11 ms·
The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewstuart 4y agoCrypto will come back again. The reason is because it's very closely related to gambling and triggers the same obsessive thinking as gambling does - based on my observations of how I felt and thought when I did some crypto investing - I found myself constantly checking prices and devoting huge amounts of thought to it - I even wrote a crypto trading bot to analyse strategies. If you know anyone into crypto you would know they talk about it non stop. There are HUGE numbers of people who's brains are deeply involved with crypto. They'll be back for more. Crypto had a big crash only recently - about 12 to 18 months ago I think, when Elon Musk made some comments that crashed the market. That crash was rapidly forgotten and people piled back in. Same thing will happen here. Logic is not the driver of people's behavior. Crypto is essentially legal, consensual large scale ponzi scheme participation - if you understand that then you might be able to win big.
- Gigachad 4y agoCrypto shills have always just sat in the background out of mind for a while before they come out with their next rebrand of the same scam. NFTs and Web3 have had their moment and likely collected a fortune, now they have to come up with the next branding. For some reason the general public doesn't learn. The most amusing part is how the general public instinctively reacted to NFTs as thinking they were a scam, but they had so much news coverage and big numbers behind them that it became an Emperor has no clothes situation where it can't be a scam because too many people are agreeing with it. Only for it all to unravel and the public opinion returning to its just a scam.
- t-3 4y ago> For some reason the general public doesn't learn. The type of person who tries their hand at cryptocurrency speculation isn't much interested in learning or responsible investment. They are trying to get rich, thinking they will get ahead of the rest of the FOMO idiots. Most don't have the financial resources to consider low-return "safe" investments in mutual funds or the stock market, but they can buy a few *coins for a little bit of nothing and hope it goes up. The crypto-libertarians who see it as a solution to perceived problems with fiat currencies and/or government economic power doesn't seem to have much overlap with the "get rich quick" group.
- Animats 4y agoCrypto shills have the problem that this is now in the money-losing phase. This is when people start complaining to enforcement agencies. Then prosecutors, the SEC, and courts start doing their thing. The SEC just doubled their "cyber" enforcement staff. They're still working down the backlog from the ICO boom of 2018-2019, at the rate of about two scams per month. I expect the hammer to come down on a number of Metaverse schemes which collected money, promised a fancy 3D virtual world, and failed to ship. That's where an unregistered public offering becomes fraud.
- fictionfuture 4y agoOnly thing that revived crypto was all the free biden-bucks they printed. Free cash needs somewhere to go.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoNot for nothing, but the majority of stimulus money was dispensed using checks with "Donald J Trump" written on them.
- formerkrogemp 4y ago> Logic is not the driver of people's behavior. I think people are more rational than you give them credit, but, yes, emotion often informs and overrides our logic. Feelings, emotional intuition, biases, and prejudices color the lens of the eyes through which we see the world. Logic can be like prescription glasses or like Stevie Wonder glasses depending on how we check our priors. > The reason is because it's very closely related to gambling and triggers the same obsessive thinking as gambling does - based on my observations of how I felt and thought when I did some crypto investing. I noticed the same obsessive feeling and learned more about myself through that day trading. It was an expensive lesson however.
- g_delgado14 4y ago> Crypto had a big crash only recently - about 12 to 18 months ago I think, when Elon Musk made some comments that crashed the market. That crash was rapidly forgotten and people piled back in. Same thing will happen here. Except 12-18 months ago we weren't entering into a recession. So, although I am generally bullish on crypto, I am not so optimistic on things coming back to normal any time soon. Remember the old adage folks - "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent".
- senectus1 4y agothis is true. I was also flooded with some really obvious bullshit... this crash is going to sweep the table clean. There is a chance it might come back cleaner and stronger than before. More mainstream maybe, with some regulation.
- heavyset_go 4y agoI, unfortunately, agree with this. Different generations of digital assets will continuously be used to grift certain demographics, with the potential for even larger bubbles and busts in the future.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a great point: even above speculation, a core part of cryptocurrency's "stickiness" is that it's effectively unregulated gambling with extremely large upsides. I think that points to the best recourse we have, after the next crash: it needs to be regulated into the dirt.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 4y agoLuckily for the world, regulators tend to step in right after collapses. Crypto is finally large enough to have the eye of regulators, and if a real collapse materializes this time - they may pounce. I suspect they'll aggressively take out stablecoins. They are the only real source of liquidity in crypto. Price action follows liquidity, so hopefully, any future swings will be much much smaller.
- mechanical_bear 4y agoRegulate a useful technology into the dirt because you have incorrect assumptions, and are generally ignorant about it?
- woodruffw 4y agoI can assure you that, to my vague displeasure, I am somewhat of the opposite of "generally ignorant" of cryptocurrencies. And I haven't stated any assumptions, other than the relatively bland claim that "people gamble with it."
- Godel_unicode 4y agoMore to the point, consumer protection in the form of regulation is what makes a currency and banking system real. There's far too much risk for the average person to consider using cryptocurrency the way they currently use EUR or USD without such a regime.
- datadata 4y ago
- dboat 4y ago> If you know anyone into crypto you would know they talk about it non stop. Not really. There are a lot of people holding, mining, DCA'ing into projects they believe in who have no trouble at all keeping it to themselves. Your remarks about gambling are similarly projecting a portion of the community onto the rest. Those traders who treat it as a speculative asset are gambling as you say, and tend to be obsessive in the way you describe, but you seem not to be aware of everyone who deals with crypto differently than you did. There are a lot of crypto projects that people don't expect to moon, that effectively serve their purpose right now, and will just get better at it in the future. None of what you wrote is nearly as generally true as you made it out to be.
- 3np 4y agoAt the same time, I assume that most of the liquidity in the markets come from professionals and the people described in GP, whereas the casual retail/investors you describe tend to not keep their assets on orderbooks or in liquidity pools.
- Nav_Panel 4y agoYep, exactly. I've been working in crypto for 4 years and counting, still haven't purchased a single token as an investment. I don't like downside risk, I like to build product. We've weathered one bear market, we'll weather another. Thankfully there's cool stuff in the ecosystem that isn't a scam, but it's not newsworthy, so it doesn't go viral.
- candiddevmike 4y agoCan you give some examples of cool stuff that isn't a scam? I'm genuinely curious.
- Nav_Panel 4y agoOne of the cool parts of crypto is that it enables new forms of social coordination that take place entirely within an online context. We haven't even scratched the surface of what could be possible with DAOs; the UIs and educational materials don't exist yet. But given how online people are in general (and they're only likely to become more online in the future), it's natural they'll want digitally-native ways to organize themselves, represent ownership, qualify membership, etc. The shift in concept required here is from viewing a token as "an investment" to viewing it as a form of legible social proof within its community context, which becomes more meaningful as communities grow beyond the "tipping point" where interpersonal proof (think webs-of-trust) is sufficient for coordination. NFTs (yes, they're still around!) are already serving this function for certain experimental communities (and even in less experimental ones, see POAPs). In general, everything above is still in the experimental, live or die phase. We don't quite know where it's going. But it's pretty damn cool to watch if you're deeply invested in the internet as a medium (and as someone who "grew up online", I absolutely am).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Strs2FillMyDrms 4y agoI think it CAN come to an end. The backbone of crypto and the blockchain is the willingness to maintain it which has a cost. The reason why this maintenance is cost effective is because the major holders are few and at a < 1/2 of the entire base. As long as the "right" people are winning, there will be enough justification to keep the ball rolling. If there will come a day, in which the ammount of holders become so dilluted that there stops being any clear (lets say) influencers at the top, then the "cool boy's club" will be no more. This is when exchanges will no longer have any skin in the game. Massive runs and "outages" until a few weird naive dreamers are left at the helm of the sinking ship.
- latchkey 4y ago> On Monday, the Financial Times published an interview with Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of the FTX crypto-trading exchange, in which he said bitcoin doesn’t have a future as a means of payment because it is too complicated and environmentally costly. https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1526098754163687424 https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1526098754163687424
- 4pkjai 4y agoI think he's a little biased because he's heavily involved with Solana
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoTBF Solana is the future of crypto. Disclosure: All of my crypto is in Solana :D
- arcticbull 4y agoYes I love how decentralized it is, and how like any good decentralized system it has to get rebooted every few weeks.
- SilasX 4y agoHe also owns a exchange that makes a mint on trading in BTC and related derivatives.
- latchkey 4y ago-removed-
- SilasX 4y agoWas that intended as a reply to something I said? I don’t know how that addresses my point. Edit: My comment was intended to refute the claim that he’s just pushing people toward his investments by saying he still earns money from the popularity of BTC. I don’t see what it adds to the conversation to bring up his past earnings, at least where you out the comment.
- formerkrogemp 4y ago
- adam_arthur 4y agoIt doesn't and never has. 0 intrinsic value. Great to see all these idiot fueled bubbles popping
- Nav_Panel 4y agoSame with greenbacks tho EDIT: let me elaborate before you downvote: the value of a US dollar is not "intrinsic", it's the result of the strength of the US government and military, i.e. due to social factors that cause it to be accepted as a medium for exchange. Crypto is no different: any crypto asset that has an exchange value (i.e. for which there's a liquid market) is backed by social proof of some kind, although likely on not nearly as large a scale or with as much force as the US military. I highly doubt crypto is going to replace the dollar, because then it's internet communities vs the US government, and the US government has a lot more material power than internet communities, but there's no good reason why a cryptocurrency can't have some value as a legible unit of social proof, especially if the social relations involved have some material stakes (hence the DAO). The idea that "money = intrinsic value" is a naive view of the world; Marx didn't believe that (he saw value as based on labor added), nor did Hayek, etc.
- adam_arthur 4y agoRemind me again what the price of BTC is most commonly quoted in?
- datadata 4y agoThe answer to this question does not demonstrate that USD has any intrinsic value, it merely demonstrates that USD is the most valuable and well circulated of the currencies. These currencies still have zero intrinsic value.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoThe best crypto grift was the neobank startups that were front ends for investing in anchor, a 20%APY crypto ponzi. Anchor crashed with Luna and all those startups kept their money in failed stable coins and have folded and failed to make payroll. They lost all of their money and all of their customers money. Woof
- arikr 4y agoWhich Neobanks have gone bust or are likely to as a result of Luna?
- mikestaszel 4y agohttps://www.alice.co/ https://www.alice.co/ is one.
- vishnugupta 4y agohttps://twitter.com/FatManTerra/status/1527153694218797058 https://twitter.com/FatManTerra/status/1527153694218797058
- sebmellen 4y agoAnd they’re a YCombinator company!!! https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/stablegains https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/stablegains “EARN HIGH AND STABLE INTEREST FROM DEFI LENDING MARKETS” Jesus…
- mountainriver 4y agoI heard an interesting theory that the crypto bubble as tied to the US free money machine
- etaioinshrdlu 4y agoCrypto cannot create wealth, only move it around. If too many people become crypto-rich and try to spend it on real-world assets, the assets will just inflate in price. What can happen is that crypto could replace other forms of money. Governments will likely fight this tooth and nail however, because crypto is currently an anti-government technology.
- RestlessMind 4y agoBitcoin was created from scratch and is worth >500B today. And by worth, I mean you can literally sell your bitcoin on one of the crypto exchanges and get real dollars back. If that is not wealth creation, I don't know what your definition of wealth creation is. When we look at all the crypto coins, the combines value creation is >1.2 Trillion USD as per https://coinmarketcap.com/ https://coinmarketcap.com/.
- __del__ 4y agowealth isn't the same as "i can get money for this"
- RestlessMind 4y agoWealth is the stuff that people value. Money is one of the measures we use to measure that value, particularly when talking about "wealth creation". So if public stock market valuation is considered a good measure for wealth creation, why not crypto market cap?
- 10x-dev 4y agoCrypto lets governments track every citizen's purchase ever made, forever. KYC ensures that a wallet is tied to a person. I am surprised governments haven't yet jumped on this fully (without proof of work, just a government run digital currency and a blockchain).
- fallat 4y agoOh ho, they are. You have no idea how hard they are jumping in.
- anm89 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbZ8zDpX2Mg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbZ8zDpX2Mg
- gfodor 4y agoCrypto crashes every couple years and of course it has grown immensely since the last crash so the scale and scope of these kinds of “analyses” grow with it. I’d imagine in 5 years in the next big crash it will be the top news around the global for many weeks.
- stephen_g 4y agoNo, I think there is a natural limit - eventually you have enough people burned by the scams, crashes, hacks etc. who will keep away, to the point that you don't have enough new entrants to put enough money in to have continuing growth. Unless there was an actual crypto economy, but at this point, there's not much more than speculation.
- guerrilla 4y agoTrue, pyramid schemes always have an upper limit since they depend on people not already knowing about them.
- dorkwood 4y agoNew people come into existence all the time, though. The kids of today will be the adoptees of tomorrow. We will never run out of new blood.
- mattwilsonn888 4y agoThinking you can lump together the centralized scams and true crypto (of which Bitcoin is clearly the winner) forever will get you burned. The excited laymen will certainly be turned off as they make that same mistake in thinking, but the narrative will change and I can promise you nobody hates the scammers and grifters more than the 'crypto community' themselves.
- boardwaalk 4y agoMaking predictions about something that’s only been around in any significant way for a decade and is subject to so many social, political, and economic pressures (extremely chaotic in themselves) is probably pretty fraught.
- karaterobot 4y agoIf crypto goes down in value to ten percent, or one percent of its current value, will people who believe in it admit it was a grift? If it goes up in value again, 2x or 10x its current value, will people who said it was a grift admit it was more than that? I would bet money (fiat or digital) that, in either case, most people on either side will just say "I haven't been proven right yet", because it's just camps yelling at each other at this point.
- arcticbull 4y ago> If it goes up in value again, 2x or 10x its current value, will people who said it was a grift admit it was more than that? I've called it a grift since 2017 so yeah. Being a grift has nothing to do with its price and everything to do with its fundamental structure.
- odsb 4y agohow is BTC not fundamentally sound. You can literally take 1 Billion dollars worth of BTC and cross the border without anyone questioning you. How does that not change how you see things ?
- arcticbull 4y agoFundamentally sound as what? - As a currency, it's garbage. Currencies are inflationary to incentivize spending. A deflationary currency incentives hoarding, and harms the economy by dropping velocity. All the worst periods in history have been deflationary, not inflationary. Currencies benefit from being able to respond to changes in population, to shocks, to changing demographics. And they shouldn't cost a fully-realized (inc. block reward) $200+ to transact. - As a 'hedge against inflation,' it's garbage. In the most inflationary period in decades, it went from 69K to 28K. That's a drop of 60% in nominal terms. While the dollar dropped 9%. That means it dropped 69% in real dollar terms in a few months. RIP. - As a 'store of value,' it's garbage. A store of value must be predictable. You should have a reasonable expectation that you can extract the same amount of value from it in the future. See above. - It's an environmental catastrophe, wasting as much power as an entire nation (and yielding kilotons of e-waste per year) to achieve 6tps. Millions of times less efficient than Visa, or FedNow or RTP. It has sufficient throughput at the L1 level to service a large flea market or a mid-sized Costco, not the world economy. Lightning is a nothing burger. It would take 75 years, 2/3 of a trillion dollars in fees, and the entire rest of the block reward to open a channel for everyone on earth. And LN has quadratic routing complexity meaning even if you did, it wouldn't be functional in the first place. Even your example of smuggling money across the border doesn't make sense - you need to buy Bitcoin at one exchange in one country, then sell it at another exchange in another country in order to spend the value. That takes days, costs percentage points, exposes you to huge counter party risk and massive forex swings ... and KYC. And being a public ledger, both governments can fire up chainalysis and see exactly who moved it where. So even if they don't ask you questions as you move across the border, they'll follow up. Just give it time. In exactly what narrative does it come across as 'fundamentally sound'?
- WFHRenaissance 4y agoThe issue here is actually pretty easy to grok. Crypto is a new market, so there is a historical amount of information asymmetry between consumers and producers. This brings a lot of scammers to the space. A lot of crypto is definitely bullshit, but there are some use-cases that I admire that aren’t just gambling on Shit coins.
- jankyxenon 4y agoWhat are the adopted and realistic use cases?
- WFHRenaissance 4y agoSee reply.
- piva00 4y ago> Smart contracts, DAOs, payments, self-sovereign identity, tokenization of real world assets, a few security use-cases, operating markets for prediction and asset-trade outside the control of external authorities (libertarian wet dream stuff), insurance and legal arbitration outside of the control of external authorities (more wet dreaming, but it’s happening), supply chain / provenance of assets… None of this has proven any value in the real world. Libertarian wet dreams are the other side of the coin of communists' wet dreams: utopian, not based on reality, not feasible in our current reality. Legal arbitration is only possible under a legal system, that is under a government, that has a military and other enforcement powers. Some bits proving that a contract is valid won't change that... As usual from the cryptospace, it's all techno-babble built on a house of cards that hasn't given anything to reality except an easier way to transfer funds without KYC, so basically it's a wet dream for criminal activities: scams, drug deals and so on. Ring me up when all these wet dreams become a reality, they've been repeated ad nauseam for quite a few years already and nothing has really materialised.
- sk0g 4y ago> you’d be an idiot to ignore the realistic and adopted use-cases Ignoring the hostility, what would you list as the realistic and adopted use-cases for crypto?
- DrBazza 4y agoIt’s just tulips all over again. It has an intrinsic value because some people place a value on it. It’s just not what it is now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania
- anon9001 4y ago> As an inevitable crash occurs, many of the swindles and alleged swindles are coming to light. Yeah, bubbles make overvalued prices. Crashes occur. Losers fail. Winners gain bigger marketshare and mindshare. Spectacular failures are actually a sign of a functioning market. The worst possible thing that could have happened last week would be the federal reserve offering Do Kwon a very cheap bridge loan to stabilize his section of the crypto economy, lest we risk broader market contagion. Crypto failures are fast and painful as opposed to long and corrupt. This is a feature, not a bug. Also, ironically, this author has spilled a fair amount of ink over all the market crises of the years. He wrote a whole book on the dot-com bust. The Luna saga was over in about 3 days. > The list includes some traditional tactics for illicitly relieving rubes of their money, such as pump-and-dump schemes and phishing for passwords. It also describes new, more novel schemes, including the “pig butchering” crypto scam, which often involves an attractive person approaching you online and offering you spectacularly lucrative crypto investments. Sure, I get these DMs on discord too. Don't fall for scammers. They were doing the same nonsense with "Double your Square Cash!" scams shortly before the crypto boom. Or offering great deals on "GPUs" during the shortage. This is not a crypto problem in the slightest and crypto probably makes these lower end scammers easy to prosecute. > The over-all aim was to make crypto investing seem mainstream and draw in gullible investors who feared they were being left on the sidelines. Does anyone seriously believe that etrade or robinhood advertising options trading to me is somehow different? There are constant commercials for precious metals and ETFs and all kinds of things. I know a fair amount of bitcoin millionaires, all of whom were called "gullible investors" at the time. What really bothers me is the incredible amount of ignorance I see in the comments section about crypto, blockchain technologies, poor understandings of economics, etc. Wtf HN. Do better. I feel like I'm watching my peers get old and resistant to change and dismissive of new technologies and exciting possibilities. Also, if you appreciate my contrarian (for HN?) view and are looking to take on more risk, now is the time to build for web3. The people chasing easy money will give up and the people moving the tech forward will build while no one is watching.
- plaguepilled 4y agoOh fine I'll bite. >Does anyone seriously believe that etrade or robinhood advertising options trading to me is somehow different? There are constant commercials for precious metals and ETFs and all kinds of things. Well they're equally bad in terms of being a scam, unless you are a hedge fund that has enough liquidity to even need options trading in the first place. Not sure what other conclusion you could come up with there. >What really bothers me is the incredible amount of ignorance I see in the comments section about crypto, blockchain technologies, poor understandings of economics, etc. Being bothered by the flaws of crypto does not equate to being uninformed. That kind of logic is what I expect from a car salesman, not HN. Yes, that wasn't nice of me, but being told I'm old and resistant to change because I disagree with someone doesn't engender friendly interpretations. No asset is a pure force for good nor evil, but there are material issues with crypto and pretending they're ONLY a technicality is convincing no-one.
- tluyben2 4y agoI think cryptocurrencies/nfts are crap and have no value, but to play devil’s advocate here; for all the people saying this is all doomed, the top cryptocurrency assets seem to more or less look like the tech market and BTC is doing better than, say Netflix. Netflix actually makes things and is 76% down from ath, while btc only 66%. So why is it so resilient? When will it die if it indeed has no value? Are we just grumpy tech people who are kicking ‘evil’ things that will never change or go away?
- nradov 4y agoBitcoin will (mostly) die when wealthy Chinese no longer need a way to evade capital control laws.
- tluyben2 4y agoWhich is to say, never? I mean, sure there is a chance after Xi some open market president will appear, however, it is more likely, as all opposition is no longer in play, that it will get more closed and there will be more use for cryptocurrencies from that perspective.
- mattwilsonn888 4y agoCannot read your mind but I'll make a guess based on the fact that you are comparing it to a tech stock and the fact that most people on this website make this mistake: You are viewing Bitcoin as a technical project rather than an economic one. Bitcoin is not technically interesting - it is economically genius. Undergrad cryptographers have learnt enough to re-implement the Bitcoin protocol, but understanding the genius of the composition of those simple primitives is a practice of game theory and economics. Historians of money who know not how to program have far more authority than a bitter techie when it comes to analyzing Bitcoin.
- jwmoz 4y agoBTC and ETH are doing fine, in comparison with regular stocks such as NFLX, PTON.
- floatinglotus 4y agoI do not yet trust crypto to be an effective store for value. Call me old fashioned, but I want to store my money in something safe and reliable like Beanie Babies.
- alexb_ 4y agoThere is absolutely zero legal usecase for cryptocurrencies. None. "oh but it might be useful for doing-" you are wrong. Full stop. "but what about censorship" Circumventing government censorship is, by definition, illegal. "but what about trustless" We do not live in a world where there is nobody that can be trusted. And if we did, why the hell would you want a currency where nothing can ever be reversed? "but what about NFTs/smart contracts/DAO" All of these are useless and have resulted in nothing but blatant scams and illegal activity (because that's all cryptocurrency is useful for) Cryptocurrencies have many great uses. You can gamble with them, you can buy drugs with them, you can pay ransom on software that just locked down your entire business for a day, as well as many other illegal activities. EVERY SINGLE OTHER USE, WITHOUT EXCEPTION, is something that centralized systems already do well. And if someone is trying to convince you otherwise, they are either trying to pass the bag to you or make you a part of their scam.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agopaving the road to hell with your good intentions. half your arguments could be applied to the other crypto.
- WFHRenaissance 4y agoMmmmmmmmmmmm This is a good polemic line I’m stealing
- dns_snek 4y ago> There is absolutely zero legal usecase for cryptocurrencies. None. "oh but it might be useful for doing-" you are wrong. Full stop. What's with the dismissive, ignorant and hostile attitude? There are plenty of legal businesses that will accept cryptocurrencies - Mullvad VPN for example. > Cryptocurrencies have many great uses. You can gamble with them, you can buy drugs with them [...] Why are you surprised? Replace "cryptocurrencies" with "cash" and the same use cases apply, it's a currency after all, facilitating transactions is the core purpose of cryptocurrencies. > EVERY SINGLE OTHER USE, WITHOUT EXCEPTION, is something that centralized systems already do well. Yes, centralized systems handle most of our transactions just fine, most of the time. Do you expect people to have to argue in favor of choice while setting an impossibly high bar for any kind of competition? Do you believe in freedom of speech?
- jmartin2683 4y agoAt the end of the day, it doesn’t really do anything unique or useful.
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agoblockchain might have practical and interesting (if contrived) uses. but the fiat value of cryptocurrencies is a speculative bubble i'm sure. without belabouring the whataboutism that usually follows this argument. lines between blockchain the tech and crypto the casino are blurry.
- RichardHeart 4y agoThe Great Finance/Startup/Stock/Housing/Everything Grift May Be Unwinding. They will bottom, then all wind up again. The same structure will generate the same outputs again and again.