21 ms·
Apple says iPhones will switch to USB-C chargers to comply with new EU law
- neves 4y agoIt invisible hand of the Government :-)
- galkk 4y agoNice. Hope that one day they will come after power tool batteries too.
- outcoldman 4y agoThey should start with the batteries first :D Every device in that smart home innovation comes with some battery that I have never seen before.
- franciscop 4y agoPower tools already have a standard, smart home is a totally different beast though, and AFAIK most items should use USB-C?
- neogodless 4y agoAre you saying power tools have a standard battery interface? That you could use batteries from any brand with any tool? That has not been my experience.
- ianschmitz 4y agoThey most certainly do not. Each brand has their own battery platform.
- franciscop 4y agoNot all of them follow it ofc (like micro USB when released) but a bunch of them do, and I'd recommend buying compatible for compatibility sake AND for support for it: https://www.powerforall-alliance.com/en/#tools https://www.powerforall-alliance.com/en/#tools
- generalizations 4y agoAnd I guess that means we won't get any more cable interface innovation for a while. Are we really that certain that micro USB -- I mean, USB-C -- is the format to standardize on for the foreseeable future?
- fazfq 4y agoIt doesn't matter what you think, the busybodies have made their choice so you can't make yours.
- nilespotter 4y agoCouldn't agree more. I don't understand why the HN crowd is so supportive of government telling people what to do, as evidenced by your rapid downvotes. I don't use an iPhone but I'm disappointed Apple caved.
- enriquec 4y agohacker news was overrun with non-technical people (with no real engineering or economics knowledge) long ago (like 6+ years). hardly any interesting discussion or deep understanding here anymore
- frosted-flakes 4y agoIt's not much different than governments regulating electrical power oulets/plugs. And no one thinks that that should be a free-for-all. Of course, there's still fragmentation among different continents/countries, but that was inevitable given the time periods these things were standardised. It's unfortunate that the world didn't decide on one standard, but at least almost all countries are internally consistent. There's no need to make the same mistake with USB.
- hooverd 4y agoWe should allow electrical and networking companies to innovate again. If Cisco wants to use something else instead of RJ45, they should be allowed to be.
- dagmx 4y agoIt’ll be nice to see USB-C across the range. Though the timing is uncanny because when Lightning was announced they said it was going to be around for ten years. Obviously that didn’t factor into the EU ruling, but 2022 is the tenth year of lightning. So if they switch next year that’s an amazingly accurate prediction.
- orra 4y agoHonestly, I'm kinda surprised Apple isn't switching to USB Type-C... but only in the EU.
- yreg 4y agoThat would double the amount of iPhone models they need to manufacture and sell. It might happen, but Apple likes thin product lines.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> That would double the amount of iPhone models they need to manufacture and sell. Aren't they already doing that with the US iPhone 14 models now having no SIM tray vs the rest of the world with SIM trays?
- batuhanicoz 4y agoNot an expert but I would think not putting a board in is way easier than putting in a different one. It's also harder to manage supply for two different boards with different connectors, making different cables, split the accessories ecosystem etc. Apple, esp. under Tim Cook, is super efficient when it comes to this stuff.
- Marsymars 4y agoThey could do the same for EU iPhones; sell them without a physical port and make people charge wirelessly.
- dzikimarian 4y agoThey couldn't. They already have mediocre market share here.
- yreg 4y agoTrue, but that sounds like a PR nightmare. In that case I would expect them to go no-ports worldwide and claim that their amazing MagSafe charging is superior and how bold they are.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoI, surprised they hadn’t changed over yet, only major manufacturer not to yet, and they went all in on USB-C on iPads and MacBooks.
- nelsonic 4y ago"$43.5B on Lightning cable sales alone" ~ https://medium.com/swlh/the-real-reason-apple-doesnt-want-to-add-a-usb-c-port-to-the-iphone-91da3c9d4045 https://medium.com/swlh/the-real-reason-apple-doesnt-want-to...
- scarface74 4y agoYou really think Apple sells $43B worth of Lightning cables?
- pdpi 4y agoThe number is probably overinflated as all hell, but the article does arrive at that number as the lifetime total, not yearly sales.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoThe profit margin must be very high at the prices they charge.
- yreg 4y ago>Apple sold more than 2.2 billion iPhones and more than 360 million iPads before they stopped making numbers public. >Say for every second iPhone or iPad sold, a user bought just one extra Apple Lightning cable for $19 which probably costs Apple around $1 (if not less) to make. >That’s give or take $43.5B on Lightning cable sales alone. I don't follow, `(2.2B + 360M) / 2 * 18` is not 43.5B.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> a user bought just one extra Apple Lightning cable for $19 I've bought a lot of Lightning cables over the last decade and I'd say that 90%+ of them were under $15.
- shtopointo 4y agoWell I'm glad the EU decided to tackle important subjects. Not like they have a monetary and energy crisis going on at the moment.
- andsoitis 4y agoYou can work on multiple problems at once. For instance, since you brought up energy, even recently it was feared that Europe will have trouble this winter but now they have a glut: https://www.wsj.com/articles/europe-once-fearing-gas-rationing-this-winter-has-a-glut-11666804514 https://www.wsj.com/articles/europe-once-fearing-gas-rationi... There are also long term and short term problems that warrant different strategies. Some problems are important to solve but not urgent, while others are both.
- shtopointo 4y agoI’m glad the WSJ is covering that but have you checked energy prices in Europe when compared to last year? Newspapers can say whatever, the reality on the ground is that energy prices have gone up 5-10x in the past year. Some problems are not even worth mentioning before the big ones are solved. Sometimes you have to hone all your energy to solve the big problems and worry about the small ones later. Priorities and such. As far as I see the EU govt is more interested in image than actual solutions. Taking on Apple and winning looks sexier than fixing the very unsexy problem of energy or inflation.
- izacus 4y agoYou've literally gotten a link about how EU is actively working on exactly what you want. And fixing the anticompetitiveness of Apple at once. Efficiency!
- ohbtvz 4y agoThe law has been on the books for years and has been enacted for a while already. It's Apple who's making an announcement here -- that they are bravely deciding to follow the law. And the EU has multiple employees. They can work on different things at the same time.
- falcolas 4y agoGood. When we're constantly adding more data transfer functionality and power capabilities to USB-C, I don't buy the "but muh innovation" argument. The magic of USB-C isn't in the physical interface, it's in the chips that connect to the interface (both in the device and the cable). And if those chips want to change the pinouts after bootstrapping via the current pinout configuration, they can and will.
- enriquec 4y agoyou may not buy the "but muh innovation" - its also sad that that passes for discourse for you - but it is economic fact. whats your opinion on "muh regulatory capture"? what about lightning vs microusb?
- hooverd 4y agoI don't see anybody complaining about the RJ45 format, or NEMA. If you let companies run wild they would probably come up with a way to shove DRM into connectors.
- enriquec 4y ago"hooverd not hearing anyone complaining" isn't an accurate measure of innovation lost through politicizing technology and mandating connectors
- xxpor 4y agoOh, people complain about NEMA all the time. It's objectively the worst commonly used socket+plug system from a safety perspective. It's somewhat mitigated by the common voltage being half of what the Europlug etc sees. RJ45 (akchually 8p8c) also has its issues: people complain about how easy it is to break off the stupid plastic tab all the time. There's proto-DRM in SFP connectors though, you're right. There's an EEPROM in the connector since it needs to negotiate with whatever it's plugged in to, and companies like Juniper and Cisco will only support their own optics (at least, they used to).
- 4y ago
- brundolf 4y agoI'm so excited for this. I was about to buy a new iPhone, but with this news I'm going to wait another year just so I can get USB-C
- kitsunesoba 4y agoI actually sprung for a new phone this generation (14) since it was rumored that it would be the last of the Lightning models. Gotta get maximum usage out of all the Lightning stuff laying around the house.
- popcalc 4y agoSunk cost fallacy much?
- kitsunesoba 4y agoMore like there's no point in throwing out a bunch of perfectly good cables. Would rather they get tossed because they no longer function.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThere's also no point in getting a new phone one or two years early. And this will only extend the life of that Lightning stuff by so much. So you have to compare both scenarios in their entirety. They both generate waste in different ways. And some of that Lightning stuff can get adapters, 3 for $7 on amazon.
- danpalmer 4y agoIt's sad that it took legislation to make this happen, but I can see why. I worked in a pseudo-Apple-store during the height of the 30-pin dock connector and I sold so many cases, speaker docks, charging cables, and all sorts of weird accessories that were built for the 30-pin connector. Then Apple switched to Lightning. It was better in every. single. way. And yet people got burnt. There was so much hardware that was now incompatible that people understandably didn't recognise the benefits of the Lightning connector. This mattered far less for other companies because of the lack of brand recognition. If someone switches from one non-Apple device to another non-Apple device, they don't necessarily expect to keep using the same cables, and back in the day every manufacturer had their own. The expectations of Apple were higher only because of that brand recognition. Sadly, the fact that so many got burnt in the Lightning transition means that there is _still_, a decade later, a resentment among many. I've spoken to so many people who don't like Apple devices, who when asked why say things like "they're always changing their cables". It's obviously not true, but to most people who aren't familiar it might as well be. I think this even burnt the MFI manufacturers. 30-pin compatible speaker docks and other accessories were very widely available, but there are far fewer devices made for Lightning. There are other factors here like the rise of Bluetooth and Wifi enabled devices, and the demise of the iPod, but I think manufacturers also knew customers didn't want Apple specific connector hardware anymore – I know I didn't. Ironically, the long-delayed USB-C transition has probably had the opposite effect. In attempting to compensate for the public view of Apple changing connectors, they've become somewhat known as being the company with the wrong connectors. It's sad, given Apple's core role in defining the USB-C spec, but it's understandable. I look forward to a USB-C iPhone. It's a shame it took legislation to make it happen, but I understand why given how long customers' memories are about the 30-pin connector. As much as we'd like to think USB-C was the "right answer" several years ago, it's a bit more complicated than that.
- paulmd 4y agoTry asking the same enthusiasts who are adamant that switching to USB-C is no big deal and legacy cruft needs to be eliminated what they think about switching to a new PCIe power connector. Forget the 12VHPWR problems, we had a push for a new connector last gen too and it was universally reviled for some reason. People do not want a new connector, let alone a new voltage rail to help move that power a little more safely, they just wanna keep doing 8-pin forever even when it swells to 4+ connectors and starts dictating PCB layouts etc. If people want to be evenhanded and honest about seriously looking at legacy standards, it's time to have a chat about ATX and PCIe add-in-card form factorand their relevance in the 21st century. It's time for a new connector and new voltage rails and new form factors for GPUs in general, that standard dates back to the original AT PC (ATX is literally "AT eXtended") and a PC no longer looks anything like it did in 1980. The "add-in-card" is now pulling more than the actual CPU and the growth of the coolers makes supporting them physically difficult, and the chaos in the market has made solutions impossible because there is no standard for physical dimensions or connector plug-points etc. This is textbook, it's the exact same situation as pre-USB connector standards, everyone is doing their own sizes and layouts and it's chaos. Why should we not have government intervention to impose some common standards and get everybody on the same page so solutions can be engineered and we move forward? Why should a GPU not be a 6x4x12 inch box (or a set of other standard sizes) that slides as a module into the case with high-current connectors in a standardized location? No more GPU sag, no more 4x8pin, just one XT90 jag that contacts as you slide the module into its receptacle on a rail. Sounds like heaven to me. EU should look at giving a standards body a mandate to move forward past that and we can work towards mandatory adoption of the new standard and outlawing the sale of legacy ATX within 5-10 years. That sounds extreme but it's what we did for USB-C, right? But it's different when it's your sacred cow and you have to pay for new hardware...
- philliphaydon 4y agoI must be the only person on HN who thinks the lightening port is better than USB-C.
- collegeburner 4y agono you're not. sturdier, clicks in better and doesn't wear down the same way. and im not even a apple fan/user.
- frosted-flakes 4y agoYou've never had a bad connection with Lightning? Every Lightning cable I've ever had has two pins that have become blackened due to frequent arcing. And the "click" is dependent on the quality of the cable. USB-C cables from Apple click in exactly the same as their Lightning cables, for example.
- philliphaydon 4y agoSo I had an iPhone 4 which i ditched quite quickly as I thought it was a junk phone and went Android for a while. Picked up again at iPhone 6 when I was paid for some work with an iPhone 6 Plus and have had iPhones since. So that was 2014, 8 years of Lightning ports. I've had 0 lightening cables break in any capacity. While the USB-C cables I've had for Headphones, iPad, Asus Keyboard, Corsair Mouse, and a few other little things. I've had to replace 5 cables. I love the idea of having 1 cable that I can use for everything. But no matter what anyone says, the lightning cable is superior in terms of physical connection.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoBeen using Lightning models since the iPhone 6 generation and haven't seen this behavior even once. The worst I've seen was a couple of times where the phone's port got pocket lint stuck in it, making it harder to plug in cables which was fixed easily enough with some careful teasing with a SIM ejector tool. I don't have anything against USB-C but its "click" factor varies a lot between cable/port manufacturers due to much wider tolerances/variances in manufacturing.
- hobbitstan 4y agoI often wonder how much money Apple makes from the fact that lightning cables all seem to die after a few months. I have usb cables that are decades old that still work, but lightning…
- ulfw 4y agoAnd I just threw two Anker USB-C charging cables away in the last four weeks as both broke internally.
- alphabettsy 4y agoAnker has been great about replacing in my experience.
- scarface74 4y agoYes because it’s impossible to buy third party Lightning cables…
- frosted-flakes 4y agoApple takes a cut from every licensed Lightning cable sold.
- scarface74 4y agoI doubt that Apple is getting a “cut” of the $5 cables you can buy from Amazon or your local bodega.
- marrone12 4y agoThey do from MFi certified cables. You have to pay apple a licensing fee. and the non licensed cables will sometimes give you an error.
- scarface74 4y ago
- 1-6 4y agoIt would be better if EU regulators asked Apple to open their Lightning cable standard so other phone vendors can use it. I very much like Apple’s implementation of their charging cable because it uses less space on the device.
- RealStickman_ 4y agoWhy would the other phone vendors switch to a different connector though?
- hot_gril 4y agoCause the EU forces them to, lol. Yeah it ain't happening.
- RealStickman_ 4y agoWhy would the EU force a connector that is inferior in data transfer rates on everyone?
- hot_gril 4y agoOh, I could see them mandating not the fastest connector (USB-C for instance if something faster comes along). Speed hardly matters, though. They just won't mandate Lightning cause it's a proprietary connector, so it's out of the question.
- dzikimarian 4y agoIt's USB 2 in different plastic mold. Awesome indeed.
- robertoandred 4y agoWhat a pain, forcing everyone to buy new cables.
- tremon 4y agoIndeed. To resolve that issue, the EU came up with this legislation.
- ericmay 4y agoYea but now people who were using the Lightning cable will have to buy new USB-C devices and replace existing cables. While the parent was being a bit disingenuous, they are correct that this will create additional e-waste that really probably wasn't necessary to do. I'm happy that Apple is switching to USB-C, for whatever that is worth.
- robertoandred 4y agoWhat? This legislation is what’s forcing everyone to buy new cables and throw out their old ones.
- alistairSH 4y agoUnlikely. How many people in the EU don't also own USB-C devices already? I don't really care which port Apple uses, but I'd like them to be consistent across the range. It's annoying carrying Lightning cables (phones) + USB-C cables (iPads and laptops) + USB-micro (camera chargers) when I travel.
- tzs 4y ago> It's annoying carrying Lightning cables (phones) + USB-C cables (iPads and laptops) + USB-micro (camera chargers) when I travel. This might help: Anker Powerline II 3-in-1 Cable, Lightning/Type C/Micro USB Cable https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B071WNQYV6 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B071WNQYV6
- kennend3 4y agoI suspect you misread the legislation. Anyone who currently has a lightening cable/phone wont need to change it ;) And yes, eventually it will lead to e-waste as people replace their Lightening based phones with USB-C, but didn't the same thing take place with the 30 pin dock connector? At least after this apple wont need dongles like this beauty : https://www.apple.com/ca/shop/product/MQLU3AM/A/usb-c-to-apple-pencil-adapter https://www.apple.com/ca/shop/product/MQLU3AM/A/usb-c-to-app...
- jl6 4y agoReserve some celebration until we’ve seen the implementation. It’s not beyond Apple to manufacture an EU-specific SKU and charge €100 more for it.
- dimmke 4y agoOh my god, please please please this in the US this is an instant buy for me. Can they switch over everything? Airpods too?
- sdze 4y agoaccording to EU Law it is mandatory for all these kinds of devices.
- tomjakubowski 4y agoApple's Beats earbuds case is already USB-C so I imagine it's coming for Airpods.
- ribit 4y agoApple has been moving their entire lineup to USB-C for a while already (iPad Pro in 2020, iPad Mini in 2021, more devices this year) . Sure, in public they have to oppose tech sector regulation, but I wouldn't be surprised if they were secretly happy as it provides them with an excuse. If some customers who have heavily invested into the Lighting ecosystem complains then can always say "look, it was the EU, blame them".
- CharlesW 4y agoAbsolutely. If Apple would've switched to USB-C without an EU mandate, they would've received mountains of bad press about the unprecedented amount of e-waste and confusion that will result because of this switch. So they pressured the EU to mandate the change to a standard that Apple helped pioneer, so that Apple's environmentally-friendly record would remain unblemished.
- adam_arthur 4y agoThe mountains of e-waste created by keeping around a zombie protocol far exceeds a transition to a widely used and accepted standard. The majority of people with iPhone likely already have USB-C cables anyway, so requires no net new purchase
- scarface74 4y agoHow many of those users have USB C cables capable of video over USB, USB3 speeds etc? If the EU were going to “mandate” something, don’t be half assed about it.
- adam_arthur 4y agoI dunno, but lightning doesn’t support that anyway, so who cares?
- scarface74 4y agoActually, Lightning can support USB 3. The first generation iPad Pro did. But I thought EU was trying to prevent incompatibility?
- latchkey 4y agoI switched to the magnetic charger long ago. Just keep it near my bed... plop my phone onto it before bed and wake up in the morning with a charged phone. Easy.
- muhehe 4y agoGood. I was thinking about buying iphone, but this was the ultimate thing that made me not buy it. I just hope Apple doesn't decide to screw it up somehow. Like making sure only pricey apple chargers works. Then it wouldn't matter at all.
- lrvick 4y agoAs someone that deeply detests Apple and would never give them money, I will admit the lightning connector is superior in durability, inspectability, and safety than USB type C in virtually every way. The real crime here is that Apple insisted on patenting the design and keeping it for only themselves, forcing the rest of the industry to adopt an inferior connector and ultimately force it on them too. Classic Apple.
- fsflover 4y ago> I will admit the lightning connector is superior in durability, inspectability, and safety than USB type C in virtually every way Any links to back that claim?
- tengbretson 4y agoDo you have a source for the question you are asking?
- anoonmoose 4y agoYes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33360137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33360137
- lrvick 4y agoThe pins are on the outside making it easy to visually inspect for damage, or obstruction. With USB C a bit of conductive debris can be in the hollow cavity in the connector and cook your hardware. Or bend pins. Watched it happen. Also if you work in high security environments where badusb attacks are a risk, lightning makes it is even easy to inspect data delivery pins are intentionally missing before you plug in a cable to an airgapped machine. With USB C you have to custom make complicated usb m-to-f condom devices with transparent enclosures so you can visibly inspect the PCB traces. I have worked in high security environments where these were a must. Further lightning is simply a solid metal connector and more structurally sound. It is hard to bend pins or cause a short. I have distributed a lot of usb-c devices and watched people hand them back to me with snapped or crushed connectors many times. I hate that Lightning was made by Apple instead of the USB standards boards. USB Type C is a terrible connector. I literally use laptops with barrel jack power to avoid it.
- Havoc 4y ago> Apple’s engineers should be left to come up with a solution That’s precisely what we’re trying to avoid. Every company coming up with their own version that is definitely totally superior to the other companies’ and thus incompatible
- illuminerdy 4y agoAnd who says it needs to be compatible? Companies design what they feel are the best/better components for their products. If consumers want to have a "standard" connector that works with multiple devices, they have that with the many Android OEMs that choose to use USB. But I don't see why the government should be forcing companies to use a standard when it has no clear connection to safety of the product.
- post_break 4y agoReminder, lightning is still usb 2.0 which is a joke with these 4k videos and tons of photos. Apple could still put USB C on there with 2.0 speeds, like Samsung did as recently as the Flip 3...
- sdze 4y agoBut this is not a Lightning problem. It is the controller that only supports USB2. First iPad Pro for instance was Lightning and had USB3 transfer speeds.
- post_break 4y agoA single camera adapter had USB3, everything else on that device is USB 2.0.
- datadata 4y agoIt takes courage to follow the law
- irrational 4y agoI’m somewhat surprised Apple is doing this. I 100% thought they would abandon any sort of connector and go completely wireless.
- Mikeb85 4y agoIt's especially ironic that Apple had to be forced to use usb-c since they were the first to adopt Thunderbolt and they use usb-c/thunderbolt in all their laptops and newer iPads. Seems they held on to Lightning connectors simply to sell more cables (or maybe spite).
- jaywalk 4y agoI don't think it's either of the reasons you stated. I think it's more about how many accessories are out there using Lightning that will be obsoleted by the switch. It's like the Dock to Lightning switch, but on a much larger scale simply because there are far more iPhones with Lightning (and therefore accessories) than there were with the Dock connector.
- throwaway434814 4y agoIt only took them 8 years to adopt a standard every other phone company already did. Another 8 years for jack 3.5mm on iPhones?
- giantg2 4y agoIs it bad that I assume they'll have logic in the phone that says only fast charge or whatever with Apple chargers?
- aquova 4y agoI've never really understood why they hadn't done it yet. The iPad has used a USB-C connections for a few iterations now, they got a lot of criticism for switching only to USB-C style connectors on their Mac line years ago, yet they've resisted bringing the iPhone into the same ecosystem. There's a lot of third party peripherals that are reliant on lightning, but that doesn't really seem like something that would hold Apple back.
- smoldesu 4y agoI feel like a Thunderbolt 3 iPhone has been possible since at least iPhone X. If Apple went all-in on a high-bandwidth connector for all their devices, maybe they could resurrect the dead dream of FireWire.
- netheril96 4y agoMe too. One of the stated benefits of the Apple ecosystem is how well they work together. Except when iPads and MacBooks all switch to USBC and iPhones stay on Lightning.
- whiddershins 4y agoI suspect it is harder to waterproof a usb-c jack.
- stop50 4y agoshould be easier or around the same.
- kennend3 4y agoWhy come here to spread FUD? Thankfully NO USB-C phones are waterproof? Oh wait, many are? https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/7533279?hl=en https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/7533279?hl=en Pixel 7 Pro, 7, 6a, 6 Pro, 6, 5a (5G), 5, 4, 3, and 2 phones are designed to be water-resistant. Why would a USB-C jack be any more difficult vs lightening?
- lacker 4y agoI'm generally not a fan of the EU mandating technical decisions, but for me personally, Lightning connections have always been really low quality. Since my iPhone was about a year old, it often won't recognize a new Lightning cable that's plugged in, I have to unplug and re-plug it several times. Or it will charge for a minute and then suddenly think it's disconnected. Or you will bump it slightly and it thinks it's now disconnected. I have never had such trouble with USB-A, micro-USB, USB-C, or even the old 30-pin connectors. It's especially annoying when I'm in my car, which unfortunately only supports a wired CarPlay connection. Sometimes I'll go over a bump, it'll disconnect my phone, and I have to mess with it while driving in order to get the directions going again.
- selykg 4y agoI've had iPhones since the original came out with the big ol iPod connector on it. Generally upgrading every two years, except the last one which was an Xs to a 14 Pro. I have never had this happen. I welcome the USB-C change, but I have never once had what you're describing happen in however many years the Lightning connector has been out.. feels like 8+ years, but without looking I wouldn't know. I've had, I think, one Lightning cable fail to work and that was because my cat chewed on the cord.
- lacker 4y agoYeah, surveying my friends I found one other person with this problem, but it isn't the majority case. It doesn't seem to be a problem with the cable, it's really a problem with the connector on the iPhone itself. All my iPads charge fine on Lightning cables. I keep my phone for longer than two years, for one. Or maybe there's something specific to my pocket, where the sort of lint that gets into the iPhone is especially degrading to the connector?
- philsnow 4y ago> I'm generally not a fan of the EU mandating technical decisions How do you feel about California mandating emissions standards for vehicles?
- can16358p 4y agoWhile I'm against forcing a company to use a specific connector (especially Apple where every millimeter counts), I think this was way overdue because of terribly slow USB 2.0 speeds even on "Pro" models that shoot ProRes and 48MP raws.
- scarface74 4y agoYou realize that nowhere in the “mandate” are any speed requirements and most cheap USB C cords only support USB2 speeds?
- can16358p 4y agoPractically, I'd be really really surprised if Apple moved to USB-C but still keep USB 2 speeds. Moreover, even the cheapest USB-C devices and cables I've seen happily work over USB 3 and I've yet to see anything with USB-C form factor that doesn't support USB 3 even if it's not mandatory.
- scarface74 4y agoYou mean like on the brand brand new 10th generation usb C iPad? https://www.macrumors.com/2022/10/27/ipad-10-slower-usb-c-port/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/10/27/ipad-10-slower-usb-c-po...
- can16358p 4y agoThat's stupidly absurd on Apple's side. Let's hope they don't do the same with the USB-C iPhones then.
- fortran77 4y agoApple should provide free eWaste recycling for lighting cables, with some assurance that the will actually be recycled.
- Yorch 4y agoI never had a device with lightning. My only Apple device, an Ipad Pro, has USB-C. But I found USB-C very delicate and prone to fail with time. I'm not a fan of this connector type.
- stop50 4y agoI only had cables that failed and cheap usb powerbanks that had bad ports but usb-c ports are the most robust i have seen.
- nvahalik 4y ago> Joswiak also claimed that the proprietary Lightning cable and the USB-C cable would not exist if Apple had agreed to the EU original demand of using the older Micro USB charging cable which had poor reliability and could easily be damaged. So... what happens when USB-C no longer makes sense anymore? Will they have to keep using it no matter what? Wait for the law to change?
- hot_gril 4y agoUSB-C will make sense forever now. Nobody will develop something else. That's not necessarily a bad thing, it is what it is.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoUSB-C might very well be the last wired connection standard, but I expect a port free iPhone within 10 years that charges via induction and has some way to do some data transfer by that as well.
- hot_gril 4y agoRight, and they might switch the law to allow that at some point.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe EU already allows for a port free iPhone. Just that if they provide a port, it has to be USB-C. But the tech and acceptance isn't really there yet for such a product, but I'm pretty sure it will come eventually.
- lesuorac 4y agoEh, that's the wrong take about the guys statement. The actual take should've been [Citation Needed].
- ttepasse 4y ago> So... what happens when USB-C no longer makes sense anymore? Will they have to keep using it no matter what? Wait for the law to change? According to the amended Directive, the EU Commission should review it every few years and if I remember correctly the law gives the Commission delegated authority to change the annex for the law, where USB-C and USB-PD are specified. Meaning, when the industry want’s to change it, the industry, presumably the USB Implementor’s Forum, needs to go with their proposal for a better alternative to the EU Commission. Which is not unreasonable, I think.
- hot_gril 4y agoThis effectively decides that USB-C is the final iteration of phone connectors. Nobody is going to invest in making a new one. Maybe there wasn't much room left for innovation anyway; Apple has been showing for a while that they prefer the lock-in.
- adam_arthur 4y agoNot true at all. If USB-C hits hard limitations, vendors will come together to create a new spec. The EU law has provisions to reassess the standard every few years. There are already many specs such as web standards that are critical to society and collaborated on by many vendors.
- hot_gril 4y agoIt took the industry years to get their act together and leave micro-USB behind, and that was without the replacement being illegal. Maybe Lightning even gave them a reason to look for something better. With other standards, there's at least competition, and adopting a better one can be a selling point.
- adam_arthur 4y agoIf a better standard is needed, one will be created
- hot_gril 4y agoIf a better standard is needed by every phonemaker and agreed upon, and they cooperate in developing it, and the EU (which btw is not where any of these phonemakers are HQ'd) agrees with it.
- adam_arthur 4y agoYes, just like browser vendors agree on standard changes
- seydor 4y agoBS, they love it. Users will just HAVE to buy iphone 15, because it has the noticeable usb hole to differentiate them. Lighting cables are the new green bubbles. Using one means you re poor or hate the environment or both
- popcalc 4y agoThis right here is the truth. Consumers learn to associate "new cable" with new model aka I'm wealthy enough to grab the latest doodad on launch. Like a monkey wearing a palm leaf, new iPhones or AirPods are a status symbol. Apple's core market is not San Jose VCs or Mar Vista interior designers. It's Americans living pay-check to pay-check only afloat through credit. Their primary product is the ability to be envied by your neighbours, your classmates, or your colleagues. This is coming from someone who has completely bought into the Apple ecosystem.
- repler 4y agoWhat happens if I plug my USB-C iPhone into my 100W USB-C charging cord for my laptop? Does the phone charge? Does it get hot? Does the brick get hot?
- stop50 4y agocase 1: an cable without chip, conforming to the usb3 spec both devices transfer the highest amount below the cap that is supported case 2 wirth chip: the maximum power transfered is now the minimum between charger, phone and cable.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoI already plug my iphone lightning cable to 100W USB-C charging block for my laptop. USB-C doesn't send full power unless the device wants it.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoDoes this mean Apple will add USB-C functionality beyond just charging? For example, connecting to hard drives.
- ThatPlayer 4y agoNo, that'll be up to Apple to implement if they choose to. The only EU requirements are USB-C for charging, and USB-PD for charging protocol. They could remove all USB data functionality completely if they wanted to, the EU law is only about device charging.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoI'll be happy to carry just one charging cable for everything in my bag in a few years. Hopefully this gives Anker the chance to make One USB-C Cable To Replace Them All with gold connectors and ∞ durability
- pipeline_peak 4y agoAt this point, the only proprietorship Apple holds onto is out of preserving branding by mediocrity. Not being able to use my friends Android charger is an absolute nuisance. I absolutely could care less about Lightning bolt, Firefly or whatever the fuck it’s called these days…
- kkirsche 4y agoI have to wonder, when will a company just say, No. Your citizens like our products more than they trust you, we can force their hand by immediately pulling products specifically to spite them while being “compliant”
- lossolo 4y agoNever? EU market is too big for Apple to lose it because of some connector. It's second biggest market for Apple in the world after Americas [1] 1. https://businessquant.com/apple-revenue-by-region https://businessquant.com/apple-revenue-by-region
- kdinn 4y agoI'm amazed this hasn't happened earlier. They've switched their laptops across ages ago. I have a MacBook, Samsung phone, Sony headphones, Samsung earbuds as well as several other USB-C accessories and I only need the Macbook power cord to charge any of them. When I travel that's the only power supply I take. When I need to charge my phone, I just unplug the Macbook and plug in the Samsung phone. But if I had an iPhone I couldn't do that!