24 ms·
VSCodium – Free/Libre Open Source Software Binaries of VS Code
- Grimburger 4y agoSadly the remote ssh and a few other MS extensions don't work with VSCodium
- tpmx 4y agoThat one is closed source. It's kind of oddly designed - it ssh:es in to the remote host to download some binary from MS servers, executes it and then communicates with it using SSH TCP forwarding.
- lozenge 4y ago"Some binary" = the same version of VS Code (maybe without Electron and some other parts). Makes sense as you need to - edit files, run tasks and terminals, and run extensions which access the remote filesystem (eg Jump To Definition taking you to header files installed in system folders) - basically everything you need VS Code to do when you run it locally. The alternative would be running VS Code as a webserver remotely and the local VS Code Electron just acting like a browser window pointing at your server. It probably wouldn't feel as responsive.
- tpmx 4y agoOr just use the SFTP parts of the SSH protocol. Enabled in openssh by default.
- lozenge 4y agoDoes SFTP let you launch processes? And if so, which ones are you going to launch - are you going to use system grep to implement searching the open folder? There's a lot of different versions of grep out there!
- tpmx 4y agoThe SSH protocol lets you exec processes on the remote host. https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc4254#section-6.5 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc4254#section-6.5
- misterdata 4y agoThe alternative is actually possible and works reasonably well from the browser: https://github.com/coder/code-server https://github.com/coder/code-server
- zamalek 4y agoI hadn't considered that option, thanks for the tip. I'm currently on Silverblue and that basically mandates the SSH extension.
- shp0ngle 4y agoAs other mentioned - it actually runs the whole VSCode remotely.
- skohan 4y agoGood reason to stay away from those extensions!
- bmitc 4y agoIs there an actual reason or just "reasons"? Because those extensions are extremely useful and enabling. I honestly am not sure how to live without them at this point. I use all three of the remote development extensions on a daily basis. https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/remote/remote-overview https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/remote/remote-overview
- dx034 4y agoThey do work with Code-Server (VSCode in Browser) though, which also works on top of the open source parts of VSCode if I'm correct? I wonder how that worked. Code-Server works surprisingly well anyways, but with VSCode built on Electron I guess it's not that much of a surprise.
- Havoc 4y ago>remote ssh That was my first thought too - the majority of the value I get out of VS is via this. Though I believe there is another IDE that has similar...forgot which one. So at least not a monopoly
- IshKebab 4y agoIntelliJ added remote development support a while ago but I've not tried it. I think their new Fleet IDE probably supports it too.
- mekster 4y agoFleet is still at pre alpha stage.
- RealStickman_ 4y agoEmacs! :)
- pxc 4y agoThe way the VSCode extension works (doesn't just rely on SFTP to sync files and doesn't require anything to be preinstalled on the remote server) is closest to Transparent Remote Access, Multiple Protocols in Emacs. Emacs' version is more flexible and a little more quirky. I would guess that like many VSCode features, Emacs was the inspiration here. https://www.emacswiki.org/emacs/TrampMode https://www.emacswiki.org/emacs/TrampMode Tons of IDEs and editors have SFTP sync plugins that can work sort of automatically, but that's pretty different.
- xigoi 4y agoI guess Vim with the built-in netrw plugin could qualify?
- justsomeguy123 4y agoSo glad this exists. It took people quite some time to group up for this. I find it... borderline immoral to have an open source product and then have binaries contain telemetry and other stuff that's not in the main tree. But, hey, we couldn't expect Microsoft not to muddy the waters a bit.
- mekster 4y ago> borderline immoral Who are you to say about the moral? They've poured millions and millions of dollars into it and telemetry is there partly to make it a better product and what you do is talk about moral and expectations?
- WalterGR 4y agoFirst submission about it is from four years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17850960 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17850960
- justsomeguy123 4y agoI know VSCodium isn't new but VSCode was released in 2015, so it took the community about 3 years to form.
- fathyb 4y agoJust to clarify, the code for the telemetry is open, it's the configuration with the endpoints that's not on the main tree.
- eterevsky 4y agoI don't see how it is immoral at all. It's not like they are adding some malware in the binary. From the sound of it, the only "closed" part is configuration, like the endpoints for telemetry API. As far as I am concerned, telemetry is a good thing. Unless you are very paranoid, I don't see a good reason to disable it. Telemetry makes it possible for your usage patterns to influence the development of the product, which is beneficial for you as a user.
- polskibus 4y agoWhat is non free about MS vscode ?
- mirekrusin 4y agoFreedom from telemetry/tracking and license on released binary.
- ville 4y agoBut telemetry can be disabled with a single setting? "telemetry.telemetryLevel": "off"
- dijit 4y agoWhy is it, when people have legitimate complaints about something on hacker news (in this case the fact that what is delivered as a binary is not what you see as source code), people are so quick to side with the tool for being trustable? How do you know that flag does anything except attempt to hide sending of telemetry? Or not even that, simply logging that you would prefer not to have telemetry taken. The EULA explicitly forbids you from attempting to reverse engineer the binary, so you’re literally taking this on blind faith. Don’t you find that troubling? Even if Microsoft didn’t have a murky track record with telemetry in their operating system (being randomly turned back on or never being completely turned off): the default position should never be to trust. Trust is earned.
- glogla 4y ago> Why is it, when people have legitimate complaints about something on hacker news (in this case the fact that what is delivered as a binary is not what you see as source code), people are so quick to side with the tool for being trustable? Corporate bootlicking.
- jterrys 4y agoI'll be straightforward and say that as a whole, I do not trust an operating system in which one of the first configurable options it presents me are whether I want to toggle my 'advertising ID' on or off. As a result, quite honestly, I wouldn't trust any product produced by that company.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoConsidering MS ownership of github, I wonder if at some point will using VS Code with telemetry feed copilot.
- weikju 4y agoI’m in the camp of those who aren’t waiting until it’s too late and avoid vscode
- dx034 4y agoI guess it always depends on how much you value the IP of your code. But for many projects, I find Copilot too valuable to avoid it because of telemetry/privacy reasons. And I guess if you work on anything open source, leakage of source code isn't a concern anyway.
- perfopt 4y agoWhat do you use instead? What is a good editor (with the functions of VSCode) for Rust and Python? vi/vim is nice but I find the convenience of VSCode - auto complete, show inf doc etc - very useful
- weberer 4y agoPycharm is really great. https://www.jetbrains.com/pycharm/ https://www.jetbrains.com/pycharm/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bayindirh 4y agoYou can always use Eclipse, Kate, Sublime Text, BBEdit depending on your OS and preferences.
- nicoburns 4y agoSublime Text or IntelliJ’s IDEs are probably the most direct replacements.
- cabirum 4y agoIs telemetry.telemetryLevel=off not enough? The setting claims it completely disables all telemetry.
- gabrielgio 4y agoThe binary license is different, and you can't reverse-engineer it. So it comes to whether you trust MS or not, which does not cut for some people that would like to run or trust only FOSS software.
- car_analogy 4y ago> The binary license is different, and you can't reverse-engineer it. Why not?
- gabrielgio 4y agoBecause the binary is under EULA, so you are not allowed to do so: https://code.visualstudio.com/license https://code.visualstudio.com/license > You may not reverse engineer, decompile or disassemble the software, or otherwise attempt to derive the source code for the software Check `5. SCOPE OF LICENSE.` VSCodium fixes that, it removes all the proprietary bites and branding. The only downside is that, as far as I know, you can't access a plethora of tooling that would require the proprietary bits.
- car_analogy 4y agoIf they don't want us to find out what their software does (the definition of reverse-engineering), it's safe to assume it's malicious, or will be. Edit: In other words, if you bought a sandwich, and the EULA for that sandwich forbade you from examining what's in it, how it was prepared, and what effects it has on you health - would you eat that sandwich?
- zasdffaa 4y agoMic-ro-soft - enough said
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- numlock86 4y agoSo this is Code-OSS with a different release/binary license?
- Iolaum 4y agoI think VSCodium is a successor of code-oss.
- Jamie9912 4y agoHow does it handle settings sync?
- alg0rith 4y agoIt doesn't.
- teekert 4y agoBut, no remote-ssh, which I live in :(
- bayindirh 4y agoMount the remote system via another tool, and show VSCode that path to work with?
- bmitc 4y agoThe remote developer extensions in Visual Studio Code allow you to run VS Code as if it's on that machine. So, the integrated terminal, file system, and all VS Code extensions all behave as if they're on the remote computer (because they are).
- bayindirh 4y agoAh, like Eclipse's RDT toolset, gotcha. Thanks.
- bmitc 4y agoThe killer feature really is the fact that your extensions work seamlessly on the remote computer. Without the little tag in the bottom left showing you where you're at (on your local machine, a container, or a remote machine), there's basically little that lets you know you're on a different computer aside from some hints (like the terminal's available). https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/remote/remote-overview https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/remote/remote-overview It really is quite nice, especially for things like containers, WSL, or headless development on something like a Raspberry Pi.
- bayindirh 4y agoEclipse has a similar feature called RDT for a very long time. It can either work over standard SSH or via its own userspace daemon. I don't remember how it works in detail, but if my memory serves me well, you develop the code locally, and it pushes it and builds it there, and runs it. At the end of the day, you use your Eclipse installation on the local system, but develop at the remote system transparently. I've used it 5-6 years ago, but didn't use it recently since I didn't need it. However, it's a very mature system and doesn't limit what extensions or plugins you use. It's just an overlay. I'm using Eclipse since its inception, and probably won't migrate away ever, but it's nice to see alternatives. Also, I'd never touch VSCode due to plethora of reasons, but these are my own reasons and this comment box is not the right place for them.
- RektBoy 4y agoWho even use VScode professionally? I'm still waiting for multi-monitor window support, which not gonna happen, IIUIC. Mentioned this in VScode subreddit, I got downvoted to hell, because clearly nobody needs IDE's windows in different monitors.
- 3np 4y agoSounds like something that should be handled by your WM. Expecting your IDE to handle "multi-monitor support" (precisely what functionality are you even expecting here..?) sounds less professional, if anything :P
- lozenge 4y agoI think they mean tearing an editor (or other panel) out into another window to move to their other monitor. Currently you can open another window, but it comes with its own explorer, terminal, problems, test runner, etc. Soon you'll have the same file opened twice in different screens, and... bleh.
- dx034 4y agoBut you can just drag it across two screens and divide it up along the border? From my experience that works fine as long as your screens have the same resolution.
- lozenge 4y agoTrue, you can divide the editor into two (or more) splits, and also divide the bottom part (Terminal/Debug Console/Problems). If you're the type that doesn't move windows around often, that could work.
- sjnsjks 4y agoPerhaps there is some hidden configuration for this. But did you try to have separate windows of vscode on monitors with different DPI or set different scale manually? There is a shared thing going on between running instances. I can't have one window 100% and other 150%.
- tmdh 4y agoWhat's the difference between this and code-oss?
- Shadonototra 4y agopeople like to hear my findings about shady stuff? despite this existing, the raspberry people chose to add microsoft's repo overnight, to offer vscode https://www.cyberciti.biz/linux-news/heads-up-microsoft-repo-secretly-installed-on-all-raspberry-pis-linux-os/ https://www.cyberciti.biz/linux-news/heads-up-microsoft-repo...
- IshKebab 4y agoWhat's shady about that?
- eterevsky 4y agoI'm not sure why I should trust VSCodium more than I trust Microsoft. There were supply chain attacks coming from open source community and none that I can think of coming from Microsoft.
- shp0ngle 4y agoI mean, you can re-build it yourself, in docker https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium/blob/master/docs/build.md https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium/blob/master/docs/build.... But I think you can also just build VSCode itself yourself. (But, I am not sure if that still doesn't have some non-free parts.) https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/wiki/How-to-Contribute#build-and-run https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/wiki/How-to-Contribute#b...
- tristan957 4y agoMicrosoft isn't using node modules from NPM?
- mekster 4y agoWho has more resource?
- topspin 4y ago> none that I can think of coming from Microsoft Would a supply chain attack on Microsoft be worse than the damage Microsoft itself does? Actual data loss has occurred via Microsoft updates.
- My70thaccount 4y ago
- spicysugar 4y agoFor me, Vscodium Logo >>> VSCode Logo
- ayushnix 4y agoI stopped using Code-OSS and Vscodium after this bug. For the longest time, the "solutions" suggested in that issue tracker were disabling CORS validation. https://github.com/eclipse/openvsx/issues/306 https://github.com/eclipse/openvsx/issues/306
- ghuntley 4y agoHey folks, Geoff here from Gitpod. Very pleased to see there continues to be strong interest in open (and FOSS) software development tooling. VSCodium uses the OpenVSX registry (which Gitpod folks created) because the VS Market place is proprietary and can only be connected to from official Visual Studio branded products. If you can't find an extension when using VSCodium then please send a pull-request to this repository https://github.com/open-vsx/publish-extensions https://github.com/open-vsx/publish-extensions with the identifier and that will help grow the ecosystem of open tooling. ICMYI - We blogged more about this over at: - https://www.gitpod.io/blog/cloud-ide-history https://www.gitpod.io/blog/cloud-ide-history - https://www.gitpod.io/blog/openvscode-server-launch https://www.gitpod.io/blog/openvscode-server-launch - https://www.gitpod.io/blog/open-vsx https://www.gitpod.io/blog/open-vsx If you got any questions lemme know. <3
- frostwarrior 4y agoThere are many extensions that break in VSCodium because they expect the "code" binary. Where can I report that?
- filiptronicek 4y agoHi, Filip from Gitpod here! It is a bit puzzling to me that this would be an issue, since extensions generally do not call any VS Code binaries, they should ideally access everything through the VS Code Extension API (https://code.visualstudio.com/api https://code.visualstudio.com/api) and never call any VS Code-related binaries, since VS Code can run on a portable mode as well. If issues like this arise, it is most likely a fault of the extension itself, so reporting should be done on a repository or an issue tracker of that extension. I have never seen an extension call the `code` binary, so I would guess it could realistically only be helpful for some kind of a workaround for an API limitation. If you have any of these extensions that break on VS Codium, could you please share them with me? I would love to dig for more and help towards fixing said extensions there.
- rufugee 4y agoIs there a way to tie VSCode extensions to their VSCodium counterparts? I installed codium and started manually installing plugins, but realized that authors, etc don't match up. For example, the Rails plugin in official VSCode shows "周鹏" as the author and 245K downloads, but in codium it's "bung87" with only 3.9K downloads. I'm just thinking about supply chain attacks. I don't personally review all extension code on the VSCode side, but there's a certain amount of (false) comfort when over 200K folks have downloaded a particular extension.
- jxf 4y agoIf anyone is interested in an experience report, I've been using it for about three years and it's exactly the same experience as VSCode (even works with Live Share, for example). The main thing you'll have to contend with is that the extension registry for VSCode is different from Codium, as Geoff says here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31606704 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31606704 This means you might find that extensions you use in VSCode aren't in Codium. This is usually remedied by just downloading the extension manually yourself or by asking the extension developers to cross-publish.
- Cupprum 4y agoSome Microsoft extensions do not work in vscodium. I have been using it for more than a year now, but i still miss the remote development using SSH.
- fartcannon 4y agoYou get all that for free with a terminal in Linux. And KDE has all kinds of tools that remotely work with SSH. Dolphin can, for example, treats a remote SSH connection like a local file system.
- hughw 4y agoHow does a Linux terminal replicate the remote capability of VS Code?
- ilovecaching 4y agoI'd still rather support a project like (Neo)Vim or Emacs that isn't developed under the auspices of a corporation (whose mantra is embrace, extend, extinguish), and have proven staying power. We've seen IDEs and text editors come and go through the revolving door of public opinion for decades, but Vim and Emacs have both continued to hold strong as tools you can use over the course of your entire life, and they've continued to get better and better as technology has improved.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoAnyone know how VSCodium is for remotely developing C++ and Python code on a Linux server? Last I checked (a while ago), I think the remote-over-ssh package was only available in VSCode.
- whalesalad 4y agoI think this is still the case.
- mikaelsouza 4y agoMaybe I'm being a bit naive, but the telemetry is supposed to help the VSCode developers to improve the product, right? It feels a bit strange when some of us want the benefits of what this telemetry may give (a better product, perhaps?) while not willing to conceive information to improve it. Maybe it's similar to how ads work. I use an ad blocker, but because I feel ads make the product worse, not better. I am not sure if my pov makes sense though.
- usrn 4y agoTelemetry is stupid for many reasons, a big one is that many of your users will block it so your data will be bad.
- pluc 4y agoMaybe it has to do with Microsoft's history of collecting too much information for profit and ignoring user feedback that has disillusioned people into denying it? Have you seen Windows telemetry?!
- czx4f4bd 4y agoOn the one hand, I sorta agree with you and I find some of the kneejerk anti-telemetry perspectives to be maybe overly paranoid. On the other hand, I do think there's a valid concern here because the telemetry is closed source. Short of reverse engineering the official binaries and/or inspecting what it sends back to Microsoft, there's no way of knowing what it's actually collecting, which is understandably concerning given Microsoft's history. And you'd have to do that for every release, since any update could expand the scope of what they gather. Personally, I don't quite care enough to bother doing something about it, but I can see why folks who are inclined to distrust Microsoft would not want to trust them on this.
- skohan 4y agoTelemetry is also not the only solution to the problem of improving a product. For something like a code editor, I cannot imagine what they can learn from telemetry that the cannot also learn from methods like user interviews.
- pisspiss 4y ago
- shitshitshit 4y ago
- toastercat 4y agoI used and loved VSCodium for a while, but as a Windows user, I found it was incompatible with the Remote SSH plugin that makes development on WSL2 a breeze. Is there any news on this front or an alternative users have found? EDIT: Just scrolled down to read the rest of the comments, and see this is still the case. :(
- dizhn 4y agoWindows 11 wsl2 is supposed to be able to run gui apps (without needing hacks). It should therefore be feasible to run vscodium on wsl2 itself and develop that way. I used wsl2 for a bit and it was really nice but it had the side effect or reminding me how much I missed running Linux and how much I didn't want to upgrade to Windows 11.
- skohan 4y agoHave you considered switching to a Linux desktop environment? Unless you need Windows for some reason, Linux is generally the best development environment in my experience.
- toastercat 4y agoI actually do run Linux on my work PC, but I prefer Windows to every Linux DE I've tried (including GNOME, KDE, Budgie, MATE, and XFCE, although XFCE is by far my favorite), so I'd prefer to stay on Windows if I can.
- skohan 4y agoWow really? Cool if it works for you, but after switching to Linux I find Windows very annoying and high-maintenance.
- toastercat 4y agoI've found the opposite (although I do run Windows 10 LTSC). Most Linux distros I've tried break between releases, driver issues galore, UI aesthetic and performance inconsistencies across apps that use GTK/QT/Electron/etc. I love Linux, but as a desktop, it's really nowhere near as consistent or cohesive as its corporate counterparts.
- aftbit 4y agoI wanted to like VSCode, but when I found out that both the Python language server and the remote SSH editing plugin are only available in the MS-blessed binaries, I quit using it and went back to vim. At least that's everywhere.
- fb03 4y agoHave you tried PyCharm? Even the community edition is pretty solid. Btw, how do you set up your vim+python? do you use something like coc.nvim to get language server protocol working with it?
- aftbit 4y agoI do not use the language server with vim yet. I have a few dozen plugins that I use for syntax highlighting, Ctrl-P, airline, etc. I think my python highlighting comes from vim-polyglot. However I have been wanting to get better autocomplete working. YouCompleteMe is not bad but nothing really competes with VS, especially for TypeScript.
- kupfer 4y agoNot the one you asked. But I just install lunarvim when I want a fat IDE. It has many of the bells and whistles like lsp and linter preconfigured. It's started with a different command, lvim, so I can still fire up normal vim on a rust file if I just want to read it or whatever. I used to use coc.nvim, but lunarvim has easy integration for several languages and it's very painless to set up. I'm not customising the normal vim anymore, the linux distribution's defaults are fine. There are other vim 'distributions' with IDE like features besides lunarvim.
- fb03 4y agoThis was my pain point regarding 'making the leap to VIM'. I wanted something that was easily installable and reproducible. with PyCharm I can download a software and that's it. With VSCode, if I wanna develop in Rust, I install rust-analyzer with 2 clicks and that's it. Coc-nvim has always been a world of hurt that has been putting me off the 'vim-ide' train for quite a while. Thank you for informing me about things like 'lunarvim'. I'm gonna check it out now!
- ibejoeb 4y agoBeen a while since I've looked at this. It used to be that settings sync was a Microsoft-only feature, and that still seems to be the case. Are there any independent implementations of settings sync?
- upupandup 4y agoDoes this mean we can modify this to ship/distribute our own VS Code flavors? what are the limitations of VSCodium? I see from the comments, SSH doesn't work, which was a big feature and some extensions not working (any ideas on which and why?)
- bstar77 4y agoWarning: slightly off topic I don't know if others are doing the same, but I'm trying to wean myself off of vscode/vscodium in favor of neovim. My main issues with vscode are bugs and performance. The vscode undo history constantly gets corrupted, performance with large files is terrible, extensions can be a mixed bag, vim integration is not consistent and performance in general is sluggish. On the other hand, I've been trying out Lunar vim and it has feature parity with vscode and suffers from none of the issue I mentioned. My only issue is taking the time to learn how to do a dozen or so operations that I have not investigated in Lunar Vim yet. Lunar vim is blazing fast when paired with Alacritty. Once I get around to filling the final few knowledge gaps I have, I'm done with vscode.
- urlwolf 4y agoI have absolutely no use for a code editor with a typing latency as high as vscode. Anyone who has not read https://pavelfatin.com/typing-with-pleasure/ https://pavelfatin.com/typing-with-pleasure/ is doing himself a disservice.