19 ms·
FTC to crack down on companies taking advantage of gig workers
- junon 4y agoI hold no opinions, genuine question: how might this affect (sites like) Fiverr?
- bdcravens 4y agoFiverr (and similar sites like Upwork etc) are more of a contracting marketplace, where workers can set their own prices, etc. I believe the FTC guidance here is tackling more captive gig working environments.
- LinkLink 4y agoYeah relative to Uber especially markets like Fiverr are really just job boards for actual contractors to set their own fees and offer their own services through a facilitator. Fiver exercises no actual control over the people using their website other than choosing what types of content are allowed and ensuring order delivery. If anything Fiverr is an independent contractor for both of the other involved parties.
- dominotw 4y agowould be interesting to see uber let drivers set their price.
- encryptluks2 4y agoThey should not just crack down but heavily fine the companies that abused the system and mislabeled employees. It is too little too late IMO.
- mugivarra69 4y agowill update my posteriors when i see some evidance contradicting my a priories.
- tempie_deleteme 4y ago> gig workers are consumers entitled to protection under the laws we enforce consumers of the opportunity to labor?
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoThis is because antitrust laws in the US have been reinterpreted by the courts to only apply where there is an adverse impact on consumers. In order to punish anticompetitive behavior that negatively affects workers in keeping with existing precedents, they get into redefining workers as consumers.
- gruez 4y agoIs gig workers' poor treatment because of "anticompetitive behavior" or because they're low skill labor with plenty of other takers if one driver refuses the deal?
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoThat depends a lot on the specific gig and market. To use taxi services as an example, in some metros Uber has completely taken over the market and can thus reduce driver compensation or add fees for drivers. Hidden fees in particular are classic anticompetitive behavior.
- tempie_deleteme 4y ago
- bpodgursky 4y agoThe FTC is empowered by congress with the mandate of ensuring "consumer protection", so if they want to make a land-grab and expand their mandate, they have to twist the definition somehow to make their legal authority nominally cover it.
- pessimizer 4y ago
- t-writescode 4y agoUniversal Healthcare would be the most useful thing that could happen to help gig workers.
- it_citizen 4y agoDefinitely the first and biggest step in the right direction. But it would mostly be, well, catching up on most western countries. However those countries are also complaining about gig workers being taken advantage of.
- stetrain 4y agoAlso labor competition in general, and self-employment, and small businesses...
- propogandist 4y agoMake their VCs pay for health care, they subsidize everything else. Most of the companies in this space make no money, and should be shutdown anyway.
- Eleison23 4y agoThis will not happen, and the reason is that Obamacare made a great effort to decouple health care insurance and benefits from the employer. Since insurance is now available for purchase on the open marketplace, there are whole classes of employers who don't need to worry about including it in their benefits packages which they offer. It would be a step backwards to require or force companies to include it, especially to gig workers or contract employees; they should simply compensate them enough that they can afford to purchase an appropriate plan on the marketplace. If you do not like this structure then you should have worked to block Obamacare from becoming law, because that was a primary objective of the legislation: to decouple health care plans from large companies and employers, and make that insurance more accessible, on the free market, to more workers than ever before.
- propogandist 4y ago>they should simply compensate them enough that they can afford to purchase an appropriate plan on the marketplace. agreed, but they won't. Most of the "gig" companies are exploitative parasites.
- ocbyc 4y agoOften these "gigs" are extremely flexible for students that can't work a full time job, and have random periods of idle time. Notwithstanding higher education should be more attainable by those same gig workers. It feels like they're trying to move the first rung of the ladder higher and higher. They would rather a young person take on mounds of debt, instead of say a low paid internship or apprenticeship. Current minimum wages ensure automation are going to win.
- worried4future 4y ago> They would rather a young person take on mounds of debt, instead of say a low paid internship or apprenticeship. Current minimum wages ensure automation are going to win. Yes. Abolish the minimum wage. Higher minimum wage forces more people out of the workforce entirely and skews the labor market in favor of large corporations vs small businesses. Amazon can absorb any minimum wage hike you can conceive, they don't want to and they will fight tooth and nail against it, but they can afford it. Your neighborhood pizza shop will go out of business (and be replaced by a Pizza Hut -- paying twice as much but employing 25% as many people and working them 400% as hard) if they have to pay their drivers 15 or 20 or 25 (or more) dollars an hour. Both of these effects, lower labor participation rate and consolidation of the employment market in fewer large corporations, are much worse for society overall.
- ocbyc 4y agoA worker is worth what a business can pay for the value they bring. Arguably a low paid apprenticeship is more beneficial than mounds of college debt. Somehow taking debt is seen as better than simply breaking even. I know many jobs that would benefit from someone "sweeping the shop" while they learn the business.
- eropple 4y agoAnd when they starve or go homeless in the process of “learning the business”? Spherical cows don’t work in physics, let alone economics. Minimum wages are suboptimal but starving is worse.
- dustractor 4y ago
- noahmbarr 4y agoIs this a generically targeted release (initially) aimed a specific company/vertical?
- justinzollars 4y ago
- euroderf 4y agoIf in practice this works out to be the Precariat[1], it's a win for the evolution of the modern economy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precariat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precariat
- shrubble 4y agoIf healthcare is so important then it shouldn't be taxed in any fashion. From bandaids and cough syrup at the pharmacy on up, if it's essential to human life it shouldn't be taxed.
- MadSudaca 4y agoWe’d need to collect tons of taxes just to pay for the bureaucracy needed to not tax anything considered essential to human life.
- pessimizer 4y agoIf we'd just provide health care free at the point of service, we wouldn't have to worry about the taxes.
- pensatoio 4y agoI agree, but so is food. Good luck convincing the govt to draw that line.
- andai 4y agoFirst 2000 calories, tax free! (Once everything is cashless they'll know exactly what you're eating anyway.)
- sudosysgen 4y agoIf it didn't imply giving the government so much information, that would actually be a great program.
- therealdrag0 4y agoFree meal replacement by mail. Huel, Soylent etc. ;)
- chockablock 4y agoIn the US most states (37/50) don’t have sales tax on groceries. Also food bought with SNAP benefits (food stamps) is exempt from sales tax in all states.
- qeternity 4y agoI find this all really bizarre that so many people are so quick to jump to this kind of thinking. Honest question: why does anyone think these people are being taken advantage of? Why would you work a gig job if it weren’t a) desirable for whatever reason or b) if you had a better offer. Where do we draw the line of interfering with an agreement between two competent, free parties?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- schroeding 4y ago> or b) if you had a better offer. ... isn't the lack of a better offer one of the components necessary to exploit a worker? You can only exploit a worker, without violence, if they are (financially) pressed against the wall and have no better options, right?
- qeternity 4y agoNot necessarily, but let's take your example. People often point that the gig companies aren't making any money, and the response to that is often along the lines of "well a business model like this shouldn't exist then". So given that these companies aren't making money, what if these changes drive them out of existence? If gig workers truly don't have a better offer, well now they have no offers. What do this people do then?
- schroeding 4y agoThey will do an even shittier job or be without any income. You want to say "better this job than the worse one then", right? I understand that. But if you view the working conditions of gig workers as exploitive, this can't justify their existence, IMO. Otherwise you get a race to the bottom and can justify any work condition with the exception of the absolute bottom of the barrel. Whether or not you see the working conditions for gig workers as exploitive is up to you, of course.
- kryogen1c 4y agoI have yet to see a convincing argument, here on HN or elsewhere, about how these companies are taking advantage of workers. Most of us are old enough to have seen these companies spring into existence, so here are the steps: 1) 100% of people are employed or unemployed. Uber (for example) doesn't exist 2) uber starts existing, some previously unemployed people and some previously employed people start working for uber 3) those people that willingly took those jobs are being taken advantage of What is the principal that justifies 3? People are not agents of free will, and any sub-utopic framework they have to participate in is immoral? Even if that's the case, I'd like to see the argument that those people who chose and choose to work at uber have worse outcomes than they otherwise would.
- dylan604 4y agoUber originally hired licensed drivers and paid them handsomly. As Uber continued to become Uber, the deals the drivers had kept changing. That by itself is being taken advantage of from the driver's perspective. It only got worse from there.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoThe argument I’d make is that Uber game-ifies payouts, so it can be hard to actually know how much you’re making and it could take a while to realize if you’re profiting. Throw in some wishful thinking and gambling tendencies and you can quite easily take advantage of human psychology. Separately - companies in the US take advantage of most employees. So I’d say any large employer could do with an FTC shakedown.
- kansface 4y agoSo you’d be OK with requirements that eg Uber provides those numbers in plain English?
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoI think the system needs to change. You have no idea if the ride in that zone will take you 30 minutes away so you actually need to drive back unpaid to get higher fares. I think with enough transparency it can be fair to the drivers - but to the detriment of the customer experience.
- yieldcrv 4y agoWho are they targeting, who is this for?
- baby 4y ago"protecting America's consumers". As a consumer I like Uber, but I don't understand why I have to pay hidden fees for everything, why I can't easily unsubscribe from something, why I receive spam constantly on my phone and email, why I can't easily cancel a flight if I realized that I made a mistake right after buying it, why my rent can dramatically increase arbitrarily, why medicine is so expensive, why AirBnB can display fake prices on their page, why I can become broke for receiving a paycheck, why healthcare is tied to my job, why...
- morelandjs 4y agoFor starters, they are not accurately advertising the compensation for the gig. By every sane measure, the money earned is wages less the cost of owning and using the vehicle. They are not so subtlety convincing people to sign on to a terrible deal, because a lot of workers don’t realize how expensive vehicles are.
- ciupicri 4y agoAs far as I know most of the workers use their own vehicles and in that case, how is it possible they don't know how expensive they are?
- rdtwo 4y agoI’ll believe it when I see it. Probably huge fines for small and medium business and nothing for the big offenders
- tlogan 4y agoAll these problems are because gov do not offer health care and we have strange regulations that certain employees (not all) need to offer it. So if they do crack down on “taking advantage” then a new set companies will arise: Uber-driver subcontractors. Less than 50 employees so they do not have all these rules and they offer services to Uber. Same like cooks, security guards, cleaning and other subcontractors which do not have any protection but Google, Facebook and others depends on them. In short, regardless what FTC does it will not help the actual workers.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agos/on companies taking advantage of //
- siliconc0w 4y agoAny employer who pays less than the cost of living is effectively transitioning that cost to the state and should pay the difference to the state (or, easier, to the worker). Otherwise we're effectively subsidizing these companies and food delivery isn't something the state should subsidize.
- throwaway09223 4y agoThis style of argument is nonsense. As to earnings, if I have a company and I earn $20k/yr on the side for myself I am not "transitioning that cost to the state" and I should not be prevented by law from operating my business. The same is true if I employ someone to do the work rather than doing it myself. As to determining the cost of living: How would you propose this even be done? The cost of a student living at home is very different from a single person, and in turn is very different from a family with arbitrarily large numbers of dependents. There is no such thing as a universal cost of living. Prohibiting part-time work only hurts people who could otherwise benefit from it -- like students who do not have availability to work full time hours.
- fairity 4y agoI'd like to discuss whose responsibility it should be to ensure citizens have access to basic income (to purchase food and shelter) and healthcare. Is it: 1) the government 2) corporations or 3) nobody? Currently, it's the government's responsibility if you're unemployed. And, it's the corporations' responsibility if you're employed. As a result, you have corporations that are trying to skirt the responsibility by claiming that their workers are not actually employees. But, why do we rely on corporations to provide basic income and healthcare to BEGIN with? Isn't it better if the government provides a social safety net to ANYONE (employed or unemployed)?
- d23 4y ago> But, why do we rely on corporations to provide basic income and healthcare to BEGIN with? Isn't it better if the government provides a social safety net to ANYONE (employed or unemployed)? Healthcare maybe. But the income argument taken to the extreme: if no one works, society will cease to function. When you work for a corporation you are trading your effort for wages. It seems reasonable to pay a living wage to someone working 40 hours a week. They are contributing to society and shouldn't have to struggle.
- fairity 4y ago> If no one works, society will cease to function. I assume you don't actually mean to suggest EVERYONE would stop working. Rather, I assume you're suggesting that UBI, at a level of ~$1500 per month, would result in anyone making minimum wage to quit. Is there data that supports this? I would think that ~$1500 per month provides such a sub-standard quality of life that most of these people would continue working to supplement their income OR invest in learning to further their career. And, corporations, would be forced to increase pay, which would take some readjustment, but wouldn't be the end of the world. > It seems reasonable to pay a living wage to someone working 40 hours a week. I'm saying that, if you remove the need for a social safety net, this statement doesn't ring true. That is, if you're not providing value to an employer, it's not reasonable for them to pay you ANYTHING.
- unity1001 4y agoAll it took was the Eu telling those companies that those were employees, not contract workers and the companies had to give them full rights. ~6 months later, the US regulators 'just' see the light...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- syntaxing 4y agoThe government should regulate gig workers the same reason why we don’t have child labor. At some point, society needs to agree that protecting a certain group of people is important morally instead of spewing economic religious thoughts like “buTS iTs ThEir cHoice”. I’m pro capitalism but in some cases, laissez faire means we want the privileged to remain privileged and the poor to remain poor.
- ciupicri 4y ago
- LinkLink 4y agoUbers real disruption is labor exploitation but not in the way you think. Uber is allowed to get away with the mistreatment of the Drivers because they define them as independent contractors, but how do they do this? An employee of a company is in traditional terms, somebody who acts for the benefit and interests of a larger entity which engages in business to business or customer interaction, in return for earning a reasonable wage and defined employment terms set by the company. An independent contractor is an individual entity, who by setting their own terms and prices, provides a service for other individual entities for the purpose of earning a reasonable income for themselves. What Uber has done, is see all the protections afforded to employees of a company both traditionally and federally, and sidestep them because they call their drivers independent contractors. It is implied that the Driver is setting their own pricing and terms of employment. They may legally technically be doing so, but what they're really doing is agreeing to the same terms set by Uber and defined by Uber as every other driver, as if they were employees. This allows Uber to really do whatever they want to an "independent contractor" which has agreed to their terms of not setting their own rates, having no transparency, and being totally subject to Ubers conditional compensation agreements.
- kderbyma 4y agothis is very similar inside of software service companies and IT. the company provides on-site resources who are all technically contractors with their own separate legals. they should be avoided at all costs.
- hilyen 4y agoA lot of people talking about Uber, so I'll mention that with Uber, you use your own vehicle. That vehicle loses value the more you work for Uber with it. Uber is extracting that value from your vehicle and using it to profit from. Uber, Doordash, etc should be paying for the depreciation of every vehicle they use, as well as fuel usage.
- gruez 4y agoWhy should they be on the hook for it? Shouldn't the per mile/minute rate that they pay the driver already theoretically covers it.
- hilyen 4y agoIt doesn't.
- gruez 4y agoSource? Uber's rate for san francisco ($0.91 per mile) is way above the IRS's standard mileage rate, which is only $0.625 per mile. I'm sure that there are ways to make your costs exceed that (eg. if you get a short dated lease, or an expensive car), but that seems like the driver's problem than uber's problem.
- ciupicri 4y agoThen don't work for Uber, Doordash, etc?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- theknocker 4y ago
- dirtbag__dad 4y agoInteresting how the FTC paints these companies as evil, yet the FTC owns the (lack of) rules they are operating in. People will always make what’s best for themselves within in their environment. If the FTC wants certain behaviors, they need to address it. If they fail to do that, it’s themselves they should blame.
- mbfg 4y agoI assume those who decry this effort to regulate gig companies, are against minimum wage, and against setting minimum working conditions, as well. Clearly no one would need to take a job if these safety nets weren't there, and would they be better off with no money, rather than $.50/hour? If an argument is made as to what is the minimum standard that a person should expect to receive at any company is truly the question, then fine. That is a reasonable discussion. And likely one that no one honestly knows the exact answer to. What do we want to be as a society? How little do we want to help people who weren't "the lucky ones"?
- klyrs 4y agoYes people on HN regularly argue against minimum wage and, occasionally, debate the economics of slavery.
- mbfg 4y agoTell me how that argument is qualitatively different for arguing against gig workers rights? Again if you want to argue it's quantitatively different, then fine. Then it's just a discussion on how low is too low. But the arguments here tend to be of the form, if you don't like, don't take it, or take it and shut up.
- klyrs 4y agoI didn't say that I agreed with them, did I?
- ab_testing 4y agoI feel that one thing that is taboo to discuss on HN is the work done by illegal immigrants and their effect on the depression of wages and benefits provided at these lower end jobs. As per the Pew center research report from 2014, there are approximately 28M unauthorized immigrant workers in the United States. The availablity of these cheap workers pushes out the legal workers from fields like agriculture, hospitality, construction and leisure where illegal workers are more concentrated, as employers can discriminate against local legal workers since illegal workers are cheaper to hire and control. This makes the legal workers go to the gig economy as provides an upper hand to the gig economy employers. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/anthropology-in-practice/what-are-the-jobs-that-immigrants-do/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/anthropology-in-practic...