10 ms·
TikTok banned on government devices under spending bill passed by Congress
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoReally really sad. I hope the US stays open to competition. Otherwise we will go the way of Soviet Russia.
- edgyquant 4y agoWe will. What the US is doing here is the same thing it has always done. This is just current and an app so people think it’s something new.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ffssffss 4y agoThis is already happening at a state level, and with some not-unconcerning implications: https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/22/tech/tiktok-universities/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/22/tech/tiktok-universities/inde... For those two schools, students are completely blocked from accessing TikTok on school networks.
- tareqak 4y agoI wonder what school boards and the different levels of government will think about a sudden increase in students using VPNs and Tor.
- edgyquant 4y agoThey’ve likely blocked tor already
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoWill students even bother? They mostly have cell phones with data, they might not even notice unless they are connecting their phones to university wifi for some reason.
- thevagrant 4y agoI don't think that would bother me with my kids. Is TikTok a necessity for school related activity? When I went to school, I couldn't access the internet. I had to wait until I got home.
- CircleSpokes 4y agoUniversity isn't the same as grade school. It is absurd a public University would do any sort of filtering or censorship on their networks.
- coderintherye 4y ago>any sort of filtering This is a rather absurd position if you consider it. To take the absolute simplest example, you really think a school should not be allowed to filter traffic from students specifically launching purposeful attacks on school network infrastructure?
- np- 4y agoAttacks are a bit different than someone trying to access information, though. Much like it is illegal to punch someone in the face, unless they try to punch you first.
- CircleSpokes 4y agoMaybe I should have been more specific. In my mind there is a difference between stopping outgoing ddos attack and blocking/censoring websites.
- coderintherye 4y agoNow define "outgoing attack". You're trying to keep it defined to "ddos" only but surely you would agree that the school filtering a student actively attempting to hijack school infrastructure to send active shooter threats to the student population should also be filtered yes? Keep going a few steps and you'll realize that's exactly the problem, there's no level of specificity you can define here that works without some level of subjectivity. Try and see. Good luck. Suggested reading: https://twitter.com/yishan/status/1586955288061452289 https://twitter.com/yishan/status/1586955288061452289
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoOklahoma and Alabama doesn't really surprise me. However, kids are going to use tiktok via their phones and phone data plans anyways, it doesn't sound very effective.
- Thorentis 4y agoGood. Tik Tok is bad for children, regardless of who owns it.
- eiiot 4y agoMost schools ban social media websites on school Wifi (Instagram, Discord, etc.)
- ffssffss 4y agoI should have been more precise with my words, I'm talking about universities where adults are attending. I don't think that's true for most universities? At least it wasn't 10 years ago. Back then we all used Facebook quite a bit!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- endisneigh 4y agowhat's curious is why any social media would be allowed on government devices.
- Adraghast 4y agoHow else would the folks at Eglin AFB get their Reddit fix? ;)
- defrost 4y agoThe Q's must drop . . . ( apologies, that was hard to resist )
- nodogoto 4y agoA lot of government agencies maintain social media presences. The White House has a Twitter account, for example. So there are presumably federal employees with Twitter installed on their work phones for the purpose of operating that account.
- cute_boi 4y agoThey represent minority of workers. So, it should be allowlist approach where only few people can access Twitter, Tiktok, Facebook etc.. All other employee app installation must be disabled, if it is really privacy and "national security concern".
- endisneigh 4y agosure, but why would all government employees need access to social media by default?
- pishpash 4y agoSocial media is today's media and the first job of government is to control the media (with exclusivity) for propaganda. Why are you surprised any government not only wants to be on social media but also to ban ones it can't control?
- eunos 4y agoEven The Democrat as a party has Tiktok account.
- nixcraft 4y agoI understand why they banned it. However, I also know western apps are closed to work in the Chinese market. So I get privacy and security are reasons to ban the TikTok app at the school or government level. However, I would like to see the same tight control for every app that invades privacy regardless if it was made in the EU, USA, China, etc. Is that too much to ask? Or is lobbying so intense from Google, Amazon, Meta, Apple (who is now getting into the Ads business too), and co that it is next to impossible to have tight privacy control with these apps?
- edgyquant 4y agoAt the moment at least it’s hard to make a similar argument for any of those companies posing a US national security threat.
- happymellon 4y agoHow you can't put Meta in that same group astounds me considering that they have a significant history of this.
- dicomdan 4y ago[flagged]
- braingenious 4y agoGlad that there are absolutely no similar things happening in US or European politics! It’s great to live past the light of Valinor where no bad things happen.
- sterlind 4y agoneo-nazi is a bit over the top. there are actual neo-nazis.. the American Nazi Party, the Azov battalion (formerly), skinheads and things. sure, China's trying to force Han ethnic principles on their populace. arguably nationalist, though they're so involved in trade and stuff like the Belt and Road program that it's different. an authoritarian regime, arguably a dictatorship (Xi has the final say but he's not a strong-man like Putin, CCP is more an oligocracy.) but... no, China does not want to resurrect Hitler and lead the Aryan race into the fourth Reich. neo-nazi has an actual meaning, which is important because there are actual neo-nazis out there.
- linkjuice4all 4y agoIt looks like the federal government has banned software from federal devices via a mix of executive orders, Federal Acquisition Regulation, defense appropriations and other laws passed by Congress [0](non-exhaustive list). Many of these prohibitions target specific platforms, companies, and hardware so actions like this are not unprecedented. That being said - one of the reactions I've noticed to the "we need to ban TikTok" movement is that we should target behavior instead of specific companies. The issue with that is many companies and platforms owned by "friendly" companies would also be impacted by increased security and privacy protections provided to all US residents - not just those employed by the federal government. [0] https://cmmcinfo.org/2021/01/20/list-of-hardware-software-and-services-banned-by-us-government/ https://cmmcinfo.org/2021/01/20/list-of-hardware-software-an...
- jen20 4y ago> The issue with that is many companies and platforms owned by "friendly" companies would also be impacted by increased security and privacy protections provided to all US residents Doesn’t sound like an issue to me. Anyone tracking or profiling is inherently unfriendly, regardless of national origin. Ban the lot.
- ajross 4y ago> Doesn’t sound like an issue to me. Anyone tracking or profiling is inherently unfriendly, regardless of national origin. Ban the lot. I think that's somewhat strained. "Tracking or profiling" for the purpose of advertising when applied generically to all users in a reasonably anonymized way is... simply not in the same class as "tracking or profiling"[1] applied to target specific journalists in order to suppress coverage of inconvenient newsworthy facts. It's just not. Not remotely. TikTok got caught doing something way beyond the pale. And at this point[2] I think it's very reasonable for people to view their future behavior as inherently suspect. As a large actor, I can have very little trust in ByteDance's future behavior. But Facebook and Google and Amazon... quite frankly they've proven pretty trustworthy with the same kind of data so far. I think continued trust isn't unwarranted. [1] The more common term of art in this context is generally "espionage" [2] Until last week, I was absolutely in the "let them sell their app, they have the same rights anyone does" camp. But now? Sorry, they burned the bridge. You don't get three strikes once you're caught spying.
- rvz 4y agoThat is a good start and it needs to go further. It is also now time to fine TikTok in the billions of dollars for not only privacy violations like this [0], but for also lying [1] about accessing US data from overseas after admitting they have done so. [2] No surprise on that as I have always expected them to screw over their users. [0] https://futurism.com/tiktok-spy-locations-specific-americans https://futurism.com/tiktok-spy-locations-specific-americans [1] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-tapes-us-user-data-china-bytedance-access https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2022/12/22/tiktok-tracks-forbes-journalists-bytedance/?sh=28eee5eb7da5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2022/12/22/tik...
- washadjeffmad 4y agoA bit hypocritical since that's a tacit purpose for the existence of Facebook/Whatsapp, Google's... everything, and as we've come to discover, Twitter. I still remember when the CIA's Total Information Awareness team was rebranded in the early 2000s and some of the members hired into Facebook, which coincided with the opening and expansion of Facebook as a global "social media" site. It's wild that the news ever used to report on things like that. I suppose it did take a little longer to get rid of the journalists following 9/11.
- rvz 4y agoExcept that Facebook has paid a massive fine after they repeatedly violated the privacy of its users; and that was in the billions of dollars. What TikTok has done is much worse that Facebook and it only makes total sense for the US regulators to give out a multi-billion dollar fine to TikTok, if it wants to continue to operate in the US. There are no exceptions for large social networks with billions of users to get away with repeated privacy violations which TikTok has done.
- washadjeffmad 4y agoAnother interpretation is that Facebook purchased permission from the government to violate the rights and privacy of millions of people. It even spawned the creation of international policies like the GDPR. They weren't told to dismantle the services they used that data to build, including their ad tech, so what really did they lose except time?
- citilife 4y agoHow does the government... ban something... in a budget bill?
- jasonlotito 4y agoOn government devices. These are their devices. I’m surprised it was allowed.
- quasarj 4y agoWell, it probably just wasn't explicitly banned. Though like you say, I wonder why they don't have a whitelist instead?
- washadjeffmad 4y agoKind of funny, but the last guy who looked at me like I was an idiot for asking for a detailed list of what actions should be performed to "whitelist" something had never had to implement one himself. Each agency, bureau, department, school, and institution would not just have to have IT people to implement the whitelists (eg- in mdm or by policy, which they may not already use), but get people to serve on committees to approve, build, and maintain the whitelists, create the processes to field and test all whitelisting requests, create a process exception request process, and coordinate with whatever external governing or regulatory bodies' lists to ensure compliance. It wouldn't take long before the employees would just start using their personal devices and hotspots for everything to avoid the hassle, which would be so much worse.
- defrost 4y agoTangentially related, the Helms Amendment is but one example of leveraging the dispersal of funds. I've not looked into the specifics here but it wouldn't be out of place to tie aspects of budget funding to the existence of a questionable security risk being present in a government assisted environment.
- teeray 4y agoIf you throw the lever, the trolley won’t run over the livelihoods of thousands of federal employees, but all kinds of sneaky unfavorable things may happen.
- flappyeagle 4y agoWe should ban TikTok outright from American app stores, until the CCP allows American social media apps. It’s insane we don’t reciprocate.
- thepasswordis 4y agoNo, we shouldn’t.
- walls 4y agoWhy is freedom of speech suddenly not worth preserving when it comes from somewhere we don’t like?
- sundvor 4y agoI truly see it as a Chinese campaign to dumbify our society. We are swallowing it hook, line and sinker.
- itpragmatik 4y agoExcellent. Good decision.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoWhy wasn't it banned already? Government phones should be locked down and only used for work. They can TikTok on their personal devices
- hahajk 4y agoDeployed service members often (usually?) can’t connect to the internet using their personal devices. They use public government computers connected to govt networks.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI didn't know that. Thank you for the info
- SirAllCaps 4y agoIs there any infrastructure out there to limit or securely monitor what apps or features are enabled on company/institution mobile devices? Or are we for the most part in a "we expect you not to do this or that" era? I used to work for a small institution a while back (not USA), they used a Word file of approved apps, authored by a non-IT employee. Their whole idea of InfoSec was equivalent to taping a water balloon to a steering wheel and calling it an airbag. Can't imagine the situation is much better in most other places. Scary really.
- viraptor 4y agoAny serious corp will have some kind of MDM deployed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_device_management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_device_management This can be used for various purposes - making a list of allowed apps, restricting internet / configuring VPN, enforcing auth methods, remote wiping the device, etc.
- varenc 4y agoDoes anyone have a link to the actual bill that includes the TikTok reference? I’d love to see the exact phrasing used. Also it’s interesting that they singled out TikTok instead of a more general ban on Chinese or any non-US owned and operated services. edit: Found it here: https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2022/12/JRQ121922.pdf https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2022/12/JRQ12... The TikTok section starts on page 2001. The actual content is a bit longwinded. The only mention of "TikTok" is in the title and in the definition of the term "covered application". The key phrase from the title: "DIVISION R — NO TIKTOK ON GOVERNMENT DEVICES" It seems the to leave the door open for other federal offices to expand the the list of banned apps: "...shall develop standards and guidelines for executive agencies requiring the removal of any covered application from information technology."
- NikolaNovak 4y agoI get that this is a thing - isolating one specific app for very specific reasons. I am honestly surprised it's a thing though - shouldn't all unapproved apps be disallowed from government devices? Whether Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, Pornhub or whatever - unless you have specific reasons such as e.g. PR position, shouldn't all these be relegated to your private device?
- Despegar 4y agoThis is part of the new Cold War and you can expect this kind of Red Scare thinking shaping US policy in the decades to come.
- verdenti 4y ago[dead]
- acdha 4y agoYes. I’ve been surprised that this is getting so much attention since every federal organization has a “no unapproved software” policy.
- Sevii 4y agoIt is bizarre that this required a law when as a private sector employee I can't even use Apple Notes on my work computer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 4y agoThis doesn't require a law. Government agencies already can manage which applications are used on their devices.
- IE6 4y agoYeah agreed - why does a government issued phone or device need anything more than what is necessary to perform their job? They are compensated enough to have a separate non-work phone.
- sacnoradhq 4y agoIt's surprising what apps are allowed on government devices. Why aren't they using MDM on all devices and only allowing business-necessary apps?
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoPretty dumb not to include WeChat since it's the greater threat.
- hangonhn 4y agoI wonder if it’s because US government employees do need to chat with their Chinese counterparts sometimes. For example, when the Economist produced “The Prince” podcast, the journalists chatted with some of their Chinese interviewees via WeChat — despite having an episode on Chinese government monitoring and censorship. They really don’t have a better choice if they want to chat with someone in China.
- nomilk 4y agoUntil 2020 TikTok was accessing device clipboards even when the app was running in the background [1]. Assuming the average user doesn't really ever 'close' apps, it means TikTok had access to everything a user copied/pasted on that device. Assuming the CCP can access data on Chinese company servers, then it's fair to assume the CPP is in possession of all of the clipboard contents. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/26/21304228/tiktok-security-ios-clipboard-access-ios14-beta-feature https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/26/21304228/tiktok-security-...
- jimbob45 4y agoHow is that not an Apple/Google problem? In what world should that functionality be on by default without explicit user permission?
- teej 4y agoBetter late than never - Google and Apple have since added OS level clipboard protection and notifications.
- colechristensen 4y agoThere can be more than one problem at a time. * Companies do this kind of data collection * users don’t take the time to make themselves aware of earth their devices and software does * this kind of data collection isn’t illegal * OS providers allow this data collection without appropriate controls or use notification * and others Some of these problems have been improved upon, but it’s definitely not just one groups fault.
- usrusr 4y ago“this kind of data collection isn’t illegal“ And where it is, there's so much more that's also illegal that just about any nasty thing can be hidden between the trivialities of the resulting consent banner dance. OS level protections are truly the least bad thing because they can also set arbitrary thresholds that would be impossible to define in law.
- 4y ago
- ok123456 4y agoDoes that mean Windows is banned?
- ok123456 4y agoBan Facebook too.
- cuuupid 4y agoIt's unclear to me based on the wording in the bill whether this only applies to government devices. IANAL but sounds like it would also extend to devices with government profiles installed, i.e. any contractor that has USG MDM on their phone or laptop. Also wondering if this applies to defense or just civil-side? People forget that a gigantic portion of the government is made up of federal contractors, some agencies are almost entirely made up of contractors. Depending on how this bill is interpreted this could lead to govt banning certain social media from the personal devices of FTEs/contractors with MDM enabled.
- greggarious 4y ago>this could lead to govt banning certain social media from the personal devices of FTEs/contractors with MDM enabled. So what? The PRC run concentration camps. I don’t understand why we bend over backwards to cater to them, maybe that’s why I’ve never been a contractor despite multiple long periods of employment after years of focusing on censorship circumvention, an alleged hot topic.
- nix23 4y ago>So what? The PRC run concentration camps. Yeah the US is not that different, however in much smaller quantity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_detention_camp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_detention_camp The "Reason" is the same, keep terrorists in a minimal law protected environment, and as we all know a declared terrorist has no human rights, also the laws of the country who detains him is not in effect, for whatever reason.
- greggarious 4y ago[flagged]
- nix23 4y agoLike i wrote the scale is different, but: "The greatness of a nation can be judged by how it treats its weakest member" And now you have a Nation with concentration camps who's criticizes another one with concentration camps...bravo. But i see your use of "comrade" means your a good/bad-country "painter" who cant recognize the color grey.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OnlyRepliesToBS 4y ago[dead]
- tw1984 4y agoI have the feeling that we will eventually have two internets, a Chinese one and an American one.
- fragmede 4y agoEventually? The Great Firewall was first called that in 1997.
- nostromo 4y agoAh yes, our annual budget. The perfect place to decide if TikTok can be on government phones, and what online sellers should do to police counterfeit goods. The absurdity of these people passing bills they have never read will never disappoint. You don’t even need to pay off congresspeople anymore, because they don’t know or care what they’re voting on.
- derangedHorse 4y agoI’m surprised more people aren’t hung on this. The fact that legislation can sneak into unrelated bills is infuriating and a danger to an increasingly vote avoidant society (at least in the U.S. where voter participation can’t even reach 70% for the presidential election).
- returningfory2 4y ago> increasingly vote avoidant society Turnout for presidential elections has been increasing in the US in the last decades. Also 70 percent is great turnout when compared with other countries.
- FpUser 4y agoMain point was that "people passing bills they have never read"
- kube-system 4y agoIt ain't called an omnibus bill because things are 'sneaking' in.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoVoter apathy is an issue, but I suspect the structural design of our representation has a bigger effect. Most seats in the Senate, and especially the House, are completely safe for the incumbent. Both parties’ primary systems heavily favor the incumbent, so actually voting out a particular politician in a deep red or blue state is almost impossible.
- swarnie 4y agoCan someone confirm for me how the banning of an app makes it in to an annual spending bill? The two don't seem remotely related from an outsiders perspective.
- supreme_loquat 4y agoCongress is totally broken, large bills like this are consistently shoved through and members of congress aren't given the opportunity to even read them before it's voted on. What's worse is they vote to pass them not even knowing what's inside, and what's even worse than that is that most of them couldn't care less about what's inside. They get told by the party leaders to vote for it and then they'll be taken care of, given party funding when reelection comes around, etc. I highly recommend following Justin Amash if you want to hear all about how it's broken, his twitter is quite informative, he also has a podcast although many of the episodes are not related directly to politics. Even if you disagree with some of his political stances, it's astounding to hear straight from a former house member just how bad it is right now. No time to read bills, no floor amendments allowed by the speaker, if you don't vote how the leaders want you to then you're never given any committee assignments (especially bad given there's no opportunity to offer amendments on the floor), etc. And it's not just one party, Ryan may have officially killed the floor amendments but Pelosi has done a stellar job keeping them dead.
- calltrak 4y ago[dead]
- davedx 4y agoWonder if this is why Musk ran the Twitter poll against it. Xi leant on him?
- o--o 4y agoTikTok is banned because USA companies lost to its competition it has nothing to do with security or privacy. YouTube and others tried copying TikTok and failed, and now they are trying to remove the competion. But as we all know, this will not work! Cat is out of the bag, and there is no stopping it online.