20 ms·
The Fermi paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the contact era
- belter 4y agohttps://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2211/2211.16505.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2211/2211.16505.pdf
- krapp 4y agoAnother Fermi Paradox thread. Take a shot any time von Neumann probes are mentioned. Regarding the paper (or at least its abstract) it's worth mentioning that our own radio transmissions have become significantly less likely to be detected after our transition to digital, and that electromagnetic signals dissipate, so they might no longer be recognizable as intelligent signals beyond a certain distance. That would seem to restrict the "Contact Era" window from "a few hundred to a few thousand" years to a century or less. One would expect that advanced civilizations became essentially radio silent to us long before we were even capable of detecting their transmissions in theory.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoI post this on every Fermi paradox thread. Non-directional radio transmissions (e.g. TV, broadcast radio) would not be distinguishable from cosmic background radiation at more than a light year or two away [0]. Highly directional radio emissions (e.g. Arecibo message) an order of magnitude more powerful than the strongest transmitters on Earth would only be visible at approximately 100 light years away [1], and would only be perceptible if the detector were perfectly aligned with the transmission at the exact time it arrived. Space is really big, and radio emissions are comparatively really weak. [0] https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/245562 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/245562 [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0610377.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0610377.pdf
- Mistletoe 4y agoI feel the same way. How do the SETI people explain this away and justify their search? One light year is tiny, I think it would take an incredibly generous Drake equation estimate to make that contain intelligent life. Same for 100 light years too. But I lean towards pessimistic Drake equation values. Life is even more rare and precious the more I dig into the equation. > The true stellar density near the Sun is estimated as 0.004 stars per cubic light year, or 0.14 stars pc−3. > There are around 60,000 stars within 100 light-years, and the same again with 100-200 light-years, and then the numbers fall quickly. By the time we're 1,000 light-years out, there are fewer than 8,000 stars and, at 1,300 light-years, fewer than 5,000 stars.
- throw1234651234 4y agoThere are other techno-signatures to look for: Dyson swarms (marked by irregular dimming). Infinitely more powerful transmitters - i.e. irregular pulsars. Oumuamua type fly-bys. "Unnatural" gasses in atmospheres. All purely theoretical, of course. As far as we know, we might not even notice life on Alpha Centauri planets 4ly away.
- m4rtink 4y agoI think a big Orion drive powered spaceship flight profile would be widely noticeable. Like, nature rarely produces hundreds of sequential nuclear detonations in deep space in quick succession, possibly perfectly matching high energy transfer orbits. Just not sure what would the other party thing about builders of such craft. On the other hand, its clear what would they think about anyone running a Nuclear Salt Water Rocket - eq. riding continuous fission detonation for minutes or hours! They would definitely think they are batshit insane! :D
- pharke 4y agoI would have to assume that they know this and are in fact only looking for messages that are purposefully sent at very high power. It's also why they favor listening at the hydrogen line since transmissions at that frequency stand the best chance of penetrating through cosmic dust, i.e. you would only use that frequency if you were intentionally trying to transmit across interstellar distances. I think they don't popularize the downsides of a radio search since it could threaten their already tenuous funding. Basically, they have to be optimistic in order to maintain the pittance of a budget given to them which allows us an extremely small chance at detecting a purposefully sent signal if we happen to be in the right place at the right time and listening on the right frequency pointed in the right direction, etc. In order to do SETI right we really need radio telescopes in solar orbit far away from the Earth and enough of them so that they can cover all of the nearby stars or other likely directions for signals to originate from. The only way we're going to get there is if space launches continue to become a lot cheaper. Fingers crossed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_line
- maerF0x0 4y ago> Non-directional radio transmissions (e.g. TV, radio) would not be distinguishable from cosmic background radiation at more than a light year or two away this is going to come across as sarcastic in text, I genuinely mean this. Why don't the authors know this? Why doesn't someone tell them?
- cannonpr 4y agoBecause I suspect that under focused analysis the signal won’t quite look like cosmic radiation background. Now I also haven’t done the analysis, but information, and entropy are funny things. Will they get to watch a human TV show ? Hell no. Would it look “random” versus showing that it once contained some structured information ? I think that’s a very open question. There are probably more serious papers that deal with the matter and how long and far “techno-signatures” survive in the noise.
- PaulHoule 4y agoAn old NTSC video signal has a clear periodic structure. Simply counting lines is going to reveal a lot about the structure and if anyone gets the idea of plotting lines they will figure out how to decode it. An efficient digital signal is going to maximize the use of bandwidth if it looks like white noise. That said, a signal like that needs a carefully calibrated receiver, so part of the signal in time-frequency space is going to be allocated for something that is easy to acquire and will tell to how to decode the main signal. You might see a periodic structure: if you want to run a "signal frequency network" with multiple transmitters with the same signal, have to deal with a lot of reflected signals, or listen from a mobile terminal that suffers from the Doppler Effect you will probably turn off the signal for part of the cycle so that reflections can die down and you can reset your echo cancellation algorithms. Thus digital signals aren't going to be invisible but they are going to spend maybe 5% of the energy in a way that is easy to interpret as opposed to all of it.
- maerF0x0 4y agoMakes me wonder if alien life will actually not find our messages simply because we're using such "ancient" techniques. Perhaps they invented a TV like object and used a NTSC like signal, but like 100k years ago and no one in their race knows to look for our old signals. Maybe our comms look like hieroglyphics to them ?
- bnralt 4y agoI've been wondering what the advantage of von Neumann probes are. Once you have the ability to autonomously construct probes, it seems like it would be easier and faster to mass produce them in one solar system and send them directly to their destinations. For instance, with a von Neumann probe you have to have probes with additional mass for self-replication, have it accelerate halfway to point A, decelerate halfway their, spend time replicating a new probe that will accelerate halfway to point B and then decelerate, then spend time manufacturing a new probe, then have that accelerate halfway from point B to point A, then decelerate the second half of the way, etc. But if you can automate manufacturing, you can just make specialized devices that mass produce probes in one system, and send them directly to their destination, without waiting for the parent probes to stop at all the in between points to do some manufacturing. And the probes are going to be much lighter because they don't need replication devices in them.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThe point is that solar systems have tiny amounts of resources when compared against the idea of colonizing an entire galaxy, whereas the concept of a von Neumann probe swarm would have resources proportional to the task. Now, whether that is actually possible in any serious sense is very much in doubt.
- bnralt 4y agoThere are ~2 x 10^9 stars in the solar system. The mass of earth is 6 x 10^24 kilos, with about 1/3 of that being iron. So even if we're just using the mass of a single celestial object the size of the earth, and only looking at iron alone, that'd be 1,000,000,000,000,000 kilos of iron you could use per star (for reference, this would be the equivalent of ~300 million fully fueled Saturn V's per star). It seems like a single solar system would have enough resources.
- tsimionescu 4y agoI am quite certain that using all of the iron in a single planet's core is well beyond the difficulty of building a self-replicating probe (which itself is well beyond our technical capabilities). Not to mention, such probes are unlikely to be build able from a single metal, and some metals used for advanced electronics are significantly rarer than iron.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoFurther because a sufficiently powerful compression+encryption scheme would be indistinguishable from noise, how would we even know any pattern is or isn’t a natural noise or an artificial noise?
- antirez 4y agoThe first alien we will ever encounter is likely a neural network we built with our hands.
- mbg721 4y agoI think the first alien we ever encounter will be something like a bacterium or virus, it will spur a debate as to whether it's really life, and it might already have happened.
- chii 4y agoBut that wouldn't technically be an alien, since it's not extra-terrestrial.
- ben_w 4y ago"Alien" doesn't only mean "extra-terrestrial", for example: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/immigrate/diversity-visa-program-entry/diversity-visa-if-you-are-selected/diversity-visa-submit-your-iv-and-alien-registration-application.html https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/immigrat... And: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/dec/12/gender-segregation-not-alien-culture-universities-chief https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/dec/12/gender-segre...
- messe 4y agoOk, but right here, in this context, everybody else in the thread is quite obviously referring to extra-terrestrials.
- api 4y agoIf something visits us from another star system it's also likely to be an AI. Hibernation for thousands of years to travel between stars would be almost trivial for machine intelligence. Just turn yourself off. It'd be easy to tie this directly to solar power. Have an array of solar panels that powers you near a star and in interstellar space you just naturally go to sleep. When you approach the next star system the light generates power and wakes you up. Star travel is easy if you don't have a fixed life span or are able to just deactivate. No need for crazy physicists' nightmare propulsion systems to travel close to the speed of light or wormholes or any of that far-out stuff. Chemical propulsion will do just fine. For humans or any other biological entities to travel between stars they'd need to be able to basically die and be resurrected like tardigrades. We can imagine an alien biology that would make this easier, but for humans we have no idea how to do this and survive.
- douglaswlance 4y agoIf we assume alien life in the universe is predatory and seeks to consume other life forms, and since the universe allows detection from other species over infinite distances and time scales, we would expect life in the universe to either be totally undetectable or else be consumed by life that is totally undetectable.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoThat could very well be true but it's a bold assumption indeed.
- Zigurd 4y agoBold and odd. I read Under the Skin. Excellent and innovative sci fi, but nobody goes that far and spends that much even for a Kobe beef burger. Even here on bloody barbaric Earth, weapons exist mainly to keep trade from being disrupted and the largest military has an environmental compliance department.
- pharke 4y agoThat's not a great starting assumption. How would the economics of travelling hundreds or thousands of light years in order to "consume" (whatever that means) other life forms work out? What is the benefit? How would it be worth the investment?
- izzydata 4y agoIf you are talking about a dark forest then it is more opf the idea that any other sufficiently advanced civilization would simply destroy you as soon as you are known to them rather than attempting to consume any potential resources you have as that isn't economical. The most economical thing could be as simple as sending a small object at light speed through your sun to cause a supernova. This eliminates you as a potential threat and you have no chance to use other limited resources outside of that system.
- Hizonner 4y agoWhile your main point stands, I doubt that crashing even a moderately sized planetoid into a star at any achievable speed would do much to that star. It definitely wouldn't cause a normal supernova. You might be able to produce some nasty radiation/ionized crap/relativistic debris that would be unpleasant for that greenish scum clinging to some of the planets, but it'd be a really expensive way to do even that. Sure, if you get close enough to C, you can deliver as much energy as you want, but you're probably going to use the energy of several stars to get a small object going fast enough to deposit a really destructive amount of energy into a single star. Efficiency is part of finesse...
- staunch 4y agoMy pet theory (which I'm sure is not original) is that absolutely all intelligent life, through AGI and/or genetic engineering, eventually converges into an undifferentiated super intelligent state. These super intelligences continuously decide, for one reason or another (but always the same reason(s)), not to expand their presence into the universe in an invasive way. Maybe it would simply be unnecessary for them to do so, or maybe they consider it unethical, or maybe they do it but in a way that is undetectable to non-super intelligences.
- brotchie 4y agoYup, feel like there's a "strong attractor" to a non-biological super intelligent end-game for any civilization and this happens relatively quickly once their species enters an external-to-biology recursive self-improvement state (e.g. humans discovering, externalizing, and transmitting technology over multiple generations leads to recursive self improvement of technology). Just as there's probable chemical gradients in the laws of physics that lead to the self-assembly of self-replicating objects (e.g. life), the path of technological self improvement to begat super intelligences could be a "natural" gradient in the way our universe works. Sci-fi time: Pet theory is that there are a whole stack of civilizations out there that have recursively self improved to bring into existence super intelligences that can then self improve themselves. Very quickly they find some "jailbreak" understanding of our universes laws of physics which quickly results in that civilization's "matter" blinking out due to not-yet-understood physical phenomenon. Perhaps you "win" at the universe by hitting this state and then "porting out" your solar system's matter to some ring -1 universe, leaving some kind of shadow, or remnants that's dark matter.
- nckthrn 4y agoYes, my extremely layman pet theory is that dark matter / energy are the evidence of advanced intelligent civilisations too; just we don't understand what we're looking at yet.
- lapcat 4y agoThere's no paradox. Technological civilizations destroy themselves relatively quickly. That's becoming painfully obvious.
- puchatek 4y agoNot every intelligent life form out there will have the same homicidal baggage in their genes as the homo sapiens
- lapcat 4y agoWhy not? The same general biological evolutionary principles would apply.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoI'd suspect the vast majority would. Apex predators are pretty much the only niche that gains any incremental, real utility from investing energy in increased intelligence. What benefit would an individual slightly smarter manatee acquire?
- ionwake 4y agoHi, I found this comment interesting could you please elaborate? Don't scavengers benefit from as much intelligence as possible to survive?
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoScavengers are probably the second most likely to develop intelligence, and I was definitely thinking in terms of carnivore vs. herbivore. Intelligent scavengers such as corvids and raccoons come to mind. That said, it's quite possible to scavenge with limited intellect. Vultures, for example, are somewhat intelligent, but not the extent of a dolphin, wolf, or primate. Additionally, a sufficiently intelligent scavenger will probably eventually turn to hunting. If you've got tool use, and are hungry for something dead, it's not a terrible leap to kill the thing yourself. On the whole, intelligence in nature is largely focused on predicting another animal's actions, and planning to take advantage of that foresight. The benefit of being better at that than your peers is immediately obvious in a hunter: predict, hunt, kill, eat. For things that aren't doing the hunting, more passive solutions can be optimal: evolving faster escapes, or natural defenses such as being very large take less energy, and can be developed much faster, when compared to the rather energy intensive process of maintaining a large brain and raising intelligent young.
- time_to_smile 4y agoBefore we worry about communicating with civilization far away in space but coexisting with us in time, we should work at communicating with civilizations coexisting with us in space but far away in time. One of my favorite "out there" theories is that it's possible (and I mean conspiracy theory possible) that the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum[0] was caused by an industrial civilization facing the same global warming problem we are today right here on Earth, wiping itself and several other species at the time out, but otherwise leaving the planet fine and recovering in short geological time. The interesting part of this "theory" is that because PETM happened 50 million years ago, even if there was a civilization as complex and large as ours today, very little (essential none) evidence of it would survive. My last bit of techno optimism is that if we do find ourselves unquestionably headed towards climate catastrophe, we should start investing research into figuring out how we might send some kind of message to a future civilization that emerges 50-100 million years after us. Something along the lines of "human were here! watch out for those hydro carbons!" 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Thermal_Maximum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Therm...
- causality0 4y agoIf they'd sent us the same message we wouldn't have listened.
- cartercwchen 4y agoI prefer the Dark Forest interpretation of the Fermi Paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_forest_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_forest_hypothesis
- izzydata 4y agoI thoroughly enjoyed Cixin Liu's Three Body series. Even if wildly unlikely I find the idea kind of comforting to existential dread despite it being possibly the worst fate for humanity.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoYou prefer to live in a universe where this is true, or just think it is the most likely explanation? Because frankly you should seek help if it is the former.
- 1970-01-01 4y agoThe question of what to do if we're blasted with an artificial signal could be the most important decision ever made.
- steveBK123 4y agoThe author raises an interesting question in his notes - human nations & races have for much of human history distrusted each other & gone to war. And yet we broadcast our location and welcome out into the cosmos assuming that alien species will be benign and friendly!
- joshuahedlund 4y agoIMO that fact is actually a pretty strong reason to doubt the dark forest hypothesis as a serious explanation for the lack of observable aliens. If we've broadcast ourselves to each other for thousands of years and now even to the universe, why should we expect that every single other civilization out there is consistently doing the exact opposite?
- 4y ago
- 1970-01-01 4y agoUntil SETI locates something like a pulsar braking and accelerating to signal prime numbers we're really really really unlikely to stumble onto more life. Space is just too big.
- eloff 4y agoBut is it? We can detect things about the chemical makeup of the atmospheres of extra solar planets. Our own atmosphere is broadcasting the likely presence of life, plus near certainty of industrial civilization. We could detect that up to some distance with our technology. What could advanced aliens detect? What if they used gravitational lensing to magnify the signal? We can’t rule it out. Let’s hope the dark forest explanation for the Fermi paradox is wrong - because we’ve long had a campfire sending smoke up that’s been visible for many, many light years.
- russdill 4y agoOur signal for oxygen and other bio-signatures is so much stronger than the signals we have been sending recently and it's been going out for...quite some time.
- rvnx 4y agoMaybe they found Earth already and they just find it boring: "yet another planet likely filled with idiots"
- saalweachter 4y agoI mean, the Great Oxygenation Event is ~2 billion years in the past, and the Cambrian Explosion is only half a billion years ago. If intelligent, space-faring aliens checked it out, there's a 75% chance they arrived while the most interesting thing on Earth was, well, I can't think of anything that wasn't "technically before the Cambrian but like, only by 50 million years". Fungi? We should look for oxygen-rich atmospheres, but we need another signal before we jump in a rocketship and go looking for someone to talk to or eat.
- causality0 4y agoThe universe we find ourselves in isn't very compatible with a species like our surviving for an extended period. If humans exist for millions of years we're going to either spread out to fill the galaxy or our machines will. The fact earth was free to develop us means that no other species like us existed long enough to beat us to it. We ought to hope that's because species find some other priority besides expansion and power, because otherwise the reason we're free to exist is because species like us always wipe themselves out before they spread.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> because otherwise the reason we're free to exist is because species like us always wipe themselves out before they spread That's a complete non-sequitur. There can be plenty of reasons for a species like us never appearing on the first place, and they are way more reasonable than postulating that life like us always destroy itself.
- cortic 4y agoWe are actually running out of places in our history to fit a great filter. Most of the events in our evolution seem probable, even inevitable. In fact the only place IMO that's really left is the emergence of the first self replicating RNA molecule. But even that seems too probable to be a great filter. And if its not behind us, it has to be in-front of us or we are under a great misapprehension about the nature of the universe.
- kiba 4y agoProbably, inevitable based on what sample size?
- bena 4y agoTechno-optimism. We didn't have planes, now we have planes. We rode horses and now we go to the moon. Therefore, anything you can possibly imagine is inevitable because "technology". We will circumvent every possible logistical and physical barrier because of nebulous reasons. It's a lot like that scene in Silicon Valley when Big Head is pitching a neuralink-esque device for a phone to the CEO and the CEO asks how long it will take and Big Head says "Soon, we just got to figure out how". Like, no shit, the "how" isn't just the important part, it's the only part.
- wokwokwok 4y agoGood grief, did anyone read the paper, or are you all just sprouting your own personal Fermi paradox theories? > The basic assumption of this work is the hypothesis that alien civilizations do not bother to explore merely biotic planets, so that the radiosphere criterion becomes the main trigger for alien civilizations to send interstellar probes The tldr; in this work is that they assume there’s a finite (short) duration during which civilisation are “noisy” and given that our “noise” is currently at most ~100 light years from us, no one has noticed us and bothered to send a probe or direct a signal at us. I mean, it’s an interesting (not, in my view, novel) take, in that it posits that every civilisation has a finite spherical band in which they are “detectable” by radio emission before they go to “quiet” technology like fibre optic; and you’d have to be specifically looking at just the right time while you were in that (supposedly) brief band. …but, it really doesn’t to give any thought to spectral analysis / why a “quiet” civilisation would be undetectable on the basis of generating complex / unusual chemical signatures in their atmospheres, and why we don’t see anything like that out there. It’s really, just restricted to the consideration of radio broadcast and, unsurprisingly, given the restrictions, makes it implausible anyone would notice us / we would happen to be looking while anyone was “noisy” and visible in the radio spectrum. Eh. Did I miss anything interesting in there? It doesn’t seem particularly novel.
- denton-scratch 4y agoWell, I didn't notice the bit about a "noisy period" - I took the sphere to be the surface of a volume, not a shell. I think the idea was that once you start emitting detectable information, you don't stop. It's all hypothetical. All the stuff about probes: it doesn't matter whether the aliens are interested in talking to us. It doesn't matter whether they are interested in space and stuff. The authors define this sphere as the space wherein a hypothetical alien civilization COULD have detected our existence, and COULD have signalled or sent a probe in response. Also, they choose to define their sphere in terms of the beginning of the radio era. That's arbitrary. There might be other signals that planets carrying life emit, that we don't know about. SETI searches for radio signals like a drunk searches for his keys under the street-light. Note: I only read the abstract.
- m4rtink 4y ago
- spuz 4y agoThis paper seems to explore a question I've had for a while which is: What is the maximum distance an Alien civilisation could eventually detect life signatures from Earth assuming their detection technology matches ours? I know that our current radio signals extend 100 light years or so but at which distance could these eventually be detected? I ask because I've read that in order for the SETI program to make a detection the signal would need to be much more powerful than the radio transmissions we currently produce.
- yourapostasy 4y agoOur electromagnetic shell drops below the noise floor around 15 light years out for say 5 MW military radars. For coherent signal decoding into carrier wave and payload waveforms as opposed to being able to point to a signal and say, yep that's not natural, probably around 5 light years out. Some discussion here [1] to get you started. Even assuming super duper alien technology that violates what we know of the physics of signals transmission that can pick up the faintest earliest human radio signals, our 200 light year shell is insignificantly sized against the backdrop of the galaxy at large [2]. Yes, if someone out there is broadcasting on radio frequencies, it would be the galactic equivalent of The Russian Woodpecker [3]. That's possibly a Kardashev Type II or at least a very high like 0.90 Type I level technological civilization accomplishment to put out artificial radio frequencies on the scale of naturally-produced ones. There is lots of discussion on ideal frequencies to broadcast upon and look for [4]. There is even a discussion familiar to IT data protection folks that is the interstellar equivalent of a station wagon filled to the brim with tape hurtling down the freeway [5]. But the gist is we'd do better to reconfigure our economic north star upon moving the metric ass-tons of humans off Earth into habitats and working out how to move us around space faster and faster, than waiting for ET to visit us. [1] https://www.quora.com/Radio-and-other-signals-have-been-leaking-out-into-space-for-some-time-now-Can-anyone-say-exactly-how-far-out-into-space-these-signals-may-have-reached-Could-an-alien-civilization-have-found-them?top_ans=130959975 https://www.quora.com/Radio-and-other-signals-have-been-leak... [2] https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/news/a27934/galaxy-map-human-radio-broadcasts/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/news/a27934/galaxy-ma... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar [4] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-astrobiology/article/abs/alternative-standard-frequencies-for-interstellar-communication/FB26FD4A82336550678BE706C0F01DD8 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journa... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interstellar_communication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interstellar_communication
- T-A 4y agoLooks similar to https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ac561d https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ac561d
- borbulon 4y agoIf I were an advanced civilization with some sort of jump technology, I'd have probes jump to different solar systems for only a few milliseconds, which would be more than enough time to collect technosignatures. I wouldn't wait to for the technosignatures to come to me.
- molticrystal 4y agoIf you like thinking about the Fermi Paradox, a series that might be enjoyable is the Universe Today's Beyond Fermi's Paradox [0] , it is about 17 articles on different aspects of the problem along with links to papers and essays to make it easy to go deep into a topic. [0] https://www.universetoday.com/?s=%22Beyond+%22Fermi%27s+Paradox%22%22 https://www.universetoday.com/?s=%22Beyond+%22Fermi%27s+Para...
- _tom_ 4y agoThe Fermi paradox assumes that "intelligent" is one threshold, and we are beyond it. We couldn't communicate with the most advanced primates from a million years ago. A civilization a million years past ours would be unlikely to want to talk to us. The average star in our galaxy is a billion years older than our sun. You can only communicate with civilizations near your level, which are inherently much rarer. We aren't old/developed enough to be interesting to talk to.
- kiba 4y agoWe couldn't communicate with the most advanced primates from a million years ago. A civilization a million years past ours would be unlikely to want to talk to us. The average star in our galaxy is a billion years older than our sun. Based on what? Just because a civilization is extremely sophisticated doesn't mean we have nothing to offer. We still study primates and ants. Hell, we even desire that we could communicate with chimps and dolphins. Communication is impossible with primates and ants simply because they lack the hardware to engage in abstract communication.
- serpix 4y agoWe as a species are very hostile towards all forms of life on earth. Some of us are scientists and open to communication and peaceful existence. Some of us are locusts, everything is devoured for personal gain. Our track record for meeting other species and other human cultures is such that were the roles reversed, meeting a human traveller from another star system would better be met with armed resistance.
- ProAm 4y agoIt really comes down to distance and timing. Space is too big and the speed of light is too slow.
- saalweachter 4y agoSo a fun thing to try to think about is "What's missing from our intelligence?" Our brains may just be made up of lumps of neurons, but we can break out various capabilities we have: * language * tool use * memory * ability to think about hypothetical situations * ability to think about abstract concepts * theory of mind We can think about what alien creatures or civilizations are like that lack them. A civilization without tool use, a civilization without language, a creature with no memory. But thinking about capabilities we don't have is really hard, because, you know, if they exist, my brain isn't equipped to think about them. I can think about having a perfect memory, or being able to think about N things in parallel, or being able to learn things by directly copying the information to my brain. Are those good enough to be new capabilities, or are they just minor variations of the capabilities I already have?
- _tom_ 4y agoMy other pet theory is that organic life forms are an intermediate step in the development of intelligence. No one will bother with us, until the inevitable artificial intelligences develop.
- sacrosancty 4y ago
- mcculley 4y agoThere won’t be anything artificial about such intelligences. I have taken to calling them synthetic intelligences.
- _tom_ 4y ago"Next step intelligences"
- superposeur 4y agoIn my opinion, the excitement occasioned by the discovery of so many exoplanets has clouded our collective judgement on the Fermi Paradox, leading the overwhelmingly most probable resolution to be underemphasized. Namely: there is no life out there. Not due to baroque mechanisms such as techno-self-destruction but just due to its sheer unlikeliness. As large as the number of stars in the observable universe is (let’s say 10^24?), the space of combinatoric possibilities that must be threaded for the sustained chain reaction of life to occur is probably that much vaster. The so-called Drake equation is not useful since multiple terms have error bars that are not even estimable.
- georgeg23 4y agoI don't think people realize how quickly EM radiation falls off with distance, and how large the scale of "transmitters" would need be before we could detect. Today we can finally, barely detect massive planets occluding suns, and we can only do this in our neighborhood of this galaxy. Modulated communication from a source not at planetary scale is currently impossible for us to detect. We need something much much bigger than the Arecibo telescope (RIP). Arrays of coherent antennas can achieve gains equal to their total aperture, but spacing them out far apart does not help for communication receiver gain G/T. That technique only gives better angular resolution for imaging.
- spookthesunset 4y agoI also suspect that in time we will discover new mediums of communication that have better properties than the electromagnetic spectrum. Maybe when we listen on those mediums there will be a ton of chatter…
- georgeg23 4y agoWithin EM, gamma rays (highest frequencies) may be able to achieve sufficient spatial directivity for interstellar communication, but we'd have to be very lucky to have a beam pointed at us. Also currently our gamma ray receivers suck, and they have to be in space because our atmosphere largely blocks it.
- lugu 4y agoMy pet theory to address the Fermi Paradox is that we live in a unpleasant place in the universe/multiverse. Out there, exists a place much more attractive (think of another dimension with much better physical properties). And this is where everybody is.
- buryat 4y agothe grass is always greener
- credit_guy 4y agoThe Fermi paradox is good for a nice chat at a party. But it's not a paradox at all. Imagine there's an alien civilization in our galactic neighbor Proxima Centauri. How would we know they are there? To make it more plausible. Let's say we figure out a way to send a space probe to Proxima Centauri. How do we communicate with that probe? Easy, you say, just like we communicate with the Voyagers: they point a reasonably large parabolic antenna at us, we point a point a much larger one at them, and we chat all day long. Except that Proxima Centauri is 2000 times farther that Voyager. And signals decrease with the square of the distance. By the time Voyager gets to be 4.25 light years away from Earth, their puny 22W antenna will send us a signal that's 4 million times weaker than what they send us now (when we get less than 200 bits/second). It's actually worse than that, of course. If Voyager were to send a signal from some arbitrary place 4.25 light years away, we'd get it as something 4 million times weaker. But if that place is in the solar system of Proxima Centauri, it's like us looking straight at the headlights of an incoming car. That very weak signal will need to be extracted from the extraordinarily bright noise coming from the star that's roughly speaking about 1 second of arc away from it. Now imagine that instead of Voyager, it's just some aliens that are not pointing an antenna straight at us, but just minding their own business. They could be launching rockets, watching satellite TV, waging wars, and from time to time lobbing Himars at each others, and even nukes. How would we know they are there? And now finally imagine that there are no aliens in the Proxima Centauri system, by the luck of the draw, but there are in 5% of all the star systems in the galaxy. Only the closest ones to us are 40 light years away, instead of 4. That's another reduction in signal by a factor of 100. The only question is not why we didn't "see" any aliens so far. It's why we wasted so much money on SETI. Was Carl Sagan not able to do the back of the envelope calculation I just did here?
- twawaaay 4y agoWe've been able to fly or emit radio signals only for a bit more than 100 years. If there exist any other civilisations and we assume they start independently, there should be ones that started billions of years ago. Which is enough to visit entire galaxy even at very slow speeds. The paradox is that we are not seeing any signs of any other intelligent life.
- whatshisface 4y agoIf you assume that intelligent life has to pass a certain number of "steps" to develop, doesn't the central limit theorem dictate that the more of those steps there are, the closer in time each separate species will achieve intelligence?
- dragonwriter 4y agoIf you assume that they vary independently, yes.
- random314 4y agoThe central limit to theorem states no such thing even if the steps vary independently. Central limit theorem states that the "average" of "any" kind of distribution is normally distributed. It doesn't make the underlying distribution behave in any particular way.
- whatshisface 4y agoSD divided by mean also tends to fall.
- random314 4y agoSD is defined by dividing by the square root of the number of samples. It is never divided by the mean - as this metric has no relevance. The SD as it relates to the central limit theorem is the confidence in the estimation of the average E(X) of a distribution. It means that the SD reduces i.e. confidence increases as the number of samples increase. You don't need the central limit theorem for this. It follows from the definition of standard deviation where it has the square root of the number of samples in the denominator.
- whatshisface 4y agoThe variation in the random variable relative to the value of the random variable goes away for large sums.
- cletus 4y agoFocusing on radio communications for SETI purposes and as a solution to the Fermi Paradox I find to be incredibly outdated thinking. Let me summarize: 1. Planets are incredibly inefficient in creating living area per unit mass; 2. Orbitals are incredibly efficient at creating living area per unit mass. IIRC 1% of Mercury's mass could create a full Dyson Swarm around the sun and have billions of times of the living area of Earth; 3. Space orbitals as typified by an O'Neil Cylinder (being 2-4 miles wide and 20-40 miles long) don't require new physics or new materials. Stainless steel has sufficient tensile strength; 4. Orbitals easily allow energy generation from solar power collection, which in space would be much more efficient than on Earth. So this idea isn't even predicated on nuclear fusion power generation becoming commercially viable. If that does happen, this becomes even more likely. The point is it's not required; 5. Dyson Swarms (being a collection of orbitals that would capture the energy output of the Sun in the same way that water droplets in a fog would obscure something) can be built incrementally. We use the term "Dyson Swarm" instead of the original "Dyson Sphere" because of the misconception that a Dyson Sphere is a rigid sphere. There is no known of theorized material with sufficient strength for that. Same for ringworlds; 6. Such a Dyson Swarm built between the orbits of Venus and Mars would not be that crowded. The mean distance between orbitals would still be hundreds of thousands of kilometers; 7. Orbitals will generate heat. That heat needs to be vented. The only way to do that in space is by expelling mass, which isn't really sustainable, or by radiating it away. Physics tells us that the wavelength of light radiated away is basically just a function of temperature of the radiating object. At any reasonable temperature, that means largely infrared ("IR") radiation; 8. The amount of energy such a megastructure would have available is beyond comprehension. We use an estimated 10^11 Watts of power. Capturing Solar output would mean ~10^26 Watts of power. That means if the population of humans was a quadrillion people (ie 10^15), the average power each person has would be the same as the entire Earth currently uses. Think about that; 9. This is likely the most practical way to travel between star systems, as in imparting momentum from light onto a spaceship. People who have looked at this see it as quite practical to get to ~0.86c this way. Beyond this, believe it or not, the aerodynamic drag of interstellar gas slows you down too much; and 10. The timeline from going from this to coloizing the entire galaxy is pessimistically 10 million years (assuming 0.01c and 100k LY across the galaxy). If you accept these premises, such a structure would stick out. There's no hiding something like this. The signature would be heavy on the IR spectrum and would be visible from thousands of LY away. A galaxy that had been fully colonized this way would be obvious from millions of LY away. I find this idea attractive because it is incremental and requires no new physics or theoretical materials (unlike, say, the many attempts to come up with a mathematical basis for warp drives). Radio band usage in this scenario is completely irrelevant.
- shireboy 4y agoYeah, this is where I've landed on Fermi. It's very likely life exists elsewhere - possibly even on moons in our solar system. And it's somewhat likely intelligent life exists in other solar systems. But physics is such that it is much less likely two intelligences will be able to talk to eachother much less reach eachother. To quote Douglas Adams: Space is really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space."
- puglr 4y agoIt routinely bothers me a bit that, IME, most IRL discussions of the Fermi paradox tend to omit this rather simple explanation. Half the time it's brought up, FTL is offered as the solution. Which as best we can tell is fundamentally impossible. That squishy or otherwise organic bodies are generally unable to travel interstellar distances has always seemed to me to be the simplest solution. Assuming intelligent life is out there, surely there are civilizations that have destroyed themselves and so on. But lack of FTL travel would be a common constraint, regardless of all other scenarios.
- pmontra 4y agoEven with FTL you have to know where to go. Let's say you do 100 solar systems per year (going somewhere close to the star and some local jumps to look around.) There are 100 billion stars in the Milky Way. It takes a billion years to sequentially scan the galaxy. Optimizations in the search algorithm to cut that number down to 100 years are left as an exercise ;-)
- bottled_poe 4y agoBranching factor of two means around 30 hops to visit every star.
- pmontra 4y ago2^30 probes at the final hop. Maybe those FTL ships will turn out to be cheap to build like in Vance's Demon Princes novels.
- fedeb95 4y agoMy problem with this kind of things are its assumptions: life is made of carbon, every discovery being conditional probability of being discovered, each civilisation makes exactly the same chain. And the biggest of all: life is the most general and important thing for everything that comes to be in the universe. I.e, everything lives in our own terms
- theptip 4y agoPerhaps I'm missing something, but this seems to get the Fermi Paradox backwards. It explains why we haven't been visited by aliens (the light-cone of our radio transmissions is small and therefore aliens outside of it couldn't send probes to us), but the key observation of the Fermi Paradox is in the other direction; why can't _we_ see _other_ civilizations, in all of the billions of years of history in our light-cone? If extra-terrestrial civilizations exist, we expect to be able to see some trace of them with our telescopes. Particularly at Kardashev type II and above (star-scale structures like Dyson Spheres). Fortunately if you fix the Drake equation, the paradox dissolves: https://arxiv.org/abs/1806.02404 https://arxiv.org/abs/1806.02404.
- jjoonathan 4y ago> [The Fermi Paradox] explains why we haven't been visited by aliens (the light-cone of our radio transmissions is small I usually hear the Fermi Paradox brought up in opposition to the reasonable-sounding null hypothesis of "life is common but stars are far." The argument goes that technological development and galactic colonization should be a very fast process (millions of years) compared to variation in nucleosynthesis/abiogenesis/evolution timelines (billions of years). In other words, if the story of the Milky Way were an hour long movie, the Milky Way would transition from empty of life to full of life inside a few seconds, and landing at the half-way point of that transition would be an unlikely feat of synchronization. That's why Fermi Paradox speculation often doesn't distinguish between "waiting for a radio transmission" and "already here" -- the transition should be very fast on geological timescales. Aliens wouldn't stick in "waiting..." for 100 million years, they'd eventually send colonists to grab the free real estate. In other words, I don't think it's a mistake that the article repeatedly threw in the caveat "unless civilizations are extremely abundant" because that would be a common objection to its thesis. > if you fix the Drake equation, the paradox dissolves Yes, it's possible to toss enough uncertainty into the equation to raise the probability of low N significantly above 0, but the whole idea of FP is that you have to work curiously hard to make this happen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 4y agopopular Physics (physics.pop-ph) It look like physics.pop-ph is the new physics.gen-ph for low quality submissions. Skimming the paper, it does not look promising either. Attempts at answering the Fermi Paradox often fails to meet the bar of science. It's impossible to estimate any of the parameters except for things which are approximated through observations, like the number of galaxies. Otherwise, predicting how many rocky bodies may have life, who knows. Or how many attain intelligent life.
- booleandilemma 4y agoIt always amazes me that right now, as I type this comment, there could be countless intelligent civilizations out there with their own histories, philosophies, science, literature, etc. All asking themselves the same thing: "are we alone?".
- zshrdlu 4y agoAs Carl Sagan noted, the opposite is equally amazing. Are we really all alone? Such a waste of space-time ;)
- ikrenji 4y agoi feel like its premature to discard the possibility of FTL travel and it should be taken into account when discussing the fermi paradox. if FTL travel / FTL communications exist, we have no means of detecting that