26 ms·
Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ‘history of crashes’
- EricE 4y agoThis is seriously needed near me - there are a couple of freeway interchanges with notorious merges that sport accidents bad enough that at least a couple cars get towed every week. Not sure it would cause the idiots that cut in and cause them (and who usually get off scott free) to shape up but would at least give more heads up to other people to maybe not tailgate at high speed?
- akira2501 4y agoI would assume that a statistically significant increase of accidents in an area is due to road design failure and not to lack of driver information. The obvious answer is to fix the road, not add more automated distractions to a drivers attention load.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoAgreed, in principle. There is an intersection on my commute that was almost certainly designed to look pretty and break up the monotony of the grid layout with some elegant curves. Sadly there are accidents almost every single week, most likely because of bad sight lines and how much turning goes on. It would be nice for them to "fix the road" by just straightening it out but it would likely require a staggering amount of time and money because of how much infrastructure has been built up around it. The city has already tried what it can, so I think having the warning in the app is the best we can do in the meantime.
- madspindel 4y agoIs it a road design failure if it's more dangerous to drive above the speed limit? In Sweden we have some roads with a lot of accidents caused by people driving above the speed limit. They fixed this by installing automated speed cams. The goal is not to give people speeding tickets but to get drivers to slow down. It works really well so I actually believe this new Waze feature will be really handy. Edit: Btw, I use Waze to get alert about the speed cams.
- EamonnMR 4y agoI can think of one intersection in my town with several accidents. It's a cross intersection with stops signs on one street and none on the other. The accidents probably all boil down to some combination of "He won't pull out" and "I'm tired of waiting." A signal light would eliminate this indecision. I fault the road design, because it requires patience people just don't tend to have to use it safely.
- rattlesnakedave 4y agoIt's not mutually exclusive.
- akira2501 4y ago> They fixed this by installing automated speed cams. That is a user hostile way to solve the problem, and it still leaves the design issue open. _Why_ are people driving too fast for what the road can safely allow for? There's a lot of work being put into road design which naturally calms traffic, and a good part of it shows promise. Large wide open boulevards seem to encourage people to driver faster than what is actually safe because they feel comfortable driving at that speed with that much perceived space. If you narrow the road, add center island obstructions to limit long distance views, remove outside lanes for parking with curb extensions or put in protected bike lanes, roundabouts, better lane markings, they all seem to make drivers more aware of the density of their environment and work to slow them down naturally. And again.. this all works to get them paying attention to the environment, not simply trained to wait for an automated alert with financial consequences.
- b112 4y agoThis fad only works for a short while, then people just get used to it.
- jackvalentine 4y agoIs this your opinion?
- 4y ago
- macNchz 4y agoGenerally I agree, we should absolutely design roads to guide drivers into proper behavior, but there are some drivers who are simply way more dangerous than others^, and I'd love to have this feature to know where to be extra alert for other drivers messing up. I have a fascination with watching dashcam videos on /r/roadcam and /r/idiotsincars (I think it has made me a better/significantly more defensive driver), and seeing some of the videos from places that have fixed cameras that catch every crash just makes it clear that some portion of people simply don't pay attention to anything. In the 11'8" bridge example (https://11foot8.com/ https://11foot8.com/), they've installed a system that detects if the approaching truck is too tall, flashes an "OVER HEIGHT" neon sign, and automatically turns the traffic light red. They even raised the bridge 8 inches a few years ago. People consistently ignore the sign, run the red light, and rip the roof off of their truck on the special bar that was installed to protect the bridge from direct damage. In the Milwaukee Roundabout example (https://www.youtube.com/@MilwaukeeRoundabout/videos https://www.youtube.com/@MilwaukeeRoundabout/videos), drivers are coming across the bridge way, way above the speed limit to go sailing as far as they do. Perhaps in this case the road could be narrowed and speed bumps installed, but this is a contingent of drivers who are not paying attention to the road, and the rest of us would benefit from knowing where they screw up. ^As an example, 17-19 year old drivers have a 19-fold higher risk of a fatal single-car crash than 60-69 year olds: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022437517307600#s0035 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002243751...
- hammock 4y ago“Warning: teenagers at the wheel” (in the style of “children at play”)
- BitwiseFool 4y agoI have a feeling this would be considered unacceptable ageism elsewhere, but Japan requires some drivers to display a sticker which indicates to "other drivers that the marked driver is not very skilled, either due to inexperience or old age". For the Young/New: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoshinsha_mark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoshinsha_mark For the Elderly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C5%8Dreisha_mark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C5%8Dreisha_mark
- anigbrowl 4y agoThe obvious answer is to fix the road If you're paying, sure. If you're not, the obvious answer is to route away from the accident-prone routes while trying to minimize increases in journey time.
- julianeon 4y ago"never let the perfect be the enemy of the good" fix the road <= perfect solution warn people that the road is bad until the road is fixed (possibly never) <= good solution
- dmix 4y agoI've heard Waze is merging teams with Google Maps. Will Google Maps adopt these unique alert features?
- Someone1234 4y agoIs this actionable? Seems like noise without purpose, almost like showing off their data haul without there being anything a driver can change to be safer with this additional information. Plus is this road-usage normalized? A freeway with bumper-to-bumper traffic is going to have more crashes than a country road with a few vehicles an hour, but one crash a day on one Vs. multiple a day on the other could be required to indicate a more dangerous stretch in real-terms.
- googlryas 4y agoWouldn't the thing the driver could do is pay more attention? Like it or not, but driver attention rises and falls along a drive. Or, take a different route, probably eventually as presented by waze? Presumably they aren't just going to say "hey a lot of people die on this route. LOL good luck"
- Someone1234 4y agoSo the goal is to keep the driver's attention on the road by flashing an additional notification to distract them from the road?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- googlryas 4y agoMaybe? A one second glance could put you in the mindset where you're ready to brake hard, or put some extra distance between you and the car in front, or choose to not search for the next song you want to hear, etc.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoMost GPS and Map Apps have audible notices. Mine speaks up if there is debris or an accident ahead and it is not intrusive or wildly distracting. For as long as these kinds of navigation utilities have been around, it seems like the implementation of non-intrusive or at the very least not-overly-distracting notifications have been figured out by the industry.
- nfRfqX5n 4y agoassuming they have the data, it would be great for them to publish a report of the most dangerous roads. they could even suggest routes that are "safer"
- grecy 4y agoAnd that should result in the roads / intersections being redesigned to make them safer.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe roads that are "safety corridors", at least the ones in California, are rural two-lane, two-way undivided roads where people kill themselves trying to overtake cars that are going 1 MPH slower than them. The only way to redesign these is with K rails down the middle, but the ideal thing to do is mandate speed limiters in cars.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI would expect speed limiters to make overtaking more deadly.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe point is to stop idiots from overtaking.
- Dylan16807 4y agoBut it won't do that. Sure, it'll probably reduce the number of overtakes. While making the ones that happen so much worse.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoIf they're so much worse that the overtakee is frequently fatally involved the problem will eventually mostly solve itself in a perverse way...
- xwdv 4y agoWhat I would like is warnings about roads with a history of police sightings.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoIf that information were to be shared, it would stop being useful quickly.
- sammalloy 4y agoI use Waze every day. The police (speed trap) notifications usually appear in the same spot so it’s already the case if you remember where they were the day before.
- drewg123 4y agoIt would be nice if they could offer an option to avoid roads with histories of crashes (like tolls and ferries). One example I have is there is an intersection on my way home that Tesla maps (and Google maps) wants me to turn left at. The problem is that its a left turn without a signal, across 4 lanes of traffic with limited visibility. This is a recipe for crashes, and I've seen multiple crashes here. However, if you go 1/4mi out of your way then you go under a bridge and wind up at an on-ramp to the same road .. no left turn needed. It took me a while to discover this route when I moved here. It would be nice if there was a "safer route detected, +1 minute" option presented to me.
- kqr2 4y agoIt would be nice if there was an option to avoid uncontrolled lefts on busy intersections in general, aka "UPS mode" which supposedly UPS does: https://hbr.org/2014/04/ever-notice-that-ups-trucks-rarely-make-left-turns https://hbr.org/2014/04/ever-notice-that-ups-trucks-rarely-m...
- gibspaulding 4y agoI've been wishing for this too. Not fastest or most fuel efficient, but the easiest route. Really just as few turns as possible, but especially avoiding things like two way stops and uncontrolled left turns.
- Scoundreller 4y ago“Lowest cognitive difficulty”
- mkmk 4y agoWise Waze
- joshbuckler 4y agoEase Waze
- tantalor 4y agoAt a higher level you could model a danger/anxiety/rage level for a segment of road taking in lots of signals like crashes, sudden stops, swerving, honking, speeding, etc. Then you could offer an "avoid shit drivers" route option.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>Then you could offer an "avoid shit drivers" route option. All that would do is route me around the wealthy suburbs. Unfortunately that's rarely a good way to get where I'm going.
- geocrasher 4y agoThere is room for such alerts in many ecosystems. For example, WordPress: There should be alerts for stale plugins, plugins that have recently changed authors, and other metrics for awful plugins. It could be condensed into a trust level rating from 1-5. That's only one example.
- ungamedplayer 4y agoMy google maps has been doing this for weeks already. Is google maps Waze?
- modulated 4y agoGoogle bought Waze in 2013
- clamprecht 4y agoWhy doesn't Google Maps (or Waze) offer 3 choices: 1. Fastest route 2. Shortest route 3. Safest route <-- this is the big one The insurance companies would love it, and I'd love it. The data is out there... I've been asking this for over 10 years.
- tonymet 4y agoAlso the "least stressful route"
- IshKebab 4y agoThey have started suggesting routes with fewer turns.
- tonymet 4y agowhich i like, but "least stressful" for me would be avoiding busy intersections, or road construction, areas with lots of accidents, crime-ridden areas. I frequently take more complicated back roads to avoid areas like the above.
- alsodumb 4y agoWhen the total distance traveled for the shortest vs fastest option is very high, Google always shows both the options (or at least, some versions of them). I think safest route is hard to define, especially given that the data is not dense and may not be relevant (e.g., an intersection had a lot of historical accidents so its technically unsafe based on data but it has been rebuilt recently and there has been no accident since so its currently safe).
- maxbond 4y agoSpeculation, but probably their legal department feels like that'd be a sort of implied warranty, and if the route wasn't appreciably safer (what does that even mean? Surely reasonable people/people with a different set of strengths & weaknesses will differ), they might open themselves up to lawsuits? Possibly a similar situation if they claim they can tell one route is safer than another, but then don't give you the safer option?
- sixothree 4y agoI remember a local news story where a woman described neighbors having complained to the city for years on end about a particularly dangerous intersection where someone recently died. She lamented how now that someone had died the city would have to do something to fix it. And all I could think about was how the city was very literally not going to do a single damn thing about it.
- odysseus 4y agoThen it's time to vote those city council members out until they start listening their constituents.
- blackhaz 4y agoSorry for the rant, but is there a navigation app that allows to turn off all those alerts and notifications? This is horrible. You begin driving with Google Maps and are barraged with endless pop ups like "would you like to save 2 minutes?" or "do you know this is a toll road?" or something else. The damn thing won't shut up and demands so much attention instead navigating - THIS is what's really unsafe. Also, the overdensity of information on the screen is mind-boggling. Combined with the choice of mild designer palette robbing all the contrast - I wonder if this is only me struggling? Or am I getting old?
- timmytokyo 4y agoWaze allows you turn off most alerts. For each type of alert, you can configure whether it should be shown on the map and whether it should issue a vocal alert.
- jakear 4y agoUgh, worst of it for me was a trip back from the Olympic peninsula late at night a while back -- Apple kept trying to auto-reroute me to a path that would have me waiting 3+ hours for the ferry instead of driving around the peninsula (<2 hr). So now it's dark, raining, I'm on unfamiliar roads, and I have to keep taking my hands off the wheel and fucking with my phone to get it to just keep on doing what I configured it to do in the first place. I cannot fathom why the "No, I don't want that route, keep me on the one I picked" interaction is not treated as permanent. Edit: I just checked and they still seem to think the Kingston-Edmonds ferry is some sort of magical warp drive that instantly transports you from A to B in precisely 1 half hour from your arrival at either endpoint.
- sedatk 4y agoI'm surprised to hear that Waze is doing something. After the Google acquisition, all I'd seen were new voices and new car models to mark your location on the map, nothing else. Is Google using Waze as their staging platform now? Because Google Maps features aren't incorporated into Waze (lane-based navigation, street names in voice guidance etc).
- kmfrk 4y agoThe Planned Drives feature telling you the best time to leave sounds pretty cool. I just wish there were a good Google alternative for it. Especially if you manage to plot the congestion graph for the entire day. https://techcrunch.com/2016/03/16/waze-now-tells-you-when-to-leave-thanks-to-its-new-planned-drives-feature/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/03/16/waze-now-tells-you-when-to... Some Home Assistant documentation at - https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/google_travel_time/ https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/google_travel_tim... - https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/waze_travel_time/ https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/waze_travel_time/
- H8crilA 4y agoAround the place where I'm from the local government put one cross next to the road for each fatality. It was on a local single-lane road. And they used data that stretched decades back. There really was a lot of those, especially around every turn, and it did make people slow down. Ironically the crosses were eventually removed because they were deemed distracting. To be honest they kind of were, at night, because they were covered in slightly reflective paint so that you can still see them at night.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway1777 4y agoThey could also alert when there are drivers nearby with a history of crashes and bad driving.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoJust figure out which drivers are correlated with a lot of deceleration from other drivers. As a bonus this will catch all the "leaves close calls in their wake but never winds up at fault so they think they're a good driver" brand of bad drivers.
- tonymet 4y agoThis will soon be banned in the way that Real Estate Agents are banned from mentioning "bad neighborhoods".
- LeonB 4y agoI (in Australia) want preferences about avoiding right turns across busy roads (equivalent to left turns in the US). I use Google Maps and it seems to constantly choose options with all of the difficult turns. Passengers in my car (ie my family) want an option that prevents the driver from complaining about the navigation.
- sammalloy 4y ago> I (in Australia) want preferences about avoiding right turns across busy roads (equivalent to left turns in the US). I use Google Maps and it seems to constantly choose options with all of the difficult turns. This would be incredibly useful in congested areas. Good feature suggestion.
- mmis1000 4y agoI would like google map add the cost of turns to the length of route. It always turns a lot(sometimes even zigzag) and think it would be sooner to arrive at the target. But that isn't really the case in city area. I would like a option that avoid turns if possible unless it is really too far.
- darkwizard42 4y agoJust an FYI, when Google Maps comes up with routes, there are penalties for complex maneuvers built in when ranking routes. An unprotected left will add a time penalty to the route option when it is ranked against alternatives. I understand what you are hoping for is a much harsher penalty (or maybe even a way to customize it completely), but wanted to point out that things like U-turns and other maneuvers are treated as penalties
- Scoundreller 4y agoThey already have these warnings on Waze in France. Either history of crashes or high risk of ‘someone gonna die’. Usually you hear something like “you are entering an automated speed control zone”. I wish Waze did Audio call-outs of speed limit changes.
- remote_phone 4y agoWaze innovation died as soon as they were bought by Google. It’s really sad. Same thing happened with Nest.
- sammalloy 4y agoQuestion: what is the average delay in real-time traffic reporting in the app? In my area it always seems to lag at least 15 minutes behind actual conditions, which makes it less than helpful.
- efitz 4y agoIs there any open source geodata about traffic accident frequency?
- dudeinjapan 4y agoThis is a wonderful idea. A college friend of mine died in a single car accident. They interviewed a DOT officer who said something to effect of "Yeah, people drive way too fast on that street, no one anticipates the sharp corner, I guess nothing can be done." The first step to fixing any problem is acknowledging the problem exists.
- lucisferre 4y agoMy experience with Waze is that it is more likely to cause crashes, at least where I drive. It constantly recommended side street shortcuts with little to no time benefit. These are streets where there is usually not room for two cars to pass in opposite directions and pedestrians, dogs and bikes are frequently going to be hazards.
- sandworm101 4y agoSo... We need a technological answer to replace a simple sign? "Dangerous road ahead" conveys the message pretty well.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoThey should do speed traps next. (Looking at you Springer, New Mexico.)
- 1970-01-01 4y agoHas been a feature for over a decade.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI know about "speed check" ahead. This was in the wee hours and it is unlikely anyone would have "crowd sourced" it. When I googled later though I found plenty of people complaining about this particular place in this small town where the police regularly trap "speeders". (FWIW, it's a 15 MPH school zone ... no kids at 6:00 in the morning but apparently that's not relevant.)
- carom 4y agoThis is my street. 2 lanes each way with a turn lane, goes to 3 (no parking) during rush hour. The right lane is usually pretty empty so people go fast to get to the light. Left turners will be turning through 2 stopped lanes of traffic and not see the cars flying down the right lane. At least once a month there is an accident. Tried calling a few city departments to report it but couldn't find the right one.
- lynx23 4y agoInteresting that this kind of alternative-route-calculation is now beginning to creep into car navigation. It is a well known (and unsolved) problem of pedestrian navigation for blind people. Often, the shortest path is not the best, period. Especially because dangerous or uncomfortable sections of your route will actually cost you more time then going the longer, but more safe alternative. However, its a question of what data you have. For blind pedestrians, the insight until now was always that we simply dont have the data to be able to calculate this reliably.
- penguin_booze 4y agoOn my wish list is the ability to quickly drop a pin/mark a location/make a short audio recording while I'm driving. I might spot a pothole I want to report, or see an interesting landmark about which I'd like to search more, or want to note down the number plate of a misbehaving vehicle. When driving through unfamiliar roads/places, I've no way to track where and what I exactly I saw.
- bravetraveler 4y agoWhen I think of Waze or any navigation thing... I'm longing for fewer distractions. Not more!
- 2devnull 4y agoIf more people used waze this would be a cool natural experiment: Does priming people to think a road is dangerous increase the number of crashes? There are self-fulfilling prophecy type effects in psychology. I can see how making people more anxious could do that. Also could see how removing the more risk averse traffic from certain stretches of road, would make the traffic that remains more dangerous; fewer cars leading to greater speeds. I feel like waze and other “people engineering” apps don’t fully grasp their responsibility in shaping human behaviors.
- culopatin 4y agoI would love if they had a rating per county of speed traps in case you’re driving alone on a long stretch at night and there is no one to report them.
- fire 4y agonot much longer 'till it straight up tells me to take the highway to the danger zone
- thisismyswamp 4y agoThis is way overdue and such a gain for little effort both in the engineering and on the user side. Not about to switch from maps to Waze, but does inch closer!!