19 ms·
Solar canopies on parking lots
- sharmin123 4y ago[dead]
- c54 4y agoWhat are the companies in this space doing the installations and system integration? What are the bottlenecks on rollout other than prohibitory regulations? What is the reasoning for the government prohibiting solar in “Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, and Wisconsin”?
- ghouse 4y agore: "prohibiting solar" -- many utilities are able to convince their public utilities commission or legislature that it's in the best interest of the state to prevent competition to protect their natural monopoly.
- ch4s3 4y agoOr to cover up the fact that they couldn’t balance the load during peak solar production and don’t want to make investments in the grid…
- SteveGerencser 4y agoVery much this. We were in the middle of designing and installing a total solar array for our farm when the state ended every single subsidy and electricity buyback plan. We could install all the solar panels we want, but any electricity we pump into the grid is done for free (we don't get paid) and any power we take from the grid we pay 100% for with no credit for any power we pushed upstream. This forced us to increase the panel array size by another 25% to 30% to make sure we had more coverage, increase the battery storage we needed, and increased the breakeven point to more than 30 years. We decided to not do it. For a world that needs more renewable energy (I sort of hate that term) politicians work awful hard to make it not happen.
- ozzydave 4y agoIn this case it’s really on the executives at the utilities, who have a lot of power over the local politicians. This podcast did a great explainer: https://gimletmedia.com/shows/howtosaveaplanet/dvhz9ab https://gimletmedia.com/shows/howtosaveaplanet/dvhz9ab
- zo1 4y agoIt's not just in the US that this sort of thing happens. Sitting here in sunny South Africa, where we have regular rolling/controlled blackouts (load-shedding) because the utilities simply aren't able to generate enough electricity to cover all the demand. You'd think they'd incentivize people generating their own solar like crazy, but they don't. They actively punish people that push back to the grid with onerous requirements. The dirty little secret is that a lot of us have "old" "analog" electricity meters, which can literally go backwards when you push to the grid, which many do.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoIt will take a few years to fix that probably. But ultimately, politicians won't want to be in between companies and consumers and some very significant savings on their power bills. No public utility is that strong. It's interesting how solar panels stopped being a divisive topic between different political factions. Everybody likes saving money on power bills. And lots of people are waking up to the notion that 1) they are paying a lot for power and 2) a lot of other people they know are not because they have solar panels. It's irresistible for lots of people. As world + dog starts driving EVs, businesses will want to offer them power charging at their venues to provide a convenient way to top up. That requires cheap power and solar is a great way to get that. The collective power of lots of businesses and consumers demanding their right to access to solar will win ultimately. It's winning everywhere else. Of course there are some places where it is taking a bit longer than it should. But better late than never.
- zugi 4y agoThe article says these states "actively" discourage rooftop solar, but "actively" may differ from what most readers think: > They typically make it difficult for homeowners or property owners to install solar and connect it to the grid, or they prohibit a third party from paying for the installation. The "net metering" takes active work and costs by the utility to support, so some states never enacted it. The "pay a third party" prohibition stems from existing utility monopoly rules that allow only the utility companies to sell electricity. So what they "actively prohibit" is not just solar - they actively probihit anyone but approved utilities from selling electricity in the state.
- martijnvds 4y ago> they actively probihit anyone but approved utilities from selling electricity in the state. What a great example of the free market!
- egypturnash 4y agoThe answer to your last question is basically “red state politicians are deep in the pockets of coal and oil interests”. It’s not exclusively a GOP thing, Manchin is theoretically a D but he sure is holding back a lot of stuff in the Senate due to him being massively invested in dirty energy, but it’s more a Repub thing than a Dem thing.
- 0x53 4y agoBeen thinking about this a lot recently, I guess the hurdle to clear is probably convincing Walmart to let you put solar panels over their parking lot. I wonder what the economics of it would be if Walmart did it themselves? Tangential, the reason that we have so much parking space (as the article mentions) is that it is dictated by law in most places how many spots are required based on the building size. https://www.strongtowns.org/parking https://www.strongtowns.org/parking
- ehnto 4y agoShopping centre owners in Australia have been completing lots of solar canopy projects lately. The incentive is to power their shopping centre and save on electricity. It makes sense here because electricity is pretty expensive, so you get ROI really quickly. You also get paid for any excess generation you put back into the grid.
- prawn 4y agoNot sure if this applies to commercial buildings as well, but for homes, you get paid a pittance for feed-in tariffs. It used to be lucrative and early residential adopters got great rates locked in presumably for life but anyone since faces tariffs that get reduced and reduced. One hassle for those with the early tariffs is that they can't scale up their systems without revising the contract and losing their rates. Many early adopters were putting on 1-3kW systems (probably because panels were more expensive or they were not completely confident about the technology) when you'd probably put on 5-10kW now.
- CyanLite4 4y agoNet-energy metering is such a bad deal in most places that it wouldn’t make economic sense to do it.
- taneq 4y agoDo many places actually do net metering? Where I live, feed-in tariffs are 1/4 or less of the electricity supply cost. Net metering isn’t sustainable if you amortise the infrastructure cost over the energy supplied. Even so we’ve seen the static connection fee portion of our bill rise much faster than supply costs.
- shadowofneptune 4y agoThis is somewhat common to see in Arizona, since covered parking is very appreciated where it exists.
- burlesona 4y agoThis is a great idea, but as the article says it’s the kind of thing that doesn’t happen because the incentives and expertise don’t align. Moreover, big box development is usually designed on a mere 15-20 year lifespan, and very cheaply built, so a major capital project like a solar installation on the roof or parking conflicts with that model. It’s also almost certainly illegal in many municipalities, most of which basically say “no” to everything by default and only allow development that follows strict land use and aesthetic rules; yes even for parking lots.
- rob74 4y agoStrange to see "aesthetic" and "parking lot" mentioned in the same sentence. Well, if there really are rules against it, then (as the article also says) citizens and businesses should pressure their politicians to change those rules.
- csours 4y agoPeople like trees. I like trees. Solar panels don't like trees. If you put trees in parking lots (like some cities require), it's hard to get effective use of solar panels.
- alexvoda 4y agoDo American parking lots have trees? Pictures I have seen are usually barren asphalt wastelands.
- Eleison23 4y agoI rarely see significant use of trees around my home. It's unsurprising that cities mandate them because they provide shade... so if PV arrays confer even more shade, you could stop relying on trees! With a mandate to build a parking lot of a certain size, a business is going to say no trees; they would reduce auto capacity, present a maintenance burden, attract wildlife, and continually drop organic stuff on your customers' cars. And so that's exactly why cities find the need to mandate them!
- latchkey 4y agoI was thinking a solar canopy over the California Aqueduct [1] would be neat. Keep the sun off from evaporating the water. Oh hey, just googled that, I'm not the only one. [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Aqueduct https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Aqueduct [2] https://www.asce.org/publications-and-news/civil-engineering-source/civil-engineering-magazine/article/2022/03/solar-panels-over-california-canals-test-possible-joint-siting-benefits https://www.asce.org/publications-and-news/civil-engineering...
- sulam 4y agoNot only has this been considered in California, it’s actively done in India.
- h0l0cube 4y agoPreviously on HN: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200803-the-solar-canals-revolutionising-indias-renewable-energy https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200803-the-solar-canals... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24046951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24046951 (70 comments 148 points)
- aaron695 4y ago
- DavidKarlas 4y agoAlso water cooling air under panels improves performance…
- fho 4y agoSomebody watches Rosies videos? :-)
- milleramp 4y agoAlso as someone who is not allowed to install PV panels due to HOA restrictions, why can’t I subsidize this and own my own piece over the aqueduct, the same as if they were on my roof? This seems so obvious, to allow people like me and others who live in apt complexes to have some skin in the game. Why do the solar panels need to be on my roof to benefit, why can’t they be over the aqueduct or in Palm Springs?
- ec109685 4y agoI thought with higher voltage power lines, transmitting power over longer distance starts to be feasible. The environmental impact of building solar farms in the middle of the desert didn’t seem very high compared to impact of global warming (or like they said growing grain for ethanol). Regardless, the answer should be yes to anything that will move us along towards more clean energy.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoWhy transport energy from far away via expensive cables when you can just put some cheap solar panels right next to where they are needed?
- CyanLite4 4y agoThe dirty little secret is that there is little payback for retailers to do so. Walmart could do it at scale, but they already can put megawatts of solar on existing roofs for their stores. Article mentions several states where solar is discouraged to protect monopolies. Not to mention another article out saying Republican-led states are actively punishing corporations who reduce their emissions. Walmart isn’t going to see a realistic payback from that investment, and could even face backlash. They also sometimes get tax credits and incentives from the power company to build a Supercenter in a certain area. They do however buy into solar farms to offset their carbon. Other retailers (Trader Joe’s or Starbucks) it wouldn’t make sense for, most lease their buildings and don’t have enough expertise to take this on. Commercial property owners wouldn’t care about this.
- thephyber 4y agoI think your point is very important. Stakeholders other than the owners (eg. Renters at apartments, condo owners within an HOA, companies that lease office space, etc) want at least some of the benefits of solar, but don’t have enough clout to do it. Some states in the USA have a “community solar” project concept where you can invest in a solar project and the power it generates can directly credit your electric bill (basically decoupling location from solar ownership). I just wish it worked better and more people were investing in it.
- Pxtl 4y agoSmarter greener move is to not have surface-level parking in the first place. We know how to build green. We know what it looks like. It looks like dense, urban living. There's a reason the lowest carbon state is New York, and the lowest carbon nation per-GDP is France.
- downvotetruth 4y agoRoof is still an option.
- onethought 4y agoFrance is not the lowest, it's beaten by a host of other countries: - France 0.1 - Sweden 0.06 - Somalia 0.04 - Congo 0.03 In fact a lot of countries in Europe/South America hover around the 0.1 mark.
- jonas21 4y agoOkay, but in places where surface-level parking already exists, why not put solar over it?
- panick21_ 4y agoBecause that makes it that those parking lots will stay there for 25 more years. You want to remove these parking lots systematically from any kind of urban or even subburban environment as soon as possible. Not invest more into them. That is a far more worthy investment.
- emj 4y agoLooking at Rutger campus, used as an example in the article, https://osm.org/go/ZctEjpw05- https://osm.org/go/ZctEjpw05- up to 50% of the area seems to be for car infrastructure. That's a lot of area.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoIt doesn't imply that the parking lots will stay there for 25 more years. It implies that until it is more valuable to construct something else on that land, the PV array would remain there for 25 more years. Whether or not parking is allowed under the array is entirely orthogonal.
- btbuildem 4y agoFor a layperson, this seems like such a no-brainer: you're basically upgrading open parking lots to car ports. Drivers should love that, no? The lobbying angle explains A LOT. Of course, it's entrenched players clinging on to their profits. Oh well. The cost argument is interesting.. one would think it would be cheaper to build on already-developed lots, since no earth-moving and other infrastructure work is required -- but it looks like the structures must conform to a higher standard. Nobody cares if a panel topples in some remote field, but it one falls on someone's car, bad press and lawsuits. I certainly hope things move forward and we see more solar over the desolate landscape of the endless parking lots in North America. If anything, the promise "free" power to the lot owners could tip the scales.
- kumarvvr 4y agoIn crowded city centers, i doubt wind would be fast enough to topple panels. Even so, the frames are sturdy enough to hold the panels against strong winds.
- freddie_mercury 4y agoCrowded city centres have more wind due to the Venturi Effect, not less.
- rob74 4y agoGenerally there are no huge parking lots in crowded city centers (or, if there were, they would be shaded by the highrise buildings producing the Venturi effect, so no good for solar panels), so the problem would take care of itself. But anyway, I don't think engineering a roof over a parking lot so it can support a solar panel and not fall over is an unsolvable problem.
- freddie_mercury 4y agoI agree but the OP is the one who brought up crowded city centres like that was relevant to the amount of wind. I don't understand what relationship they were trying to suggest there.
- foogazi 4y agoI’ve seen solar go up in CA school parking lots: https://timesofsandiego.com/opinion/2017/03/11/solar-power-is-first-in-class-at-californias-k-12-schools/ https://timesofsandiego.com/opinion/2017/03/11/solar-power-i...
- dabiged 4y agoThis has become very popular in Australia with both of the big retailers, Coles and Woolworths.
- nikolay 4y agoOrange County public schools all have these, but does it make any financial sense given the huge investment and the fact that the panels have less than 30 years of lifespan?
- downvotetruth 4y agoThe "inflation" bill that further supports the fossil fuel industry about to be passed will certainly make it more appealing in the U.S. at the expense on developing countries that get more sun. Solar is great, but subsidizing installs in Prudhoe Bay don't make a lot of sense atm.
- onethought 4y agoThe panels easily pay for themselves over 30 years, so - yes. Also likely they improve the maintenance of whatever is under them, just from weather protection, even concrete maintenance.
- dehrmann 4y ago> The panels easily pay for themselves over 30 years, so - yes. But do they cover their opportunity cost?
- onethought 4y agoThe opportunity cost of what?
- sokoloff 4y agoOf whatever else one could choose to invest in instead of the solar installation.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoDoes your opportunity cost computation cover the cost of not producing power from renewable sources?
- happyopossum 4y agoSome of the points in the article make sense at first blush, and may even be correct, but I lose hope when it starts out with a complete fabrication : “Undeveloped land is a rapidly dwindling resource” Note - roughly 6% of the US is developed space, less than 3% of that land is urban. [1] The author then compounds the mistrust by stating that by 2050, we might need up to 0.5% of land dedicated to generating solar power. ZERO POINT FIVE percent. And I’m supposed to think that’s a problem? 10 million acres out of the nearly 2 billion we have in this country? Yeah - that doesn’t concern me. It’s a shame too, as I like solar canopied parking lots and think they make sense in some cases - making such weak justifications at the top of the article though, makes me think I may be wrong about it. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-10/the-real-role-of-land-values-in-the-united-states https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-10/the-real-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wnevets 4y ago> Note - roughly 6% of the US is developed space, less than 3% of that land is urban. Undeveloped land that people actually want to live on/near is a dwindling resource. Sure Kansas is filled massive amounts of undeveloped land but you don't see Americans rushing to move there.
- creato 4y agoSounds like a good place to put solar panels then?
- wnevets 4y agoTransmitting electricity from Kansas to either of the coast sounds incredibly impractical.
- dylan604 4y agoI tend to like the food that Kansas is currently using its land for, so lets just look for some other less useable land that doesn't also grow food and tends to get a lot of sun while also being at least close to the west cost. Obviously, I'm talking Nevada, Arizona, and eastern California. Seems a much more practical option
- ChuckMcM 4y agoThese are really a great way to reclaim some power. Some times however you'll want 15' clearance so that you can drive delivery trucks to the stores under them. But overall it just makes a lot of sense. In California at least I've seen these projects get killed by squabbling between the person willing to fund the work, the management company/developer that currently has the lease rights to the location, and the underlying land owner who is leasing the land to the developer. I have suggested to my representatives that perhaps something like the "you must approve this sort of plan" laws that would facilitate California's commitment to becoming 100% renewable.
- reaperducer 4y agoI've seen a lot of these in the Southwest, but I'm surprised I don't see them more. One church I know did this to most of its parking lot, and has tons of spare energy to sell back to the grid.
- moffkalast 4y agoWith EVs becoming more common this plus chargers at every parking spot should be a complete no-brainer.
- leereeves 4y ago> Some times however you'll want 15' clearance so that you can drive delivery trucks to the stores under them. Not a problem. Solar canopies can be built 20' off the ground. (A grocery store near me has one.)
- Scoundreller 4y agoHere's one in Montpellier France: https://www.google.ca/maps/@43.5849703,3.8875289,133a,35y,39.54t/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.ca/maps/@43.5849703,3.8875289,133a,35y,39...
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoHere in Tasmania, Launceston airport has a carpark with a 20kW solar canopy covering the roof of the covered parking area. https://www.driveparkfly.com.au/about-us/ https://www.driveparkfly.com.au/about-us/
- ncmncm 4y agoYou get 20 kW by covering just three spaces.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoYeah, could be more, but it something at least. Probably some cost / benefit analysis went on there that we wouldn't know about from the website.
- ncmncm 4y agoMight be they push 20 kW out to the grid after subtracting off what they use. A grocery store burns a hell of a lot of power on refrigeration.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoAt a guess it's probably something to do with the network connection at that location.
- prawn 4y agoThere's a shopping centre in Adelaide with 1MW of solar canopies and 1.3MW on the roof. That project started in 2018: https://www.castleplaza.com.au/centre-info/learn-about-our-solar-program https://www.castleplaza.com.au/centre-info/learn-about-our-s...
- asimpleusecase 4y agoWalMart should do this and become a net energy producer.
- panick21_ 4y agoWalMart lobbies hard to make sure all their buildings have basically zero value as it reduced property taxes. They will put up the cheapest possible building and invest absolutely nothing into it. They deprecate it very quickly. Investing on solar panels on the roof or the parking lot just means more investment in a specific location that they don't care about.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoAs has been noted elsewhere, at present commercial solar PV can be 100% depreciated in the first year. This is about to change, however.
- rmason 4y agoMichigan State University locally here did something very similar a few years back. They claim there's a thirty year payback but seeing as how we live in the second cloudiest city in America I am skeptical. However I cut them a little slack because universities are first adopters driving science forward even when the ROI isn't always there. But we get a lot of snow here and it is really nice to come out after it's snowed and not have to clear the snow off your car!
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agocloudiest city in America is almost certainly why it's a 30 year payback instead of a 10 year payback in a better climate
- ncmncm 4y agoMore typical lately is three years. Panels are way cheaper than before.
- panick21_ 4y agoYou know what would be 10x better for society? Not have a society where half of every city is compromised of parking lots. The car and parking lots problem is a huge part issue in the US in particular. Not only is the whole concept incredibly bad environmentally, in terms of CO2 of course, but also emissions and other problems like cities being hotter and causing water management issues. These parking lots are also a huge economic problem a symptom of the reason why so many towns are functionally broke. Encouraging cheap building for box stores or fast food restaurants with huge parking lots represents and incredibly uneconomic proposition and is losing cities money. Lots of infrastructure cost for very little in terms of property tax. Not to mention that such a development pattern makes city centers less attractive, and that is exactly the place where cities could be making actual money. Often is actually the poorer denser areas of the city that financially support the sprawl of the richer part of the city. So instead of plastering solar panels all over parking-lots ever effort should be made to eliminate the parking lots themselves. Infill development has to be done, and the city needs to support it with by relaxing their often borderline sociopathic zoning orders (along with a host of other harmful regulation). Changing the development pattern would save far more energy then plastering parking lots with solar panels will ever do. And not only will it help for the environment, things like the housing crisis in the Bay Area (and other places could be solved or at least massively impacted). Talking all the under utilized commercial zone property in the Bay Area and zoning it for mixed-use could potentially add 1000000s of housing units in the 'missing middle' segment. See this talk on the Bay Area by City designer Peter Calthorpe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUtdFbK4YG4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUtdFbK4YG4 The organization 'Strong Towns' has made this one of its central issues: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Em7nqDqQ8oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Em7nqDqQ8oM For some more details on the economics Joe Minicozzi: The Cash Flow of Urbanism:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFC_Q4WQKVk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFC_Q4WQKVk So what I end up with is that inside of cities you shouldn't have parking lots hardly at all, and outside of the urban environment you might as well just put them onto some empty space. Putting solar panels on parking lots will just make those parking lots an even more persistent and harder to remove in the future. So remove the parking lot, don't buy the solar panels, invest that money in a trolley bus instead. It will be better for the environment and the city.
- 4y ago
- chefnote 4y agoThis is a good idea. Hope it gets shared wider.
- Prcmaker 4y agoFlinders University (South Australia) covered some large carparking with solar panels just a couple of years ago. The solution to the problem of funding seemed to be to get the staff and students to subsidise it through drastically increased parking fees. The idea rapidly turned from popular to unpopular, though was implemented anyway.
- sumedh 4y ago> The idea rapidly turned from popular to unpopular, though was implemented anyway. Do they have good public transport?
- prawn 4y agoThey're at the intersection of a couple of major arterials including the major arterial, so I'd guess public transport to be as good as anything suburban relying on buses. There are always complaints about parking costs for hospitals (including one adjacent to this university) so that rise may have been inevitable and just muddied the issue?
- _ph_ 4y agoPutting solar on parking lots (and of course all kind of roofs) should be so obvious, that it shouln't need to be mentioned. Besides having the area already ready, they would even improve it (shade) and the grid is in place and the eletricticy can partially be used on-site (cooling, heating, and of course, charge electric cars[1] while they park). In more northern regions like here in Germany, panels are already efficient enough when mounted vertically, as on walls, especially fences. But it is worth stressing, that solar is even more efficient if you put it on fields rather then farming for energy production. Another interesting option is to mount solar panels higher up with some gaps and then do farming below them. For many crops, the yield is barely reduced due to the solar panels and with the global warming, the partial shade even might result in lower water consumption. With solar (and of course wind in suitable regions) we have all the energy production potential available, not only to fight climate change but overall have more and cheaper energy in the long term. Not to mention no environmental pollution. [1]: For the average German electric car the math works out that on average 10 solar panels would produce enough energy to operate the car - they would basically fit on a car port. The driving distances in the US are certainly longer, but then there is also more sun and the car ports might be larger, in consequence, the calculation wouldn't be far different.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> Another interesting option is to mount solar panels higher up with some gaps and then do farming below them. Or put them on grazing fields[1] and get the extras of i) shade for the lambs, ii) free plant management around the panels, and iii) maybe reduced water consumption. [1] https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2021/04/mixing-sheep-grazing-with-solar-farms-yields-major-land-productivity-increase/ https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2021/04/mixing-she...
- ncmncm 4y agoReduced water loss is one of the chief selling points for "agrivoltaics". The cheapest setup, in most fields, is to make fence-rows of bifacial panels, running north-south to pick up morning and afternoon sun, and particularly to block late afternoon sun that stresses plants most. But some crops (and livestock) benefit from protection against hail and storm rain. Then, again put up fence rows, but with the panels sticking out from both sides. Running them east-west, it is easy to tilt them to pick up the southern light better. (Northern, for you kiwis.)
- eliaspro 4y agoThe German state of Baden-Württemberg mandates PV on all car parks (>35 cars) and all new private and commercial buildings since 2022. https://www.baden-wuerttemberg.de/de/service/presse/pressemitteilung/pid/photovoltaik-pflicht-fuer-alle-neubauten-ab-2022/ https://www.baden-wuerttemberg.de/de/service/presse/pressemi... (German)
- martijnvds 4y agoI've read some horror stories about big solar installations not getting a license to be connected to the grid after installation (either because the grid is "full" or because of bureaucracy working super slowly). Is that a problem there as well, or is that more of a local issue in some (other) areas of the country?
- phito 4y agoI don't know about Germany, but here in Belgium my house solar panels have not been working for about 2 years now. There are too many solar panels in the street injecting electricity on the lines, during sunny days the voltage goes over the ondulator's safety threshold and everything stops. There's been about 2500 complaints about this last year in my region of this small country. And the company in charge of the grid refuse to give any compensations.
- lovemenot 4y agoYour panels are still working fine. Essentially, your problem is that you supplier is unwilling to invest in storage and management systems and doesn't provide inter-connectivity to the grid. Could you create a separate grid in your home? Off-grid or maybe hybrid, having no connection to your domestic power connections nor the supply. You'll be able to reuse nearly all of the existing solar equipment and will just need to invest a bit more to re-architect some of the electrical system in your home. It may be a little awkward to use, since you'll be sometimes unplugging appliances from one supply to another. But if you were willing to invest in energy storage too, there'd be more consistency from your solar and less need to unplug appliances.
- simon_000666 4y agoChallenge here is too much solar destabilizes the grid and there’s not enough peaker plants/other sources to handle to variation in generation/load. The reason residential makes more sense is that it’s consumed at source. I don’t know the power draw needs of supermarkets but I doubt it warrants fully covered parking lots. Residential is better because it decentralizes power generation more and puts more power in the hands of consumers.
- ncmncm 4y agoStrangely, power system engineers are not complaining about destabilized grids. Solar can be turned off instantly if it were ever a problem. In the future all the grids will also have plentiful storage, and be overwhelmingly more stable than today.
- simon_000666 4y agoHmm, it’s anecdotal but I know several grid engineers in the UK and Europe who are employees to deal with exactly that problem and spend most of their time complaining about the instability caused to a grid that needs investment to adjust to the new reality. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.abj6734 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.abj6734
- ncmncm 4y agoYes, the grid needs to adapt to changing conditions. Strangely enough, it has engineers who know how to adapt it. Some, you even say you know. "Ooh, a turn is coming up! Who will turn the steering wheel so we don't run off the road?" ... "Oh, we have a driver? Why didn't anybody tell me?
- II2II 4y agoMy instinctive response: if the parking lot is too large to generate power that will be consumed at the source, it is yet another reason to consider parking lots as inefficient land use. My second response: if society considers the electric automobile as an acceptable substitute for efficient land use and transportation infrastructure, perhaps we should be mandating this form of in situ power generation for automobiles so that people who make more environmentally sustainable decisions and those who cannot afford an automobile do not end up subsidizing power for those who choose to drive. EDIT, just to be clear: I commented on electric cars since they are a way to consume power at the source.
- guerby 4y agoFun fact: a standard parking spot of 2.5x5 meter covered with regular PV panels will produce in a year (in my country) about 2.5 MWh which is enough to power an EV for 16000 km. Of course less than needed in winter and more in summer. Edit: fixed computations 2x2.5x1000 hours of sun of 20% efficient = 2.5 MWh then 2.5 MWh / 150 Wh/km = 16666 km.
- analyzethis 4y agoWhy not go one step further and place solar panels over roads? All the space ever needed is already available!
- amelius 4y agoI guess because it is a maintenance nightmare.
- koheripbal 4y agoSpace isn't the issue when it comes to power generation
- bilsbie 4y agoYou’d get the added benefit of gas savings for the vehicles parked under then not having to cool down with AC. Maybe not a huge difference.
- chiefalchemist 4y ago> The appeal of parking lots and rooftops, by contrast, is that they are abundant, close to customers, largely untapped for solar power generation, and on land that’s already been stripped of much of its biological value. Also, the panels mitigate the parking lots from becoming heat storage batteries (so to speak). There's a reason summer temps fall further at night in rurals areas (e.g., Vermont) than they do in urban / suburban areas (e.g., New Jersey). Trees and such don't hold heat the way pavement does. Now obviously simply adding solar panels to parking lots in NJ isn't going to have a massive impact, but it's not going to hurt either.
- tiku 4y agoYou can even farm under them, but it will cost a lot of extra material to put them up higher and you lose some space.
- koheripbal 4y agoThis is not efficient. Farming requires many centralized functions not scalable in an urban environment.
- washbrain 4y agoI wonder how this impacts carbon vs, say, eliminating the parking lot and encouraging better public transit and biking and using the reclaimed space for more housing or commerce.
- proggy 4y agoI have similar thoughts. Surface parking lots are often targets for infill development of residential / commercial structures, which if built intelligently can increase density and therefore walkability / bikeability. I’d imagine adding solar panel canopies to surface parking lots increases their value significantly, reinforcing the car-centric land use pattern and making it more difficult to replace them. It is far more energy efficient to walk short distances in a dense urban grid than it is to drive long distances between buildings that are separated by oceans of parking lots. All that said, this is still a good solution for the land use pattern we have today. When it comes to environmentalism I’m of the view that perfect can often be the enemy of good.
- lttlrck 4y agoThis is interesting because (in CA at least) the benefit of residential solar is offsetting the electricity that you use. So use 1 kWh and generate 1 kWh, net cost is zero (Net Metering) But overproduction is paid at NSCR (Net Surplus Compensation Rate) which is a couple of cents per kWh [1] - a small fraction of the cost you would pay (this detail is often masked by solar companies) So presumably there is a different framework for non-residential solar farms like these where it is, perhaps, predominately generation? https://www.sce.com/regulatory/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices/net-surplus-compensation https://www.sce.com/regulatory/tariff-books/rates-pricing-ch...
- mgerdts 4y agoEach of these installations could be paired with charging infrastructure appropriate for the location. Around office buildings where the typical stay is several hours, charges could exist in many or most stalls to charge cars through the work day. Retail where the stay is typically shorter would focus on rapid chargers. Some would focus on those that are shopping, others would replace the gas station on the edge of the lot. Every sufficiently large building has a loading dock. Those that get regular use with trucks that sit there for a while (trailers loaded and unloaded while the driver waits) could have rapid chargers for trucks. Some battery capacity would be needed to account for grid limitations in some areas. This would be a great second life for degraded car batteries. If the batteries are near full while the short term expectation is for high generation, the price could drop.
- hk1337 4y agoAt the very least it would provide shade for cars and power the lighting for when it gets dark.
- cogman10 4y ago> Retail where the stay is typically shorter would focus on rapid chargers. Some would focus on those that are shopping, others would replace the gas station on the edge of the lot. L2 chargers is what we desperately need. L3 chargers should be reserved to be built at long range locations. L2 chargers at a grocery store could give you ~40 miles in an hour. Enough to cover your daily commute. Put a bunch of L1 chargers in an office garage. They'll do around 4 miles in an hour. The reason to do it this way is because the same L3 connection doing a single 350kW charger can power ~30 L2 chargers. The circuit doing a single L2 chargers can power 10 L1 connections. We can reasonably put a slow charger pretty much anywhere someone would park. These slow chargers hardly impact the grid and are cheap to add.
- fnbr 4y agoAre L1 vs L2 vs L3 chargers radically different in cost? Or is it that you want to provision charging speed proportional to the power being supplied from solar at the business?
- dclowd9901 4y agoI wish, in Phoenix, they would make this a requirement on all new construction and also require old construction to retrofit in the next 20 years. We absolutely need it here, and the places that do have it, it’s wonderful. I actually think at some point people will _prefer_ to patronize locations that have solar shading over ones that don’t. And just think: if they generate enough power they might be able to compete on prices by supplementing profits with solar generation.
- danans 4y agoThe approach of reutilizing existing parking lots is great, but some spots without solar panels should be reserved for the solar self-charging cars that are coming to market in the next few years: https://sonomotors.com/en/sion/ https://sonomotors.com/en/sion/ https://www.aptera.us/ https://www.aptera.us/ https://lightyear.one/ https://lightyear.one/
- d4a 4y agoEven with those solar cars, it would be better off for them to plug into a larger grid and set of solar panels compared to the small ones built in. The purpose of those small panels is to charge when no charging is available. In this case, if enough current and charge is available (via solar canopies and mains power) then the built in panel is useless.
- danans 4y ago> The purpose of those small panels is to charge when no charging is available. The Lightyear and Aptera can charge up to 40 miles of range per day on their built-in solar panels, and the Sion can add about 15. With that much charging capability, the built in solar panels can provide energy for a vast majority of the daily miles driven in the vehicles, and not just function as a backup for when plug charging is unavailable.
- therealdrag0 4y agoThe point is they can get that days worth of charge in an hour by just plugging in under the canopy, so it’d be silly to make an exception for such a rare car.
- danans 4y agoIt's only silly if you don't think that a lot more EVs in the future will solar self-charge similarly to those cars.
- 4y ago
- D-Coder 4y agoIf a large company (let's say Walmart) offered free recharging for EVs in their parking lots, that might bring more customers in. Your car needs an hour for recharging, might as well be right in front of the store.
- thatsamonad 4y agoThe Walmart near us has a set of EV chargers in its parking lot that offer free charging for up to 2 hours. I bought my first EV earlier this year and I’ve definitely visited that Walmart more than I ever would before because it’s convenient to get a quick charge in and grab a few groceries, etc, I might need anyway.
- mperham 4y agoOregon just passed new rules which require larger parking lots to have shade trees or solar canopy. No more giant hot asphalt wastelands.
- motohagiography 4y agoIs the precise reason there are not solar canopies everywhre because the cost of panels is not competitive with the value of the power they yield? Something seems economically broken in the solar business. It should be an arbitrage that so many people pile into that panel prices plummet as fast as compute processing and RAM has. Economically, Moore's law should also apply to solar panels, but the R&D isn't economical either. Sure, the hard problem isn't collection but transmission and storage, but again, what is the R&D bottleneck? We could say the subsidies on fossil fuels means the competitiveness of solar is suppressed, but maybe we need some breakaway regions that make it viable, like a hundred solar Las Vegas'es that run on cryptocurrency chips signed by solar power producers, and govts can tolerate our autonomy in exchange for taking the risk on tech to create newly sustainable economies. If you really want solar power, legalize gambling with a provably solar powered cryptocurrency. I could build the first low powered rig in an afternoon, as it would be a panel hookup, a raspi, and the secret sauce would be the HSM that signed the tokens it produced. If someone stole the keys, you just fork and grandfather tokens produced before the compromise. If someone swapped their panel for grid power instead of solar to produce them, the sun is the ultimate open random number generator and by encoding bursts from it into the token, you could see whether a miner was producing consistently based on volume relative to the random stream from the sun. I don't think it's the tech that is the problem, there's something fishy about the economics, as these are solvable problems.
- CyanLite2 4y agoFor one, very sunny places like California are getting very close to the "too much solar" on their energy production. Until microgrids take off, this is going to be a very serious problem in the next 12-24 months. California will probably have one of the lowest kWh/$ rates in the country during summer daylight hours. But off-peak hours will be much more expensive. Adding more solar would not help in these places because it would interfere with the economics of mass power production. The investment to build power plants (nuclear or gas-fired) is too high when you can only run that plant during night-time hours but sit idle during the day. Texas has been in a similar situation, before the Feb 2021 disaster, they were giving away free power at night because of too much wind production. All of that energy production has to go somewhere and grid-scale energy storage isn't feasible just yet. If it's not consumed, then it's just wasted. Two, the tech is just forming to help solve some things, such as "floatovoltaics". Covering Lake Mead will help, or the Great Salt Lake in Utah. But water is very corrosive. Engineers have also stayed away from putting power lines in water for good reason. The tech for floatovoltaics is just now emerging, and even the national electric code has just put something in it for 2023. Three, raw materials shortages. Solar requires a lot of silicon, aluminum, glass, and steel. Batteries require a lot of rare earth metals from harmful mining practices. You need billions of tons of copper just to handle the wiring and distribution side of things. Almost all lithium battery and solar manufacturing is overseas in China. There are some in the U.S., but not enough to make a serious dent in solving the overall problem. EV batteries have secured over 140% of the available lithium mines in the world. Alternative batteries like sodium-ion are exclusively produced at scale in China, but startups like Natron Energy are trying to change that (again, not enough to make a dent). But the main point is that there isn't enough lithium, cobalt, nickel, copper, silicon in the world to go around without having some serious inflation and supply chain issues along the way. The tech doesn't yet exist for grid-scale energy storage that doesn't rely on lithium and its closest cousin sodium-ion doesn't have the manufacturing scale to produce the billions of cells annually needed to tackle this problem. Four, the U.S. lacks political will. Republican states are actively damaging companies who are reducing their carbon emissions. Fox News labels climate change as "woke politics". Thus, you have 40-50% of Americans believing solar panels and EVs as "bad" things. It then trickles down to local politics like where the article shows that Southern states should be accounting for 33% of solar production, but due to poor politics/laws they only account for 7%.
- olivermarks 4y agoIMO solar over tarmac and concrete urban areas is a good idea, but not on grass/dirt if it can be avoided
- bitsoda 4y agoWhile it's implied, another added benefit would be that cars in warm climates would no longer have to blast their A/C after a day of work after the sun has incinerated its interior to 120°.
- taldo 4y agoGoogle has a couple of small canopies over parking in their campus (near B42 [0]). I vaguely recall someone saying that it was so expensive to get permits and stuff, that they just dropped the idea altogether. [0]: 37.42155847329576,-122.08624401157378