25 ms·
Emergency SOS via satellite
- tosh 4y ago> the service extends to France, Germany, Ireland, and the UK in December This is new to me. I thought the feature was limited to US + Canada. Did they mention additional regions in the keynote?
- stevewatson301 4y agoNot in the keynote; this seems to be a recently finalized expansion.
- rtkwe 4y agoIt'll need to be approved in individual countries so it'll probably get turned on in a lot more areas. In the US there's an explicit exception to life threatening emergencies that let you use basically any radio frequency I wonder how many countries have something like that that could at least allow them to enable the emergency contact portion of this without the check-in for non emergency situations.
- tyingq 4y agoAs someone who grew up in the era before mobile phones, it truly is strange to see devices that do roughly everything Captain Kirk's communicator could do. But in my lifetime, and available to average people.
- braymundo 4y agoI bet Kirk's communicator couldn't even play games, so it's wilder. :)
- heynowheynow 4y agoNo, it was just corporate MDM managed to prevent it. :)
- avian 4y agoIf it did, Scotty would be working on an adtech backend, Bones would be researching ways to make games more addictive and humanity would never have left Earth.
- goda90 4y agoWhen watching sci-fi movies and TV, I often wonder what happened with the development of gaming, social media, and virtual reality in the timeline of the show. It seems like in most of the cases where they actually get mentioned in sci-fi, it's kind of dystopian.
- piperswe 4y agoStar Trek at least shows using the holodeck for leasure, though they don't go into the specifics of using the holodeck for communication (you could be in the "same room" as someone lightyears away!) or for gaming.
- dylan604 4y agoDidn't Kirk have to cheat to beat Spock's unbeatable game? Games might not have disappeared, but maybe they changed to be unrecognizable by people that can only travel at slower than warp speed.
- wongarsu 4y agoAnd phones like the CAT s61 [1] are well on their way to add the functionality of Spock's Tricorder into the same package. https://www.catphones.com/en-ca/cat-s61-smartphone/ https://www.catphones.com/en-ca/cat-s61-smartphone/
- germinalphrase 4y agoListed features: - thermal imaging - laser assisted distance measurement - indoor air quality
- Kye 4y agoI can do 1/3 with my iPhone already using the lidar and 3/3 with attachments.
- dylan604 4y agoI don't remember anyone using a tricoder saying, "hang on. i need to switch attachments to do the thing."
- Kye 4y agoThat's because it's science fiction. Imaginary futures are usually better than reality.
- freeflight 4y agoTho I do remember a whole lot of "We can reconfigure the tricoder to do the thing"
- freeflight 4y agoEven more impressive is the fact how it can do all these things for around the same price as other smartphones, while being way more rugged. Definitely gonna keep those CAT phones in mind for the next time I need a new one.
- xattt 4y agoGrowing up during proliferation of mobile devices but in financially-limited circumstances, there are certain things that I’ve relegated to “not for me” because of an imprinted cost. Getting a smartphone and paying a recurring fee for data (when I was perfectly capable) was still a major point of hesitation for me. Satellite-based communication devices remains as one of the self-imposed unobtaniums.
- elboru 4y ago“Available to average people” that’s what amazes me. I remember when I played with an iPhone for the first time. It was an amazing device, but I thought it was a luxury device for rich people only. A few years later smartphones got a lot cooler and cheaper, to the point where it actually helped spread the internet to sections of the population that weren’t able or didn’t want to use a PC.
- sitkack 4y agoI used to buy used cars for less than the price of a new top-end iPhone. They aren't phones, they are pocket computers/jewelry that sometimes make phone calls.
- heynowheynow 4y agoand Dick Tracy. We haven't arrived at full tricorder yet though.
- DonHopkins 4y agoWe're at bicorder, looking forward to quadcorder.
- lancesells 4y agoAs dystopian as the keynote for these new emergency features felt, they are real-life helpful features. 99.99% of people will never need it but for the small fraction who do it's amazing.
- Watchwatcher 4y agoAll the features, and none of the freedom. Kirk and the crew would have a lot of bad things to say about the iPhone and it's walled lawn. It's tragic that I can't install an application I wrote without going through Apple on the thousand dollar computer that I bought.
- SaberTail 4y agoI find it amusing that Star Trek didn't anticipate communicators or tricorders having a flashlight function like our phones do. When they need lights, they either carry special-purpose ones or shoot a rock with a phaser to make it glow. Generously, maybe someone did think of it, but it would have been too difficult to make a prop with a bright enough light source.
- vel0city 4y agoI use my phone's flashlight a good bit, it is very useful. That said, if I was going on some away mission where lighting was going to be questionable, I'd probably bring some kind of dedicated lighting equipment like a flashlight. My flashlights have adjustable beams. They throw out many times more light than my phone's flashlight. Using the dedicated flashlight gives a way better lighting experience than using my phone's flashlight. But it is like cameras, the best flashlight is the one on you.
- Jemm 4y agoHonestly if I could shoot a rock with a phaser to make it glow, I wouldn't bother with a flash light either.
- freeflight 4y agoAs far as I remember the shooting rock with phaser thing was more about having a source of heat, as not to freeze to death. I can see the communicator on the chest being used as a flashlight with the powerful LED we have today. But 90s TV show prop departments would probably have had one hell of a time trying to make that work, and practical, so instead they gave everybody futuristic looking flashlights aka "palm beacons" [0] [0] https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Palm_beacon https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Palm_beacon
- eternityforest 4y agoPretty much everyone who does field work still has a flashlight. It runs down the battery and you might not want to be holding a phone if there's rain. Plus, flashlights are very fast to access. And often brighter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Centrino 4y agoThe article doesn't mention which satellites or which satellite provider is used. But Apple invested $450 million in Globalstar. https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/11/emergency-sos-via-satellite-made-possible-by-450m-apple-investment/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/11/emergency-sos-via-sat...
- WhyNotHugo 4y agoI was really wondering what kind of satellite-based emergency SOS they were using -- mostly because I'd never heard of it until it was being shipped in a commercial product, which is something very rare to see. So basically, they have their own infrastructure for their own proprietary 911 service with global coverage? It's really amazing that we live in a world where we can have such infrastructure, but at the same time, it's owned and controlled by a single corporation. I notice there's multiple mentions of these satellites working with the "Find My" service, which keeps track of where a device is (in order to find it where it's lost). So I guess all this infrastructure also allows Apple to pinpoint down any user worldwide -- even if they're off-grid.
- kotaKat 4y agoIt's basically running on the same system as their current SPOT trackers in the S- and L-band. L-band up, S-band down.
- addaon 4y agoAre you sure about that? I was under the impression that this was running on N53, which is towards the bottom of S band, both directions.
- 310260 4y agoIt's suppose to be on Globalstar's existing network which would be S-band and L-band but CDMA. It's not 5G-NR just yet though that's likely where they're headed. I think Apple added n53 as part of this deal at Globalstar's request. Globalstar is trying to lease their spectrum terrestrially for small cell networks and network capacity solutions for the carriers. https://www.globalstar.com/Globalstar/media/Globalstar/Downloads/CompanyOverview_Partnership.pdf https://www.globalstar.com/Globalstar/media/Globalstar/Downl... (PDF warning) Here's a presentation with some details.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoAt first I thought that Apple might be using the Gallileo sattellites put up by EU, but it looks like they have their own thing going with Globalstar. This kind of makes sense, and near-earth satellites are easier to reach for a phone. https://www.esa.int/Applications/Navigation/Galileo_now_replying_to_SOS_messages_worldwide https://www.esa.int/Applications/Navigation/Galileo_now_repl...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tony_cannistra 4y agoI'm glad to see that they at least talked to some IRL dispatchers for this press release, which hopefully suggests that they've been doing it all along. But really, I desperately hope that we can find a way to educate folks on the proper usage of technology like this (which, if you count things like the Garmin inReach and the Spot devices, has been available for a decade). They're undoubtedly life saving, but they also are taxing mostly volunteer-run search and rescue organizations with folks who really probably don't need help, they just needed to bring some water and a jacket. But they didn't , because they didn't know better, and now need someone to risk themselves on their behalf. It makes me nervous about the longevity of volunteer-run search and rescue organizations, frankly. It's unfortunate that these are the majority, at least in the rural parts of USA that draw lots of outdoor adventurers.
- mwint 4y agoIsn’t it going to make calls using this feature much easier, if there’s a 10m-accuracy GPS pin around the subject?
- whartung 4y agoWell that’s the GPS point. Make this more casually available and folks are likely to more casually use it. The problem for the teams isn’t necessarily finding the party, we’ve had these beacons for years. Rather they have to climb into the mountains in the first place to solve what could have, ostensibly, been readily prevented. Thus taxing a limited resource even further. What should temper that is now there perhaps may be signs posted telling folks about the service, and that help is available (or not) but it’s likely going to be rather expensive if they have to come get you. It’s never been suggested that while the S&R teams maybe volunteer, as I understand the rescued party incurs costs of the operation.
- tony_cannistra 4y agoActually, in many places in the United States, SAR calls don't cost you anything. Usually it's the ambulance / helicopter ride. But even then, there are helicopter operators (like the U.S. military, which responds to many SAR calls where I live) that don't charge.
- papito 4y agoThis is great, but people do still need to keep in mind that this is not a full replacement of the emergency beacons that use the Cospas-Sarsat system, which would work anywhere, from pole to pole. If you are going to do extreme hiking in Patagonia, get a real distress beacon. There is no service charge except for the device itself. This is no joke - I had to use mine in the middle of Death Valley (of all places) during a seizure-like episode. Saved my life.
- RL_Quine 4y agoYeah, it's no replacement for a dedicated device, but it's with a whole lot of people all the time.
- heynowheynow 4y ago406 PLB's - monitored by satellite - Garmin InReach Explorer+ looks alright and doesn't need a special factory battery replacement. 121.5 ELTs - requiring sar aircraft proximity - are obsolete.
- mrtksn 4y agoJust like with Apple Watch Ultra, Its for people with serious hobbies but not professionals or those on the extreme end. I think they have a name for that market segment.
- piperswe 4y agoIn computer hardware, that market segment is typically called "prosumer"
- xchip 4y agoWhat sort of link does the phone use? 5G?
- yieldcrv 4y agoyeah band 53 via the Qualcomm X65 modem you can pretty much tell what an iphone will be able to do based on what qualcomm is currently able to do
- xchip 4y agoyou guys are awesome
- mcculley 4y agoDo you happen to know when Apple will be able to put a modem into a MacBook Pro?
- nickcw 4y ago> LTE Band 53 is a part of the TDD (Time Division Duplex) LTE spectrum that requires only a single frequency band for both the uplink and downlink. LTE Band 53 has a frequency range from 2483.5 - 2495 MHz with a bandwidth of 11.5 MHz. From: https://www.everythingrf.com/tech-resources/lte-bands/lte-band-53 https://www.everythingrf.com/tech-resources/lte-bands/lte-ba... Quite impressive they can receive that on the satellite with 1W (guess) of power and a not very directional antenna in the iPhone.
- Jtsummers 4y agoIn the earlier videos on it they showed that the phone has to be pointed a certain way (which makes sense given the power constraints), but you are guided through the process. https://www.apple.com/newsroom/images/product/iphone/standard/Apple-Emergency-SOS-Connected_inline.jpg.large.jpg https://www.apple.com/newsroom/images/product/iphone/standar... - Shows the screen you'd see.
- keepquestioning 4y agoSo Back to qualcomm aye? The ghost that can never be killed.
- teeray 4y agoIf you’re looking for emergency comms where cell service is unavailable, you can do really well with a 2m/70cm Baofeng UV-5R. It’ll run you like $60 between the technician’s license (easy to get) and the radio, no subscription. From mountains (no service), I’ve gotten into repeaters 60 miles away. Knowing the community on those frequencies, they’ll treat your emergency with the same respect and decorum as those submitted through the SOS feature (many even train for it through organizations like ARES). I certainly don’t mean to poo-poo this announcement in HN commenter fashion—-I think it’s actually really great to have. Just wanted to highlight an alternative to shelling out $1k+ for a capable phone if you don’t have one.
- swader999 4y agoThat's quite an undertaking to get up to speed on using and programming one of those.
- barbazoo 4y agoThat's what I thought too. Definitely a capable radio but quite a learning curve.
- davidwihl 4y agoGetting that sort of range is not common. Most of it is line of sight. Sat comms work far at sea where VHF is useless. With ARES, you are relying on an inconsistent volunteer network with spotty results by location and time. I'm a licensed ham and have worked emergency events. I would not rely upon this if my life depended on it.
- ingalls 4y agoI'm also a HAM and work Search and Rescue, I would also never use this as my primary emergency device unless I had someone I knew actively monitoring the frequency. Buy something like a Garmin InReach Mini (~$15 a month subscription free) or a PLB (no monthly cost)
- aabhay 4y agoNo one here has mentioned this here, surprisingly, but the UX on this feature is absolutely incredible. Clear, thoughtful, helpful, and deeply integrated with user services. It almost makes me _want_ to get into trouble, just to be able to use this service!
- dagmx 4y agoThere’s a demo mode in the settings fortunately
- MarkMarine 4y agoThere is!!! Awesome! This should be a top comment because I was worried how I’d teach my parents to use it.
- wstrange 4y agoThis is really going to eat into Garmin's Inreach market (ditto for Spot, Zoleo, etc). It says free for the first 2 years. I'm curious what the yearly cost will be after that, and how it will compare to an Inreach plan. On an ongoing basis, it's the subscription fees that really add up.
- Alex3917 4y agoThe bigger threat to Garmin is probably just the new GPS. There are probably a lot of folks who will now put off buying their first bike computer for a couple years now that an iPhone with Strava is going to be almost as accurate as an Edge 530 or whatever. Having a real bike computer is still going to be better, but by significantly less than it was a year ago.
- CarbonCycles 4y agoGarmin has already released the new GPS chipset that uses multiband (similar to Apples). https://support.garmin.com/en-US/?faq=9NWiPDU4gM0JWMfdWFol7A https://support.garmin.com/en-US/?faq=9NWiPDU4gM0JWMfdWFol7A The new GPS chipsets are absolutely a beast in challenging conditions and incredibly accurate/precise over the older technology.
- petre 4y agoOne doesn't need to buy an expensive Garmin model. I've got an Edge 130 and an older Edge 25 that I've bought second hand. The 130 came as an upgrade to the older device and is perfect for my use. Both devices connect with my Forerunner 245 watch for the HR. Whenever I don't want to use them (commute or sub 20 km workout), I just use the watch. Dual frequency GPS is probably going to make its way into cheaper Garmin models soon enough, maybe thanks to Apple. Having a phone on the handlebar/top tube is cumbersome and annoying, battery life is crap and distractions galore. I don't want needless phone calls from annoying people interrupting my workout and distracting me from watching the road. I've set up my Garmin devices to ignore phone calls and texts from the phone during workouts.
- mikestew 4y ago
- pqdbr 4y agoFrom the article: > A text compression algorithm was also developed to reduce the average size of messages by 300 percent I don't think that's how percentages work.
- kotaKat 4y agoI suspect the algorithm is just the frontloaded questions they ask you -- of course they can shrink all that down into a handful of bytes and unpack it on the other end as "car crash, 3 people, injuries reported, lat/long". So the percentage "works", in a way, until you get to the freeform text.
- Slartie 4y agoAlso, a 75% reduction (which I assume was meant by their 300 percent) is not that impressive when it comes to text compression. I'd guess that should be easily reachable with zstd by just creating a pre-shared dictionary generated from a bunch of typical emergency messages. Especially when those messages are partially auto-generated by a wizard-style questionnaire and will thus adhere to a previously-known structure and contain a lot of known elements and words.
- dont__panic 4y agoYou know damn well there's a new "Staff Engineer" at Apple who fluffed this "algorithm" up as an argument for a promotion from Senior Engineer. And likely a few product folks and managers who ballooned this entire project way out of proportion for their own career advancement.
- __turbobrew__ 4y agoStaff engineer at apple discovers gzip
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoFrom my friends who work at Apple, there’s a lot less of that promotion-driven work because most of the engineers there are at ict4.
- stall84 4y agothat is awesome. I wonder if this (it must be) amounts to a hardware or software upgrade on satellites already in orbit, along with updates to the phone's iOS right ? This article just mentions the 'client-side' changes but .. there has to be some accounting of the hardware in space being used right?
- sschueller 4y ago
- fassssst 4y agoYou don’t need it until you do.
- tony_cannistra 4y agoThe United States and Canada are really, really big. There are big swaths of those countries (especially Canada) where people regularly live / drive / recreate, but are several hours driving away from cell phone service.
- mastax 4y agoA lot of people go hiking and few of them buy sat phones or epirbs. It's nice to have. We're well past the point of diminishing returns for smartphone features, yes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DMell 4y agoI spend the majority of my time in the mountains here in Estes Park, Colorado where I carry the following in the winter - for both climbing and skiing: - Probe - Shovel - Beacon - InReach Mini I also work SAR and my partner has worked dispatch for the National Park Service here and it's not uncommon for someone to be trying to climb something akin to Longs Peak late fall in a tshirt and shorts - having absolutely no idea what they are doing but hiking it because they saw it on All Trails.
- Cass 4y agoThis isn't meant for heli-skiers who go out with a few thousand bucks of equipment. None of the average hikers I know own a satellite phone, plenty of them like to hike alone, and an hour of walking into the woods (hardly a strenuous hike) will frequently land you somewhere with patchy service (and this is in a country with perfectly well-functioning infrastructure, not the middle of the Rocky Mountains.) I'm sure this is going to lead to a few spectacular, high-profile rescues, but I'd bet the average use case is going to be "saved me three hours of crawling through the woods on a broken ankle to get back to the last place I had cell service."
- millzlane 4y agoYesterday I had a cust. come into the store with a iPhone 14 pro that was stuck in SOS mode. My tech couldn't resolve the issue with a restore in AC2. I wonder if this is related or just a coincidence.
- nabaraz 4y agoI wish iphone 14 models still have a sim tray. This is the only thing keeping me from upgrading.
- tosh 4y agoThe models in Europe come with a SIM tray.
- easygenes 4y agoIs this enabled by the giant satellite that just went up that astronomers are worried about?
- zosoworld 4y agoNo, that's the Bluewalker from AST. This is Globalstar.
- Mo3 4y agoStuff like this is the reason Apple is valued as highly as it is.
- robg 4y agoReally impressed how Apple is leaning into unregulated “safety” features. Fall detection for grandma, crash detection for drivers, now this for adventurers. When you’re doing as well as Apple is, small reasons for consumers to buy keep adding up over the competition.
- angrygoat 4y agoIf this becomes available in Australia, it would be a decent reason for me to upgrade my phone. I quite like bushwalking, and I quite like the idea of more adventurous walks – and knowing I can text for help would be a real plus.
- Nursie 4y agoYep, extend it to Aus and I have a reason to upgrade from my 12 pro!
- Jemm 4y agoGroundbreaking? Hardly.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThen you should have no problem pointing me at what other smartphone already has this ability.
- adamredwoods 4y agoTerrestar Genus (2011, now defunct) https://www.engadget.com/2010-11-23-terrestar-genus-now-available-to-anyone-who-wants-one-for-just.html https://www.engadget.com/2010-11-23-terrestar-genus-now-avai... Android: https://www.thuraya.com/en/products-list/land-voice/thuraya-x5-touch https://www.thuraya.com/en/products-list/land-voice/thuraya-... Lynk: https://lynk.world/ https://lynk.world/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/09/a-virginia-company-has-connected-mobile-phones-directly-to-satellites/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/09/a-virginia-company-h... Add-on for existing phone: https://www.bluecosmo.com/iridium-go-global-smartphone-access.html https://www.bluecosmo.com/iridium-go-global-smartphone-acces... T-Mobile is planning on it: https://www.t-mobile.com/news/un-carrier/t-mobile-takes-coverage-above-and-beyond-with-spacex https://www.t-mobile.com/news/un-carrier/t-mobile-takes-cove...
- binarymax 4y agoIt's not clear whether this is for US/Canada customers, or if it only works in the vicinity of the US and Canada. If I'm a US customer but am stranded in the middle of Africa, will this work?
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Emergency SOS via satellite is available in the US and Canada starting today, November 15, and will come to France, Germany, Ireland, and the UK in December. I take this to mean the service itself only works within the stated countries. I wonder if it would work in overseas US territories like Samoa.
- bmicraft 4y agoI'm guessing the only thing limiting it is integration with existing services
- lxgr 4y agoIntegrating with local SAR services is one issue, but Globalstar's coverage is another (contrary to its name, it's not actually global, since it requires satellites to have both mobile devices and at least one earth station in view at all times).
- kube-system 4y agoAnd regulatory approval for transmitting on those frequencies in that specific locale.
- kotaKat 4y agoWorks in the specific countries. If you have an iPhone 14 from another country that isn't supported, it'll work in that country. If you have an African iPhone 14 and are stranded in the middle of the US, it should work.
- vikR0001 4y agoHow can a little iPhone possibly have enough power to transmit data all the distance to a satellite?
- zikduruqe 4y agoSpace isn't that far away. It's only 60 miles. I've communicated via LEO satellites using only 1 watt of power from an handheld radio.
- Temporary_31337 4y ago1 whole watt is a lot by modern, digital standards, but satellite does not have a directional antenna with gain to receive your signal. It looks like Garmin InReach transmits at 1.6Watts. I wonder what the radio is inside the new iPhones.
- kkielhofner 4y agoWhen you're going straight up you don't have to deal with obstructions and the curvature of the earth. For OP if you want to see it in action there are plenty of YouTube videos[0] of amateur radio operators with an HT (walkie-talkie) contacting astronauts on the ISS - which is 254 miles up. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3cZe-UASAHs https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3cZe-UASAHs
- syncsynchalt 4y agoNot much different than my spot tracker... which transmits my position to satellites every 10 minutes for 2-3 days with 4xAAA batteries.
- kawfey 4y agoiPhone satellite SOS communicates to a constellation of 24 GlobalStar Gen 2 Low Earth Orbit satellites, orbiting somewhere between 800 and 1000mi[0]. This is the same satellite system that SPOT messengers talk to (which are also tiny devices)[1]. The user points the phone at the satellite (in reality, the UI tells the user where to put the phone in relation to it's measured antenna pattern to maximize the gain towards the nearest satellite), while the satellite has a huge, very very high gain antenna array to pick up the signal and pass it back down to a ground station. iPhones can output up to 2 watts of RF power, which is enough for a tiny <HELP! Here's my LAT/LON & status> message. It's using 5G NR band 53 [2][3] I'm sure someone out there has already run a linkbudget and posted it to their blog, but I haven't found it yet. [0] https://space.skyrocket.de/doc_sdat/globalstar-2.htm https://space.skyrocket.de/doc_sdat/globalstar-2.htm [1] https://www.findmespot.com/en-us/products-services/spot-gen4 https://www.findmespot.com/en-us/products-services/spot-gen4 [2] https://gearjunkie.com/news/apple-iphone-satellite-messaging-off-grid-how-it-works https://gearjunkie.com/news/apple-iphone-satellite-messaging... [3] https://itecspec.com/band/nr-band-n53/ https://itecspec.com/band/nr-band-n53/
- nickcw 4y agoFrom the small print > The service will be included for free for two years starting at the time of activation of a new iPhone 14, iPhone 14 Plus, iPhone 14 Pro, and iPhone 14 Pro Max. Which kind of implies it will be a pay for service after two years.
- pathartl 4y agoI would assume it's rolled into the iCloud subscription after two years
- sneak 4y agoThe product announcement for the iPhone 14 said nothing about any sort of recurring subscription costs for such a service.
- brookst 4y agoMaybe? If I were the product manager there, I would fight tooth and nail to only make a short term commitment to support it at all. Two years in, if it's un unmitigated disaster costing $1B/year and generating zero rescues and zero PR, kill it. You can't do that if you've promised "free for the life of the phone" or something.
- BoardsOfCanada 4y agoThat could be some very bad PR in two years. Imagine "X got lost and died two days after his apple(tm) subscription expired".
- president 4y agoThis could be mitigated by not blocking access to the feature after the 2 years and charging for each use.
- adrianmonk 4y agoThey could just let you use it and charge you a one-time fee. And don't require the payment to go through before unlocking the feature, obviously. There will be some people who you can never collect payment from, but not that many.
- jmbwell 4y agoSet backcountry search and rescue aside for a second. Seems to me this is for ordinary people doing ordinary things outside cell range, and finding they need help. A family member has a heart attack. A collision with a moose. Who knows what. Less “should’ve brought water and a jacket” and more “we’ve been on route 9 for two hours, a moment ago everything was fine, now he’s not breathing, we have no bars, and we have no idea where the nearest hospital is.” Besides, even if this feature only saves a single life, seems worth it to me.
- swores 4y ago> Besides, even if this feature only saves a single life, seems worth it to me. Not that I think it will only save a single life, but if that really were the full extent of its benefit that of course it wouldn't be worth it - think of the millions Apple have spent on R&D plus the (presumably tiny but it adds up when selling millions of devices) extra cost per device - there are many ways that money could have been spent as a PR move by Apple to save thousands if not millions of lives.
- dpkirchner 4y agoThis seems somewhat contrarian -- what changes can Apple make to their iPhones that could save millions of lives?
- swores 4y agoThat doesn't seem relevant to the question of whether it's worth spending a huge amount of money on saving a single life? When I talked about spending money as a PR move I meant non-product related, the way companies donate to charities, or do charitable research, or hell they could've even invested in for-profit health startups that would have a higher expectation than saving a single life.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoApple is a profit-seeking company that builds tech products. Building products that saves lives will increase sales, because people want to be safe, thus increasing profits. How does donating to charity increase profits? It doesn't, so why would Apple spend money there? Apple is not in the business of saving lives, they're in the business of building tech products. If those tech products can also save lives, that's the most life-saving we can expect from a profit-seeking company that builds tech products. I don't understand why you're expecting Apple to save lives at a loss.
- gz5 4y ago>Satellites move rapidly, have low bandwidth, and are located thousands of miles away from Earth, so it can take a few minutes for even short messages to get through. Low orbit satellites can be about 500 kilometers / 300 miles so would be the logical next step?
- samcat116 4y agoYes which is why you're seeing LEO constelations now. But most previous ones were in GEO which is much farther away.
- COGlory 4y agoI was just on the ground coordinating with 4 friends that got buried in 5+ foot of unexpected snow in the mountains (forecast said 1"-2" when they went up) for the rifle opener in Montana. I wound up getting sick so I stayed home (hilariously I was the only one who got an elk) but I sent them up with my InReach. All I can say is THANK GOD that I did, because it turned into over a week long effort to get them out. Two decided to walk out and were able to text me a nav point that I was able to meet them at (took all day to get there because of the snow and mud, but I made it and was able to pick them up). The other two stayed up there, and we sent probably 100 texts back and forth coordinating what turned into like 3 solid days of fighting to get up there with snowcats and get them back down. Multiple situational changes that we would have been hosed without. In the end, I spent like $80 on texts, but it was money well spent. I think it's great for people to have SOS built into their iPhone, but there needs to be a "use it now, pay later" or no one is going to activate it and actually have it available when they need it. The other half of the equation is that you really need to be able to send texts. The SOS button is very expensive. Extremely expensive. That will keep a lot of people from using it. (Yes insurance exists, but hardly anyone has it). Being able to text your friends for help is substantially more useful. Being stuck on a backroad with no service, 5, 10, 20 miles from where anyone can be expected to drive by is a far more common scenario than breaking your leg at the top of a mountain and needing to be evacuated.
- MarkMarine 4y agoFor Emergency services there is no “activate and pay later” because you don’t need to activate, and you don’t need to pay. If you have an iPhone 14 it’s supposed to just work if you’re calling 911.
- JadeNB 4y ago> For Emergency services there is no “activate and pay later” because you don’t need to activate, and you don’t need to pay. If you have an iPhone 14 it’s supposed to just work if you’re calling 911. This is nothing special about the iPhone or the version; every cell phone is supposed to put through calls to 911: > All wireless phones, even those that are not subscribed to or supported by a specific carrier, can call 911. https://www.911.gov/calling-911/frequently-asked-questions/ https://www.911.gov/calling-911/frequently-asked-questions/
- user3939382 4y agoWait, what? iPhones are sat phones?? It has the antenna for that?? Since when? The GPS is a passive receive. I skimmed the article and didn't see, how on Earth (lol) does this work? Sat antennas are huge. Maybe these search and rescue SOS beacons have their own signal?
- MarkMarine 4y agoThey got around the antenna issue by using a really poor antenna that requires the user to aim the phone at a passing satellite, plus a pretty cool UI to help you do that.
- MBCook 4y agoNew this year. The phone basically guides you to point it at the satellite (and turn as necessary), which is why it doesn’t need a big antenna. It’s not as good as a Garmin or some such, but you have it with you.
- stagger87 4y agoYou have to point the phone at the sky for long periods of time AND track the sat position in the sky while you do it. It's probably some long spread spectrum approach (lots of processing gain), as well as I'm sure a bunch of other cool tricks/techniques.
- user3939382 4y agoThere are obviously people out there that are deep experts on radio, signals, propagation, antennas, etc. That's not me, but I know enough about it to appreciate that this is completely amazing.
- cookingmyserver 4y agoDoes anyone know how they track the position of the communication satellites? I assume they use GPS for the users position, the gyro and accelerometer for device orientation, and then periodically load and update the LEO sat paths on the device when they are connected. Or is the antenna able to estimate LEO position via a signal the LEO sats sends out?
- homero 4y agoWhat network are they using exactly
- totalZero 4y agoI'm pretty sure it's Globalstar. https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-picks-globalstar-satellite-service-iphone-14-series-2022-09-07/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-picks-globalstar-sa...
- balozi 4y agoPredictions of where this tech goes from here: shall the satellite SOS infrastructure be adapted into full-blown satellite-based wireless service for all mobile devices? I am thinking global 5G capabilities off satellites, untethered from domestic wireless network carriers. Sort of like how doctors got pager service in 1950 progressed into the smartphones we have today.
- rapsey 4y agoEventually absolutely yes.
- Scoundreller 4y agoI’m hoping for some low bit rate stuff. I suspect coordinating the uplink might be difficult to squeeze a lot of data through, but downlink could have a linear stream of repeating data (weather, news) that you could get an update on at any time by pointing your phone the right way, especially if you can draw an arc that follows the satellite going past by. And that wouldn’t chew battery power either. My bandwidth needs are extremely minimal outside of work/home, so with a tiny bit of bandwidth, some texting and news updates could make it possible to live a wireless-subscription free life. Something like othernet: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Othernet https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Othernet
- rootusrootus 4y agoIsn't that exactly what AST is attempting with their BlueWalker satellite and the planned "bluebird" network?
- alach11 4y agoThis must have been such an exciting feature to develop. It's great to be able to work on something very likely to save lives in the near future. And clearly a lot of love was put into the UX of the product.
- alach11 4y ago> The service will be included for free for two years starting at the time of activation of a new iPhone 14, iPhone 14 Plus, iPhone 14 Pro, and iPhone 14 Pro Max. Interesting to see the hidden in the fine print at the end. Will they be selling a subscription to the service?
- qubex 4y agoAs remarked by others this is likely so they can kill it off in the near future (in a couple of years) if it is an unmitigated disaster. It’s highly unlikely they’ll make it into a subscription service because the optics could be so bad (“man dies of exposure after Apple declines credit card and disconnects satellite emergency service”).
- ryeights 4y ago>“Some of the most popular places to travel are off the beaten path” I think this would imply the path is very well beaten.
- knodi123 4y agoNo one goes there anymore because it's too crowded.
- matt-attack 4y agoToo true Yogi.
- Hippocrates 4y agoApple is building up a nice portfolio of life-saving features. Currently we have fall detection, a-fib detection, crash detection, satellite communication. These are all solid value-adds and differentiators from the competition. I'm not sure if they amount to a strong selling point for _everyone_ yet, but I'm sure that's where Apple is headed. I am extremely bullish on Apple's ability to measure health signals in the next 5-10 years, that when fed to AI, will be able to detect health issues long in advance. This may take more sensors, more research, more AI development, but we're definitely headed there. At some point iPhone and Apple Watch will probably be marketed as the devices you need if you don't wish to die early.
- MBCook 4y agoTBF Google had crash detection first, by a few years. But I agree. If they can add a cheap part (better accelerometer) or re-use an existing one (pulse detection for a-fib) and provide really great possible benefits for some people? Sounds great.
- blablabla123 4y agoYeah I was planning to buy no more Apple products but they do something really right with the Watch and the iPhone. If you've ever been in a situation where you need help it turns out it's on the practical side not so easy
- tyingq 4y ago>At some point iPhone and Apple Watch will probably be marketed as the devices you need if you don't wish to die early. Or you'll have to turn over your data to get the reasonable health insurance rates and not fall in the risky rate bucket.
- yurishimo 4y agoGod forbid the US become a civilized nation and offer a real competitive national healthcare options. I live in one of the more expensive European nations when it comes to healthcare. €100~/mo with a €400~ deductible per year. Worst case scenario, I spend €1600/yr on healthcare.
- Hippocrates 4y agoI've had a few situations skiing at resorts where I was just a bit off-piste and found myself struggling through waist-deep powder. In the dense trees and snow it can be very difficult to see and hear even a small distance away. Add an injury to the mix and it's trouble. I would never consider buying a standalone satellite communicator device for this but having one on my phone is an awesome value add for me. As someone else said "The best camera is the one you have with you". Same is true for satellite communicators.
- taylorbuley 4y agoI was digging up and replacing a piece of my well-line, in the dark because that's always when my well line breaks, and my phone accidentally called the police through what must have been some serious jostling. The dispatch seemed understanding, and used the opportunity to verify that my phone connectivity was coming from where it said I was. Later that night, two sheriffs show up around midnight to make sure that everything was OK. It was the first time that I felt like my personal technology was really doing its own thing without me.
- m463 4y agoApple's phone app has one HUGE design failure: touching anything in the app will dial a number immediately. I have accidentally called back phone spammers. It made elderly parents scared to use their phone. I've had many many friends butt-dial me. There should absolutely be an option that is on, or can be enabled: confirm before calling. In the case of emergency calling, they should figure out how to confirm before calling. I'm sure apple has some scenario in mind where it has to be the way it is now, but I think there should be a way. At a minimum, opting into the current behavior should train the user how calls are initiated and what options are available.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> Apple's phone app has one HUGE design failure: touching anything in the app will dial a number immediately Agreed 100%. I hate that I have to be super careful and really think through each time I press something to make sure it's not going to be a shortcut that immediately dials a phone number. I too have called spammers back.
- fortuna86 4y agoGreat technology. Roll it out to more phones than just your latest model.
- fckgw 4y agoHow? Push out an OTA update that installs an entirely new cellular modem with satellite communication frequencies?
- fortuna86 4y agoMost smartphones have GPS built in, are you telling me it was impossible to utilize existing hardware for this feature? Or was it a deliberate decision. Ok, perhaps not phone calls or text. What about a beacon feature?
- dagmx 4y agoHow? I don’t think you quite understand how this works or GPS for that matter. GPS is unidirectional. Your phone isn’t communicating back to the satellite.
- fortuna86 4y agoadmittedly I don't, but can't a GPS system can tell you where you are, why can't GPS systems know where each phone is and create an emergency system from that ?
- error503 4y agoGPS is receive only, the phone doesn't talk to the satellites, which just broadcast their signal to everyone. There is certainly a new radio (& ancillary equipment & antenna) in the latest model to support this feature.
- fortuna86 4y agoAny phone can still use Maps based on GPS, meaning any phone can send their location via GPS. Why not make an emergency beacon feature with this ?
- dang 4y agoOngoing related thread: Apple’s satellite emergency SOS feature: A review and deep-dive explainer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33611586 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33611586 - Nov 2022 (14 comments)
- Kairinz 4y agoLiterally just got back from a road trip in southern Greece where I had reception almost half of the time spent driving. Didn't see a single car for over 2 hours of driving. Car had a clutch issue, but things worked out. Can actually see how this becomes useful.
- jrnichols 4y agoI'm a Paramedic in Northern California and am VERY happy about this feature. Even in some of our SF Bay Area counties, we have a lot of windy mountain roads with no cell service at all. Our portable radios don't even work up in the hills. To have an iPhone be able to send GPS location to the public safety access point is fabulous. Our dispatchers can at least drop a pin on a map and we can route to that location ourselves. This already happens in a lot of cases but the caller has cell service. We've been on multiple incidents up in the hills where people have reported that they had to drive several miles down the mountain before they were able to get any reception to make a 911 call. This will save us a lot of time, and it will save lives. This is a game changing feature.
- fragmede 4y ago> Even in some of our SF Bay Area counties Even? no (and you'd probably know better than me) but as a fellow bay area person, there are tons and tons and tons of roads and places that aren't covered by cell service, just go into the mountains a little bit. and then you also have to ask which cell carrier everybody has. there's a real digital divide once you get out of the city and the towns that surround it
- whimsicalism 4y ago> and then you also have to ask which cell carrier everybody has Not for emergency services you don't.
- fragmede 4y agoAh you're right. I was still thinking back in the GSM vs CDMA days where AT&T phones physically couldn't talk to Verizon towers (and vice versa) so 911 couldn't work either.
- jrnichols 4y agoright, that's pretty much what I said. We have A LOT of space that has no cell reception at all. We don't have to ask about which carrier, though. That information will come through automatically along with the subscriber's information. Even a cell phone with no active plan can still dial 911, regardless of carrier or model.
- almog 4y agoI think it's great for phones to include to have some of the functionality of a SEND (Satellite Emergency Notification Device) front-country situations where cell service is unavailable. These are some of the reasons why I wouldn't use it as a replacement for an ad-hoc SEND or PLB (which I use for long distance hiking): 1. Short wave length (~2.4GHz iPhone < 1.6GHz SEND < 406MHz PLB). Shorter wave length are less affected from terrain obstructions. 2. UX - to send an emergency signal using iPhone, due to its shorter wave length, one has to point to the approximate LEO satellite position. Last time I searched on how it would look, it seemed that an on-screen instruction would guide the user where to point the phone, I'm not sure if there there is any accessibility mode that would use voice to do that if for example the screen is broken (or the user cannot see). If the screen is broken, would the user even be able to activate the SOS feature? Using voice? What if you're caught in a super noisy wind storm or the mic is broken? Perhaps future models will have a physical trigger to activate it. 2. Durability - other than PLB/SEND being much more durable when it comes to impact and water damage, the battery itself, at least with PLB is rated up to -40. A phone battery starts to become unreliable at +30f. 3. Latency and reliability: iPhone I believe, due to its short wavelength only transmit to LEO satellite, where as PLBs does LEO, GEO and MEO, which means lower latency in some cases, especially when the sky is obstructed by terrain and even more so if you're unlucky to be in an east-west canyon that doesn't follow a LEO satellite orbit, theoretically at least you have a better chance with GEO satellite. Also, in places such as canyons where GPS fix is unreliable, COSPAS-SARSAT MEO and LEO satellite that serve PLBs will use Doppler location approximation. Not sure if Iridium LEO satellite that serve iPhone do that.
- davidw 4y agoIt's been a while since there's been a phone feature that I've really wanted. I spend a lot of time mountain biking outside of cell range and this would be a nice feature to have. Hope it makes its way to Android soon.
- kawfey 4y agoAs a ham radio evangelist, I'm slightly sad that our radio service has become a bit more irrelevant as a backcountry backup or emergency comms solution, thanks to this, the SPOT/inreach messager, and general LEO satellite broadband internet access, but more happy that it's here, since these systems are FAR more accessible, reliable, and easy to use for SOS or way-off-grid general communications. Ham radio still has it's place for first-response communications relief and health & welfare checks, and search-and-rescue (generally where other radio or internet systems are offline, aren't installed, or aren't reliable) as well as just being a fun hobby.
- kube-system 4y agoHam's greatest advantage is also its greatest weakness: being strictly non-commercial.
- madrox 4y agoThese are the features that, in my opinion, should drive the next generation of innovation. We don't need VR or blockchain as much as we need to go the last mile on the promise to connect everyone everywhere to give them the services they need to raise quality of life.
- monkeydust 4y agoHave to agree. As a hardened Android user it is this type of feature that would make me consider an iPhone
- JTbane 4y agoCould this result in false alarms, as people call for help accidentally or in non emergencies? I know PLBs in aviation have a very high false alarm rate (98%).
- rootusrootus 4y agoYou can't use the service without first dialing 911. Hopefully that will convey to most users the gravity of what they're doing.
- jabagonuts 4y agoFor those wondering... > The service will be included for free for two years starting at the time of activation of a new iPhone 14, iPhone 14 Plus, iPhone 14 Pro, and iPhone 14 Pro Max. ^4 > ^4. Users who purchased an iPhone 14 model before the availability date of Emergency SOS via satellite will receive two years of the service free starting from the service availability date.
- la64710 4y agoFTA “ Apple designed and built custom components and software that allow iPhone 14 to connect to a satellite’s unique frequencies without a bulky antenna.” Quite mind blowing IMHO.
- bookofjoe 4y agoI think Garmin's VERY afraid of this camel's nose under its heretofore exclusive tent.
- lou1306 4y agoUh, care to elaborate? I thought Garmin specialized in GPS and similar "passive" satellite-based tech, not actual comms? Edit: nvm, just googled and found out about the Inreach thing.
- rootusrootus 4y agoAnd not only this, but in the fitness watch arena too.
- thwayunion 4y agoCan this replace an inReach yet?
- kornhole 4y agoPerhaps the same places that rent out bear cans can offer rental Iphones for those of us who normally only carry anonymous phones with burner SIMs.
- joshmn 4y agoI was in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area the first week September on a solo trip. It was my third trip of the year. I was hoping to get 300 miles of paddling in for the summer. I have paddled thousands of miles over the years, all across the BWCA. It was Tuesday, my last day before I had to get back to the real world, and I was pretty sore. I decided on a day trip: I got up before the moon set, and I was hoping to be out until it rose again. On this loop, I took a less-traveled route on what would be my return-half. There are many of these less-traveled routes, just as there are few people in the BWCA — that's part of the reason why you go to the BWCA. I was in good spirits, amazed by the beauty of the water and the streams and the sounds. Instead of turning to head to Agnes I turned to head back through Ramshead. I hadn't done Ramshead before and it had some cute islands on my map I wanted to check out. The river was very low. So low in fact, I had to walk in the first half-mile or so of the day. This meant that the usual route to get to the portage between where I was and where I needed to be wasn't so clear. I looked at three maps and decided it must be on the other side of the wild rice patch. I was certain I would only have to push through a hundred yards or so. A hundred yards became a thousand, which became a beaver dam I would have to carry over. I swung my leg over the side of the canoe to cross onto what I thought was a sturdy dam-y thing. No. I was now in 1.2 meters of mud, and I am only 1.5 meters tall. It's also disgusting. I put my other leg in to try to get my other leg out, and all is fine, my leg is dislodged. But gone is my shoe. Fuck. I bravely stick my arm into the mud as deep as I can and I'm blindly feeling around for a shoe. Every stick I touch I think is a bone — or at least, I hope they were sticks. No shoe. At this point, I am unhappy, and a little irritated. Everything was going way too fine my entire summer until this. After about 30 minutes of trying, I decide the shoe will be left for the next ice burg, whenever that may be. I take an irritable breath of frustration and anger and decide I have to continue onward anyway. I find a small beaver pond — no more than an acre large at this point — at what looks like would be the portage. There seems to be a dried creek bed to my east, and my maps show that the landing is near, but I can't seem to find it the path. I climb atop a large river rock to try to get a better view. I still can't see where I need to go, but I do see some annoyed river otters, a beaver, and a bear in the distance. What I'd give to be a bear at this point: a bear who didn't have a neurological disposition to avoiding, at all costs, textures. I decided to try pushing through more wild rice along the south-end of this small beaver pond. Ah, good choice joshmn: the portage. I dismount, take another sigh of angst due to my shoe situation, and march through. I thought this portage was just 100 rods. It must have been pushing 300, and it was not fun. Along the way were the remnants of a grouse who seemed to have made an enemy of a wolf. Grouse and I have a long-standing connection through my mother, and I treat them as a symbol in these parts. Normally good, if not great symbols. Seeing one in this condition, in these circumstances, was far too fitting. I got through to the other side physically unscathed but emotionally torn. There were beautiful evergreen trees towered above me and it smelled like pine. If I had my shoe, I’d love this, but at this point, I wanted my bed. I put in the creek where I hoped to wash some of the mud off my body and my canoe. No chance: this creek had the most-ripe algae bloom I had seen in years. And it was only going to get worse. I took the creek through to Ramshead, but before I got there I had to carry over a bunch of river rocks due to the water level. The noise of me and my canoe scared the birds that were resting on the other side: cranes, ducks, mallards, geese, and more. I saw turtles dive into the water. Normally, I’d admire the turtles. Now, I’m just irritated. I cross the lake, a 500-some acre lake, but it must get no deeper than ten feet — I see plenty of rocks, and the algae indicates that the lake doesn’t get cold enough to kill it off. I’m on the other side, where the portage should be. It’s 1PM, I should be at the landing by 3:30PM. And the portage isn’t where the portage must be. I blame the water level and check my maps. Normally, I’d get out and walk the shore and into the woods to find it, but with one shoe I wasn’t as brave as I normally was. I was also annoyed, tired, frustrated, and anxious, so I was hoping for an easy way out in the wilderness — something that doesn’t happen. I get out where the portage is on my map, load up, and walk 200 feet in the direction of the portage on my map. I can’t seem to find any semblance of a portage. I turn around, put in, and decide it must be on the other side of this little peninsula I’m on. Nope. It’s 4PM, I’m still on this shore, and I’m feeling like Tom Hanks; my canoe Wilson. My phone has no service, and it’s at 20% due to the pictures I was taking. I give my whistle a blow, hoping that someone will whistle back. No. 30 minutes passes, another SOS on my whistle. Nothing. God dammit. I started mentally preparing to spend the night. On every other day trip, I pack prepared — I pack for the worst. This time, I packed light for some reason, and I left my fire-making stuff in the car, along with my usual bag of high-protein snacks. It’s 5PM. I have memorized every inch of this shore and still no luck. Another whistle, another request timeout. At this point I started trying to make sense of what status code I was. 404 would be the instinctual one, same with 410; 412 made sense, but maybe 416. I was losing it. Sun sets at 7:30PM. It’s now 6. I thought about going back the way I came, but even then I’d be back at midnight — not great, but at least I know the route. I had tried calling everyone in my contacts to see if they could help me figure out where to go, but I had no service and no calls were connecting. I say fuck it and decide to call 911 on my phone. A minute passes. “911, what’s your emergency?” “Sorry, what?” “Yes, 911, what’s your emergency?” “Ugh okay so I’m actually in the boundary waters right now and I’m lost and I can’t get out. This is really demoralizing, I have paddled thousands of miles and I’m just not able to figure out where to go. Can you help me?” “I can see your approximate location on Ramshead. Stay there and I’ll get search and rescue out there as soon as possible. Call me back in 30 minutes and ask for Tom.” “Okay.” Click. I ask myself what the hell just happened. I find a rock to perch on as the sun starts to fade behind the trees. It’s very pretty, though I’m exhausted. I try to think what do I do for the next 6 hours until search and rescue gets here: after all, they have to go in the way I came, which is fine… but they’d have stuff to spend the night at least. I just had the shirt on my back, an empty Hydroflask, a dead phone, and the crust from my sandwich. I ate the crust. It’s 7PM and I call Tom back again for an update on the location of the rescue squad. As much as I wanted to ask him how the hell he connected to me, I didn’t. He said that they were en route. I didn’t know what that meant, and he didn’t know what that meant either. I hang up. A duck lands 15 feet away. Must be nice to be able to fly. I hear a float plane flying overhead. “No way,” I say to myself. They flew across the lake. Bah Humbug. Then it comes back and starts circling me. They land at 7:20PM. Sun sets at 7:35PM. We needed to get out of there with some daylight otherwise we won’t be able to see the rocks below. They instruct me to paddle over, I do, we ditch the canoe, and at 7:41PM we’re in the air. Fuck. They flew me to Lake Vermillion, some 65 miles away from my car. We’re chatting on the radio: “Are you okay?” “Physically yes.” “Your ego?” “Fucking shattered, man.” “It’s okay.” “So, how much do I owe you guys for this trip and do you take insurance?” “It’s a volunteer thing, you’re fine.” We landed on Lake Vermillion. I was just there a few days before visiting a friend. My phone had died. One of the guys in the rescue squad offered to drive me to my car — yes, 65 miles away. I tried saying no, he wouldn’t let me. We’re chatting on the way there. His son is a software engineer for LinkedIn. His daughter is high-up in some marketing company in Chicago. He retired from FEMA a few years ago and wanted to stay active. He was leaving for Florida at the end of the month for the winter. I got home at 11PM that night. I plugged in my phone to charge and jumped in the shower to rinse myself off. I was gross, even by BWCA standards. In the shower I tried to figure out how much the plane ride should have if it was billed to my insurance — I figured that would be my donation to the volunteer org that picked me up. When I got out of the shower I opened up HackerNews to see what I missed that day — after all, it was Apple’s day. The top post is about the satellite tech in their new phones.
- modeless 4y agoI'm surprised there isn't much discussion here about the similar capability announced by SpaceX and T-Mobile (first of many carrier partners) earlier this year. It will not be exclusive to emergencies, and will work with unmodified existing phones, not requiring you to hold the phone a special way, other than generally having a decent view of the sky. Even if SpaceX is delayed, there are competitors working on similar services, so it seems like this special hardware won't be necessary a few years from now.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> I'm surprised there isn't much discussion here about the similar capability announced by SpaceX and T-Mobile Because the Starlink satellites in question don't exist yet, and it's Elon Musk making claims about existing handsets working -- he has a spotty record when it comes to making accurate announcements. I enthusiastically look forward to more capability in this space. But I doubt very much that Apple is introducing limitations unnecessarily. Claiming that existing cell phones will be able to reach up to a satellite, even in LEO, is such a large claim that it needs someone more trustworthy than Elon Musk to explain how it works.
- modeless 4y agoDistrusting a whole technology simply because you happened to hear about it first from Elon Musk is pretty silly IMO. Anyway, there's nothing impossible about it. AST Spacemobile has already demonstrated a satellite to ground link with regular cell phone hardware on one end (the space end, since it's easier to launch a phone than a giant phased array antenna, but they also did just launch a giant phased array and will demonstrate that in the next few weeks). The technology works. And T-Mobile obviously believes that too. You don't have to take Elon Musk's word for it. Apple isn't introducing unnecessary limitations. They launched the best thing that's possible today. But what I'm saying is that it's very likely that in just a few years it will be essentially obsolete.
- rootusrootus 4y agoWhere did I say I distrusted anything based merely on Elon Musk saying it? I gave a few reasons why what he claimed should be taken with a huge grain of salt. His own history is a pretty strong recommendation in that regard. Comparing BlueWalker to Starlink v2 makes no sense, unless you think SpaceX is going to be putting that huge phased array on every v2 satellite they put in the sky? It's a different technology entirely. Now, maybe Elon was hinting at an impending acquisition? :). That would certainly be on character for him.
- jiggawatts 4y agoIt's a bit sad that there's no mention of support for this feature anywhere outside of EU & US. The irony is that this feature is especially useless in Europe, which is so built up that it's a challenge to find a location that isn't covered by mobile networks, or within walking distance of civilization. Meanwhile in Australia you can find yourself 100 km from the next nearest human by accident. My coworker for example went driving in north Queensland and got his 4WD stuck in mud. That can be a life & death situation in a place like that, but just an inconvenience in most of Europe. Even if Apple can't get the emergency services integration organised in every nation, the "send my location via satellite" feature would still be useful. That way you could get your friends or relatives to organise help on your behalf.
- ineedasername 4y agoPeople are referencing wilderness scenarios here— which absolutely a great use case— but it’s more than that. Not long ago I drove a long distance along plain old US interstates. With about 400 miles in between two major cities there were a few stretches of 5-10 miles where I didn’t have cell service, sometimes 25-40 miles in between local town exits or gas stations. Had I not scouted the routes ahead of time, I would have had no idea where to go or which direction to walk if there was a problem, much less an emergency like crashing where I couldn’t walk. There are still large gaps in coverage as large as not-walkable-in-a-day in what you’d think are at least minimally developed areas. And they are minimally developed, but you’ll have no idea of what direction that developed portion is if you’re stuck without cell service or an actual physical map. No one should go on any long car trip letting GPS guide the way without scouting the route a bit ahead of time to know what’s nearby in sparse areas. Apple is filling that “oh f$ck” gap a bit. Nice feature.
- aendruk 4y ago> When users want to reassure friends and family of their whereabouts while traveling off the grid, they can open the Find My app and share their location via satellite. Everyone else in my family uses Android. No way to expose this information to them?
- threeseed 4y agoFind My available on the iCloud website. Maybe you can create an account for them and add them as a Family Member.
- jojobas 4y agoI hope this doesn't become SAR's "eternal September".
- eternityforest 4y agoWhen I first saw this I thought I would wait till it comes to Android before I upgrade my phone(Which is a bit past the security update period already) but if I ever do go on any serious trips outside cell range, I'll probably want a real satellite messenger anyway. I'm really glad this exists though, a lot of people will be much safer when everyone has this.
- diguejdudjxu 4y agoHi guys how are today 10000 people are going to object our 7 hell
- FounderBurr 4y agoI’m wondering how low it will take this service to be completely overwhelmed by non emergency use. People already call 911 all day for things that aren’t true emergencies… how will this service cope with that?
- s3p 4y agoDoesn't matter IMO. Globalstar was barely afloat in revenues of <$100m annually before the deal, now they've already made triple that. The investments to their satellite network will likely move proportionally to the load that Apple users draw from it. Again, they weren't a highly successful business to begin with, so the concern of Apple users hogging bandwidth from non-Apple users is slim.
- giggyhack 4y agoThis depends on the state where the rescue happens. In Colorado, rescue is free in ask cases except for isolated cases of extreme negligence.
- throwaway892238 4y agoHello, I'm a moron! I once got myself trapped, alone, in a canyon, at night, with no gear, and couldn't get out. It was dumb luck that I didn't go deeper down in the canyon; I was just close enough to the top-out that I had 1 bar of signal sometimes. I was able to text and call emergency services and send my lat/lon. Finally a local sheriff was able to find me. He threw me down some tiny poly cordage, and I was able to claw my way up a crack. If I hadn't had that bit of cell signal, I could have been stranded for days (or forever?), or drowned in a flash flood. In that moment, I don't care how much it costs me, I'm going to take any emergency service option I can get. I don't have an iPhone, but I would consider getting one now. Aside from that, I live in upstate NY, and probably 85% of the land around here has no cell service. If you can't make it to someone's house who has a land line, this is probably the best option to get ahold of emergency services.
- bookofjoe 4y agoI recall when Apple announced this feature many commenters here scoffed, saying it was impossible without an external antenna. I don't see those comments here now.
- bookofjoe 4y agoT-Mobile/Starlink announced its vaporware just before Apple unveiled its actual product: https://techcrunch.com/2022/08/25/t-mobile-phones-will-connect-to-starlink-for-free-starting-next-year/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/08/25/t-mobile-phones-will-conne... Now people are using Apple's while "real soon now" = next year for T-Mobile/Starlink