24 ms·
The erosion of the Mac experience
- solardev 4y agoMy dream: Windows 7 on a Linux kernel on a M2 Macbook, with a HDMI and USB-A port.
- egypturnash 4y agoThere is really no reason to keep on adding stuff to OSX/MacOS. It's done. It does everything it needs to do. It has been done for something like a decade. It should be in maintenance mode, with bugs being fixed as they show up and nothing really changing. And yet every year there's a new version. Mostly it's a bunch of new features on the bundled programs that I don't ever touch. And a new skin on the GUI. Sometimes it breaks something that was working just fine; I personally quit staying up to date when I balked at a new OS whose main feature was "broke all 32-bit apps forever". I finally upgraded to the latest version in the past few months so I can deal with getting stuff working on the M2 Air I'll be getting soon. Preparing for that has made me replace two perfectly-functional drawing tablets because Wacom's newest drivers won't support them and the ones that do predate the M1. Honestly I doubt I'm gonna be upgrading that M1 from whatever OS it comes with until the latest version of Illustrator stops working on it, or Apple stops doing bugfix releases. Or if I have to replace it because it gets broken. I just do not need this endless cycle of change for its own sake, done by people whose idea of what a computer "should" be is increasingly shaped by growing up with an iPhone in their hand instead of an 8-bit computer on their desk.
- jononomo 4y agoYeah, I completely agree -- the MacOS is finished and should be in long term maintenance mode for the next 25 years. We should turn our attention to other problems.
- metadat 4y ago> I doubt I'm gonna be upgrading that M1 from whatever OS it comes with until the latest version of Illustrator stops working on it, or Apple stops doing bugfix releases Unfortunately security updates are more important than ever and patching old OS versions is not a high priority for any OS vendor. Even Ubuntu LTS only gets critical updates for something like 5 years. The tragic reality is too many thousands of people's jobs at Apple depend on delivering new features for it ever to go into maintenance mode.
- BirAdam 4y agoFundamentally, I believe that Apple's biggest fans fall into two different camps. In one camp, you have people who effectively want macOS on an iPad with a touch-centric UI which is made obvious by their assertion that a unified everything across all devices is the correct path forward. The other camp wants a traditional desktop operating system on their Macintosh computers. Personally, the only reason I enjoy Macintosh machines at all is the UNIX platform with a distraction free environment. The has been dying and I have therefore gone back to using Slackware with TDE. I don't want 50,000 notifications. I don't want my computer to be a dumb terminal to network services. I want my UNIX environment to be a first class feature and not an afterthought. The Apple Silicon chips are the sexiest thing to happen in technology since the introduction of the first ThreadRipper, but they aren't worth the trade off for me personally. Being forced back into the Apple world with, what is in my opinion, a distracting environment just makes me less productive.
- nuclearsugar 4y agoI recently upgraded MacOS and now TextEdit occasionally crashes randomly. And pasted text has bizarre spacing even in plain text mode. Are they eating their own dog food?
- Finnucane 4y agoBack in the 90s when I was doing graphic design work, you had to use a Mac. Windows wasn’t up to the task. Windows postscript support was bad and service bureaus wouldn’t guarantee output. I recall watching three it guys struggling to get a scanner to work right on a pc. Probably a lot of younger folks don’t remember just how crappy Windows used to be. There’s not as much of gap now. But then, I think the Mac has been in decline since OS 10.6 at least. It’s just more closed, more bloat, less reliable since. Now I prefer to use Linux at home, thought I have a Mac for work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Macha 4y agoThis seems like a very weird choice of post to refresh/second-chance queue given the subject matter and the 100s of comments from two days ago. Did a mod misclick?
- lapcat 4y agoI don't mind a second chance for submissions, but resetting/falsifying the timestamps of comments is horrendous.
- etempleton 4y agoI think both Windows and MacOS are in weird places. Linux is Linux and I don’t see it suddenly becoming a better option for the masses any time soon so I don’t know what the solution is. MacOS could be great with some small tweaks to the finder and modernization of how windows, full screen, and external displays function. They just need to do a comprehensive rethink here because it is clunky. Windows is actually for maybe the first time in decades not that clunky anymore—yay! But Microsoft is still Microsoft and bugs are plentiful. For every bug they kill they implement two more. And not just small edge cases, normal every day functionality just won’t work for multiple releases. Outlook crashes when I pin an email? Xbox app won’t download game updates? And then there are all of the house ads, but those can usually be hidden away. Linux, well, is Linux. I get it, you have it setup perfectly, for you. And it is super stable, for you. And it has come a long way in usability, for you. It just isn’t a suitable alternative for your average user. Both Apple and Microsoft I think are taking for granted their operating systems because they are not the revenue drivers they once were. Instead they are the platform that all their revenue drivers hang on to.
- sfvegandude 4y ago> Windows is actually for maybe the first time in decades not that clunky anymore—yay! Does it still re-install candy crush without my permission? Serious question. How bloated is Win11?
- etempleton 4y agoI don't think so, but I am running the Pro version so I can't speak with authority. Windows does do some weird stuff particularly after larger updates, but I haven't run into anything quite as egregious as that.
- smeagull 4y ago> Linux, well, is Linux. I get it, you have it setup perfectly, for you. And it is super stable, for you. And it has come a long way in usability, for you. It just isn’t a suitable alternative for your average user. Funny, I feel the same way about both Windows and MacOS. Although both have made massive steps backwards lately.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoI have seen stories about the erosion of the Mac experience ever since multi-finder. If all are to be taken at face value, the Mac ceased to exist-- eroded into nothingness, somewhere around 2004. Like how every release of iOS is "less snappy" than the last. It now must be so slow it actually travels backwards in time.
- dagmx 4y agoHalf of this rant is “things were better in my day and the younger generation can’t do what the older generation did”. No, the space has moved on from catering to you. That’s different than them not caring. This entire rant is so ego-centric that it doesn’t really add anything of value to the public discourse. This however, in my experience, is endemic of the author. Steve Troughton-Smith has some of the worst takes on Apple. A lot of his understanding of the technology is just outright wrong. His subjective opinion is valid but he states them as facts and that rarely holds up on closer inspection .
- pipeline_peak 4y agoThe future of apps is in the web. Keep your fancy Cocoa, WPF, GTK, the world keeps turning.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI think Apple is just not interested anymore in selling general computing. It's not where the big dollars are. It's not that general computing isn't worth doing right. Many people still need to create deep content instead of consuming it or at best create some mindless tiktok nothingness. And it illustrates the problem with opinionated design. If the designer's opinions don't correspond to your own, it's not useful anymore.
- da39a3ee 4y ago> Fresh new hires, who’ve never known a reason to care about the Mac, trying to rewrite key portions of the OS I'm confused. Don't Apple developers develop on MacOS machines?
- falcolas 4y agoYou can use a platform for development without giving it a second thought or care. All it needs to do is host an ide, compiler, and emulator.
- anonymouse008 4y agoThis guy has no idea what he’s talking about. One language, one gui framework, and one API paradigm - unified across all contextual devices - is exactly what Apple should do. SwiftUI is not it by any means, but to say that the idea of SwiftUI tries to achieve is a bad aim is completely wrong. The aim of UIKit on all Apple devices is 100% correct; and allows developers to go deep into the API forest to create mystical interactions for their customers, friends and users - in every device context. Merging AppKit and UIKit (MacCatalyst) should have been the team to win out the battle, just like in the days of the competing iPhones. The idea Apple is letting both live and fostering the wrong team is its only black eye in this story - So no, the Mac is flourishing, you’re just not following the way.
- grishka 4y agoNo, it's absolutely unacceptable to merge touchscreens and keyboards/mice. These should be separate frameworks where you couldn't reuse any GUI code whatsoever, not a single line. You must design everything from scratch for phones and for computers because of how different the interaction paradigms are.
- smeagull 4y agoUnify everything by fragmenting further?
- incanus77 4y agoIt's not the mystical interactions or feel of widgets, layout, and function that are the problem, it's bad UX paradigms, declining consistency between apps and across versions (a Mac hallmark), buggy software on an aggressive annual schedule, holes and rot in developer documentation, constant treadmill of Xcode and device updates, and general lack of attention to detail in Mac apps. I've been a Mac user and dev for twenty years. Music.app is probably the most egregious example and gets a lot of flak for good reason. It's so bad, when I'm working all day on my Mac, I listen to music on my iPhone instead. It's utter trash, designed with the foremost goal to push Apple Music sales and subscriptions, with everything else propping that up. There are still so many magical features — Safari Cloud Tabs, using your iPad as a second display with automatic keyboard & mouse switching, attention to Focus and Notification management, a very solid iCloud sync service for so many core data apps like Contacts, Notes, and Messages, and so much more. But the whole platform just feels like a rot, and the generational gap alluded to in the post is spot on. It's not necessarily an age thing, but it feels like those who "get it" and know what the Mac was and could be, and those who are making decisions and setting deadlines who are largely driven by company-wide synergistic goals. It could be both. But instead, the latter is winning.
- what-imright 4y agoWhats with these Apple complainers they never shut up? Why do they find fault in the minor details of the best computing experience ever delivered?
- Shank 4y ago> Why do they find fault in the minor details of the best computing experience ever delivered? The whole point is that the Macintosh Operating System was all about caring about details. Criticism like this comes from a place of love, not from a place of hate. I love my Mac. I love the experience. I love using it. However, when the "dismiss" button on a notification hides itself as I hover over it, and I have to move my mouse off of the invisible control and back onto the control to fix the bug, on a regular basis, it's grating. Why? I love my socks -- I just wish they would stop coming with holes in them. They're great socks and other than the holes I love wearing them. Other sock makers make socks that aren't as comfy but don't have holes. Why can't these just not have holes?
- dleslie 4y agoI believe that Apple is strategically choosing to coast on their desktop software while they work to harmonize their mobile, desktop, and entertainment software stacks. Why? Because based on rumors, patents, and the decisions they've made and the actions they've taken (or not taken), it appears as though that Apple believes that in the not so distant future the concept of having a separate mobile device and a computing device will be irrelevant. Consumers will have a single device, and that device will be capable of some form of altered reality interaction, or at least some impressive context switching behaviour. It's already the case that an entire generation has been raised with their primary computing experience not being on general computing devices, but on some variant of mobile or tablet computing. It's not too much of a stretch to consider that they will be most comfortable with a device that behaves with some familiarity to that experience, but which can engage in much greater utility in a pinch. And it will be mobile, and it will require a better input experience than mashing your fingers on the small screen that splits its available space between the important information and large input elements.
- stephen_g 4y agoThat seems exactly the opposite direction they’ve always gone though. Microsoft tried to have a completely unified PC/tablet experience, where their desktop OS basically became completely tabled focused in Windows 8. Whereas Apple has always made a strong distinction between e.g. the iPad and the Mac, refusing to build a convertible Mac or any Mac with a touch screen…
- resist_futility 4y ago
- analog31 4y agoInteresting generalization about a lot of mature tech businesses, borrowed from TFA (edits mine): What the future of <product> looks like as <company>'s employee base ages out and that care & attention is lost forever? Fresh new hires, who’ve never known a reason to care about the <product>, trying to rewrite key portions with unforgiving yearly timelines and shaky foundations...
- jagger27 4y agoThey really have to stop this release cadence. It’s not working and hasn’t been working for so long.
- darkteflon 4y agoThat’s my biggest gripe with MacOS: the yearly release schedule. Give us two or three years on each major release - at least. Take the labour saved and do something about bugs that affect system stability (the well-documented finder memory leak, for example), particularly problematic apps (looking at you, Music.app) and the woeful developer documentation.
- flenserboy 4y agoYes. Yes yes yes. The desktop is there for work, and having a stable interface + a stable, bug-excised system makes everyone's lives better by making work smoother and more predictable. Apple makes great hardware; it deserves software to match.
- rc_kas 4y agoWindows sucks MacOS is headed towards suck If you want a glimpse of the future of desktops : r/unixporn
- not_alexb 4y agoWake me up when Haiku is the future of desktops.
- _chu1 4y agoHopefully soon, Haiku is awesome
- speed_spread 4y ago[flagged]
- bergenty 4y agoI don’t know I’m kinda liking windows again.
- hammyhavoc 4y agor/unixporn is full of horribly impractical and poor UX made by bored people who don't really use their computer for serious work. Just tinkerers. Same crowd who post elaborate and artistic BuJo stuff up with to-do entries of "Post up new photos of BuJo to Reddit" and "Get some new pens for BuJo" as tasks. Meta crap.
- kastagg 4y agoPeople customizing their own machines to suit their needs is in fact a good UX as long as they enjoy it
- hammyhavoc 4y agoIf you take the doors off of a small city car to make it quicker to get in and out of at the expense of keeping thieves and the weather out, is that good UX?
- happyopossum 4y agoI have been hearing this for almost 2 decades now, as long as I’ve been following the ‘community’. Meanwhile, in my real life, my parents, wife, kids, and friends, are all happier than they ever ever been with their latest MacBooks and macOS. Things like iCloud photo syncing, universal control, and airdrop feel boring to us, but they make the computing experience feel pretty much like living in the future for them.
- hnburnsy 4y agoNothing against you and your family, but I am disappointed when for example, the Netflix app shows 2 rows of 6 titles when probably 100 could fit on the 3024-by-1964 native resolution display. Heck even the top 10 list scrolls to the right and only shows 1 through 4.
- bqmjjx0kac 4y agoAnnoyingly, nearly every video streaming service uses this horizontal-scrolling skeuomorphism, presumably modeled on video tape rental shelves. Give me vertical scrolling, or give me death!
- Nathanba 4y agoMy opinion on this is that it's purposefully slower to browse through titles so you can't ever create a full mental map of all available titles. That way it feels like you could still find something new if you just tried harder.
- InTheArena 4y agoI've of two minds on this topic. The first is that the vast majority of concerns are coming from the Independent developer iOS/Mac scene. Some of these concernes are legit. There is unquestionably problems with Apple's quality with some software. The new SwiftUI based Settings app in Ventura is not yet stable, and when Apple's entire raison d'etre has been it just works, it's understandable that people get upset when things just don't work. If I were a independent mac developer, with my only source of revenue depending on Apple's goodwill and development APIs, I can see being upset. On the other hand, it seems to me that the Apple community, especially the independent mac community has become increasingly a toxic monoculture. Just like polarization affecting other parts of the world - the community has become vitriolic, isolated and extremist at times. Anything not done in line with the one true Steve Jobs and in a way the community wanted - the apple way - has been labeled a disaster and "problematic". In particular I think of the crusade/jihad against 1Password 8 when 1Password went Electron (in part to address many of the same problems). It got to the point that people were posting "evidence" of how bad 1Password 8 (electron based) was by posting screenshots of a misidentified previous version (which was worse). The twitter abuse heaped on developers just working to make a great product was a bad look. The Apple podcasting community talks about Apple the way Trump fans talk about Democrats or Democrats talk about Republicans. It often bleeds into non-apple content as well. I've consistently found that the angriest people on twitter are apple partisans. I finally unsubscribed to Accidental Tech Podcast after listening since almost the first episode just because of how negative everything is. It's not universal - I found another apple centric podcast to replace it - but it is pervasive. To be fair - a lot of that is that this is what the modern media does. For example Linus Tech Tips's Tech Linked channel has the following headlines for their videos over the last 90 days: 1) Apple Betrayed Us All 2) Apple has no Shame 3) Apple got SERVED 4) Apple calls this PRO? 5) It's over Apple, the EU won! 6) Something is wrong with the M2 Apple Air 7) Apple will never escape this. so I am inclined to treat a lot of this as just what people do to get listens and clicks. I think the right perspective is somewhere between the two extremes. I wrote an app recently in Swift and SwiftUI that was amazing in how little effort it took to get a good (but not great) app and interface. Much faster than Flutter and far more visually fluid (animations, look and feel, etc). I can see its limitations though, and if all I knew was Objective C and AppKit, I could completely see where a developer would be skeptical of the approach. But the promise is most definitely there for a brighter future. In the mean time, my personal PoV is that things like Slack (which is electron based), 1Password 8 and Adobe Creative Suite shows that you can be both pluralist and great. Attacking them for not being pure isn't helping anything. Long term, I have hope. Most of the criticisms of Apple's software were echos of similar complaints of the horribleness of Apple's laptops a few years ago. They turned that around - and I think Apple is honestly working to fix their software in the same matter. Apple needed to get off of Objective-C (who knows C anymore, to say nothing of objective-c?) and AppKit (30 year old technology at this point). Like the Intel to Arm transition, a lot of work is going on behind the scenes to make the transition work. Apple really wants to be the BMW of the compute world - and Tim Cook's entire strategy seems to be the BMW every nickle and dime strategy. If Apple really wants to do that, they need things to just work.
- mylons 4y agoI just started developing in Swift/SwiftUI with a few app ideas in mind as a 37 year old with quite a bit of XP developing web services and *nix based utilities. I _really_ like the overall experience of Swift and the mac ecosystem a lot. Maybe there is a lot of truth in the headline, but other than XCode not being as excellent as PyCharm or VSCode, I'm having a lot of fun and getting some users along the way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brundolf 4y ago> other than XCode not being as excellent as PyCharm or VSCode I can't help pointing out the irony that PyCharm uses custom native rendering and VSCode is an Electron app, while Xcode is the only native Mac app of the bunch Obviously there's a lot more that goes into a piece of software, but
- y2bd 4y agoI don't have a ton of Xcode experience, but from what I've touched, while it does feel good to use in terms of a "native" experience, as an IDE it feels lacking. Even basic things like the text editing experience feels limited compared to other IDEs (e.g. why is there still no auto-formatting built in? why can't I duplicate a line without having to use pseudo-Emacs movements?)
- mylons 4y agoi just don’t find the developer XP to be as good. i did kind of chuckle a bit, though, when i typed VSCode.
- nbzso 4y agoApple should accept the old Mac OS X HIG principles and make them mandatory. The UX is so broken, that in some moments I have Windows Vista reminiscence. But hey, I am an old user. I should move away and say: Yes Apple, you know better than me.:)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- firecall 4y agoIt's not Vista bad! LOL Stage Manager is a disaster though! Like, really horrible as a desktop macOS feature IMHO. I feel like Apple are trying to shoehorn bad iPad features into macOS to unify them. Instead of making iPadOS more like macOS and therefore more useful generally. I dont know - something is screwed up in Apple's strategic thinking. They admitted as much though with their back-to-the-mac push a few years back. Shrug. I've been using Macs since the mid-80s, and i'm very conflicted. The experience isn't the same anymore, for me But then the computing world isn't the same, and my needs aren't the same. I used to customise and feel a personal connection to my Mac. Now they are interchangeable and disposable. Like servers, they are cattle not pets. The new M1 Macbooks are amazing though and we've never had it better in many ways.
- GekkePrutser 4y ago"App <xxx> wants to access documents / network / blablah" kinda is. I'm not saying controls on such behaviour are not useful. What is bad is dumping a truckload of popups on the user.
- nbzso 4y ago>But then the computing world isn't the same, and my needs aren't the same. Strongly disagree, the needs are the same, the interfaces and information flow are different. This is not a reason to abandon basic UX and UI principles. On the desktop, the paradigm is still a mouse (pointer device) and keyboard. Accessibility and Usability requirements are the same. I had more pleasure in recent years from customized KDE environment than the chaotic changes in macOS. Unifying UX for desktop computers with UX for touch devices is an absurd proposition.
- runjake 4y agoThe key point in this Twitter rant is that the SWEs who understood the Mac (and NEXTSTEP, for that matter) have aged out. Most everyone has retired or moved onto other opportunities. There's very few of them left at Apple. And they're often overruled by younger managers. Apple is hiring tons of fresh new SWEs who have no understanding, nor desire to understand "The Mac Way". I'm not saying this is right or wrong, the world needs to move on, but it's a punch to my nostalgic gut. If you're hanging onto the Mac out of some belief that Apple will re-find their way WRT macOS, don't. That train left the station years ago. It's past time to move on.
- KerrAvon 4y agoYour assertion about “The Mac Way” is simply false. The VP in charge of macOS is an ex-NeXT person; a lot of ex-NeXT and Apple people still work on it. macOS user experience continues to be driven from the UI design group and executives, as it always has been. Feel free to criticize the design direction, but understand that it’s fully top-down intentional, not something that just happens because individual software engineering positions are suddenly filled with non-Mac people. That’s not how it works. macOS is designed by UI designers.
- queuebert 4y agoMaybe different types of users need different user experiences, and Mac is the least flexible of the three major OSes.
- layer8 4y agoThe same seems to have happened at Microsoft for Windows.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoWhy does the world need to move on? The world needs desktop computers. Phones and even tablets are useless for doing actual work.
- what-imright 4y agoJobs was against dogma. It’s a changing world and the perspective and input of the young is valuable. What exactly are you moving on to? Ubuntu? Windows? Behind macOS is the most valuable company in the world adding fixes, features and security patches. There isn’t any other computing solution today that can deliver what Apple does.
- emptyparadise 4y agoThe future of Apple is half iOS apps and half Electron apps. It's a shame because they uses to be very good at native apps. I understand the economics of it, but it's still a shame. Worse may be better, but it still feels bad.
- brundolf 4y agoPutting myself in Apple's shoes: I just don't see the financial incentive to invest a whole lot in the native GUI story for the Mac in 2022 Regular people mostly use iOS. Many don't have traditional computers at all. That was originally the Mac's core market. It still has a strong professional market- but many of the serious professional tools (Adobe, Blender, IDEA, etc) use their own custom in-house GUI frameworks, or maybe something like QT And then most of the rest of the space is covered by web apps and/or Electron Personally I can think of... three third-party native Mac GUIs that I use on my work computer, and two are background apps whose only GUI is a settings window you can open The Mac is just... not really a GUI platform the way it used to be. Desktop OSes in general aren't. It's a bummer, but it feels like the new reality
- grishka 4y agoYou know, actively making stuff worse costs money. Not touching it is free.
- dangoor 4y agoThe Mac is a nearly $40B annual business: https://www.statista.com/statistics/263428/apples-revenue-from-macintosh-computers-since-first-quarter-2006/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263428/apples-revenue-fr... It's small compared to iOS, sure, but I think it's still an important part of Apple's overall portfolio. It's currently what all of the iOS developers need to use. Its what Apple's own people use for their work. I guess the difference of opinion may turn on the phrase "invest a whole lot". I have no idea what kind of investment Apple is making in Mac native GUI frameworks. It's obviously non-zero and is likely what most would deem non-trivial, but I'd argue that it's worth a decent size investment because it is still a potential differentiator for a $40B part of their business. I will also note that there are some excellent professional native Mac apps, even beyond Apple's own. Things like Pixelmator and the Affinity suite, for example. I'm definitely running a combination of native Mac and Electron apps right now, but I still appreciate the native apps when they're available for the job at hand.
- KerrAvon 4y agoI would also say that if Apple didn’t actually care about macOS, the money spent on it would probably be better spent on porting Xcode to Windows.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoThe erosion of the Mac experience began with Sublime Text. It’s a perfectly cromulent editor, but it was the inflection point where the Mac was becoming an important business target for efforts outside the ecosystem, and where developers who hadn’t been on Macs by choice were being issued them by their employers. It was the first widely adopted third party app on the platform that was both non-native and adopted enthusiastically. Formerly native apps embraced more cross-platform junk (Adobe famously moved a lot of its suite toward Flex, based on Flash). And then by the point Macs were becoming anything like commonplace, everything was a web app. Not that I disagree Apple’s UI frameworks have degraded the experience. But the whole platform was a wasteland before they even had a chance to degrade anything.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoThe thing is though, even though Sublime Text doesn't adhere to all Mac UI conventions, it does respect the most important ones and its appearance can be brought further inline with custom themes. Additionally, it's always performed excellently which makes up for shortcomings in overall "nativeness". This cannot be said for much if not most cross platform software that runs on macOS — much of it is strictly least common denominator when it comes to UI conventions, system integration, etc and more often than not is slow and bloated. I would say that the erosion started in earnest with Atom. People flocked to it because it was free (even though Sublime kinda was too, being nagware) despite its performance being horrendous and its lack of maclikeness, setting precedence for the acceptance of generic UI, sluggishness, and high resource consumption.
- 1123581321 4y agoI agree. Interesting point. I was one of those who switched, and, looking back, I didn’t give any thought to how Sublime was built vs. how Textmate was built. A testament to the performance and level of system respect from Sublime, but it did popularize the viability of the approach and a lot of less careful software followed.
- ben-schaaf 4y agoThe only thing really differentiating ST and "fully native" apps (like TextMate) is that more of the UI is custom. It runs native code (ObjC/C++), uses appkit, native dialogs and generally follows platform conventions.
- cc101 4y agoI'm facing a bitter conflict with Mac App Review. I feel so poorly about this that I can't sleep, and my mind is in turmoil. After 37 years writing Mac software, I'm wondering if there is anything left of the Mac and of the Apple spirit that made such a difference in my life. I hate to give up my current work (5 years and 13,000 lines of code), but in a sense it would be liberating to be free of Apple.
- treve 4y agoI've had very similar feelings with a different ecosystem. The reality is that you don't have to be a Mac developer. You can jump ship, try something else and even come back later if it didn't work out. I tied my identity as a developer to a technology. When the technology got worse, it made me feel worse. Trying something else felt like a break-up, and I haven't attained the same reputation I had in my the ecosystem that I had spent 15 years pm; but this was 6 years ago and I'm glad I moved on and not looking back. It _will_ be liberating; it's just a soulless corporation at this point. Reach out if you want to chat. This really resonated with me!
- duncanc4 4y agoI have been a Mac and iOS developer for 7 years now and am moving away. I feel like Apple treats developers really poorly from App Review process to forced updates of your hardware/OS/Xcode.
- 1over137 4y agocc101 I was in that exact situation a few years ago! I feel you! I'm still writing Mac software, but now spending more and more time learning about different technologies with an eye on getting out one day.
- licebmi__at__ 4y agoI got my dad a Mac about 10 years ago, and never got into the experience. I mean I got it for him, used a couple of days to tell him where was everything, delivered and then came back to my trusted thinkpad with i3. About a year and a half I got a macbook from my employer even as a replacement from a T480 which was awful because of thermal throttling. After a couple of months, I got the m1 macbook air as my personal laptop. I guess the experience with the software I commonly use got better, but I feel like the biggest reason is that the experience with other laptops just became worse.
- hnaccount_rng 4y agoYeah… I mean I love the “don’t have to think about anything” experience of all Apple products. That’s the reason why I use their stuff. But at least in the last couple of years before the M1, the number of things that were just plain annoying… it really made me look for an alternative. And really… there isn’t one. Windows is so annoying to use and even the Linux fanatics I work with manage to run into trouble like once a month. And yeah it’s fixable trouble. But I really don’t want to deal with that shit. I want a useful trackpad, a useable browser and a usable mail program. I want my laptop to reliably suspend and wake up. I want, if there has to be a kernel crash, that I get all my windows back in the state I left it. That really doesn’t sound like too much. And yet it is. And the worst part: Apple knows it. There is now quite a number of subpar experiences (looking at you Apple Music App) that they can just get away with.
- kcplate 4y agoThis is my perspective as well. Apple products are basically out of the box usable for me (short of a couple of helper apps on MacOS) and frankly just do not crash or cause me any downtime. But…I am admittedly well past my “OS tinkering” days. I finally realized how much unproductive time I spent trying to make whatever OS I was using “productive” and visually “correct” and realized it wasn’t net positive. So I just decided the default options was good enough, short of my couple of must have helper apps (Rectangle and Hiddenbar)
- lastangryman 4y agoI feel like I may be the only developer that prefers Windows to MacOs. I really, really just do not get the "Mac Experience". It feels so clunky and counter intuitive. - Why does the alt tab equivalent cycle through applications first, and I need another shortcut to cycle through the windows of that application? When I have an IDE with 5x instances, hosting different projects, it's a pain switching back to the project I want from another application - I attach a non Mac external monitor to a new MacBook Pro from work and the text is super blurry. Much googling later and I need to use something called Better Display to create a virtual display, and project that to my monitor. It's so confusing and sometimes break when I wake up from sleep and need to configure it again. - Why is there 2 modes of "full-size" windows? Regular style "fill the window", then another wierd one that sort of takes over the whole screen - Why does finder sometimes open in a sub folder as the "top level", then it's a total pain to move up to where you want. - Why are 3rd party applications distributed as Disk Images? Then some as package installers? It's weird and nonsensical. Mac hardware feels great, but I just cannot understand why it's the preferred developer platform.
- Tao3300 4y agoFinder sucks so much.
- tourincomplete 4y agoI just switched to Mac for work, and the app/window switching experience has been frustrating me so much I sent this to my coworkers: ——— Going from fullscreen App A to App B back to fullscreen App A: Brain on Windows: 1. Alt-tab -> App A 2. Alt-tab -> fullscreen App B Brain on Mac: 1. Cmd-tab -> App A 2. Cmd-tab -> Random App C 3. Cmd-tab -> back to App A 4. Cmd-tab -> other App B window you weren't looking for 5. Cmd-` App B windows a few times, nope not here either 6. Triple finger salute -> fullscreen App B Why. Why?
- nordsieck 4y ago> Why are 3rd party applications distributed as Disk Images? Then some as package installers? It's weird and nonsensical. Maybe you use a lot of paid software? I just use homebrew for everything, and it just works(tm) 98% of the time. Which is way better than my experience with Windows. I tried using a variety of Nanite, Chocolatey, etc. And none of it seems particularly mature. > Mac hardware feels great, but I just cannot understand why it's the preferred developer platform. In my experience, Windows is developer hostile if you aren't using Visual Studio. Almost everything is deployed to Linux, and OS X is close enough that most stuff just works, but the drivers and UI are also completely dependable.
- account-5 4y agoI first used a computer in 2005-ish. Started with Windows XP. I quickly moved to Ubuntu in maybe 2006 after reading a book about free software, of which I had no knowledge. I've been using Linux at home and windows at work ever since. I've never thought the apple premium was worth the cost especially when I could use decade old hardware (cheap) perfectly fine with modern operating systems. All this being said, every time I'm given a Mac to use its a bad experience. I find it very hard to see how people can find it an easy operating system to use. I'm aware this is just my experience but every time Macs are mentioned all you ever hear is how easy it is to use. When I'm using it I have to Google how to do simple stuff like copy and paste.
- firecall 4y ago"When I'm using it I have to Google how to do simple stuff like copy and paste." Really? everytime? :-)
- account-5 4y agoActually I got this mixed up with taking a screenshot, which kinda proves my point because I had to Google to find this out. Also no one can say CMD+shift+5 is intuitive to take a screenshot, prtsrn is much easier.
- _chu1 4y ago[flagged]
- ShamelessC 4y agopretty subjective
- account-5 4y agoOf course it is, that's been my point throughout. Every argument here is subjective. It's all based on experience and anecdote. Most people who use Macs seem to think their experience is somehow an objective truth, its not. I use a Linux desktop and have no issues whatsoever and never have to tinker with it, nothings ever broken; I experience none of the usual tropes people roll out as reasons they don't use Linux on desktop instead of Mac OS. And similarly when using Mac OS I experience none of the "amazing" user experience touted as the reasons everybody should use it. My experience is no less valid then anyone elses and also no more objective either. EDIT: Unless of course you're talking about the screenshot keyboard combo for taking a screenshot? In which case I'd hazard that pressing one button named "Print Screen" is objectively more intuitive that 3 buttons with no obvious connection to the job at hand.
- barrenko 4y agoThis whole rant touches on the true topic at the heart of this. Software developer a.k.a the programmer used to be the key person behind everything. Just like brick layer or road builder. But now that the roads have been (mostly) built, or so it seems, what are the professions in the spotlight, and even more importantly, in the shadow?
- illi 4y agoThe Mac experience peaked some years ago in many ways. Now when the hardware is back on track we can at least enjoy that plus some good MacOS features, and ignore or tweak the not so great stuff. They have certainly lost a lot of quality in the OS and 1st party apps, but the summed experience is still more positive than negative imo. My mbp14 is the most (or maybe 2nd to most) enjoyable of all my 8-9 machines since the G4 days. And that's coming from a software conservative :) I hate when an update changes stuff without obvious improvement.
- srvmshr 4y ago> Fresh new hires, who’ve never known a reason to care about the Mac, trying to rewrite key portions of the OS Apple Support engineers do not understand the basics sometimes. I noticed my 15" 2880x1800 screen showed a resolution of 1440x900 after 12.5 upgrade. I raised a ticket and my request was patched to Apple US who ran a bunch of tests remotely & were confused what & why. I never bothered looking at resolution before, so this half resolution thing bothered me. I dug out an exact replica config from office running 12.0.1 & voila it was running 1440x900 too. Then it dawned on me: The retina screen allocates 4 hardware pixels for each 'screen' pixel - so effectively canvas size was 1440x900 although screen resolution remains 2880x1800 at 220ppi Apple engineer in the bug report still struggling to understand this. I have no words except teling him this is a feature not a bug. I genuinely think the software devs are very fragmented within Apple & they don't really understand the customer facing issues entirely.
- sys_64738 4y agoMost Mac users are also iPhone users. Most iPhone users are not Mac users. To increase Mac users you need a consistent UI experience not alien concepts for iPhone only users. Unifying the interface is evolutionary towards iPhone equivalence is the outcome. After all, the App Store makes money from iPhone and iPad apps not Mac so Mac needs to evolve in the slipstream of iOS investment.
- ralmidani 4y agoI haven’t run Windows since 2014. I got into the Apple ecosystem in 2018-2019 (first Mac, then first iPhone). By 2021, I was completely disenchanted and bought a Framework DIY (now running Ubuntu/GNOME). Honestly, the only thing I truly miss when not using a Mac is easy copy-paste in the terminal. In every other way, GNU/Linux is a superior experience.
- jagger27 4y agoThe Elementary OS terminal has two function copy/paste. If text is selected it copies it, if not pass Ctrl+C to the terminal. It's a reasonable solution. For me it's the overall Command-key semantics that I miss when using Linux. I like being able to use readline shortcuts in any text field (Ctrl+A, Ctrl+E, etc.) macOS really nails it there and no desktop environments on Linux even attempt to replicate the feel. The other thing I miss is how VS Code's text navigation shortcuts work. The modifier combinations of selecting text, navigating (with or without a selection), moving and copying text selections and how that interacts with multiple cursors are totally different on Windows and Linux. I'm not sure if it's even possible without the Command key (super) because of how the super key is treated in Linux. It's all very depressing and makes me feel held hostage on macOS because of my muscle memory. I don't like how Apple treats me.