14 ms·
Twitter's anti-Mastodon filter evasion
- jojobas 4y ago> Twitter's anti-Mastodon filtering is clown shoes amateur hour. I'd think it will be effective for 90%+ of people trying to link to where they're leaving. This evasion manual will not be seen or understood by an average user.
- ajb 4y agoEvery news outlet, and perhaps journalist associations such as the NUJ, should set up their own mastodon instance now and advertise that that's how to avoid Musk's blocks. There's no need for them to take this lying down.
- nemo44x 4y agoAnd they’ll just be reporting news to each other leaving a massive vacuum on Twitter for others to quickly fill. Most people don’t really care about this story. They’re just users looking for news, opinions, trending topics, etc. if you don’t follow these types of accounts then you haven’t noticed much change on Twitter. Honestly if anything I’ve noticed Twitter is probably a bit more fun and interesting now.
- _djo_ 4y agoPeople are on Twitter because of accounts like that, across the spectrum. It was the one place where you could find everyone, including politicians, organisations, journalists, experts, and random people with cool interests, and interact on a more or less equal basis. When enough of those leave it'll just become Truth Social or Parler. You might personally find that more fun and interesting, depending on your political background, but it'll never sustain the same user base.
- ithkuil 4y agoMusk could have kept twitter that universal platform and keeping an eye on political interference from within, knowing that right wing people would just trust him doing the right thing. But no, he wanted to make a big public outcry out of it, and he's now reaping the consequences.
- class4behavior 4y agoYou should be able to choose with your wallet or whatever you're paying with - your self in this case - but for communication classic server-client structure does not offer that option because you have to rely on the choices of the rest of your contacts. That alone is enough to support alternative solutions. Yet, it's really funny how so many on HN, the vanguard of startups among news aggregators, rather continue to fanboy Musk than engage in brainstorming opportunities the Fediverse and ActivityPub offer.
- Imnimo 4y agoImagine you're the schmuck who agreed to Elon's "hardcore" work environment, showed up at 1 AM to do spontaneous code review, slept in the office, all because you so fervently believe in Elon's grand vision, and this is what you get assigned to implement.
- rolenthedeep 4y agoPeople love to play this game of "well actually mastodon is bad because in this extremely specific situation you can lose your account or not be able to migrate" In the case where all of the normal options are gone, sure, you're fucked. But in 99.9% of cases, you do have options to migrate. Mastodon has options. You are given control, even notionally. Twitter doesn't even pretend to give you options. If you're banned, fuck you, that's it. If a billionaire buys the platform, fuck you, that's it. If a mastodon server starts going downhill, you have options. If a mastodon admin goes off the rails, you have options. If dama happens and the server defederates from another, you still have options. Mastodon gives you more opportunity and choice in all circumstances. There is no escape hatch for Facebook or Twitter, if something goes wrong you're just fucked. There isn't even a live person you could hypothetically talk to about it. Sure, mastodon has problems. The exchange is that it's a truly free service without adversiments, algorithms, or coerced engagement. You don't generate money for the platform owner. That comes with risks, and you have options to deal with that risk. Whether or not you like those options is entirely irrelevant. The options exist on mastodon, they do not exist on Twitter.
- charcircuit 4y ago
- malermeister 4y agoDo you have any evidence for 1) ?
- charcircuit 4y agoThis Internet archive link proves that this has existed for years. https://web.archive.org/web/20201105015447/https://twitter.com/safety/unsafe_link_warning https://web.archive.org/web/20201105015447/https://twitter.c... You can appeal a link from being blocked by using this form. https://help.twitter.com/en/forms/authenticity/spam https://help.twitter.com/en/forms/authenticity/spam
- ChrisSD 4y agoIt was designed as a security feature but it's been coopted to block competitors (or anyone else the CEO takes a personal disliking to). Therefore calling it an "anti-Mastadon" filter is accurate in this context, no matter the specifics of how that filter is currently implemented.
- littlestymaar 4y ago> 1. It's not an "anti-Mastadon" filter. It's a security feature of twitter's URL shortener for preventing spammers, malware spreaders, etc from propagating links to their stuff both on anb off twitter. They've repurposed an existing Twitter tool (what else could they do, with nobody left to implement new tools?) to block Mastodon, but that's an active move to try and block Mastodon nonetheless.
- hcks 4y ago
- smcl 4y agoThere are still people who are happy enough on Twitter for now, but who might want to share an interesting post from mastodon.social. Not everyone is the comically exaggerated caricature you have in your head, most people are just normal users that want to tweet things to their friends.
- fhd2 4y agoSo others know where to find you - there's a bunch of tools for that, but unless you use the same one it doesn't work. Can't think of a more efficient way personally. Though I don't think anyone needs to be obnoxious about it with series of tweets and stuff.
- noduerme 4y agoIt's a lot harder to decentralize when you have decentralized tools... There's some corollary here to the law of momentum that allows social networks to become juggernauts. It probably applies to repressive governments as well. Maybe: The more entrenched the system is, the more you have to use the system's own tooling to get people to escape it?
- smcl 4y agoNot sure I see what's obnoxious here - they've just found a couple of neat ways to circumvent bans on tweeting some URLs.
- fhd2 4y agoI wasn't referring to anything in the article or about including your Mastodon handle in your user name or description. Some people though keep tweeting how they "left Twitter", cross post content etc. I find that a wee bit obnoxious - but since I don't really use Twitter anymore it doesn't bother me, I could just understand someone wanting to take action based on it.
- 4y ago
- paulgb 4y agoThe pivot from “I am against censorship that goes far beyond the law”[1] to “I get to use censorship to kneecap a competitor because it’s my site now” was almost comically quick. [1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1519036983137509376 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1519036983137509376
- matwood 4y agoAgreed. And the fact they are blocking mastodon shows it must be impacting Twitter user numbers.
- masklinn 4y agoOr, just as likely, mastodon users are elon critics and thus hurt his feelings, which is a bannable offense. Thus mastodon cross-posting and reposting is a proxy for bannable offenses, and therefore a bannable offense.
- lrgart 4y ago
- 0ct4via 4y ago
- atoav 4y ago> If they had merely done what Musk does now If they had merely done what Musk CLAIMS he does. But what he claims is not what he actually does do. That flight tracker he banned is based on publicly available information that everybody can legally access, at the same time he posts someones license plate for weird paranoid reasons. How can he be against doxing when he does it himself with people other than himself? > there is certainly way more speech now than before Speech does not get more free, when there is more of it. Speech replaces other speech. There are certain things you can say on a anonymous image board you cannot say anywhere else. But there are also certain discourse you can have in other places that would not be possible elsewhere.
- srajabi 4y agoI wonder how long before Twitter patches this, one thought is that since they've fired so many people they may not be executing well enough to patch this quickly. Also, is there a way to do this where they won't be able to patch? Maybe alternate domain names for these known domain names that are being blocked, similar to what thePirateBay did.
- christkv 4y ago
- lotu 4y agoThe timing is very suspicious. But that’s the excuse I would use in court for anti-competitive pratices
- sofixa 4y agoSource for that speculation?
- christkv 4y agohttps://help.twitter.com/en/safety-and-security/phishing-spam-and-malware-links https://help.twitter.com/en/safety-and-security/phishing-spa...
- rsynnott 4y ago"The domain"? Saint Car appears to be filtering links to _all_, or nearly all, mastodon instances. Did you read the article?
- waihtis 4y ago
- bmitc 4y agoPost is now accepting new users via a waitlist. It’s only a matter of time before it steals everyone worth stealing from Twitter.
- DoctorOW 4y agoI somewhat hope so but my personal preference is Mastodon. Journalists are one of the larger demographics for Twitter so I think it's smart in theory that Post targets them. Twitter's draw was the flow of information like a crowdsourced newswire, so it'll fail in "stealing" journalists until it "steals" others. TL;DR Less of a foregone conclusion than you say.
- Hakkin 4y agoI'm not going to fact-check this article for obvious reasons, but is this article referring to actual CSAM or drawn artwork? The author seems to be heavily implying the former but I suspect it's actually the latter.
- waihtis 4y agoboth is the safe guess here
- pleasedontsell 4y agoThe article cites the second and third ranked instances as the most active instances and prevalent CP communities, but both are japanese so I'm going to guess it's mostly drawn artwork.
- goodpoint 4y agoThe article is simply complete FUD
- vidarh 4y agoYou could use the same arguments against the web. It's bullshit fearmongering that uses the existence of a couple of heavily blocked instances to smear the thousands who have nothing to do with them other than using the same software.
- codeflo 4y agoI'm exactly in the target demographic that desperately wants a a return to the old, decentralized, protocol-based internet. We need working alternatives to Twitter to prevent a single mentally unstable billionaire from having this kind of power. But everything about Mastodon seems badly designed and engineered. The focus on "servers" seems technologically anachronistic, but worse, fragments the community and creates (IMO) unacceptable privacy concerns. Self-hosting requires unnecessary hoops, loses some community functionality, and runs into the risk of "defederation", which only exacerbates the problem of servers being overly important. If you do decide to go with one of the existing servers, and hadn't been there early enough to get into one of those run by the foundation, you're basically required to trust your online identity and private message secrecy to an anonymous activist admin with a kitty avatar. Why Twitter should feel threatened by this clusterfuck at all is a mystery to me.
- pxoe 4y agolack of algorithmic feed (and the whole anti-algo slant) and lack of openly viewable likes on people's profiles are actually gonna backfire. mastodon is gonna get lonely and boring, because it's kinda hard to do content discovery, particularly the kind where you get recommendations based on people you follow or interested in, so that those recs would be in closer proximity to you, rather than just getting random posts from trending. for how much algo stuff (like topics, suggested tweets, etc.) and particularly algo feed gets talked shit about, it's vital to discovery of new posts and new people. without those things, it's easier to just run out of stuff and people to see, and end up in a place where you're caught up with things, and new people aren't entering your circle, and the activity just stops. well, it is also unlikely, because people just do stuff and mix other people in, but it's easier to end up in that static state, when you don't get suggestions in other ways. at least there are reblogs. but there's also no option to filter those out right in someone's profile. so it's gonna get real annoying if those are gonna be the only way for someone to push content from somebody else.
- vidarh 4y agoWhen you follow someone, you can mute just boosts from them if you like. Other than that, all of these things are things people can build using the API. I agree they're needed, and I think enough others do that things will get built. I certainly want to build my own algorithmic feed, because reverse chronology is already a nuisance to me.
- LinuxBender 4y agoThey mention base64 encoding messages to evade filters. There were actually other base{n} methods [1] created specifically for Twitter to be more space optimized though not as readily available to operating systems. I guess this is less useful if they are really expanding the text limit to 4k soon but figured I would add it in the event they add a parser for base64. This assumes most people would be able to: npm install base2048 I think it might be interesting if Mastodon added a function to automatically detect and decode base2048 for browsers in javascript since JS is required to view a Mastodon site anyway. Bots would then have to adopt this logic, rendering most bots useless until they adapt and evolve. But I am not a developer and maybe this is just not possible. [1] - https://github.com/qntm/base2048 https://github.com/qntm/base2048
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 4y agoThis link shortener works: https://spacekaren.sucks/ https://spacekaren.sucks/ It seems to work by blocking connections to the Twitterbot User-Agent while allowing other connections.
- Nux 4y agoThey'll then just ban links they can't open. They should serve some sort of content instead.
- lapcat 4y agoIt's unlikely that Twitter has the (human) resources at this point to implement comprehensive censorship of Mastodon. They're currently only warning about links to popular instances such as mastodon.social, but links to smaller instances such as the one I use are still fine. One advantage of decentralization.
- zipidedoda 4y agoFrom the very bottom of the Mastodon front page: "Sponsorship does not equal influence. Mastodon s fully independent." This has never worked in the history of everything.
- fareesh 4y agoIf it becomes a popular trend for youtube channels to upload YouTube videos that are just previews with a links to Rumble videos, and the destination videos violate YouTube TOS, if YouTube created a Rumble filter to quickly address it, it would solve the problem. Would it be accurate to call this censorship or a quick and dirty solution against accounts trying to evade TOS? Framing the Mastodon filter by omitting that context is insincere. This type of insincerity is fairly typical in politics (which this entire ordeal is).
- DoctorOW 4y agoThis is being echoed throughout the thread but Mastodon instances whose TOS is similar or stricter than Twitter are also being banned. This is why I feel it's anti-competitive. The thing that makes yours a false equivalence is after looking up Rumble it appears to be a centralized. This is more like if Microsoft decided to block servers without the Windows Server headers citing the use of Linux servers in illegal activity. Windows server likely does make up a small amount of CP servers but that's not something within the control of those software competitors. In both instances the only link between illegal content and the vast majority of legit users is using a competing software.
- matwood 4y agoMusk comically overpaid for Twitter and can do anything he wants with it. My (and I think most peoples) problem is the hypocrisy displayed by Musk and his sycophants. I would respect Musk a bit if he dropped the free speech charade and simply said it's his playground and he'll do whatever he wants. I don't think YouTube has ever claimed to be a public town square or a desire for free speech absolutism.
- jansan 4y agoI like how Mastodon is becoming the new Outkube: https://www.theonion.com/new-decoy-website-launched-to-lure-away-all-moronic-int-1819573050 https://www.theonion.com/new-decoy-website-launched-to-lure-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- decremental 4y ago
- jw1224 4y ago> Also, TIL you can put a meta-redirect inside of a data:text/html URI and it will indeed redirect. That will probably come in handy at some point. > Also TIL, <script> works just fine in data:text/html URIs, despite me having NotScript installed... Also remembering that one for later. This seems pretty concerning to me… I would’ve expected the browser to prevent this somehow. Any security experts able to verify?
- blacklight 4y agoI am an admin of a small instance that most likely isn't on Twitter's block list, so my profile name and description could report the link to my Mastodon profile without getting me banned. However, even without a ban from their side, this has really been the last nail in the coffin between me and Twitter. Suspending accounts for posting links to another (open-source) social network is wrong on so many levels that I don't even know where to start listing them. So I've decided to permanently deactivate my account and say goodbye for good to the stinky fascist shithole that Twitter has become.
- concordDance 4y agoNote that the vast vast vast majority of people and posts on Twitter are not fascist. Stinky shithole I'll grant, but that's been true for a decade.
- concordDance 4y agoI'm never sure if people are downvoting because they disagree or because they think its a bad post that doesn't contribute to the discussion... maybe we should have a system with more than one way of voting?
- guerrilla 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- soheil 4y agoGlad to see Twitter is doing this. The reason Musk bought Twitter was to rid it of the type of behavior you frequently see on m6n. It's a direct competitor to Twitter. Twitter is a commercial product and needs to maintain its users and revenue. It'd be foolish for it to amplify a coordinated attacked on its existence by the very people who very publicly advocate for the destruction of Twitter. I'm sure many people will do their best to minimize the influence of these cult-like echo chambers with negative contribution to society.
- guelo 4y agoFree speech absolutism is so complicated
- tiffanyh 4y agoFor a free service, there’s a lot of strong opinions here. While I’m no Elon fan, he’s entitled to do what he wants with what he owns. And he paid a bunch of money to have that right.
- dEnigma 4y agoI think people mostly take issue with the hypocrisy of claiming to be a paragon of free speech while censoring all kinds of things because Musk personally dislikes them.
- tiffanyh 4y agoIsn’t the simple answer, just stop using Twitter if you feel so strongly about this n
- lapcat 4y agoThat's exactly what people are trying to do by switching to Mastodon! And Twitter seems to be trying to prevent people from switching to Mastodon.
- tiffanyh 4y agoA service is trying to make it difficult for you to switch to a competitor. Surprise surprise.
- lapcat 4y ago> Isn’t the simple answer, just > difficult for you to switch to a competitor Do you not see the self-contradiction in your own comments? In other words, the so-called "simple answer" is not so simple if you can't even post your Mastodon link on your Twitter profile.
- sebastialonso 4y agoIt is, and shockingly for some, it's also exercising free speech to point out the hypocrisy. You can do both!
- garganzol 4y agoThis should be targeted by antimonopoly committee, now. This is a clear violation of fair competition rules. Antitrust law enforcement in 3, 2, 1.
- yboris 4y agoI tried to post the link to this particular post (article?) on Twitter and it claimed there was an error: > Something went wrong, but don’t fret — let’s give it another shot. Twitter is not letting me share this information!
- FireInsight 4y agoIt's a toot on Mastodon that's why
- deadalus 4y ago
- xqcgrek2 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 4y agoIt's so unreal watching this unfold. Whenever you think it can't get any worse they go one step further.
- avinassh 4y agoThese are some fine tricks. But potential downside is Musk could start banning people who are evading the censorship
- RivieraKid 4y agoI don't think Mastodon has any chance of overtaking Twitter. Here's how I would do it: Create basically a clone of Twitter, with the same UI and functionality. The goal would be to make transition as seamless as possible. I have no interest in learning about why Mastodon works, why it runs on multiple domains and getting used to its UI. I just want Twitter without Elon. Make it possible to easily transfer your data, including the people you follow. You would be able to see which of them are on the "new Twitter" and get notified when they switch. Be inventive in making people convert. Perhaps organize a coordinated switch of many high-profile users to generate a lot of media attention. Or provide incentives such as some sort of ownership share.
- FireInsight 4y agoYou'll probably get that if Musk steps down as CEO... The best part about Mastodon IMO is that it's NOT Twitter, speaking as a Mastodon user of course. It feels way more manual and it feels like I need to build my feed and community myself, but it's empowering for specifically those reasons.
- mmastrac 4y agoIt's not about the look of the social network - it's about the people you are interested in moving to a place and you following them. Mastodon has been that for me (the infosec people moved over and enough interesting "celebs") and I've been enjoying my time after a couple of days of adjustment.
- d0m 4y agoNot that I care, but you could even copy the current twitter usernames to your new twitter, alongside all their public tweets and followers. So, when switching, a user wouldn't even need to add back their data or find back their previous followers.
- kevincox 4y agoBut then you have a platform with all of the architectural problems Twitter but doesn't yet have a disliked leader on charge. It is basically inevitable that eventually this same thing will happen again and we are back in the same place. This is why Mastodon is enticing. It provides some architectural advantages that mitigate this problem at a fundamental level.
- drooby 4y agoGiven how clumsy this "censorship" is, I highly doubt that this is a conscious effort of censorship, and is instead an automatic filter that was already in place to prevent malicious activity. Mastadon's original account was suspended for breaking the new TOS for linking to content that was in violation (the jet tracker), which then prompted many other people to break the TOS. I suspect there is some algorithm that twitter has had for many years that checks: IF link is highly associated with TOS violation, THEN flag content as "potentially harmful".
- lapcat 4y ago"Twitter will no longer allow free promotion of specific social media platforms on Twitter." https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/social-platforms-policy https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/social-platfo...
- drooby 4y agoLmao! My comment did not age well.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoWow. I can't believe they actually wrote this down.
- rkapsoro 4y agoI suspect this whole "Twitter blocking Mastodon links for anticompetitive reasons" narrative is wrong to the point of being disingenuous. People have been tweeting links ElonJet trackers on Mastodon instances (including the official @joinmastodon account!), getting both themselves and the target Mastodon instance domains flagged. This is edgelord behaviour. Twitter's policy is simple - do not dox people with real-time location information. Elon's jet has a PIA which limits legal use of broadcast ADS-B information (https://nbaa.org/aircraft-operations/security/privacy/privacy-icao-address-pia/ https://nbaa.org/aircraft-operations/security/privacy/privac...). Those tracker accounts are using non-public information. Jack Sweeney, the guy who runs ElonJet, is on record saying he'll stop tracking if paid money. This is extortion. That is why Elon is pursuing legal action against him. The only criticism I believe one can make here is that Elon's personal involvement (albeit brought on by attacks on himself and his family) has meant Twitter's moderation team has made enforcement of this particular ToS violation a priority. I agree that the solution to Twitter's previous bias is not more bias, and I look forward to Elon & the Twitter team coming up with a better solution for this. Unfortunately left-minded techies have uncritically jumped on this narrative of Elon cravenly blocking Mastodon links because 'he feels threatened by it'. Just because someone has been very successful does not mean it is legitimate to mistreat them.
- rkapsoro 4y agoAlas. Since I made this comment, Twitter announced their new Third Party Social Media policy, and it looks terrible and unnecessary. https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/social-platforms-policy https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/social-platfo...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Twitter's policy is simple - do not dox people with real-time location information This is a novel Twitter policy interpretation and everyone knows it. It’s par for the course for Twitter. But it’s hypocritical of Musk to be doing it. > Elon's jet has a PIA which limits legal use of broadcast ADS-B information No, it does not. It lets operators rotate their aircraft address. Elon didn’t. He held the phone wrong. If the FAA wanted to restrict the use of this information, it wouldn’t be publishing it.