16 ms·
Microrobots can brush and floss teeth in a proof-of-concept study
- Victerius 4y agoNanomachines, son! They brush my teeth in response to mastication.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoDon't masticate with your mouth open
- Jistern 4y agoPro Tip: Buy a professional dental pick. I bought one on Amazon for around $35 about 10 years ago. I use it every day. It works great.
- neonological 4y ago
- svantana 4y agoI find it strange that there is so little innovation in the field of everyday tooth care. Particularly the inefficiency of brushing one tooth at a time. I like the idea of https://blizzbrush.com/ https://blizzbrush.com/, has anyone tried it? It's a bit suspicious that the single-pack is "sold out", but the 5 and 10-packs are not.
- whoomp12342 4y agoidk, I think the 1 pack means that people are wiling to try it but have not decided as a mass if they want to continue use. It doesnt mean its a bad product
- unsupp0rted 4y agoTotally agree there's too little innovation in this field. I hadn't heard of the Buzz Brush and it's fascinating to me, although it does look half-baked and too indie at the moment for me to trust it with my dental health. Also it's too expensive to try as a throwaway test. Any other cool innovative products that replace standard brushing?
- dmcgee 4y agoNot that replace standard brushing, but I worked with a company in Denmark called Novozymes. They produce enzymes for a variety of applications including dental care. They have a set of enzymes that they license to Unilever for a toothpaste called Zendium, which has some market share in Northern Europe. The enzymes break down microfilm that develops on teeth, making brushing more effective. There was RCT done on it I believe, I read the paper years ago, can't seem to find it now though.
- unsupp0rted 4y agoAny concern those enzymes would get swallowed and break down membranes in the digestive tract?
- krageon 4y agoSeeing as they pass through the acid in your stomach (and will denature there, which is the point of your stomach) you must be primarily worried about any of the bits before that. These enzymes are made to go in your mouth. If they dissolved the tissues in there they wouldn't be appropriate for that, so this is not a concern.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoBased on the video, I wouldn't implicitly trust the brush to have enough precision to hit the small chunks of food at the gumline.
- hanniabu 4y agoNot buying it. That would only work if it were firmer because as it is now I'm extremely doubtful your teeth will magically fall into those grooves when the sponge has so little structure. On top of that it seems hard to clean, A toothbrush is open and has short bristles and often after rinsing it I'll look and still find debris where I need to clean again and deliberately get pieces out.
- macinjosh 4y agoIf you are in the US, like me, you might not be aware of Novamin toothpastes. They are available in other countries. It is my understanding that it can enclose dentin tubules exposed by enamel loss. This article provides some background: https://medium.com/@ravenstine/the-curious-history-of-novamin-toothpaste-620c6bef8881 https://medium.com/@ravenstine/the-curious-history-of-novami...
- nso 4y agoI've had bad teeth since adulthood, partly due to a medication changing the pH of my saliva, and partly due to a Pepsi addiction. I swear by the Novamin tooth paste, my life has gone from always having small aches and icing in my teeth to my teeth hardly being a factor anymore.
- safeimp 4y agoI was considering this recently based on a thread from last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31954800 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31954800 Do you have a reliable source to purchase? I've no interest in purchasing via Amazon, wouldn't feel comfortable trusting the content.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoI have, after years of deliberatng, decided to use an electric toothbrush. Its been 2 years and I want to know what I should be expecting. Maybe I am sleepy when I a brushing so I don't notice but asking still. Novamin sounds interesting. Its available here on amazon so I might splurge on it but again, what I am to expect out of it as opposed to regular Colgate ?
- nso 4y agoFor me it removed that icy feeling.
- stjohnswarts 4y agobeen doing nano-hydroxyapatite for the same reason. I use stannous fluoride based toothpaste in the morning and nhdpa at night before bed.
- Silica6149 4y agoThis sponge you put in your mouth made me think for the first time about how much bacteria is potentially on a normal toothbrush. I'm betting this product is even less hygienic since it's a sponge instead of only bristles.
- bamboozled 4y agoWhy not leave your toothbrush in hydrogen peroxide overnight?
- Silica6149 4y agoGood idea, it's just I never thought twice about the cleanliness of a toothbrush. I guess it's been ingrained in me to think it's normal to run a toothbrush under water to "clean" it.
- rusticpenn 4y agoYou are supposed to change the brush every few months precisely for this reason.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoI thought it was because the hairs on the brush get 'blunt' from erosion on your teeth. The 'applied science' guy had an electron microscope capture of new and old toothbrushes and it was the differences between needle sharp edges and worn out clubs.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoI remember a myth busters episode where they demonstrated that toothbrushes left in open air will easily get fecal matter on the brush hairs due to aerosolized poop from when you flush an open lid toilet. Definitely a great conversation ice-breaker.
- liotier 4y ago
- dubswithus 4y agoI remember some articles about good bacteria outcompeting bad bacteria in the mouth and preventing cavities. Seems like it probably didn't pan out.
- moffkalast 4y agoNah it did, the problem is you have to take a pill every day and they cost way too much for that sort of frequent usage. Like $60 per 20 pills kind of price, which is hard to justify without hard proven evidence of actual benefit.
- krageon 4y agoHow did you get this price? Can I get them somewhere? $3 per day to never have teeth issues again is an absolute bargain.
- moffkalast 4y agoI think I saw it on amazon a few years back? It's possible there wasn't enough demand to keep selling it, but I've also no idea what it was called anymore.
- f6v 4y agoHave you seen how much it costs to get crowns or implants? There’s zero incentive for innovation, people keep bringing their money.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI would like to think that most dentists like their patients to have healthy, cared for teeth and that they play in important role in it. I would not like to think that most of them actually work to our detriment so that they can do more expensive, painful procedures on our mouths and teeth. That’s a pretty cynical outlook I’d need to see evidence for.
- prepend 4y agoI’d like to think that, but my dentist makes about $170/year from me having healthy teeth. They make $1500/crown (in addition to the $170 for cleaning). I’ve been to three dentists this year. I find it interesting that one said I had an emergency and needed a crown right away (a year ago), one said they’d watch the tooth, and one said nothing. Cynically, I don’t like agency issues where experts make lots of money off their advice and it’s difficult to double check.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI had a dentist for several years and everything was normal just clean and go. A new hygenist shows up and suddently "You have severe plaque below the gum line we need to do a deep cleaning (root scaling/planing)" so they do that and it's almost $500, next time rolls around and she says it again and dentist concurs. I had been brushing and flossing diligently (probably too much) since the last time and just looking at my teeth saw nearly no plaque. I left and said I'd call them back to schedule. I go to a new dentist the following week and they say I have lovely teeth and it looks like I've been taking great care of them, then I tell the dentist what the previous one had said and he's like "listen, I'm not going to bad mouth anyone, but your teeth look great, they just need a typical cleaning that you came in for". That's when I knew something was really wrong with the other place, so it happens. I know my story is anecdotal. Personally I think my old dentist got rid of her previous hygenist that wouldn't agree to hornswoggle patients and they tried to get me to do expensive treatments.
- sAbakumoff 4y agoMy daily tooth care consists of 3 steps: 1. Clean between teeth by using an interdental brush 2. Clean between teeth by using a water flosser 3. Clean teeth surface by using an electric brush. I am not sure how would the sponge replace these 3 steps.
- LeonM 4y agoThere is quite some innovation, but consumers are slow to adopt IMO. Last year, my dentist warned me I have quite severe receded gums. This was due to me pushing my toothbrush too hard. So, after doing some research I bought an ultrasonic toothbrush. These have a static head (it does not oscillate/rotate) which emits ultrasonic waves to clean your teeth. Same principle of an ultrasonic parts cleaner. The head is still a traditional brush, though very soft. The brush is used to transfer the sound waves, you do not use it to 'scrub' your teeth. There is not friction involved. From my experience, I can highly recommend an ultrasonic toothbrush. It takes some time to get used to, but personally, I will never go back to a traditional 'friction' type brush (manual or electric). The model I have is the Silkin' ToothWave. Prices have come down significantly since I bought mine (I paid >€200 IIRC, now they are ~€90). Note that some vendors sell traditional 'friction type' oscillating electronic toothbrushes with ultrasonic as a feature. In my opinion, these do not offer much benefit, it is better to go for a fully ultrasonic model.
- afterburner 4y agoInteresting. I've also had success using a Sonicare but always moving from the gums to the tooth (instead of along the gumline as the manual suggests).
- d1sxeyes 4y agoLooks like 250 EUR on their website?
- LeonM 4y agoLooks like that pricing has not been updated for a while. I paid something like 200 euros, that was about a year ago. Most online retailers in my country now list them for less than 100 euros.
- jachee 4y agoWeird. In Dutch (https://silkn.nl/toothwave-black https://silkn.nl/toothwave-black) it’s €119. In English (both EU and GB), French, Spanish, and German ( e.g. https://silkn.eu/toothwave-black https://silkn.eu/toothwave-black) it’s €249.
- amelius 4y agoI want something that I can use in the office (i.e., without easy access to a sink).
- david_l_lin 4y agoI think it's because incumbents in the space have played a huge role in preventing adoption of new technologies that actually prevent disease. Dentists make money not from preventing disease, but from performing procedures when disease has already progressed to the point of no return. Cavities and gum disease are bacterial infections that are completely preventable. I feel the need to plug what we've been building at https://www.bristlehealth.com/ https://www.bristlehealth.com/. We've built an at-home test that leverages the microbes in the mouth to detect disease, and provide actionable and personalized recommendations that can reduce your risk of gum disease, cavities and persistent bad breath.
- barbazoo 4y ago> Dentists make money not from preventing disease, but from performing procedures when disease has already progressed to the point of no return. I find that hard to believe as dentists wouldn't be the group of people I'd imagine developing those new ideas and products. How would that work?
- yunohn 4y agoNobody wants to go to the dentist until it’s too late, because it’s so expensive nor covered by health insurance. Even if it’s not intentional, dentists aren’t R&D specialists. They’re a service, at a premium price, whose livelihood depends on people going for treatments.
- barbazoo 4y agoWhat lever do they have to prevent new products from being developed that help people take care of their teeth?
- yunohn 4y agoThe lever is the lack of funding and motivation brought about by the previous factors. It’s not an individual choice, rather a medical industry wide systemic issue. A popular example: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/goldman-sachs-asks-biotech-research-191500553.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/goldman-sachs-asks-biotech-re...
- runnerup 4y agoFor me the "unbreakable" floss string combined with a floss pick in this particular product: https://www.amazon.com/DenTek-Triple-Clean-Floss-Picks/dp/B003K01BMI https://www.amazon.com/DenTek-Triple-Clean-Floss-Picks/dp/B0... was a massive innovation that finally allowed me to regularly floss easily at the age of ~30. Prior to that I couldn't handle the floss string well, and all other floss picks (even nearly identical ones from the exact same brand) just snap apart between my very closely-spaced teeth.
- Komodai 4y agoThis looks like a really bad dropshipping site... Especially considering the fact they've imported reviews from elsewhere, like AliExpress (even has the same name format, C**e).
- bilsbie 4y agoIt’s just an over regulated industry where it’s too expensive to try new things.
- diob 4y agoDentistry exists all over the world...
- bsenftner 4y agoIn grad school, one of my friends worked for a US medical device manufacturer. They had several dental innovations that they did not bother to market in the US because the regulation to get approval out weighed what they felt the market offered. They made their profits in other countries and were happy with that.
- jklinger410 4y agoCapitalism only creates innovations where there is potential for expanding profits. Permanently fixing teeth is infinitely less profitable than keeping them in a constant state of disrepair.
- fileeditview 4y agoI guess this is the first step to nanosites[1] from "Diamond Age" by Neal Stephenson. [1] https://en.gyaanipedia.com/wiki/Nanosite https://en.gyaanipedia.com/wiki/Nanosite
- prepend 4y agoI’ve been waiting, since reading that book, for nanobots that brush my teeth, trim my hair, shave, etc so I wake up every morning and not need to do this stuff.
- Chris2048 4y agoWait, news on actual irl Drexlerian nano? > may one day.. oh, nevermind. Microbots "may one day" do shit, not "can".
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoWait so, what do these microrobots actually look like? Are they just small black bristles that you put in your mouth?
- Silica6149 4y agoIron nanoparticles controlled by a magnetic field it seems like. The thing I'm curious about though is, how do they remove all the iron particles afterward? Would I just get a month's dose of iron each time this thing brushes my teeth?
- upsidesinclude 4y agoSuck on a big bar magnet! Really, that would do. Better still would be an electro magnetic retainer. Then the particles cloud be captured and returned to a container. I doubt iron nano particles would be reusable, but you wouldn't want them down the sink as they would likely be nucleation points for rust Is anyone familiar with the health consequences of inhaling or otherwise ingesting nano iron?
- afterburner 4y agoMore magnets?
- hanklazard 4y agoYeah, the name is really misleading, if I’m understanding the tech correctly.
- sillycube 4y ago
- kleer001 4y agoDon't get too excited. It's >> ... a proof-of-concept study...
- gwbas1c 4y agoIf you're young, don't laugh. Once I turned 40 my dental hygienists really spent a lot of time educating me on how to properly brush my teeth. It really requires delicate care. (Remember, most of our ancestors didn't live to be old enough to need delicate dental hygiene.) If something like this works, it'll be wonderful. Carefully cleaning my teeth when I'm half asleep is not fun.
- safeimp 4y agoI turned 40 a few years ago and finally moved over to an electric toothbrush and my dentist has noticed improvements. Ultimately an electric is similar to a human but I like that it's consistent. Consistent pressure on my teeth and consistent time in each quadrant as well.
- thfuran 4y ago>Remember, most of our ancestors didn't live to be old enough to need delicate dental hygiene.) Really low historical life expectancy figures are mostly due to extremely high infant and childhood mortality as well as higher mortality in childbirth. It's not like adults were elderly at 40.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYep, if you lived til 16 you could easily and not surprisingly live to 60, after that it goes down hill pretty fast for most people without modern medicine...They didn't have a lot of retirement plans back then unless you were lucky enough to have some kids that wanted to keep grandpa around.
- bmau5 4y agoIf it makes you feel better most people don't brush their teeth correctly (supposed to hold toothbrush at a 45 degree angle along the tooth/gum line). I think there's another future where brushing and flossing largely become obsolete. If we could develop a more effective mouthwash tailored to restoring each persons oral microbiome we could likely reduce the need for brushing and flossing (and instead replace it with a daily rinse). A lot easier than half asleep brushing!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ComputerCat 4y agoI wonder if in the future this could be used to help care for people in long term hospital stays who are unable to brush/floss, or people who require at home care. Very interesting idea but I think it will take a long time for the general public to adopt this tech.
- MrYellowP 4y agoI don't recall where this story is from, but I've read it somewhere. It's a story about a guy who invents shaving microbots, which you apply in your face, who do all the work. Iirc they were on a gel, though ultimately that doesn't matter. At some point they supposedly deactivate themselves for some reason I've forgotten, to prevent them from doing harm in case they enter the body. The end of the story is that the inventor, who kept using his microbots, eventually died of unknown cause. The autopsy showed that he had pneumoconiosis/silicosis, aka a dry, dusty lung. Because he kept inhaling them. Microdroplets of liquid, containing microbots. I believe this story isn't far fetched. Imagine you have thousands of these teeth brushing bots in your mouth. If you have some on the back of your throat, you will eventually have them in your lungs. All it takes to accumulate enough of them to cause issues is repeated use and time.
- bmau5 4y agoThis is very interesting and has a lot of potential, especially for people who struggle to brush their teeth, but I think there's another future where brushing and flossing largely become obsolete. If we could develop a more effective mouthwash tailored to restoring each persons oral microbiome we could likely reduce the need for brushing and flossing and instead replace it with a daily mouth rinse that clears out food debris and selectively targets pathogenic bacteria while promoting healthy species. I'm a bit biased, though, because this is something we're working towards building at my company down the road.
- Victerius 4y agoLike a dishwasher but for teeth?
- coryrc 4y agoSome people rarely brush their teeth and never get cavities. Some people brush thrice daily and floss and still get cavities and need root canals. The working theory is we could all be in the first group with the right bacteria in our mouth.
- newscracker 4y agoCould it also be about the level of salivation in general, since saliva also helps kill some bacteria and keep the mouth cleaner (relatively)?
- bmau5 4y agoDefinitely! Saliva is our best natural defense against cavities (and harmful bacteria), so we always recommend people who have struggled with cavities or dry mouth to consider options for increasing their saliva production, like chewing sugar-free or xylitol gum.
- bmau5 4y agoThat's it exactly. Some beneficial species play an active role in suppressing the pathogenic species (those that release acid or cause gum disease) and have other benefits including helping us break down dietary nitrate into nitric oxide, which is critical for heart/brain health. My company tests/researches the oral microbiome and we're starting to discover the signatures of what puts people in one group vs. the other, with hopes of helping develop more personalized approaches down the road, but for now helping people understand what will work best for them. Here's my company for anyone who is interested in learning more: https://www.bristlehealth.com/ https://www.bristlehealth.com/
- peterlk 4y agoThis is really neat. But I remain skeptical > In both instances, a catalytic reaction drives the nanoparticles to produce antimicrobials that kill harmful oral bacteria on site. So, what happens if I swallow this stuff that I'm putting in my mouth?
- kortex 4y agoNothing that isn't already happening. There is magnetite in many foods already. Often as inexpensive iron fortification. Also, your cells are more robust to external reactive oxygen than bacteria. The catalysis occurs when hydrogen peroxide is "activated" by the magnetite to produce singlet oxygen, which then goes on to damage biofilms and bacterial walls. Your epithelial cells are basically expendable. Internal ROS isn't good, but that isn't the case here.
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoCan anyone recommend an electric toothbrush? I have always used a regular manual one, but lots of people including a dentist have recommended an electric one. Wanna see what the hype is about.
- sudofail 4y agoPhilips Sonicare is the way to go. Lot of different options, but they're all great.
- arnejenssen 4y agoPhilips sonicare + Waterpik flosser. Sensodyne Repair&Protect (has NOVAMIN that restores the teeth)
- michelb 4y agoMaybe NOVAMIN doesn't do much: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7068624/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7068624/
- whartung 4y agoIt's been awhile, but back when I tried one I didn't care for the Sonicare. Simply it made my hand numb.
- moffkalast 4y agoHaha yeah it takes a week or two to get fully used to it, I know a few people who just couldn't stomach it.
- NikolaNovak 4y agoI've used regular $10-$25 electric tooth brush for a decade and assumed they're good enough. I've gotten Phillips Sonicare for holiday, and understanding that this is anecdotal evidence, I am shocked at its increased ability to dislodge food from the crevices. I could swear that sometimes the vibration it puts on the tooth, dislodges food from places it's not yet directly touching, just through the vibration through the tooth, which never happened with cheaper electric brushes. Overall, my teeth feel far cleaner afterwards, kinda like after the dental hygienist is done. So it gets my support, expensive as it may be.
- system2 4y agoThis is probably one of the worst visual representation I've ever seen.
- downrightmike 4y agoWasn't there a Professor in Florida I think that introduced a new plasmid to the bacteria normally in our mouth and proved to prevent tooth decay? I've tried to look for it, but haven't been able to find it again.
- colordrops 4y agoNo thanks on putting nano-particles in my mouth.
- samstave 4y agoSo as an aside; Ciliac Disease is caused by the body falsely thinking [this was that] and attacking its own internals... SO... Lets assume that you add these and then they get ingested (which ALWAYS happens in brushing teeth) --> long term "micro-biome-biotics" affect on gut biome) Gut biomes are the most important health aspect for nutrition we should be plugging AI into... This seems like it will result in not-good outcomes.... Imagine programming "toothpaste" such that the bots that ARE ingested devour/destroy/attack/plant-payloads on cells in the system... --- Future Bio-Cyber-Nutrition attacks: A powder that is applied to a food substance that survives heat, cooking ; results in the bio-breakdown or attack of the individual. Level III: A recon biometrix that can be ingested and give the gut bio of a target.... in order to create a specific attack vector. Levvel IV: an agent who can determine dietary habits Level VI: Spore attributed to specific diets. --- Cyber warfare is not just computers ; its protein folding... When we were "folding proteins" for health.... Health can be - OR + <-- When we use the term "for health" ... it is ofr hte '-' <-- We are designing proteins to kill. Not heal. UNLESS you're Thiel.
- 14 4y agoAs a health care worker this would be great for very fragile or palliative clients where brushing effectively just isn’t possible. Fragile clients will often do a poor job or if you help them they don’t always tolerate how hard and long you need to brush to be effective. Not to even mention flossing. And with palliative patients they can often be bed bound and unconscious to you can’t really get in with a toothbrush and water and brush properly. Instead they get a small piece of foam attached to a stick basically and you rub it around their mouth and get any big chunks out. Very poor effectiveness. For me good mouth care for the palliative clients would be really nice to see.
- linsomniac 4y agoProTip: I went from rarely flossing to basically every day with "this one weird trick": I now floss my teeth in the shower. I like staying in the shower a little longer, so the 2 minutes went from chore to luxury. And the amount of food I remove on a daily basis is astonishing!
- uejfiweun 4y agoThis is actually genius, I'm gonna start doing this as well. Thank you for the great idea.
- doublerabbit 4y agoYou can brush your teeth in the shower too.
- linsomniac 4y agoDone and done! That's another part of that plan, I floss and then brush.
- decebalus1 4y agoYour comment reminded me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMQTg4Y0YT0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMQTg4Y0YT0
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoI get the comedy but now I'm wondering why he ordered a pair of chinos if he doesn't plan to get out of the shower.
- matsemann 4y agoIsn't the science on flossing not showing any benefit? Edit: looked it up. No solid scientific evidence flossing helps.
- justinpombrio 4y ago
- todd8 4y agoThis was envisioned in a science fiction story or novel decades ago, but I can’t remember where I saw it! It might have been a novel by Robert Heilein. It was just mentioned in passing in the story, but since that time I’ve wondered if it will ever be realized; I thought it might take the form of a small robot about the size of a June bug that would slowly crawl around in one’s mouth while we were asleep.
- bobabob 4y agoffs, that's about time. I can brush my teeth just fine, I just hate doing it and I felt like this field had been lacking advances like this for a very very long time.
- cambo 4y ago"What ever you do, _never_ swallow the Dentic"
- birdfood 4y agoI'm looking forward to the day when we have bio-engineered slugs that feed off the left over food in our mouths while we sleep. If their trails can strengthen enamel all the better!
- freeflight 4y agoThanks, but I rather not choke on slugs in my sleep.
- ggm 4y agoI am really tired of the hijacking of concepts like "bot" or "robot" to mean "small magnetic particles which form a virtual scrubbing brush, and we make them move by rotating a magnetic field" these are lumps of magnetite. they have no autonomous element, no programming, no decision logic, no ALU, no FPGA, no WiFi, no data, no analogue computer, nothing. Its not smart dust: its dumb dust and a rotating magnet. Its not a bot.
- _def 4y agoThanks for the explanation, as I was really wondering what the robotic aspect is in this.
- throwntoday 4y agoI'd like to second this and just say, please leave these kind of posts on reddit. There's nothing of interest or relevance to technology here. I come to this site for substantive links, not clickbait.
- E2EEd 4y agoKey feature is swallowing the dentic as harmless. Risk management is the priority.
- nyxtom 4y agoI swear it amazes me sometimes how advanced dental care technology continues to push in the US.
- stevenalowe 4y agoTake my money…