17 ms·
Apple Execs on iMessage for Android (2013)
- sfifs 4y agoAnd this decision gave them the US mobile market (very profitable) but basically lost them the messaging and ancillary commercial services enabled by messaging market in the rest of the world.
- puttycat 4y agoYep. It's interesting how uniform the US messaging mesh is (practically everyone on iMessage). An average American's chance of having Whatsapp installed on their phone is a function of how likely they are to have contacts from abroad.
- glandium 4y agoIf they have contacts in East Asia, they won't have Whatsapp either.
- rootsudo 4y agoChina, no. Wechat. Japan, no. Line. S. Korea, no - Kakaotalk. South East Asia: Whatsapp, yes. It is interesting.
- gcanyon 4y agoThailand: Line.
- tuankiet65 4y agoSEA is a bit more diverse than just Whatsapp. Vietnam: Facebook Messenger, Zalo (home grown IM), Viber.
- alephnerd 4y agoVietnam: Zalo or FB Messenger, not WhatsApp
- spacehunt 4y agoExcept for Hong Kong, where most people have Whatsapp + at least one of Telegram, Signal, Line, Wechat.
- pjmlp 4y agoAnd on the Balkans region most likely will be Viber.
- int_19h 4y agoThe actual market share for Apple in US mobile market is around 50%, so even if every single one of those use iMessage exclusively, there are still plenty of people locked out of it. If you don't have any in your social circles, that's probably due to the nature of those circles.
- dagmx 4y ago~50% overall but something like 87% for teens. That discrepancy in numbers is really going to be interesting within a generation or two.
- kweingar 4y ago> within a generation or two Not sure I agree. A generation or two is eons in tech. In that timeframe there will likely be another massive paradigm shift that totally washes away today’s thinking about phones, communication, etc.
- dagmx 4y agoThat’s assuming however that the paradigm shifts are sudden or that Apple can’t adapt. Their existing market dominance among teens positions them very strongly to keep brand loyalty into whatever paradigms come next.
- Spivak 4y agoEveryone makes this mistake. Something being popular with young people is no guarantee it will remain popular as they grow up. The social pressures that lead teens to want iPhones drop off over time.
- dagmx 4y agoNobody said there was a guarantee it would stick to the same percentages as they grow, but brand loyalty is definitely a thing for people that develops in their formative years. It’s also not just “social pressures to use iPhones” but the fact that parents can: * give them hand me downs due to longer device lifespans * the ability to get them more easily serviced when their kid breaks something by going to the Apple Store * the ability to more easily buy a decent midrange device on a student discount * the ability to communicate more easily themselves using iMessage * appealing to privacy and safety in Apple marketing People over index on social pressure from other teens. There’s lots of reasons teens get devices and many come from parental choices. Maybe the percentages will vary as they grow but any company worth their salt is paying attention to the possibly high rate of market drop off that they’ll experience
- Telemakhos 4y agoBoth are American companies. Whatsapp is Meta (Facebook), and iMessage (actually now Messages) is Apple. If you care about security, the question is which is more likely to comply with the US government's requests for information: Meta or Apple. If you don't, the question is price point, ignoring the question of which is more likely to make your data marketable. That is likely Meta, so we could rephrase this as, "Do you care to pay more for Apple's privacy, or is it okay for Meta to sell your messages to anyone willing to pay?"
- sfifs 4y agoThere's Line, Kakao Talk, Viber, WeChat, SnapChat... all very popular in different countries & with different demographics. WeChat is of course the most sophisticated in terms of ecosystem beyond just messaging. None of these may have arisen or become so popular if Apple & Android had created interop.
- nine_k 4y agoI wonder how Telegram was not mentioned in the thread so far.
- batiudrami 4y agoTelegram is orders of magnitude smaller than any of the those listed above, except maybe a Viber (I’m not sure; it seems to have some use in SEA countries).
- fomine3 4y agoIs Snapchat used like them among every generation?
- Un1corn 4y agoAs always, it's important to remember that people choice of messaging depends on network effect more than anything else. But even without it, they are both E2E encrypted. Of course you could ship new code that send the messages unencrypted but it would be extremely risky for Meta and the government, depending on the target
- v8xi 4y agoAs the world reaches peak device, they'll probably open up and pursue some of these other markets, too
- gcanyon 4y agoThey have roughly half the US market, and no one has the world market. This decision seems unlikely to have had the ability to change that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mike_d 4y agoI saw a humorous exchange at a social event: Someone is texting another person to exchange phone numbers and a green bubble appears. "Is it not working or are you on Android?" In that moment I understood the genius of not just shipping an iMessage for Android app. Not having an iPhone is perceived as a failure state.
- adlpz 4y agoIn the US. In continental Europe I've seen just the opposite. In many social contexts having an iPhone is associated with either being a mindless fanboy, a basic trend-following drone or, in general, bad with money. As in "why would anyone overpay for a phone that does just the same as an Android?". It's a very curious phenomenon.
- mike_d 4y agoThe US is an absolutely huge win - get the valuable customers and leave the rest for Android. For comparison the 2021 advertising spend in the US was greater than that of the next 10 countries combined.
- eckza 4y agoWhat’s fascinating to me is that this discourse has the tone and pacing of literally any HN conversation. Take from that what you will.
- 63 4y agoI was thinking similarly. The tone is incredibly casual considering the implications of the decision on both the company and society at large. There are basic spelling and grammar errors for goodness sake. I'm not criticizing, I just find that intensely interesting.
- dev_tty01 4y agoThe rest of the conversation almost certainly happened in person. These emails were just getting out some initial thoughts. Happens all the time. Also, notice that Tim Cook wasn't in the email conversation.
- 63 4y agoHe was cc'd. You can see in one of the screenshots in the second tweet in the thread.
- csomar 4y agoThe people at the top are not Gods. They are regular people, just like you and me; or more just like HN since they are working in Tech.
- Maursault 4y agoI thought most of it was a little surreal to converse about innovating that way, as though innovation was specific. No one here would ever say, "what we have to do as HN members is innovate. Once we do that, we can make our comments better and draw in more users from Slashdot." I thought the whole thing was fake until I got to the end and saw what Internal Tech Emails was. Then I just thought it was all pretty phoney. That isn't how ordinary people converse. I'd almost think they can walk without their feet ever touching the ground.
- dereg 4y agoFederighi and Schiller nailed it. With the benefit of hindsight, it’s clear that Google would have bungled a WhatsApp acquisition. I think it’s refreshing to see that Fed & Phil had in mind a clear path to value with their existing hardware+software strategy, rather than rushing to the growth and market share at-all-costs strategy popular at the time. It’s so easy to point to Federighi’s email and scream “monopolist”! But Apple was in no way close to commanding a monopoly in the mobile market back then.
- db1234 4y ago>it’s clear that Google would have bungled a WhatsApp acquisition Google Meet Google Meet (Original) Google Meet (Acquired)
- rjzzleep 4y agoThe whole thing is a bit mind boggling to me. Everyone I knew that had gmail was also actively using hangouts. How they could screw that up is beyond me. It even had voip integration. All they needed to do was polish the app. They announced the shutdown of hangouts and the removal of google fi integration and despite the uproar they doubled down on it. Genuine question to people here. Why ? They keep claiming that they're a data driven company. What data are these decisions based on?
- natch 4y agoMy theory is that Googlers feel extra special and entitled and it makes them lazy. And products just languish as a result. The theory isn’t anything deep, but it seems to fit the facts.
- simonh 4y agoIt would be a poor explanation if it didn’t fit the facts. When faced with a body “the butler did it” is an explanation, but in the absence of actual evidence or reasoning to support it, it’s not a compelling case.
- 4y ago
- erikpukinskis 4y agoIt bothers me that they straight up lied to us about this. They said in the iMessage announcement that it’d be an open protocol. Really duplicitous. That and the way they remove you from group chats if you ever try to turn off iMessage makes the whole thing feel like a dark pattern to me. Apple really has us hostage as iMessage users. I’m generally a big Apple fan but iMessage feels like abuse to me.
- dev_tty01 4y ago>They said in the iMessage announcement that it’d be an open protocol. Do you have a reference for this? At the Facetime announcement, Jobs said that would be an open protocol. Then they ended up in a big patent suit over Facetime and it didn't happen. Not sure how much the suit influenced the decision, but for whatever reason the Facetime protocol was never opened up. I don't remember a similar announcement about iMessage. As far as abuse, how so? They provide a messaging app. That app is compatible with SMS. There are several alternative messaging apps. Where is the abuse?
- insaneirish 4y ago> They said in the iMessage announcement that it’d be an open protocol. Really duplicitous. Source?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lolinder 4y agoWhere did they say it would be an open protocol? I went and found the WWDC 2011 announcement [0], and they described it as a "new messaging service between iOS users" (big bold text from the slide). I watched all the way through the end of the demo, they never said anything about it being an open protocol. In fact, right at the end he said they were "building this on the push notification system that we built", which implies that it's using internal iOS systems, not something they ever intended to make public. Even if they had said it would be open, changing their minds later wouldn't be a lie, it would be... changing their minds. I'm not an Apple user or fan, and I dislike iMessage's weird half-baked integration with regular SMS, but this feels like an overreaction even if there was a place where they claimed it would be open. [0] https://youtu.be/LPMjUtfQPks?t=4296 https://youtu.be/LPMjUtfQPks?t=4296 The link above will take you right to the part about iMessage.
- permo-w 4y agothe digital markets act should reverse this decision
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SmileyKeith 4y agoThis isn't the primary part of this conversation but I found this quote pretty interesting: > Now, we are starting to work on Safari again but look at Chrome. They put out releases at least every month while we basically do it once a year. Even though this was in 2013 nothing about the release cycle (still only major changes with the major OS release versions). I wonder if some of the other emails have more context on this.
- scarface74 4y agoWell this is obviously not true. Apple releases point upgrades to iOS along with Safari changes throughout the year.
- Jtsummers 4y ago"Basically" means "not literally but for all practical purposes might as well be" but in fewer words. Safari's major features, for all practical purposes, are released annually and not with point upgrades unless they were planned features (same with iOS, iPadOS, and macOS) that didn't make it into .0.
- scarface74 4y agoSo Google releases features without planning?
- Jtsummers 4y ago> So Google releases features without planning? Or they release them at a faster cadence, which was the point of the quoted portion of the emails. That doesn't mean no planning. EDIT: Actually, I reread your comment and have no idea what you're getting at. Why do you think I'm suggesting Google has no planning?
- scarface74 4y agoI’m not. I’m suggesting that it is no different what Apple does and what Google does.
- v8xi 4y agoWas just talking about this with my wife. We had an extended family group chat come in that was an absolute disaster with each of us getting several messages per response. I believe this is because it contains a mix of android users and we were discussing how Apple forces us to have a worse experience to maintain their exclusivity.
- batiudrami 4y agoIt’s because it falls back to MMS with android users in the group which does have a weird duplication issue. Best bet is to use another platform for group chats (Signal is excellent but WhatsApp may be a path of less resistance)
- pvg 4y agoCouple of threads from two years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26753014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26753014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26746065 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26746065
- typon 4y agoIs iMessage an American phenomena mostly? I don't know a single South Asian or Chinese person who uses iMessage. In Canada, most people use WhatsApp or Messenger, and some tech-savvy millenials use Signal.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoUS teen survey. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220406005379/en/Piper-Sandler-Completes-43rd-Semi-Annual-Generation-Z-Survey-of-7100-U.S.-Teens https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220406005379/en/Pip... > 87% of teens own an iPhone and 87% expect an iPhone to be their next phone; 72% of teens already have AirPods
- hallway_monitor 4y ago
- scarface74 4y agoSo in the rest of the world that uses Android are they equally “brainwashed”?
- hu3 4y agoAndroid is not tied to a single phone brand. Their users have a myriad of options.
- scarface74 4y agoSo Android users aren’t “brainwashed” for choosing one operating system. But iOS users are? I’m sure if iOS users weren’t so brainwashed they could find Android phones that are more performant that are supported longer than iPhones…
- dagmx 4y agoAs opposed to what? It’s the same as any other network effect in any other social group. Using signal or telegram or WhatsApp isn’t intellectual superiority. It’s just a network effect motivated by other factors like cost of data vs cost of sms etc… at a certain point of time. while using other messaging services isn’t a sign of intellectual superiority, judging others for their choices is very much a sign of low self confidence.
- zmmmmm 4y agoI like Phil Schiller's response - > And since we make no money on iMessage what will be the point? In case you ever get fooled into thinking Apple really cares about its users or their experience - they care as far as it makes them money. Then they don't care.
- threeseed 4y agoIt's not mutually exclusive. I am sure Apple cares about its users or their experience and making money.
- hu3 4y agoIn different proportions, as is evident.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- goldenchrome 4y agoIf it doesn’t make money there should be some strategic importance. Phil is arguing that targeting Android users has neither financial nor strategic benefits. It’s bad business practice to put energy towards something that doesn’t serve your mission because you lose focus and discipline. For the things they do invest in, Apple puts a lot of energy in the user experience because they believe that there are business benefits to doing so. This is true of most well-run companies. Generally speaking, our economic system works out well because the incentives of businesses align with the incentives of the consumer.
- howinteresting 4y agoWhat a crock of nonsense. The interest of the consumer would be better served by not sending potato quality images and videos to Android users.
- wvenable 4y ago
- kornhole 4y ago"I am concerned the Imessage on Android would simply serve to remove an obstacle to Iphone families giving their kids an Android phone." -Craig It was with great difficulty that I convinced my girlfriend to try an Android phone that I had tricked out for her. The main obstacle was that her entire family of more than twenty are locked into Imessage. She felt ostracized afterwards being the green bubble in the family. She has gotten many of them on Signal, but they treat me with some disdain. I really learned what a firm grip Apple has on its users, and it is proven here yet again that it is by design. She must really love me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cokeandpepsi 4y ago
- kornhole 4y agoThe Android phone I gave her and we use is GrapheneOS, and we have a Nextcloud server for most all our needed services. It is far more private than Apple who knows where you are at all times, what you are using on your phone, who you communicate with.. and is building an advertising business to capitalize on this.
- dmitriid 4y ago> I really learned what a firm grip Apple has on its users, and it is proven here yet again that it is by design. > The Android phone I gave her and we use is GrapheneOS, and we have a Nextcloud server for most all our needed services. Or, you know, perhaps your girlfriend not thrilled by either the OS nor by the services you foisted on her? Or, perhaps, "by design" people are not enthused by the prospect of running their own Nextcloud servers?
- dwaite 4y agoHaving grown up with IRC, AIM, ICQ, MSN, Jabber, etc etc. I can say this was and is _always_ the case. I have a group of friends who refuse to use Signal (because of the phone number requirement) and for several years the only channel we could agree on was Steam chat. I have a side of my family that I have warned that I will only see their messages once a month because they will only use Facebook Messenger. I keep my Facebook account for them.
- guidedlight 4y agoWhy is Apple is being attacked for not providing a viable platform-level messaging solution to a mobile platform they don't own or control. Isn't that Google's job?
- pcurve 4y agohttps://www.npr.org/2022/09/08/1121756012/iphone-android-text-message-green-blue-tim-cook https://www.npr.org/2022/09/08/1121756012/iphone-android-tex...
- thomasahle 4y agoPeople dislike Apple intentionally making interoperability between platforms worse (something that hurts users of both platforms) in order to make money of network effects. They are hurting inter platform communication by encouraging people to use the only messaging app on the market that isn't multiplatform. Secondly they intentionally provide a bad experience (like low res images and video) when people do try to communicate by text. TFA is the most direct example that this is entirely according to their plan. I think it's fair that many people dislike this.
- interpol_p 4y agoIt seems a stretch to label this "intentionally" making interoperability between platforms worse, when in order to create interoperability they would have to devote significant engineering and design effort into creating a solution for a platform they don't own or control. Recall that when iMessage was introduced, the messaging landscape was very different. It was basically SMS "but nicer" for iPhone users with a simple fallback. My understanding of low res images and video is that it's a limitation of MMS messaging? I dunno, I read the exchanges and it seems fairly benign. Execs asking the question of "do we want to invest in this or not?" and coming to the conclusion not to invest outside their own platform.
- thomasahle 4y ago> they would have to devote significant engineering and design effort into creating a solution for a platform they don't own or control. They wouldn't even have to engineer it themselves. Opening for third party developers would quickly solve the problem. Besides, making a multiplatform app doesn't seem to be an issue for Apple im other contexts, or for any other maker of messaging apps. > My understanding of low res images and video is that it's a limitation of MMS messaging? Apple could fall back on a more modern MMS version, like RCS. It's pretty clear from the article, as well as countless others (like https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-apples-imessage-is-winning-teens-dread-the-green-text-bubble-11641618009 https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-apples-imessage-is-winning-... or https://www.npr.org/2022/09/08/1121756012/iphone-android-text-message-green-blue-tim-cook https://www.npr.org/2022/09/08/1121756012/iphone-android-tex... ) that they simply don't want to. They'd rather make more money while making people less happy. You don't have to blame them, but you can understand why it makes some people unhappy.
- ummonk 4y agoAll this time I've been assuming that Apple keeps iMessage as iOS/Mac only as an anticompetitive tactic, but that this would never be admitted in writing and they'd be smart enough to only talk about verbally in unrecorded meetings. These emails actually make me change my mind on both aspects. First, apparently they were at one point undisciplined enough to talk about risky topics in writing. Second, the reasoning in those emails is actually very reasonable. iMessage was a non-revenue-generating service that cost them money and was funded by sales of Apple devices, so it's being offered as a service to users of Apple products. This isn't unfair behavior on Apple's part.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe one defence I can think of is that keeping it tied to apple devices means they can ban spammers more effectively since there is a real cost to getting back on the network.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrtksn 4y agoThe reasoning is quite sound, yes, but it doesn't consider the long term implications. No one outside of the USA is using iMessage and they are one regulation away from losing it in the USA too. Also, outside of the USA if they piss off Mark Zuckerberg enough they can lose the rest of the world because who would want a phone that doesn't have WhatsApp? It also demonstrates the harm with these lock-in strategies very well. They are concerned that their product wouldn't be compelling enough for people to buy it. Wouldn't be better if they owned the messaging platform and provide the full experience for iOS due to the fact that they control the device? Owning the platform would have given them also the ability to get revenue from non-Apple users through things like payments and other services that can be integrated into the app. In its current situation, it might be the case that Apple has won the battle but might end up losing the war.
- onethought 4y agoWhy is WhatsApp special? iMessages is used a lot outside US. Why is there a “messenger war”? Like what’s the end game? Why do you want people using your free messages product? Data? But e2e encryption and privacy are primary features… I don’t get it
- Watchwatcher 4y agoIf you ever needed further proof that you should not financially support Apple, eh? I assume all the big successful companies are like this. To change it, if that was your desire, we need to be outside their influence. That's why FOSS is so valuable.
- pcurve 4y agoLook at the timestamp on these emails. 7am. 9pm, 10pm.
- paulcole 4y agoThey’re among the 5 or 10 most important people at one of the biggest companies in the world. They’re not sliding down a dinosaur’s tail at 5PM.
- trentgreene 4y ago“Sliding down a dinosaur’s tail”? What does that mean? Never heard the idiom before Edit: is this a flintstones ref?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoYes, as in working the type of job that the flintstones did where they stop working at a set time. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uq7noaMwLfg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uq7noaMwLfg
- pcurve 4y agoI smiled big when I read that reference. Some people are so creative :)
- Vibgyor5 4y agoI am more surprised at the speed at which they reply with a reasonably well-thought response
- colordrops 4y agoLaughed at "Apple Execs on iMessage for Android (2013)"
- paganel 4y agoThat Craig guy had made a very good point in the last message. Barring the socio-economic thing, which makes lots of iPhone users in the US look down on non-iPhone users for not having access to iMessage, WhatsApp was, and still is, the better messaging app compared to iMessage. So why would have hundreds of millions (at that time) WhatsApp users migrated to a worst messaging app?
- lotsofpulp 4y ago>So why would have hundreds of millions (at that time) WhatsApp users migrated to a worst messaging app? Higher quality images/video. Whenever we are at a wedding or whatnot, the fastest and easiest way to share high quality pics/video is to iMessage it.
- paganel 4y agoWhatsApp has a way better interface to quickly share photos at the same original resolutions (or very close to them). I'm now forced to use iMessage because WhatsApp has stopped working on my older phone, and it comparatively sucks at that.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI do not see anything in WhatsApp to let me share media at original quality, or near it. This website says it still compressed quite a bit at Best Quality: https://beebom.com/whatsapp-best-quality-photo-option-live/ https://beebom.com/whatsapp-best-quality-photo-option-live/
- Scharkenberg 4y agoProbably referring to sharing them as "Documents" (files).
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoI, for one, could never understand the appeal of using the messaging app that would work only on devices made my one manufacturer. Imagine your emails could be read only on iPhones and Macs, how far would it take you? Why are messages any different?
- manv1 4y agoBecause at the time, it was the only way you could message people who weren't on phones and on phones. Over time that changed. Now, it's basically a US thing. In other countries messaging apps are used by the majority.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoiMessage was launched Oct 2011. iOS had plenty of cross platform messaging apps by then.
- badwolf 4y agoRIP Blackberry Instant Messenger
- sidcool 4y agoHere in India, Apple has a cult like following among teens. Anyone not having an iPhone is considered uncool. And many of them use the archaic iPhone 5 or 6 rather than a latest Android. The obsession is unreal.
- neilv 4y agoI'm a little surprised that there's zero surprises. If you hadn't seen these emails, but were asked to write the dialogue for what people would say in that scene, you might write pretty much the same arguments.
- MarcRd11 4y agoIt's a shame
- MarcRd11 4y agos
- wraptile 4y ago"I am concerned the iMessage on Android would simply serve to remove an obstacle to iPhone families giving their kids Android phones." Pretty damning for anyone who still thinks that Apple didn't intend to directly profit from teen bullying.
- mmmlinux 4y agoWhy is SMS type texting not prevalent outside the US? I keep seeing arguments about how everyone uses whatsapp or wechat or what ever, But why? Is the SMS service not there for some reason? Is it perceived as less safe to give out your phone number? Do many people have data only devices with out a number?
- beal 4y agoOutside the us carriers continued to charge for sms
- thekid314 4y agoI think people first moved away from SMS because it cost extra to send them, while messaging apps were virtually free. Then messaging apps beat SMS on features, you can send photos, videos, files, read receipts, works across platforms, etc.
- fidor 4y agoOne of the reasons, at least here in the UK, is that for a long time you only got so many SMS messages in your phone contract. MMS was also awful for a long time. WhatsApp solved both those problems, and most importantly was on every device possible.
- thirdsun 4y agoAnd it was easy to set up. No need for accounts and email addresses. The fact that your phone number served as id and login meant that even my tech-illiterate mother was able to use it.
- justsomehnguy 4y agoSMS is limited to 140 symbols per message (half of that for non-Latin languages), costs money, multimedia messages are a royal PITA to handle.[0] Most providers moved to bundled plans with tons and tons of SMS included, but only when they already lost to WA. [0] Last year I needed to send a photo through MMS. It took me 3 attempts to find a proper combo on how to photo in a format acceptible for MMS. Think 640x480 at best. Only three because I've used MMS in the past so somewhere back in my mind there are still info about it. If I were 20 y/o I wouldn't even figure out what I need to do.