13 ms·
Auto giants like BMW, GM and Toyota make drivers ‘subscribe’ for basic features
- josephcsible 4y ago> BMW currently requires car owners in some countries to pay roughly $12 per month to access a safety feature called “High Beam Assistant,” which automatically turns off a car’s high beam lights when it senses another car to avoid blinding other drivers at night. > “Safety should come standard,” Wallace said of adaptive headlights. “Some automakers might think that those are simply a convenience feature, but there’s a demonstrated safety benefit.” This is the second-worst example of this kind of thing I've ever seen. The only worse one was gating air bags (yes, the kind that save your life if you crash) behind a subscription: https://hackaday.com/2021/05/18/do-you-really-own-it-motorcycle-airbag-requires-additional-purchase-to-inflate/ https://hackaday.com/2021/05/18/do-you-really-own-it-motorcy...
- calvinmorrison 4y agoComfort is a safety feature as well. You need to be awake and able to focus on the road. Saab had a funny one for this - there were 3 vents in the front of your dashboard, but one always blew cold air no matter what, so that in the winter, you could point it on your face. Heat cranked and no warm fatigue... a beautiful thing. Antipatterns are the worst.
- switch007 4y agoHigh Beam Assist is a dangerous anti feature imo. Kind of glad for it to be gated behind a paid subscription, saves having to turn it off. I’ve driven various cars with this feature and they never turn it on and off when I would. I’ve nearly been crashed in to because a car at a junction thought I was flashing them to pull out, as I was doing 60 mph, and they did. (Also, I’m assuming the automatic turning on of the high beam is included in the paywall, not just the turning off !)
- cameronh90 4y agoConfusing scenarios like you mentioned are why highway code rule 110 says you should only flash your headlights to let drivers know you are there, not to convey a message, and rule 111 says never assume flashing headlights is a signal inviting you to proceed. Obviously, it's not your fault that someone else interpreted the headlight as an invitation to pull out. And indeed, it's probably one of the most widely ignored rules in the highway code. Nevertheless... it's still the other driver's fault. I've personally had it where other drivers think I've flashed them out, but I had actually just gone over a bump in the road. (I'm assuming you're British because you say junction.)
- prh8 4y agoInteresting, do you mind sharing what makes you've experienced it with? My new '22 Subaru is my first experience, and if anything, they are off way more than I would like.
- switch007 4y agoFord, Kia, BMW, Vauxhall
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't think it is a safety feature, it is a convenience feature. Any driver can still turn down the brights and any reasonable one will.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt is a safety feature for the people in other cars being subjected to high beams. As an aside, one option I like to use to get people behind me to turn down their high beams is to orient the side view mirror so the high beam goes back to them.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI get how high beams work, and hate how some people don't turn them down. That said, I still think it's a convenience feature because turning down your brights is something that everyone is already capable of doing and legally obliged to do. Very similar to assisted driving features that control tailgating. Should every car with assisted driving capability have to enable it?
- HarHarVeryFunny 4y agoMy 2022 Nissan Versa has that "high beam auto-dim" feature as standard. I love it - as a conscientious driver I'd always manually dim, but it's a PITA on a curvy road with little forwards visibility where you are dimming/undimming a lot - nice to have it auto. Incidentally - the 2022 Versa so far seems to be a great car. Lots of software features that might be considered "luxury" come as standard.
- jacooper 4y agoThe smarter cars get, the worse they are for consumer rights and Privacy. Unfortunately its a general trend, everything that is getting "smartified" is becoming an anti consumer black box, and If you care about your privacy or owning the device you bought, you are out of luck. It happened with TVs, and now its coming for cars too, there might be options now but they won't last long, is there a dumb TV in your local supermarket? No, and there is no privacy respecting TV either. I dont hate smart things, I wish I can enjoy all the new convenient tech without being spied on and my private life getting sold to the highest bidder. I want a smart home, a smart car, a smart TV, a smart vacuum. But until they stop being spyware, there is no option other than just not buying, or hacking it to stop spying. The only way to stop this is with regulation, because every other monetary incentive, will continue to push everything towards the same goal, spyware and spying on your every move.
- jfghi 4y agoIt’s easy, just don’t buy one /s
- colechristensen 4y agoMy totaled 2009 Jetta is going to be with me until I grind it to dust. When the dystopian future hits, I'll have a backup car that isn't reporting every behavior and remote controlled.
- nbzso 4y agoSurveillance capitalism, transhumanism, AI government, tech overlords. People have no guts or comprehension to revolt. We are an easy target for the combination of psychology and technology hacks which is “bestowed” upon us. For some time ahead, there will be a temporary mitigation route. But in general, we all have fallen to our internal strive for comfort and convenience. Eventually, with high energy prices and scarce resources, we all be renting everything. So you will own nothing.
- harha 4y agoI think they’re also a bit blind towards what potential market they’re losing, even if it’s just step by step. My peer group would probably have been a great target 10 years ago. Now I hardly know anyone at my level with a car, and if, it’s an old one or cheaper brand. I think this is a luxury product in decline, other options just keep getting better. If I like to pay a lot, I’ll just Uber everywhere. Public transport is becoming less shitty (eg with contactless payments in a lot of places, and google maps to find the routes), cycling is safer (and showers in offices) etc. Why deal with this nonsense, and insurance and fines and parking and repairs? I think they’re looking at these revenue streams as a way to save themselves because it might increase revenue per customer, without seeing that it might actually reduce their market share even further.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoThis, I think, is one of those cases where we need regulation. I would be fine with banning subscription features in any vehicle. What you drive off the lot is what you get for the life of the vehicle, barring physical damage.
- mikedelago 4y agoI'm not looking forward to the future of this. Is an affordable vehicle with competitive features and no subscription model too much to ask for?
- jleyank 4y agoThey can try, but customers might rebel and safety or standards agencies might get involved. I would think this bs will drive people towards leasing cars, which is also logical in case the 2030-2035 no more ICE comes to pass. Is this what the vendors really want? Or the hackers will have a field day, and any vendor that breaks ranks should do quite handsomely.
- csours 4y agoGet that Monthly Recurring Revenue BAYBEEE. If you have MRR, you're a tech company, not a dirty smelly thing manufacturer, and Wall Street might love you. It's kind of funny that the article says > "But it’s not just BMW: industry watchers and consumer advocates warn that the nickel-and-diming threatens to become standard as automakers chase a recurring revenue model pioneered by Elon Musk’s Tesla." GM launched OnStar and Satellite Radio years before Elon bought into Tesla. Disclosure: I work for GM and I am representing solely my own point of view.
- le-mark 4y agoWhew I thought for a moment “scours” was speaking for the GM board, good to know!
- csours 4y agoThey tell me I need to say that.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoWith Tesla, the recurring revenue model makes sense. You get features that can consume considerable bandwidth and mobile data, things that can have considerable cost to Tesla. People usually cite the music streaming and satellite maps, but you also get Netflix, YouTube, and a dozen other video streaming services. I don't use those video streaming services often in my car (usually just when waiting for a table at a restaurant), but I'm sure there's a long tail of people that spend a lot of time Supercharging and will watch hours of content every month and consume tens or even hundreds of GB of mobile data.
- csours 4y agoYes, I think it is vital to understand which subscriptions people are willing to pay for. People are most willing to pay for things where they understand that there is an underlying cost to providing the service, and where they derive value from updates or ongoing service. The service should also be provided at a competitive price - for example you cannot charge for navigation in most cases because people can use free nav services (Google Maps etc)
- _fat_santa 4y ago> General Motors has told investors it aims to generate up to $25 billion in software and services subscription revenue annually by 2030 — up from an estimated $2 billion in 2021. Stellantis, formerly known as Fiat Chrysler, is shooting for $23 billion by 2030. If they made $2B and are shooting for $25B, this practice will only escalate.
- gonzo41 4y agoIt's like a hostage situation. They are choosing the worst way of making 23 billion. They could instead do real innovation and just tack a grand onto the price. People will still buy new cars.
- neogodless 4y agoGM is definitely escalating. They are requiring the "optional" OnStar on all models of some of their brands, and some models of other brands. $1500 up front, covering a 3 year subscription. Not part of "MSRP" but it's not optional either. Now OnStar isn't a necessary set of features. And it certainly should remain optional. But if demand is high enough, consumers will buy from them anyway and they'll continue to escalate as much as they can.
- WhatsName 4y agoI wonder if there is a hidden dynamic that makes markets with decreasing competition increasingly hostile towards the end user? Will every industry end up being the next printing/telco in the long run?
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThere is nothing hidden here. It’s well known and studied that the less competitive a market is, the better at extracting consumer surplus sellers get. That’s why unregulated markets always converge towards monopolistic/oligopolistic configurations. The issue for corporations is that like consolidation, competition law enforcement also acts like a pendulum. Right now, we are at a point of low enforcement with high consolidation. As electors get tired of being fleeced, they will start to complain and you should see enforcement increase.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoAlternatively, competitors will arise that sell the products people actually want. The hard part is designing regulation that curtails the oligopoly without preventing new enterprise. It is easy to fall into a steady state of high corporate extraction + high regulatory barriers.
- arielweisberg 4y agoAs long as competition remains real I think there will always be a manufacturer or model that gives you close to what you want. Mazda for example has stuck with physical controls and hasn't been making any noises about pushing a bunch of things behind a subscription. There is a subscription for remote start and some useless notifications, but at the moment it's nothing to worry about. I don't think they can afford to do annoying things given their market share. They are great cars and it's my preferred brand for sedans, hatchbacks, and SUVs with entry level luxury.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoGovernment regulation is still required. Relying on corporate goodwill is a fool’s errand, historically speaking.
- octoberfranklin 4y agoYes but who regulates the regulators? Google "regulatory capture". Democracies have a poor track record of controlling regulators who make subjective decisions. There is a solution though: regulate size. It's objectively measurable. The Mazda example that GP gives is legit, but it's on the knife's edge of disappearing -- one more wave of consolidation and it will be gone. But of course regulating bigness is a very pre-2007 solution. In the modern world it's all about ever-increasing bigness. Because everybody loves zombie megacorps living off of an IV drip of cheap debt.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoCitizens regulate the regulators.
- throw10920 4y agoYou'd think that, but if citizens were capable of regulating anything, then they'd just directly avoid buying products with anti-features. My average friend and family member is both well-educated and gives almost 0 effort to either (a) looking at what government regulators are doing or (b) researching their big purchases ahead of time.
- dlmiller 4y agoI have a 2021 Subaru that can only remote start via the App that requires a subscription to their "STARLINK Safety and Security" service. It comes with 3 free years, however its $99 a year after that. Not as egregious as other companies as I can get a factory remote starter installed. It appears that dealers deliberately order vehicles without the remote starter in order to push subscriptions.
- anotherman554 4y agoI doubt the dealer cares about subscriptions per see, they would be happy to install a factory remote starter for an additional fee.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prh8 4y agoWith Subaru, you can also buy additional years for cheaper when purchasing the vehicle. I think I could do 10 years (7 additional) for 375. Personal preference now/later but that 375 goes on the loan anyways.
- dlmiller 4y agoI wish that was an option for me. I bought it "used" with 1100 miles, last year. That may have been an option, but I wasn't made aware of it. I had to sweet talk the Subaru support to get the free 3 years. I was also under the impression it had remote start, which it does via the app, but not via the key fob without the remote module installed.
- prh8 4y agoThe remote module isn't stock on any trims, as it seems to be a bit pricey and it seems most people prefer the app remote start. I think that you can have remote start (for fob) dealer installed after the fact though. Maybe check on that.
- chris72205 4y agoAll of these aren't quite the same though. Charging to use hardware that is already present in a vehicle and contained to that vehicle (heated seats) is not the same as charging to use an app that requires a network of hardware behind the scenes to start a vehicle remotely. The latter has continuing costs and it's foolish to believe that would be free forever. Should you be _forced_ to pay this? No. But that's a different problem.
- margalabargala 4y agoThere are multiple different kinds of remote start. Recurring payment to start your car over the internet? Maybe. Recurring payment to start your car by hitting a button on your key fob from 50 feet away (vs having to be in the car)? Not so much. Furthermore, it would be perfectly reasonable for the maker of a $60k car to include in that price the cost of supporting internet connectivity for the lifetime of the car.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoAny vehicle that was available with "telematics" already collects and transmits a huge amount of information, regardless of whether you have a telematics subscription, including location, speed, interior and exterior temperature, whether the wipers are in use, engine parameters, accessory settings, you name it. Whether you're paying for any services or not your vehicle is generating a substantial amount of data, so the notion that remote start needs to 'earn its keep' is nonsense.
- charles_f 4y agoI can somewhat understand the logic of charging me a recurring fee for a service that costs the provider a recurring cost, gets regular improvements, and where data is maintained. TV/sat radio? Ok (not that I would buy that). Remote tracking / start? Why not. Internet access in the car? Sure. Satellite maps with updates? Maybe. I would hope that given how much you charge me for the product, these come included, but MRR right? But the idea of charging a recurring fee for something that's already in the car? Heated seats? Remote start with a fob? That's blackmail-powered greed. As far as I see it, that's the manufacturer's version of protection racket. If you stop paying them, then they're remotely breaking your car. Just because they planted a mole in it. Just because they can. This is so f-ed up beyond grasp. The good thing is that they have the right lobbies, so that won't ever be changed by customer protection. I wasn't surprised that BMW, Tesla or Ford would do something like that. But for whatever stupid reason, Toyota is a disappointment, because I thought they would be part of a few manufacturers not playing that game
- cma 4y ago> I wasn't surprised that BMW, Tesla or Ford would do something like that. But for whatever stupid reason, Toyota is a disappointment, because I thought they would be part of a few manufacturers not playing that game I didn't think Sony would follow Microsoft in charging a subscription for online play, but they pretty much had to because buyers didn't weight the hidden costs of it appropriately and Microsoft was already doing it giving them a big margin advantage (which could bleed over into marketshare advantage by investing it in marketing and exclusive titles).
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoBut Sony is already charging others for everything. Just to appear on PS4 bar, you have to pay a premium. I sincerely doubt, they were bleeding money ( unlike MS at the beginning of Xbox ) providing free online play. In fact, it was their differentiator.
- everdrive 4y ago>I didn't think Sony would follow Microsoft in charging a subscription for online play, This is explicitly why I'd never buy a PS5, and really didn't touch PS4 except to play Bloodborne. All digital services seem to eventually become anti-consumer. You become reliant on the service, the service keeps changing for the worse or becoming more expensive, and it becomes harder and harder for the user to extricate themselves from it. Even in cases where it's easy to step away from a service, it almost always either degrades over time, or else morphs into something you don't have any interest in. It's like a ticking clock. You can't even enjoy this product because you know it's totally ephemeral. Eventually it will be worse than it was, exploit you in some way, or price you out of it. There are a few exceptions here, but they are rare, and I suspect they are still going to go extinct at some point as well, they will merely take longer.
- barrysteve 4y agoWe must have kit cars now, like you build your own pc, and have them verified at the MOT/pits/vehicle inspection when you go to give it plates. The only way to know what goes into your car and truly own it (currently) is to build it from parts. The EV conversion market is growing too. Making cars electric drastically reduces the complexity for dads-at-home.
- LanceH 4y agoSomething which can be helpful when trying to avoid features is looking for "work" versions of the vehicle. It's frequently a different sales manager who is more amenable to plain vehicles. You'll be looking for "fleet" sales, which is generally for corporate clients or maybe high end clients. Some places will insist you go through regular sales. For example, I bought a pickup but didn't want 4 wheel drive. Being in the suburbs, of course, they only order 4 wheel drives pickups. I ended up getting a "work truck" ordered from a different part of the state where they are used as work vehicles. The useful stuff is generally still available (leather seats), just without the extra that a company won't pay for like pin-striping.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KennyBlanken 4y agoAll Ford vehicles, including fleet vehicles, have telematics built-in and it's active whether you're paying for it or not. Ford even offers free fleet telematics services and you don't have to do anything to activate it. Source: worked for a company that had a bunch of vehicles. Boss was unaware we could automagically see fault codes, mileage, oil change status, etc. People don't get it: any vehicle with telematics is transmitting a ton of data the entire time it's running, whether you pay for telematics or not.
- hmmmcurious1 4y agoWell I'd be damned software really is eating the world
- Gordonjcp 4y agoOne of the features mentioned is a "remote starter" that lets you start the engine from outside the vehicle by pressing a button on the key. I'm not sure why anyone would call this a "basic feature", or indeed why anyone would want it.
- phren0logy 4y agoIt's useful if you live somewhere very cold
- prh8 4y agoOr somewhere very hot. I've done both
- pards 4y agoRemote start is a basic feature in cold climates like Canada, especially if you have young kids. It's hard enough to wrangle kids into the car, let alone when it's -40°C outside. Remote start allows the interior of the car to warm up beforehand.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ok123456 4y agoThis just means that circumvention will be an lucrative industry. For heated seats, someone will add a bypass that just adds a physical switch that is spliced directly somewhere between a power source and the actual heating element. Just have to figure out an aesthetic place to mount it. The only downside being, in this case you can't control it via an aPp or through the tablet that replaced the actual console controls. Big loss.
- sonthonax 4y agoYeah, heated seats are just wire filaments connected to the car’s power supply. That has to be trivial to bypass. Maybe as an added bonus you can turn it on with a button.
- rfiat 4y agoI think a much bigger downside would be its effect on the price of your insurance. I can't speak for any other country but in the UK insurers have a reputation for being petty about modifications. Even something as minor as a DIY heated seat switch would have to be declared to your insurer who could refuse to cover you or charge a silly premium for cover.
- ok123456 4y agoThat's a U(k) problem not a me problem. Here people put their cheap base model pick up truck on the highest, cheapest, Chinese lift kit that money can buy with no real effect on the price of their premium. You only pay more when you want to insure the cost of the replacement of your modified parts, which very few people are going to bother doing.
- MerelyMortal 4y agoNot everything will be that easy to bypass.
- bilsbie 4y agoI predict in ten years we’ll all be buying and restoring cars from the early 2000s. It will be kind of like Cuba.
- abruzzi 4y agoI sometimes suspect I'll continue to drive my 20 year old gas powered vehicle until I can't buy gas anymore. Its not that I want a gas vehicle, but that the rise of EVs coincides with a complete re-thinking of the automotive model that I /really/ don't want--subscription services, touch screens, "connected". As someone that has a very difficult time managing my real life, I've reduced my periodic payments to mortgage, utilities, internet, phone, insurance. No netflix, no streaming music services, no amazon prime. And even then I frequently forget or mis-budget. I really don't want to add 100 monthly fees to do this or that.
- benhurmarcel 4y agoI don't think so (outside of hobbyists), they'll be forbidden to drive in most cities.
- lukeschlather 4y ago> Toyota, meanwhile, started charging $8 a month to remotely start vehicles using a key fob — a feature that had previously been free. It's probably not safe to operate these sorts of features in perpetuity. Funding the security team to deal with hacks seems necessary and the cost is reasonable. Really, it's comforting to hope that in 20 years time you might still get security updates. (As opposed to my smartphone which is only 4 years old and can't be upgraded to the latest Android at any price.)
- throw10920 4y agoIf the product arrived defective (including security flaws), then the liability is on the manufacturer and they should fix it free of charge, because they sold you a product with a defect. This is categorically different than software updates and feature releases - in that case, you can justify a recurring subscription, because extra value is being provided to the customer. In the bug-fixing case, the customer literally did not receive the value was promised to them (false advertising) - the bug represents an unfulfilled obligation, and the fix is not new functionality, but the fulfillment of what was already promised and paid for.
- lukeschlather 4y agoSecurity issues with software are "normal wear and tear." If you want something to remain secure you need to provide regular security updates. Assuming it's secure at ship-time, a remote-start keyfob is unlikely to be secure 5 years from now (not without regular software updates.) This is distinct from something like heated seats where yes, if it works it works.
- FpUser 4y agoI can guarantee that I will not ever pay a dime for those monthly billed extras that have no recurring costs to manufacturers. Go away vultures. Next time I buy car I will first look if company uses monthly fee in their vehicles and if it does off to the next one. If they all do then as previously said - I just will not subscribe.
- drumhead 4y agoIt sounds like the Auto makers want to keep profiting off the used car market as well. I would say the solution would be not to buy cars from makers that introduce subs. But people will do it anyway. Sounds like a new world of perpetual renting.
- kirykl 4y agoAuto companies are scared of big tech. So stuff like heated seat subscriptions ends up happening due to some cargo cult bureaucracy, where the idea could be good (new innovative feature) but execution is horrible.
- hjupadhyay 4y agoToyota ! That breaks my heart.
- krnlpnc 4y agoVote with your wallet. Do not purchase any car with these "features"
- remir 4y agoHow long until home appliance companies charges you a monthly fee for feature like "steam wash" or ice cube machine on a fridge?
- neilv 4y agoHow does this fit with "right to repair"? Besides the recurring revenue motivation, can this be pretext for restricting right to repair?
- more_corn 4y agoBmw was a test limited to South Korea. Toyota was a limited test too. We have an obligation to the future to make those tests fail by completely boycotting companies that do it. You don’t want to live in the dystopian future where you don’t own anything and every little thing is a recurring monthly subscription. Boycott every company that does it or else you’ll get the shitty future they’re selling.
- reaperducer 4y agoSo, if I have to pay for it every year, they fix it for free when it breaks, right?
- MikeDelta 4y agoI wonder how long it will take before aftermarket shops appear that can crack and activate all those modules.
- balozi 4y agoVoid warranty and assume road safety risks that the auto maker would traditionally be responsible for.
- AlexandrB 4y agoSo if one of these subscription features breaks, the manufacturer is paying the full cost of repairs, right? Or is the consumer still on the hook for that even though they're "subscribing" to the feature?
- isitmadeofglass 4y agoThe real reason they are doing this is because they see the gigantic gap between themselves and Tesla, even though Tesla isn’t even close in production volume, and the major difference is that Tesla has positioned itself to be a Feature subscription auto company and gotten a “tech evaluation” while they are seen as just mounding and moving metal.
- natch 4y agoThe main record-scratching surprise moment for me with most of these is the outrageous pricing for what is offered. Like taking Subaru's subscription for example, for $99/year after the first three years, for a very limited set of features. Whereas to compare, there are brands that for the same $99/year give you network connectivity with full screen web browsing, access to YouTube and other streaming services in park (including without wifi, using mobile data included in the price), live traffic data, remote start, remote warming/cooling, remote viewing of live dashcam video from every part of the car front/back/side, remote honk, remote light flash, remote unlock/relock, remote window venting/closing, remote seat heater prewarm, map data updates, remote charge monitoring, remote charge stop and start, remote alarm notifications, remote status notifications of pretty much anything, remote viewing of car location, remote viewing of car speed, status, driving direction, temperature… I mean putting all that up against Subaru's offering for the same price, Subaru is just nuts. I won't mention the competing brand which actually catches flak on the Internet for having subscriptions, because then I'll be accused of being a FaNbOi.
- anotherevan 4y agoCue 'alternative' firmware à la John Deere tractors.