33 ms·
January 1, 2023 is Public Domain Day: Works from 1927 are open to all
- mdaniel 4y ago> Franklin W. Dixon (pseudonym), The Tower Treasure (the first Hardy Boys book) I loved those books growing up
- lb1lf 4y agoAs did I, my father had talked my grandfather into buying them as they were released in Norwegian in the fifties, so I had some fifty books on my shelves and read them all, some several times. I adored them, but in hindsight: Gawds, how formulaic they were. I bet with some practice, a ghostwriter could probably churn out a Hardy Boys book in a couple of days. Excellent childhood memories, though - along with Anthony Buckeridge's Jennings books, I spent more time with Hardy Boys books during rainy summers than I care admit.
- twiddling 4y ago"I bet with some practice, a ghostwriter could probably churn out a Hardy Boys book in a couple of days." AI written pulp
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Jan 1, 2023 will also be a fine day for film in the public domain, with Metropolis, The Jazz Singer, and Laurel and Hardy's Battle of the Century entering the commons. Also notable: Wings, winner of the first-ever best picture Academy Award; The Lodger, Hitchcock's first thriller; and FW "Nosferatu" Mirnau's Sunrise. Metropolis is so influential that I'd call it a must-watch for... well, basically any fan of popular media of any kind. Film, literature, graphic arts, video games, music(!). Its influence is everywhere. Sunrise is one hell of a roller-coaster of a movie. As with anything in the silent era (especially the non-comedy films) it's a bit of an acquired taste but it's among the earliest films that I didn't just find interesting or funny, but that really got me on the edge of my seat, several times. It's got some real "yell at the screen" moments :-) I enjoyed it way more than the director's more-iconic Nosferatu. Though, for my money, it's no M or The Passion of Joan of Arc, as silent film dramas go. Still, really good, and I think a lot of critics hold it in far higher regard than I do. Haven't seen the rest. > On the literary front, we have Virginia Woolf's To The Lighthouse, AA Milne's Now We Are Six, Hemingway's Men Without Women, Faulkner's Mosquitoes, Christie's The Big Four, Wharton's Twilight Sleep, Hesse's Steppenwolf (in German), Kafka's Amerika (in German), and Proust's Le Temps retrouvé (in French). Damn, what a powerhouse year in literature. And look at that, my favorite novel (To the Lighthouse) is about to be public domain! The Holmes news is awesome, too. Bunch of copyright troll dicks have been making doing anything with Holmes risky for years. Great that everyone can more-easily ignore them.
- whycome 4y agoMetropolis + AI could result in some cool outputs.
- runarberg 4y agoIt actually could be kind of interesting to have AI fill in the missing segments. I believe there are only 2 remaining, and we roughly know what is supposed to be there, but not able to restore it because of how few original copies remain. So you should be able to do a supervised learning to interpolate the remaining scenes and be fairly confident that it matches the version that was premiered in 1927.
- grujicd 4y agoI disliked Metropolis quite a lot. Maybe it was influential and was probably a gamechanger at a time. But is it good in any way from today's point of view? I'm not talking about effects or scenography which could not technically be better at that era. I'm talking about acting and script which look abysmal to me. I would probably not have this kind of opinion but it's often on some kind of top list and my expectations were high. Maybe I'm missing something? Or is it just touted for historical significance? It's not that I have a problem with old movies. Casablanca came out only 15 years after Metropolis and is perfect in every way I care about.
- wazoox 4y agoActing in silent movies is entirely different from what came later. That's why most silent stars didn't make it into the "talkie" era. Just like aliens in 60s movies speak English and are obviously people in disguise, you just have to adhere to the conventions of the time. Similarly, the ways to make the script go forward are usually quite different from what came later, because of the constant interruption required by text inserts. Last, the musical score is important. A bad one can make of break a silent film (versions from archive.org and similar sites often have random music instead of a true score). So you may need to learn the way of the silent movies before really appreciating them (out of slapstick comedy such as Harold Lloyd and Buster Keaton).
- dang 4y agoRelated (but we moved most comments hither): 2023's public domain is a banger - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34071163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34071163
- dark-star 4y ago...that is, unless Disney can force another extension to Copyright law in the next couple days. I wouldn't be surprised if they did (or tried, at least)
- jedberg 4y agoThey stopped doing that a while ago. They realized it didn't matter and was more beneficial for them so they can scoop up more public domain and make more movies out of it.
- phist_mcgee 4y agoKids don't care about Mickey they care about Rocket Raccoon.
- Pet_Ant 4y agoYeah, I realised my children, barely a decade old, don't really know the cartoon characters I took for evergreen as a child: Mickey Mouse, Bugs Bunny, Tom & Jerry, Yogi Bear, Woody Woodpecker and Rocky & Bullwinkle. I mean they could probably name all of them, but don't really have an attachment or think they belong to a pantheon of any sorts. I assume that companies foresaw this coming and decided not to invest in further developing or promoting characters that they couldn't have exclusive merchandising rights for the foreseeable future. Just making money off a new movie isn't enough if you can't have sole rights to license the t-shirts and have the current children introduce it to their children.
- jedberg 4y agoThey aren't stuck with 6 TV channels to choose from and they don't have the privilege of Saturday morning cartoons to introduce all of them. They have curated experiences on streaming apps.
- gus_massa 4y agoI tested with my 5 years old daughter: * She knows Mikey and Minie, I was sure about that, but I asked her anyway what kind of animal they are. [Hi from Argentina. In Spanish(es-ar) it's not obvious that "Mikey Mouse" is a "ratón".] She likes them. * Surprisingly, she knows Tom and Jerry, but she thinks it's a cat and two mice (??). I guess my brother show her a few cartoons (??), and in some of them Jerry has a friend (??). * All the other are dead. They have been good characters.
- jedberg 4y agoSo in theory every streaming service could put all these movies on their service, right? And I could sell a box set of "top movies of 1927"?
- cmeacham98 4y agoIn the US, yes (not willing to make a claim about IP laws in every country). Although I'm not sure how big the market will be as it will also be completely legal to share and download them on internet for free.
- pavlov 4y agoYes. But they are black-and-white and silent, which severely limits the audience these days. Some of these movies have circulated with more recent soundtracks, and those are off limits. In particular there’s a somewhat infamous 1984 version of “Metropolis” with music produced by Giorgio Moroder and Freddie Mercury. That won’t be in the public domain until 2079…
- not2b 4y agoA streaming service could hire musicians to do a new score for public domain silent movies, they would then have the exclusive right to distribute the combined work.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoYes, yes.
- ALittleLight 4y agoIt's absolutely shameful that public domain has been pushed so far back. I say make it ten years max.
- not2b 4y agoThe Berne Convention (an international agreement) requires at least 50 years of protection, and the US signed it. But 50 is a lot less than 95.
- mod50ack 4y ago50 years of protection after the death of the author.
- not2b 4y agoIt's 70 in the US now. From the US Copyright Office: "As a general rule, for works created after January 1, 1978, copyright protection lasts for the life of the author plus an additional 70 years. For an anonymous work, a pseudonymous work, or a work made for hire, the copyright endures for a term of 95 years from the year of its first publication or a term of 120 years from the year of its creation, whichever expires first. For works first published prior to 1978, the term will vary depending on several factors."
- mod50ack 4y agoYes, I know. The requirement of the Berne convention is 50 years after death. The US goes twenty years beyond that.
- twiddling 4y agoIf AI is the author then what?
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoNothing AI created can have copyright under current law.
- cauthon 4y agoQuestion about how public domain works in the US, specifically with regards to this comment in the original post: > Here are just a few of the works that will be in the US public domain in 2023. 2 They were supposed to go into the public domain in 2003, after being copyrighted for 75 years. But before this could happen, Congress hit a 20-year pause button and extended their copyright term to 95 years. Is the “20 year pause button” permanent, i.e. copyright term for all works moving forward will be 95 years? Or will that eventually expire and the term will revert to 75 years?
- not2b 4y agoPermanent. The term is 95 years now, unless Congress changes the law. And reducing it would be very difficult legally, with copyright holders suing for their theoretical losses if Congress "deprives" them of 20 years of protection that they now consider their property.
- 1980phipsi 4y agoI don't know if those suits would succeed. If Congress gives someone a benefit and then gets rid of it, then you can't sue the government to force them to keep giving it to you.
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoYou can, and it'll go through the federal courts. Your case might be quickly dismissed, or it might eventually cause a Consitution question to the Supreme Court. Or not.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- StevePerkins 4y agoYou could simply reduce it on a go-forward basis, grandfathering in works that are currently covered by the 95 year term. Not going to happen of course, regardless. But laws change all the time, and grandfather clauses generally make it a solved problem.
- georgeburdell 4y agoSteamboat Willie, which was an early (first?) appearance of Mickey Mouse, is 1928 so this next year could be interesting for copyright law
- fjfaase 4y agoPlease note that this list is for the U.S.A.. If you live in another part of the world, these books might still be copyrighted. For example, in the Netherlands (like most of the EU), it is +70 years, meaning we still have to wait 5 more years. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_in_public_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_in_public_domain
- mod50ack 4y agoNote that for a number of EU countries, US works are in the public domain once they are PD-US due to the application of the rule of the shorter term.
- londons_explore 4y agoAnd in other countries, it's really unlikely you'll end up in prison or sued for using something that is both 75 years old and already public domain elsewhere in the world.
- fjfaase 4y agoThere are a number of books that are based on Winnie-the-Pooh and quoting fragments. For a long time, I have had the idea to write a kind of annotated version of the stories with references to all the books that reference the text. I understand Disney has the rights to the Winnie-the-Pooh character and that they still might cause trouble for those who publish text from the books in Europe.
- mod50ack 4y agoNone of A. A. Milne's work will enter the PD anywhere in the EU until 2027, including all the elements of his character Winnie the Pooh, not counting elements introduced by other writers who added more later.
- mod50ack 4y agoIt's about equally unlikely that you'll end up in prison or sued for downloading copyrighted content in the United States, especially if it is PD elsewhere. In fact, if it is PD elsewhere, the chances of your being prosecuted for downloading it approach zero. Works passing into the public domain have very little to do with people actually getting practically slapped around for downloading them. But they have EVERYTHING to do with creating derivative works. If you create a film based on a book that is PD-US but still copyrighted in the EU, you can expect to get sued. PD terms also affect legal libraries and archive significantly.
- 1970-01-01 4y ago>Franz Kafka, Amerika Looking forward to someone taking AI/ChatGPT and finishing the unfinished book.
- kristopolous 4y agoWill the relevant YouTube videos that are "blocked in my country on copyright grounds" get unblocked on that day? Anyone from YouTube know if this is the case?
- santiagobasulto 4y agoExcuse my ignorance: does this mean that anybody can "legally" (for example) torrent-download Metropolis? Or that can be a "free" Netflix-alternative created today with movies that are part of the public domain? Edit: a lot of answers, thanks! But still, still kinda discussed. It certainly is an interesting topic.
- londons_explore 4y agoBroadly, yes. But there are details you'd want to ask a lawyer about. Things like if you rip one of those movies from a DVD, and that DVD was made more recently, you have to be careful not to include any creative work done more recently - for example an adjusted end credits sequence, coloring, restoration work, or minor re-editing.
- chr-s 4y agoYou'll often find these old silent movies with a more recently recorded soundtrack which may still be under copyright. For truly free film, I believe you'd need to scan a print of the film. I'd be interested to know of any efforts to obtain and host truly free archival copies of these old films.
- roflc0ptic 4y agoyes, you can now legally torrent metropolis. You can also make derivative works (e.g. you personally could make Metropolis 2: The Reckoning!) without fear of consequence.
- niij 4y agoyes From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain : > Because those rights have expired, anyone can legally use or reference those works without permission.
- kmeisthax 4y agoYes. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Internet Archive already has torrents of public domain film. There's also Project Gutenberg and Standard Ebooks for public domain books. Wikimedia Commons has a huge archive of public domain images and sound recordings.
- Thorentis 4y agoOur current copyright is far far too long. 20 years would be far more reasonable. We can talk about side issues all we want, but at the end of the day, copyright is about protecting the ability to generate profit. 20 years is more than enough time to profit from creative works. Are we as a society really saying that 75+ years is how much time people ought to be profiting from creative works? An absurd proposition in almost any other industry or pursuit.
- andirk 4y agoSeeing as the USA's ultra affluent crust is grossly crowded with generational wealth, I don't think they'd like the idea of removing any of their profits, however long ago and however void of any of their own toil, regardless of the overall good it would do.
- robocat 4y ago> is grossly crowded with generational wealth The top ten wealthiest people in the US did not inherit their wealth - and power law distribution of wealth really matters. That said, I agree there is a problem with intergenerational wealth, although possibly more through family political power and influence than their raw financial power.
- wraptile 4y ago> The top ten wealthiest people in the US did not inherit their wealth Not sure what you mean by that. Just going through the wikipedia articles they certainly seem to have inherited some part of their fortune. Using money to make more money isn't particularly complicated. You also inherit the social standing which makes successful investments much easier.
- robocat 4y agoThe money they “inherited” is a tiny percentage of the money they made. The other things they inherited matter: education, political and financial connections, and if they hit $0 they usually have backup options. What I am trying to say is that the money is almost irrelevant. If money were the only relevant issue, then the top ten would have all come from “ultra affluent” families and the top ten should all have recognisably older wealth surnames, like Windsor, Rockefeller, Washington. Inter-generational wealth matters, but where does Ford come into the Forbes list? Certainly the poor are less likely to move up (who on the Forbes list had parents from 1950s China?) Most importantly, the majority of arguments about the wealthy fail the smell test, as soon as you see the billions of people in the world who desire to be as well off as a poor person in the US. Don’t just look at those that are far wealthier than you, look at the number that are far poorer, and the arguments they would make about how you inherited your wealth.
- 33955985 4y agoCopyright should be life of the author/s full stop.
- chihuahua 4y agoBut then we'd get sob stories about how this condemns Walt Disney's great-great-grandchildren to starving in the street.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gus_massa 4y agoYou also get sob stories about the children of a famous singer that just died in a plane accident at the top of their carrier.
- loonster 4y agoNo publisher would want to sign a contract with an author that isn't likely to live much longer. It needs to be either a fixed amount, or Life + something.
- ars 4y agoIt should be life of author or 40 years, whichever comes later. Corporations and the like get 40 years.
- t-writescode 4y agoThat would not protect the author's family in case they died shortly after they wrote their final book "to help their family survive". It also would encourage authors to have "unexpected deaths". I'm a fan of 20 + 20.
- 33955985 4y agoThen make your children co-authors.
- a-dub 4y agocue science fiction plot: the robots walk among us, but there's a gap in their knowledge that goes back one hundred years from their activation dates, after the great rights wars locked down robot access to nearly any copyrightable human knowledge. the real ai wars end up being purely about intellectual property. society flirts with repeating history as the mistakes of the past are revealed to half of us from a hundred years ago, year by year.
- ogogmad 4y agoIs Battleship Potemkin in the PD in both Europe and the US?
- jteppinette 4y agoCopyright, Trademark, and Patent Law should not exist. Contract law and trade secrets cover all necessary use cases. Checkout Stephan Kinsela @NSKinsella for more info.
- LastTrain 4y agoI found this thread’s Libertarian!
- postalrat 4y agoSo you don't mind me taking all the frontend from https://easypub.io/ https://easypub.io/ Or doing whatever I want from any code of yours in github.
- jteppinette 4y agoI don’t mind at all. I am open sourcing it, and it is free lol.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoHmm, how hard is Der Steppenwolf to read? I'm a (lapsed) intermediate level German speaker, but I remember reading the first bit of it in English in high school and liking it. Also, https://www.fadedpage.com/ https://www.fadedpage.com/ has stuff freely available under Canadian copyright law, which seems to have stuff from the 50s (70 years maybe?).
- seabass 4y agoIs there a resource that hosts public domain content in a browsable, searchable format? I am really excited to see that Metropolis will be in the public domain soon--but where would I go to download it?
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://archive.org https://archive.org https://archive.org/details/metropolis.1927.fritz-lang https://archive.org/details/metropolis.1927.fritz-lang
- aaron695 4y ago
- easybake 4y agor-r-r-remix...
- joshspankit 4y agoConsider this: At 75 years past the death of the creator it’s possible you cannot use anything that came out throughout your entire life. Nothing you grew up with, nothing that inspired you, nothing that speaks to the life you lived. It’s even possible that your children and your grandchildren will not be able to use anything you knew. Definitely not anything they knew. We’re in real danger of cultural death with these rules restricting our expression. Thankfully current artists have the option of open licenses for their works. If I could, I would flip a switch right now where I am only exposed to things with open licenses for the rest of my life. I’m happy to forget about everything Disney ever made. They can go put it in the vault forever and protect it with all the lawyers and guards in the world. I will never ask them to release it and they can feel safe that no one will be able to “steal” it.
- fyfirhffuug 4y ago>We’re in real danger of cultural death with these rules restricting our expression.< Isn't it sort of the opposite? Without these rules we'd be stuck drowning in an even larger and blander sea of retellings and reimaginings. The only time I see this considered noble or akin to staving off death is when the culture being preserved is already stagnating anyway.
- joshspankit 4y agoRight in this very moment there are hundreds if not thousands of musicians making music absolutely terrified that they will accidentally use prior works they can’t get permission for (or can’t afford). Some are terrified they’ll use “the wrong sample” (is there a list of wrong samples? no), some are even terrified they’ll accidentally “create” a chord progression that someone else already has the rights to. In these cases, that artist can end up getting a little popularity and maybe even a little income, then end up in debt with the song pulled from the internet, never to be played by them again.
- fyfirhffuug 4y agoRight but in these scenarios the similarities to a prior work are the cause of the problem they might face. It's stifling to the musician sure but not in a way that's preventing anything actually unheard before.
- t-writescode 4y agoDoes anyone know any motions in place to adjust copyright to a more reasonable time frame, even providing exceptions for companies like Disney, which harm all of us by their continual extension? It'd be nice to know what group to throw money at and ask how I can help.
- divbzero 4y agoTo put US copyright duration [1] in perspective: – If you published something and die today, it will not enter public domain until January 1, 2093. – If a company hires you to publish something today, it will not enter public domain until January 1, 2118. [1]: https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html
- AlanSE 4y agoThose dates will be just in time for people to read the earliest wave cli-fi books as they're living through it!
- darknavi 4y agoDoesn't this also assume there aren't any more legal extensions?
- robin_reala 4y agoYou can always choose to dedicate your work to the public domain via a grant like CC0.
- taink 4y agoIt is not always legal to do so; in some countries it is impossible to forego your copyrights. CC0 is a tool that allows to get as close as possible to a public domain dedication. See https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/public-domain/cc0/ https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/public-domain/cc...
- eatbitseveryday 4y agoAre films in the public domain legally copiable?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoSo what? Nothing I grew up with is public domain. My culture belongs to corporations and I don't expect them to enter the public domain until after I'm long dead.
- choeger 4y agoI came to the conviction that digital artworks, any form of digital property, really, needs a public clearinghouse. You simply shouldn't be allowed to sell any digital license for a product you didn't register at that clearinghouse before. The task of that clearinghouse would be to provide the customer with the bought content in case of dispute or any other problems. So if, e.g, Amazon goes out of business, all my books would be available for me to download from said clearinghouse because I own the license. Same for steam games or Disney videos. Many (but not all) of the problems with DRM or copyrighted works would vanish if we established this legal requirement.
- readerbaza 4y agoNowadays digital stores sell you the privilege to get access to said content, you own shit. Making virtually unlimited profit on a limited initial amount of time, labour, costs is what's evil here. "X number of years" argument will never solve it (the shorter the worst the hype push will get). Should be capped by a function of said time, labour invested plus costs and allowed profit adjusted for inflation. I don't care how much one thinks he deserves to milk such work/invention. Look at what Nikola Tesla gave us and what he got in return.
- christkv 4y agoIs there a similar site for things going out of copyright in the eu?
- jl6 4y agoFun copyright fact: content created today by anyone under 20 is likely to still enjoy copyright protection in the year 2151, when Star Trek Enterprise is set.
- yardstick 4y agoTo those that believe copyright should be limited to a decade or two, what is your answer to Donald Knuth’s The Art of Computer Programming? It has been around since 1962, and yes has had new volumes added over time. Should Donald have been forced to give up his copyright and revenue stream in the 80s for a book that is still popular today? The book is reasonably priced at around $60. 1. https://www.informit.com/promotions/art-of-computer-programming-books-and-ebooks-140521 https://www.informit.com/promotions/art-of-computer-programm...
- ddevault 4y agoTAOCP is not a single entity; each volume has its own copyright term. The original purpose of copyright is not to enable rent seeking, but to encourage artists to keep making new works. So as old volumes of TAOCP fall out of copyright, it incentivizes Knuth to write new volumes. It would be the system working as designed.
- yardstick 4y agoWould you agree with: post copyright expiration, no one, original author or otherwise, should be able to profit from it? Ie if I were to sell TAOCP after the copyright expired, can I sell it at a price above the costs of printing, distribution, etc? Because any profit would be rent-seeking.
- phone8675309 4y agoHow magnanimous of the corporations that have a stranglehold on our culture to allow us peons to have access to works nearly a century old. Thank you, corporate masters.
- melllvar 4y agoAlong these same lines, Tom Lehrer recently put all of his works (music and lyrics) into the public domain. Downloadable from his site [0] where there's a notice to this effect. [0]: https://tomlehrersongs.com/ https://tomlehrersongs.com/
- vkaku 4y agoUS copyright laws are a joke.