14 ms·
Why Men Are Hard to Help
- BlargMcLarg 4y ago>In particular, the dramatic rebalancing of power relations between men and women over the last few decades has rendered old modes of masculinity — especially men's role as family breadwinner — obsolete. They aren't obsolete. The mere notion of this is laughable to anyone spending a bit of time looking around. What happened was the standards cranking up to 11 and either the rewards aren't visible, or they simply aren't there. In addition, there's far more entertainment available and children are no longer seen as an automatic achievement. Some might even say, having kids is actively discouraged in the upper circles. >Feminist writer Susan Faludi has pointed out that many men are "clinging to a phantom status." She's right, of course. Based on what? I don't necessarily see men clinging onto a "phantom status" as much as their (potential) lover, family, friends and business network not giving a hoot unless their status is deemed great. Men are still primarily judged on status, not the other way around. >He is not the only one. A common thread running through many of the challenges facing men is the culture shock of women's economic independence. The article really misses nuance on this whole "economic independence" thing. Yes, women got "more economically independent". No, they can't just start families on their own and get by. In many countries, they can't even get a decent home (dual income households say hello). Check the demands of typical college-educated women, and then compare with the available pool of men. Now compare to the current education system, the way society works and what is happening with starting wages. There simply aren't enough men for all those women, and it's evident most women aren't willing to drop their standards yet. Meanwhile, men aren't willing to "step up", as popular lingo would like to claim. The author correctly identifies so many things, only to come to the most safe conclusion. The same conclusion which has yet to be proven correct.
- isthisthingon99 4y ago> There simply aren't enough men for all those women A man I know is attempting to add a new wife to his household every 5 years...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwawaysleep 4y agoYeah a lot of this was women assuming what happens with guys. A richer guy gets a hotter wife, so a richer woman should get a better guy right? Nope.
- onion2k 4y agoThat's not quite accurate. A rich man gets a hotter wife by most men's standards because most men's standards of "a hot woman" are very similar. The same is true for rich women, but women's standards for what "a hot man" is vary far more. Both are attaining what they think is hot though.
- phpisthebest 4y agoA few years ago OK Cupid released data that flies in the face of your narrative, and it showed based on their research that men have a far wider range of acceptable looks than women do, at least of the user of their app
- onion2k 4y agoMen on a dating site will message pretty much everyone. That doesn't mean those are the people they find hottest. In fact, men are often reluctant to approach really hot women because they think they'll be rejected.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>That doesn't mean those are the people they find hottest. In fact, men are often reluctant to approach really hot women because they think they'll be rejected. Pretty sure that is a result of experience not just some miss placed belief >Men on a dating site will message pretty much everyone While true, the data was not just placed on messaging. Other data seems to back this result as well.
- cloudier 4y agoThat’s not the full context on the data OK Cupid released. Men tended to rate women in a normal distribution, but they also mostly messaged women in the uppermost range of attractiveness. Women tended to rate men more harshly, rating most men below average attractiveness, but they also tended to message those "below average" men regardless of their assessment.
- scythe 4y ago>The article really misses nuance on this whole "economic independence" thing. Yes, women got "more economically independent". No, they can't just start families on their own and get by. To be pithy, we went from men having economic independence and women not to a situation where neither (save the highest earners) has economic independence. Couples are now interdependent and single people often need roommates. If you're economically independent, by definition you don't have to concern yourself with your partner's income.
- rhino369 4y agoAgreed. In many ways the conclusion about outdated status is ass-backwards. The men being left behind are opting out--skipping a career and a (planned) family. Successful men are the ones still clinging to the "outdated" view that they are the breadwinner. If I didn't feel like I had to provide for a family, I'd get drunk at night and play video games all-day. Certainly better than working 60 hours a week.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rahidz 4y agoSo the only (weak) conclusion mentioned is the possibility that men are less ambitious/driven/motivated, meandering around from major to major; from job to job, while women know what they want and do everything possible to achieve it. Which is odd, it seems like almost a reversal of the typical gender stereotypes (men are strong, ambitious, career driven; women are fragile lilies who don't really know what they want). I'm curious, is this limited to the United States? And is it possibly something biological? (declining testosterone?)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dageshi 4y agoI have a theory that it comes down to women's biological clock. They know they will only have the option of having a child between certain age ranges (ideally) and that's close enough in the future to plan for. They need good grades to get into college, they need college to have a career and establish themselves before they hopefully find a partner and have a child around 30ish? Might not go according to plan, but it's a template of sorts. Men really don't have anything like that, in the past perhaps there was, an expectation of getting educated and established by a certain age in order to attract a wife and provide for her and the family. I think it probably leaves some men unanchored with no real direction or ambition, no clue even what they should do.
- dcolkitt 4y agoSeems like it's mostly driven by changes to the composition of the job market. 50 years ago many more good paying jobs required a degree of physical labor that heavily favored men. The economy today has shifted from manufacturing to the service sector, which favors cooperation and communication. Women, even a hundred years ago, have always been more pro-social than men. They tend to have more friends, talk to their friends and family more often, know and ask more about the personal lives of the people around them. This far predates modernity, and has probably been true going all the way back to the neolithic era. The only difference is that in an age where email jobs have replaced the factory floor, the economic premium to these skills has gone way up.
- paulhart 4y agoAnd yet, for the men who go to (the right) universities, and choose to join a fraternity: https://slate.com/human-interest/2022/10/sex-ratio-college-campuses-hookup-culture-friends-with-benefits.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2022/10/sex-ratio-college-c...
- mistrial9 4y agothe extremes of meaningless sex, and no-sex, are both increasing.. ?
- tksiden 4y ago
- FrontierPsych 4y ago
- belorn 4y ago> "For what it's worth, I think Jonathan is onto something crucial. Women have fought a long battle against misogyny from without; now men are struggling to find motivation from within. Rather than external pressures, the challenge facing men is one of internal drive and direction." ... > "These gender differences in academic performance become apparent early. Girls are 14 percentage points more likely than boys to be "school ready" at age five" Is the theory being presented that 5 years old boys have inherently lower internal drive and direction than 5 years old girls? In my world, providing motivating and directions to 5 years olds is generally the responsibility of adults.
- dleslie 4y agoChildren may be (generally) equally motivated and driven, but without equitable assistance and opportunities they're going to experience differentiating outcomes that are dependent upon the behaviour of adults around them.
- jacobolus 4y agoNo, but statistically small boys are more physically active, more distractible, have a harder time sitting still, etc. Statistically girls are more verbal at a young age, and spend more time talking, reading books, etc. and less time playing sports or video games. Some differences are probably biological, and some are due to different socialization. Either way, when kids get to school, the young girls are (on average) better prepared and more likely to follow teachers’ directions. Then school systematically rewards well prepared (and “well behaved”) students while punishing under-prepared or troublesome students. For many students and their families, rather than leading struggling students to seek additional help and work harder to catch up, it just causes emotional pain and feeds apathy or resentment towards schoolwork.
- belorn 4y agoIf the answer is no then the theory being presented by the article is false. Good to have that cleared up. The problem is not then that men are struggling to find motivation, but rather that school are designed at early age for the statistically small girl. An external pressure we should fix. In the case that this isn't biological but culturally, we should fix the culture, an external pressure. Either way, fixing that children at the age of 5 already get unequal outcomes based on gender seems like a problem we should address, not 10 or 15 years later when those factors can multiply and compound. For example, if science and statistics can prove that boys are more physically active at that age, then the school system should adapt and incorporate more physical activity for boys in order to create better motivation. It is just as much discrimination to not do that as if schools were to measure muscle mass and give girls a lower grade, and then be surprised that women motivation later in education would be lower.
- Kye 4y agoI'm glad it's increasingly possible to discuss intersections of sexism that primarily affect men/boys without it turning into an ideological sparring match. Although it's not how I identify these days, I was raised as one, and I really needed help in K-12. I was mostly treated with anything ranging from indifference to contempt by teachers for asking or even appearing to need help. The article correctly identifies the result of experiences like mine: >> "Rather than external pressures, the challenge facing men is one of internal drive and direction." But then fails to identify this. It was hard not to notice girls were treated better by a faculty made up almost entirely of women. This kind of lopsided representation leads to the exact same sorts of problems when it goes the other way. We're just not accustomed, as a culture, to recognizing it when it fails to match our well-developed heuristics for identifying sexism. Recognizing the fact that this lopsided representation is due to the undervaluing of teaching due to sexism doesn't actually help the kids it affects. The internal drive is crushed early, and it's not easily fixed. All the lovely ideas presented by the article won't amount to anything, and don't by the presented data, when we shove kids into a room where half of them are destined to be treated as uncontrollable monsters in training at worst and future leaders who don't and shouldn't need help by dint of birth assignment at best at five years old. Women get cut down later in the pipeline by shitty bosses, sexist work cultures, etc. Men get cut down as boys and, if they're lucky, they may find some support later in life if they're willing to conform to toxic norms.
- dfee 4y ago> Women get cut down later in the pipeline by shitty bosses, sexist work cultures, etc. Men get cut down as boys and, if they're lucky, they may find some support later in life if they're willing to conform to toxic norms. If (as you say) the support comes from conforming to toxic norms, does the lack of support come from conforming to non-toxic norms? Then wouldn’t the toxic norms, providing support, actually be less toxic - at least in terms of receiving support?
- Kye 4y agoSupport in the same way extremist groups "support" disenfranchised young men by telling them how to buy guns and build bombs while confirming all their beliefs about who's keeping them down with propaganda. I bounced off a tech career track because of all the sexism and, for lack of a better term, "bro shit" in the classes.
- eastbound 4y agoAs a difficult masculinist, who criticizes every article on the topic, I can assess that at least in this article, the journalist did their job and didn’t resort to simplet answers like “muh men don’t cry”. Look at the balls it takes to write the following: > I asked Hershbein what was behind the massive gender gap in Kalamazoo. Because he is a true scholar, his answer was, "we don't know." When you see that, you know that you’re facing a good scientist. Someone who listens and looks at the world. Real science is dirty and doesn’t bode simple explanations.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoIf he did know would he feel safe to say it? What's the probability that true rational fits within our ever diminishing Overton window. Reality wasn't created with our moral sensibilities in mind - to presuppose that it was has rather religious connotations to it. Even in the face of 2:1 female to male college student ratios, look up the ratio of sex specific scholarships that still very very very heavily favor females. As if now wasn't the time to proclaim victory for female enrollment and at least move those scholarships to be sex agnostic.
- ryan93 4y agoPeople talk about enrollment favoring women. But from what I found men still dominate engineering, some sciences and are close to equal in medicine(more men pursue surgery). In blue collar trades men predominate. I don't see how the increase in women obtaining psychology or public health degrees means they are surpassing men. No criticism intended I have a useless degree(economics) myself.
- nonrandomstring 4y ago> Look at the balls it takes to write the following: ... When you see that, you know that you’re facing a good scientist. But it's more than that isn't it. There are many great scientists. What you see here is the courage to speak the truth. Not to be afraid. Not to turn your back on it. In a bullshit culture run by imposters, that is as close to heresy as you can get. Lesser scientists find the truth and know they would be better to bury it to protect their selfish short-term ambitions. Those kind of "good scientists" are ten a penny.
- city17 4y agoInteresting article with a clear analysis of the problem, just wish the author would have gone more in-depth on possible causes. Even if there is no clear statistical evidence for why men are doing worse, it can still be helpful to explore possible reasons, rather than just stating 'we don't know'.
- anon87658907 4y agoI was hopeful for this article, as it touched on some aspects that are important. Most CEOs being men doesn't help the welder. In the one program, there were no male counselors. But it fell back into the familiar trope: if men aren't succeeding, it's entirely their fault. They don't have the motivation, etc. When people use this line of thinking for Black communities we rightfully call them racist, but how can you look at these numbers for men and boys, especially in the lower class and not see something structural? The cynical side of me thinks it's because the people who could study it don't care. There's a notion that a group that has had power for centuries is now losing it, and so it's just providing balance. But making individuals of today worse off won't provide justice to those long passed. I will give credit to this article for not making the case that we should do something because if we don't then it will harm women in finding mates, like you see in so many other similar articles. Men's well-being should be worthwhile on its own.
- bittercynic 4y ago>...it's entirely their fault. They don't have the motivation... I think this is a leap, or maybe we have different ideas about motivation. Seems to me motivation and direction exist at the interface of an individual and their environment. Sometimes forming over the course of a lifetime, and sometimes changing with the wind, but always connected to the environment.
- cercatrova 4y agoSomewhat related, but in my experience with other male friends, oftentimes (not all of course but at least a few, anecdotally) women might say it's okay to tell them about a problem and/or cry, but as soon as you do, they are immediately turned off by it and no longer see you as a strong man who can provide for her. Some of the aforementioned male friends have even been broken up with due to such an incident. It's of course nonsense because every human being regardless of gender should be able to express one's feelings and cry if needed, but perhaps not everyone sees it that way. It is an interesting example of a revealed preference in the sociological space [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revealed_preference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revealed_preference
- leobg 4y agoI think there may be a misunderstanding. From my experience, women do feel closer to a man who is able to share his feelings, and, yes, cry. But expressing feelings is a very different thing from complaining and/or giving up responsibility. I’d argue the problem is that men are often weaker in the area of handling emotions in general, hence they tend to “flip” from “I’m feeling nothing at all” to “I’m useless and the world is going to hell”. That’s what freaks women out, because they feel they can no longer predict your actions. It scares them. (Expose the generalizations. Am on my phone here with no proper keyboard.)
- sage76 4y ago“I’m feeling nothing at all” to “I’m useless and the world is going to hell” I don't see anything wrong with people feeling like any of those 2 from time to time. If it is continuous and long term, then it's a matter of concern.
- thatcat 4y agoIts the transition from one extreme to the other with no gradient that makes it emotionally weird.
- 4y ago
- carabiner 4y agoBecause men are bullied when they ask for it. This is what Brene Brown found: > Here’s the painful pattern that emerged from my research with men: We ask them to be vulnerable, we beg them to let us in, and we plead with them to tell us when they’re afraid, but the truth is that most women can’t stomach it. In those moments when real vulnerability happens in men, most of us recoil with fear and that fear manifests as everything from disappointment to disgust. I've experienced this firsthand, and I think most men have, with their girlfriend or wife (or even mother or sister). Your value as a male romantic partner relies on you being that "rock," and anything to dispel that notion makes your value plummet. Women, even Margaret Atwood-quoting feminists like my ex, are repulsed by male vulnerability.
- qnsi 4y ago[deleted]
- throwawaysleep 4y agoI think it is more that many men don't consider the benefits worth the effort. Plenty of men are happy living in an old building playing video games all day. Don't need a lot of money for that. They need a better reward than just a nicer career to consider it worth it.
- throwaway5959 4y agoHonestly fellow throwaway, that sounds pretty nice.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoAdmittedly, if I end up never having a relationship/family, I could walk away from anything intense in 5-10 years pretty easily.
- danielvaughn 4y agoI’d recount some of my own experiences here, but since my actual name is connected to this account, I’d rather not. But I have also experienced this first-hand, many times throughout my life.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoBecause if they need help, or want help, or seem like they might need or want help, they isn't a man. har har har. They'll only accept help as a favor to you. But they'll call in that favor some time down the line, by making you accept their help, which you'll only accept as a favor to them, of course.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis is part of a greater trend in the United States for higher education. Women now enroll in college and I believe matriculate at a rate of two to one when compared against men. Most articles, like this one tend to lay the blame at the feet of boys and men in a way that would be obscene if it were applied to women or minorities. EG they are just lazier and unmotivated. This is a superficial answer that fails to get at the deeper question: why are they less motivated. Of course I don't have an answer for why, but I I think it is a very pressing question. It is tied to higher rates of depression, suicide, low productivity, and antisocial Behavior
- dcolkitt 4y ago> Most articles, like this one tend to lay the blame at the feet of boys and men in a way that would be obscene if it were applied to women or minorities. EG they are just lazier and unmotivated. But surely, we can acknowledge that there are at least some intrinsic behavioral differences between men and women. For example men are intrinsically more violent than women. 90%+ of violent crime is committed by men. This holds true across every human society ever studied. Another example, it's probably also a human universal that men have a higher predisposition to substance abuse than women. So the fact that men commit far more murders at women, we can probably lay the blame at the feet of men. It's not that society has let them down. It's that testosterone increases the propensity to violence. So, we can't categorically rule out that men are intrinsically less suited to productive participation in a post-industrial economy. (For example getting in bar fights and going to jail during prime earning years.)
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThere are absolutely intrinsic differences between men and women. I think it is a valid question if men have gender specific challenges they face in modern society, economies, and cultures. It is important to remember that the purpose of society is to serve men and women, not the other way around. If there is a problem, we should look at society with a critical lens to see if there are areas to reform to create a better fit. Sure, men are probably always going to commit murder at a higher rate. That said, if men are depressed due to a lack of competitive and physical outlets, that is something worth consideration.
- oldgregg 4y agoMen still 100% rule the world and always will. It's just now a small group of elite men rather than power being more distributed. The entire "feminism" project is mostly just social engineering for elite men to castrate their competition and consolidate power under the guise of equality.
- qorrect 4y ago> The entire "feminism" project is mostly just social engineering for elite men to castrate their competition and consolidate power under the guise of equality. How so ?
- chrisseaton 4y agoNot endorsing the argument, but for example 'The Case Against the Sexual Revolution' by Louise Perry could give you the opinions behind this. Her opinion is that men have co-opted and subverted feminism to ironically increase exploitation of women.
- Manuel_D 4y agoAt the tech companies I worked at in San Francisco, we set up diversity hiring initiatives aimed at increasing the share of women and PoC engineers. Recruiters were given bonuses and quotas for hiring favored demographics. In practice, this meant that men who didn't go to Ivys, MIT, Stanford, and other top colleges didn't even get interviewed. Most women were interviewed, and they got multiple chances to pass interviews. The end result of this system is that elite men were hired exclusively, while women of various classes were hired. I don't think this was some moustache-twirlingly evil plot to exclude non elite men. I think leadership just responding to pressure to increase the share of women, and the end result was this set of double standards. The end result of mandating a specific percent of women is that companies get more selective when choosing men. And FWIW, most women didn't like this situation. I'd say at most 1/3rd were supportive of these practices. The double standards were open secrets, and many women worried that this would affect perceptions of competence. Especially when equal promotion rates were also enforced. Since now you have a double standard at hiring and both groups were guaranteed equal numbers of promotions, which inevitably led to different standards in promotions too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _8j50 4y agoI won't disagree with the "men have it hard" crowd but as a man myself my observation of the root cause is complacency. Blame "male privilege" or "men rights don't exist" or whatever but I have not seen this problem in poor countries or in immigrants from poor countries. i.e.: in the US at least you can get just enough to be complacent as a man by doing bare minimum stuff. So why endure hostile environments, places where you don't feel like you belong, etc... when the benefit is "you can afford just a little more stuff", especially when you are not planning for long term success. Contrast this with east asia or india where you have the other end of the extreme where mostly men kill themselves when they get bad grades or fail standardized tests because it means they can't get any job that matters or pays well and subsequently lose social perks like getting married.
- the_jesus_villa 4y ago>i.e.: in the US at least you can get just enough to be complacent as a man by doing bare minimum stuff. Why aren't women in the US complacent? Couldn't they just get by doing the bare minimum?
- _8j50 4y agoI can't speak for women but they face greater challenges if for example they don't have a degree since blue collar work is not female friendly and even if it is, women don't tend to get satisfaction out of those jobs. It also has to do with ambition, women get pregnant or plan to get pregnant so for those women they typically have to plan for child care/future much earlier than men. Just in society as well, women who earn less are often forced to rely on a man which makes them feel less independent. So to be complacent as a woman, I would imagine being able to guarantee a future where men and children don't control your life or force you to give up your ambitions as well as for many women avoiding "nursing/caring" stereotypes and "physical labor" would be some of the things they desire before being complacent. Of course I am talking about women who pursue college, there are many women who are happy with depending on a man that is well to do but their daughters see how their mothers fare when older and usually want the opposite. These are just my observations, there couldn't be anyone who is less qualified to comment about women than myself, so if any woman reads this, please educate on things I have gotten wrong.
- hooloovoo_zoo 4y agoI wonder if men just have a different perceived utility from these changes of status. Maybe men only want to do something if they think it might take them from 30th percentile to the 99th percentile, but aren't interested in something that is guaranteed take them from 30th percentile to 60th percentile.
- GZJOHN 4y agoReading this article I'm once again struck by how, as with so many problems in the U.S. is so rare to look outside their borders to learn from what is working in other countries. Americans seem to have an almost pathological blindness to seeking out the experience of other countries.
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoIt's not obvious that cross-country comparisons are useful for the kinds of problems the article describes. They seem cultural, and you can't really just decide that the US is going to have the cultural norms of some other country even if you think you'd get good results.
- noirbot 4y agoThere's also other factors - almost all other countries are a lot more culturally, racially, and religiously homogeneous than the US. Obviously a lot of that is upstream from the resultant culture, but it still makes comparison hard. It's easy to point to things the US is "doing wrong" that it's famous for, but it's important to remember that very few cultural dividing lines are actually a majority in the US, and almost everyone is some melange of different traditions and identities compared to most other countries.
- Tainnor 4y ago> almost all other countries are a lot more culturally, racially, and religiously homogeneous than the US. That's not even true in the developed world, much less so in the rest (where ethnic or religious conflicts often lead to disastrous consequences). It's just that Americans sometimes have a narrow lens when it comes to diversity: "they're all white (or all black), so they must all think the same, speak the same language, have the same religion, etc." Linguistic diversity, for example, is much greater even in individual European countries than in the US.
- noirbot 4y ago
- the_jesus_villa 4y ago>He is torn between being the kind of man he has been told to be and the kind of man the world seems to want now. Ironically, I think many men seem to experience this in the opposite direction implied by the article. Men are told to be obedient male feminists, and they find a world in which that mentality sets them up for failure. Women on the otherhand are encouraged to pursue the "toxic masculinity" mindset that men have been chastized for. So it seems that masculinity itself is a winning strategy, just the sex pursuing that strategy has partially reversed.
- bittercynic 4y agoFor any young people reading this and feeling hopeless - it's not universal. There are friend groups, companies, and places where people are kind to each other, and if someone comes in playing dominance hierarchy games (is this what you mean by 'toxic masculinity?) they will be politely redirected, and eventually shown the door. There are good situations out there, and as you get older you may gain the ability to explore more and find one.
- rglover 4y agoAny young man who is confused should read this series: https://www.amazon.com/Rational-Male-Rollo-Tomassi/dp/1492777862 https://www.amazon.com/Rational-Male-Rollo-Tomassi/dp/149277... It will give you peace of mind and it will take away that "wtf?!" anxiety you feel (in time; it's not immediate so be patient). Just read the books and consider the ideas, don't get sucked into the manosphere bs (there are a lot of idiots who grift on these ideas—the only guy who actually backs up his points is the author of this series).
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoThe ability to survive as a species is a powerful driver and not easily removed. It might for some, but the majority of boys will become men.
- notjes 4y agoMaybe all these programs to help students are just a cash grab and tackle pointless non issues.
- rafaelero 4y agoI think there is another distinction to be made here, and that is around sexuality. Gay men seem to be immune to the problems mentioned in this article. They are much more educated and do seem to make the most of the opportunities available (at least that is a trend established from my anecdotes). I think this new generation of problems affecting men is a straight men phenomenon.
- tksiden 4y agoIt's easier to get internships these days by being LGBT, or poc. In an increasingly ultra competitive environment, I can't say I haven't thought about claiming to be gay.
- rafaelero 4y agoI doubt that explains much of it. This advantage already starts in college, and there is no affirmative action for LGBT at this stage.
- wara23arish 4y agoI have a gut feeling that this is because of parenting. I think parenting methods these days dont work. I think it is perfectly okay to use fear of punishment to discipline kids. From what I see today, most kids dont have a limit that they wouldn’t cross. There is no fear from their father/mother/authority figure that can set them on the right track. My gf works with kids, the stories I hear are absolutely mind boggling. Children show up to school with only cookies/chocolate for lunch/breakfast. Discipline at home is nonexistent. Parents give their kids an ipad and call it good. Girls are generally calmer and have an easier time focusing than boys. so maybe its a case of boys having exacerbated effects because of their natural tendencies.
- npc54321 4y ago
- rektide 4y agoThe US's industrial world has been hollowed out, so there's literally far less things to do. Drive & ambitious besuits a nation doing things. But our nation has offshored a vast amount of what it used to do, & the cost of living & risk of starting small businesses stack up to a huge lack of opportunity. I love computers & coding, but it makes me so bloody sad how America is only good at "movies, micro-code, & pizza delivery". We have some other fronts for innovation & advanced works, huzzah, but we are so uncompetitive (given our absurd costs of living, adversarial legalism, & extremely acquisitive mega-corporations), that so much doing stuff, making stuff is inordinately hard to support. What id there to be ambitious & driven for in a world where so few have roles & jobs where they get to be a real & significant part of making stuff? That post-war post-depression era, of building a country anew was such fresh & wide opportunity, & that wont come again, but making a competitive internal economy with things to do, rather than a fistful of megacorps & nearly everyone somewhere deep deep deep down the org chart.... it's the choice between vitality & forever rot. Men wont get better under the prevailing economic dominance by juggernaut corporations using offshore labor. The new EV tax-credits being tied to onshore labor is interesting. But these are still micro scale incentives, an isolationist policy assuming sparseness. Creating a more open competitive economic competition at home, finding ways to tackle extreme cost of living crunches & supporting new ventures, enabling new industrial growth... there's much to do to heal & restore America to a place with things worth doing. This challenge isnt American; we all share making affordable life with things worth doing tennable.
- Mikeb85 4y agoI mean, the article has all the answers. It's an economic problem and the fact is lower class men are, for lack of a better word, fucked.
- RadixDLT 4y ago"Meanwhile, the labor market has become a more hostile place for many men — especially those with less education. In 1970, the wage of the typical American man who completed his education with a high-school diploma was over $50,000 in today's dollars. Now, it's less than $35,000. While the gender gap in earnings has narrowed, the class gap has widened. In fact, the wages of most men are lower today than they were in 1979, while women's wages have risen across the board."
- WalterBright 4y agoI wonder how much of this correlates to being raised without a father in the home.
- RadixDLT 4y agothis article ignores the elephant in the room, boys are being ignored in the education system, while only focusing on girls, this can have many problems for boys when when they grow up
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoI wonder if educators have trouble making the trade-off between "Do I spend a little effort to make sure the just-good-enough kids stay clear above that good-enough line? Or do I spend a lot of effort to bring almost-good-enough kids above that line?" If girls have a head start at 5 years old, there may be a compounding effect. It is sad to think about. I guess if you can afford private schooling and tutoring, you can decide how to allocate those resources. In public school you're a little bit at the mercy of your zipcode.
- dc-programmer 4y agoIt was refreshing that the researchers interviewed did not speculate reasons for the phenomenon. As a laymen though, I’m free to guess. I do think boys propensity to binge video games is a explanatory factor. Based off my experience, playing progress- oriented games tricks your brain into thinking you are accomplishing something tangible. I think the only thing that steered me away from heading down a dark path was athletics, which grounded me in the real world growing up
- uejfiweun 4y agoVideo games are essentially hamster wheels for human men. Just wait until the modern text2img or text2video ML models become text2videogame models... I know that for me personally, I'm practically racing against the clock to try and get my relationship / social life in order, because once I can procedurally generate unlimited excellent gaming content from my home computer I'll pretty much never be bored again.
- explorer83 4y agoThe PHD authored book "No More Mr. Nice Guy" by Dr. Robert Glover actually goes into this topic. He's provided counseling to hundreds of men. He lies the blame at several societal factors but one that sticks with me is that 100+ years ago the predominant occupation was farming. In farming, men taught boys how to work and corporate with other men. Then the shift to manufacturing meant the men were gone all day away from the kids. It's now common for women to play a bigger role in raising boys. In addition, in the modern education system women outnumber men. So boys are now being raised and taught more by women then men compared to other parts of human history. Anyway it's a good book and written by a PHD with real world counseling experience, not some pick up artist or right wing activist. I recommend reading it if you struggle with your own masculinity in today's society.
- JSavageOne 4y agoThe education system itself is a huge part of the problem in my opinion. Women are naturally more obedient, while men are more skeptical of authority. The education system is designed to reward the most obedient - those who can sit still in class for lecture after lecture and complete homework assignments. Add to that the fact that most teachers are women, and it is not surprising to me at all that boys lag girls in school. Boys outperforming girls on standardized tests shows that they're not stupid, just working within a system not suited to them. As a male I always hated school because I thought it was tyrannical, being forced to learn and do things I didn't care about. Luckily I still complied enough to get by, but had I been more principled I might've just withdrawn from it altogether. I think a lot more men would relate to my experience than women. A better education system I believe would better facilitate independent thinking, real world problems, and entrepreneurship. > "The cost-benefit analysis showed an overall gain of $69,000 per female participant — a return on investment of at least 12% — compared to an overall loss of $21,000 for each male participant. In short, for men, the program was both costly and ineffective." I wonder how they calculated this. If they are referring to post-graduation earnings, this does surprise me. I wonder how many years after graduation they are using to calculate these values.
- jl2718 4y agoCost-benefit is easy to explain. Men with a low-tier liberal arts college degree fare far worse than men in the trades. A woman with any college degree at all, is a shoe-in for government or administrative jobs, and a woman with no college degree is likely claiming almost zero income in a tip-based role.
- tekdude 4y agoSome thoughts, probably a bit ramble-y: For whatever reason, I don't know why, it seems like young boys have less 'intrinsic motivation' to learn and gain skills than girls. This means that if a boy wants to grow up into some career... then they need someone to guide them and provide a trajectory with a series of tangible accomplishments to get there. Without that guidance, very few boys have the ability to manage it themselves, and even fewer if the accomplishments are amorphous concepts, like 'learning' and 'understanding'. They need to see an effect of what they're learning in the real world, somehow. I don't know why... maybe to compare themselves against other students? To feel like they exist? In the past, maybe 20-30 years ago, it seems like parents or the school system would have identified the boys lacking intrinsic motivation, and track them into something else. For example, if a boy wants to become a pilot, but doesn't know any actual pilots, there's no flight school nearby or they can't afford it, and the school doesn't have any teachers who know anything about flying, and he doesn't seem focused enough to learn on his own... then he would have been nudged into something else. Probably toward a trade or other blue collar job, which inherently have defined training programs with tangible steps of accomplishment that can keep students interested and motivated (or they won't require much training at all). For whatever reason, that kind of tracking and nudging isn't as prevalent anymore? I don't know... Part of it is probably the push to send everyone to college, but also a general disdain for trades in the education system. Though it is true that blue collar jobs mostly don't pay as much as they used to, relative to white collar degree-requiring jobs, so I can understand that sentiment... But, no tracking/nudging means that more students are essentially being left to fend for themselves in terms of motivation, and harder today than 20 years ago. Why spend time studying a topic that won't provide any tangible sense of accomplishment for maybe 5 to 10 years... when you can play a video game with a literal 'Accomplishment' badges? Yes, it's unfortunate that the boy who wanted to become a pilot wasn't really given that opportunity... but is it worse for him to be nudged into a different career than him for him to play video games through his teens, drop out of college, and then working sporadic service jobs? I don't know... From my own life, I know that I was pretty unmotivated throughout school up until my junior year when I was able to take a basic programming course (not actual BASIC... it was C console apps). I didn't have the intrinsic motivation to learn coding on my own... I just wanted to play Counter-Strike and WoW. After that class though, my grades all started improving, and I did well through my CS degree and afterwards. Without that one programming course... who knows what would have happened? Or, what if I could have taken it earlier in high school? Or if my school had more than one programming course? What's my point here? Not sure... maybe we as as a society should realize (again) that kids need real guidance in their education. Especially boys. They need to feel a sense of direction beyond just learning for learning's sake. If we're going to give every kid the opportunity to chase their dreams, then we'll need to re-think the structure of our education system. More investment to expand topics being taught, more structured curricula with periodic tangible accomplishments, more student tracking/nudging, more specialized magnet schools, maybe even boarding schools to bring students to certain training programs. For whatever reason, a lot of girls seem to be doing fine in the system as it is. The article has some thoughts, but I can't come up with any theories myself.
- verisimilitudes 4y agoI'm so glad this article made the front page, whereas my latest article upload that was actually about programming on Hacker News was shadowbanned so it wouldn't receive any votes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 4y agoNonprofits and assistance programs are often unenthused about helping men, which may account for some of that difference in results. I helped a lost homeless man near my home. There is a YMCA nearby, and you'd think an organization that has "Young Men" in their name would be a place I could point him to get help, but nope. It's a "family" YMCA: https://www.ymcasf.org/locations/peninsula-family-ymca https://www.ymcasf.org/locations/peninsula-family-ymca
- tester756 4y agoI've always heard that girls/woman do mature faster, they're something around 3 years ahead and it felt reasonably cuz I've noticed that majority of relationships in my circle are like that - woman is 2-4 years younger. I think it could explain successed in formal education I feel like this gap starts closing around 20s
- bArray 4y agoI really don't like the framing of this article. The framing (to me) is as if the fault is with the men, and the solution must come from men. Many activist groups have spent generations influencing almost all systems (education, industry, politics, etc) to promote minorities, but instead of raising females to the level of males, they instead removed opportunities from males. I can give tonnes of examples. There are scholarships at schools only for females, there are job application events where only females can attend and there are now positions in political office where only females can apply. There are no opposite example I'm aware of. These are not additional opportunities, these are removed from men and given to women. Anecdata for schools: I know multiple teachers (read: more than 6) that thought it appropriate that they purposely bias their attention in classrooms towards the girls in their classes to "correct the balance". I heard in some cases they would even say "I don't want to hear from a boy", or purposefully pick any girl over a boy to answer a question. In a room full of teachers, not a single one objected to this. In modern times we are told that systemic bias is bad and that more should be done to stop it. And yet, we systematically see bias in the name of "positive discrimination" and simply ignore the extremely obvious fact that young boys and subsequently men have been suffering for a long time as a result. Let's go back to basics. We know how to treat people fairly and promote desirable behaviour. We used to live in a meritocracy and we apparently stopped it to address historic bias. Surely this is now done (for females vs males)? When can we return to a meritocracy?
- tuatoru 4y agoI don't know about fault. The article says that boys and men have less motivation, less persistence, and less ability to plan. These are synthetic facts being pointed out. The article repeatedly says that no-one knows why these things are so: they are symptoms, not causes. The article also says figuring out the causes is a fairly urgent and important problem, yet it is being ignored. > Let's go back to basics. We know how to treat people fairly and promote desirable behaviour. We used to live in a meritocracy and we apparently stopped it to address historic bias. Surely this is now done (for females vs males)? When can we return to a meritocracy? This was never true. That is pure nostalgia.
- 4y ago
- sh4un 4y ago
- tomohawk 4y agoHiding in plain sight: > In 1972, Congress passed Title IX — a landmark statute to promote gender equality in higher education. Quite rightly, too: At the time, there was a 13 percentage-point gap in the proportion of bachelor's degrees going to men compared to women. Just a decade later, the gap had closed. By 2019, the gender gap in bachelor's degrees was 15 points — wider than it had been in 1972, but in the opposite direction. Today, women far outperform men in the American education system. When debugging a system, you look for what changed. The above change may have had necessary components, but like any change, it also had unwanted side effects.
- austinjp 4y agoCurious, how many others are finding the comments here depressing? All the way from feminism is a plot by elite men, through fear of emasculation (literal castration, or declining testosterone), through men losing out because of incentivised quotas, and.... so on. Many of which are portrayed as "the problem" without any scrutiny, or appeal to evidence, or just a cursory consideration of whether these opinions actually take the conversation in productive directions. It looks a lot like the intersection of the Dunning-Kruger effect and (deep breath, I had to look this up) ultracrepidarianism [0] and oh yeah, fragile egos. It frankly makes me lose yet more confidence in HN as a place of remotely well-conceived opinion. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sutor,_ne_ultra_crepidam https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sutor,_ne_ultra_crepidam
- em-bee 4y agoare you saying here that people here are not competent to talk about their own experience? sure, some of the speculations for the reasons of the experience may be over the top, but that doesn't negate the experience itself. part of the problem there is of course that every individual only has their own limited experience to draw on. this is not a topic generally studied. and it's also not a surprise that a larger crowd of HN readers are struggling socially. (and not to forget that the topic is likely self-selecting and attracting people who have a story to tell, or feel strongly about it.) so yes, HN is not representative of the average world, but some of the stories shared are indicators of serious problems in our society. and some are not new problems either. if you disagree with some of the points made here, please do provide counterpoints that we can discuss.
- bradlys 4y agoModern feminism has definitely been taken over by PMCs to disenfranchise workers from uniting. You’d have to be blind to not notice the “if you critique anything we say/make/do then you are the enemy!” type of division being spread throughout modern feminism and most identity politics. It’s also used as a nice defense against any critiques in general. “Our movie doesn’t suck - it’s because you’re racist and sexist that you didn’t like it!” Why do you think the government back in the 60s started really narrowing in on MLK when he started talking about class? You think that was a coincidence…? Also the quotas thing is def real. Idk where you work (I work in SV) but I’ve seen them and I’ve seen how they affect men directly.
- silexia 4y agoWhy do we still have Title IX in law if it has achieved it's goal and swung the other way? My theory for the gender performance gap... Men need productive work to be happy and motivated. Schoolwork, mostly filling in worksheets, is not productive work.
- TerntUpAcademy 4y agoPorn, video games, drinking and other forms of entertainment. I believe most of these disproportionately affect males in negative ways while females are not affected nearly as much. The overall acceptance that it’s okay to keep doing these things when they clearly have negative impacts is always going to cause more issues for men then women
- jvanderbot 4y agoRequired reading for discussing any of this is "Is there anything good about men"? According to this, there's a preference (genetic and societal) to condition men to take risks, and that risk skews the distribution outward, with more failures and successes. One of the main punchlines is that comparing means is useless. Men just have way more outliers in both directions, and grades (maximum-capped) will tend to be lower on average, while income (no maximum cap) will tend to be higher on average.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoSimplified answer that is not flippant: Testosterone. Hormones have an enormous impact on how we think and behave. Testosterone numbers is a ‘ratio’ and not an absolute number. So this keeps changing all the time. For women, this skews wildly during PMS when they have a surfeit of testosterone as a ratio. Which gives rise to all the lame jokes about ‘that time of the month’. But men deal with that elevated testosterone as a ratio throughout until middle age. Men go through ‘andropause’ too, but don’t get enough support. Women get used to mood swings and wild variations in their hormone level right after menarche. This is also why while gender transitioning, MtF is more brutal on mental health than FtM.