36 ms·
Nuclear is back on the table for a green future
- pydry 4y agoThis seems to be a barely rewritten press release on behalf of "Maria G. Korsnick, president and chief executive of the Nuclear Energy Institute, a trade group that promotes nuclear power".
- impostervt 4y agoI just finished Bill Gates' "How to Avoid a Climate Disaster". Very good book, and it makes two points (among many others): - To reduce carbon in the air, getting clean electricity is key. If we can do that, we can more easily reduce emissions from other areas. - There are no paths to clean energy by 2050 without nuclear power.
- outside1234 4y ago* No paths to nighttime clean energy without nuclear power
- shepherdjerred 4y agoThat’s the same thing
- defterGoose 4y agoYou both just said the same thing.
- BatFastard 4y agoposter added provision Nighttime energy.
- neysofu 4y agoI believe parent was making a point that the nighttime vs daytime distinction is irrelevant, because the grid never goes to to sleep. Having sufficient clean energy during daytime only is not acceptable.
- Brometheus 4y agohttps://www.e3dc.com/#Intro https://www.e3dc.com/#Intro
- tcfhgj 4y agoWhy is that?
- pfdietz 4y agoBabcock and Wilcox have gotten out of the nuclear business. What business have they gotten into? Thermal storage of grid energy with a > 50% round trip efficiency. It heats sand with a compact resistive heater, stores the sand in insulated silos, and recovers the energy by a Brayton cycle system with a really interesting and compact fluidized bed heat exchanger. Storage capacity is sized for 100 hours of operation. Not just overnight, but four days. https://www.babcock.com/home/about/corporate/news/babcock-wilcox-nrel-sign-exclusive-ip-option-agreement-for-advanced-renewable-energy-storage https://www.babcock.com/home/about/corporate/news/babcock-wi... Westinghouse is also doing thermal grid storage now. Pumped TES can have a round trip efficiency > 60%. https://www.energy-storage.news/nuclear-power-company-westinghouse-to-build-2gwh-pumped-heat-storage-in-bulgaria/ https://www.energy-storage.news/nuclear-power-company-westin...
- heretogetout 4y agoHow many GW of wind, solar, and nuclear can we bring online in the next 28 years?
- ben_w 4y agoIn 2021, we added this many new gigawatts: 183 PV[0], 100 wind[1], 7.88 nuclear (but 8.6 nuclear was also shut down)[2] 28 times that, ignoring the shutdowns (I don't actually know how long wind lasts, IIRC nuclear is "about 50-70 years" and PV is "about 30 years"), gives a total of: 5124 GW PV, 2800 GW wind, 218 GW nuclear. But that's a lower bound for PV, as that's growing with what looks like an approximately exponential long-term trend (since 1992) of 36.5% per year. While such a growth rate is physically possible to maintain for 28 years even without going into space, given that if we did make so much we wouldn't merely give everyone an American lifestyle but also be able to get the entire human population continuously flying[3], I'm assuming it will turn into a sigmoid before then. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_reactors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_rea... [3] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%28105*1.365%5E%2828%2B2021-1992%29+MW%29+%2F+10+billion https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%28105*1.365%5E%2828%2B...
- mlyle 4y agoThe thing is, 183GW from PV is like 20-30GW of nuclear, because nuclear's capacity factor is near 100% and PV's is often near 10%. Storage seems hard and expensive. We're going to need a whole lot of approaches: - Wind taking a bigger share of renewables - Whatever storage we can reasonably build, including some exotic stuff like power-to-gas-to-power. - Nuclear filling in a little bit - PV comically overbuilt and routinely throwing away a lot of power midday on most days. - Still peaking off natural gas, a little bit.
- ncmncm 4y agoRenewables' capacity factor is much greater than 10%, in practice. If you need falsehoods to make your case, you have no case.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> There are no paths to clean energy by 2050 without nuclear power. This is either stupidly wrong or stupidly right. Stupidly right, there's fairly new nuclear plants in operation that there's no real reason to shut down, so will probably be running in 2050. Stupidly wrong, it seems to be placing some entirely unwarranted implication that without nuclear we'd be lost, when most serious analysis agree that renewables will be about 80% of energy production, which doesn't really leave much room for nuclear to take all the credit. IEA's net zero roadmap: > In the net zero pathway, global energy demand in 2050 is around 8% smaller than today, but it serves an economy more than twice as big and a population with 2 billion more people. More efficient use of energy, resource efficiency and behavioural changes combine to offset increases in demand for energy services as the world economy grows and access to energy is extended to all. > Instead of fossil fuels, the energy sector is based largely on renewable energy. Two-thirds of total energy supply in 2050 is from wind, solar, bioenergy, geothermal and hydro energy. Solar becomes the largest source, accounting for one-fifth of energy supplies. Solar PV capacity increases 20-fold between now and 2050, and wind power 11-fold. > Net zero means a huge decline in the use of fossil fuels. They fall from almost four-fifths of total energy supply today to slightly over one-fifth by 2050. Fossil fuels that remain in 2050 are used in goods where the carbon is embodied in the product such as plastics, in facilities fitted with CCUS, and in sectors where low-emissions technology options are scarce. > Electricity accounts for almost 50% of total energy consumption in 2050. It plays a key role across all sectors – from transport and buildings to industry – and is essential to produce low-emissions fuels such as hydrogen. To achieve this, total electricity generation increases over two-and-a-half-times between today and 2050. At the same time, no additional new final investment decisions should be taken for new unabated coal plants, the least efficient coal plants are phased out by 2030, and the remaining coal plants still in use by 2040 are retrofitted. By 2050, almost 90% of electricity generation comes from renewable sources, with wind and solar PV together accounting for nearly 70%. Most of the remainder comes from nuclear.
- BenoitP 4y ago> most serious analysis agree that renewables will be about 80% Well, let's see them; and see how much they rely on yet to be proven industrially new storage tech (and without humongous mining activity)
- boringg 4y agoBill Gates, while wealthy and renowned for his tech contributions, has had some missteps in the climate energy space slowing down actual progress with his diversions (i.e. putting money/political will into new moon shots and saying that we don't have the technology to deal with this yet -- instead of deploying readily available technology which is ready).
- dane-pgp 4y ago> instead of deploying readily available technology Well there's no opportunity for him to make inflated profits off a technology that he can't patent... https://www.wired.com/story/opinion-the-world-loses-under-bill-gates-vaccine-colonialism/ https://www.wired.com/story/opinion-the-world-loses-under-bi...
- ncmncm 4y agoBill Gates has not, in fact, been responsible for tech contributions. His effect has been balefully negative, from the get-go. He is personally responsible for "have you tried turning it off and on again?". Before MS, that was plenty of reason to demand a refund.
- jeffbee 4y agoI know HN is just desperate for that i-told-you-so moment when fission rises from irrelevancy to save us all from climate change, but it's just not going to happen. Look at this figure [1]. The amount of proposed solar and wind and battery projects in the United States at the end of 2021 was 1000s of time larger than the amount of proposed nuclear power projects. And one big difference is the renewables are actually built, while the fission projects never make progress. Fission's purported resurgence is a press release blitz being coordinated by defense contractor grifters who have no higher ambitions than raking a few tens of billions of dollars in consulting fees out of government budgets. 1: https://emp.lbl.gov/queues https://emp.lbl.gov/queues
- mikece 4y agoI would love to see nuclear be far more of the base-load production in the US, but rather than large gigawatt-scale reactors I think it would benefit everyone more if we moved to using SMRs (small modular reactors). Not only could manufacturing economies of scale be realized but SMRs can passively cool themselves in the event they need to scram or shut down. The scenario that concerns me the most is a terrorist attack on our grid and externally on a nuclear power station: if a plant can be scrammed AND the backup diesels sabotaged then pretty much all nuclear plants in the US would be looking at a Fukushima-like event once the batteries to the primary cooling loop ran out. Nuclear is definitely a good idea for the future, but only if SMRs are the basis of moving forward.
- politician 4y agoA Rolls Royce (SMR) for every community! [1] https://www.rolls-royce.com/innovation/small-modular-reactors.aspx https://www.rolls-royce.com/innovation/small-modular-reactor...
- VBprogrammer 4y agoI think your perception of the risk from terrorist attack on a Nuclear power plant and the actual risk involved are out of whack. Especially given that human error is a much more likely source a radioactive leak.
- rectang 4y agoThe fundamental problem is the concentration of radioactive materials at a single facility. (Hydroelectric power has a similar problem with the water behind dams.) Whether it's human error, terrorist attack, or natural disaster, nuclear facilities are vulnerable in a way that solar and wind facilities are not.
- Shadonototra 4y ago"American"'s nuclear energy is back on the Table for a Green Future years of anti-nuclear propaganda all over EU past decade, thanks Germany, only to end up depending on the US even more, while boycotting their friend France
- iammru 4y agoGood. It's the most logical choice to complement other green initiatives.
- ZetaZero 4y agoNo paywall https://dnyuz.com/2022/06/15/nuclear-is-back-on-the-table-for-a-green-future/ https://dnyuz.com/2022/06/15/nuclear-is-back-on-the-table-fo...
- photochemsyn 4y agoFunny article in that it doesn't discuss lifecycle costs. A side-by-side comparison of the cost of grids powered by nuclear power plant relative to those powered by wind/solar/storage is what I'd expect to see from a 'paper of record' like the NYTimes. Except in some specific cases (Finland, other Arctic regions with long periods of low sunlight) I'm pretty sure this cost comparison comes down firmly on the side of wind/solar/storage. Storage is the main cost barrier for 100% renewable-powered grids, but this is also an area where technological development is possible. Much of the discussion of energy in the American media is pretty poor these days. For example, the solar tariff issue on China sourced PV - there are simply no US companies making panels of comparable quality (monocrystalline Si lasts longer and is more efficient). Concepts like requiring Chinese manufacturers to open factories in the USA if they want to sell in US markets would make sense but probably would violate some trade provision or other. Another factor that this article should have mentioned is the reliability of the global uranium ore -> fuel rods supply chain. Costs vary significantly based on the purity of the ore (18% is the top, 0.1% is the economically viable limit) and like oil, uranium ore is not globally distributed (unlike sunlight and wind). As far as Russia/Ukraine, the real agenda the US government seems to be pushing there is using that conflict to rapidly increase LNG exports to Europe from the US West/South coast, even though energy prices are spiking due to inflation (and plausibly due to exports of crude oil from the USA, allowed under that 2015 bill lifting that restriction). A far better plan for Europe would be to go 100% renewable asap, meaning no need for fossil fuel imports from any party. Yes, that's technologically possible, but would require massive economic investment.
- nonethewiser 4y agoSunlight and wind distribution is quite uneven.
- adrianN 4y agoUranium ore distribution is also quite uneven. Fossil fuel distribution is also quite uneven.
- 4y ago
- nonethewiser 4y agoSmall distributed reactors sound great, but don't they exacerbate the waste disposal problem? I think the logistics and politics would be easier to manage if the waste production was highly centralized.
- philwelch 4y agoAs long as the deployment of nuclear power is large and growing in scale, there's zero waste disposal problem, because all of the long-lived wastes can be reprocessed into fuel using breeder reactors.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI think the idea is that you'd have something like 10 100 MW reactors enclosed in a single facility rather than 1 1000 MW reactor in that facility. You'd probably put all the hot fuel rods in a single cooling pond in that scenario. Security for such a facility would be less expensive than having to manage 10 plants scattered acrooss a wide region, as well. Note that provision of cooling water is also a major issue in all these designs. Whether or not this would be cheaper overall is anyone's guess. There are also questions about the reliability and efficiency of small modular reactors in general; past novel nuclear reactor designs like the pebble-bed reactor were similarly promoted but never went anywhere.
- ncmncm 4y agoMultiplying the number of moving parts by 10x cannot reasonably be expected to lead to increased reliability or reduced cost.
- goodpoint 4y agoNot to mention nuclear proliferation and risks of terrorism or social unrest...
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoPlease can the nuclear industry stop paying PR consultants. We have one use for the nuclear industry - building scientists who can then build nuclear bombs. IMO this is a reasonable use of public funds - the strategic needs of nuclear weapons are not going away. But please please just accept that and move on. Stop getting in a vital public debate. Nuclear fission is a terrible civilian technology - vastly expensive, the effects of a catastrophic failure are massive and the costs to avoid it (yes you can build safe nuclear plants) are huge - basically nuclear projects need to be on the A game - all the time, year after year, constantly upgrading and improving for decades to come. I might believe that for five or six plants run to just build weapons. But i refuse to believe we can build 1,000s of the fuckers in every country on earth and think that they will be all maintained to standards better than Fukijyma
- gfodor 4y agoChina is going to do it, and you seem to believe the safety profile of nuclear energy technology has been frozen for 50 years. It's extremely strange to think something as broad as the process of nuclear fission can be spoken about as having a universal, never changing risk-profile, regardless of technological advancement. We don't do this for any other technology. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-11-02/china-climate-goals-hinge-on-440-billion-nuclear-power-plan-to-rival-u-s https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-11-02/china-cli...
- rectang 4y agoThe fundamentals of that risk profile haven't changed — you still have high concentration of radioactive materials in a single geographic location. The risk profile for nuclear is unlike that of other technologies. They told us it was safe back then. They tell us its safe today. They will always tell us it's safe. The fundamentals tell us they're wrong.
- gfodor 4y ago"The fundamentals" is doing a lot of work there. It's fundamentally unsafe to move at a high velocity in a meat-based body. Does this mean the risk profile of high speed transportation is invariant across technology? The "fundamentals" you speak of boil down to the first principles analysis, based on physics, of the possible states a nuclear energy production system can get into. This is not invariant with regards to technology. It seems far too reductive to claim "putting radiocative materials together in the same location" should box out all civilian use of a energy production mechanism.
- stakkur 4y agoI'm reminded of the software world, where 'interim' or 'just ship it now and adjust later' actions lead to...technical debt and often worse. I feel nuclear creates the mother of all technical debt.
- unchocked 4y agoI will hazard that the problems with nuclear are not technological but political, and the economic problems with nuclear are there because of political reasons. France gets ~75% of its power from nuclear, safely and economically. France inhabits the same physical world as the rest of us, but is different politically. If there were a will, there would be a way. If the environmental movement had paid more attention to James Hansen's testimony in 1989 than it did to Chernobyl in 1986 then we would be living in a different world. There is no amount of damage from nuclear accidents that will be worse than what we are suffering from climate change, with no end in sight. Proliferation is another story, but how's that going anyway...?
- adrianN 4y agoFrance is currently not building enough reactors to replace those that will need to be shut down due to age in the near future. They would need to build a lot more if they wanted to satisfy demand for heating and transportation. I assume they have good reasons not to build more reactors.
- Jorge1o1 4y agoThe reasons are political… just like in the United States. HBO with their Chernobyl miniseries single-handedly undid years of progress in the perception of nuclear energy.
- jlkuester7 4y ago> HBO with their Chernobyl miniseries single-handedly undid years of progress Wait, seriously? That miniseries was not perfect, but I thought it did a pretty good job of pointing out the issues with Chernobyl were largely political and not technical. (Sure the RBMK reactors were flawed, that is a technical issue. But the only reason that escalated into a disaster was due to gross mismanagement and flagrant disregard of safety systems...)
- rectang 4y ago
- Simplicitas 4y agoStunning how many well-informed people here are still so distrustful of nuclear energy despite all the advancements.
- amelius 4y agoNot surprising. Software development has advanced, yet every day somewhere some piece of software crashes.
- neysofu 4y agoYou can't say the same about reactors, it's a weak comparison.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drewvolpe 4y agoPeople are irrationally concerned about low-probability but high severity risks, which is what nuclear is. The chance of someone in the US dying from a terrorist attack is about 1 out of 3 million. It's a rounding error compared with heart disease (1:6), suicide (1:93), storms (1:35k) or even sunstroke (1:6k). Yet, the US spends $52B / year on the department of homeland security.
- ncmncm 4y agoPeople are rationally distrustful of habitual dishonesty, corruption, and gross negligence at industrial scale.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- k__ 4y agoI recently saw a good evaluation of nuclear power by Hossenfelder. https://youtube.com/watch?v=0kahih8RT1k https://youtube.com/watch?v=0kahih8RT1k
- rib3ye 4y agoHere is a 2016 map of Nuclear power plants operating and under construction. https://www.carbonbrief.org/mapped-the-worlds-nuclear-power-plants/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/mapped-the-worlds-nuclear-power-... Some things I found interesting: Under development: 11 in China, 3 in US Operating: Over 40 in the US and no major accidents since Three Mile Island (1979).
- ncmncm 4y agoThe US ones, anyway, will be cancelled. Each dollar poured down the rathole first, diverted from renewable build-out, brings climate catastrophe nearer. That has thus far not stoped the pouring.
- notJim 4y agoThis appears to be out of date. Watts Bar 2 [1] is completed and operating. Summer 2-3 were cancelled [2]. Sounds like Vogtle is getting close to coming online [3] 1: https://www.tva.com/newsroom/watts-bar-2-project https://www.tva.com/newsroom/watts-bar-2-project 2: https://www.chooseenergy.com/news/article/failed-v-c-summer-nuclear-project-timeline https://www.chooseenergy.com/news/article/failed-v-c-summer-... 3: https://www.southerncompany.com/innovation/vogtle-3-and-4.html https://www.southerncompany.com/innovation/vogtle-3-and-4.ht...
- traveler01 4y agoDon't know how germans thought that closing down nuclear plants in favor of natural gas was a good idea, both politically and environmentally
- loeg 4y agoTheir electorate is very anti-nuclear (it made sense politically).
- lelag 4y agoThinking about it makes me mad. For all their renewable production capacity they still average over 300g of CO2 / kwh with all the gas and coal they burn. All of it, credit to the german green movement trying to save the planet from... Not sure. Even assuming the occasional Chernobyl/Fukushima-level disaster, as terrible as those catastrophes are, nuclear plant accidents are localised and will never threaten mankind survival. Climate change IS threatening our future, however. And don't get me started on the political cost which the news make so obvious now.
- Brometheus 4y ago/remindme 10years
- lelag 4y ago/remindme in 80 years If I have to choose between an additional 3 Fukushima and the loss of thousands of costal cities due to sea level rise, I know what I'm choosing. This study predict than sea level could rise by 2m by 2100 displacing up to 187 million people. Fukushima displaced about 160 thousands. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6561295/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6561295/ Pick your poison, wisely.
- thehappypm 4y agoIt’s probably easier to deal with sea level rise since it’s slow motion. If there’s a Fukushima every year.. wow.
- neonsunset 4y ago
- neonsunset 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoHistorical lifecycle costs for nuclear plants are perhaps not useful for comparison. Newer reactor plans are drastically different.
- ncmncm 4y agoNot in cost. A very substantial part of opex is maintaining the steam turbines, a cost not matched by any in renewables. Thus, even completely ignoring monstrous capex, fuel and waste handling, indemnity subsidy, and decommissioning costs, nukes cannot compete.
- jnsaff2 4y agoI recently read the Serhii Plokhy book Atoms and Ashes, where he discusses 6 most notable nuclear accidents in depth. And his conclusion was pretty grim. Paraphrasing: If we bet on nuclear for mitigation of climate change, it is inevitable that nuclear accidents will happen more often. Also each accident causes a major setback in peoples minds regarding nuclear safety and the next Fukushima might kill off a lot of progress and the opportunity cost lost would be huge. I don't know how to argue with this. I personally think nuclear is really safe. If the worst accidents have killed a few hundred and caused premature deaths to at most hundreds of thousands. Compared to the millions of premature deaths PER YEAR for fossil related energy and the possible billions coming from climate change, nuclear is as safe as it gets (I mean probably more PV installers will fall off roofs than get killed by nuclear accidents), but peoples fears might not be surmountable.
- londons_explore 4y agoAll it takes is for a few newspapers to regularly publish alongside any article about any power source the figures of "X people died per year by nuclear, Y by solar, Z by coal", etc. Any newspaper mogul could make that happen. Any time there is any accident, people interviewed need to start with "There is a risk this incident might stop nuclear from being the safest energy source. But to be honest, I think we'll still keep the crown".
- tptacek 4y agoIt sounds like the argument presented here is that if we actually use nuclear power, there will be more accidents, which will cost us the opportunity of actually using nuclear power.
- ncmncm 4y agoEach accident saves us from building more nukes than would have been built otherwise. The benefit has probably been well worth their costs.
- zosima 4y agoThere is quite clearly not even remotely 100.000 premature deaths from Chernobyl. The only cancer that clearly went up in immediate connection to Chernobyl was thyroid cancer, and that was in most cases very treatable. It's also unclear how much of the increase in incidence, was due to increased screening. Thyroid cancer seems to have affected the general population, but in a dose-dependent manner, where the increased risk became really low when looking outside the cleaning crew. On top of that there is some evidence to suggest that the risk of leukemia and other blood cancers increased in the cleaning crew. (But still really low numbers). And as far as I know no signs of increased blood cancer rate was seen in the general population. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28929329/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28929329/ It actually appears that the largest loss of human life from Chernobyl happened because of panic. Women chose abortion because of the perceived increased risk of malformation in offspring. As far as I am aware, the actual increased risk of malformations has not been detectable, and I presume it to be negligible. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8516187/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8516187/ https://www.vice.com/en/article/ywyqzv/why-hundreds-of-thousands-of-women-ended-their-pregnancies-after-chernobyl https://www.vice.com/en/article/ywyqzv/why-hundreds-of-thous...
- zosima 4y agoThe biggest problem nuclear has is that it's too cheap and the fuel lasts too long. That means that the oil, gas, wind and solar industry has more money and interest in spreading FUD. On top of that the fear that has been succesfully deployed, has pushed nuclear energy into a bureaucratic nightmare, driving up costs, and also incentivizing a large part of the nuclear industry (the part living off the regulation and bureaucracy) to continue the FUD. The total number of causalities and environmental impact from non-weaponized nuclear power, including Chernobyl, Fukushima and three mile island are so small, that I guess a larger number of people have died or been injured from rare-earth metal mines for solar panels or floods due to dams for water turbines.
- sirmike_ 4y ago
- losvedir 4y agoOne thing I don't understand is the uninhabitable zone around Chernobyl is not that big, and the U.S. has plenty of space. And electricity can be transmitted decently far, right? So... is it unreasonable to have lots of fairly low-regulated nuclear power plants in, say, 50 mile uninhabited areas (maybe even make it a nature preserve or something for animals)? And if one or two meltdown, oh well?
- mwint 4y agoProbably the issue is that access to water (for cooling) correlates highly with access to water (for human civilization).
- philwelch 4y agoThe Chernobyl power plant did not have a containment building around the reactors until after the meltdown. Every Western nuclear power plant has a containment building around the reactors. That's the single biggest factor.
- ncmncm 4y agoTMI and Fukushima had containment, for all the good it did.
- Vecr 4y agoIt did a lot of good? TMI slagged the core but the containment held, and Fukushima's cores (the ones that melted, obviously) was still mostly covered, the hydrogen explosion was the major problem.
- ncmncm 4y agoTMI vented a very large amount of radioactive krypton. (Given its density, it would better be described as dumped to the river, where it spread out along the banks downstream, gassing riverfront neighborhoods.) Fukushima's containment exploded in hydrogen detonations, and vented a great deal of radioisotopes. They are today flushing tritium to the ocean, which seems wasteful; we will want the 3He that decays to.
- dehrmann 4y agoI could never take climate change seriously when nuclear wasn't on the table. If climate change were really a concern, you'd consider a power source that's safer than coal, but has negligible CO2 emissions (mining). I'm glad to see people are taking it seriously.
- ncmncm 4y agoNo. When it is a choice between spending 5x plus buying coal for another decade, or spending 1x and displacing carbon immediately, the correct choice is dead obvious, and getting moreso with each passing day as the 5x shades toward 6x and beyond, relentlessly.
- pfdietz 4y agoThat used to be a valid argument.
- TradingPlaces 4y agoNukes are expensive and take many years to build. No reason to shut them down, but also not a lot of good reasons to build them.
- ncmncm 4y agoSpending to keep them operating diverts money from building out renewables. So, no.
- TedShiller 4y agoNuclear is great as long as it’s not anywhere close to where I live
- katz_ 4y agoNuclear is necessary for the near term. And it’s already a mature technology
- ncmncm 4y ago"Mature" means its cost is not falling, while the competition has already plummeted far below, without slowing. So, your opinion about nukes' necessity will have zero effect on outcome. The rest of the world will act on cost, to even your benefit.
- 99_00 4y ago
- goodpoint 4y agoIt's appalling how these conversation on HN are made of people endlessly repeating only a handful of pros and cons. No progress in the conversation and no discussion of more subtle aspects, like centralization of control/power, systemic risk, nuclear proliferation etc.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe most reliable output of the nuke industry has always been dishonesty. It is a big chore countering it everywhere it blooms.
- goodpoint 4y agoIt's an intrinsic problem of any activity with a combination of huge financial interests, concentration of power, secrecy, national pride (and the ability to create invisible pollution).
- johngalt 4y agoThe near future looks like Solar + Natural gas. Driven entirely by economic factors. It is cheap to build PV, and Natural Gas plants cost less than sufficient batteries/storage for PV. I used to be very bullish on Nuclear. The numbers just don't pencil out in the US under the current constraints. We would need a vast reduction in the overhead to build a Nuclear plant, or a vast increase in the costs of the alternatives.
- ncmncm 4y agoNatural gas will soon be too expensive to extract, as ammonia synthesis at $0 opex undercuts it.
- bullen 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayLxB9fV2y4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayLxB9fV2y4
- synergy20 4y agoBest news for the day, I'm a firm believer that nuclear is the _only_ way for true green energy on earth at scale. it's a manageable risk(checking out what France is doing) and there is simply no other _true_ alternatives.
- NickChasanis 4y ago
- redtriumph 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220615121046/https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/15/business/dealbook-dc-climate-task-force.html https://web.archive.org/web/20220615121046/https://www.nytim...
- systemBuilder 4y agoIt's not that we don't have nuclear power plants, nuclear fuel, and nuclear technology. One problem is that France's nuclear industry has committments to use something like 2/3rds of the world's reserves of Uranium Ore. Another problem is, we've had 3 once-in-1000 years accidents in 40 years. By my calculations, the entire world will be a radioactive waste dump in 250,000 years, given the rate of land contamination by nuclear accidents. Why do nuclear cheerleaders ignore this fact? They must.
- simonCGN 4y agoNuclear energy is by far the most expensive form of energy. Also, the nuclear waste problem remains unresolved.
- AngryData 4y agoEveryone arguing over replacing currently energy usage like that will be even close to enough, it won't. Personally im a nuclear fan and I think many of the costs are artificially high by preventing nuclear industry growth and bad legislation that outlaws things like breeder reactors, that said we are going to need wind and solar even with massive nuclear investment just by the total power we need to produce to make industry green. Electricity generation isn't the only way we use fossil fuels and cause pollution. Fertilizer production needs hydrogen, where does that hydrogen come from? Natural gas. Why? Because not using natural gas increases the energy costs of fertilizer production near 10x over. Since it is currently 1% of total world electricity consumption already, that is a near 10% global increase in electricity demand for one (admitedly large) product. The replacement of plastics with other materials like paper, glass, and metal? All require higher energy input to produce than plastic. Not to mention that plastic will eventually breakdown and release carbon also. As the most economical mines start to dry up and we seek lesser ores to mine, mining and processing electrical requirements will continue to rise. Nearly every chemical reagent all around you causes pollution during products, but it can be 90% solved, mostly by the addition of more electrical electricity for heating, cooling, high and low pressure chambers, ect. to not create so many waste products that we trash into both the atmosphere and the ground and water. We don't use those cleaner methods now mostly because using the electricity to do so costs a LOT more. Nearly every industry on earth can be cleaner, but it costs significantly more electricity which needs to be fairly cheap. Something like concrete production could be done more far more cleanly, but again, massive amounts of additional electricity needed. And that is before we get into things like active carbon sequestering. Or goals shouldn't be a direct replacement of fossil fuel electricity sources, our goals should be exceeding currently world electrical output multiple times over without fossil fuels, which means we should be producing nuclear, solar, wind, hydro, and geothermal power across the board in an attempt to meet our extreme future demands. Maybe solar and wind and batteries will be up to the task in the future with some new technology, but also maybe not. Nuclear is a known feasible solution to providing as much power as we could ever want or need with technology we have right now. Solar and battery tech is often assuming we will continue on the same path of increased efficiency and reduced costs seemingly indefinitely, but you know what, they thought the same thing with nuclear energy until they started hitting some walls in generation efficiency and costs. And if it ends up not being significantly cheaper or easier, you gotta start bringing up questions of land usage and grid complexity on top of everything else.
- at_a_remove 4y agoWhether you think nuclear is a good idea or a bad idea, too costly or a price we will have to pay, one thing I can say is true: we have spent so very much time and effort demonizing nuclear power that if it were a good idea, we're going to have a lot of people standing in the way, because the message was received, loud and clear.
- phs318u 4y agoI'll take this seriously when proponents of nuclear energy are happy to invest in the absence of something like the Price-Anderson Nuclear Industries Indemnity Act (TL;DR - the act socialises any costs above $15B for insurable events). Until then, any discussion of costs is apples to oranges. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear_Industries_Indemnity_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear...
- credit_guy 4y agoSolar and wind have a storage problem. Day-to-night storage is a solved problem, but summer-to-winter is very far from being solved. Batteries, pumped hydro, flywheels, compressed air are simply off by factors of 100x or more. There are just 2 plausible solutions: chemical storage, or massive overcapacity. Chemical storage means hydrogen, or ammonia, or iron powder, or some other substance that can undergo reversible oxidation. But you have capital costs associated with both the oxidation and the reverse reaction, and you also have roundtrip losses. For example, let's say you use hydrogen (by far the most promising candidate as of now). You need to build a plant to perform the water electrolysis and a power plant to convert the hydrogen into electricity. Both these plants will work at most half of the time, but in reality, much less. So, whatever capital costs you have for an electrolysis plant, you just double, triple, or multiply by 10. The same for the hydrogen power plant. A hydrogen power plant will cost at least as much as a current natural gas power plant. That is not a lot, but if you multiply by 5, then it becomes a lot. But what if you could run these plants 100% of the time. Now we are talking. Let's say you build lots of solar capacity in Morocco, run an electrolysis plant year long, liquefy it, ship it to Germany, where it is burned in a power plant 365/24/7. Or make the hydrogen in Australia and ship it to Japan. Or make it in Nevada and ship it to New York and Toronto. Do you still need nuclear? I'm not 100% sure. But if lots of people who were against nuclear before changed their mind, then maybe they ran the numbers, and it turns out we need nuclear. But it's certain we need nuclear if we ever want to explore the outer solar system. And if we climb again the knowledge ladder of commercial nuclear fission, then maybe one day we'll be able to make efficient nuclear rockets.
- p1necone 4y ago> massive overcapacity How bad of a solution is this? How bad does solar/hydro output get during the off season in most places (presumably wind is more consistent than those two when averaged out over shorter time frames than a whole year)?
- credit_guy 4y agoTake a look at this chart with monthly solar electricity generation in Germany [1]. In June there's 6 times more solar generation than in December. That's it, if you want to build enough solar capacity to cover you in December, then it's going to be 6 times more than you need in June. Solar might be cheaper than natural gas, but not by a factor of 6. [1] https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/monthly-generation-of-solar-pv-in-germany https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/monthly-gener...
- egberts1 4y agoIt is either nuclear or hydroelectric power. The only two near-zero-carbon options.
- amai 4y agoNuclear fission is dead and won't come back to life even if Bill Gates spends his entire fortune to market it. I'd rather bet my money on nuclear fusion than nuclear fission, e.g. https://marvelfusion.com/technology/ https://marvelfusion.com/technology/
- amai 4y agoNucular, the word is nucular!
- Jistern 4y ago
- dang 4y agoCould you please stop breaking the site guidelines, such as with flamebait posts, ideological battle, and personal attacks? It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for. We ban that sort of account, and you've unfortunately been doing a lot of this already. (Incidentally, this doesn't have to do with your views—I don't even know what they are. You've just clearly not been using HN as intended, and that's already a problem.) If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.