12 ms·
iPhone 14 Pro faced 'unprecedented' setback leading to removal of new GPU
- tinus_hn 4y agoSounds like a great opportunity for a desktop machine where power usage matters much less.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Pulcinella 4y agoI wonder if this was planned to use the PowerVR ray tracing solution. I believe Apple and Imagination Tech quietly buried the hatchet some time ago. I also wonder how this will work for the Metal API. Metal currently does have support for accelerating ray tracing via acceleration structures and a few other things that require GPU hardware features not present on older GPUs that are not specific to ray tracing only. It doesn’t not have support for ray tracing specific hardware acceleration like in NVIDIA’s RTX and AMD’s RDNA2 chips. This means you can buy a 6000 series AMD GPU, stick it in an Intel Mac Pro, and not actually be able to use the RT acceleration hardware!
- fleetfox 4y agoMetal API. I can not understand why they did not just go with Vulkan.
- Pulcinella 4y agoMetal predates Vulkan by almost 2 years.
- chamwislo 4y agoIt predates the name change from Mantle to Vulcan by almost two years. Metal was built using Mantles ideas. When AMD gave it to Khronos, they changed the name to Vulkan. Here is a comment from 2016 from a person already tired of explaining this to people. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11112078 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11112078
- acdha 4y agoThat has no citations and is pretty ranty. Given the timing, it seems more likely that all of the people in the industry working on similar problems identified the same problems with the previous generation APIs and since they all work with the same major developers they're going to be coming up with similar solutions.
- chamwislo 4y agoAt the time, Apple was using AMD GPUs in their macbooks.
- GeekyBear 4y agoMantle beat Metal to the press release stage, but Metal shipped before Mantle did. Mantle morphed into Vulcan even later than that.
- dagmx 4y agoI’m sorry but you’re quite wrong that Mantle was a simple name change to Vulkan. The mantle API was a foundation but what came out was quite different. Much of the Mantle team also went on to work on DX12 and Metal as well, so they have as much lineage to Mantle as Vulkan does The comment you link to also ignores all the context of the timing, including the significant amount of time between when Metal was released and mantle was donated to khronos, and how much khronos was pushing AZDO OpenGL at the time. The post you linked is quite biased and uninformed.
- gmueckl 4y agoThat's still no reason to keep Metal alive and ignore Vulkan. It's a huge competitive disadvantage by now. Put Metal on live support, implement Vulkan and transition to sit on a Vulkan translation layer. Profit!
- grishka 4y agoAnyway, MoltenVK is a thing.
- scheeseman486 4y agoMetal is missing enough features that wrapping from Vulkan will never be ideal.
- sbuk 4y agoBecause Vulkan didn’t exist when Apple developed Metal.
- my123 4y agoMetal does have that support on the API side afaik. Just that they didn't implement the raytracing support in the AMD driver side...
- terafo 4y agoMetal raytraycing is a thing and it's the officially supported API. I think AMD just didn't bother to write the driver since their GPUs are present much viewed as legacy by Apple.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoQuestion: If even most PC gamers are pretty take it or leave it, on the whole real time raytracing thing in AAA PC games, it being more of a flex rather than a must have, then what's the point of having this tech on a phone for iOS games? I don't game on my phone, so am I missing something wild here where seeing raytraced reflections on a six inch screen would be the ultimate game changer and have everyone rush out to upgrade their phones?
- Larrikin 4y agoMachine learning and AR are far more interesting applications of the GPU than high resolution traditional games on a tiny cell phone screen.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoWhat does this have to do with raytracing or lack thereof on a iphone GPU?
- Pulcinella 4y agoIn my mind it would basically be UI skeuomorphism 2.0, this time with photo-realistically rendered materials, lighting, and shadows.
- bpye 4y agoI wonder if they might be applications for accelerated raytracing in augmented reality applications? There have been a handful of publications suggesting it for a while, such as https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6297569 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6297569 . This demo video is pretty convincing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2MEwVZzDaA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2MEwVZzDaA - looks like it was part of a PhD thesis https://www.peterkan.com/download/kan_phd_thesis.pdf https://www.peterkan.com/download/kan_phd_thesis.pdf
- klausa 4y agoYou're missing the fact that Apple uses the same building blocks for their chips across all of their devices. The M1/M2 are "just" a bunch of the same CPU cores found in A14 and A15. They do the same with the GPU blocks — the GPUs in M1/M1 Pro/M1 Max/M1 Ultra (and presumably M2/3/4 etc. iterations of those chips) also have the same GPU cores, "just" more of them (and probably clocked differently, not sure on that). So missing the RT hardware for iPhone 14 Pro is probably not a huge deal. Missing it for A16 tape-out, which if the pattern holds, means it'll also be missing in M3-generation of chips, is a much bigger one.
- retskrad 4y agoThe M1 was such a groundbreaking chip. I don’t expect Apple to wow us again until the M4 or M5. This is a good time for Apple to pause, look at what Qualcomm, AMD and Intel are doing and see how they can attract the same class of talent that gave birth to the M1 again.
- crazygringo 4y agoI wouldn't expect another M chip to be groundbreaking in the same way ever again. Instead I just look forward to incremental improvement year after year, the same with the A chips. That's more than enough. Something similarly groundbreaking would requite a similarly radical redesign. Maybe there will be one another couple decades from now, but I can't even begin to imagine what it would be. Maybe something related to ML if anything.
- epolanski 4y ago> That's more than enough. Sure but..already the second gen didn't show gains _that_ impressive over the first one. If M1 successors will start showing Intel 2010s gains gen over gen, it's not gonna do great.
- KyeRussell 4y agoHow well the M series will do over time would be based on its comparative performance. For all the “not that impressive” gains of the M2, there still seem to be plenty of people that historically wouldn’t buy an Apple computer but are ‘begrudgingly’ buying Apple laptops due to M series performance. Have we seen anything that delivers a comparable value proposition, let alone a better one? It seems natural that M series chips won’t forever be uniquely positioned ahead of the pack. I don’t think that anyone besides Apple actually wants that in the first place though. I have every expectation that they’ll keep up with the pack, or simply move back to third party chips, even if that means changing architectures, which Apple is not scared of doing.
- nomel 4y ago> Sure but..already the second gen didn't show gains _that_ impressive over the first one. I don’t think performance is the only metric. For all we know, there could have been some considerable cost reduction.
- spoonjim 4y agoAmazing that with all this drama it never made it to the customer facing side or had any impact on the success of the launch. Truly an outlier among high performing companies.
- CharlesW 4y agoExactly my thought. Another was: Because Apple shares technologies between platforms, I wonder if this GPU development hiccup had any bearing on the apparent delay of refreshed MacBook Pros and the Apple Silicon Mac Pro.
- turpialito 4y agoFTA: 'Apple engineers were "too ambitious"'. Yeah, right. I'm sure management had nothing to do with pushing unrealistically time-framed specs down to engineering.
- Waterluvian 4y agoAnd then later the article says: > The error resulted in Apple restructuring its graphics processor team and moving some managers away from the project. Not suggesting this is or isn’t it, but the manager thing cuts both ways. I’ve had managers who push overly ambitious goals, and managers who defer to the overly ambitious engineers because they seem confident enough and the manager has failed to understand the engineer’s capabilities. I’ve experienced many engineers who are waaaaay too ambitious and really do not comfortably understand the true development cost to everything. They deliver the first 80% on time and the second 80% puts the project six months behind.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe phone comes out once a year, anything that doesn’t make it can just go in next year.
- vouaobrasil 4y agoThis seems like an odd use of 'unprecedented'. It's in the same category as "I made an unprecedented dietary decision today and decided to drink chamomile tea instead of mint". Yes, it might be unprecedented because I've never done that before, but it's also super boring. Who cares? So they tried to put too much graphics power in the iPhone and it didn't work. And it's not exactly a setback either. So they had to have a slightly less powerful phone. Whatever. Sometimes these article titles are ridiculous and I'm quite tired of this hyperbole, especially in tech. What about "iPhone engineers tried a powerful GPU but had to use a less powerful one".
- colechristensen 4y agoYes this is the engineering equivalent of putting too much ham on your plate at Christmas dinner. Unprecedented amounts of ham go uneaten! Early specs of engineering project don’t match final specs, oh the humanity!, more at 11. News content is frequently very stupid.
- squarefoot 4y agoApparently, every post we write here is unprecedented too. ...except if writing two consecutive identical posts, the second one being then not unprecedented, but making that pair unprecedented. Ok, I'll stop now:)
- Spooky23 4y agoExactly. “Engineer Blows Budget” is also known as a day that ends in “y”.
- mbreese 4y agoAgreed. When they wrote “missteps”, I figured that there were errors found in the GPU design. Instead, it seems like the design was fine, but had an unexpectedly high power draw. The GPU worked, it just needed more power than they expected. That doesn’t seem “unprecedented” to me.
- ip26 4y agoUnless they had previously perfectly modeled and predicted power, until this moment. (But that seems unlikely)
- tiffanyh 4y agoMac Pro I wonder if this was a bigger setback for the Mac Pro than anything else.
- exabrial 4y agoYou know what'd be better than a new GPU? USB-C with full speed USB 3.2/3.1 and Thunderbolt 3.
- ChildOfChaos 4y agoWhy? Most people don't care about this and only use the port for charging.
- jacooper 4y agoMost people care about having cables that actually work and don't cost a ton to replace
- acdha 4y agoAnd they’ve had that continuously since the iPhone came out so that’s a distraction from the real reason the EU acted: incompatibility. Lightning is a better connector but it’s not enough so to be worth so many people having cables which only work with one family of devices, especially since it’s not even Apple’s own laptops.
- mccorrinall 4y agoI found lightning worse than USB-C. So far none of my USB-C cables broke, however I already broke one lighting cable and my current one is only charging from one side. I sometimes plug it in with the wrong side up, and it doesn’t charge my phone. Then I have to plug it out, turn it by 180 degrees and plug it in again. Anyway, these issues could be user issues or bad luck (so please don’t comment on this), but I have one nitpick which isn’t: USB 2.0 speeds for pro-res footage are a joke. Why even praise your camera and the pro resolution format being introduced on iphone, when I can’t get it off my PC via cable vat decent speeds? I only used it once to make for a side project, and had ~30min of footage. Took about 1.5h to copy.
- dwaite 4y ago
- alx__ 4y agoThis yearly upgrade cycle is terrible. Their phones are fantastic, and now they're stuck in some sort of spiral to push things every year. They could stand to chill out I got the new 14 Pro, but only because I wanted the mag charger feature. Before that, the 11 Pro was still a solid phone and did everything I wanted and more. Won't be upgrading at least 3 years
- dilap 4y agoyeah, I went from a 12 to a 14, and honestly you could swap it back and I wouldn't even notice or care. maybe this is what we should expect, though, as the tech matures -- like cars: there's a new model every year, but only significant upgrades every half decade or so.
- pantalaimon 4y agoWhy did you feel the need to upgrade?
- dilap 4y agowhat can i say im a sucker but mostly 'ciz work paid for it & and i could give my old phone to my brother-in-law (who had recently lost his in a hilarious dating mishap -- a hike, a river, old shorts w/ holes in the pockets...). to be fair, the camera is better -- but im such a pitiful photographer it's wasted on me. also, the pill sucks compared to the notch. (notch disappears mentally, pill doesn't.)
- grishka 4y agoEven stupider is their OS yearly release cycle. Apple OSes are feature-complete. They have been for quite some time. They do need iterative updates to add new APIs for new hardware, but that's really it.
- ladberg 4y agoI like to stay on older OSes because I agree they're feature complete and I don't want to lose battery life to the newest ML hotness I probably won't use and won't run efficiently on my old phone. I've praised Apple for allowing me to do this by continuing to put out security updates for older phones, but the most recent set of pretty important security updates (15.7.2) have artificially been restricted to only devices that don't support 16. This is incredibly frustrating because all the work has been put into making my older device secure without having to update to the latest OS, Apple won't let me have the update and I have to go to 16 instead.
- andy_xor_andrew 4y agoI'm curious what software features were planned that depended on the high-power GPU, which I guess must have been scrapped. Usually Apple does not ship a new hardware feature without some software feature that showcases it. At one point Apple seemed all-in on using dot-matrix projections to scan 3D spaces. I wonder if this GPU would have enhanced that capability somehow. Or perhaps it was simply supposed to be the icebreaker for a future M3 chip of some kind.
- the_duke 4y agoFor the past few years there were regular rumors that Apple will launch AR glasses and/or a VR headset "really soon". AR goggles would definitely need to be light weight, so they would probably rely on an iPhone to do all the processing.
- GeekyBear 4y agoI wonder how much TSMC pushing back 3nm plays into this? Weren't they projecting 3nm risk production to start at the tail end of 2021 originally?
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoHardware development is brutal because there's long lead times. It is a regular occurrence that features ship in a broken state and the software (drivers, firmware, etc) either has to work around it or turn it off. That it was so bad they had to revert to the previous generation design sounds unusual, but it's not unheard of.
- bpye 4y agoCompared to the delays that Intel have seen in recent years it's honestly quite impressive that Apple have managed to get new silicon every year largely on time.
- ChuckMcM 4y agoSimulation fail? I'm surprised they didn't know exactly how much power it would draw, that seems to be a standard thing in chip design suites. If a company like Synopsys blew it I'd expect some financial recovery actions. That said, unprecedented? Pretty much every chip company I know of has made a chip that didn't meet thermals. The Pentium 5 was the poster child for a while of a reaching too far.
- dboreham 4y agoPerhaps it used a new unproven process, making power dissipation difficult to predict?
- ip26 4y agoSounds like they just discovered it late in the design process, not in silicon.
- jasonhansel 4y agoOne would think that the makers of smartphone chips would be particularly good at and experienced with calculating power draw.
- wmf 4y agoI wonder if A16 was backported from N3 to N4 which increased power consumption.
- therealcamino 4y agoThe article doesn't say it was an issue with the tools; it sounds like the design was too ambitious. Leakage power is not hard to quantify, but dynamic power is harder to evaluate, because it's workload-dependent. It's not always completely straightforward to get an answer.
- sounds 4y agoPiling on the speculation, the dynamic power draw when raytracing was enabled, especially the memory access patterns - and the poor performance in spite of the increased power draw - might have been the final blow. But if an entire h/w project is punted to "the next release" there's more than just one feature that contributed. So maybe the halo feature, raytracing, plus the other new Metal 3 features all contributed?
- zahma 4y agoAdding ray tracing to an iPhone screen as “overly ambitious” is one way of putting it. On that size display, is it even impressive to the user? Are devs going to design to that capability? I just don’t see the point when a lot of desktop users aren’t in possession of nice enough graphics cards to enable ray tracing.
- vineyardmike 4y agoiPhone chips have a long lifecycle and a large user base. The iPhone is one of the most popular devices in the world, and they have a 5+ year lifespan between yearly upgrades to people who buy secondhand years later. So an iPhone 14 chip will find use through 2027 or later. The iPhone chips periodically also end up in lower end iPads, Apple TVs, HomePods, etc. Beyond that, the engineering efforts impact all apple silicon, including Mac, so the efforts can apply to more devices.
- zahma 4y agoSeems kind of assbackwards to start baking in ray tracing to the smallest device. Is there some advantage to this?
- upbeat_general 4y agoOne possibility is that it doesn’t make sense financially on any other platform for devs. macOS games are dead and iPad games are better but still adding a complex feature for a small group of iPad users might not make financial sense.
- armchairhacker 4y agoApple is adding a GPU upgrade to iPhone? I really want them to compete with Nvidia release a brand-new, efficient but affordable GPU for mac. So that I can do ML training on mac and not rely on Nvidia and Windows. It would also help people who want to use mac for gaming,
- 14u2c 4y agoDid you miss the M1 / M2 series?
- wmf 4y agoThe M1 Ultra is already "equivalent to a 3090" (lol) so maybe the M2 Ultra will be "equivalent" to a 4090 (lmao).
- smith7018 4y agoApple bases the M series off of the A series. So the M1 is based on the A14 while the M2 is based on the A15. If this report is correct, then that means the M3 was supposed to get ray tracing.
- bpye 4y agoI wonder if the M3 could still get raytracing since the power budget is higher...
- redacted 4y agoI'm really curious as to why Apple has been unable to reproduce their leap in CPUs in the GPU space. It's not exactly surprising when Nvidia parts handily beat the M1/M2, but when both Qualcomm and Mediatek have better GPU performance _and_ efficiency [0] something is up, especially given just how far ahead Apple has been in mobile CPU [0] https://twitter.com/Golden_Reviewer/status/1605604617416429582/photo/1 https://twitter.com/Golden_Reviewer/status/16056046174164295...
- 7speter 4y agoDoes Apple need to catch up with Qualcomm and MediaTek in terms of raw gpu performance when Apple can optimize software and apis given to developers to work on its hardware? Or am I really out of date and is their public evidence of Qualcomm and Mediattek outperforming apple's hardware in real world workloads? Nvidia primarily makes add on GPU's, if I understand their business correctly. Apple integrated a GPU onto its m2 (or whichever chip is used in their studio) that performs comparably to the 3060, and even beat the the 3090 in some benchmarks/workloads. I think that's pretty impressive.
- packetlost 4y ago> beat the the 3090 in some benchmarks/workloads Did it actually do that or was it in the "performance per watt" comparison?
- literalAardvark 4y agoNah, it gets 10x fewer fps in anything, if you can even run it. Laughable comparison, really, given the disparity of the two. This isn't an ARM vs AMD64 competition where Apple has a 40 year instruction set advantage it can exploit. The 3090 is nearly state of the art.
- astrange 4y agoThe official marketing comparison was to a mobile 3090, not a desktop 3090. Completely different GPU.
- 7speter 4y agoIts really quite interesting to see that all of these companies that make chips are having varying degrees of issues with making GPU's. Intel's arc was rumored to have some issue with its silicon, AMD's RDNA3 is this strange failure after RDNA2 shocked the world (and everyone thought they would easily build on that), and Nvidia, while successfully pulling off incredible generation to generation performance uplift with Lovelace, has Jensen telling people that the silicon for cutting edge graphics is going to be much more expensive from here on out. I'm wondering if its issues with trying to miniaturize their designs to 4nm and beyond, and if this recent issue with apple ties into the issue with sram not being able to really be miniaturized further using current industry knowledge.
- pantalaimon 4y agoHow is RDNA3 a failure?
- nimish 4y agoIt's significantly less power efficient than was shown off.
- mastax 4y ago(from memory) more than twice the FLOPS, 60% more RAM bandwidth, but only 20% more FPS at best. There's something strange going on.
- 7speter 4y agoAt the moment the flagships are being matched by the 6950xt in some benchmarks. Hopefully the ‘fine wine’ effect kicks in and the 7900xtx gains on the 4090. The gpu market desperately needs that to happen.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoMy sadness is unprecedented - I can’t get a ray traced giant bag of gems for $20.
- olliej 4y agoNo, you just can't get it in real time. But you can it in my app for the much lower price just $0.50/frame. it's a bargain!
- fexecve 4y agoI wish HN had a way to mute submissions by certain users. That way I could be blissfully unaware of certain categories of tabloid news stories in here.
- tw1984 4y ago> The error resulted in Apple restructuring its graphics processor team and moving some managers away from the project, including the exit of key figures that apparently contributed to Apple's emergence as a chip design leader. This sounds like an IQ test to me. You have a team that kept a good track record for making breakthroughs, breakthroughs that made your trillion $ market cap possible. they tried to make another one but not successful this time. So you remove those key figures from the project after dozens have already walked away in the last few years? You need to have a <100 IQ to cook a paywalled story like the above.
- lizardactivist 4y agoOh dear. I hope humanity and civilization can recover from this "unprecedented" turn of events.