18 ms·
Video gaming may be associated with better cognitive performance in children
- pgt 4y agoIf you're playing video games competitively, you're probably not drinking to excess.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI don't think many 9-10 year olds are alcoholics.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoThese were children - 9 and 10 years old. It is doubtful that any of them were playing competitively or drinking to excess. Even in older folks, 3 hours a day isn't really playing competitively nor does it mean you aren't drinking. We used to spend many hours getting drunk and high and playing games. It was great fun, and still is from time to time.
- shric 4y agoLink to the study: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2797596 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle...
- armatav 4y agoProblem is avoiding them being used as a coping mechanism for stress
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoWhy? Assuming it doesn't become overwhelming I don't see the issue with that, same as any other stress relief.
- DelightOne 4y agoIts too addicting.
- falcolas 4y agoNo more addicting than TV or movies. More engaging, on the other hand…
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI don't know, I think a great number of previous video game players have grown up and become functional humans given the majority of children in the last few generations will have played videos games for entertainment in one fashion or another. There's always outliers who will have problems of course, but that doesn't mean it's bad for the rest.
- Gigachad 4y agoI feel like I have the opposites of an addictive personality. I enjoy playing games but I struggle to stay interested in any game for more than 10 hours and then I need a few months to reset and play it again. The only thing I have become addicted to is Hacker News and reddit. Arguably worse for you than games, for reddit at least.
- practice9 4y agoPerhaps the underlying addiction mechanism (dopamine) also improves cognitive performance (as a side effect)
- educaysean 4y ago
- dtdynasty 4y agoFrom personal experience I do agree that video games can be used as a form of distraction and escapism. but I think teaching mental awareness and moderation could change it from distraction to relaxation.
- formerkrogemp 4y agoHey, you can your relaxation with a side helping of micro transactions and loot boxes.
- TapWaterBandit 4y agoYea, video games can definitely end up being an unhealthy coping mechanism used to avoid addressing your real life issues. That said they are probably on balance a better coping mechanism than some of the other popular ones out there (Alcohol, drugs, porn, gambling) but definitely worth keeping an eye on. Especially because video games aren't restricted for children like all those others things are (at least in theory).
- notch656a 4y agoGambling is roughly described as gaming with higher stakes, IMO. My totally unqualified, unsubstantiated guess would be the average gambler has higher cognitive performance than the average video game player. A dumb gambler goes broke sooner or later, which doesn't make them all quit but it does make some of them quit, which I would wager causes a selective effect towards the smarter ones.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI think you're envisioning gambling as a poker shark, when it could be someone betting on horses, playing slot machines, or buying scratch cards.
- reducesuffering 4y agoHave you been to a casino? 95% of Blackjack players aren't even playing basic strategy, something that takes a single day to learn. Instead, mid-rank players in popular online games like Valorant and Overwatch 2 are quite formidable multi-level thinkers.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 4y agoBut what percentage of those people are playing as anything other than a lark? I might go to the casino one time every three years. I can guarantee I am utilizing a sub optimal strategy
- dandellion 4y agoWhy unhealthy? I've been using games as a coping mechanism for stress and personal issues for about twenty years and as far as I can tell I'm reasonably healthy. Most people my age that are clearly unhealthy it's because of drugs, alcohol or weight issues, not videogames. I'm somewhat prone to stress, and I find taking a few days off to play games helps in recovering from burnout, while something like travelling which helps some people, stresses me out.
- rubyist5eva 4y agoVideogames as a coping mechanism for stress stopped me from committing suicide. It's not so simple, nothing ever is.
- nottorp 4y ago... and instead using binge watching abysmal Netflix series as a coping mechanism for stress because it's more 'mainstream'? :)
- Mikeb85 4y agoOf course. Most video games force you to make decisions at a fairly rapid pace with ever changing information. It's like chess on steroids.
- red75prime 4y agoTic-tac-toe on dopamine, more likely.
- badpun 4y agoMost of them don't have the depth of chess, though. It's more like working in McDonalds.
- Mikeb85 4y agoOnce you get to a high enough level in chess it's a ton of memorization. It's not that deep. Some games are shallow but lots of games have far more depth than chess.
- badpun 4y agoIsn't the memorization just a required to play competetively at all? At highest level of chess, memoryzation is a given and it's about brain power and creativity.
- Mikeb85 4y ago> it's about brain power and creativity Part of the whole Hans Neimann cheating scandal is that he played too close to optimal as measures by his correlation to a computer. So no, it seems mostly to be about drilling positions with solvers and playing faithfully to that. I played chess competitively as a kid, before chess programs were very strong or widely available. We memorized maybe 4 moves in and that's it. After that it was all strategy, creativity, etc... Nowadays they're doing far more work with solvers and it's pretty much taken the strategy out of it. Which is why Go is increasing in popularity. Competitive gaming probably as well.
- 4y ago
- etiam 4y agoCareful now. Self-assortment into those who don't play at all and those who play at least three hours per day? There's good reasons to think those weren't otherwise equivalent populations in the first place. I'm buying "associated" but any sort of claims about effects from the games are going to have to come from elsewhere.
- rednerrus 4y agoWould you assume the same thing about playing a musical instrument or playing a sport? What is playing video games except practicing cognitive performance? It works spatial reasoning, logic, dexterity, problem solving, reactions, etc.
- etiam 4y agoHow is the alternative not?
- m463 4y agocould be kids who have access to a console and have several hours a day free might be in a different socioeconomic environment? but with cheap phone games, maybe not. hmmm...
- raydiatian 4y agoI’m inclined to disagree based on antithetical first hand experiences. In fact the only console we ever had growing up, my father smashed in front of us after a year because all he gave a shit about was our grades. When a few classes started slipping he blamed the box. Also, “associated” is different from “causality”, right?
- noduerme 4y agoI had a similar upbringing. Video games and TV were blamed for bringing down our grades, and were extremely restricted. We never had a console. Dad would come home and put his hand on the TV to see if it was warm, and ground us if it was. I was allowed to spend time on the computer if I was writing BASIC or playing something "educational" (like Carmen SanDiego, or Oregon Trail). The occasional Sierra game slipped in. The first real game machine I was allowed was a Game Boy, when I was 12. For better or worse, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have become a coder if I'd had access to lots of games in elementary school.
- notch656a 4y agoHaving 3 hours PER DAY to do anything for leisure, even if it's a form of escape from terrible circumstances, is quite the luxury. I would guess at the population level circumstances that allow 3 hours a day of non-essential activities like this to be associated with circumstances that allow better cognitive performance than those without 3 hours a day of time to do something for personal interest.
- recursive 4y agoIn 10 year olds? I would think most 10 year olds have more time than they know what to do with.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoHuh, my immediate assumption was income played a huge role but the video game cohort had poorer parents. The gender difference is huge though, the nongaming cohort had 288 males and 840 females while the gaming cohort had 372 males and 307 females. Also, I'm a bit confused why they just dumped anyone with between one and three hours of videogame playing a day.
- notch656a 4y agoVideo games are like the cheapest way to keep a kid busy for low income working parents. I guess they could send the kids outside but people nowadays start asking questions if a kid is caught outside while single mom is working for 3 hours or something. Given infinite money I think many of those parents would send the kid with nanny if needed or whatever to organized sports, piano classes, etc.
- imran-iq 4y ago> Video games are like the cheapest way to keep a kid busy for low income working parents Source on that? Video games (console or pc) is very expensive and not something low income folks can generally afford for their kids.
- Laremere 4y agoThe high end gets expensive, but the low end is pretty cheap. Considering that a game can keep a child entertained for a hundred hours or more, the overall cost can easily drop below $1/hour. Compared to the cost of a movie or other activities, it comes out cheap.
- hot_gril 4y agoNot if they're old/used. Even new games are cheaper than sports lessons, music lessons, or living in a nice area for other activities. Of course, without video games either, kids will find a way to have fun regardless. My grim apartment complex still had kids kicking around a soccer ball or riding bikes in the parking lot.
- darkteflon 4y agoMy son started playing games (with me) at 4 yo (partly because we were all locked indoors for months on end). Anecdotally - and providing you use some discretion as to choice of game - I’ve found it absolutely fascinating to watch both the pace of development of problem-solving skills, and some of the frankly astounding leaps of logic and intuition young kids are capable of. I vividly remember one rock-moving puzzle in Breath of the Wild that had me stumped until he piped up with a proposal that turned out to be the correct solution. Fascinating stuff.
- andrewmutz 4y agoWhat games do you recommend for kids of that age?
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoAs mentioned, Zelda Breath of the Wild is a great game for kids, even as young as 4-5. My kid is 6 and had an amazing time with it, as did I.
- treeman79 4y agoMy then 8yo daughter who is behind in love with horses saw me riding a horse in botw. Zero experience with video games she picked it up and spent six months working at it so she could get a horse. Completing shrines so she could get enough stamina to tame the horses. She has collected all the rare ones now.
- cloudking 4y agoMinecraft in creative mode
- exitb 4y agoI’ve found that the same games I was playing around that age are actually still fun - Commodore 64 games. Basic, non-distracting graphics and simple joystick controls make things easy for young kids.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CharlieDigital 4y agoI remember reading a paper that there's a strong association between spatial reasoning and performance in math. This made intuitive sense to me given that there is some overlap between manipulating objects in a 2D or 3D space and visualizing a math problem whether numeric or geometric. I find it hard to believe that typical video game puzzles can help increase cognitive performance, but plausible that training spatial recognition might help train the same regions of the brain we use for math. Even the basic mechanics: teaching math to my kids when they were young was purely a visual exercise of moving groups of things (coins, Cheerios, M&M's) around.
- dymk 4y agoAsk yourself: are you a shape rotator or a wordcel?
- ransom1538 4y agoMy son (6) is allowed to only play one game. https://play0ad.com/ https://play0ad.com/. It has been a surreal experience. He is able to gather resources, launch campaigns, build cities, he now creates complex strategies to defeat the enemy (me). The game has great LAN game play so we can attack each other . The next step, he wants to know "how do we change this?" Code. Compare this to watching tiktok?
- heavyset_go 4y ago0 A.D. also has a built in JavaScript interpreter :)
- fragmede 4y agoI'm sure your son could find a way to play the game in a way you disapprove of if forced. Kids on TikTok are learning social skills and creating things in order to star in their own videos, learning to harmonize with all sorts of music and being movie editors. There are even foreign language and math lessons to be had. I'm not sure why you have to dismiss the platform as a whole. Time spent with a an active and participating parent is going to be better for the child, no matter what toy is used.
- Kiro 4y agoWhy 0AD? I presume it's because it's open source but why would that matter here?
- renewiltord 4y agoWas it the urge to hold your inventory full until the game ends? Haha But seriously, the thing that's interesting is if you could challenge a child's spatial intelligence more in a VR or game universe than in our limited gravity enabled world. Curious indeed. Can't say it overwhelms my fear of screen time but it's a thing.
- jjice 4y agoComplete anecdote, but my dad and I would play games like Zelda growing up (fond memories). Not sure if that's why I like puzzles now, but it definitely fits with the problem solving involved in software engineering. Or the two are completely unrelated.
- slt2021 4y agoonly competitive gaming develops brain and teamwork (for team play games). leisure/casual gaming is no better than browsing TikTok.
- jacooper 4y agoAt least you would enjoy it mor than tiktok
- dorkwood 4y agoI don't know about that. I used to play a lot of point-and-click adventure games as a kid. I think those developed my problem-solving skills. It was certainly a better use of my time than watching cartoons.
- gmd63 4y agoA fear of mine is that competitive gaming will usher in a new fascism based on "rank" -- sort of as you're displaying here. I was in master league when I played Starcraft competitively, so I don't discount the real lessons you can learn from intense focus towards a clear goal, and the acceleration provided by competitive arena. But there are plenty of people who cheat or buy their way toward "success" in games, because they are chasing the "status" they get from a silly little virtual badge. I know a handful of these folks in real life. They have many other problems, but are very "successful." I know a World of Warcraft Gladiator (rank 1 arena champion for a season) who botted honor at the expense of other players (in-game currency to attain higher quality gear) and in real life juiced his company's image by purchasing online accounts and controlling conversation in forums. I've shared a meal with a current professional gamer who nonchalantly engages in crypto fraud. Winning is absolutely not everything. Some of the greatest things we can attain in this life will require mass cooperation of humans, and those experiences require dedicated folks with faith in humanity--people who aren't always looking for every crack in the law to screw over their fellow man to get rank 1. I've seen lots of heartwarming content on TikTok, and left most Counter-Strike and Call of Duty lobbies feeling very dispirited.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoNot all games are the same. Maxis and older Blizzard games were probably the best.
- kahon65 4y agoWhich games are mentionned please?
- akomtu 4y agoVideo gaming is massively better than mindless "content" watching because it has the perception-thinking-action feedback loop. On the other hand, I have little hope about gaming in the today's society: the pressure to make money will select the most addictive type of gaming that's going to be even worse than mindless watching (slot machines in casino?) Btw, what does "associated with better outcomes" really mean? It means that in a large sample of lab rats, 10% demonstrated a sudden spike of activity, 40% didn't react and 50% slided into depression. The study gave each outcome a score and found that the average score is slightly positive, so readers are encouraged to think that all the lab rats had this outcome. After the study got completed, those 10% of the rats got suicidal and died within a week, but studying that was outside the scope of the study.
- starside 4y agoI would like to see a comparison to other mentally demanding hobbies, such as sports, cooking, crafting, art, dance, etc. My money is on video games not looking so good.
- ASalazarMX 4y agoI wouldn't compare the focus needed to play amateur sports with the focus needed to finish Megaman 3 on the NES at an amateur level. It teaches you resource managing, planning, timing, memorization, and delayed gratification.
- drooby 4y agoI credit RuneScape with teaching me the value of delayed gratification and basic economics. I credit competitive Halo 3 with teaching me team building and strategy skills. I credit StarCraft with training my mind to travel at warp speed. Honestly. My video game experience was instrumental to my success so far in life. This is not surprising to me.
- XorNot 4y agoCivilization 1 was my introduction to world history.
- dchichkov 4y ago/s I credit Civilization 1 as well. Or should I credit my parents who had PC/XT at home when the price of PC/XT was that of 3 new (soviet) automobiles? /s
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoI sunk a decade into civ 2. Oh man, the memories. I wish gog would acquire rights to release that abandonware with soundtrack and everything. Running it yourself requires running it on top of win3.1 in dosbox now days, and it's still janky. I would legit pay $60 for a perfectly working copy.
- ericmcer 4y agoIn the same boat and it is great until I run into a more complex multi-faceted problem, pick a solution and end up 30 miles down the road before I realize I need to backtrack and try a different one. If my childhood had more books and boredom I might have the patience to spend longer in the planning stage and less enthusiasm for the drinking coffee and pounding out a solution stage.
- throwaway09223 4y agoMine had a lot of books and boredom. I rarely regret just getting things done. Excessive planning is a much larger issue. I find it's usually better to just do something twice rather than spend too much time thinking about it.
- nostrebored 4y agoThe question you have to ask is what is the trade off in the long term. Are these skills where development is frontloaded while gaming but happens naturally over time for other kids? I played games competitively as a kid. I did well cognitively. If I could go back and get the time back I would.
- dubeye 4y agoMy kid is 3.5. Would love to game with him but had assumed it was years off.... Any tips on games or consoles? I think I have an ancient ps4 in the attic somewhere but very open to buying new kit
- twostorytower 4y agoNintendo Switch. Animal Crossing? Breath of the Wild in a year or so.
- bcrosby95 4y agoMario Kart. The great thing is you can turn off the handicaps for yourself to make it a little more challenging to play with them. I regularly play with my 7 year and twin 4 year olds - we bought the switch about a year ago.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoTeach him arithmetic or how to read first. Or chess!
- odessacubbage 4y agoif you can dig up a hacked wii somewhere, that's probably a pretty perfect device for that age range. stuff like wii sports & just dance + the nintendo back catalogue is not a bad place to start.
- abledon 4y agoNow they need to segregate the people who play video games into primarily FPS (valorant/overwatch/COD/Battlefield etc..) vs other genres
- cwkoss 4y agoOr only play sports games
- hot_gril 4y agoI played a lot of video games as a kid because that's what other kids did. Probably taught me some logic skills, but I would've traded it for a real childhood and social skills. Self-exploring coding was far more educational anyway. Card/board games are a good in-between with a social component and without the mindless or consumerist aspect of some video games. My wife and I decided our kids won't have video games at home. We'll see how it goes.
- jacooper 4y ago> my wife and I decided our kids won't have video games. We'll see how it goes. I think you kid would feel excluded in school, when everyone is playing together online and talking about the latest games.
- hot_gril 4y agoIt can feel that way sometimes when something is popular, but it's never really everyone, usually not even the majority.
- annyeonghada 4y agoIs this such a strong component of the American teenager identity? I know exactly one person here (Southern Europe) who plays videogames and nobody talked about it. Sports, music, fashion, movies, politics: that were the things that could make you or break you in high school.
- jacooper 4y agoI don't live in America, so I don't know. I agree its not the biggest thing in high school, but in pre-teenage gaming is big, at least where I live.
- hot_gril 4y agoIt can be up to 1/2 of the class who plays them regularly and maybe 1/8 who talks about them a lot. I'm gen Z (married sorta young) and grew up in a city in California. The thing that'd exclude you more is not being on social media, but even then, not really.
- mberning 4y agoIt’s also associated with dropping out of college because of your hopeless WoW addiction.
- technovader 4y agoAnd you KNOW those are the people reading this study to feel good about their hobby "This makes me smart"
- mberning 4y agoWhen I was 14 I thought playing an RPG with lots of text was as good as, if not better, than reading a book.
- civilized 4y agoSince I see we're using this as an excuse for general video-gaming-and-parenting discussion... I'm currently very conflicted about video games for my son (7). He loves them but mom hates them and insists on a limit of 10 minutes per day. I am not sure she is wrong. I played a lot of games as a kid and I probably could have done better things with my time. Not that I got any guidance as to what those better things would have been, but still. At the same time, it seems like a lot of dads are bonding with their boys by playing games, and I wonder if I am missing out. I just don't know what to think.
- Globz 4y agoIn your situation I would give him an hour per day (10 minutes is a very short amount of time to do anything fun or see progress in most games) then monitor the outcome based on your previous baseline , does he ask for extra time when its time to call it quit, do you see a negative outcome on his grades, focus and desire to play outside or with other toys, etc. Then simply cut back if you see any downsides with 1 hour per day. You should definitely play with him during that time if you can, it is a great way to bond with your son and try to change the activity during the week, like play lego with him instead of gaming and see what will be his reaction when a video game is no longer involved. Video games are always good in moderation and there are definitely some great games for kids, exploring with him when searching for a new game will teach you a lot about about why he’s drawn to such and such game and this way you may be able to find other hobbies outside of gaming which are related to his interests.
- jacooper 4y ago> He loves them but mom hates them and insists on a limit of 10 minutes per day. Come on this is ridiculous! 10 minutes is nothing!. Maybe 2 or 3 hours, but 10 minutes? It will take him a full year to finish the first part of a game!, and will never allow him to discover games with depth and stories(my favorites), so he is going to play quick mobile games, which IMO are the worst. > I am not sure she is wrong. I played a lot of games as a kid and I probably could have done better things with my time. Not that I got any guidance as to what those better things would have been, but still. Games in my experience are a gateway to most of tech, for example my first interaction with networks and servers was when trying to create a Minecraft server to play with my friends. Like everything, doing it moderation is the best, I think 2 or 3 hours would be fitting(not that I had them personally), But please make sure there is actually something else for him to do, because otherwise he is going to spend the whole day waiting for these three hours. > At the same time, it seems like a lot of dads are bonding with their boys by playing games, and I wonder if I am missing out. Probably, your kid is also missing out on playing with his friends online. To this day gaming is one of the biggest ways to keep in touch with remote people for me. But that's just my own opinion.
- artur_makly 4y agomy only beef ( as a dad to a 10yr old ) is that at all the game he loves playing are incredibly bloody violent. - Far Cry - Assassin's Creed *exceptions ( Fortnite ) What kind of games do you recommend that can extend his critical thinking while increasing his focus? Lastly, is there a WYSIWYG game creation platform that is high-quality/fidelity? not Minecraft/Roblox. I see him making stuff in the game industry one day. p.s. HUGE props to Elon's edu platform: https://synthesis.is/ https://synthesis.is/ it's been worth every damn penny.
- Cognitron 4y agoPortal?
- waboremo 4y agoMario Maker 2 and Game Builder Garage are great for getting into game creation (or at the very least level creation). Super intuitive as well. As for extending critical thinking, I feel puzzle based games are great at this like Captain Toad Tracker. But also strategy games like Mario Rabbids are great because there's basic math mixed in with probability and action. Also games like Brother: A tale of two sons (which you can play with him) can go a long way to developing more complex feelings of empathy which might help him in the long run in regards to games that are just mindlessly super bloody violent. Psychonaut 2 is another great one, lots to talk about there and there's some action but it's never bloody.
- r00fus 4y agoMost games on Nintendo aren't that gory. Also lots of "card games" essentially boil down to math/statistics.
- tmtvl 4y agoWhen it comes to WYSIWYG game creation the name that immediately springs to mind is RPGMaker, though while the platforms are high quality, they are very much not high fidelity. WYSIWYG doesn't work that well together with high fidelity anyway, placing a thousand little griblets by hand can get tedious after a while.
- davidmurdoch 4y ago
- gchamonlive 4y agoI wonder if the industry incentives have shifted and if it impacts these cognitive benefits. Games changed a lot over the past two decades and I am not quite sure they preserve the same sense of challenge, opting for quick rewards and addictive mechanics.
- armchairhacker 4y agoMaybe, but games in general have actually gotten a lot more complex and difficult over the years. Look at any long-running series (e.g. Super Mario Bros, COD, Street Fighter), the newer games have more and more mechanics, and they are competing against newer franchises with the same complexity. Also look at the popularity of Elden Ring, rougelikes and other "hard mode" games. Even some F2P games like Clash of Clans have a surprising amount of complexity, some of it being the alternate currencies and addictive mechanics they use to get people to spend more. You may still be right about games not impacting cognition the same, as the complexity has shifted from mastering and creatively utilizing simple mechanics into learning convoluted ones. Also, older games were much less likely to have "easy mode" and there were no online guides, you had to figure out everything yourself. But even some modern games are like this (except for the "no online" part): "retro" and "indie" games like Slay the Spire and Celeste.
- yakattak 4y agoI think the reward systems have evolved differently than the gameplay systems. The reward systems are addictive but the gameplay has improved in a way that I think is more cognitively demanding. Puzzle games can be more creative with their puzzles, FPS games can add elements like a compass and ping systems, RPGs have these amazingly well written and told stories. Games these days definitely have the same sense of challenge (if not more, looking at you Soulslikes), even if losing still gets you a loot box. There was an interesting study done on children that talks about rewarding them for activities they like [1], and how it makes them start to dislike them which. It’s old (1973) but I’ve noticed some of the fatigue myself in the MMOs I play. [1]: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281453299_Undermining_Children%27s_Intrinsic_Interest_with_Extrinsic_Reward_A_Test_of_the_Overjustification_Hypothesis https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281453299_Undermini...
- 4y ago
- seventytwo 4y agoIt wouldn’t be surprising at all that a child’s relationship with video games is no different than their relationship to any other form of media - it can be constructive and educational and productive, or it can be a waste of precious time. Big AAA games can still be fun and formative, too. Discuss the meta aspects with the kids - what ads do they see inside the game? What team aspects or problems solving is needed? How are video games like the real world and how are they not? How much is the CIA involved in the plot lines of the latest CoD game?
- guelo 4y agoI'd be interested in measures of social and emotional intelligence.
- yucky 4y agoKids are playing more and more video games than ever before, and test scores across the board are way down to some of the lowest levels recorded. We conclude video games are helping kids. Something tells me they'll not be able to replicate this.
- doubled112 4y agoCorrelation does not equal causation?
- yucky 4y agoOf course not, I was just pointing out that the poorly designed study that goes against all of the actual observable data makes the results a bit suspect. Like many things, I suspect that in moderation video game playing doesn't have any impact on standardized testing. I suppose if this study can be replicated then we can all be thankful that excessive video game playing has made kids dumber at a lesser rate than they already would be.
- marmot777 4y agoOkay, I don’t have to feel as guilty when my son spends too much time on Minecraft and Roblox.
- marmot777 4y agoMy son does always try to improve the game creating, I think they are called modules or something, for Minecraft and full on games for Roblox so that’s some educational value.
- 1-6 4y agoBut what about exposing the brain to hours of fun and entertainment? That certainly may take a toll on kids adjusting to society when everything goes offline.
- hackitup7 4y agoThis isn't strictly about cognitive performance, but Diablo II taught me more about negotiation than anything I ever learned in school. You could also probably make the argument that it's one of the most stark examples of how diverse teams are more resilient to adversity.
- treis 4y agoTry a bunch of shit until it works is how you beat video games. Sometimes distressingly similar to what I do at work.
- b33j0r 4y agoI’d be a very different person without games when I was young. Got me into programming, thinking beyond my immediate reality… etc. More stimulation is probably good for development, that’s how pathways form, I have been told. Call me armchair “points out the obvious parts then gets pessimistic guy,” but we’ll likely never actually know if it’s a correlation in the time period that’s more consistent with like… the nutritional availability and parenting habits. Or for that matter The Osbornes going off the air? I suspect that a lot of our policy actions must be suspiciously based on suspicions until we make a major breakthrough in neurology or statistical analysis. Do what works for now. Seems like brains that are engaged have better outcomes than passive ones, let’s do that for now!
- mkoryak 4y agoI’d be a very different person if I played more video games when I was young. I spent a lot of my time outside exploring and playing games with my friends. Later in college when a lot of my peers were playing counter strike all day long I got into programming because I always wanted to learn how to do it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gnramires 4y agoI lived in apartments with not many play opportunities during my childhood, but virtual worlds provided pretty much that play environment for me (of course, with different risks and less whole body physical activity). The game was Tibia (it still exists), and it required a lot of planning, had all elements you'd want children to be immersed in, like: in-game mysteries (is it possible to solve X or Y quest, get a certain item, and so on?), some of which persist today (probably the remaining ones can't be solved), social interaction: you needed to trade with players for almost everything -- buying all equipment, even to use magic you were required to trade unless you could make them yourself), in-game economy, mechanically, the game wasn't too hard, it was very well balanced; a big element was finding where you could be more efficient to sustain your own advancement through the game; trading was a major gameplay element, making friends: for many, this was really the point of the game, just meeting people, talking for hours, finding where they came from (often distant countries I'd have no opportunity to visit); most activities greatly benefited from a group, although you could solo; coordination: you needed a really good attention and coordination to play in certain situations; most of all, you needed to understand your capability and the requirements to make sure you didn't lose weeks or even months of progress (the death penalty was something like 10% of your total playtime!). It's hard to overstate how much growth it afforded me and by brother -- the lessons are too numerous to cite, from interacting with people to managing risk on everything you do. We did recognize, even at the time though, that it could get us 'hooked' in a bad way -- and that the game was ultimately limited and there was a life outside (other activities) with a greater horizon. My brother just quit completely one day to never return; I always kept visiting the world out of curiosity and nostalgia. It really felt like having a wild virtual childhood. I still think about people I've met in that world some 20 years later. Unfortunately, some of the aspects that enabled this experience have been degraded significantly. The greatest loss was probably due to cheating and bots. Cheating was already possible, maybe right from the beginning, but it took a long time to develop and become widespread. At one point though, almost every serious player was cheating, and a significant portion using bots to automatically achieve high levels with low risk (or just amass fortunes and transfer to "clean" characters). Seeing no great alternative, the developer (Cipsoft) started to understandably introduce the various cheating systems (automatic aiming and item usage, etc.) into the game itself, reduce death penalties, and so on. It also copied other games that have automated markets and so on, and for a while bots almost ruined the game (only much later they got a deal with BattleEye that significantly improved the situation -- but the game was already changed). The game now is much less wild and much more like a single player experience. One very interesting aspect of the game is how much this wilderness is important but still very troublesome. The risk is what teaches risk management; but it also enables other player abuse. The possibility to kill and get killed was very scary (of course, maybe not as scary as many IRL risks), but it also built serious trust, when you had to trust your friend wouldn't turn against you for personal gain, find who to trust, etc.. It really showed what's ugly about humans at the same time as what's really amazingly beautiful -- some of the most kind and selfless people I've met were playing that game (and also a handful keen to set you back a long time just for pleasure). I think one way or another everyone that played it learned the value of cooperation in some way. I thought it was my yardstick of civilization to see if people would kill for fun when "it's just a game" (with serious in-game consequences for your victim) or act cooperatively -- I thought the ideal game was not one where you can't kill one another, but one you can, but almost no one does (I never subscribe to the notion that in game killing was "a fun part of the game" -- although I did see the allure of the loot; after all, not killing was also part of the game; in any case, you could always stop playing or opt for non-pvp servers, which most of my IRL friends did -- but I refused). A very interesting experiment just in life, is the least I can say. Note: There is a spiritual successor of the classic game going on in https://medivia.online/ https://medivia.online/ Be warned -- this kind of game is as much of a time sink (and perhaps as addictive) as it sounds; but if you feel ready for this sort of experience, it seems still possible; I haven't ever played Medivia.
- hayst4ck 4y agoNictone has been known to cause nootropic effects, yet it results in long term damage and dependence. Considering the gaming industry is big money (just like big tobacco, big weed, big sugar, and big infinite scroll), I would take any study like this with a boulder of salt. Video games might improve cognitive abilities, but they also cheat the reward centers of your brain and offer the feeling of success while achieving none. A Stanford professor was teaching a seminar on engagement (engagement is a euphemism for addiction). He has a pretty choice quote: "You will play my game thinking you're getting better and better, but you will just be playing longer and longer." Games can be a force for good, but the average game company is not optimizing for cognitive performance, they are optimizing for engagement (or loot boxes), the lack of alignment coupled with capitalist investment into games seems hazardous to the positive qualities they can have.
- djtango 4y agoAgree although if you can sift through the noise there are some gems about. For me, the golden era of games was SNES to PS2 as feels like the best mix of budget creativity and computing power. The industry was still figuring itself out back then. Games like Hollow Knight aspire to that older era too. That said, I recently picked up Overwatch 2 and I'm impressed at how high the skill ceiling is, the spatial and strategic reasoning to play that game semi-pro is definitely nontrivial and Blizzard are definitely a part of Big Gaming. >Games can be a force for good, but the average game company is not optimizing for cognitive performance Unsure if you have games like Factorio in mind or Nintendo brain games but games that are mechanically rich (eg Souls or Elder Scrolls) can give plenty for someone to reason about if they are already so inclined. I spent a lot of time thinking how to min/max from a very young age and it's a similar mindset to at least QA but also coding.
- govg 4y agoOverwatch 2, for all the criticism it gets has a really good core that has been worked on for a while now. It's a shame that good game and level design will be marred by Blizzard's monetisation and content policies. If you're in the market for more gems of games to play, Deep Rock Galactic is quite fantastic.
- Waterluvian 4y agoMy 5 year old makes redstone machines. His ability to navigate a minecraft world is ridiculously good. When I was 5 I was desperately trying to get over the first pit in Super Mario Bros.
- mizzao 4y agoVideo games prepared me for building a startup. Each game was a set of unfamiliar rules that I'd have to learn quickly and optimize decently well against. Once I got good enough to reach the upper echelons of a game, I'd get bored and do the same with a new one. Repeat with dozens of different games, and it's very similar to the feeling of all the new unfamiliar things one has to learn in building a company. Plus, the game that generates the closest feeling to building a startup as a whole has been Civilization :-) And, it turns out ideas from games can be useful in products too: https://parsnip.substack.com/p/tech-trees https://parsnip.substack.com/p/tech-trees
- whimsicalkiwi 4y ago
- whimsicalkiwi 4y ago
- tastysandwich 4y agoJust curious if it accounted for other factors, like socio-economic status? also of note: Further, the researchers stress that this cross-sectional study does not allow for cause-and-effect analyses, and that it could be that children who are good at these types of cognitive tasks may choose to play video games. Also surely the type of video game plays a huge role. I can't imagine hours spent killing bots in Unreal Tournament did me much good. But I did learn words like "critical" and "paralysis" from playing Pokemon Yellow. One thing I do credit to video games - and I'm sure is similar with a large number of HN'ers - is my current career in software engineering. Installing cracks, mods, skins, etc. You learn about the file system, how to edit files, anti-virus software (to check the cracks you downloaded), and how to reinstall Windows XP when the crack turned out to be a virus.
- giobox 4y agoGiven the long list of caveats attributed to the results, it does seem like not much credence was given at this stage to filtering out other external factors leaving that to further research. It's secretly pleasing to think gaming might have made me smart as a kid, but I suspect as with so many things in education its socio-economic status. They looked at kids able to spend "3 or more hours a day" gaming. That requires a pretty stable homelife on top of the budget for the games etc etc - something I was lucky enough to have growing up, but not true of everyone.
- aaron695 4y ago
- throwaway0asd 4y agoThey separated these children into two groups, those who reported playing no video games at all and those who reported playing video games for three hours per day or more. So what happened to the 50% of total children that were somewhere between 0 and 3 hours per days of games? Were they discarded or rounded into one those two groups, because that leaves a huge gap in the middle?
- ummonk 4y agoYes, smarter kids with higher attention spans will play video games for more hours in a day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- foobarbecue 4y agoI owe it all to Lemmings
- makach 4y agoThat is no surprise considering the complexity of some games. We're not playing space invaders anymore. The learning curve of some games are off the chart whilst still making learning addictive. Game makers have access to extreme resources, psychology, graphics, music and coding frameworks that enables them to push entertainment as any illegal drug - except **mostly** without the bad side effects. Gamers also have access to these resources when consuming this content.
- nirvgorilla 4y agoCrash Bandicoot taught me to stay away from the voodoo.™
- Cwizard 4y agoI’ll be honest, I didn’t read the article but I learned a lot from video games and by extend the internet when I was a kid. It thought me that if you work on something, you will get better at it, and you will be rewarded. This is not the case for a lot of other things in the life of a teenager. If you work hard at school you aren’t really rewarded, you just have to pass (binary outcome) and if you do an extra project it’s not like you get extra points. If you take a student job, you don’t get a raise when do a good job, you just get more work. If it wasn’t for video games the lessons I would have learned was that you should do the bare minimum not to fail/get fired. Which is a really sad attitude to have.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> This is not the case for a lot of other things in the life of a teenager. If you work hard at school you aren’t really rewarded, you just have to pass (binary outcome) and if you do an extra project it’s not like you get extra points. Thank you for saying this. The point itself is something I knew and concluded on my own, but the way you phrased it made me realize that, as a parent, it will be my job to provide a structure on top of school, that rewards my kids somewhat proportionally to effort. As opposed to parents giving near-binary (5+ is good, 4 is meh, 3 sucks, 2 or below and the belt is out) rewards otherwise uncorrelated with effort, which was my experience as a kid, as well as others in my cohort I talked about this with.
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoYes, just do not forgett to have the kid do some sport and be active, that helps as well.
- bestest 4y agoHow much time do your 4-5 year-olds spend playing video games on a daily / weekly / monthly basis?
- rpigab 4y agoRelated, 2012 study : "Learning, attentional control and action video games" C.S. Green and D. Bavelier https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3461277/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3461277/
- imsaw 4y agoI credit Dota 2 for the habbit of reading frequent changelogs and adaptation of new features (hero and item patches) and strategy. Generally, multiplayer (competitive) games are exciting as we get the adrenaline rush from out smarting our opponent. But there's always a point where you feel the repetitiveness and lack of purpose as you get to the average level but not enough dedication to compete with professional atheletes.
- lucasfcosta 4y agoI'll add the classic comment here: "correlation does not mean causation". Maybe it's the kids with better cognitive performance that like videogame better. I wouldn't find that unlikely considering it's more mentally stimulating than other "real-world" activities. Also, I personally learned to code by writing bots for an MMORPG, so I definitely owe my career to videogames.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tmalsburg2 4y agoCausality also doesn't need to be unidirectional. Perhaps cognitive performance has an impact on video gaming, but video gaming likely also has some impact on cognitive performance.
- thesz 4y agoI play Serious Sam to better focus on other tasks. I do so because I cannot walk long hours as I did before for exactly same purpose. If you ask me, I'd better walk. But I can't. PS Walking releases brain-derived neurotrophic factor, playing FPS does not.
- theclansman 4y agoI would also add that it's impossible to find direct causation in psychology or sociology because it's impossible to have all the variables when it comes to humans. So this is the best we can get.
- SergeAx 4y agoI had an access to personal computers in my school after classes, most of the time we were gaming. After some time teacher said that games are not allowed anymore except ones we wrote ourselves. That's how my software engineer career started.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoMaybe it is more of a gender difference. I have yet to encounter a boy who doesn't like some kind of videogame but not so for girls... But this would mean that intelligence in not distributed equally among gender.
- tunnuz 4y agoAs an Italian teenager in the 90s, Ultima Online was the reason why my English vocabulary was so rich compared to my peers. I strongly believed it has contributed to me traveling and experiencing living abroad, which has since defined my life.
- nunodonato 4y agoSame for me. I still credit video games to my higher-than-average English. I remember playing RPGs (savage empire) with a dictionary by my side
- LatteLazy 4y agoWe really need to ban studies that are just designed to find "associations" or correlations etc. They're useless. They just waste resources that could be used to find actual causation and fuel people talking about things no one actually knows which just reenforces people's prejudices.
- CarnunMP 4y agoHaven't read the study (and tbh I'm skeptical of such scientism, e.g. reading too much into FMRI tea leaves). But perhaps one thing in the mix here, if there is indeed an effect, is that kids who get more time to themselves to pursue what's interesting to them and play, away from meddling adults who know what's better for them, develop faster. Or indeed kids whose parents share their interests and play with them.
- CarnunMP 4y agoIncidentally I was struck recently by how rarely in this talk[1] Jon Blow says 'children' or 'kids' when he's clearly talking about young humans. Instead it's just 'people'. :) [1] Video Games and the Future of Education: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWFScmtiC44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWFScmtiC44
- carabiner 4y agoI didn't learn anything from hours of Counter-strike, half-life, flight sims (ok this taught me some aviation trivia) as a teenager. I deeply regret these hours, as I could have spent them outdoors hiking, rock climbing, running. Maybe even talking to girls and building better social skills.
- tralarpa 4y agoI thought the same about my passion for Lego-style construction toys. Then, as a 25-year-old, I had to build something out of cardboard with people about the same age. It was really surprising to see that they had no intuitive understanding at all of trivial things like "which side do I start from" or "this thing is wobbling and needs a little reinforcement at the corner" (I am not talking about "complicated" things like gears and robots etc.). So, who knows what you learned from those games?
- insanitybit 4y agoMy mother always assumed this was the case, and as such she supported me playing video games. Her feeling was that it was fundamentally puzzle solving and hand eye coordination.
- numlock86 4y ago> Executing problem solving tasks in virtually limitless different domains in a rewarding and fun way may be associated with better cognitive performance in children Wow, you don't say ...
- Filligree 4y agoBut it's fun! Nothing fun can be good for you!
- maartn 4y agoRead about the methods: They used visual cues on computer screens to test who was better in responding to visual cues on computer screens. Let me guess.... The kids who were experienced in responding to visual cues on computer screens scored better (-‸ლ)
- veidelis 4y agoHow could you!
- devpl 4y agosure, this is why depression cases are rising
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 31337Logic 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33356876 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33356876
- pombrand 4y agoI credit Battlefield 1942 for helping me waste my time in highschool leaving me with bad grades and hollow experiences.
- stuckinhell 4y agoI'm guessing narrative games or walking simulators aren't included. I have definitely seen video games that have difficult puzzles or complex game loops focus my kids on problem solving and how to use tools like notepad or something at their disposal. However as they are on the internet more and more, I think they are getting lazy and just getting the answers from youtube.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoI "grew" my young mind with Civilization, Railroad Tycoon, X-Com, Master of Magic, Master of Orion II, Alpha Centauri, a bit of Dune and other RTS games. I also read a ton of books. I am not sure if this was all great or not. But I guess it gave me some sort of benefit overall.
- LittleBox 4y agoI always find it hard to say anything of value about a subject like this. I used to not believe in these things at all. But now that I think about it, gaming did get me into programming with Roblox. I'm also quite adept at puzzle solving and in general spotting things that are out of the ordinary. I guess I could attribute that to my great love for the legend of Zelda series but I'm no expert in this field. So, who knows...
- marquislek 4y agoI credit pokemon for teaching me the value of diversified skill sets in team building also that 6 level 10 charmanders is not the same as 1 level 60 charizard