17 ms·
NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on Mars
- dom96 4y agoThis is amazing! Just scale this up, send a dozen or so of them to Mars for redundancy and you've got the first necessary life support system for a Mars colony. Really exciting stuff.
- knodi123 4y agoI built a CO2 filter for my house, a "bioreactor" full of algae fed by an air pump! It was a fun project, although by my napkin math, I'd need about 200 of them to offset the breathing my family does. Still a good proof of concept, and I haven't optimized the output at _all_. Anyway, my point is - why do we need exotic technologies to convert CO2 to oxygen? An algae bioreactor can do it using decades-old and well-understood techniques, plus you can build yummy algae cakes out of the waste product.
- Chris2048 4y ago> well-understood techniques presumably not so well understood on the moon or mars? Suddenly you have more, and more complex, variables with sustaining life.
- ttfkam 4y agoI don't think you've thought this all the way through. The algae didn't just convert the CO2 to O2, there needed to be an energy input for that. The Sun, which has far lower output once you're on Mars. What would be the O2 output of your algae farm then?
- knodi123 4y ago> The algae didn't just convert the CO2 to O2, there needed to be an energy input for that. Yeah, but from the article, "MOXIE works its magic by sucking in air, filtering out dust, and compressing and heating the gases to 800 degrees Celsius. The heated air flows through a solid oxide electrolysis instrument that splits carbon dioxide—which makes up 96 percent of the Martian atmosphere—into oxygen and carbon monoxide." So it's not as if MOXIE works for free either. > mars gets less sun than earth Yeah, about 43% as much. You can address that with mirrors.
- outworlder 4y agoNow we are talking about mirrors, temperature control, salinity control, food sources, killing competing organisms, water intake and filtering, somehow shielding them from radiation (while still allowing sunlight!) and probably a billion things I haven't thought about yet. Mess it up and your organisms are all dead. MOXIE sounds better if all you want is oxygen (and CO). Give it power and off you go.
- knodi123 4y ago> Now we are talking about mirrors, temperature control, salinity control, food sources, killing competing organisms, water intake and filtering lol, this comes across as FUD. Mirrors aren't high technology. They have no moving parts and do not require batteries. Temperature control? Keep it the same temperature as your habitat, you should already have parts for that. Heck, keep it in your habitat. But algae isn't that sensitive, it can operate over a temperature range. Salinity control is absurd, who's putting salt in the water and why can't you just tell them to stop? Water intake and filtering? What? Dude it's essentially just water in a transparent container. There's no flowing or filtering. Killing competing organisms? Algae is the competing organism, it can take care of itself, even if we brought competing organisms to Mars, which would be a silly thing to do. I mean, maybe radiation is a factor, I don't know, but all that other stuff is not challenging. And you're spending so much time inventing "challenges" for a simple algae farm, while just handwaving at a device that needs to compress the gas and heat it to 800 degrees celsius? I'm not saying MOXIE won't work, or won't be useful in some circumstances. It's just that I don't understand why it's supposed to be simpler than tried-and-true alternatives.
- danrocks 4y agoAnd then we can start putting ads on it /s.
- bamboozled 4y agoAt the rate we're going, we'll need these on Earth soon :(
- KronisLV 4y ago> At the rate we're going, we'll need these on Earth soon :( Climate changes and dangerous weather events aside, I don't think that things are quite as dire, in regards to breathable air. Well, at least outside of certain metropolitan areas in certain countries. That said, the fact that we even have the technology to do this is good - if we ever actually needed to utilize it after the collapse of too many ecosystems, at least we'd have the option to try scaling it up, provided that the powers that be would deem it "financially viable".
- photochemsyn 4y agoCool stuff: > "MOXIE works its magic by sucking in air, filtering out dust, and compressing and heating the gases to 800 degrees Celsius. The heated air flows through a solid oxide electrolysis instrument that splits carbon dioxide—which makes up 96 percent of the Martian atmosphere—into oxygen and carbon monoxide. The machine then separates out the oxygen and expels the carbon monoxide, alongside other gases, as exhaust." The real necessity is to make methane, assuming you want to launch rockets from the Martian surface. The presence of ice on Mars in some regions means this might be plausible: dig up ice/dirt, warm to generate water, split water, collect H2, mix with carbon monoxide to make syngas, pass over catalyst to generate CH4.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- skykooler 4y agoYou can actually run a rocket engine on carbon monoxide and oxygen, no hydrogen needed: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19910014990 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19910014990 The downside is relatively low Isp, so you need a much larger rocket to get to orbit.
- was_a_dev 4y agoMy thought here is surely it could be sufficient for Martian applications. In reality, rockets off Mars initially will be to return humans and Martian samples. So such a rocket would be convenient if sourcing Hydrogen proves to be very difficult.
- mr_toad 4y agoYou can make carbon nanotubes out of CO. Build a space elevator and you don’t need rockets at all.
- elsonrodriguez 4y agoLong term we'd want to manufacture methane there, in the meantime people have drafted missions that just bring extra hydrogen to Mars and combine it with carbon on-site.
- hbossy 4y agoVarious navies have been doing this for decades but it's all classified submarine technology.
- snarf21 4y agoSerious question: Why are we so focused on Mars? We haven't even made it back to the Moon once. We haven't built a completely self contained, perpetually self reliant colony in some place like Death Valley or the Arctic? Wouldn't experimenting with things give us a lot of learnings when we have increased issue that would come from being on Mars?
- swarnie 4y agoTimeframe, this planet is dead. Mars is the only next best option if you have 100bn and a rocket company kicking around.
- bumby 4y agoIt’s would be orders of magnitude easier to make this “dead” planet more hospitable than to do the equivalent to Mars.
- dijit 4y agothis is the conclusion I keep coming to also; anything we develop that makes mars habitable would do so infinitely more effectively and easily here on earth. I guess that's not sexy but there is a part of me that looks on this planet with fresh eyes when I learn more about the universe. What we have is astonishingly beautiful and we will miss it terribly if leaving became the only option. So logically, emotionally, we shouldn't be looking at mars as longingly as we do.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> anything we develop that makes mars habitable would do so infinitely more effectively and easily here on earth This experiment turns CO2 into oxygen and expels CO. How is that “infinitely more effective and eas[y] here on Earth”?
- dijit 4y agoBecause we don’t have to ship the equipment to another celestial body where it cannot be maintained or debugged? If you’re suggesting that it has no use on earth then… https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmosphere?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmo...
- secondcoming 4y ago'A tree'... what's that in Olympic-Sized Swimming Pools?
- spywaregorilla 4y agoA tree's production capacity seems like a very natural unit of measurement for oxygen production to me?
- Arnavion 4y agoDifferent trees produce oxygen at different rates, due to difference in size and difference in species. Also even knowing about one standard tree doesn't tell you how many people it would support, for example.
- Tade0 4y agoWhich tree specifically and what age?
- spywaregorilla 4y agoIf you have the capacity to use that information, you also have the capacity to understand the ballpark of what is meant by "a typical tree".
- pessimizer 4y agoAnd if you don't, you don't, and a comparison to something that you understand would be better. Give me man-minutes.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoMan minutes in a suit with controlled oxygen? Man minutes in a cockpit? Man minutes in open atmosphere? A bunker? A ship? Large man? Woman? Obese man vs fit? Golly this is as poorly defined as the tree problem isn't it.
- wernercd 4y agoThis begs the question, with all the hoopla about CO2 on Earth... can this be used at scale to pull CO2 out of the atmosphere here? Or add a couple steps to create Sugar? This might be useful on mars but are we using anything similar here?
- gpm 4y agoCan it be used here? Yes, of course, though you need to concentrate the CO2 in the atmosphere first. Is it useful? Almost certainly not, just don't burn the hydrocarbons in the first place and use that nice concentrated source of carbon (and atmospheric O2), instead of burning oil and O2 to produce CO2, extracting the CO2 from the atmosphere, and then unburning it. Will someone do it here? Probably, SpaceX is saying that they will as a way to develop the technology and claim they're carbon neutral.
- politician 4y agoYes, but (1) the atmosphere is a lot thicker here, and (2) we would need to power it with green energy. The combination of 1 and 2 means that we would have to build a lot of renewable energy infrastructure dedicated to doing this instead of using that infrastructure to replace fossil fuel generation. If it makes sense at all, I think that it would make more sense to deploy a solution like MOXIE-at-scale *after* we have replaced fossil fuel power generation. There's an argument that says that the planet itself could clean up the excess CO2 reasonably quickly once we stop adding more.
- nonameiguess 4y agoBeing able to do something like this is important because being able to refill on-site means you don't need to bring enough oxygen with you for a return trip, but we should remember this is nowhere near sufficient to start terraforming the Martian atmosphere. The biggest issue is still the density. It is well, well below the limit at which human bodily fluids boil at normal body temperature. Getting the molecular mix right might eventually be a concern many, many centuries from now, but first we just need more gas at all. It doesn't help that Mars continually loses more atmosphere due to solar wind because it doesn't have a magnetic field, too. I have no idea what we could realistically ever do about that, but solving that is a prerequisite to ever having permanent colonies that don't need to live underground forever.
- Tade0 4y ago> I have no idea what we could realistically ever do about that There's some discussion about it here and there, but the most viable route seems to be just wrapping the planet in 5cm diameter superconducting wire: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-astrobiology/article/fundamental-physical-and-resource-requirements-for-a-martian-magnetic-shield/600798772F8D2C2898A8F3D4058204A6 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journa... Doing this on Mars would be a monumental task, but the concept itself isn't completely ridiculous.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoQuestion, while these Moxie things seem like they would be obviously good assets for a long term self sufficient base, is there any reason we can't just burn candles like on nuclear subs? I would assume that any effort to start colonizing mars would have to get the transport so cheap that shipping an absurd quantity of these candles is probably much more economical than a MOXIE unit?
- arcastroe 4y agoWouldn't burning candles consume oxygen rather than produce it?
- spywaregorilla 4y agoNot normal candles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_oxygen_generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_oxygen_generator
- ceejayoz 4y ago"On the International Space Station, chemical oxygen generators are used as a backup supply. Each canister can produce enough oxygen for one crewmember for one day." That's a lot of candles if you intend to use it as the primary supply for a multi-year multi-human mission like Mars will entail. "An explosion caused by one of these candles killed two Royal Navy sailors on HMS Tireless" probably gives NASA engineers the shivers, too.
- extrapickles 4y agoThey have also been the cause of fire[0] on the Mir space station. They make for a reasonable emergency oxygen supply (no working infrastructure required), but you don't want to use them regularly due to the fire risk they represent. [0]: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/25-years-ago-fire-aboard-space-station-mir https://www.nasa.gov/feature/25-years-ago-fire-aboard-space-...
- outworlder 4y ago
- naikrovek 4y agoI think the comparison to a "tree's worth of oxygen" is misleading, because trees overall produce very little of the Earth's oxygen; most oxygen (50-80%) is created by phytoplankton in the ocean. Shipping tons of single-celled organisms to another planet (once we're sure it's devoid of life otherwise, a high bar, I suppose) is going to produce oxygen much more quickly if you can give them a good environment to do so.
- valarauko 4y agoI think it's a fair comparison if the point is to communicate to a lay audience. Most people have a reasonable mental model of how large a tree is, and the volume it occupies. Comparing the device to something like "the average daily output of 3000 deciliters of equatorial surface seawater" (made up comparison) is a harder sell. We'd have to fall back to comparisons like "4 football fields" or "2 school buses" worth of seawater - though it'd be an interesting comparison.
- mc32 4y agoIt gives people a false sense of connection. How much oxygen does a small tree produce, over what period of time, what species of tree? It's like someone saying, "hey I knew your cousin Dan". Nice, I have no idea of their relationship but they're trying to "break the ice" so to speak with an irrelevant tidbit.
- CyanBird 4y agoWell, that's the natural give and take when you need to address a global audience with unknown levels of background level knowledge on the topic, a tree is relatable and conveys a workable metric despite the values being unknown
- valarauko 4y agoI feel the goal of the comparison is to give people a quick heuristic, rather than a detailed breakdown. The article does say the device produces 6 grams of oxygen per hour. In there any species of tree that would be intimately known to a global anglophone audience?
- richardfey 4y agoI wouldn't man any mission to Mars with no less than THREE fully built MOXIEs and replacement parts to fully rebuild at least SIX. And it would still be extremely risky, since everything would be stored in the same proximity.
- lakomen 4y agoWhat I'll say to that is that we should focus on making our planet livable or preserving our planet before we try to colonize another. And since we can't seem to get even that right why bother with Mars?
- worldsayshi 4y agoI agree that making our planet livable is certainly much more important and we are very bad at that. But I don't see that researching livability on Mars makes us less likely to succeed on Earth. On the contrary, researching Mars livability probably has some probability of producing breakthroughs that could help us overcome our problems here.
- oehpr 4y agoImagine for a moment we all stop what we're doing, crack our knuckles, and then REALLY clean our planet up. Clear the oceans of plastics, the sky of co2, the lands of garbage, and our hearts of consumption. And then humanity gets wiped out by a rogue meteor. A rogue blackhole. A really bad solar flare. An object comes to our solar system and knocks us off our orbit. Our home is wiped clean in nuclear fire. Take your pick. We have all our eggs in earths basket. I love earth, lets get the hell out of here though.
- mr_toad 4y agoThe technology that would allow us to survive on Mars could probably allow us to build self contained underground habitats that could survive a meteor, solar flare or even being flung out into deep space. Only something that actually resurfaced the planet, or destroyed it completely would actually require us to leave. The most likely cause of Earth’s total destruction is our Sun turning into a red giant in a few billion years.
- donkarma 4y ago
- outworlder 4y ago
- elina123 4y ago
- dieselgate 4y agoI think a turning point in my perspective as an adult is being hesitant to change. Current generations laugh at people who were resistant to telephones or something - but I’d certainly not want to leave Earth and live on the moon or Mars. Edit: but cool technology I suppose
- mr_toad 4y agoI’m old enough to remember people saying cellphones would never catch on.
- cletus 4y agoAs always, whenever we have something like this people get overexcited for terraforming Mars. Or even living on Mars. First, terraforming. This is such a monumentally massive task that it is almost beyond comprehension. The distribution of molecular velocities in a fluid is a Boltzmann distribution. The average of that is the temperature. Some molecules go very fast. In a liquid this allows them to overcome surface tension and gravity and become a gas. This is evaporation in water. In an atmosphere, a certain portion of the molecules are fast enough to escape the atmosphere and to be lost to space. This is called the Jeans escape energy. The Earth's atmosphere loses about a million tons of gas every year. And that's fine because the atmosphere is many orders of magnitude more massive than this. Mars has lower atmosphere and no protective magnetosphere from solar winds. This means proportionally more mass loss. The atmosphere would have to be so massive that you can afford to lose possibly millions of tons of it every year. You can calculate how much energy that requires and it is massive. So this brings us to creating oxygen for habitats. This is a way more solvable problem. Mars still has all the suual negatives: 1. A weak atmosphere, which is actually worse than no atmosphere, because it covers all your stuff in dust. Some dust storms last months; 2. The ground is toxic (eg perchlorates). There'd be no growing food like in The martian; 3. Low gravity; 4. No protection from solar and cosmic radiation because of no magnetosphere and (almost) no atmosphere. So you can calculate the energy cost per gram of oxygen this produces and work out how much you'd need to create for whatever use (eg breatheable air, making water, making rocket fuel) and then work out how you'd get that energy. Solar is the likely candidate. I think you'll find the required footprint is massive. Oh and cosmic radiation is important for life on Earth. Why? Cosmic rays are constantly hitting nitrogen in the atmosphere. At a predictable rate, some of these nitrogen atoms (7 protons, 7 neutrons) such that a proton becomes a neutron. 6 protons and 8 neutrons is Carbon-14. That's literally how we do carbon dating (because C14 is radioactive).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Invictus0 4y agoHow feasible is it that Mars could become a mining outpost, powered by nuclear and solar, lightly staffed by humans, and mostly mined by robots, either autonomously or remotely from earth?
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoPretty cool.. These are the sorts of issues we should be looking hard at now. Water, air, food, other supplies, medical etc.
- ChoGGi 4y agoThis makes me more appreciative of the Surviving Mars devs (or at least the original ones thanks paradox).
- PaulHoule 4y agoThe carbon monoxide is possibly more valuable than the oxygen. It's a good feedstock for making hydrocarbons and petrochemicals and also as good a reducing agent as hydrogen for making metals. In fact you could use the CO to make, say, iron, producing CO2 which gets cycled back into the above reactor.
- knodi123 4y ago> to make, say, iron ? but iron is an element?
- im3w1l 4y agoHe means that you use carbon monoxide and iron-compound-rich mars dust to get elemental iron and carbon dioxide.
- PaulHoule 4y agoThis is how a blast furnace works https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blast_furnace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blast_furnace since it partially burns coke to make CO which reduces FeO to Fe producing CO2. An alternate approach is to reduce FeO with hydrogen producing H2O. Either way this is likely to be a circular process in a space economy since volatiles like H2O and CO2 are precious.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoCarbon monoxide helps reduce iron oxide to iron [1] [1] https://chem.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Inorganic_Chemistry/Supplemental_Modules_and_Websites_(Inorganic_Chemistry)/Descriptive_Chemistry/Elements_Organized_by_Block/3_d-Block_Elements/1b_Properties_of_Transition_Metals/Metallurgy/The_Extraction_of_Iron/Iron_Production https://chem.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Inorganic_Chemistry/...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Out_of_Characte 4y ago
- nonethewiser 4y agoI had absolutely no idea this was possible.
- aradox66 4y agoTechnology is so unbelievably primitive compared to biology. They have to heat air to 800C to replicate photosynthesis! And they don't even get carbohydrates out of it. Makes sense, our tech is a couple billion years behind.
- purim 4y agoWe burn dinosaur juice to make engines that burn distilled dinosaur juice to push an object 1/20th of the engine fast enough to escape gravity. To deliver an oxygen making device that weighs roughly a quarter of the engine that has the output of 1 tree to Mars will take a dozen launches. There's no way this is scalable. Whatever innovation we produce here, has to be super light and super small enough to be economical. We absolutely need a world changing type of locomotion one that isn't medieval like the one we use and pride in. If there's an alien race that has discovered locomotion via warping the space around it (sort of like a bubble formed around an object under water allowing friction free movement) then our solution would be funny to them. "So you dig up this dinosaur juice, you then, chuckles, light it on fire to push a tiny payload on top of it to put stuff in space?" "Then your hope is to weaponize it so you can fight better wars and colonize other planets to dig rocks and ship it back home?" All of this must be amusing and depressing to an alien race that has mastered space travel and then some.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> We absolutely need a world changing type of locomotion one that isn't medieval like the one we use and pride in We had cryogenic rocket engines in the 60s [1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_rocket_engine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_rocket_engine
- klabb3 4y agoI guess liquid is better than gas but any propellant is quite limiting on large spacetime scales.
- 4y ago
- eterevsky 4y ago6 to 8 g/hour which is roughly 1/5 of what a single human consumes (0.84 kg per day).
- mumumu 4y agoThat's better than I expected. MOXIE was a small proof of concept. If it scale linearly, a device with the mass of the rover could produce oxygen for a few people.
- strictnein 4y agoFrom the article: > "The demonstration is only the beginning. A future version, about the size of a “small chest freezer,” would produce oxygen at a rate equivalent to several hundred trees."
- Bakary 4y agoAre there any other websites similar to this? Aggregators of non-sensationalized significant science news