23 ms·
Apple is quietly pushing a TV ad product with media agencies
- micromacrofoot 4y agoThis feels inevitable. When you chase growth infinitely ads becoming more appealing over time.
- mholm 4y agoI'm wondering if this is going to be the start of a lower cost tier, or perhaps raising the price to watch without ads? I don't think Apple could get away with normal ads on Apple TV without an option to get rid of them, even if it's a light touch.
- dave78 4y agoI feel like it's inevitable now that all streaming services are going to add an ad-based tier. Initially it will just be a cheaper option and you'll still be able to pay for an ad-free experience, but I am concerned that eventually the ad-free option will go away. It probably depends on how much money the services can make from advertising per subscriber per month - but it seems plausible that ads could be worth more per subscription to the streaming services than the $10ish dollars a month most of them charge.
- Abekkus 4y agoThe sad thing that sticks in my head is that, if you’re the person who could afford the higher tier ad-free experience, you’re also worth more to the advertisers than people who can’t afford ad-free. so if ad-based free tiers are profitable at all, then they are going to be more profitable than the paid subscriptions, and ad-free options will go away.
- ridgered4 4y agopavlov suggests companies now just sell the high value ad-free users data so they can be targeted by ads elsewhere in their lives while the source service remains (technically) ad free, which makes a sickening amount of sense.
- Someone1234 4y agoSee, I think they'll creep ads into the "adless" tier, and it will become a "less ads" tier in reality. Paramount+ already does this with their "adless" tier, it has ads. Unskippable ads.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIdeally, that would qualify for action from FTC or whatever government agency is responsible for businesses advertising one thing and selling another.
- Someone1234 4y agoThey'll just call it the "Ad Light" tier then.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat is fine. Ads on an “adless” tier is fraud.
- hexo 4y agoLower cost tier and Apple? Nope. Just normal (very high) cost and maybe much highier cost. IMHO
- AyyWS 4y agoiPhone SE, iPad, and the MacBook Air all disagree with you. I feel like this is the cheapest Apple products have ever been. My grandma had a colorful $2000 Apple laptop in early 2000s and you can get a MacBook Air now for $1000. That's a heck of a price decline without figuring inflation.
- account-5 4y agoI wouldn't call any of those low cost. Only relative to other Apple products might they be considered "cheaper".
- squeaky-clean 4y agoChromebooks start around $150, and perform well at around $400 and are perfect for the grandma use-case
- AyyWS 4y agoI wasn't very clear. She had a mac laptop around 1998 or so.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoI meant it in response to "you can get a MacBook Air now for $1000". It is the cheapest of the Apple laptops but it's not a particularly cheap laptop.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI was pretty surprised at how shit ChromeOS' accessibility features are, when my elderly dad got one, considering their market is basically young kids and old people.
- philistine 4y agoThey've done a ton of free content already, like Baseball or Jon Stewart and if I had to bet they're rushing to put ads on all the free access they're giving. Whether or not we'll see an ad-supported tier depends on how popular their other hobbled tiers are. The Apple Music paid tier but only with access through Siri comes to mind.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- neilv 4y agoThat has precedent (including with YouTube and Kindles), and I always assume that the platform owner did the math. But it's interesting to me because I'd guess that the people with disposable income and willing to spend it on luxuries (including not seeing ads)... would be among the most valuable targets of consumer product/service advertisers.
- pavlov 4y agoThat's why the streaming platform can sell those users' data at a premium to a platform like Facebook. When the platform does reach that user with an ad placement somewhere else, that spot is valuable.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoMy girlfriend just canceled her Hulu last night because they just raised the rates on even the ad-supported tier.
- jsonne 4y agoThis is inevitable for basically every media service whether its streaming music like Spotify, connected tv like Hulu, etc. You'll have a premium tier with no ads, perhaps a less ads but still some ads semi premium tier, and then an ads supported tier that is either free + ads or some small fee + ads. I know it's verboten to say this on Hacker News but it plays out this way over and over because some % of the consumers (read most of them) are actually okay with the trade off of having ads to pay less or pay not at all. This is even more pronounced outside the US where some markets are 99% ad supported. People should have the choice to pay for an ad free experience but its also okay for others to choose an ad supported one too.
- codalan 4y agoThe issue is when there is no ad-free tier. Cable TV started out ad-free. The content was paid for by subscribers. But that wasn't enough. Now cable TV is just as ad-ridden as broadcast TV. Even Spotify will randomly shove an ad in my face when all I want to do is navigate to my playlist, and I'm a paying subscriber. I hate the way it interrupts my flow so much that I'm probably going to cancel them in the next month or so.
- jupp0r 4y agoBold prediction: if ads on paid streaming services become the norm, there will be a renaissance of piracy because it will once again offer the superior user experience.
- saiya-jin 4y agoit never stopped being a superior experience for many types of users and many locations
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIt's inevitable. Paying for cable TV was once pitched to the American public as a reprieve from ads. Now, virtually all cable TV channels have more ads than than broadcast television had in the first place.
- fullshark 4y agoWell its inevitable to have an ad-tier and an ad-free tier at least. One of the benefits of digital ads v. linear TV ads.
- Msw242 4y agoWhat do you do when you find out that you make more per ad-tier user than you do for ad-free user[0]? The incentives go in the wrong direction from a UX perspective [0] https://www.cordcuttersnews.com/hulu-makes-about-15-in-revenue-per-customer-every-month/ https://www.cordcuttersnews.com/hulu-makes-about-15-in-reven...
- smeyer 4y agoCan the answer not just be to charge more for the ad-free tier? The gap between what I'm willing to pay for a streaming service with and without ads is a lot more than what the current going rate is.
- 4y ago
- newsclues 4y agoI’m investing in a media server, hard drives and a seedbox.
- msoad 4y agoor just pay for put.io
- nehal3m 4y agoI'd never heard of this service. Seems nice. Do you use it yourself, and how do you like it?
- sva_ 4y agoSeems very grey-area. Would definitely not want my credit card details to be on their list.
- ricardobeat 4y agoNo thanks. The day ads show up, my TV+ subscription will be gone. This double-dipping is ridiculous.
- user3939382 4y agoYep, at this point I'm burnt out on ad exposure for the rest of my life. Exposure to AM/FM radio or cable TV for more than a few minutes is a grating experience. Any service that forces ads is dead to me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Calvin02 4y agoApple doing a 0 to 100 on ads is pretty remarkable. Bold prediction: Apple will increasingly turn to services to maintain revenue growth as people don't upgrade their hardware as frequently because hardware innovation is also slowing down. On a similar note, Apple will find it hard to move into VR because it'll never be a big enough business for them but a make or break for Meta.
- quest88 4y agoHave they been against ads? I don't know. I know they've been pushing privacy, but I always thought it was because they want to be the only ones to know your behavior so they can sell ads instead of FB or Google.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoMore like 0 to 25. I hope they do go to 100 so we can move past the Apple mysticism which is rampant in the US.
- smoldesu 4y agoApple is definitely enamored with the service business model, but I think the issue with VR is a lot more clear-cut; Apple can't release a $1,000 headset in a market where $400 headsets exist too. VR is a novelty, and people will probably reach for whichever option is cheaper. If you want a more clear-cut example of this happening in the past, compare the launch of the PS3 with the Xbox 360. The PS3 was the better console in every way, being faster, having more features and not being made by Microsoft! The Xbox 360 destroyed the PS3 at launch. Turns out, desperate consumers just wanted a cheap box to play vidya on. I think Meta knows this, which is why they go out of their way to undercut everyone, all the time.
- sircastor 4y ago>Apple can't release a $1,000 headset in a market where $400 headsets exist too. VR is a novelty, and people will probably reach for whichever option is cheaper. I disagree. Apple did this kind of thing with the iPod and the iPhone. IIRC, the iPhone was $600 when it came out, and people paid it, even when there were dozens of other options. There are certainly people who are price sensitive, but Apple’s never really cared about selling to those people anyway.
- perceptronas 4y agoI might be wrong, but it feels like this will negatively affect their other products in the long term. Brand reputation goes both ways. Of course, in KPI spreadsheets Apple TV will bring more revenue and that's what counts. Slower growth of iPhone sales will be blamed on global recession.
- theGnuMe 4y agoIf I can continue to pay to avoid ads I will be ok with it.
- Y-bar 4y agoIf News+ is any indication, your outlooks are bleak: > Why are there ads in Apple News Plus news feed? Just subscribed to Apple News Plus. I am surprised to see ads in the Apple News Plus feed. Please remove these ads for paying subscribers. I realize that ads in articles that Apple can't control, but it is insulting to have them in the feed itself. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/252017203 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/252017203
- jeffbee 4y agoGeneral comment on Apple TV+. Is my impression incorrect that it is a distant last place among streaming services? There's nothing on. You get a free subscription if you replace your iThing and then it takes a few weeks to watch Ted Lasso and Severance, the only two shows they have, and you're ready to cancel.
- scarface74 4y agoThey aren’t playing the same game as the other streaming services besides Amazon. Both Amazon and Apple are using streaming to get you into their ecosystem and make the bundle more attractive.
- wccrawford 4y agoAlso, "For All Mankind" and "Servant". They've had a few shows, but I generally agree that it's pretty slim pickins there.
- cube2222 4y agoThey actually have very good shows overall. Not many, but very high quality. Other than the ones you've mentioned there are also See, The Morning Show, Mythic Quest, and For All Mankind, which are all great, as well as Foundation, which was quite good as well.
- jon-wood 4y agoYou should watch Foundation and For All Mankind as well next time you replace an iThing. The Apple TV+ library is definitely a lot smaller than competitor's, but what is in there is on the whole incredibly high quality.
- tjpnz 4y ago>There's nothing on. They've got Yo Gabba Gabba.
- nonameiguess 4y agoLess content, but it's pretty consistently higher quality than other services, at least so far. It's more than just those two shows. It was actually kind of hilarious to see Apple win a best picture Oscar with a tiny indy film on their first try after seeing Netflix spend years and billions on huge names blowing their load on near miss after near miss.
- wintermutestwin 4y ago20+ years now of not watching a single video ad (since the TiVo). I will never ever go back to that insanity. I'm unlikely to hoist the jolly rodger again as my internet connection is tied to my income. Honestly, I know that the day will eventually come when these parasites will eliminate ad-free streaming and ad-blocking on the web. At which point I will raise my middle finger as a flag and tackle my neglected reading list. Obligatory Bill Hicks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHEOGrkhDp0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHEOGrkhDp0
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- AlexandrB 4y agoYeah, there's really no way I'm going back to a cable tv style ad hellscape. Before subscription streaming services I bought a lot of physical media so I might go back to that or the digital equivalent.
- dont__panic 4y agoAny reason you wouldn't use a seedbox? I'm strongly considering one since streaming service Balkanization started, and price increases are only making it more tempting. All I have to do is cancel one service to justify it, after all.
- wintermutestwin 4y agoYou are asking me why I wouldn't pay for a service provided by dubious entities that is primarily used for activities that are illegal?
- dont__panic 4y agoThere are a lot of happy seedbox users out there -- I know quite a few. The companies sometimes go belly-up, but it's not like they're doing something truly repugnant like human trafficking or stealing from vulnerable people. They're just running a VM and providing an IP and not asking you any questions about what you're doing.
- algoatecorn 4y agoI have a question: Does the current state our attention economy and advertising ecosystem play a major role in the destruction of our planet, depletion of resources, and perhaps the rise in depression through hyper-consumerism?
- weberer 4y agoI'll just say that not every talking point is directly related to every other talking point.
- lp0_on_fire 4y agoI think it's a harder stretch to say it plays a major role in the destruction of the planet and depletion of resources but in my totally non-expert opinion I am positive that the rise in depression is coupled with it. Advertising has always been a thing but advances in the last 50-70 years in tech and human sciences has turned the problem up to 11. Increasingly every little move we make and thing we say is recorded, analyzed, run through an algorithm, then used to trick the lizard part of our brain into opening our wallet. Humans were not meant to be under CONSTANT psychological assault like this and if I were king I would outlaw marketing departments and severely restrict advertising across the board.
- kipchak 4y agoI think the argument would be that prior to advertising as we know it today, people bought things because they needed them, and at a substantially lower level of consumption. For example you might need a pair of work boots, walking shoes, and dress shoes. Advertisements for 19th century shoes generally focused on their features, like quality, comfort, fit or value. Born from WWI's propaganda was the idea of using communication to convince someone of something against their interest or for your policy objectives. For example, all x are monsters and you should risk your life to go fight them, using emotional responses and conceptual associations. “make the world safe for democracy.”[1] After the war it was realized these same techniques could be used to make people buy things they didn't need. Shoes are often now sold by convincing you they will make you more athletic, cool or similar self image. As a result there is now no limit on the number of shoes that a person "needs". This consumer culture[3], and was somewhat a conscious decision in response to the challenge faced by business from the ability to produce outstripping people's demands or overproduction. Consumers were trained via advertising, in order to keep production and growth humming, at the unseen expense of overconsumption. From Paul M. Mazur's :American Prosperity: Its Causes and Consequences" in 1928, "Advertising is an educational force. If effective, desires increase, standards of living are raised, purchases are made; purchases create production, production creates purchasing power, and the circle can be made complete if desire is at this point strong enough to convert that power into actual purchases. Of course there exists theoretically that danger point when consumption has reached its limit. Such a breaking point is probably non-existent.[2] [1]https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-woodrow-wilsons-propaganda-machine-changed-american-journalism-180963082/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-woodrow-wilsons-p... [2]https://quoteinvestigator.com/2021/01/21/desires/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2021/01/21/desires/ [3]https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/a-brief-history-of-consumer-culture/ https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/a-brief-history-of-consum...
- belval 4y agoI know it's morally dubious, but I'm completely back in pirateland because of all the changes/price hikes/partitioning in the streaming space. My interests make it so I only watch 1-2 shows per platform so I'd be approaching ~100$/month. And even if I was swimming in money, it's often easier to just download the shows I want and watch them on Plex/Jellyfin than trying to navigate the (often ad-riddled) interfaces of the various platforms and finding where the content I want is. One example is Rick and Morty, it's made by Adult Swim, but they don't have a streaming service in Canada. It seems to be on Primevideo but under a different system than their regular content. The other way to watch it is to buy it from my cable provider (I don't have cable). So to watch a 20-minutes animated show I'd have to take a +40$ subscription.
- FredPret 4y agoI always ignore Prime Video because you can’t watch everything you see without subscribing to some channel.
- haliskerbas 4y agoThey have a "free to me" toggle, does it work for you?
- bombcar 4y agoIt does, and what I do is remember/bookmark the things that are in the weird channels, and then subscribe to one and cancel during the free period, and binge watch them all. muahahaha
- wmeredith 4y agoI'm in a similar mindset, but I often buy physical media copies of such things instead of pirating them or even if I pirate them. I want to support the art, because I'd like more of it in the future.
- SamuelAdams 4y ago
- moolcool 4y agoI hate how Apple is becoming increasingly an advertising company.
- debacle 4y agoEvery company, once it reaches a certain size, only can grow materially through certain venues: government contracts, financing, advertising, etc.
- NickC25 4y agoTrue, but Apple has so many interesting spaces it could grow into through M&A activity as opposed to putting ads in its TV service. Off the top of my head, wearables and gaming are just two that could promote a ton of genuine growth as opposed to promoting pirating by introducing ads. There are plenty of whip-smart folks at Apple, surely they know people adopted streaming services due to lack of ads, and have the ability to pirate stuff pretty easily.
- ls15 4y agoWhy do the largest companies need to grow any further? Maybe they should not? The world does not grow.
- algoatecorn 4y agoWhat's interesting is how this all worked out for them, whether it's serendipitous or purposeful. Conventional consumer data collection relies on users coming to the collection mechanism i.e. spending time on a website or interactions on social media. Apple is poised to withstand many privacy protection measures because their collection mechanism is in millions of peoples' hands and pockets. iPhone users are providing high-resolution data to their platform. The accuracy of your personality profile and related data are nicely packaged and easy to convert into highly targeted advertising.
- prange 4y agoThe idea that Tim Cook is Batman is pretty far fetched.
- account-5 4y agoI'm sure it was only last week on another apple thread some person got downvoted for suggesting apple will succumb to ad money. Seems the fabled apple can't resist the extra revenue.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sircastor 4y agoI’ve wondered recently if we’re going to see in the next 10 or 20 years a split generation of people who are susceptible to ads. I heard anecdotally someone talking about his kids who weren’t exposed to ads much because they (as a family) buy the ad free experiences - when they did see an ad, it was extremely effective and they were explaining to their father how much they needed this thing. Alternatively, are the poorer kids going to be the ones inoculated against advertising because they are exposed to it constantly?
- rglullis 4y agoDo you really think it works that way? People might develop banner blindness, but subconsciously they are being bombarded with messages anyway. They are being trained to consume, to associate the sites they like to visit with certain brands, pushed products by influencers... If ads didn't work, companies wouldn't be paying billions of dollars per year. The only way to fight it is by being vigilant and block them at the source and become truly allergic to them.
- yunwal 4y agoI do think it kind of works that way. Take a look at who is affected by blatantly fake news. It’s the people that grew up in an era where there were just a few “legitimate” news sources. People who grew up with misinformation just laugh it off. Not saying fake news has no effect on young people but it’s definitely a huge difference.
- rglullis 4y ago> People who grew up with misinformation just laugh it off. It does not make them immune to other types of disinformation or manipulation tactics. To think that you are so smart to be beyond that is just hubris.
- yunwal 4y ago> Not saying it has no effect on young people Please read the comment before replying
- skc 4y agoCompeting services should ironically be somewhat happy about this news. Apples entry into this space might help to legitimize it and quell at least some of the outrage.
- hardlianotion 4y ago“The last bastion is Apple TV. Apple is going to be a very good ad experience with probably a low ad load. They’re already actually very diversified in terms of revenue streams so there’s less pressure to fit lots of ads.” If it's true now, it won't be later on.
- boringg 4y agoHow much of this is tied to facebook being shut out of targeted ads? Really not looking forward to this -- this is a serious brand risk for apple to step into more advertising.
- Melatonic 4y agoI do not like apple at all and do not use their products and even I recognize this is a dumb move. They have tricked people into their walled gardens for years now and this might be the thing that finally wakes people up to the fact they are manipulating them into apple only services
- joegahona 4y agoWhen did "planning" become synonymous with doing something "quietly," as though it's somehow underhanded, deceptive, or nefarious? Just because Apple didn't respond to Digiday's stupid request for comment doesn't mean they're up to no good. Companies very rarely make their roadmaps public or hold press conferences for initiatives they're working on.
- AlexandrB 4y agoAds are often underhanded, deceptive, or nefarious so any plans to add them can be considered as such by extension.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoApple moving into Ads is a huge systemic risk for the company. No one will trust them again if they make one major mistake, and Ads are a minefield for upcoming regulations. They have so much money and financing available, instead of being greedy, they should focus on hardware.
- coldtea 4y ago>No one will trust them again if they make one major mistake They have the advantage that all other competitors at that scale (FB, Google, etc.) are worse and even more desperate for ad revenue...
- cowpig 4y agoI wish I could upvote this 100 times. Seems short-sighted to the point of company malpractice. Introducing a massive conflict of interest into their business model cannot possibly work out well in the long-term.
- kirykl 4y agoThey already had an ad product before https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAd
- ksec 4y ago>No one will trust them again. As much as I want this to happen. It wont. Just look at the spin given out by either Apple's PR or Apple Apologist: "Apple were never against Ads. Steve Jobs made iAds." Meanwhile completely forgetting Tim Cook, 2014-2015. "Apple is not in the Ads Business." - In the Context of why you should choose Apple. "Apple Ads are privacy focused and they do not track you." Cough. They are only personalised. "Apple is moving away from China." ( No they are not ). "And has been planning to do so for a while." ( No they didn't ) And literally all the Fans reading Appleinsider, Macrumors, 9to5Mac believes in it. As well as all the YouTube repeating "THE SAME" information over and over again.
- p_j_w 4y ago>And literally all the Fans reading Appleinsider, Macrumors, 9to5Mac believes in it. It's a common belief even on this site. I see it parroted all the time.
- kart23 4y agorunning ads with that amount of content is a no-brainer and it's pretty much going to be required to keep it profitable. I wouldn't be surprised if apple TV+ is losing money, I've seen $1B tossed around online.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIf Apple becomes an ad company, I'll have to seriously reconsider my commitment to Apple. The only reason I moved away from Android was Google. I had no real complaints from the phones or Android user-experience itself.
- andsoitis 4y agoWhat phone would you get?
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI'll just go back to Android. If my only options are adware companies, I might as well get the cheaper product.
- eagleal 4y agoNot only that but it's more feature rich. Like in 2022 you can't disable DTMF tones, no autosuggestion on the dialing screen, hard-limit to 100 most recent numbers in the log, and so on.
- fsflover 4y agoHow about https://puri.sm/products/librem-5 https://puri.sm/products/librem-5 or https://pine64.org/pinephone https://pine64.org/pinephone?
- kornhole 4y agoToo bad you didn't know that you can use Android without Google. Checkout grapheneos.org or lineageos.org.
- butterNaN 4y agoAlso, /e/ os*
- renewiltord 4y agoI mean, what are you really going to do? Apple has $4b ad revenue and you aren't moving. I'm sure just like now you'll have a reason "oh it's not actually X" or whatever. People make all these dramatic commitments but they never go through with it, or they leave out the true caveats that would weaken the statement.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- etchalon 4y agoI suspect this will fail, because Apple is fundamentally against providing the level of data large ad buyers want. We already saw this happen with iAd.
- vidoc 4y ago<company> is quietly <action> has been a trend for some time, love it!
- whispersnow 4y agoNo longer watching TV... Going back to reading and news...
- anonred 4y agoEt tu, Apple? Although I predict that in true Apple style, they’ll somehow manage to make ads fashionable in 3-5 years.
- errantmind 4y agoApple has finally lost touch, it was bound to happen eventually. Ads will seriously hurt their reputation as a premium product. The ads will metastasize and spread from product to product, tainting everything they touch. This will make a good case study on why a company shouldn't get too greedy about 10 years from now.
- Melatonic 4y agoMore like (cr)Apple!
- syntaxing 4y agoI stopped using Prime Video because of the stupid 5s forced ads in the beginning. It will be a serious turn off to the Apple ecosystem if they do the same.
- kornhole 4y agoThis looks like classic bait and switch in the tech industry. "Trust us, we are only interested in selling you hardware and maybe some services that protect your privacy." Once the people are sufficiently captured and wires deeply embedded, gradually change the terms and networks.
- t3e 4y agoI'm currently reading Tim Wu's "The Attention Merchants" about the history of advertising and can't recommend it enough. It's not a happy or encouraging story, however.
- wobbly_bush 4y agoI've personally gone back to reading more books instead of watching more TV, and it has been more fulfilling. It doesn't work for everything I used to watch - but for my main consumption of fiction, I now prefer books/audiobooks over TV. On the plus side, the artists are supported more directly with book sales rather than circuitous route of payment involved in subscription-based streaming. It also reduces the surface area where I can be exposed to ads.
- jitix 4y agoIf this move proves profitable (likely will) shareholders will pressure Apple to move further into ads. I wonder what an alternative ecosystem would look like. Does anybody have experience with Fairphone/PinePhone/Librem as their daily driver? I don't necessarily need all the apps, but the common ones like WhatsApp, Amazon, Uber, Doordash, etc. Also, which wearables work best with open source phones?
- daniel-cussen 4y ago