16 ms·
Tell HN: HP printers force you into agreement
The HP Smart App forces you to agree to use only their ink before you can use their app. That shouldn't be a big deal since modern HP printers work fine out of the box without a driver.
However, after you've printed a bunch of pages, they stop working and display the error message "Printer setup incomplete. Your HP+ printer must be set up using the HP Smart app. Visit 123.hp.com to download the app and complete the guided setup. Any pages you have printed were intended for setup and have been exhausted."
Conveniently, this usually doesn't happen until it's too late to return the printer.
- stn8188 4y agoI saw this same behavior and was absolutely furious at having to agree to it. I've got a decade-old HP laser printer that I refill the toner on, and it's still chugging along. Recently, I had to set up a printer for my church, someone else had bought an HP. After seeing the setup shenanigans, I have decided to never buy another HP printer. In fact, just a few weeks after setting up that one, I was tasked with buying another printer for a different office at the church: went with a Brother and it was a breeze to set up without any onerous terms to agree to.
- trentnix 4y agoYears ago, I ran out of ink in a HP All-in-One printer at my business at an inopportune time. To make sure it didn’t happen again, I bought a bunch of extras on Amazon. The extras arrived, everything looked normal, and I set them aside for a rainy day. Some time later when I finally used the ink I bought, imagine my surprise when the printer wouldn’t accept the ink because it was from the “wrong region”. HP printer ink is region locked! I called HP support and they fed me an unbelievable story that this was for my own good. You see, ink in different regions is turned for the climate in that region, the support rep explained! I was dumbfounded at such a stupid explanation. With no other option and wanting to prevent others from making a similar mistake, I tweeted about my experience. Magically, HP support promptly contacted me and sent me replacements. So now I’ve learned that not only is HP unscrupulous and manipulative, you are wasting your time bothering with normal support channels. You’ll only get results if you embarrass them publicly. I’ve purchased my last HP printer, but I fear each of their competitors is just as bad.
- serf 4y ago>I’ve purchased my last HP printer, but I fear each of their competitors is just as bad. you're probably right, but I purchased an Epson 'EcoTank' printer, black-and-white printing only & with a refillable ink hopper and couldn't be happier for simple document printing. The only gotcha i'm aware of is that they use this 'primer box' thing to squirt excess ink into during nozzle procedures that apparently will eventually fill up and require replacement, but I haven't heard of any need to do so after 3+ years of printing, so i'll count that as a win as compared to cartridge replacement which seemed to be a constant burden with our previous HP units.
- kyrra 4y agoI went with Epson as well after having a xerox laser printer for about a decade. The xerox allowed me to do aftermarket toner and it work decently well, but it's still had issues. Sadly a good laser printer, the toner is just far too expensive. When I was researching the Epson printers, I learned about pigment ink and how it doesn't smear with water like traditional inkjet printers did. It's worked really well for the last few years I've had it.
- makeitdouble 4y agoSadly Epson is getting out of laser printer business [0], which to me signals they’ll be fully focusing on screwing users going forward. [0] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/epson-completes-business-mfp-range-130000031.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/epson-completes-business-mfp-...
- liendolucas 4y agoAnother surprise is that if you want to use the printer over USB you have to purchase that cable *separately*. If you purchase online is very easy to fall for this one as people won't check for this, this happened to me around ~2 years ago with one of these low end pieces of crap.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoHonestly, I prefer this, it seems to save millions of excess cables being sent to landfill ... a good company would allow you to order one free with the printer, or have a coupon in the box to get one for postage.
- jll29 4y agoIt's a mistake to buy printers from any company who engage in such practices - switch from HP to Brother or Kyocera if you can. It's not just ink: they want to force you to use particular paper also, not sure if there are any micro-signs on printer paper to identify vendors or firmware code to check for it, but I wouldn't be surprised.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI'll take Brother printers and massive toner cartridges over HP any time.
- BonoboIO 4y agoNEVER buy a HP printer! They always find new ways to screw you.
- sfifs 4y agoThese shenanigans with refills and unscrupulous and buggy apps is pretty much why I changed to a different brand ink refill tank based printer after buying HP for the longest time - never buying HP again.
- arctan 4y agoThere's a tool called PRET - the Printer Exploitation Toolkit -- "the tool that made dumpster diving obsolete" -- that some of you might find fun and useful. You can use it to test which print protocols (ps, pjl, pcl) the printer uses, and then send files to print directly using one of them. It has a bunch of other interesting functionality too. https://www.github.com/RUB-NDS/PRET https://www.github.com/RUB-NDS/PRET
- kmeisthax 4y agoLet's stop calling it ink and start calling it licensing fluid, because it is.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 4y agoMy Epson got crap printing color; so I got suckered into buying an HP. Color with non-HP cartridges prints outline. Epson reliably chucks on in B&W. The OEM cartridge vendors should be publishing HP workarounds.
- steve_taylor 4y agoAre there any printer startups trying to disrupt this extremely user-hostile space?
- 29athrowaway 4y agoWait until you hear about the yellow dots and EURion.
- BooneJS 4y agoAnyone recommend a decent color laser printer for home office? My spouse is a private violin teacher who runs a studio out of our home.
- quickthrower2 4y agoI use a brother colour laser and I am happy with it. I am an occasional user: kids play and the occasional signature scan. I don’t have much to say about it, it works, official ink is expensive but fake cartridges work ok. Also refill kits exist but when used on non-fakes it still thinks the cartridge is “empty”. So shitty practices but there are reasonable workarounds. Having to ecycle cartridges bugs me though. Seems stupid.
- sebastien_b 4y agoDoes it come with a smartphone? If not, it’s sold fraudulently.
- quickthrower2 4y agoPrinters need to do what mobile phones do, e.g. $200 for printer get whatever ink $100 for printer, $100/year for 3 years ink contract Then they have their cake (cheap upfront price) and eat it (without needing DRM shit cat and mouse games)
- djbusby 4y agoAlso, many Samsung printers are now under HP.
- robomartin 4y agoI used to be a very loyal HP printer customer. I started buying them with the original LaserJet, back in the early '80's. They were around $3,500 at the time. As time went by the various new models started to come with "personalities". A few years ago I finally had enough. I was not going to blindly buy product from this company any more. They obviously did not care enough about the customer to deliver a good product. When the time came to replace them we tossed all of our HP's and got printers made by Brother. So far, so good. Not much to complain about other than some misguided person decided the printer should emit a sound after receiving a fax and that sound should be exactly that you hear during an emergency broadcast interruption in the US (or close enough). Silly things that happen across cultures and regions when people don't bother to check products to make sure they fit the context. Thsi reminds me of a product Sony introduced a very long time ago. They had a division that designed and marketed tape-based data storage systems. I believe this was in the early '90's. This product offered massive storage for the times. They named it "PetaFile". Imagine the surprised when they started to get feedback on this name. Nobody was going to buy a "PetaFile". The name soon changed to PetaSite.
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago
- davnn 4y agoThat sounds even worse than their previous models, which were „safety locked“ after an update. For the older models it was still possible to downgrade to the initial firmware version, which was a pain to do, though, and disconnect from the www. It‘s unfortunate because they build great hardware.
- opan 4y agoReading through comments here makes me wish for a wiki documenting decent laser printers with GNU/Linux support and any info about them that might be helpful. Something like the thinkwiki for ThinkPads. Browsing some local auction sites, I'm seeing laser printers from HP, Samsung, OKI, and others, but I don't know how to easily find out what's worth using. If I were looking at routers I could refer to the openwrt wiki before buying. Anyone know of a site like this that exists already? I'm kind of curious about thermal printers as well. Printing out a grocery list or QR code on receipt paper sounds neat.
- makeitdouble 4y agoMy impression was that most laser printers had a postscript compatible interface and/or could print from basically any input/format. At least for network printers.
- jiveturkey 4y agoalso internet connection is mandatory! only for a few models. it’s a fair tradeoff for the reduced initial cost. i imagine ultimately we will see free printers.
- ineptech 4y agoIt seems like basic laser printers ought to be sort of commoditized by this point, shouldn't they? For my modest needs, laser printers were good enough 15 years ago. What's the printer equivalent of, like, a $12 Logitech mouse? What's the Kirkland brand jeans of printers?
- a_ba 4y agoDont get a HP+ printer. HP printers come in two fashions. A plain version and a HP+ one. While the hardware is the same the former are slightly more expensive and, the latter require you to use HP+. You can tell which is which by the product code (HP+ have their product code end on an _e_) Measured by the standards of the printer industry I was pleasantly surprised to see HP posting the online requirements very clearly on their website: - Internet Access (the German version is even stronger on that requiring „constant internet access“ - A HP Account https://www.hp.com/us-en/printers/hp-plus.html https://www.hp.com/us-en/printers/hp-plus.html
- p0d 4y agoI cancelled my monthly subscription for hp ink cartridges and was surprised that the existing cartridges became unusable. I had to buy a whole new set of ink. I imagine some doc somewhere tells you this will happen. Regardless, I will never subscribe to HP again and have started looking at new printers.
- snvzz 4y agoWe are in dire need for OSH laser printers. Literally the moment there's an acceptable OSH printer, it's the end of the tiranny.
- nokeya 4y agoI have b/w HP laser printer, one of the office oriented series. His cartridges has some chip and 2 contacts on it. After a while after purchasing and some amount of pages it refused to print because of low toner. I have simply covered contacts with tape - and printer works again! However, HP software started to complain that cartridge is missing. For every page printed lol. While actually printer was working. Solution - uninstall HP software and use some generic compatible driver. And after with this cartridge it printed at least as double amount as before it become “empty”.
- usr1106 4y agoReading this confirms that not owning a printer is still a good decision. If I absolutely have to print it's a good reason to visit the library or the office. I guess it has been less than 5 times a year for many years now.
- Jipazgqmnm 4y agoAnyone who buys HP inkjet printers now has only himself to blame.
- jonaf 4y agoWe own an HP printer. The other day my wife told me the printer refused to print unless she renewed her subscription. I told her no way in disbelief. That can't be legal. She renewed the subscription and was able to print again. I'm hoping there's some kind of confusion, but waiting for the subscription to lapse to see if it happens again.
- appleflaxen 4y agoThis kind of pretend-compatibility requirements should be made illegal.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoThanks for sharing this. I would love to know if there is a printer brand that I could buy in 2022 and not be held hostage by something like this.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 4y agoI came across this last week when I got the HP Laserjet MP110we to replace a 12 year old Samsung printer that I just couldn’t find drivers for for the latest macs (Samsung sold their printer division to HP). They also have chips in the toner to detect an unofficial one and try to sell you a subscription. Seems like multiple steps backward although Wi-Fi printing from phone and laptops without cables is pretty cool (I realize I’m years late to this)!
- adamparsons 4y agoNah that would be getting a HARD return from me
- femto 4y agoFor Australian's: the ACCC has been onto this, though is this a new attempt by HP? https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/hp-to-compensate-printer-customers https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/hp-to-compensate-print... "Customers of HP PPS Australia Pty Ltd (HP) who bought certain models of HP printers without being informed non-HP ink cartridges may not work in them could be eligible for compensation, the ACCC announced today." "HP has given the ACCC a court-enforceable undertaking to compensate customers who were unable to use non-HP ink cartridges due to an undisclosed technology in their printers." ... "HP has undertaken to compensate consumers $50 who were prevented from using a non-HP cartridge." "HP has since made available an automatic firmware update for download which removes the DSF from certain inkjet printer models and allows customers to use non-HP cartridges." "The undertaking is available at HP PPS Australia Pty Ltd ." https://www.accc.gov.au/public-registers/undertakings-registers/hp-pps-australia-pty-ltd https://www.accc.gov.au/public-registers/undertakings-regist... "Details of how to claim compensation are on the HP website." "Consumers can also contact HP via 1800 625 236 for more information."
- notpushkin 4y ago> HP has since made available an automatic firmware update for download which removes the DSF from certain inkjet printer models and allows customers to use non-HP cartridges. Would it be possible to get hands on this firmware update and install it outside of Australia too?
- femto 4y agoIt sees like HP has capitulated and the updated firmware is already on wider release? https://support.hp.com/hr-en/product/hp-officejet-pro-6830-e-all-in-one-printerserie/5390307/document/c05308850 https://support.hp.com/hr-en/product/hp-officejet-pro-6830-e...
- femto 4y agoEuropeans in Belgium, Italy, Spain and Portugal are also due compensation. Get your claims in by 6th of March 2023. https://www.euroconsumers.org/activities/hp-and-euroconsumers-reach-a-settlement-on-dynamic-security-dispute https://www.euroconsumers.org/activities/hp-and-euroconsumer... https://assets.ctfassets.net/iapmw8ie3ije/KB59keIaRiPTdYg71E9x7/1818dd0a216f7ee1e739cf7db6d7c639/HP_and_Euroconsumers_settlement_on_Dynamic_Security__all_you_need_to_know.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/iapmw8ie3ije/KB59keIaRiPTdYg71E...
- loloquwowndueo 4y agoHP inkjet printers. I’ve never seen this with my laser (m255dw).
- ceejayoz 4y agoYou haven't yet.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThis is happening on a laser printer, the M209dwe.
- howinteresting 4y agoYou have the dwe printer, which is clearly marked as requiring HP+: https://a.co/d/1H1aI10 https://a.co/d/1H1aI10 The alternative dw printer is not marked as such but is over twice as expensive. I hate printers as much as the next person but in this case it's pretty clear what folks are getting into. However I'm seeing that HP wants to slowly transition to only the e line. If that happens, I'll be pretty incensed.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoI bought it at a bricks and mortar store. That notice is buried in the fine print on the box. And of course the box isn't on display at the store, just the printer. It's nice to see the notice displayed prominently on Amazon. I guess this is one time my aversion to Amazon burned me.
- ketralnis 4y agoWhy would HP gouge home users without also gouging the more lucrative business market?
- zimpenfish 4y agoOne would assume that the business market has more money and more lawyers to point at suppliers who annoy them. Plus a greater network of people, e.g. at business gatherings, they can use to name-and-shame said suppliers.
- quijoteuniv 4y agoThis is a lame strategy! What kind of people do this? What kind people pay employees to deceive the customers.
- tdeck 4y agoThe kind that want to make a profit and see that doing this is profitable.
- cortesoft 4y agoThe sad truth is that no printer company that doesn’t do this is going to be able to compete. HP and the like sell their printers at a loss, and consumers aren’t going to pay multiple X the cost of one of these types of printers to avoid the shenanigans. Any company who tries to price the printer itself at the appropriate cost isn’t going to sell enough.
- bogwog 4y agoAny source on that? I find it hard to believe that something as commonplace as a printer, a technology that has been around for so many decades, is hard to manufacture profitably. Maybe I'm wrong, since I have nothing to go by besides a gut feeling mixed with assumptions and a sprinkling of common sense, so I would love a source. The only scenario I can think of which makes sense to me is that making printers is a patent minefield, making it difficult/impossible for a competitor to come in and disrupt anything (plus it's not a very attractive industry anyways). There's probably also a lot of anti-competitive stuff going on too, like supplier contracts that prohibit working with other printer companies, etc.
- can16358p 4y agoThe problem isn't manufacturing. You can perfectly manufacture a great printer, but when HP and the like are selling printers at loss to make money off cartgridges, many consumers will simply buy the cheaper one: HP. Sure, you'll have some smarter customers who made their research and picked you, but it will probably not enough of a margin to compensate against a giant like HP.
- someweirdperson 4y agoIs that app for phones only or also for classic computers? I don't think it is reasonable to assume a phone is needed to use a printer. Information on devices made for carrying around doesn't usually need to be printed.
- userbinator 4y agoAbsolutely scummy, and yet another example of something labeled "smart" that's hostile to the user. There needs to be open source firmware for 2D printers too, like there have already been plenty developed for 3D ones. No need to reinvent the whole thing, but just replace the electronics. Presumably the printhead/cartridge interface is still much the same and they haven't gone to the effort of obfuscating/encrypting that yet... https://spritesmods.com/?art=magicbrush https://spritesmods.com/?art=magicbrush It's unfortunate that printers turned from being based on standard protocols that were documented in the manual they came with (ASCII, ESC/P2, PCL, PostScript, etc.) to these proprietary closed systems. None of the printer manufacturers, including HP, used to be like this.
- alerighi 4y agoPrinters always had proprietary software. Not only that, but the reason why the Free Software movement was started was caused by a printer that Richard Stallman had in its MIT office and that the manufacturer refused to release the source code for its software! > standard protocols You still find printers that support standard protocols, such as IPP (internet printing protocol), that work fine without proprietary drivers with CUPS on Linux. You just have to spend a little more money and avoid consumer stuff, that is Inkjet printers, and go for network laser printers meant to be used in small offices. B/W ones aren't too much expensive, and you can find ones used for not a lot of money, or even free, since companies throw them out, that still work.
- zerocrates 4y agoOne oddity is that, through Linux basically piggybacking on the support printer manufacturers built in to get out-of-the-box printing on Macs and iDevices, the world of Linux printing support is actually really good for newish printers without needing drivers. There are a lot of AirPrint and IPP Everywhere printers out there. I've had good luck in the past, as many have, with Brother's simple laser printers, but was very surprised at the ease of setup on Linux of a new Brother multi-function all-in-one inkjet printer/scanner combo thing: even the scanner worked over the network without a fuss. Night and day compared to my recollections of working with hpijs, hplip, foomatic, even poking around for Brother laser drivers sometimes for ones that didn't talk PCL. But then you have things like this where there's a pointless app forced into the mix to add more friction to that improved story... just because.
- jchw 4y agoI've given up on virtually all brands of printers. The last brand standing that doesn't seem like absolute shit is Brother. I have an ~~inkjet~~ laser printer of theirs that I have connected to the network, which I use with IPP and AirPrint with no issues. HP printers have been horrible anti-consumer garbage for as long as I can remember at this point.
- williamscales 4y agoYep, I chucked my HP inkjet and got a single function Brother mono laser printer. I figure if I need to print in color, I am probably better off just paying to use a really good photo printer.
- quijoteuniv 4y agoThis is the best solution for home use, totally agree. Is a shame that they turned inkjet technology into a scam.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe printer in question is a laser printer, the M209dwe.
- bobthepanda 4y agoCurious, how often do you find yourself printing these days? At this point I print so infrequently that going to the print shop for $1 is a more sound decision than spending $100 on a printer i use a handful of times a year.
- williamscales 4y agoI often print off papers to read, something about the form factor just works for me. I do this pretty frequently so it's worth it. Oh and return labels for packages.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago
- indymike 4y agoIt seems like this agreement should be agreed to before purchase of the device. It is a revision of the buy-sale deal at the store. Even worse, HP isn't even a party to the retail sale (yes it is their product, but the store sold it to me, not HP).
- dabinat 4y agoWhy aren’t startups trying to disrupt the printer industry? It’s been a racket for a long time. The only reason I can think of is that gouging customers must be the only real way to make money in that industry.
- mepian 4y agoThe margins in the printer industry must be razor-thin, that's why.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoWhich is why they do this junk, they are trying to squeeze every penny out
- genocidicbunny 4y agoThey are, and in this age of paperless everything, less and less useful to the average consumer. Anyone who still does a lot of printing is going to go with something that can better handle the volume, like a laser printer.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoAlso, the technology is pretty hairy, lots of patents (enforceable ones, too), and a very demanding customer base. I used to work for a company that made a very nice, but expensive, dye-sub printer. They decided not to continue the line, which disappointed a lot of folks, as the printers actually had some of the best tech, in them, but it wasn't worth it.
- someweirdperson 4y ago> lots of patents Printers from 20 years ago were pretty ok, so patents shouldn't matter much by simply building old-fashioned ones.
- kmeisthax 4y agoI would not be surprised if newer parents shadow the public domain stuff. Patent evergreening is the term of art if you wanna know more.
- messe 4y ago> this usually doesn't happen until it's too late to return the printer. Not if you’re in a country with reasonable consumer laws. I reckon this would easily be considered as “not fit for purpose” in most of the EU if you tried to challenge it in small claims.
- hedora 4y agoIn the US, you could easily argue that you were unaware of the EULA and want your money back. If the company refuses, then they are pretty clearly violating contract law. ("By the way, if you read this far, you owe me $10" is not a legimate contract, because you are forced to agree.) If that is the case, then it would be completely reasonable for the courts to render the entire EULA invalid, and fall back on first sale doctrine (no restrictions on the copy of the software you bought, etc, etc.)
- tdeck 4y agoWhat does "easily argue" mean in practical terms? Filing a case in small claims court? Credit card chargeback that inevitably gets disputed by the merchant and reversed? Haranguing customer service until they just give up and send you a coupon? In theory you might have a legal argument, but whether that's of any real use is another matter.
- hedora 4y agoIn practice, tell them you will consider the EULA non binding, and would still like your money back. If they are still dicks about it, figure out what the authors of the EULA were most afraid of, and do that. Home run fantasy land: Wait until they sue some other user based on a clause in the EULA, then testify in court, causing them to lose that case, and also invalidate the EULA for all their existing customers.
- blep_ 4y agoIsn't this the exact reason nearly every EULA has an "if any clause of this is found invalid, the rest still applies" clause? (Are those enforceable?)
- sva_ 4y agoIs there a reason why somebody would buy a HP printer in 2022?
- Nursie 4y agoBecause it’s a decent no-hassle, networked all-in-one and the ‘sample’ toner cartridges that they come with last me about six years.
- doublerabbit 4y agoAnyone in my family, probably yours too. To the outside tech user, they just want a printer and HP is global brand. My father would, considering our first ever computer was an HP so he'd be stuck with the mindset everything HP is great.
- josephcsible 4y agoBecause you need a printer, and their competitors are all just as scummy?
- sva_ 4y agoI bought a laser printer by Brother a couple years ago and never had any problems with 'fake' toners, and it also runs perfectly using CUPS on Linux. I suppose people don't research refill options ahead of buying a printer? This ongoing maintenance cost would be the first thing I'd look into. My initial question wasn't meant to be a rhetorical one. I was genuinely curious if there is any upside/reason why one should buy HP (print quality or whatever.)
- newhotelowner 4y agoRead the thread. Newer brother printers are also getting tricker with non-oem toners.
- sva_ 4y agoWell, thats depressing to hear.
- neilv 4y agoI think my next printer will have to be a non-HP. I've wrangled my current LaserJet, but I keep hearing stories that make the HP company sound like the kind I want nothing to do with anymore.
- varenc 4y agoDigression: Does anyone have a printer recommendation from a manufacturer that doesn’t pull this crap? I would love to patronize the least scummy manufacturer. Particularly I’m looking for a larger format printer that can do 11”x17” pages.
- JamesAdir 4y agoIt's not a large format printer but I've got a Xerox B205 and it works well without any shenanigans. Original toner price looks decent to me so I haven't tried 3rd party toners for it, but the option is there and it works well.
- colejohnson66 4y agoBrother’s laser printers are nice. Lexmark also exists, but they’re more of a business brand, and, as such, will cost more
- varenc 4y agoSadly it seems that Brother's only 11x17 "Ledger Size" printers are inkjet... alas. But the MFC-J5855DW inkjet printer from Brother looks decent. Will look at Lexmark too! edit: Lexmark does look very nice, but their 11x17 printer is the $3500 C925... which is a bit more printer than I need.
- liketochill 4y agoI went down the same rabbit hole after my epson WF-7620 ran out of ink in 9 months and only printed 100 pages at most. Gotta have 11x17 printing and scanning for control panel drawing packages
- someweirdperson 4y agoWith ink drying in heads and lasers emitting unhealthy dust, and manufacturers trying to lock them down, I'm considering a dot matrix printer as my next printer. Back to the roots. Looks like Epson is still making them, even including an ethernet port.
- Spivak 4y agoAm I missing something, why not just agree to it and then disregard? There’s no way the contract is enforceable, doubly when it was forced on you. It’s like how putting up a sign that says “we are not liable for blah blah” doesn’t mean shit.
- macNchz 4y agoThe printers refuse to print if you disconnect them from the internet.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAs part of agreeing you have to connect the printer to the internet and create an account.
- CarbonCycles 4y agoYou can’t. Their cartridges have some sort of way to recognize only HP cartridges (rfid? NFC?) I think this may be my last HP printer as well. Company has a f the consumer mentality.
- agilob 4y agoWhat do hp printers do that Brother doesn't?
- someweirdperson 4y agoAutomatically order new ink when running low.
- agilob 4y agoI have 3 Brother printers and they all notify me ahead of time when laser power or ink is slow. When it's "very low" I can still override the error and print a few more pages before ordering new cartridge that costs $10 for 1500 pages
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt was half the price. Should have known better.
- dcj4 4y agoDon't buy stuff from HP. They're scamming customers, it's known.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoFYI: This is probably unenforceable in most jurisdictions, including the US. Look up the term "unconscionability", particularily in US common contract law.
- gsich 4y agoYeah, so how can OP get his printer to ... print?
- reaperducer 4y agoThis is probably unenforceable in most jurisdictions, including the US Tell that to the printer and see how far you get. Apparently it is being enforced. By HP. Otherwise this post wouldn't exist. HP's lawyers know nobody is going to spend $5,000 on a lawyer to get Justice for a $100 printer.
- pabs3 4y agoWhat about a class action lawsuit? Surely there are some tech-oriented lawyers trawling HN/etc for class action ideas by now.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoWho said anything about lawyers? IANAL, but I'm pretty sure this is well within the remit of small claims court for the US, and the EU should have some agency whose job it is to deal with this.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoApparently many people are able to sue. Look up the "Leacraft v. Canon" case, which is somewhat related.
- tuyguntn 4y agoI don't understand how management makes a decision at HP. Do you guys actually use your own printers or do you have 24/7 person who prints stuff for you and your kids all the time? I need to go through their shitty app, sign up, sign in just to print something on my own printer. From time to time they have bugs in the app and I am kicked out of my own printer because app always needs to be logged in with user. Come on HP, maybe drop this bullshit "better user experience" practices? I bought a hardware from you, take my money, print and shut up
- theCrowing 4y agomake a rule on your router to deny all traffic going outside from the ip of your printer and the nagging goes away.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoTried that. Still couldn't print.
- jonathantf2 4y agoThe thing won't print without internet access at all, I've dealt with a few of these at work. We've had to tell people to take them back since they're basically unworkable.
- barbazoo 4y agoI wonder if that's "only" for the very first setup or every time you install the printer driver or something like that. Otherwise the printer will be useless once HP turns off that particular server or pulls the app. What a shit company.
- macNchz 4y agoIt checks regularly, and if the server is unreachable for any reason the printer will refuse to print until it’s able to reconnect.
- Neil44 4y agoWe’re an IT company and haven’t supplied HP for a while now because of stupid shit like this.
- ptk 4y agoI think this is only an issue with the models that end in ‘e’ if I’m not mistaken. They’re pushing it hard, but if you know to look you can find the same model without these absurd restrictions. For example, the HP LaserJet M209dwe (d=duplex, w=wireless, e=HP+) will require an Internet connection and HP’s Smart app, but there is also an HP LaserJet M209dw that does not have these restrictions.
- walterbell 4y agoDisclosure steganography. Avoid (e)vil?
- blagie 4y agoYeah no. If a company is trying to trick me like this, I won't buy from them. I've learned that lesson many times. I have an Epson which I'm happy with.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoIs it possible to upload firmware from one to another?
- matkoniecz 4y agoAvoiding any HP printers is a better idea, HP printers are especially evil.
- perlgeek 4y agoRecently bought a new printer, avoided anything with "smart" or "cloud" in the name/description.
- scottcodie 4y agoWhen a company takes an action solely to limit competition with no consumer benefit, they should be immediately investigated for antitrust behavior.
- onetokeoverthe 4y ago
- mayoff 4y agoSo you bought a printer that is marketed as “Works only with original HP toner; requires HP account, internet to operate” and now you're mad that it requires you to use original HP toner? https://www.hp.com/us-en/shop/pdp/hp-laserjet-m209dwe-printer https://www.hp.com/us-en/shop/pdp/hp-laserjet-m209dwe-printe...
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThat notice is buried in the fine print on the box, the box I didn't get to see until checkout at the bricks and mortar store I purchased it at.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoRegardless of what was advertised, I wish we had more "right to repair" laws that made this scummy corporate behavior illegal. All this "smart" shit is just an excuse for corporations to have more tracking and more control.
- solarist 4y agoYou prefer every printer manufacturer do this instead of none of them?
- noncoml 4y agoAlso, in order to use the scanning functionality of your machine you need to create an online account.
- thih9 4y agoThat delay makes it look like a drip campaign? Not happy that this strategy is expanding to hardware.
- amelius 4y agoBy the way, never connect your printer to the internet; it will download software updates that will make your life miserable, e.g. by detecting the newest generation of "fake" cartridges.
- jliptzin 4y agoEvery company and every individual involved in the printer business needs to be fired and replaced with a completely new cohort of people. They have utterly failed; it doesn’t need to be this bad.
- awinter-py 4y agoclass action. you bought a printer, you no longer have a printer. don't sue for $$$, sue for the private key so you can flash the firmware. it is the only way you can be made whole
- Blue111 4y agoBuy one of their cheap sub-$100 laser printer if you don't need colors. I have been printing daily for more then a year on the same toner cartridge, and replacements are cheap.
- can16358p 4y agoHP and its crappy tactics. I really wonder how long they will survive in the upcoming era, with this mentality.