19 ms·
General Mills, Audi pause Twitter ads, will evaluate site
- robertlagrant 4y agoThis whole thing is fascinating to watch.
- paganel 4y agoHopefully this will make people reconsider combustion engines in the fight against EVs, but I have my doubts.
- bluescrn 4y agoThe reaction seems kind of ridiculous, given that he's not really done anything yet. As of yet, there's been no high-profile unbannings, or even changes to the ToS, AFAIK. Just a plan to turn the blue checkmark into something that's not an exclusive status symbol. Yes, redundancies can be brutal for those involved, but they're not exactly uncommon when the economy isn't doing so well, or a company changes hands or is restructured. And so far, the scale of the redundancies seems to be mostly speculation?
- bpodgursky 4y agoI mean tons of companies "paused" ads when Facebook did something or another, but it was 100% just that ad budgets being cut going into a weak economy anyway. So we'll see if this is real or just convenient PR spin.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoYeah, in the two companies I worked at that did a lot of advertising - Twitter had some of the worst ROAS. If we are in or do enter a downturn, I wouldn't be surprised if these ads become unprofitable. They'll quickly get turned down.
- threeseed 4y agoSo far the list is: * Audi * GM * General Mills * L'Oreal * Pfizer * Volkswagen You then have Interpublic and WPP telling their clients to pause ads. People really don't understand the power imbalance. Twitter desperately needs these advertisers but for these brands the ad spend is in low single digits and the possibility of harming their brand just simply isn't worth it.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y agoThis is why 8$ is a good idea - the bird will never be free when it can easily be blackmailed by advertisers.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y ago$8 check marks are never gonna make a significant dent in Twitter's expenses...
- zimpenfish 4y agoHe would need about 12-13M people to sign up to cover the $1bn/year debt interest. Going to be interesting to see how far he gets in that... [edit: hedge between 12M and 13M]
- marricks 4y agoFree for who to do what with? Sure, “the bird” will be free, in a sense, when it’s profitable and doesn’t care about advertisers, but that freedom is free for Elon to do whatever he wants with it. Not freedom for users or in any other (actually good) sense of that bloated meaningless word.
- throw0101a 4y ago> This is why 8$ is a good idea An ad-independent revenue source is a good idea, but not the blue checkmark program, as it currently means some kind of identity verification, and 'random' folks having it may cause problems: > Want to call yourself Citibank Password Verification? Here's your blue tick, thanks for the $8. Want to say you're the Democratic Party of Wisconsin and announce you're abolishing the police? $8. Call yourself WXBM Local News Arkansas and invent a school shooting? Yours for $8 > Trump is banned? No problem, you can be Trump for 8 dollars, verified by Twitter. Or you can be Barron Trump and "expose the dark truth about your parents". Whatever. Go mad. * https://twitter.com/ariehkovler/status/1588306300450263041 https://twitter.com/ariehkovler/status/1588306300450263041
- COGlory 4y agoSo my cereal company is getting involved in politics now? I'm not Elon Musk fan, but he is pissing off a lot of people and institutions I don't care for.
- xadhominemx 4y agoThey are pausing ad spend on Twitter because they don’t want to be involved in politics.
- afavour 4y agoIt genuinely surprises me how many Musk defenders don’t get this. I understand the principle his no-moderation policies come from but the reality is that Twitter is going to become (even more of) a political cesspit. No brand is going to want to be associated with it.
- tomp 4y ago
- afavour 4y agoSee, statements like this are just unhelpful. It isn’t a “left” vs “right” issue. The issue is an influx of racism, anti-semitism, violent threats and much much more. Saying it’s OK because the “far left” said whatever they wanted (what are they even saying that’s so toxic?) is asinine.
- alkonaut 4y agoYou probably want to consider the political normal to be the landscape that corporations is comfortable with. If companies become defensive then it might be politically extreme. If they are not, then it probably isn't. I think this idea that "every large company on earth seems to be 'far left'" is probably a sign that the vantage point might be shifted...
- 4y ago
- dementiapatent 4y agoThe blue cathedral is offended and retaliating.
- Majestic121 4y agoWhat is the blue cathedral in this context ?
- dementiapatent 4y agoI think "the powers that be" also works in this context. Control over global public discourse is the most effective mind control tool in the world. Even moreso when your control is hidden and you maintain plausible deniability. The current ownership won't give this up without a fight.
- Brometheus 4y agoDidn't know Rupert Murdoch owned Twitter.
- dementiapatent 4y agoThanks y'all for the immediate slander and political replies. Anyways, the strategy is now clearly to burn twitter to the ground and diminish its influence since it isn't controlled anymore.
- RavingGoat 4y agoAll because white guys want to tweet the N word
- ceejayoz 4y agoJACK: Elitist, East coast, alternative, intellectual, left-winged... LIZ: Just say Jewish, this is taking forever. - 30 Rock
- lefstathiou 4y agoAuto companies cutting spending is just spite from competition which is understandable. What’s comical is the gall of General Mills, who has spent decades getting kids (myself included) addicted to sugar with manipulative advertising. It’s genuinely amazing and saddening how many people want to see Musk fail. We are watching Atlas Shrugged play out.
- CJefferson 4y agoThese companies don't personally care about Musk -- they just don't want to be associated with the fallout as he mananges to offend or annoy a significant proportion of people.
- acdha 4y agoI’d also add that Twitter is weird for being far more influential than its user size would suggest. People advertise there because it has a disproportionate impact, and many high-profile users are reconsidering how much content they create for the service for free.
- Angostura 4y agoAgreed. I work with a charity that uses Twitter to communicate with the public. They are keeping a close eye on whether it is still the kind of medium they want to be associated with.
- AnonCoward42 4y ago> What’s comical is the gall of General Mills, who has spent decades getting kids (myself included) addicted to sugar with manipulative advertising. Nature made everyone addicted to sugar. Of course not everyone is as prone to this as others, but sugar is energy and organisms (we included) need energy. Manipulative advertising is also a bit redundant. Advertisement is meant to be manipulative, which is maybe more obvious by a pejorative/synonym for advertisement: propaganda.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIf you don’t want to be ostracized financially, don’t embrace being this flavor of human. Actions have consequences. It is genuinely amazing and saddening how many people continue to make excuses for Musk’s actions and behavior. If that is what success is, yes, please, fail. No one told Elon to light a substantial amount of his wealth on fire with this effort; his character and emotional health led him here. Wealth amplifies who you already are. He could’ve just been the cool dude who made sexy electric cars and rockets that land themselves. He might still go back to that after the Twitter experiment, but the reputation will take Herculean efforts to recover. By no means a Musk hater by the way. Own multiple Teslas (acquired pre shenanigans), took my kid to see the first falcon heavy launch, and used to to drive to the cape all of the time to see earlier F9 launches at all hours. I respect the ambition, just not at the cost of being a decent human being, and I think that’s a fair position to hold: disappointment.
- prepend 4y agoIt’s funny. I watched the Social Dillemma and thought we were doomed. Maybe the way to fix social media is to just have Twitter die by whatever Musk is doing and Facebook die from trying to become the metaverse. I hope they pull ads from Facebook and Instagram next. In fact, Im pretty sure the world will be ok if Audi and Genera Mills ceased to exist. Imagine how many fewer kids will get diabetes if Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Lucky Charms blinked out of existence.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoMaybe it's because I'm Minnesotan (been living here for 20+ years now, time to call myself one), but we'd eat Cinnamon Toasters and Marshmallow Mateys instead. Malt-O-Meal FTW: https://www.maltomeal.com/ https://www.maltomeal.com/
- JohnClark1337 4y ago
- rob74 4y agoIf Twitter and Facebook went bankrupt tomorrow, other, not necessarily better, social networks would surely step in to take their place. Same goes for car makers or makers of sugary foods.
- prepend 4y agoPerhaps, or maybe it was a fad and people will move on to some other vice. Facebook is different than MySpace and Friendster. So it’s not really that easy to just clone an existing service.
- foobarian 4y ago> Imagine how many fewer kids will get diabetes if Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Lucky Charms blinked out of existence. Unscientific gut feeling guess: sugary sodas need to go waaay before the cereals.
- 4y ago
- Proven 4y ago
- MichaelZuo 4y agoFor some reason nowadays there's a huge cohort of haters on HN in every Elon Musk-adjacent post. As if he was some arch-villain in disguise plotting to destroy them personally. Whereas in reality he isn't as terrible nor as perfect as what all the millions of critics and boosters suggest. I'm explicitly writing this out because I believe HN should always be a place of engaging in substantive discussion, and not mindless agitation regarding any topic.
- Brometheus 4y agoYet you yourself provide no substance to the discussion and just formulate some centrist statements without any points adding to the discussion.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI clearly made at least one substantial point addressing at least one topic in my prior comment.
- whateveracct 4y agoHe's just kind of unlikeable (to many) due to the things he says and does. I don't think it's hard to understand. It's not some immoral thing to dislike a person for their personality.
- xnx 4y agoI'd love to see a social platform where your followers see what you post for free, but you have to pay for anyone for comments else to see it (that goes for comments too). Advertisers would be treated no different than any other poster. Everyone would get a portion of the money that was paid to show them content. You could set your own threshold for what it cost for someone to show you something.
- petilon 4y agoThank God for these advertisers. Twitter is very powerful — demagogues can use it to subvert democracy, and repressed peoples can use it to start revolutions. To have this service by controlled by one person — no board and no shareholders to answer to — is to put too much power in the hands of one person. And Musk has proved himself to be unworthy of wielding such power (for example, by tweeting a link to a conspiracy theory on Pelosi). If these advertisers can provide checks and balances on Musk's power, I won't be one to complain about that.
- Majestic121 4y agoAre you being sarcastic when you present 'board and shareholders' as a 'check and balance' ? I'm honestly not sure if you are, because the idea that a board and shareholders can be thought as a counterpower is ludicrous to me but it's hard to detect sarcasm in a message
- andyish 4y agoNo doubt they'll all be back in a few months. If Twitter brings in verified users for a fee it's ultimately going to get leveraged for advertising. I imagine an "only target verified users" option being offered to advertisers with a surcharge associated with it. They're going to get paid from people being verified, and get paid more by companies wanting to advertise to verified people.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoYes, and they're being pretty open about it by calling it a pause. They and the scalp taking outrage class get to strut around feeling victorious and in a few months when it's hip to hate some other target, the advertisers will quietly start buying ads again. Pretty much everyone understands the game now and that it's entirely about signaling and nothing else.
- soared 4y agoBrand safety is massive concern for large brands and they consistently decline cheaper performance to ensure brand safety. Source: I’ve spent $10MM in ad spend the last 2 years for major brands, and constantly set up brand safety settings that are so strict they reduce performance significantly.
- bitwidget 4y agoBut that wouldn't make sense. How many people are going to pay the $8 a month while also being OK with ads? I can pay $8 to Hulu and get an AD supported video streaming service, since I can't get the content for free legally. Why would i pay that same amount to still see ads while also paying to see tweets that other people have created?
- Flatcircle 4y agoI'm surprised to be saying this, but it seems like so many of the tech start ups are just media companies that sell ads. I just read a book about HBO, (tinderbox by James Andrew miller). It's amazing how many things were similar in the 80's compared to today. One example, HBO was using subscriptions to finance shows just like Netflix does today. There's dozens of other examples. The more things change the more they stay the same...
- hammock 4y agoIncredible that we are now in the new era where people don’t know/remember what HBO was (and probably Netflix DVDs too)
- elcomet 4y ago> One example, HBO was using subscriptions to finance shows just like Netflix does today. Aren't they still doing this ?
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoThis shouldn't be surprising, of the FAANG they all have elements of taking advertising money, for some it is their entire business model/cash cow. Up until recently N wasn't doing advertising. It seems like that is the only solution Tech companies have to the constant growth cycle imperative that they or the shareholders imposes on them.
- tannhaeuser 4y agoI've got zero stake in this, but what's the point of GM, VW, and others to boycott Twitter? To give their ad spend to Google and Meta instead? That's beyond laughable. Update: Ok I could get there's a conflict of interest with automotive (and space travel I guess) but come on ...
- forkLding 4y agoYou just explained it, imagine if one of your competitors (Tesla) now knows how much you spend on Twitter, its like a strategy game but now they know your advertising budget. Also they want to see the boundaries between Tesla and Twitter, are you funding your competitors by just spending money on Twitter?
- ksidudwbw 4y agoThere are powerful lobbies threatnibg with blackmail and defamation
- magwa101 4y ago
- yrgulation 4y agoMakes perfect sense. As twitter is now a private company at the whims of a crazy bro i think more companies should reevaluate wether they want to use his services and products. He needs to convince users, corporate or private, that this ad platform is worthy.