19 ms·
Meta Meets Microsoft
- croes 4y agoNext step of evolution: This VR-meeting should have been an email
- aphroz 4y agoFacebook and Teams teaming up together is literally my nightmare.
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoDon't forget that LinkedIn and Instagram will tag along for that ride.
- seydor 4y agoFaceteam
- gofreddygo 4y agoMetasoft.
- SilverBirch 4y agoSo the obvious conclusion from this is that Meta continue sinking billions into hardware, Microsoft build the actual application and get it sold into enterprise. Meta share price continues to tank, and then Microsoft acquires Meta and spins off Facebook keeping the VR stuff that they actually want. (I realise the dual class shares prevent this, but it would be very funny)
- bee_rider 4y agoIs there some Facebook:IBM, Microsoft:Microsoft analogy here?
- smcl 4y ago> Microsoft’s shift to Teams as its de facto OS Ugh, I think we all want less MS Teams in our life, not more :-/
- rbanffy 4y agoI've been using a Windows laptop as my work computer for about a year now and I'd love to have less MS in my life.
- gofreddygo 4y ago6 months for me also for work. Just naturally started using my personal 2012 macbook for everything non work.
- rbanffy 4y agoOh yes. I never even take that hateful computer out of the backpack if it’s not for work. I much prefer my Mac and my Linux laptops to it, even though it’s allegedly faster.
- smcl 4y agoHonestly I really don't mind parts of the Microsoft experience. Visual Studio is a pretty good IDE, and VS Code a lighter, more extensible alternative for some specific cases (I use it to fiddle with our Angular frontend apps). The .NET ecosystem is pretty good, and the Windows UI on its own would be pretty good even if I prefer a tiling window manager like xmonad. I can use cygwin and get a decent enough set of Unix-y tools that feel more "right" to me than Powershell (which I don't think I'll ever enjoy). So that sort of stuff allows a decent enough, but not perfect, developer experience. But there's enough other fucking irritating bullshit that drives me up the wall - like Outlook is cluttered and annoying, and yeah Teams can fuck right off.
- bsldld 4y agoPossibility of Microsoft buying Facebook is not unthinkable. Microsoft is already an investor in Facebook. Both HoloLens and Oculus are already moving in the same direction with enterprise play.
- foobarian 4y agoDidn't also a lot of Microsofties leave for FB a decade back or so? Could be an easy culture meld.
- PretzelPirate 4y agoIf love Microsoft to acquire FB for other reasons as well: 1. MS doesn't need to sell my data to make their services profitable. 2. MS could merge Facebook and LinkedIn so I could have a person and professional identity in a single app and switch between my networks! I don't have a FB account at all right now). 3. What's App could tie into the existing messaging infrastructure and work for Xbox or Personal Teams messaging. 4. MS could replace the Mixed Reality platform with Oculus. I use Mr for VR and the software kind of sucks and many games don't have MR controller bindings by default, though that's less frequent nowadays.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- philjohn 4y ago1 - nobody, except the data brokers, sell data. Microsoft though, collects a huge amount (telemetry in Windows) and is leaning more heavily into ads in the core product.
- randoglando 4y agoThis will not happen, simply because Zuckerberg owns FB. Also, this deal makes no sense for FB. They still make a large amount of money (10s of billions every quarter) and the only advantage they get from this is Microsoft's brand (compared to FB's brand, which is currently doggshit).
- sjellen 4y agoMicrosoft gets it cloud gaming/gamepass on another platform. That was the big takeaway for me. Very early Netflix, get your streaming service on every platform possible before they see you as a threat or opportunity.
- tacker2000 4y agoOk, so a VR version of MS Teams might be “compelling”, but does anybody really think that companies are going to supply their employees with $1k VR goggles just so that they can do a virtual meetup instead of just a normal phone or video call? I think VR has merit and could be very useful in some spaces like gaming, exploring new worlds (with good graphics) or maybe even prototyping architectural designs etc, but these are too niche for whatever Zuck is trying here… for his billion dollar bet to succeed nearly everyone would have to be using his VR product.
- yokoprime 4y agoIf at some point goggles replaces monitors, I can see this taking off... but i don't see that happening anytime soon. VR goggles are way too bulky and uncomfortable now.
- bamboozled 4y agoYou’d really want to be disconnected entirely from your surroundings while you’re working ? Sounds nauseating to me. I enjoy looking at friends and loved ones, looking out the window occasionally, taking notes, drinking coffee without a headset in the way, not having a sweaty face or being nauseated. AR maybe, VR for hours ? No thanks
- null_object 4y agoI know this may come across as saying "who would want to carry a telephone in their pocket?", but the idea that we would all be required to sit with googles on all day, in a virtual 'office' environment, in order to do our work, is beyond all dystopian imagining, in my view. Today I'm coding by my window, with the sun shining outside - some birdsong audible from the trees in the yard. One of my kids just came home from school, and we chatted for a couple minutes. I had a few (too many) meetings today, but they were all video-calls and for some of the time I could carry on with a current task. I think the receptiveness of the HN crowd overestimates the utility of this technology. It would probably be used to enslave underlings into being 'present' at the virtual office without pee-breaks for 10-hours every day. PS: I see everyone else in this thread questioning the idea that we should sit in a virtual-reality world with goggles strapped to our faces all day is getting downvoted. I think people outside the tech-nerd bubble would probably disagree.
- ianbutler 4y ago"Teams is the most obvious manifestation of virtual reality’s potential from a software perspective." No one I know likes using Teams, they're forced to. I also temporarily used teams for a previous startup and we switched back to Slack. Basic things were broken, like search, which is a no go from me. I like VR, am an enthusiast even, but if that's their representation of "potential", I think we're headed down the wrong path. I understand the spirit of Teams having everything integrated and available, but in practice they will have to do far better in user experience and functionality, it's not enough to say you have a feature, that feature has to at the very least not suck in the software world, in the VR world? It better blow people away. Most people are still highly skeptical of VR and they will need to be amazing.
- badwolf 4y agoThe search in teams is so unbelievably terrible.
- gofreddygo 4y ago> they're forced to Key point in the enterprise world. MS - archetype enterprise longing for consumer love. Meta - archetype startup trying to sell its toys to enterprise. This is just too bad for VR. Making VR corporate friendly will leave a bad taste for the young generation. Meaning this generation will never fall in love with the possibilities and potential of VR.
- hrbf 4y ago> Meaning this generation will never fall in love with the possibilities and potential of VR. I see that as a good thing.
- mFixman 4y agoThe tragedy here is that Meta employees internally use Workplace, an IMO superior product for big companies than both MS Teams and Slack. The fact that they failed at marketing it properly and was pulled from the market is one of the many signs that things aren't working right in that company.
- uni_rule 4y agoSo is the Mixed Reality suite getting folded into the former Oculus platform or vice versa? Or is it neither, and just that some tools are being ported to the Facebook side?
- dustedcodes 4y agoIf you thought Microsoft couldn’t find a way to make Teams even more diabolical they just surprise you with the meta verse.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- muglug 4y agoI know that VR is compelling, and FB's VR headsets succeed in providing some level of immersion, but I don't think people will go from remote-working-with-Zoom to remote-working-with-headset, because it's a trade the most aren't willing to make. If I'm on a Zoom call with 8 other people and the conversation shifts to something that doesn't concern me, I can bring up a code editor and continue hacking away at something without advertising that to my colleagues. But if I started in VR, I'm basically stuck there. The whole thing still feels like "we built this great piece of technology but we're struggling to find its killer app". It feels very Segway-ish.
- Robotbeat 4y agoYou wouldn’t have to be stuck there if coding in VR was feasible. …but actually, the fact that people can and do just check out of online meetings while pretending to still be present is kind of a drawback of online meeting Vs in-person meetings. Lack of focus is a killer for productivity. And if people are doing that, they should be allowed to leave the meeting anyway.
- bamboozled 4y agoHonestly, you’ve never hacked during a real life meeting ? I used to bring my laptop into the board room all the time.
- jetbalsa 4y agoJokes on you, I check out in meetings in-person as well. Just hacking away on my laptop in a corner without a care in the world.
- dougmwne 4y agoIt very much depends on your meeting culture. I suppose in the ideal world, everyone should be intently paying attention because the meeting was relevant and focused. In my world, meetings go on for hours, everyone invites the kitchen sink, and long egotistical monologues are the norm. Trapping me in VR for all that would be unpleasant to say the least.
- roody15 4y agoMeta's metaverse honestly may be gearing up to be one of the biggest financial tech failures in decades. Still after all these billions poured into the metaverse... still no compelling reason to use. Already they are pitching it as a "marketplace" of digital sorts before they even have an audience. VR done wrong. Requiring a Facebook account. Utilizing a marketplace run by Facebook. It honestly is astounding how much money is being spent here... and to say underwhelming at best is an understatement.
- randoglando 4y ago> Already they are pitching it as a "marketplace" of digital sorts before they even have an audience. Good point, that's Carmack's _exact_ criticism! > Requiring a Facebook account. No longer true as of a few months ago.
- hrbf 4y agoUpon reading news like that, I’m convinced I have made the right choice following my gut feeling and intuition to move away from the tech world. It’s absurd. This is adding yet another layer of needless complexity, just for the sake of earning yet more money. It does not solve any real issue, it benefits very few people at the expense of most. In this regard, it’s like the cryptocurrency of business applications. Late-stage capitalism in fully swing indeed.
- coldpie 4y agoI'm getting there, myself. All tech is converging on the single goal of making the rich richer by serving ads and influencing elections. I'm tired of it. I hear the local public transit company is hiring bus maintainers, training included.
- jmeister 4y agoTech is the only sector that is actually even borderline competent these days. https://www.wsj.com/articles/blame-lockdowns-on-silicon-valley-technology-artificial-intelligence-safety-privacy-innovation-liberty-new-york-crispr-11665321090 https://www.wsj.com/articles/blame-lockdowns-on-silicon-vall... "Without technology to keep the economy from imploding, they(lockdowns) wouldn’t have lasted." I say a prayer to Bezos every time Amazon delivers something perfectly, come rain, shine, war or pestilence.
- cmos 4y agoI've always had this dream of taking doom and building a map like the workplace.. but still with the occasional zombie. We all see each other, and meet up in the conference room to join a 'group zoom call' or something like that. There would also be a 'minecraft' room that puts us all on the same server to build prototypes and brainstorm together. I wouldn't bet the farm on VR.
- philote 4y agoThat raises a good point. We've had virtual worlds for ages now, but how often do companies do Minecraft meetings? Or Gary's Mod meetings? Or hell, even VR chat, that doesn't require VR. Is there really that much gained by adding a heavy headset and some hand tracking?
- jmull 4y ago> Microsoft’s shift to Teams as its de facto OS Just one example, but I think this guy has lost the thread and is not worth reading.
- criddell 4y agoThat line also stood out to me and I had the exact opposite reaction.
- xen2xen1 4y agoDepends on which world you live in. If you did anything corpate during lockdown, yeah, "defacto" OS strikes a chord. Man, so much time in teams, and they only keep throwing things in it.
- jmull 4y agoI just don't know what about it says OS to anyone. To me its just the latest iteration of crappy corporate communication software we only use because the people who sign our checks bought it. "Yet Another Lotus Notes" from my perspective.
- throwaheyy 4y agoThey keep loading it up with more and more applets.
- mberning 4y agoAll they need is their Steve Ballmer "developers developers developers" moment. Nobody wants this garbage. Nobody wants to "work in the metaverse". They don't even want to visit. People do not even like turning on their webcams for meetings with people they talk to every single day. Do you think they are going to want to don a goofy headset to do the same? The moment my employer tells me I need to wear a VR headset for some meeting is they day I put in my notice.
- vegai_ 4y agoSlack just released video chat and they've had screen sharing for some time. Teams should start feeling a bit nervous.
- vxNsr 4y agoSlack created the category and had a 2 year head start, the fact that they are being rapidly replaced by teams in many office environments has little to do with specific features in teams vs slack. It’s entirely because you get teams “free” with the e5 office license that you need to buy anyways for outlook, excel, etc.
- tkk23 4y agoSlack should invest in Libreoffice and offer a better office suite.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoAn offline locally running office suite has very little value in a post-google docs world to corporations.
- tkk23 4y agoDoesn't Google use the Libreoffice code on the server side? You still need at least a locally running spreadsheet application for the Excel wizards. If I were Google or Slack, I would push Libreoffice Calc to be better than Excel. Only then will big companies be able to use an MS Office alternative.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoI might be wrong but I assumed the popularity of running Excel locally wasn't because it was local but because that's where Excel ran and Excel is what they're in love with.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoA major factor when meeting virtually is there is a threshold of "good enough" and I think we are there. Engineers tend to not turn on video as it is and they still get our work done. Technology is not going to solve people problems (teams disagreeing, internal politics, etc.) What is the expected outcome/benefit?
- bheadmaster 4y ago> the presentation, though, was cringe Using "cringe" as an adjective immediately makes my mind imagine the author as a typical Fortnite-playing, Youtube-watching, Discord-using, skinny 12 year old boy with glasses.
- coldpie 4y agoWelcome to old age, grampa :) Here's your rocking chair, there's the lawn, time to start yelling.
- numbsafari 4y agoI can’t possibly see myself wanting to share or discuss company secrets or details on a Facebook/Meta owned platform. They have such a horrible track record when it comes to privacy, and basic honesty and integrity, that there’s no way it makes sense to use as a corporate platform.
- wilsonnb3 4y agoHow is it any different than using Office 365 or teams?
- throwaheyy 4y agoOffice and Teams are not produced by Facebook/Meta.
- greenthrow 4y agoVR is not compelling. I have tried it and it is tedious. This is the reaction of by far most people I know who have tried VR. VR is one of those things where the concept and possibilities are way more exciting than the reality of the thing. Like flying cars. The difference is Mark Zuckerberg made way too big of a bet on VR so they won't let it go.
- dylan604 4y agoMaybe theZuck should be more googly and willing to just end of life things that are not immediately profitable.
- yrgulation 4y agoKids, stop doing drugs or else you risk growing up and thinking teams is a great idea, or worse, thinking teams and meta are good for you.
- intrasight 4y agoInvest billions. Get traction. Establish a moat. Obviously Meta may not succeed. Probably won't succeed. This Microsoft thing will be one of many "throw it on the wall and see what sticks". I do applaud their gumption. And I believe that AR and VR will have a very important role for humanity in the near future.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoIf their approach is Enterprise and work environments, how does a VR headset deal with ADA (American Disabilities Act) and accessibility? Employers cannot discriminate against those with hearing/vision or other impairments and I don't know how a technology like VR can compensate for that. Assuming the headset doesn't help at all in those areas then it can't be something an employer mandates people to use. This type of device might uncover even more physical impairments people are unaware of, like those warnings in video games about flashing lights - photosensitive seizures and epilepsy. Are the benefits of a meeting technology going to far out-weigh potential employment lawsuits?
- bioemerl 4y agoIt would be a real shame if this held technology back in a substantial way. VR offers a ton of opportunity for a more productive work environment. Infinite space to work in, an active working day instead of sitting in a chair, etc etc etc. Imagine working at a customer service desk where instead of tickets in a tab you can have 3d stacks of them all across the room you're in. Or a control environment with knobs and bobs surrounding you like an old 1970s control panel, with none of the cost. Imagine designing a web page, except your screen doesn't have an edge. I think a big part of the skepticism here is that we have coded for 2d screens for so long that we don't even begin to realize the possibilities yet. I'm convinced that the future of most office is while wearing some sort of headset. Not meetings though. Those will remain 2d. Corny half done avatars and badly recreated 3d rooms don't cut it.
- icapybara 4y agoThe screen is still limited by your eyepiece field of view. You have to scroll and zoom if the page is too big. We can already do that in browsers.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoI just don't see any actual daily professional worker problems being solved. I see solutions in search of problems. People with PC's have a control environment in front of them everyday with a keyboard and mouse, 100's of controls and combinations. Keyboards are really cheap. I see VR enabled work environments like touch-screens in cars. They suck. You have little to no sensory input on your fingers and can't feel your way around to do things without looking. Is having 3d stacks in a virtual room going to allow a customer service person to better do their job? As in having measurable financial impact? If I'm running a call center with 100 people, is spending $150k on VR headsets going to help materially?
- KidComputer 4y agoThey’re screwed if they don’t make something viable before most people get pushed back into the office.
- _chu1 4y agoAll this metaverse and Oculus garbage and I still see literally no reason to use any of it nor make a Facebook account
- jtr1 4y agoIt's an admittedly squishy heuristic, but my gut feeling about whether a technology will stick or not is usually driven by how people outside the tech world talk about it. Most of my community is outside of the tech world at this point. For the iPhone and Apple watch, just about every I knew wanted one as soon as it was announced. Google glass? People were joking about how they'd rip one off of someone's face if they caught them filming. Uber/Lyft? Everyone who was pumped to ride at 10 bucks shrugged and found something else at 50. I'm sure Meta has made huge strides in leveling up immersive VR technology overall. But apart from people with a vested interest, I only hear about the metaverse as the butt a joke. There are lots of cool applications for VR. I'm just not betting on this particular one.
- ForHackernews 4y agoVR headsets look dorky and isolate you from other people in the real world. I'm inclined to agree with you that's probably enough to mean it will fail to ever go mainstream. Ironically, AR/some better Google Glass might be a hit, if it didn't look so stupid and the people pushing it were less hated. Wait until TikTok makes an AR headset and gets K-pop groups to promote it.
- anonred 4y agoYou might be underestimating normalization of deviance in society. Meta’s already demonstrated that the younger generation will adopt VR headsets for gaming. “Dorkiness” is very unlikely to be a sufficient barrier here.
- ForHackernews 4y agoHeelys[0] are popular with the younger generation but will never go mainstream, despite having more practical utility than any metaverse offering from 'Meta'. [0] https://heelys.com/ https://heelys.com/
- turtlebits 4y agoI have no interest in the metaverse, or socializing at all in VR. I just want to play games and use fitness apps, which I find value in. That said, there is nothing wrong with trying to expand into the consumer/enterprises.
- nkrisc 4y agoVideo and phone calls don't give me motion sickness, so I'll stick with those. I also happen to enjoy being able to see the room I'm sitting in while I work. If anything, AR might have some promise over VR, but I'm definitely not convinced yet.
- metacriticcap 4y agohttps://metacriticcapital.substack.com/p/meta-wants-to-disrupt-the-pc-market https://metacriticcapital.substack.com/p/meta-wants-to-disru... I wrote on it. Meta is trying to disrupt the PC market and Microsoft is taking notice and hedging their bets. It's a slightly different opinion to Ben
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blackbear_ 4y agoCan't wait to have hybrid meetings in these. It's sitll a hustle getting a mic and cam working
- CuriouslyC 4y agoPersonally I don't think VR has applications other than games. AR on the other hand will eventually be ubiquitous and important. HUDS in real life with context assistance is absolutely a killer app.
- washywashy 4y agoI remember as a kid at the dentist office they had these headsets you could watch a movie on while you received treatment. In my opinion it made the experience worse because wearing a headset for that long always ends up being either annoying or slightly painful. I’ve used an oculus and I will say, it’s not that bad to wear, but I can’t imagine wearing one of these things for any meeting going longer than 30 minutes, whatever the perceived benefits might be.
- grnmamba 4y agoI think in the near future we'll have deep neural nets that create and puppet an VR avatar for us, while we're sitting normally in front of our PCs. Kind of like a recursive version of a v-tuber: you pretend you're wearing a VR headset and listen to the pointless rambling during meetings, while your boss pretends that everyone is being so much more productive.
- ryanianian 4y agoThis is already happening. NVidia's Maxine thing takes a still photo and animates it according to your video feed. The leap to a VR version feels rather incremental.
- blobbers 4y ago… so why can’t I watch NBA games in VR? What’s the limitation there? They don’t want to put cameras every 5ft in the front row in a bunch of stadiums? The compelling use cases (not horizon worlds) to the general public are possible but not even being attempted. Can I watch a single sporting event in VR? Olympics? College? It seems like they’ve tried to do concerts but to be honest I’ve been to concerts in reality and the sweaty heat and blinding lights are different. I haven’t sat courtside.
- 972811 4y agoYou can: https://www.oculus.com/blog/go-courtside-in-vr-with-nba-league-pass-games-in-venues-on-oculus-quest/ https://www.oculus.com/blog/go-courtside-in-vr-with-nba-leag...
- shp0ngle 4y agoThis is the first time I see someone mention Teams in positive way. If the future of VR is like Teams, I guess I’ll pass
- rossdavidh 4y ago"Then one of the developers moved house, temporarily misplaced his headset, and we haven’t used it since." That is basically every real-world (pun intended) story about VR I have ever heard. "It's great! We used it once or twice."
- theknocker 4y ago
- yalogin 4y agoThere is so much skepticism in the community about this tech. Is it because there is genuinely no compelling use cases or is it because of the current implementation?
- randoglando 4y agoIMO people are thinking on a time scale that is too short. VR is different from crypto, and though it may not succeed, it can solve real problems. One example: Reducing inequality. With the purchase of a headset (~400$), everyone can have a 60" TV, and learn how to play the piano, and have access to 100s of board games (the last one hasn't been implemented yet, but possibly soon). Crypto OTOH provides no real value, and has been out as long, if not longer.
- postexitus 4y agoTilt Five is promising an amazing solution to the board game problem - IMHO, it's better than what Oculus provides. https://www.tiltfive.com/ https://www.tiltfive.com/
- h4n1 4y agoHow do you learn to play the piano without real physical feedback when pressing the keys? The "experiences" you can have through sight and sound alone are quite limited. A glove to emulate something as simple as piano keypresses would be a very complicated device.
- kortilla 4y agoLearning how to play the piano is a joke on VR. 75% of piano playing is the muscle memory that requires real keys. A $50 keyboard from the thrift-shop + youtube will be bounds better for learning piano than VR. +1 to board games though assuming it’s precise enough that you don’t constant bump all of the pieces.
- dntrkv 4y agoThe “community” is not a good gauge as to which tech will succeed or fail. Go back to the early HN days and read the comments on the iPhone release posts.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoA VR system that gives me 3-4 monitors already pays for itself by leaps and bounds in a work from home environment.
- anonred 4y agoExactly. The cost of my WFH monitor setup alone was more than what Meta’s asking for the Pro.
- karaterobot 4y agoEven in that older article he wrote about the Metaverse, it seemed like somebody just gave Ben Thompson a really good demo, and that made him bullish on the product. He's a very smart analyst, typically, but I don't think his prediction about the usefulness (or more accurately the adoption) of VR for business meetings is going to pan out. Nobody wants this stuff, and the cheaper, better solution for an increasingly remote workforce is just to have fewer synchronous meetings, not to spend thousands of dollars buying every team member a VR headset.
- totalview 4y agoI recently played Bone Labs on the Occulus Quest 2, and it totally redefines where I thought we were with VR (and with no PC to have to play it). Seriously, just check it out if you haven’t and you have a headset. I am a huge VR skeptic for many of the reasons that people state here. I have also thought that VR’s killer app was any dangerous professional training situation that you wanted to present as accurately as possible without injuries to your staff (firefighting, EMS response, etc.). If the road to adoption begins with experiences that are decidedly more interactive and immersive than screens and monitors, I am starting to see the (long) path that leads towards that future.
- tkk23 4y agoThis feels like tablets all over again. Microsoft had them for years but couldn't make something convincing. The core of Facebook is the idea of reinventing Myspace as a business app with a formal design. From that point of view, it makes sense to let Microsoft reinvent the 3d user experience. I doubt that it will create the package that will establish 3d headsets. For a workplace, it's a feature that the colleagues in a meeting are at a distance. On the other hand, we would already know if a virtual desktop with a huge spreadsheet would be more efficient than a monitor. Without a Steve Jobs, users have to figure out the purpose of 3d headsets by themselves. Meta should follow the model of the PC and let every producer of electronics build a compatible product. Let everybody use the patents as long as they build a headset that fulfills the spec. They should also avoid any lock-in and choose a free operating system. Only then can it be used by enthusiasts to experiment until the purpose of 3d headsets is found. This can still be beneficial for Meta because they can establish themselves as the leading market place for 3d apps. Furthermore, like ads on the web, there is a need for an ad network because all the free apps need to be financed. Meta can ride the network effect of being the first mover. Meta has the chance to create the next platform. I doubt that they will take the risk. By locking it down, they can be sure that they will never lose whatever they create. Unfortunately, they are only on a way to create the precursor to the 3d ipad.
- bee_rider 4y agoApple is definitely going to swoop in with their own version of the VR/AR headset once the field is basically worked and just waiting for a correct implementation. The question is really whether it is more like personal computers, where somebody outshines them, smartphones where there's enough room to share the market, or tablets where only Apple can seem to make it work really.
- whispersnow 4y agoWhat Zack imaging VR will do for us is completely the opposite of what I would use it for.
- jonny_eh 4y agoWhy does this guy quote himself so much? Each article is like 60% new content.
- negamax 4y agoSo far I have been rooting for Facebook. With MSFT in the mix, I am out. Good luck Zuck
- ferrumfist 4y agoA myriad of issues with FB is worthy of support but the moment they partner with MSFT it's a bridge too far, eh?
- negamax 4y agoYeah
- matai_kolila 4y agoThat's wild, I don't think I've ever heard of someone having such a specific moral affectation.
- cercatrova 4y agoVR meetings want to take the asynchronicity of remote work and replace it with the synchronicity of office work, but virtually. You lose most of the advantages of remote work (the only one retained is lack of commute).
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoInnovation isn't very likely to be found in a sterile corporate environment. The attempts by Meta to control so tightly what content ends up on the Quest will only end up with results that are a reflection of their creators. I felt like i wanted to throw up with the whole bay area, corporate environment vibe this presentation gave off. I was most excited by the prospect of having Xbox game pass on this thing until i found out all it is is a big screen in VR (What's the fucking point, guys?). If they have the engineering resources to convert even a portion of fan favorites into native VR experiences, that's going to kill. This feels a lot like IBM labs where the technology is "there", but these clowns are not the ones who're going to find the killer application and yet are hell bent on controlling the whole thing. Someones going to come around eventually and hook this up with porn, native video games, psychedelic experiences in legal states etc and push the boundaries of exciting yet controversial content that would never get past the committee of corpo minded rats at Meta and that will be when it takes off. For their sake, i hope Meta realize this.
- matai_kolila 4y agoHonestly I'm a little disappointed by the lack of enthusiasm for what this could be; people shat on all kinds of now-ubitquitous tech with similar "nobody will ever replace the typewriter!" kinds of arguments. It would be cool if we could solve the hardest part of interacting with others remotely, which is the lost fidelity. That's an interesting and hard problem that we haven't yet totally solved. Meta isn't there yet, but they're trying! I feel like the corpo-hate has overshadowed the positivity that used to be more prevalent in the tech community.
- moffkalast 4y agoThere used to be more positivity because it was genuinely about making great products that people will like and want to buy, instead of making something people will like just enough to let you datamine them for all they're worth. Is this seriously anything beyond Facebook trying to get companies to mandate using these so they can get high fidelity 3D video footage of every living person's house and apartment, their gait and all other possible biometrics? I certainly wouldn't put it past them. Quest headsets are cheaper than all other headsets for a reason.
- matai_kolila 4y agoOne could argue this is exactly the corpo-hate I was referencing earlier. What do we get out of being so cynical?
- moffkalast 4y agoWe get to keep some of our privacy by being cynical I suppose. As they say, fool me once shame on you, fool me twice - can't get fooled again.
- matai_kolila 4y agoI would trade a lot of my privacy in an instant if it meant full fidelity remote human interactions (I already trade a lot of my privacy for much less), but I guess I'm an optimist.
- theptip 4y agoI’d like to note that a lot of people posted yesterday complaining about a Meta walled garden - the MS partnership (and Zuck’s previous comments) to me points to the opposite strategy. One other thought - since hardware is the limiting factor right now, it’s clear that Apple will have a massive advantage with their vertically integrated hardware capabilities. But _they_ are much more likely to go with a walled garden approach, which could hold things back. I think in the short term, the enterprise market is a good way to build the installed base and bring down the cost of headsets. And especially with a lot of people recently moving to remote work due to Covid, I think there is a newfound appetite to try novel things to foster interpersonal connection while working remotely. (Not to mention that many companies now have a huge reduction in OpEx from ditching their office lease.)
- kasajian 4y agoIt was, "like", "cringe". Seriously?
- xdavidliu 4y agothe author is a self-important dilettante
- chatterhead 4y agoThe simple truth of yesterday is the same as today. The wrong people are defining what progress means and leading us towards it for profit not because they have a real vision. Meta is lame. Facebook wasn't special; the approach Zuckerberg took to create a network effect was. That's it. Microsoft wasn't special. The tactics Gates used to destroy his competition and adopt their technology was. That's it. What I'm excited about is the day people who have the ability realize that gives them the power and all they need to do is unite to create an actual digital future for humanity. Not these absurd assholes with dreams of a virtual Oompa Loompa army.
- lostmsu 4y agoSo what's the best way to use Windows on Quest Pro according to their own marketing?
- csallen 4y agoOne of the main challenges of these VR headsets is the time-to-start for any activity. It's just atrocious. If someone invites me to an impromptu Zoom call today, I can join it quickly and easily, because it's likely I was already on my computer. I see the link on my computer, usually in my calendar or in Slack. It takes me a second to click it. And boom, I'm in. Ezpz. Compare that to a VR meeting. If someone invites me, I'm likely on my computer. I have to leave my computer, go find my headset because it's bulky and inconvenient to keep on my desk, hope that it's charged which 50% of the time it's not, boot it up which takes 10 seconds, clear a safe space for me to stand in my apartment, put on the headset and draw a safety boundary, open the appropriate app and hope it doesn't need an update, and then try to figure out where the hell the invite link is that was chatted/Slacked/texted/calendar'd to me. The difference between jumping into something in 5 seconds vs 5 minutes seems trivial, but it's massive. It ends up being the difference between me doing this 5x a week vs 5x a year. What VR seems to need are more killer apps that are habitual, so I use the headset more often, so it's close by + it's charged + I keep an open space + occasionally I'm already using it when I get an invite to use it in some other way. There are all sorts of things that I regularly do on my computer, that I could potentially do better in VR if an app existed, but none does.
- enra 4y agoThis is my main problem with Quest 2 as well. I’d like to use it more, but each time it’s such a chore to set up, navigate, open the app, wait it to load etc. I wish the Quest could just preload with an app, and you wouldn’t need to redraw the boundary if you use it in the same room. Another issue is that quest doesn’t work in dark/dimly lit room, you need like bright lights shining to each corner and the floor if you like to use it in the night.
- bergenty 4y agoThat doesn’t sound right. If you use VR for all your meetings, it would be sitting on your desk (it doesn’t take much more space than over the ear headphones), would be wired and takes about 2 seconds to slip on.
- csallen 4y ago
- r00fus 4y agoJust as an aside, I was very skeptical of tech even like zoom rooms. It's simply a camera mounted on the display that has AI that focuses on people in the room and splits the display so you see everyone in the room individually. Why would you need this? Isn't it creepy? The reality is that our remote meetings without zoom rooms are definitely less engaging, so we try to find the rooms in our office where those are enabled/installed. However, the difference between that and what Meta and Microsoft are attempting is that the zoomrooms are an incremental improvement to an existing collaboration mode. Can you imagine mixed-mode meetings with VR? Unless you have tons of people who WANT to VR meet then it's going be a flop.
- bornfreddy 4y agoA bit off-topic, but is there any good "open" VR headset available? (open in sense of FOSS, or at least OSS firmware and software)
- phailhaus 4y agoI'm surprised he just glossed over one of the biggest issues: > Then one of the developers moved house, temporarily misplaced his headset, and we haven’t used it since. Meta's vision is all-or-nothing. Either everyone has it and they can Do The Thing, or someone is missing it and nobody can. Meta seems to be making no effort to create an on-ramp into the metaverse, and is demanding that everyone jump in whole-hog. It can't work, except in niche cases where the job is in VR. And nobody's going to work all day in VR if they can't glance at their phone. Full-color passthrough is close, but not good enough.
- mandeepj 4y agoI guess it's a no-brainer to imagine why Meta did not choose FaceTime for VR integration instead of Teams :-)
- nojvek 4y agoI remember the moment when I used iPhone4. It was the first phone with retina display, the touch and crip rendering was very responsive. It was the moment my perception of smartphone quality changed. VR is great. I don't think the hardware is there for mass adoption. VR hasn't had its iPhone4 retina moment yet. When it does, it will take off. We need ~100 pixes per degree of vision to fool the eye. Assuming 120d horizontal and vertical display per eye, we are looking at 12,000x12,000 pixel display for each eye. Current meta headsets have 1800 × 1920 px per eye. We need 10x that. There's more: accurate head and hands tracking, 90hz high fidelity rendering, affordable pricing, entertaining worlds, e.t.c. It will take a while, but we'll get there. I hope Meta doesn't give up so easily.
- fomine3 4y agoThere are too many boring comments that says new technology is a garbage. Let's talk about Fb and MS partnership. It seems that MS HoloLens targeted customer is going to migrate to Quest Pro. Will HoloLens sunsetting, or just a new target platform (like MacIE)? I heard that Fb hired many engineers worked on HoloLens, so MS no longer able to develop HoloLens 3?
- Khoth 4y ago> Then one of the developers moved house, temporarily misplaced his headset, and we haven’t used it since. > I’m not sure I can justify buying it for my Passport team, even if we were still going through the hassle of pulling on a headset for one meeting a week. It sounds like he's in the target audience for this VR-for-business stuff he predicts, but he doesn't really want it. If it had been truly a game-changer rather than a gimmick, they wouldn't have abandoned the meetings the moment they had an excuse to, and he wouldn't describe the meetings as "going through the hassle"