6 ms·
Great job figuring out it was a scam but honestly, it’s crazy that these things still work on anyone all the way in 2022. You would think that by now every huma
by ryandrake 4y ago
Great job figuring out it was a scam but honestly, it’s crazy that these things still work on anyone all the way in 2022. You would think that by now every human being that walks the earth would know that whenever someone you don’t know sends you “money” and then requests you send it back (or to another party) in a different form, it’s always a scam. There should be some ceremony whenever someone turns 16 or something, where you just get taught this and that’s the end of this scam. Insane that people still fall for this!
Same for the gift card scams. No legit business or government on earth in any industry asks for gift cards as payment! This is like an absolute ironclad fact of the universe. But so many people still fall for it!
- kortilla 4y agoDelta airlines gives gift cards as payment for volunteering on oversold flights. Really doesn’t help dissuade people from “$50 Panera Bread” gift cards from being involved in transactions not involving Panera Bread.
- ketzo 4y agoYeah, but approximately no business or government agency in the world ACCEPTS gift cards as payment.
- j33zusjuice 4y agoThe companies that issue them accept them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- freetanga 4y agoRedeem them. Which is a narrower definition than “accepts as payment”
- SanjayMehta 4y agoThis journalist got scammed into quitting her job and telling the world that she had been hired by an Ivy League university as a professor. Months of effort and multiple email domains created to push the scam. https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7vq8m/india-nidhi-razdan-phishing-scam-harvard-job-offer-fake-cybersecurity https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7vq8m/india-nidhi-razdan-ph...
- webmobdev 4y agoI believe she was targeted by the ruling political party, who have a history of harassing and doxxing their critics, (or the current indian government itself) to demoralise her and besmirch her reputation as a journalist. And that happened. She is now attacked by her critics for her "naivety", and ridiculed by them, and she went into depression and took a break. (It all points to that as she was never asked for any money, as is is usual with these kind of scam. )
- honkler 4y agoI don't think the ruling party and its political supporters are clever enough to execute it. It was surely quite weird what happened with her though.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoI seriously doubt that they would waste their time on this. They have much more powerful tools at their disposal. 1. Aatish Taseer: His OCI card (something like dual citizenship, but not quite) was cancelled. He claims he's been told not to even attempt to visit India ever again. 2. Rana Ayyub: she created a donation website and got clobbered with tax evasion. 3. Numerous NGOs: including Green Peace and Amnesty have had their licenses revoked. There are many more such cases, but off the top of my head, these jumped out.
- kevin_p 4y agoVictims of the gift card scam don't really think that the government wants you to pay your fines/taxes in Google Play money. The implication is that a government employee will make the problem go away if you pay them under the table. The victim is being made to feel that they're a participant in the scam, which makes them less likely to report it once they figure out they're getting cheated.
- fineIllregister 4y agoI've watched some scambaiting videos and I never see it approached like that. They do sometimes inoke avoiding taxes to get targets to buy gift cards or mark a transfer of money as personal.
- zorrolovsky 4y agoThis post seem to blame victims for the problem, and that is not fair. People can be in dark places mentally, struggle with disease, family issues, etc. Not everybody is mentally sharp 100% of the time to identify a scam attack and fight it back. The problem is not victims, the problem is scammers. There should be better mechanisms to quickly clamp down on them. In this case, it would be really good if there was a mechanism or institution where the victim could report the scam and once verified it would gather information from Google, Dropbox sign, the bank receiving the funds, and other tools scammers use to build a case against the scammer in the relevant jurisdiction, and avoid them using the same tools for further scams. My strategy to repel scams is to stay humble. Mo matter how much I think I'm prepared to identify scams, I am still vulnerable and I will continue to be vulnerable. Arrogance is your worst friend if your objective is to stay safe. No matter how many ceremonies you do when you're 16, in the right context and with the right words, you will still fall for a talented social engineer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maximus-decimus 4y agoYou're relying on the idea that all foreign governments care about their citizens scamming Americans. And it literally takes only one government that doesn't care (or isn't able to enforce for whatever reason) for your strategy to be impossible.
- vanviegen 4y agoI'm sure the US government could think of one or two things to put enough pressure on such countries, if it cared to do that.
- admax88qqq 4y agoLet's assume the scams are coming from North Korea or Cuba or Russia. You really think that there's more pressure the US apply that will make these countries go "you're right we shouldn't let our citizens scam your citizens" The root issue it archaic payment systems and banks where a check can take 7 days to clear. In this age a bank check should clean in seconds and funds should not be available in your account until it clears. It should be on the bank to not lie to you about funds in your account.
- tommiegannert 4y agoThat people buy gift cards at all boggles my mind. You're buying a currency with less versatility (and hence value) for 1:1. Where I live, we have perfectly fine government-issued bills to gift if that's your thing. Somehow, that's considered a bad present? Because it's lazy? Because it doesn't show your opinion on clothes brands? I don't get it, from the consumer's perspective. To the shop/mall it's a clear winner, since you know some receivers won't use their cards. It's a proper arbitrage to them.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoThis is one more very good reason not to indulge the insanity that is a "cashless society". If you let go of those government issued bills be sure that in no time at all you'll have nothing but fragmented, private "smart" currencies each hobbled with its own insidious restrictions.
- tommiegannert 4y agoMaybe. It's easy enough to send money to someone using the phone these days, so I'm not sure cashless would lead to gift cards here in Switzerland (or my native Sweden.) But I agree it's not a very fun package to open when it's just a promise to use Twint/Swish to transfer money. Oh, maybe the real use for gift cards is that the receiver can't haggle. "I know you wanted to give me $200, but how about we make that an even $500 instead?" :)
- geysersam 4y agoThis doesn't seem right. Cashless usually means electronic currency equivalent to physical currency. Card payments are not gift cards.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoWhether the form is electronic or physical is irrelevant to my argument. If you read it again carefully you'll see that it's about state-backed versus private currencies. Don't let the technology dazzle you.
- fallingknife 4y agoNot to mention asking to contact someone about official business at a Gmail address!
- Delemono 4y agoOne of my most frustrating revelations is this: Every new human has to learn aaaaalll of this over again. That's also why empires like the Roman was able to disappear. Knowledge fades and we need actively teach over and over again. More money to our education system! And btw people still have no clue how computers work. This hasn't changed too much :(
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 6c696e7578 4y agoThis is slightly different to most. Would it have got this far it is was a cold contact? Probably not. What this group did was lure someone into thinking they're part of a company as you're more likely to do what your employer tells you and you're far more likely to trust your employer too. It probably pays off for the scammers to spend time this way as they probably get a much better conversion ratio.
- fabian2k 4y agoI think the part that makes it more difficult to detect that this is a scam for someone that never encountered it is that it relies on the difference between real money in your account and "money" that can vanish at any point, you just don't know it. This is a case that most people don't encounter outside of this kind of scam. Another unintuitive part is that even if the rules of the bank say the money is yours, it actually isn't if it came from a third-party that was hacked/scammed/whatever. The gift card thing is something that should trigger an alarm even if you never heard of it.
- the_gipsy 4y agoWhat amazes me is that americans still use cheques, that aren't "cleared" up to a week or so. That's ridiculous.
- puffoflogic 4y agoChecks are a brilliant idea with a terrible implementation. Idea: physical financial instrument with a specified payee (OR a bearer instrument, using the same format!), with a completely unconstrained denomination, which the payer can draw up on demand and in the field. Implementation: reveal enough information about your account that anyone can "authorize" arbitrary transfers; take weeks and weeks to learn whether the funds are actually available and there's absolutely no way to convince your bank to reveal whether the transaction is verified, at any point; etc.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoAnd Dwolla exists, which is better in many ways!
- dwighttk 4y agothis one was delayed because it was sketchy. I deposited a check using my bank's app last night after my bank closed and it cleared in about 20 minutes.
- jacurtis 4y agoI mean, its not all that common. I don't get checks that often, almost everything is handled electronically. But checks are still a way to distribute money physically that isn't cash, so it serves some purpose. Most Americans (especially those under 30) do not own a checkbook and don't know how to write a check. That is part of why this scam works. 20 years ago Checks were common enough that every adult understood that Check's aren't real money and people would be more cautious until it clears. But the fact that now everything is instantaneous, Checks are maybe the last exception to that. So someone with no knowledge of checks might assume that it is "real" money. I think few people understand the differences even between a cashiers check, a personal check, and a money order. Luckily Banks are more aware of these scams and tellers have been trained to ask A LOT of questions about wire transfers before executing them. It sounds like in the posted article, that OP actually got a warning about this from the banker how this is non-reversible. But again, even OP admitted that he had never completed a wire transfer before. I've only ever made 2 wire transfers in my life (and I'm 36) and both were to buy a house. Few Americans have complete a wire transfer and probably don't understand the implications of it either. So I think this scam actually preys and relies on the fact that little knowledge exists of wiretransfers and checks.
- rustybolt 4y agoYeah OK but then there are 100s of other general principles you need to know in life. Calling someone stupid every time someone doesn't follow one of the things that's obvious to you is not constructive. We need things like this to go public to avoid them from happening, and shaming victims doesn't help here. The author is already extremely apologetic in this post, and still there are people saying he's stupid for almost falling for it. I am usually quite rational, but I've done some pretty stupid and embarassing things at times where I was not thinking everything through. I imagine most people have. Imagine you go to vacation to Paris, take an evening walk and get mugged. Your attitude is like the local saying "what an idiot for walking around in that neighborhood at night".
- rtpg 4y agoEvery day somebody is born who hasn't heard one of these stories! And honestly one thing about life is that you generally are slowly building up trust with people, and then can be asked to do things that are totally legit all the time. Of course skepticism is required, but I know a lot of people who got dealt a lot of shit by their (real) employers simply by not understanding what is normal or not, as it was their first job.
- iso1631 4y ago> Every day somebody is born who hasn't heard one of these stories 10,000, and that's just the US https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- jacquesm 4y agoI suspect that given enough effort and the right circumstances you too could be scammed. And that's pretty much the problem: scammers have near infinite time to set you up, it's their day job after all and you have a limited time to verify their bona fides.
- nindalf 4y agoI’ve worked many years in fields adjacent to scams and fraud. I’ve seen many different kinds, especially romance and financial scams. This knowledge doesn’t make me more confident about avoiding scams, it’s made me realise that anyone can be scammed regardless of knowledge or intelligence. Scams are about identifying what the victim really, really wants and offering it to them with some constraint. Some people are desperate for a job, for money to make ends meet. That desperation short circuits their common sense. I’ve seen successful romance scams that were so obviously scams. Even if you were in love, why didn’t you think twice about sending $10k the second time?? Neither of these would have worked on me because I’ve never been desperate for either of them. That doesn’t mean I would dismissively talk like you did, saying no one should fall for them. I can be scammed, it’s just a question of finding what I’m desperate for and offering that to me, maybe with time pressure. In that situation I would ignore obvious red flags like a business asking for gift cards. I need to be successful every time, the scammers need to be successful only once.