paint, hoping people forget. But I suppose they can't help themselves.
- teo_zero 4y ago> moving out of GitHub when Microsoft bought it was the right decision But what prevents Microsoft from harvesting open-source code from any hosting site? What have you gained?
- qayxc 4y agoBut why stop there? What's the difference between Microsoft, Google, Meta, and OpenAI in this regard? All of those build their models based on the same sources and it's therefore a much more general issue than just one particular company being sued.
- tpush 4y agoI mean, yeah.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's a good point, but the subject of the thread is Microsoft. I'm pretty sure that Google will happily train their models on the contents of your Gmail account, I wouldn't trust Facebook with my birthdate and OpenAI is likely doing the exact same thing. But that doesn't make it right in this case and, conveniently, someone has decided to bring suit. The funny thing is that Microsoft depends on Copyright law for their existence and now they want to change the rules to favor them when it suits them. In fact one of the first things that Bill Gates ever did that I remember is bitch about people copying the software that he wrote.
- marcosdumay 4y agoGoogle and Meta aren't redistributing your code claiming that it's theirs and that you can re-license freely.
- pjmlp 4y agoOnly because they arrived later at the party.
- jacquesm 4y agoHm, I don't know about that. I think they do plenty of stuff with other data that crosses that same line but they have not crossed it with (explicitly copyrighted) code, and until they do I don't think we should argue that if they had been there before that they would have done it, they had ample opportunity.
- bluGill 4y agoWhile the fine is a cost of doing business, if they don't change behavior they can be sued again, and courts tend to impose very large fines if they discover you were already fined for this and didn't change afterwards.
- NicoleJO 4y agoThe "fine" is 9 billion dollars.
- jwestbury 4y agoAgainst a company which makes 6-7x that in yearly profits, that's still not an effective deterrent.
- tenebrisalietum 4y ago1/6th or 1/7th of profits is significant. 9 million dollars could be ignored by a company making 54,000 or 63,000 million dollars, but 9,000 million is a lot.
- drstewart 4y agoExactly. That's why you're arguing for fines against people to be significantly more than 1/6th of their net pay, since harsher punishments are effective deterrents? Parking tickets should start at 50% of your yearly take home income. Didn't feed the meter an extra quarter? $10k minimum sounds fair.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoIf the fine is higher than what they can feasibly gain from the product in a reasonable time, it'd make them drop the product entirely even if they are able to adjust it to conform to the laws.
- jasode 4y ago>lines here that should not have been crossed without the authors explicit permission, regardless of the utility of the tool they built. Fyi... Google Books (scanned and OCR'd books) eventually won against the authors filing lawsuits of copyright infringement. So there is some precedent that courts do look at the "utility" or "sufficiently transformative" aspect when weighing copyright infringement. https://www.google.com/search?q=google+books+%22is+transformative%22+%22fair+use%22 https://www.google.com/search?q=google+books+%22is+transform... But courts in Europe may judge things differently.
- jacquesm 4y agoA number of points in Google's favor: they are not passing off Google books content as their own, they limit your access to a small fraction of the offering. The thing that surprised me about that ruling is that it was deemed final without a chance of an appeal.
- b112 4y agoAs well, Google is, because of these things, somewhat acting as a library. An libraries are very special entities.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoWhat if a library builds AI models from the content they host? The Internet Archive, for example.
- kmeisthax 4y agoNot really. Google won because Google Books was not actually a new concept; someone else had already built a book search engine the same way Google did, also got sued by the Authors Guild, and also prevailed. The only thing different about Google Books was that it'd give you two pages worth of excerpt out of the book. So it was very easy for a court to extend the fair use logic that they had already weaved into the law. I still think "training is fair use" still has a leg to stand on, though. But it doesn't save GitHub Copilot because they're not merely training a model; they're selling access to its outputs and telling people they have "full commercial rights" to its outputs (i.e. sublicensing). Fair use is not transitive; if I make 100 Google Books searches to get all the pages out of a book, I don't suddenly own the book. There is no "copyright laundry" here.
- judge2020 4y ago> Copyright is not something that can be signed over by a terms-of-use change of a hosting provider, I mean, it's obvious that uploading code requires you license the hosting provider a license to host it (which is not singing over copyright); although feel free to argue that the license doesn't or shouldn't extend to CoPilot usage.
- jacquesm 4y agoCopyright is pretty complex legal material but the one thing that stands out for me is that you receive it upon creation and it requires a positive act on your part to relinquish it.
- Eleison23 4y agoThat's not obvious, because you don't necessarily own the code you're uploading. I can upload any sort of MIT-licensed, BSD-licensed, Apache-licensed, Creative-Commons-licensed, or GNU-copylefted works I want, anywhere within reason and compatible with those licenses, but if I didn't write them then I don't have the legal right to relicense, grant exclusive or restricted license to any specified parties. So in a way this would void parts of many TOS agreements where you do relicense your User-Generated Content. If we're uploading memes to Facebook, they're gonna have to work out license terms with the copyright holders, not the uploaders.
- judge2020 4y agoUploading someone else's code without permissions is, in itself, copyright infringement. Just like you can't take someone else's code and license it to GitHub without the copyright holder's permission, you can't take images off of someone's website and sell/license them to Getty Images for profit.
- pron 4y agoI'm not sure that's the case if the repo is private and the code is not shared/disseminated to others. If you buy a book, you are not allowed to distribute copies of it, but you can loan it or sell your copy, or store it wherever you like. Copilot does allegedly distribute copies of code that it doesn't have the copyright to.
- dspillett 4y ago> Copyright is not something that can be signed over by a terms-of-use change of a hosting provider Agreeing to GitHub's terms doesn't try to assign copyright over your code, it grabs licence to use your code however they see fit which is¹ legally quite different. Of course the real fun comes if someone agrees to their terms then uploads some of my code which they have to right to assign the licence to GitHub for. What come-back do I get in that case if I don't want my stuff used that way? It seems odd to me that MS² who for many years strongly spoke against touching anything with the remotest whiff of GPL because of what it could legally do to your release requirements, are now more than happy to hoover up all the GPL covered code in GitHub and potentially mix it into their users' work output via copilot. ---- [1] in my not-at-all-legally-trained understanding [2] current owners of GitHub, for those not paying attention
- judge2020 4y agoIt seems a lot of this stems from how the DMCA does not require that these hosting providers actually check for code ownership at submission, or maybe just how they don't have an explicit checkbox for "I affirm that I can license this code to GitHub" every time someone is uploading code. If it is shown that the license in the TOS is valid, the legal question might boil down to "is the TOS License broad enough to where nobody thought that it allowed their code to be used in for-profit ML models?"
- dspillett 4y agoA checkbox would make no difference in the case where the uploaded has not been granted the right to agree to such terms with respect to the code in question, leaving the matter in the same situation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TAForObvReasons 4y agoI'd like to propose a "golden rule" test. If Copilot was truly not at risk of regurgitating large blocks of code verbatim, why didn't Microsoft train it on proprietary Microsoft code as well? Why was it limited to user-submitted code on GitHub? If there is any argument pointing to licensing or copyright or patents, it stands to reason those concerns would apply to any corpus of user-submitted code since users could easily misrepresent the licensing.
- breck 4y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 4y agoI'm sorry but Copyright is very much the law of the land no matter how often you post your links.
- breck 4y agoPhysical slavery was once the law of the land too. I like to think I would have been on the right side of history at that time, as well.
- jacquesm 4y agoYou are simply not making much sense, and to compare physical slavery with copyright is ridiculous.
- bastardoperator 4y agoIt made perfect sense. Laws change all the time... in some cases they're invalidated by the court.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Laws change all the time That still doesn't make breck right. If I say "slave ownership can't be signed over by a ToS change" that's a true statement, despite me being anti-slavery. Copyright could be many things. But that doesn't change what copyright is right now. And even if they are offensive, they don't "void logic".
- breck 4y ago> and to compare physical slavery with copyright is ridiculous. On the contrary, you cannot mathematically distinguish (c)opywrong laws as anything but a kind of slavery. Define a person A as a slave to person B if person B has legal control over person A at all times. Now imagine person A is hanging out with Person C. With (c)opywrong laws, Person B has legal control over a subset of person A's behavior in this scenario (they are forbidden from sharing certain files with Person C by Person B). Hence, Person A is a partial slave to Person B. It is not metaphor, it is literally a subset of the same thing. Intellectual Slavery is just slavery from many masters.
- zozbot234 4y agoNot "excellent" at all. This Richard Roe plaintiff is trying to use the notorious DMCA as an end-run around having to prove copyright infringement and withstand a possible fair use defense. That shouldn't be allowed, as a matter of Constitutionally-relevant protections.
- chrismorgan 4y agoBut hang on, there would only be a DMCA violation if copyright infringement had in fact occurred, right? So fair use would be a perfectly legitimate defence, causing the DMCA not to apply. Look, proving copyright infringement is downright trivial here, if copyright law applies. And that shows where GitHub’s defence will—must—lie. (And for other readers unfamiliar with the parent comment’s phrasing: “end-run” is apparently an American sporting term which here makes “as an end-run around” mean “to circumvent” or “to work around”.)
- speeder 4y agoThat unfortunately, is not how the DMCA works. DMCA was designed to catch not just normal pirates that share the copied content, but also "crackers" that figure out how to share content that is protected somehow, as such it offers various ways to infringe it without infringing the copyright itself. Basically they are accusing MS of behaving like crackers, by removing stuff from code to allow it to get shared illegally.
- mpoteat 4y agoIf this lawsuit succeeds, I have a startup idea that I think would be effective. Create a for-profit copyright registry for code snippets that are long enough to qualify for copyright protection. You can be the canonical owner of the copyright for a given piece of code! For a premium fee, we can generate and submit a patent on your behalf as well. Once I have a large corpus (perhaps millions of entries of code, most one or two lines long), I can automatically scan new respositories and send cease and desist letters for violating my client's copyright. Even if a piece of code is very common, that doesn't mean its unoriginal, it just means that there are many people violating its copyright after all. According to the logic of the folks in this thread at least.
- moralestapia 4y agoOh, the internet! Just yesterday, I bought a nice domain name for an idea that's very close to what you mention, monetize on snippets of code. If you want to team up, hit me up!
- layer8 4y agoDo note that there’s the concept of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality, which may be substantial for mere code snippets. This may be one of the reasons why the lawsuit isn’t based on copyright.
- mpoteat 4y agoThis is the code of the future to ensure your code remains original: https://twitter.com/TylerGlaiel/status/1611115741809627139 https://twitter.com/TylerGlaiel/status/1611115741809627139
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gmiller123456 4y ago
- baby 4y agoYou say that like Github Copilot could have been trained in a different way. There's just too much utility and progress in Github Copilot to let this lawsuit win.
- bee_rider 4y agoThat’s really up to everyone whose license may have been violated to determine. Personally I get zero utility from copilot (although, I only have a little code on GitHub so it isn’t a pressing issue). Signing up for disperse litigation like this seems like a pretty ballsy move by GitHub, but hey, Microsoft presumably has in-house lawyers with lots of spare time.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's not how the law works.
- baby 4y agoThe law around copyrights is from a different era
- kllrnohj 4y agoWhy should Microsoft's ability to create a new revenue stream be more important than anyone else's ability to enforce their licensing terms?
- baby 4y agoYou’re saying this like users of github copilot are out of the eq
- sfifs 4y agoThe mafia used to steal dresses from New York garment factory delivery trucks and hawk them door to door in poorer neighbourhoods. The users (poorer households) definitely got value out of this by being able to obtain dresses they could not afford, but doesn't make a case for what the mafia was doing was right.