20 ms·
Remote startups will win the war for top talent
- next_xibalba 4y agoBe careful what you wish for. Remote will eventually cause a serious compression in the total comp of US based workers.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoIf top end compensation decreases by 20% but bottom end compensation rises by 50% as I'm seeing in local jobs which promote remote work, then I really don't care. It's still a fantastic upgrade over before. The entire reason that I'm in the DFW area is because I couldn't find meaningful work in the New Orleans area, where my family has been for over 300 years. The culture of Texas is just like the hue of the buildings in its cities: beige crap. The cultural equivalent of a generic strip mall. Yet here I am, because there wasn't any remote work at the time. Because of remote employment, the wages that are now available in the NOLA area are about far higher than they were a few years ago. So I really do not care if the people making 500K are eventually forced to accept 400K, because the people who were forced to accept 80K for a senior position are now getting 140K for the same type of work, and that number is accelerating upward. Compression is a great thing at the bottom.
- weakwire 4y agoRemote startups may win the war for top talent (in the short term) but who will win on productivity and by extension revenue? I guess we will all see that in the next 24 months.
- mrkurt 4y agoI'm not sure productivity maps that directly to revenue. People are wildly productive when they work remotely. What's harder is sharing context and tackling large problems with other people.
- weakwire 4y agoMaybe the word productivity is creating some ambiguity here. Company (net) productivity is very different than individual or team productivity. Direction, Strategy and Agility play a much more significant role than raw speed or throughput.I believe with in person communication & interaction it is much easier to succeed in that. Remote introduces barriers. It is theoretically possible that remote can move 100x faster & have better net productivity than in person, however that is far from the truth today.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoI think remote has the biggest issue with onboarding people that can't hit the ground running. I'd hate to be a new grad right now.
- KerrAvon 4y agoIME: This aspect of things has not proven to be a problem in practice; Slack and videoconferencing works well, FWIW. Managers are mainly complaining about forward planning not working as well as pre-pandemic, but they’re unwilling to actually change to fix that problem, which is how you get rigid hybrid plans and not flexibility.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoThere are better and worse ways to do it. But I found it uncomfortable to provide the "spin around and ask your co-worker" experience when helping to onboard people remotely. If someone's taking much longer than expected to get up to speed you want to find some way to make yourself more available without looking like you're watching their every move.
- wppick 4y agoRemote vs. in office has no difference in productivity from what I've seen. Most of in office communication is still over slack/chat. When collaboration is needed usually a tv screen is needed to screen share since two people sitting at one laptop is uncomfortable, and video chat screen share is better for that anyways. On top of that you don't have to wait for a meeting room that may be booked at the moment you want to collaborate. Another big thing is the psychological effect of being a chair warmer. Sitting in an office environment, and being "seen" gives the impressing of working. Imagine seeing someone in their chair before and after you leave each day. It gives the impression that they are "working hard". With remote only there is no chair warming, you have to show results.
- lakomen 4y agoI'm not more productive when monitored and have to waste 2-4 hours a day getting to and from the workplace.
- asoneth 4y agoThis is the crucial question. Colocated employees clearly cost more in the form of office space. They can also command higher salaries than similarly-skilled remote workers because they constitute a significantly smaller labor pool. Despite the counter-arguments in the article I do find it plausible colocated employees (ed: or maybe organizations) may be, on average, more productive. But because there are so many confounding variables I think it'll take many years of evidence before we can empirically answer the question of whether the increase in productivity generally exceeds the costs of being in-person. (For the record my guess is that it will be dependent on the industry and role. I think winner-take-all markets and roles like R&D and startup founders may be worth the added in-person tax, and everyone else will eventually be remote.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marvin 4y agoThis thread treats the question as if it has a single correct answer, but there's a pretty big probability it will vary between sectors, companies, employees and countries.
- joshmarinacci 4y agoI sure hope so. I’ve been wait 15 years for this kind of change.
- Victerius 4y agoI've always wanted to live in the future shown in science fiction. Remote work is a big step in that direction.
- nathanaldensr 4y agoRemote startups with what cheap money? That era is coming to an end. They won't win anything, with cheap or expensive labor.
- linuxftw 4y agoRight? Startup wages are pathetic for top talent, there would need to be a fundamental shift in the industry to afford them.
- spamizbad 4y agoIs the thinking that VCs will stop funding remote companies? Because one advantage a fully remote org will have a slightly extended runway not spending money on rent, office furniture, and other costs associated with operating in-person operations. To me, an office sounds like something a tech company should only obtain after a strong and established revenue stream.
- time_to_smile 4y agoThe thinking is that VCs will stop funding startups period. In the post dotcom bust startups were exceedingly rare, and what's happening right now is much larger than the dotcom burst.
- spamizbad 4y agoIts trending downward, but Q2 saw roughly the same number of deals as Q2 2018, with funding up 25% from the same period. The funding levels of 2001-2005 are a long way down from here.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoThat doesn't make much sense. Nobody is going to decide that a few percentage points bump in interest rates is going to stop them from pursuing profit entirely. Also, it's silly to compare current conditions to post-bust conditions: the market at the time of the bust was incredibly immature and people had been throwing money at ridiculous garbage just because someone had a landing page and a marketing team. We've gone through several entire generations of startups at this point. VCs are far more sophisticated than they were back then, and far more people have made in the tech / startup industry. Millennials and Zoomers are far more hedonistic than their parents and grandparents. They will gladly go into debt to fund their lifestyles rather than cancel that 8th streaming service they haven't watched in 3 months. They're so bad at managing money that we literally have services like Trim to remind them that they're being stupid with their bank accounts. We're not entering into a recession because the economy is collapsing and value has disappeared. We're entering into a recession because of a myriad of supply chain issues and because people are literally making and spending too much. While I believe that our entire monetary system is a disaster waiting to happen... we're a long way from being in a bad spot in terms of investment.
- inferense 4y agowill they win the war though?
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoNope, on average 22 out of 23 startups will dry up into dust, and blow away in the wind. I guess the modern metric of success is how long your team survives. =)
- paulcole 4y agoI always think this is a funny argument because most companies don't need top talent. For nearly every business, good enough is definitely good enough. So the question to me is for average to slightly above average employees, will remote companies "win"?
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoYup, most of the hard problems were solved in 1960 to 1980, and modern libraries cover 99.999% of use-cases. If people are focused on Research and Development in a large commercial project, it will often catch the ire of people responsible for risk mitigation.
- ebjaas_2022 4y ago> most of the hard problems were solved in 1960 to 1980 Yes, if you're talking about sorting algorithms and similar. But there are, of course, still many, many even harder problems waiting to be solved. Harder, because they are compound, and more complex. There's still need for top talent. But it's true that most "ordinary" businesses do not need those types of programmers.
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoTrue Scientific inquiry is unpredictably random, and while someone will often eagerly publish a paper on a subject to boost perceived relevance... many rarely credit upstream sources outside academic contexts. Patents are also nice, as you often get to sue people who forgot to cite your work properly. It is astonishingly impressive anything relevant, generalizable, and repeatable actually makes it back into the public domain. Like watching your dog eat 1kg of cheese... impressive for all the wrong reasons... lol =)
- weakwire 4y ago^^^ this.
- jkukul 4y agoIt can still be a lot cheaper to hire good enough talent remotely. If you're an average company in California you can hire good enough, remote talent 2-3 times cheaper remotely than if you had to hire locally. Just compare avg developer salaries in US vs Europe. "Slightly above average" developers in Europe can do the same job twice as cheap.
- mdon 4y agoWhen workers say 'hybrid' they really mean 100% remote? what aspect of this definition is a hybrid of working from the office? The problem? When workers say hybrid, they typically mean they want the flexibility to choose where they work from and when, all the time. (In a sign of how jarring this concept is to ingrained expectations, Gartner refers to this as “radical flexibility.”) On average, that will be three days a week from home, two from somewhere else.
- ghaff 4y agoA fair number of people use it to mean that they could go into an office or that some co-workers go into an office even if they rarely do so themselves. It can mean come in for 3 days/week but it doesn't necessarily.
- strangattractor 4y agoHmmm.. Only top talent wishes to work remotely while the plebes want to drive into work each day and socialize instead of doing the heavy lifting. Going to work each day obviously makes such lack luster behavior easier to get away with.
- benreesman 4y agoIt’s possible that some companies will pay significantly more to keep all of their employees in office all of the time. But they’ll be paying 2-3 times: higher TCO, more expensive real-estate, and more scope for the (fortunately few) “I’m have people skills damnit” careerist middle managers without technical chops (higher payroll and worse mechanism design). The A16Z model sounds about right to me: flex work with low real-estate burden, spend some of the savings on frequent, family friendly off sites. I know this is controversial, just like, my opinion man.
- ekianjo 4y agoYou can pay as much as you want but after a certain threshold having the possibility to work from home is paying for itself in many ways. No stress from commuting, more flexibility and more focus.
- asoneth 4y ago> You can pay as much as you want but after a certain threshold I'm curious if there is a multiplier a company could pay you personally to convince you to endure the commuting stress and inflexibility of an in-person office? I.e. would you go back to a commute for 1.2x, 1.5x, 2x, or 3x your current salary?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoYou know what.. at three times the salary, I can rationalize a lot of corporate idiocy. There is indeed a number, but between hour commute and higher prices on everything, WFH is ideal ( and some employers muse they can lower those salaries ). All I can say is, good luck. Bar a heavy economic disaster ( its possible ), it looks the odds favor WFH crowd now.
- asoneth 4y agoThanks, that's useful input. > some employers muse they can lower those salaries That seems reasonable given their much larger labor pool of remote workers. They'll probably couch it as paying a premium to attract and retain in-person workers but its the same end-result as lowering salaries for remote workers. To me the bigger question is not how many developers will be working full remote vs hybrid vs in-person, but what the salary differences will end up being.
- vinaypai 4y agoThat might be true, but this is probably the beginning of sharply declining developer salaries. If you're going remote, a developer in California is going to be competing with devleopers in Kansas, not to mention overseas. The era of people fresh out of a developer bootcamp getting six figure salaries is all but done.
- seibelj 4y agoMy company pays SF-payscale salaries no matter where the employee lives. That's how we attract and retain the best talent.
- dijit 4y agoI’m happy for you. Let’s talk in 3 years.
- IMTDb 4y agoMay I dare to ask how profitable your company is at the moment and how sustainable their business model is ? I hope we are not talking some of those NFT thingy where money apparently appears out of thin air and disappears as quickly as it showed up.
- onion2k 4y agoI'm happy for you. Let's talk right now if you're hiring.
- seibelj 4y agohttps://recurforever.com/ https://recurforever.com/
- codegeek 4y agoI don't believe it. There is always a catch. Can you share any job descriptions if possible ? EDIT: There you go. I found one job description that says "Remote anywhere in US". It doesn't say anywhere in the world: https://boards.greenhouse.io/recur/jobs/4171929004 https://boards.greenhouse.io/recur/jobs/4171929004 I also found examples of hiring remote but specifically in Asia Pacific. Are you saying those people are getting paid SF level salary ? https://boards.greenhouse.io/recur/jobs/4625482004 https://boards.greenhouse.io/recur/jobs/4625482004
- seibelj 4y agoMy productivity went at least 10x when the pandemic happened. - No commute - No 1 hour lunch (walking, buying, eating, cleaning up) - Not in an open-desk office where I'm constantly interrupted - Meetings are much more focused and I can hop between meetings quickly - Easy to do chores if necessary during the day and then work extra hours at night to make up - Office politics much reduced, output is easier to measure by necessity and people's output is much more clear Additionally I was forced to double-down on socialization outside of the office, reinforcing relationships that exist no matter what company I work for, further reducing my aversion to jumping ship. In summation, WFH forever, I'm never going back
- bratbag 4y agoMeanwhile the people who were interrupting you have now had their productivity hit. The question is, do the two tradeoff as a net positive or a net negative for the company and how does that tradeoff work in more collaborative roles?
- rodrigodlu 4y agoOne thing I learned going from hybrid to physical, then moving back to remote in the last decade os that the type of people that interrupts you all the time don't learn how to solve similar problems, because asking is cheaper. Having a history on your slack you can just search and remember the solution given. For myself it's also easy to remind someone of the similar problem and adapt from the slack history, like similar commands and steps to solve an issue. If more than one person asks about the same problem you can just copy and paste to a wiki and pin on the channel. It's definitely better if everyone is on the Toyota model mentality instead of the ancient Ford model. Then with the spare time I can actually do a lot with my remote teammates that is more social. Online games are a thing. Sharing photos of your last hike trail is another, discovering similar tastes and food recipes is also awesome. I get that remote is not for everyone, specially people wired for social touching, but I felt extremely handcuffed in a open office space, doing my actual work by getting into the office 1 to 2 hours before everyone else. I found that I'm more willing to socialize now because of better planning, decent schedules, and doing small talks after completing the hardest parts of the sprint, and respecting everyone's schedules by proper use of async comms. Remote is not "anti collaborative". It only requires a different mindset.
- zeroth32 4y agoWho would top talent work for somebody else? It is remote, but you still have to deal with meetings, HR, woke bs, egomaniac visions... And there is always a risk that startup fails... It is pretty easy to start your own project, with some consulting on a side.
- bearjaws 4y agoI never really understood why people say productivity and socializing is difficult remote. It's difficult because people aren't putting thought into it. At my last big-co job the leadership just kept waiting for 'covid to be over' and not improving our remote work culture. Hybrid models will always struggle and 1/3/1 is going to be probably the best you can do. My company is fully remote, we embraced the GitLab model and are EXTREMELY collaborative. Every meeting has a note taker, we use Figma and Figjam for white boarding with incredible efficacy. We essentially have near the same level of documentation as a major enterprise with only 30 staff. Socializing is encouraged via huddles in Slack and I can communicate with anyone in the company if I need to. Collaboration and new ideas disseminate differently online, but as a leader I have made it a goal to make sure we are not putting barriers up online, and actively encourage 'water cooler' talk. Meanwhile we have had no problem sourcing candidates since we can pull from anywhere in the world, we have some incredible people all over the world that we would not have gotten otherwise.
- ImprobableTruth 4y ago>Hybrid models will always struggle and 1/3/1 What does 1/3/1 refer to?
- dgs_sgd 4y agoHow do you replicate water cooler talk in a fully remote environment? Do people do work while tuned in to a meeting where anyone can drop in and talk to them?
- 4y ago
- draw_down 4y ago
- oDot 4y agoWhat a lot of the journalists and execs miss is that the remote part of remote work is only half the story. The other half, arguably more impactful, is the process. Geographic distribution mandates certain work practices to remain productive, and those can be highly rewarding and enjoyable to work with. Especially compared to something like agile/scrum. They'll catch up eventually, but at least in the meanwhile I'm getting paid to help with this.
- TOMDM 4y agoOkay, how about a tad more nuance though. The better headline would be "Remote Startups will win the war for top talent among employees who prefer to work remotely" Not quite so sexy. Sure some; probably even most software devs prefer remote/hybrid work, but there are still plenty of incredibly talented people out there who prefer being in the office every day.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoI worked for 2 years in Silicon Valley with a WFH policy that I used maybe 2 days total (once for a package and the other for apartment maintenance). If you live close to work commuting isn't so bad. I need physical space in my life. Ideally every day of the week would have a commute to a different location.
- lm28469 4y ago> If you live close to work commuting isn't so bad This, I work from home when the weather is bad, otherwise it's a 10 minute bike ride, which is actually quite enjoyable when the weather is good and a nice way to compartmentalise the day (+ using my legs isn't a bad thing either)
- cube2222 4y agoAs a contrary point, I lived 5 minutes on foot from the office and still greatly preferred staying at home (even though I didn't expect that to be true before I switched to remote). The ergonomics of an office workplace can't compare to the extent I can customize my at-home office and kitchen supplies to suite my exact needs.
- fjabre 4y agoPolio, Monkey Pox, Covid variant x, environmental concerns, inflation. The office isn't coming back unless we fall into some dystopia where they force people back in. People had a taste of life WFH during the pandemic. Overwhelmingly they loved working from home even though there were a minority who wanted a return to the office. The hybrid model or remote work will be the only real possibilities going forward. Top talent does matter and is the edge that companies like Apple and Google use to stay competitive. They need that talent more that talent needs them. Plain and simple.
- ghaff 4y ago"A study conducted on the main campus of a Fortune 500 company found that just 10 percent of all communications occurred between employees whose desks were more than 500 meters apart. This suggests that once companies span multiple floors, buildings, or campuses, they’ve already lost much of the collaborative value of being “in the office” together." This point often seems to get missed. If you're at a large company, you're often working with people on different floors, buildings, offices, countries. I want to be co-located with the people I work with often just isn't an option at larger companies even if many people come into an office.
- cbdumas 4y agoThis cuts both ways though. Working from home my "circle of communication" has gotten much smaller than it ever was before, because I don't run in to people.
- ghaff 4y agoI'm sympathetic to that. Certainly much earlier in my career, I had a lot of day-to-day personal contact with most of the people I worked with. Of course it was a different time with much different communication methods available--basically desk phone and early internal company email--and expectations for in-person meetings and hallway conversations. But today even if I were in my local office, almost no one I work with would be in that office even if they weren't WFH anyway.
- ryandrake 4y agoI'd argue if a company depends too much on "spontaneous hallway conversations" for information flow/exchange, that should be treated as a problem to correct. Most places I've worked that relied heavily on word-of-mouth had similar problems: - Terrible written documentation - Major and minor decisions not reaching everyone affected, resulting in a lot of people not knowing what's going on - Perception of decisions getting made in secret or without transparency - Other non-verbal communication channels get neglected, e.g. the only way to get in touch with Director ABC is to physically accost him in the hall - Remote workers are frequently forgotten or treated as second class citizens - Favorable treatment for in-groups and cliques, based on extroversion rather than job performance These all seem like objectively bad problems for a business, and I'd argue many of them stem directly from overreliance on face-to-face.
- jstx1 4y agoI used to simply dislike remote. Now I hate it with a deeper passion with every additional day that I do it. Other things I'm looking for in a job (apart from a convenient office location) - (1) high pay and (2) stability. Startups just can't offer these things, least of all remote startups.
- jollyllama 4y agoYou can find this but the tech isn't always the sexiest. Look for manufacturing or infrastructure companies. Be prepared for legacy systems, dated IT practices, and being your own QA or DevOps. Edit: if this doesn't sound great to you, look into robotics; a lot of startups are constantly looking for good engineers willing to work in person. Often times they settle for remote, so stress in any interviews that you're willing to be in person.
- jstx1 4y agoWhy do you think there has to be some kind of tradeoff with regards to technology? Aren't there plenty of large and mid-sized companies with modern tech, more stability than a startup, higher pay and offices?
- jollyllama 4y agoI made one suggestion.
- spaniard89277 4y agoRemote work is not perfect, but it's better than going to my office without windows (yeah, you heard right). I don't do creative work or programming, as I work in HelpDesk, so I don't see the reason for going back to my bunker. It seems most of my coworkers have the same beliefs because as my company started threatening with going back to the office previous to thos summer, people left, and many became pretty hostile. In my case it takes a <10 minute walk to get to my office, I don't have to spend too much time nor money, but at home I have a cushy place, two large monitors, and over everything else, I hear birds and see nature while at work. I have to take some mandated breaks (collective agreement). In my office it was dead time, I couldn't do anything interesting. At home I wake up and do some house chores. When my journey ends, I just get up, pack some stuff and go to the beach or go meet friends. I have way more energy than when I worked at the office. I'm clearly not "top talent" but having tried this, I can't just forget it. Companies say there's a lot of intangible benefits while working at the office, and I say there is a lot of intangible benefits while working at home, at least for me. I didn't even know I was to have that much energy and do so much stuff instead of laying in the sofa because I was tired.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoAgree that WFH is ideal for cases such as yours where you're not working on the actual construction aspect (where more interaction is helpful for solving problems and/or better ideas).
- mooreds 4y agoThe $1M question in my mind is: Will wages in, say, Lagos or Buenos Aires rise to SF/NYC levels? Or will the reverse happen? Economics says that it depends on the value of the labor, but cost of living matters too (or at least, has in the past within say, the USA). I think this essay https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/software-engineering-salaries-in-the-netherlands-and-europe/ https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/software-engineering-sala... shows evidence that says the answer is "yes", that we'll see a weird fracturing of labor markets.
- ghaff 4y agoCulture, language, timezones, etc. will still be a factor. What I think you can probably safely say is that, within the US say, you'll probably have some degree of normalization of salaries over time. You'll probably still have outliers with the biggest/best-paying tech companies, some areas of finance, particularly well-funded startups, etc. But, as was already the case before, a lot of companies simply won't even try to match the top-tier salary bands. And mostly they'll be fine because hiring practices are simply random enough that no one really skims the cream with their processes.
- dfadsadsf 4y agoThere are virtually no engineers in Lagos and very few in Buenos Aires who compete with engineers in SF/NYC (the one getting SF/NYC salary) in terms of skill set. One thing that many people overestimate is number of competent engineers outside of well known tech hubs. I know that it was big surprise for FB and other big tier 1 companies when they started to hire remotely was that it was not actually easier to hire remotely than hiring in NYC/SF. The remote pool ended up being pretty small.
- vsareto 4y ago>One thing that many people overestimate is number of competent engineers outside of well known tech hubs. I think at this point, the meaning of competent is the top 1% of engineers
- TrackerFF 4y agoI'm simply not buying it. If you can't find potential in a candidate pool that's practically in the tens to hundreds of millions, it's more likely your search methods aren't cutting it. EDIT: But let me specify - the original premise to this was that there are already two comparable candidates in SF and somewhere else in the world.
- bko 4y agoOne interesting spin on this is the question "what new competitor would you be most afraid of? 100% remote, hybrid or in person team?" The poll I saw overwhelmingly had "in person team" as the competitor that is most dangerous. Talent isn't just about hiring the right people, but getting the most out of them. With 100% remote you're also selecting for people that want to be more comfortable or unsupervised. It could be a good or bad.
- koonsolo 4y agoIf it's a small company, definitely the in person team. Information just flows way faster, and if you get to keep your employees, you don't need to "waste" too much on documentation, since everyone knows everything. For a big company, if you are wel organized, I think the remote team can be way more productive. But it should be made up of mainly seniors.
- bamboozled 4y agoThey might win the war for the best “talent” (whatever that means). Remote only may lose the war for building the best products.
- cpursley 4y agoWhy non-remote employees are commuting (in anger), remote employees are spending time with their family, exercising, working on their hobbies. Which of those two employee types do you think will have have better work output? I'm have a pretty good idea, but am not totally sure.
- asoneth 4y agoIndividually I think remote workers will be more productive. But collectively I do not yet know. I find it plausible that the average in-person organization may turn out to be more productive than the average remote organization. Either way I'm excited to find out!
- bamboozled 4y agoI worked in an office for a lot of years and I almost never, ever remember "commuting in anger". I basically did a comp-sci degree on the train to and from work, contributed to opensource software, caught up on work, read books , talked to colleagues, napped etc. It was actually pretty productive alone time for me. Forced quiet time for 3 hours a day. I was young and I had a 1.5 train trip each way to work. I built my career further and could afford to live closer to my office, but it was still a 30 minute cycle each way, that was still beautiful, my more recent office job, it was a 10 minute ride in a beautiful city. I work remote now, while I think my personal life is for sure better, I'm not sure we're functioning as well as a group. The spending time with the family bit, sounds good, but I'm honestly still working insane hours remotely. Had to sacrifice a lot of personal time of late to my work. I'm probably working harder and longer hours know than almost anytime I remember. It's 6am meetings, 9pm meetings. That never used to happen for me.
- cpursley 4y ago
- gz5 4y agoAutomattic (Wordpress etc) is a great example, and have been doing it for years. However, they are very purposeful about it, including: + Hire for the culture + Commit to awesome, persistent written communication + Meritocracy in which trust can be earned by the work itself + Periodic in-person get togethers (not always to 'do work')
- jollyllama 4y agoI've heard their interview process can take upwards of 80 hours.
- echelon 4y agoThere are so many forces pulling in so many directions. The world is being re-shuffled. Ultimately, I don't think it will favor labor at US/FAANG talent prices. - Young workers typically want to socialize with other young workers - Older workers prefer to be alone, with family, etc. Have funds for larger homes and at-home amenities - Nearly everyone hates commutes - Cities are expensive and small, but exciting. Rural is large, open, inexpensive, but can be socially boring - Office REITs want a return to the office because that's how they make their income - Cities want a return to the office to support their tax base and economies - Offices and cities are a huge tax on companies - Some managers like to manage in person - Extroverted roles may tend to prefer in person - Physical work (hardware), whiteboarding, etc. are harder to do remotely. (Or impossible. You can't passage cell cultures remotely.) - Much of the time spent in the office is wasted / distracting - Remote work allows greater flexibility of running errands, doing chores, multi-tasking, childcare, ... - Workers will tend to choose remote work over onsite work if the pay is the same - It's expensive to live and work in California, not so much in middle America - The pool of talent stretches far beyond America. Fungible remote workers means you can pay $50k for someone in another country to do the job of a $300k+ FAANG worker. From a purely economic perspective, it seems like remote work will win out. But that entails drastic and cascading changes to everything. Labor will move beyond expensive American borders and become much cheaper for companies to hire and replace.
- dont__panic 4y agoCompanies could hire and replace workers outside of American borders for the last... century at least? Video chat and conference calls have been a thing for decades at this point. Why does remote change this equation? If American real estate and salaries are expensive, businesses could always just open an office in a cheaper country, somewhere in Eastern Europe, India, or Asia, etc. I'm a little confused how the bullet points you provided lead to the outcome in your final paragraph. Could you clarify?
- echelon 4y agoTo many businesses, remote workers are faceless and fungible, regardless of where they are located. There may be time zone, educational, language, regional/cultural, tax/ITAR/regulatory, or other differences between workers located in different countries, but ultimately these differences probably do not amount to much. If that's the case, then these differences do not support a six figure salary differential based on location or nationality. The switch to remote work in the US places US workers into the same pool as the worldwide talent market. If the only interface between workers is text and occasional video chat, then a command of ESL English is pretty much the only barrier to entry for having workers communicate with one another.
- upupandup 4y agoIn Vancouver I used to spend anywhere rom 80 to 120 minutes commuting one way to downtown core from the suburbs. It was brutal. You then get to the office, have to make quick small chat, settle down, get coffee, go to the bathroom, and another hour has passed before you are reading emails. meetings and then its lunch time. come back and you settle down again, go to the bathroom, meeting. 4 hours remain to get work done but you can't leave at 5 because of traffic. so you stay behind. Those times I save I directly deliver in value working remote. I can work more hours and I can be more efficient since I'm not tired. not to mention the ridiculous tax and rent costs due to property prices that do not reflect local wages adding to the stress. yeah, NO THANK YOU. I get local recruiters hitting me up and not only is the salary here ridiculously low, they are either hybrid or require showing up at the office. Vancouver recruiters are a special breed: they won't list salary ranges, and get angry when you ask for it, require 2~3x the work experience for the same position elsewhere, and 40~50% haircut when we have the highest living cost in the region. There's a reason why most of its workforce in tech do not speak English at the office, they rather have new immigrants who can put up with this toxicity, and the management exploits them. Modern day colonialism.
- redleggedfrog 4y ago"Your remote team is my company's opportunity." Purely anecdotal based on my own experience, but at my company we have some people who work in an office and lots more that work remotely. The in office staff contribute more ideas, work, fixes, and functional software than the remote teams by a factor of 4 or 5, or sometimes, depending on the in office worker, 10 times. Those are hard numbers right out of our project management system. It's simply easier to hash out hard problems in person that it is on a remote team, and the context is key. You have all the little asides, ah ha's! and comments collected up that provide a better picture than any remote team can get unless they have their headsets on the whole time. Not that you couldn't have a good remote team - I just think the methods of communication available are not best suited to our monkey brains. We're social animal, and we work best socially. What this has allowed us to do is beat out other development teams, both inside and outside the company. Hasn't gone unnoticed - we also get the most important projects and are paid the most. When it matters, the in-house people get the work. YMMV, of course, this is just one place, but I think a lot of people who want to work at home aren't interested in their success as making their work life easier.
- redleggedfrog 4y agoI'm replying to myself here - might be a bit gauche, but I read all the replies carefully and most were quite reasoned and thought provoking. Thank you! Hacker News for the win.
- vocram 4y ago> Those are hard numbers right out of our project management system the kind of work those systems track is assembly line tasks. They can’t measure alone the strategic impact employees have on a company.
- duxup 4y agoI work a sort of hybrid model. We've seen issues and topics that we decide "Let's work this one out when we're in the office." We schedule it, and what might take several video conferences and endless chats ... suddenly takes one meeting and the solution solves a bunch of other things. I agree everyone should find their best way, but for us sometimes there's more of a free flow of information, everyone is engaged on that one issue more in person than when remote. When it comes to some topics it's just much faster and the result is more complete in person.
- plehoux 4y agoI'm in the rare camp of those believing the employees will crave back the office at some point. Maybe not in the crazy expensive cities with long commutes like LA and SF, but everywhere, yes.
- dont__panic 4y agoWhy do you believe this? I think some workers prefer in-office work. But just as many likely prefer no commute at all. Just like some people love crazy expensive cities, but just as many love cheaper cities and rural areas.
- frankfrank13 4y agoIdk why but I can't help but think remote-first feels so dystopian. I joined and left a job that was 100% remote, and tbh I barely remember working there. I can barely remember names or anything I did. It was like Severance. Now I'm hybrid, and feel way more "connected" (whatever that means).
- silisili 4y agoI've been remote for a decade now and -still- feel that way. Ultimately, I think I've decided I probably prefer a hybrid approach. Like T/Th in office. But that only works if everyone is on board - that is, what's the point of me going in on Tuesday if I'm the only one there? That said, I live in the middle of nowhere in a non-tech city, so that's just a pipe dream anyways for now...
- emptyparadise 4y agoI find myself feeling that way in the office as well, so I prefer remote.
- danwee 4y agoBig win for working 100% remote, at least for me, is that it suddenly makes it possible for me to potentially work for any IT company in my entire country without having to switch cities or commuting. That's the deal for me. The moment a job description says 4 days remote, 1 day at the office... that already kills it (e.g., imaging living in Frankfurt and working for a Berlin-based company... or living in Seville and working for a Barcelona-based company)
- esel2k 4y agoI had a Berlin offer and live at the other end of the country. I was able to negotiate a 3-4per month presence but at the end I got a more competitive offer. Out of interest: Is this something that you have seen working in Germany ?
- danwee 4y agoI've seen offers for hybrid approach in Germany, The Netherlands, France,... I don't apply to such offers, but their amount is not negligible.
- didgetmaster 4y agoI think it really depends on what kind of 'worker' you are. Some people can take a task, go off by themselves, and work independently for hours or days at a time to complete it with little or no interaction with others. These people are highly productive in a remote setting. Others require constant interaction with others in order to accomplish much of anything. They need a barrage of ideas and help coming at them constantly and in every direction. While modern remote tools can help with this, an in-person office seems more ideal for this kind of worker. In the late 90s, I worked for a startup making disk utilities (PartitionMagic). I got married and my wife was doing a residency program in another state. I was able to negotiate a remote work arrangement with my company, even though dial-up connections at the time made things hard to collaborate. They gave me a new project to design and implement (Drive Image - a disk backup program). I would fly back to the office every couple of months and show them the latest version that I had completed. I did this for almost 2 years and was very, very productive. It helped that I was the only one on the team for most of that time (they didn't assign someone to help me until sales of the product reached several million $).
- throwawaysleep 4y agoAlso depends on what kind of worker you want to be. I want to just clear Jira tickets. Anything that requires cross department collaboration, I neglect until someone else takes. I have no interest in doing one damn extra meeting to deal with org politics.
- swarnie 4y agoI'm looking to leave my employer at the conclusion of this project (April/May 2023). Full remote ranks first, 4:1 hybrid next, full onsite not even considered. I imagine this is common across the industry.
- duxup 4y agoThere's so much BS and such a dance that revolves around hiring that I have trouble believing that just being remote alone will really decide if a given company gets "top talent".
- whatever1 4y agoRemote work is great once a project has been scoped out and responsibilities have been assigned. You get to work on your own terms and be very productive, because let’s face it, modern open space offices are horrible places to get work done. But, if you are not an entry level employee, your objective is to find work. That means socializing with people in the company to understand where the opportunities lie, collecting subtle clues, show your human side to gain trust. A zoom thumbnail on a scheduled call cannot do any of these. One last thing. I have not found anything as effective for problem solving as having X people in the same room staring at a whiteboard and scratching their heads at the same time.
- vorpalhex 4y agoIf the work is not obvious, it's almost certainly not important. If you can't communicate, changing where people are located won't help. Please don't lock me into a room to stare at you while you slowly gather your thoughts. My time is important. Gather your thoughts and then present them. Don't make me babysit you.
- whatever1 4y agoIf work is obvious then I don’t need to pay one 6 figures to do it. Or to put it better, if work is obvious, someone has already done the work for you
- vorpalhex 4y ago> if work is obvious, someone has already done the work for you I wish that was true. A lot of work is obvious but undone. A lot of issues go unresolved or are chalked up as "unimportant". Let me use your product for five minutes and I will give you the work that needs to be done.
- therealdrag0 4y agoAnd lots of work is obvious to some not other engineers who need mentoring or docs to do it because they’re new to the company or field or tech. White board situations are far and few between ime.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI was part of a startup that was pure remote circa 2013 based on popular OSS projects. I was quite spoiled to experience what would become the norm after a pandemic. I wrote a blog on my experiences of being "remote first". Funny enough, it includes this author's tweet that went a bit viral. https://jondouglas.dev/remote-first/ https://jondouglas.dev/remote-first/
- ctrlmeta 4y agoThe last time I checked the remote startups were not even willing to pay me half of what companies with brick-and-mortar offices were willing to pay me. Sorry, I can't see how remote startups will win the top talent with such less pay!
- goalieca 4y agoThey're paying far more than brick and mortar companies are where I live. Outside of SV and perhaps Boston and NYC, this is very likely the case.
- hackererror404 4y agoPretty sure whoever is willing to pay a ton will win the war for Top Talent.
- sbf501 4y agoNot entirely. Startups have a <4% success rate. I'd prefer a more stable opportunity. As a senior principal, I consider myself "top talent".
- foolfoolz 4y agoi think if you had 2 teams working on the same type of thing and one was 100% remote across 6 time zones and one was 100% concentrated in one city with a office they could go to and only required 1 day/week the concentrated team would have a better working relationship with each other. this depends on the people more than anything. and it’s not guaranteed. but i’d say more times than not the people seeing each other in person would enjoy their work more
- jofer 4y agoI've been working 100% remotely for about 6.5 years now. Overall I love it. However, there are very real drawbacks that have taken me awhile to fully realize. For me, the primary one is that it's _way_ too easy for everyone to get deeply frustrated with each other. Social interactions and chit-chat lead to a better understanding of people and a more accurate mental model of what people actually mean when they say something. Written text is the majority of remote communication. That's both good and bad. It's a much lower bandwidth form of communication than face-to-face in terms of being able to pick up intent and understand the context of someone's mood/etc in what they're saying. The same goes of communication over webcam. It's higher bandwidth than written text, but still lower than in-person. When you're fully remote, you'll much more commonly misinterpret folks intent. You'll also more commonly have your intent misinterpreted. At least in my experience, this tends to lead to a much higher rate of frustration and more frequent extreme misbehavior when everyone is remote. I don't have an easy solution. Occasional in person meetings help a lot, but they're hard to do well, and easy to do poorly. Having 200 people in the same room for 2 days doesn't really help the situation, as there's zero time to get to know anyone.
- brundolf 4y agoThis is a big one that it took me a while to fully appreciate I've found that even just turning my camera on in Zoom meetings makes a difference. Joining the standup call a little early, having "face to face" chitchat, builds up a small buffer of rapport that significantly improves empathy and perceived intent Especially if you need to have a conversation where there might be some existing friction/tension/frustration, doing it over video instead of text or just audio will hugely increase the good-faith nature of the conversation And of course, the occasional in-person hangout helps too, if you happen to be in the same city as your coworkers. What's important is that you each form an impression of the other as a human being, and not just as a faceless mechanism in the org that may be helping you or getting in your way at a given moment
- marrone12 4y agoJust FYI, it's "rapport" not "repor"
- burneraccountt 4y agoI think there's a barbell effect: those early in their career and those in the top levels of leadership much prefer in-person environment, while most of those in the middle prefer remote. Of course, that's a broad generalization and yes, there are different preferences up and down, but I've seen that play out. I've always been an advocate of remote work before COVID and think it'll be a much larger part of tech. It's not without flaws though, as the tooling, processes and general attitudes need to evolve. It's also hard to decouple COVID from it, too. Working remotely during a scary, global plague where schools are shut down, groceries are sold out, and family members are dying is different than working remotely during a relatively normal time.
- dogman144 4y agoAgreed. People saying socialization and collaboration is impossible in that context I think just don’t know how to make Slack friends I think. Even so, some people are just extroverted in a certain way and need that in-person. And, senior leadership often want a footprint to see and sense the troops. So, the question posed to workers is this: Because I need to see people in-person for social fulfillment/for understanding the scope of my authority in a clear way/because this is the way things are always done… I want you to sacrifice your family, finances and time. Now that family and finances are on the bargaining table, and remote companies that “do it right” can seemingly maintain all the necessary revenue generation, I think remote work will win out. It’s ultimately asking for a subset of someone’s socialization needs to be met in return for sacrificing family. Good luck with that.
- diego_moita 4y agoRemote and local will change a lot. And will merge a lot. Drop some Metaverse (or VR by Google/MS/Apple) in the mix and the patterns of interaction on remote teams will come closer to local. Add some of the Gitlab tricks into the methodologies used on local and people will need less time at the office. Add some unavoidable adjustments in the price of real estate or commuting patterns and some remotes might accept a bit of office.
- aronowb14 4y agoAs someone who took their first software engineering job as a junior during covid, I have to say I definitely struggled to learn and execute on tasks in a way which I know I wouldn't in an in person setting. I found asking for help as a junior is definitely harder when you don't have people around (walking up to someone's desk vs slack message with ~20-60 minute delay then zoom call): and I often found myself blocked on tasks. I found learning is generally harder remotely for me as well: the sheer amount of information + resources + help you get from serendipitous conversations with other engineers should not be understated. It's the same reason people got so angry over paying so much for remote university: it is objectively a worse learning experience. I think this is just my personal stance: but I think in my perfect world I work in office for the first 5-10 years of my career to optimize for learning + relationship building, and then once I get more senior (or have kids) I transition into either hybrid or fully remote.
- dudul 4y agoI'm sorry you had this experience, but I will put the blame on your company's onboarding. This was your first job so you may lack data points, but if you ended up not getting helped/being supported as a new, out of school, engineer in a remote setting, I strongly doubt that it would have been any better in an office. I've been a manager/director working with distributed teams for the past 6 or 7 years, I've onboarding dozens of folks for whom it was their first or second job and they all had a really good experience.
- swader999 4y agoI'm hundred percent remote and if I wasn't volunteering in my community as much as I do, I'd go batsh*t crazy.
- dudul 4y agoSounds like a win-win situation to me.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoEven as someone who refuses to go back to the office, I can see in person serving as a filter for passionate people who actually care about the product.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI don't like working remote. I like working in an office. I find it more productive when my coworkers are right by me. Software development done well is an interactive, creative process. It is easier if you and I work together and can brainstorm on a whiteboard, or over lunch, and reduce the friction. And then go off to our respective cubes to hack it up and then share our work. That's the process I've found works best for teams. But I want to work at what I'm doing, for the startup that I'm contracting for, in the space that I'm doing work in. And that's not here (they're not "anywhere" really) and all the local (southern Ontario, west of Toronto) companies suck, underpay, and are generally mismanaged. And I'm not moving and giving up the life that I have I have so I can be where the interesting work is. I've done that once already in my 20s -- left my parents and siblings to go to the only place in Canada where the tech industry was really a thing (at the time) -- and I won't be made to do it again. Canadian tech companies have been profiting from underpaying their engineering staff (relative to the US market) for a couple decades. Now they will suffer because they have to compete with remote. Recession might change this, but for now I intend on taking advantage of this. So, remote it is. It's not perfect. But I'm not going to drive almost 2 hours a day to get underpaid by some mediocre local company run by mediocre management and mediocre investors. There's a larger world out there, accessible to me for the first time ever.
- hashbig 4y agoThis is exactly where I am at now. I live in Canada and where I am at the local market of companies is just pathetic. I generally receive recruter emails from companies in my city offering a 25-50% of what I am making at a smaller shop remotely. I miss being in an office and having a connection to the people I work with, but I also refuse to compromise my salary, time, ergonomic home office, and flexibility to get this connection.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoWhere abouts are you, if you don't mind me asking? (You don't have to answer). I'm rural just right outside Hamilton. The local market in Oakville/Burlington is sad. And right now it's not worth the commute into Toronto (used to live there). I was getting excellent comp at Google Waterloo, but the drive was killing my body, and my soul was dead.
- rr888 4y agoWhat war? 6 months ago maybe there was a war, now layoffs are more common than shortages.
- aprdm 4y agoWhy the focus on Remote Startups tho? There's quite a few of Remote big companies. Or at the very least flexible per team.
- Ninjinka 4y agoAfter college I moved back to my hometown that doesn't have much of a tech company presence, something I was only able to do because of my remote job. I have no intention of moving, so I will exclusively look for remote jobs going forward.
- throwthisHMaway 4y agoA major swedish fashion retailer is _just now_ manating everyone in the IT department back to the office (about 4000 tech people), as of next week. There is a big pushback, and no suppprt from the unions for this return to the office. There will be a wave of resignations very soon. Who's hiring? :)
- sub7 4y agothis is false - remote teams are exponentially less productive maybe linearly less productive if remote from day 1 clever marketing hack for the author's startup though
- renewiltord 4y agoI'm pretty full in on non-remote. I think it's an advantage. Let's see if it plays out. It is true that it's harder to hire but we'll see what the final outcome is.
- ajaym0 4y agoEven so, there trouble is in how well these remote teams work together. And what about team cohesion. Dont mind me, I LOVE remote teams and distributed working, but atleast in the early stage i feel that there needs to be a balance between onsite and REMOTE work.
- dogman144 4y agoThis thread has interesting debate, and makes me think these are the core questions which I wonder how others feel: - Who believes most work friends are actual friends that by and large want to be there as well? - Who builds and maintains friends at work for 90% career management, and the other 10% are cool people you enjoy working with and then you stay in touch with 1-2 of them once you leave a job? - Who views the work socialization as actual socialization versus career management requirements? My experience with a relatively successful path in tech is that most friends at work aren’t actual friends, that 90/10 split is true, and that work socialization is for career management. It feels like the remote work debate is partially about if work fiends are actual friends and it’s worth bringing everyone in-office to support that truism, and then if remote work enables the same level of career management abilities IMO it does and it’s easier to do so. For instance, Leading in slack is a lot easier than leading vs the ex-athlete with a MBA in meetings who projects confidence.
- librish 4y agoThis seems like a very cynical way to look at the world. Work friends are real friends in the same way your pick-up league or board game night friends are real friends. You like some of them more than others, and you probably won't stay friends with most of them if you stop coming to whatever shared activity brought you together initially unless you make a concerted effort to stay in touch.
- dogman144 4y agoI think it’s a cynical way to look at work but those views don’t extend to my world. The issue with work socialization is career advancement involved, which means money, which means basic security for you and your family is on the line. I can be open and myself with my friends playing board games. Part of openness is testing out ideas and risking conflict. If I say something wrong, the worst that happens is I get a new group of friends to play Catan with. If that happens at work, my mortgage and family is on the line.
- librish 4y ago
- jedberg 4y agoI love remote work and will never go back to in person work again. But I do see some problems, both immediate and on the horizon. I look at the people on my social media that I actively follow, and they are in three groups: friends from High School, friends from college, friends from work. None of those groups are growing. The first two for obvious reasons, but last one is the concern. I think back to the last time I worked in an office. My path to the bathroom happened to go past a bunch of people I never worked with for my job, but I'm still friends with a lot of them a decade later. People who I would just start random conversations with on the way to and from the bathroom. And I'm still friends with a lot of my old coworkers who I last worked with a decade ago (the last time I worked in an office). In part because we hung out a lot outside of work, going to lunch, dinner, bars, shows, etc. But after that? My rate of making new work friends went way down. The chances for socializing are very small. The closest friends I've made in the last few years are all parents from my kids' schools, because we have constant in person interactions. My old work friendships are not only important to my psychological well being, but also in finding new work. When I need a new job I go to those friends first. I'm lucky that I already have that network, but people who are new to work life won't have that chance. Which leads to the other problem I see -- the juniors of today are the seniors of tomorrow. But the juniors of today are losing out on a lot of chances for mentorship with remote work. Remote work is great for mid to senior level people, who already have some experience and know what they are doing. But it's not great for junior employees. They need those random interactions, randomly overhearing shop talk, being in the hallway and getting pulled into a meeting "because you really should be learning this". All things that happened to me when I was a junior engineer, and helped me immensely. We try to replicate that with remote work, but it's just not nearly as effective. So either we'll have a tier of in person companies where all the junior employees will work with the few senior people who like being in the office, or we're going to have a big problem in a few years when there are a bunch of junior people who we can't promote because they didn't get the mentorship they need to move up. We need to solve the mentorship problem and the (human) network building in a remote world.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoOne huge advantage of remote, is that it seriously cuts down on harassment, sexual and otherwise. The corporate world is full of examples of predators that hide in the multitude of in-person interactions to annoy, threaten, or harass. Remote makes that harder, and makes it much easier to document harassment.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- revskill 4y agoNon-remote simply means asshole bosses.
- spoonjim 4y agoThis will just shake out into a market like anything else. Some companies will be remote, some companies will be in person, some people will be remote, some people will be in person, and for the more in-demand companies and employees they will get to decide what they prefer, the less in-demand companies and employees will need to just take what the market offers them.
- synergy20 4y agoIf you tie the company's future with employees closely, with great incentives to accomplished milestones for effective contributions, it does not matter where they work from, they might work even more as a remote player. Earning a stable and boring fixed salary, some will opt to do the minimum to get by, there is little downside of that at least for a few years. The leadership team needs to stay creative nowadays instead of saying "back to office or you're fired", how to do that? refer to paragraph 1 above.
- davidhunter 4y agoWhat is more rewarding? 1. Relocating to an obscure town in Texas to work intensely with ambitious engineers on hard space exploration technology. 2. Building a truly breakthrough software system (eg metaverse/gaming/crypto) with ambitious engineers in a fully distributed company? I find it hard to see how a company doing (1) would lose against a competitor doing (1) in a distributed fashion. I also find it hard to see how a company doing (2) would lose against a competitor doing (2) in an onprem fashion.
- bart_spoon 4y agoYes, but you are comparing apples to oranges. The comparison is: 1. Relocating to (city) to work in person with ambitious engineers on X. 2. Living where you choose to work remotely with ambitious engineers on X. When there is a choice, it seems workers generally greatly prefer 2. If your labor market is inelastic, you might be fine. If it's elastic, it seems like on-prem will definitely lose out to remote in terms of the labor pool.
- bilsbie 4y agoMy first question is does talent matter though? Most startups aren’t pushing the boundaries of any technology. I’d argue most companies wouldn’t know what to do with real talent.
- purpleblue 4y agoI worked at an all-remote company. I've never suffered such poor productivity in my career. This was a company dedicated to remote work, so the processes were streamlined for it, but I found that I spent a lot of time spinning my wheels. Onboarding was especially hard, and trying to get the attention of my coworkers was where I spent most of my idle time. Something that would have taken 3 minutes onsite now meant first scheduling a meeting and waiting until I had their dedicated time. Things like slack didn't work for more complex issues. I remember being in a technical disagreement/conversation/argument for about 1.5 hrs on slack, and I drew a picture and uploaded it and everything got resolved almost instantly. We didn't go to a meeting because it started as a simple slack conversation and it snowballed into a bigger disagreement so we never thought "okay let's have a meeting". Once it was resolved we went about our way but having slack as the primary way of communicating is exhausting and very slow. I quit and joined a brick-and-mortar company and am happy again.
- ISL 4y agoThe article headline's assertion is true for software, but it won't necessarily be true for hardware. In the hardware world, access to excellent equipment (and colleagues) can be a huge draw for top talent. If you work on optical clocks, odds are good that JILA/NIST and the Boulder ecosystem will be at or near the top of your list for places to work. You just can't do that kind of work without the right resources.
- JackFr 4y agoFounder & CEO of a startup supporting remote work posts his pitch. Nothing to see here.
- alkonaut 4y agoIn the 4 quadrants formed by startup/not and remote/not, wouldn’t remote non-startups be where top talent goes? Weirdly, the article title mentions startups but the article doesn’t.
- somenewaccount1 4y agoI agree with the vast majority of the article, but take contention with this sarcastic question: > Does anyone, outside of company management, believe that considering your coworkers your closest social relationships is a good thing? Over the years, I have really underestimated the strength of friendships which were made at the office. And also, how much they meant to me as well. The flexibility of remote work is awesome, but I don't think it is in its final form. There are definitely aspects missing which we haven't solved yet.
- nonethewiser 4y agoI agree a lot with the sentiment. But these points are terrible: > Fortune 500 company found that just 10 percent of all communications occurred between employees whose desks were more than 500 meters apart. This suggests that once companies span multiple floors, buildings, or campuses, they’ve already lost much of the collaborative value of being “in the office” together. 1. 500 meters is a huge distance. It's actually surprising the distance at which 10% of communications happens is that far, which undermines the point the author is making. 2. You aren't supposed to collaborate with the whole company. You are supposed to collaborate primarily with your team, and less frequently with adjacent stakeholders.
- muad_kyrlach 4y agoI would actually love to get some perspective on my own perceptions. If i'm slinging code, remote work sounds awesome. But when i'm slinging ideas, i want to be in person. I want to have the brains in a room around a market board figuring things out. The creative and communicative energy is just totally different. My problem with the code-slingers who want to be totally remote -- don't you need to have periodic collaborative discussions with your peers? Do you really find those discussions are as good over a computer screen as they were in a room? Over a screen, most people are multi-tasking -- having multiple conversations, doing their laundry, whatever. That's a poor imitation of true collaboration, in my opinion. What am I not considering?
- misto 4y agoAt first I was all-in for working remote, but after having done it for two years, the question that made me think otherwise was simply: - Ten years from now, would I be glad that I had spent ~70% of my time at home? As you can see from all these comments, whether working at the office is good or bad, depends hugely on context. E.g. what type of commute are we talking about? 15 minutes walking to the office or spending 4 hours everyday standing still on the freeway? There simply is no single answer for this. Working remote certainly has its upside in that it allows one to have more control of the day. Bad storm projected for next morngin? I guess I’ll just work from home. Not having to walk out the door means more predictability. But coming back to the original question, this sort of control might come at the cost of losing some color in your everyday life in the long run. And thats what freaks me out the most: am I purposefully grayscaling my life for the sake of convenience and control? I’d rather not.
- ystad 4y agoRemote only works when everyone in the company are 100% remote
- acchow 4y agoMaybe after generations of learning how to effectively work remotely. Humans and social structures evolved with in person interaction.
- lazzlazzlazz 4y agoI'd prefer to work at a fully in-person startup next time I join one, personally.
- thunkle 4y agoWorking remotely since covid has actually been a boon personally. I have intense anxiety and panic when working in skyscrapers. I get a feeling similar to fear of heights and I'm unable to function productively. In addition I was able to mitigate some of my interviewing anxiety by drinking half a glass of wine during the remote interview. I now get to work at a FAANG company where previously my mental health/anxiety would have barred me from even having a shot.
- RobKohr 4y agoAlso, local startups will win the war for top talent too. Some people like to work remote and some like to work in office. One thing that doesn't work well (usually), is hybrid where a team is a mix of remote and in office. In the end, I could see some companies or groups in companies going full remote, and some being fully on site, and individual devs migrate to wherever they are happy. One benefit of covid is it created a giant social experiment where we got a chance to taste what full remote work companies would be like, and now it is no longer something theoretical. As someone who went full remote way before covid, this is great as now their is more opportunity to stay fully remote where I am most happy.