6 ms·
Most people on antidepressants don’t need them
- mikece 4y agoYou could probably swap "antidepressants" for any number of drugs and it's still a true statement.
- Fnoord 4y agoCorrect, and also, antidepressants are used for more reasons that to remedy depression (though that may well be their primary purpose). E.g. I use them to combat GAD, though it stems from ASD.
- ldoughty 4y agoI think antidepressants are getting the spotlight because some (many) were approved with only a slim <10% improvement over a placebo... I think the same could be said about the congestion medication phenylephrine [1] (edit: added specific drug name. edit 2: added link) I get the feeling that drug approval laxed for a good while and let these slip through [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17264159/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17264159/
- cameronh90 4y agoI'm not sure how universal this is, but for me, phenylephrine is literally just side effects. It still makes my anxiety worse, but does nothing for my congestion.
- KvanteKat 4y agoWithout knowing the exact approval history in the US, I doubt that it is a lax approval process as much as it is an absence of better alternatives. There are not really any known effective clinical interventions (be they in the form of medicine, therapy, or things like more exercise), and a 10% improvement is better than nothing (clinical therapy (notably Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) is generally believed to be more effective but not by that much and it is financially out of reach for many people who are able to afford medication).
- kraussvonespy 4y agoMore on this from Derek Lowe of Things I Won’t Work With fame: https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/uselessness-phenylephrine https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/uselessness-phenyl...
- LatteLazy 4y agoFor most other drugs the effectiveness is openly disclosed to patents. Also most other drugs have fewer, rarer, less severe side effects. And most other drugs can be stopped and started much more easily...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- greymalik 4y agohttps://archive.ph/kvVIf https://archive.ph/kvVIf
- dsr_ 4y agoIf you give a single person medical advice, you can be sued for malpractice. If you propose medical policy for millions, you can be an anonymous staffer at The Economist. [Needs citations.]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vmilner 4y agoThe anonymous "Voice of God" conceit always puts me off The Economist.
- spookyuser 4y agoI can tell this thread is going to be a nightmare but whatever I really want to share my experience in case there are people similar to me that need to hear this: I cannot emphasise enough how much Escitalopram (lexapro) has helped me with issues I didn't even know I had until I started taking it. At which point I realised I was living in a constant state of anxiety up to that point, and I probably should have been on it a long time ago, but I never ever thought I reached the criteria for being "medicated" so fwiw I think it's also possible to underrate your own feelings and think you don't need them when you do.
- viiralvx 4y agoMe too! I used to be anxious about everything going on in my life. When I started Lexapro and it finally started working, I realized, "Wow, is that what normalcy feels like?" It's been a lifesaver.
- 0_____0 4y agoI also used to have general, ever present anxiety, but never was medicated for it. It seems to have abated by around age 29 to a large extent. One thing that helped was finding a group of friends who loved and accepted me as I was. Really a key moment in dealing with the social component of anxiety. I think pharmaceutical intervention and my path are both valid, but it's way harder to prescribe "friends who love you in the right way."
- viiralvx 4y agoOh trust, my friends are amazing and great. But doesn't stop the always present anxiety of everything collapsing and going wrong. Worked on some CBT to also help me manage it, but medicine has been a really great solution for me, in my opinion. And honestly, I feel like my anxiety has gotten worse as I've aged, I wasn't anxious at all like this in college and I'm now 30.
- leeroyjenkins11 4y agoSo we're the drugs able to help you get past the anxiety enough to figure out what the root was or assist in CBT? I always fear that psych drugs are used to mask the root cause.
- eyeball 4y agohttps://archive.ph/kvVIf https://archive.ph/kvVIf
- lbriner 4y agoI'm a bit nervous about these articles clearly centred on the USA which seems to have an epidemic of private drug companies pushing all kinds of stuff via doctors who may or may not be getting backhanders to push certian drugs. I'm not saying this isn't partially true in Europe but the USA definitely comes across as choosing drugs as the first resort for many things that you wouldn't in Europe. Also, as many have found out, Prozac is cheaper than therapy or CBT which is what some people might benefit from to actually help them resolve the vicious circle of depression.
- elzbardico 4y agoSadly, while this is more rampant in the US, it happens in other places too.
- _visgean 4y agoHere are some OECD stats: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_antidepressant_consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_antidepre... here is that data with US included: https://www.businessinsider.com/countries-largest-antidepressant-drug-users-2016-2?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/countries-largest-antidepres... (tho i am not sure i would trust BI with anything..) Certainly seems relevant to quite a few european countries. And even more relevant to developing countries to not follow us in that way..
- chrisseaton 4y ago> pushing all kinds of stuff via doctors And also pushing directly to the consumer via commercial advertising, which is very unusual. Not sure which way is right though. Maybe people have a right to know about which drugs are available, unscreened by a doctor who may not have your best interests in mind (for example they have to meet a budget, or they have religious opinions.)
- Auracle 4y agoI’ve always thought the fact that there are commercials for cancer drugs is very telling. Surely your oncologist will put you on what’s best, right? I’ve never had cancer but my experience with plenty of other doctors points the other way, and that they wouldn’t be spending money on those commercials if they didn’t get a return from them.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt can on one hand be argued antidepressants aren't necessary for anyone. You can argue that and be correct. This is because antidepressants don't actually cure depression, but lessen the symptoms and enable severe depression to be cured through behavioral changes. It's a line of reasoning that is technically true but really sort of missing the point. The problem with treating depressed people is to get them to actually do the things that will help them. That can be incredibly difficult without medication.
- KvanteKat 4y ago> The problem with treating depressed people is to get them to actually do the things that will help them. That can be incredibly difficult without medication. The problem with talking about doing "things that will help them" is that we don't really have a lot of effective clinical interventions. Even the most common interventions (SSRIs, Congnitive Behavioral Therapy, physical exercise, etc.) are not really that effective at treating depression and have little to no effect in large parts of the affected population. That being said, these treatments _do_ work for some people so they should definitely not be dismissed out of hand (although it may in some cases be regression to the mean more than anything else, i.e. if you get better after a while on your own but have undergone treatments of one form or another you may erroneously believe your most recent treatment was effective).
- andreyk 4y agoPretty short article, this quote sums it up: "When the results of all trials submitted to America’s medicines regulator between 1979 and 2016 were scrutinised by independent scientists, it turned out that antidepressants had a substantial benefit beyond a placebo effect in only 15% of patients." It's unclear what paper they refer to, as it is not linked. This article (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK361016/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK361016/) has many citations to papers that cover this stuff. I think the important take away is in "Antidepressant drug effects and depression severity: a patient-level meta-analysis" (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20051569/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20051569/): "Results: Medication vs placebo differences varied substantially as a function of baseline severity. Among patients with HDRS scores below 23, Cohen d effect sizes for the difference between medication and placebo were estimated to be less than 0.20 (a standard definition of a small effect). Estimates of the magnitude of the superiority of medication over placebo increased with increases in baseline depression severity and crossed the threshold defined by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence for a clinically significant difference at a baseline HDRS score of 25. Conclusions: The magnitude of benefit of antidepressant medication compared with placebo increases with severity of depression symptoms and may be minimal or nonexistent, on average, in patients with mild or moderate symptoms. For patients with very severe depression, the benefit of medications over placebo is substantial. " Short version: if your depression is mild, antidepressants may not work better than a placebo (though placebos are not exactly nothing). If it's severe, there is more of a chance it'll really help, From my personal experience, I can definitely attest to them helping, though they are not by any means a magic bullet.
- bezier-curve 4y agoWhat these articles seem to ignore is that depression is only one disorder they're approved to treat. They're approved for GAD, OCD, and a host of other anxiety related disorders.
- petesergeant 4y agoI do note that everyone (including myself) who's promoting Lexapro on this thread is talking about the positive effects it had on their anxiety
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jansan 4y agoI was about to write that there clearly are huge differences betwween the US and the rest of the world, but it seems some European countries have caught up with the US, especially Iceland, with more than 140 daily doses per 1000 adults [1]. Interestingly Iceland frequently has one of the top positions in the world happiness report [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_antidepressant_consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_antidepre... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Happiness_Report#2022_World_Happiness_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Happiness_Report#2022_Wo...
- broken_glass 4y agoAren't areas near North Pole dealing with more seasonal depression due to lack of light in winter months?
- jansan 4y agoIt seems so. I wonder how much can be compensated with Vitamin D supplements or light therapy.
- mrweasel 4y agoGiven that the lack of light can cause depression, it would be more prevalent the further North (or South) you go as the conditions aren't present at the equator. What would be interesting to know is if people who live in the more Northern regions are more resistant to seasonal depressions, compared to some one from Southern Europe or the Middle East.
- cameronh90 4y agoStatements like this need to be worded very carefully. In many people's minds, saying something like "most people don't need antidepressants" quickly becomes "antidepressants are useless". Many people who may benefit from them get scared away. Speaking as someone who has been on/off antidepressants for GAD+OCD for the better part of a decade, I've had countless people tell me that antidepressants are useless and just placebo pills pushed by Big Pharma. But for me, they are life changing. They turn me from someone who just sits indoors having panic attacks all day to someone who can live a relatively normal life. I've tried (and continue to have) therapy, but SSRIs are wonder drugs for myself and many other people. The caveat is, you often need to try 2 or 3 different SSRIs before you find one that works for you, and if you're unlucky, you may not find one, or the side effects can be intolerable. For me, I tried fluoxetine and citalopram, neither of which really worked, but sertraline changed everything almost overnight. The only side effect I've experienced is weight gain, which isn't great, but is better than the alternative. However, this is the UK which may have a different attitude to the drugs. Before and during initial treatment, I was provided with around 20 behavioural therapy sessions, and even now I still have quarterly drug reviews with a doctor. At no point did I feel like I was being pushed onto SSRIs, and they checked to make sure it wasn't something environmental that could be easily remedied before asking if I would like to consider medication.
- aa-jv 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sirsinsalot 4y ago> Be careful what you pimp These aren't drugs you can just ask for (in the UK) at least and the parent wasn't "pimping". Undermining someone's account of their positive experience using therapeutic drugs because of your own bias shows an astounding lack of compassion.. Getting help, help that often involves therapeutic drugs to bootstrap other life changes _is_ taking responsibility. Your comment neatly sums up the toxic attitude of "I don't understand it so it must be bad". Put your ego aside and listen to people living with seriously debilitating neurological issues that you fortunately do not.
- benevol 4y agoThe first question has always been the same: What does the pharmaceutical industry need?
- janandonly 4y agoOpen door, meet obvious. Obvious, meet open door.
- hexage1814 4y ago“Buy things you don't need with money you don't have to impress people you don't like”
- z33k 4y agoI went through a phase in my life a few years ago where I tried most antidepressants available in my European country. All were prescribed to me at varying doses by a psychiatrist working in our public health system. Almost every single antidepressant gave me withdrawal symptoms (extremely intense mood swings and brain zaps) when I tried decreasing the dose. I mentioned this to my psychiatrist, who advised me to split the pills in order to slowly decrease the dosage. Even splitting the pills and taking a quarter of a pill less every 2 weeks was giving me withdrawal symptoms. I resorted to carefully dissolving the medication in water and volumetrically dosing to get the right rate of tapering off. This scenario happened to me with both Sertraline and Fluoxetine. The "newer" antidepressants like Escitalopram and Vortioxetine gave me less withdrawal symptoms, but they also had more severe side-effects whilst on the medication. Obviously this is all anecdotal, but my hope is that doctors would put greater emphasis on the possible adverse effects of antidepressants to patients. No other class of medication has been so... rough? for me. Glad to be medication-free now.
- awestroke 4y agoMost people on coffee do not need it.
- xwdv 4y agoI’ve never been on antidepressants but I had a period in my life where I went through a long depression. Inevitably I came to accept I was depressed because my body was telling me something in my life just wasn’t right, and I suspected what it was but didn’t really make an effort to do something about it. Once I made necessary changes things started getting better with time and eventually I got back to normal. However, if I had been on meds I doubt I would have had this sort of introspection and probably would not have bothered changing anything as long as I felt good. I think a lot of people are resistant to real change and antidepressants just help them cope indefinitely.
- caddemon 4y agoPrescription of antidepressants really should be coupled with therapy (and often is), which if done right should prompt plenty of introspection. Also in those with severe depression, functioning is so low it can be difficult to even engage in therapy or make life changes without other treatment first. I think you make an interesting broader point though. Clinically there is not enough consideration of life circumstances when evaluating depression, in my opinion. Obviously something like a death in the family is taken into account, but from what I've seen baseline quality of life is not a huge consideration in whether depressive symptoms are clinically meaningful. I suspect antidepressants would be more effective if this were better teased out. In any event, there are certainly interesting philosophical and policy questions here, but for an individual that suspects depression, they should seek professional help regardless. A good clinician is not going to just prescribe meds and then tell the patient they're done.
- xwdv 4y agoI view overcoming depression similar to weight loss. A lot of people will try hard on their own or with the help of someone else to achieve it, but at the end of the day it’d be far easier to shove a pill down someone’s throat rather than convince them to change their lifestyle and values, simply because most people will try and fail anyway. With the right mindset, I think you could overcome any depression naturally if you are willing to really reconfigure your life and can endure the change. The deeper in it you are, the harder it will be of course, but I think it’s possible.
- sirsinsalot 4y agoLike it or not, you are your neurology. You are your synaptic structure, you are your neurotransmitters. This trick of conscious self awareness doesn't trump neurology. You can't meditate out of physical systems malfunctioning any more than you can meditate away a broken leg. These drugs are like casts for broken bones. Just because you can't see the broken system doesn't make it less physical. Get a cast. Heal the anatomy. Try and walk again.
- swayvil 4y ago>Like it or not, you are your neurology. You are your synaptic structure, you are your neurotransmitters. Yeah, but look who's saying that. Your neurology etc. By that logic the cast of Seinfeld is a tribe of gnomes living inside your tv.
- sirsinsalot 4y agoNot really, I'm just saying you are your neurons and their configuration and function. If not, what are "you"? There's nothing else but the state and mechanics in your brain and their interface with the world. I appreciate for some, this fact is scary. For some, it undermines odd outdated ideas of soul or spirit. That doesn't make it less true. Sometimes this complex, organic, non-deterministic, environment coupled, feedback driven system ... gets out of balance and needs help.
- swayvil 4y agoYou are merely reiterating your argument, with an accusation of fear and religion on top.
- sirsinsalot 4y agoYour comments were not a rebuttal of mine, just a vague "doesn't sound right to me". So ..
- amanaplanacanal 4y ago
- gilded-lilly 4y agoI’m someone who has dealt with mental health issues over the course of my life. The main causes are the following: 1) Illicit drug use. 2) Stress/anxiety/fear/grief The answer is to accept the hard truths and understand what is the root cause of your depression. Is it lack of friends and family? Lack of hope for the future? Lack of enjoyment in things that previously made you happy? Belief that somehow success/truth comes at the expense of enjoyment of life (“ignorance is bliss”). Is it past trauma? A job/relationship you hate? Body/health issues? Aging? Feeling like you’ve achieved all your dreams but you’re more unhappy than ever? Bullying? Feeling unsatisfied? Unfulfilled? Shame about past behaviors? All of these problems have solutions. Figure out what is at the core of your problem, and then treat it. Every problem is different. For me, I realized I was harboring an incredible amount of pent up rage and resentment. The rage was so deep that it was all I could think about. Then I realized, I had to forgive the people who’d wronged me. And forgive them I did. I genuinely forgave them, in my own mind. And just like that, all my happiness came back to me. Suddenly I was free. Also, I believe that almost all of our problems can be traced back to fear. So stop worrying. It’s a waste of energy. There are some mental health issues that do require hospitalization and a short stint of medication to get people back on their feet and able to function. But I don’t believe in long term medication. Drugs are not the answer.
- TchoBeer 4y ago>The answer is to accept the hard truths and understand what is the root cause of your depression. Is it lack of friends and family? Lack of hope for the future? Lack of enjoyment in things that previously made you happy? Belief that somehow success/truth comes at the expense of enjoyment of life (“ignorance is bliss”). Is it past trauma? A job/relationship you hate? Body/health issues? Aging? Feeling like you’ve achieved all your dreams but you’re more unhappy than ever? Bullying? Feeling unsatisfied? Unfulfilled? Shame about past behaviors? some of these things (body/health issues, bad job/relationship, lack of friends) are causes which can be fixed with direct action. Some (aging, past behaviors, trauma, lack of family) can't be, but can be somewhat mitigated and be made less depressing with therapy. Others (lack of hope, anhedonia, lack of fulfillment) are not the cause of depression but the symptoms. to lump these all together seems strange to me.
- swayvil 4y agoI have these friends. Husband and wife. Rich. Academic. Political. Both on antidepressants. They get a dog. Beautiful white german shepherd. Dog is a bit wild. So they consult a "dog psychiatrist". Psychiatrist puts dog on antidepressants. Why not a few weeks of Doggy Dicipline Academy? It's common to get german shepherds a bit of training. "Nope" says the psychiatrist. "That would be cruel". They worship that psychiatrist. Dingalings.
- imperio59 4y agoThe number of shills and bots for big pharma on this thread are saddening. If you want to see the real horrors of these drugs check out https://ssristories.org/ https://ssristories.org/ ...
- rjh29 4y agoWeird take, they genuinely work for 15% of people, it says so right in the article. Me included.
- lm28469 4y agoI think we'll look back to this era the same way we currently look back at the time we prescribed heroin for all kinds of things: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/38/Drug_store_sign_for_products_Heroin_and_Aspirin_before_US_Heroin_ban_1924.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/38/Drug_sto... The fact that they work and helped people isn't mutually exclusive with the fact that they're abused, over prescribed and have crazy side effects
- seattle_spring 4y agoIt's interesting to see comments like this gain traction in reference to anti-depressants, but get heavily criticized when they are pointed at ADHD meds.
- Zak 4y agoWhat this suggests to me is that what we diagnose as "depression" has multiple causes, and current antidepressants are fairly effective at treating at least one of them. It's as if we had a single category for "breathing trouble" and consistently treated it with antibiotics. Sometimes it's bacterial pneumonia and that works very well. Often it's emphysema or lung cancer, and antibiotics don't help.
- eduction 4y agoI find it interesting that the article doesn’t describe a single harm from the drugs, instead focusing on alleged weak efficacy. My theory is that the article is playing into a vaguely Protestant ethos that drugs are Bad and Unnatural and thus suspect, and (implicitly) that suffering is actually good to some extent and that alleviating it through “artificial” means is unnatural. This attitude is ubiquitous in the US and I assume UK (where Economist originates) as well. Even artificial sweeteners are ridiculously scrutinized and suspect for the same reason. If some or even many people are taking what the article calls “useless” drugs, how is that, absent serious side effects, bad?
- niffydroid 4y agoThis article approaches the drugs for being used to treat depression. I am on 2 anti depressants and not because I have depression. I take Fluoxetine in the morning to help with my foggy head due to fibromyalgia. I then take Amitriptyline in the evening to help with chronic pain so I can get to sleep. A lot of drugs are licensed to treat X but doctors will use them to treat Y.
- amai 4y agoTry Vitamin B1 as antidepressant: Cheap and basically no side effect: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26984349/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26984349/ Especially some B1 analogues like Benfotiamine and Sulbutiamine are promising: https://nootropicsexpert.com/sulbutiamine/ https://nootropicsexpert.com/sulbutiamine/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_B1_analogues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_B1_analogues
- pipeline_peak 4y agoI've taken Prozac zoloft mirtazapine Cymbalta, and wellbutrin, probably a few more I can't remember. They all made me incredibly anxious, like I could jump off a building. I dknt know why. I'm about to schedule with a psychiatrist for Lexapro, wish me luck.
- ziroshima 4y agoI view depression as the result of a faulty process. It seems to me that it's mistake to take a drug to correct these symptoms, rather than learning to control one's thoughts and perspectives.
- m_a_g 4y agoI think SSRIs must be analyzed separately for depression and anxiety disorders. SSRIs are only marginally better than a placebo for depression. But they are incredibly beneficial for panic disorders and GAD (a bit anecdotal). Still, they will not "get rid of" panic disorders and GAD; only CBT or other therapies can do that. But SSRIs should not be dismissed easily for anxiety disorders, especially if the alternative is using Xanax or recreational drugs (including alcohol).
- joemazerino 4y agoAnecdotally I don't know a single person with solid life habits (exercise, meditation, social interaction, belief and practice with God, engagement with nature) that are on anti-depressants. I kicked the habit myself some years ago and haven't looked back. In comparison, everyone I know on antidepressants are massively deficient in certain areas and refuse to work on them.
- thenerdhead 4y agoHaving read Brave New World again as an adult, I found it to be quite related to this theme. Related: https://lithub.com/aldous-huxley-foresaw-americas-pill-popping-addiction-with-eerie-accuracy https://lithub.com/aldous-huxley-foresaw-americas-pill-poppi...
- joflicu 4y agoIt's not clear that I need mine either. But whenever I try to get off my medication (Effexor), I just can't: with a month, I am having debilitating anxiety and suicidal thoughts. I have to live with horrible side effects for the rest of my life.
- 0xCAP 4y ago"Dreamland" by Sam Quinones has everything you need in the subject. Terrific read, top 10 IMHO.
- jeffwask 4y agoMaybe don't take medical advice from an Economics e-zine.
- renewedrebecca 4y ago
- prego_xo 4y agoIt's people like you who keep the world turning.
- dang 4y ago(We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33272853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33272853)
- stillbourne 4y agoWho needs or doesn't need antidepressants is a conversation that should be had between a doctor and their patient and is frankly none of the business of the economist.
- Melatonic 4y agoDangerous title for this article and I am not sure I like it. That being said I personally think lack of exercise and desk jobs are having a very big negative effect on mental health in general. For anyone that has owned a dog - especially a larger high energy dog - what happens when you keep that dog inside all day and do not take it on walks or let it run? What if you then also provided it with all of its favourite food and plenty of fun dog TV shows and games and stimuli but still forced it to sit in a 500 sq ft box all the time? The dog would go nuts - anyone who has owned one knows this - they become an anxious mess. Some of them become self destructive, some of them become neurotic and repeat weird behaviours, and some just sit there and look sad. Are we really all that different than dogs?
- PeterStuer 4y agoSSRI's don't remedy depression. They regulate depression related anxiety. They do not cure deptession, just mitigate a sympton.
- Jordrok 4y agoArticle seems to be a bit short on numbers in general, and surely this is a complex topic, but this part stood out to me: > Doctors rarely talk to patients about stopping the drugs because they fear this could lead to a return of depressive symptoms. But for many people it may be safe to stop. Even among long-term users with several past episodes of depression, a recent trial in Britain showed that 44% of patients could stop taking pills safely. Those don't exactly seem like hugely encouraging numbers.
- taylodl 4y agoMaybe the Economist should try staying in their lane? From some of their recent articles I'd say they struggle enough with finance and the economy.
- PointyFluff 4y agoNot only are news articles like this terribly ignorant they are dangerous. I'm all for freedom of speech, but when your speech hurts people there need to be consequences.