30 ms·
Luna Cryptocurrency Collapse: How UST Broke
- leach 5y agoI remember kicking myself for exiting LUNA at 20 dollars early on before it blew up. As I left I kept hearing whispers and sketchy things about it. In hindsight I’m glad I pulled out when I did.
- quickthrower2 5y agoYou got lucky. Be happy enjoying an upward curve, you don’t need to find the trough and peak.
- knodi123 5y agoif humans were any good at taking that specific piece of advice, the world would be a better (and very different) place.
- quickthrower2 5y agothe even better advice that i know is wise but I just cannot take from a former colleague: “the less you need the richer you are”
- the_jeremy 5y ago> This matters for three reasons. ... First, over $15 billion in crypto value has been wiped out through luna and UST alone. ... Second, it raises questions about other stablecoins. ... Lastly and possibly most signifcantly[sic], the collapse of UST has caught the attention of powerful politicians and regulators. To oversimplify, it only matters if you care about crypto. And if you do, you already cared about this.
- kayamon 5y agoWhenever people lose of money, that money has to be paid back to wherever they borrowed it from. Expect to see some more bank bailouts down the line to cover the cost of all this.
- baersandbowlszs 5y agoThis isn't a matter of debt though, is it? The absolute worst case for a retail crypto investor is that they lose all of the money they put in. I can't imagine a bank signing off on a big loan to buy speculative assets. So the money is already "paid back". Right?
- gerikson 5y agoThere are very few banks lending money to crypto speculators. People may have mortgaged their houses etc., but in those cases the bank gets the house.
- rglullis 5y agoThe thing is that this "money" never existed in the first place. It was created out of thin air, and it vanished just the same.
- kayamon 5y agoIt'd be nice if there were a form of money that were created with a locked inflation rate, distributed at random, fair to all, voted upon by its users, backed by a real-world asset, and freely tradable online. Oh well.
- seanhunter 5y agoThere will absolutely be contagion into the rest of the economy. A lot of funds are long crypto, they will have received margin calls so will have to liquidate other assets driving those prices down etc. It's still to be seen how much contagion there will be, but there will be some.
- 5y ago
- akkartik 5y agoI prefer Matt Levine from his newsletter today: "Safe assets are much riskier than risky ones. This is I think the deep lesson of the 2008 financial crisis, and crypto loves re-learning the lessons of traditional finance. Systemic risks live in safe assets. Equity-like assets — tech stocks, Luna, Bitcoin — are risky, and everyone knows they’re risky, and everyone accepts the risk. If your stocks or Bitcoin go down by 20% you are sad, but you are not that surprised. And so most people arrange their lives in such a way that, if their stocks or Bitcoin go down by 20%, they are not ruined. "On the other hand safe assets — AAA mortgage securities, bank deposits, stablecoins — are not supposed to be risky, and people rely on them being worth what they say they’re worth, and when people lose even a little bit of confidence in them they crack completely. Bitcoin is valuable at $50,000 and somewhat less valuable at $40,000. A stablecoin is valuable at $1.00 and worthless at $0.98. If it hits $0.98 it might as well go to zero. And now it might! "I have in the past told the story of TerraUSD and Luna by saying: The weakness in TerraUSD is Luna. One UST can be exchanged for $1 of Luna, but that only works if people continue to have confidence in Luna; if Luna goes to zero then TerraUSD will follow. But you could also tell the story by saying: The weakness in Luna is TerraUSD. Luna, as the cryptocurrency of a blockchain ecosystem, would rise or fall with the value of that ecosystem. But Luna, as the thing supporting a stablecoin, could go to zero in a week if that stablecoin needed support. Terra was so unstable because it was trying to be stable."
- quickthrower2 5y agoSurely no one through stablecoins were low risk?
- iaabtpbtpnn 5y agoStable is right there in the name.
- lupire 5y ago
- quickthrower2 5y ago
- mrintellectual 5y agoThe crux of the problem is not Luna itself, but the Anchor Protocol (19.5% yield), which enticed users to burn Luna by investing in UST through a, for lack of a better phrase, Ponzi scheme. I get it - people like decentralization. But without some form of regulation, either by the broader crypto community itself or by governments around the world, situations like the LUNA/UST collapse will keep happening. There are also rumors of a Terra fork: https://agora.terra.money/t/terra-ecosystem-revival-plan/8701 https://agora.terra.money/t/terra-ecosystem-revival-plan/870.... Thanks, but no thanks.
- kova12 5y agoProblem with regulation is that the term itself is ambiguous. What does it mean, who will do it, what are their limits and on what authority do they act? I am not familiar with this specific crypto, but when I am offered to join a business that pays 19% in USD, I immediately know it can not possibly not fail. Regulations or not, you can't offer such dividend without major risk. Then the subject of jurisdiction comes up. Who issued the tokens? If it is a USA company or person, it is one story, and they are likely already subject to some regulations. If it is an international community like ethereum, its another story. USA can probably ban it's distribution in USA, but not regulate. Then, why would the regulations have to be mandatory? Organizations can voluntarily approach SEC and ask them to regulate the crypto they are about to issue. Submit to the appropriate rules and be an investor grade business. No new laws are really required for that. This way you could have trusted that if Luna fails, someone would go to jail. It's just wouldn't have been 19% dividend in that case, following rules comes with a price tag.
- phphphphp 5y agoI disagree. Anchor was a dumb-money trap that increased the fallout of UST’s collapse by at least an order of magnitude, sure, but it was not responsible for the collapse: algorithmic stable coins are fundamentally flawed, they’re a perpetual motion machine, they’re based on the belief that you can artificially create and sustain a market within a set of very narrow parameters. Luna was doomed to fail regardless of Anchor — and the founders knew that, because they’d failed in the same way before, anchor was their attempt to shore up the ruse (which worked… until it didn’t).
- huitzitziltzin 5y agoOf all of the wildly implausible ideas to come out of the crypto area, algorithmic stable coins are the least plausible.
- TacticalCoder 5y agoYet, somehow, DAI (an algorithmic stable coin running on top of Ethereum as I understand it) has apparently managed to keep its peg since 2017. I read on it yesterday and I'm very intrigued. It's a gigantic target for dark hats and yet so far nobody found a way to attack it. And it's not small: $6bn of DAI worth 1 USD each circulating.
- boppo1 5y agoHow is it a dark hat target?
- ironSkillet 5y agoPeople love trying to take down big fish. Even better if they can make money doing it. Not saying it's vulnerable, just that it's quite a big fish.
- zucker42 5y agoAs I understand, Dai is an overcollaterized stablecoin. People mint Dai by locking up cryptocurrency into its smart contracts worth more than the Dai they get. I believe that collateral can be automatically liquidated in the case of a crash of those assets. This is different from an "algorithmic stablecoin" as the term is commonly used, since by that people usually mean a coin which doesn't utilize collateral.
- skybrian 5y agoThe question is why is one cryptocoin "collateral" and the other "not collateral?" What's preventing whatever coins DAI depends on from a death spiral?
- rufius 5y agoThis article seems to assume it matters. It does not.
- freedomben 5y agoI think the elephant in the room is the self harm that is happening. It may be very rare, but it is happening, and it happens in stock market crashes too (not just in crypto). Even if you don't care about crypto, even if you think people who trade in crypto are idiots, please remember there are real humans behind these things. If you're licking your wounds, remember that things come and go. I know that's a shitty thing to deal with (I've lost my ass is crypto before too so I know first hand), but don't do something to yourself that is permanent and can never come back from. It's absolutely NOT worth it. If you dodged this one, now is the time to be full of compassion to your fellow humans, not dancing on graves and gloating in "I told you so."
- whatever1 5y agoWhat I want is these crypto charlatans who were giving malicious financial advice to go to jail.
- Animats 5y agoYes. The US SEC puts about two of them out of business each month, and often claws the money back, but jail is rare. Too rare.[1] The IRS sometimes comes in after the SEC if someone operating a fraud didn't pay their taxes. They put people in jail for years.[2] Remember, Al Capone was sent to Alcatraz for tax evasion. [1] https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/cybersecurity-enforcement-actions https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/cybersecurity-enforcement-acti... [2] https://www.irs.gov/compliance/criminal-investigation/founders-of-crypto-ico-plead-guilty-to-tax-evasion-after-raising-24-million-from-investors https://www.irs.gov/compliance/criminal-investigation/founde...
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWe see how many went to jail in 2008 when the ‘real’ economy had trouble…
- scoofy 5y agoI've been angry about it since the beginning. This was predictable, and now people are asking for compassion? Compassion was us yelling about this since the beginning. Compassion was the folks who developed Dogecoin as a satire coin to explain the problems involved in the system. Asking people to 'be full of compassion' is fine, and dancing on graves is terrible, but the time for compassion was the warnings that were years back, in the face of 'have fun being poor' taunts, while never ever folding or letting up. The sentiment here was the same type of nice but not kind nonsense that has gripped much of the culture. I try to think of the people I convinced not to speculate in these markets. The fortunes not lost because people came to me as a life long investor, asking my opinion of cryto markets, and me carefully arguing that they were a commodity, not an investment vehicle, and you don't generally invest in rocks, because rocks don't produce anything. Those of us out there that saved people from losing their life savings will never be acknowledged, because humans do not care to think about the lives that were saved by safety precautions, only the lives that were lost due to negligence. https://medium.com/@philberent1/why-the-terra-luna-protocol-will-almost-certainly-fail-ca9d3e9b3662 https://medium.com/@philberent1/why-the-terra-luna-protocol-... https://twitter.com/jordonaut/status/1352363163686068226 https://twitter.com/jordonaut/status/1352363163686068226
- stickfigure 5y agoAre there other algorithmic stablecoins? Who is next?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- IdEntities 5y agoThe one I've seen mentioned most often is DAI.
- mingw__ 5y agoDAI isn't an algostable. It's overcollateralized, so to mint $1.00 of DAI, you generally need $1.50 of crypto or centralized stablecoin.
- BrissyCoder 5y agoDoesn't seem to address the "why it matters" portion of the headline.
- woah 5y agoI'd be interested in some analysis of whether Luna would have been more likely to work without the "Anchor protocol".
- wmf 5y agoIt likely would have limped along as a microcap wannabe coin that no one cared enough about to attack.
- memish 5y agoUSDD next? Just announced yesterday by Justin Sun. 40% APR! https://twitter.com/justinsuntron/status/1524726284399480832 https://twitter.com/justinsuntron/status/1524726284399480832
- IdEntities 5y agoThere are only a few ways to make consistent >15% yields in this world: - Buy Treasury bonds in 1980 - Invest in shaky emerging market debt - Be a credit card lender - Invest in the early phases of a Ponzi scheme before it blows up Good luck to USDD investors.
- byecomputer 5y agothe S&P 500 will get you pretty close to that if you're in it for the long run
- IdEntities 5y agoIt won't be consistent though. No one would ever call investing in broad market indexes "StableGains" or something like that. I probably should have left EM debt off the list.
- redisman 5y agoThere’s a sucker born every minute. Anyone who sees 40% interest and doesn’t think it’s a scam would’ve lost that money on some other scam
- vyrotek 5y agoWhat a mess. And now I just saw this. What? "Leading crypto exchange, Crypto.com, has announced that its users who traded embattled Terra’s native token, LUNA, on May 12 at around 12:40 – 13:39 (UTC) did so with the wrong price. Crypto.com, one of such exchanges, has revealed that traders involved in the concerned transactions would have their transactions reversed, and a $10 reward in CRO, the native token of the platform, would be given to them as compensation for the inconvenience." https://watcher.guru/news/crypto-com-reverses-traders-luna-may-12-transactions https://watcher.guru/news/crypto-com-reverses-traders-luna-m...
- ParksNet 5y agoEncouraging Crypto to fail, and encouraging politicians to ban exchanges, is the quickest way to cut CO2 emissions and reverse chip shortages.
- kova12 5y ago
- greiskul 5y agoYou know, people elsewhere in this thread are asking for compassion. It's not enough to just show compassion to those that lost. Their money didn't get destroyed, they traded it for something they didn't understand, based on lies of the counterparty that sold them the crypto. If people that lost their money deserve our compassion, which I believe they do, those that took their money deserve our contempt. But I'm not worried. You sound like someone that hasn't fully cashed out yet. You are still in the ponzi. And you probably won't hear me. So keep your coins, since you are so smart. One day, they will be worth the actual value they bring to the world. Zero.
- lostmsu 5y agoAs said out above the crashed cryptos were PoS, and the comment you replied to said nothing about those who lost anything. So you and the grandgrandparent are the salty ones here as kova correctly pointed out.
- immigrantheart 5y agoA lot of crypto are moving to PoS.
- FridgeSeal 5y agoYeah any day now I’m sure. 100 tiny coins that nobody seriously trades moving to PoS doesn’t mean anything, ETH has been moving to PoS “real soon now” for literal years. Bitcoin and it’s variants can hardly decide on the max block size, so a fundamental shift like PoS doesn’t seem likely. Also, PoS doesn’t solve resource shortage pressure - it reduces some power consumption, but it still puts artificial pressure on chips and drives.
- jmyeet 5y agoThe very idea of an algorithmic stablecoin is beyond idiotic. A lot of Crypto Andys are former gold bugs who bemoan th eloss of the gold standard (fun fact: the US dollar was never 100% backed by gold). Collaterized currencies are better but gold bugs still miss the point of what makes the US dollar work. A currency only persists so long as people believe in it. That's it. As soon as that belief goes, it's all over. Even if it's collaterized that's true. What actually maintains the value of the US dollar is the long dick of the US government through the Fed obviously but also foreign and domestic policy. It's the ability to project military power anywhere on the planet. It's the nuclear arsenal. So it obviously sucks that people lost sometimes a lot of money on Luna (seriously the subreddit is a dark place now) and I believe at least some of the anecodtes of people losing their houses.. This probably shares a lot of pathology with gambling addiction (fun fact: gambling addiction has the highest rate of suicide of any addiction). But you also need to recognize that a lot of people who got wiped out by Luna were in it to get rich quick. I mean even the ~20% staking returns on Anchor should be alarming by itself. Who is paying for that 20% return? It's bound to be a Ponzi scheme.
- gfodor 5y agoThe idea of an algorithmic stablecoin is genius, time will tell if it works. But overall Luna’s crash isn’t too damning of the idea, because the root cause was a Ponzi scheme. (Which was identified and advertised as dangerous within the crypto community.)
- audleman 5y agoThe ponzi part was not the root cause, it merely sped up asset accumulation until it became a ripe enough target. The root cause was the flawed arbitrage mechanism. It relied on always being able to redeem 1 UST for $1 equivalent of LUNA, and that relied implicitly on LUNA having value. Without that, whenever somebody cashes out UST they also cash out LUNA causing both prices to enter a death spiral. And what value did LUNA have? Nothing more than the promises of the development team that you were getting in early on a soon-to-be-burgeoning ecosystem. "Hundreds of developers! Amazing new protocols!" In other words, vaporware. Which during a bull market can work for a time. I agree with you that a functioning algorithmic stablecoin would be "genius". However I prefer calling it the Holy Grail of stablecoins. Powerful, if it exists.
- woeirua 5y agoLuna is a sideshow. Sad for the people who got caught up in it and lost their savings, but Tether is the real game. When Tether blows up the entire crypto system is going to blow up. And this is why Luna was important, because it caused a loss of confidence in stablecoins across the board. For a while this week, it looked like Tether might actually lose its peg and start a death spiral.
- RyanShook 5y agoIsn't Tether actually backed by dollars though? Edit- here are current reserves: https://tether.to/en/transparency https://tether.to/en/transparency
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Isn't Tether actually backed by dollars though? No [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tether_(cryptocurrency)#Questions_about_dollar_reserves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tether_(cryptocurrency)#Questi...
- gjs278 5y ago
- smcl 5y agoOh good lord no. It's backed by something they originally said was dollars, they then relented after people poked around a bit and confessed it's just a basket of stuff they consider equivalent to dollars (plus probably some dollars I guess?)
- byecomputer 5y agoassets: NFT of tweet, hubcap, the power of love, cracked iPhone 5
- Tao332 5y ago
- sub7 5y agoThe idiots who yelled "have fun staying poor!" are now yelling "we're people too please have empathy!" Can't make this shit up
- mondoveneziano 5y agoLUNA is trading at below $0.00001, that is below 1/1000th of a cent right now. For many, getting rid of it may be much harder than just ignoring it. A few weeks ago the price people were willing to pay for it hovered around $100. I say "the price people were willing to pay" instead of "value", because now that nobody wants to speculate with LUNA, it did fall down to its intrinsic value: Practically zero. Nobody needs it for anything besides buying and selling it from and to other people, which is not happening anymore. Cryptocurrency is gambling, plain and simple. The difficulty that fiat currency faces is inflation, which roughly means diluting the economy that backs it too much. The difficulty with cryptocurrency is that there is nothing of worth backing it. Factor in the horrifying externalities, and its worth is negative. For Bitcoin, the most popular one, on the order of 100.000.000.000.000.000.000 of hashes get calculated to mine a single block, multiple trillion per second. Within ten minutes, only a single one of those 100.000.000.000.000.000.000 hashes is actually used, depending entirely on luck. The rest are thrown away entirely. They do not form part of the final hash or anything else, the energy spent on them is lost.
- donkarma 5y agoYou have contradicted yourself. By your own admission, Bitcoin is backed by the world's energy and computing resources (at least what is used on the network)
- mondoveneziano 5y agoAll energy and computing resources used on mining Bitcoin are spent and cannot be used for anything else. The concept of "backing" means that resources are available, and the entity backing them merely represents them. Stock is backed by the services and products a company provides. Fiat currency is backed by their respective part of the world economy. Resources are not depleted by backing those. Saying Bitcoin is "backed" by the world's energy and computing resources is like saying that a wildfire is "backed" by a state's forestry reserves.
- light_hue_1 5y ago
- ambrozk 5y agoI interviewed with Terraform Labs less than a year ago. The guy interviewing me was a pretty standard eng manager who'd left Amazon for the excitment of a crypto startup. I tried to prep for the interview by researching their white papers to figure out how the various balancing and investment mechanisms actually functioned on a technical level. But it was difficult to make sense of their white paper, which was fairly general, and different portions of their documentation seemed to contradict one another. When I asked what I'd been misunderstanding, he told me that I hadn't misunderstood anything: their white paper was not a full spec, and their documentation was out of date. In that case, I asked, how could one actually understand the protocol? "It's probably not possible at this point," he told me, "These things are in motion all the time." I thought his answer was pretty eye-opening. Their interview question was: design a simple app which allows one to query the effect of crypto price changes on the supply & price of LUNA. I gathered that the upshot was, how big a movement would be required to break the $1 peg? I wonder if their models weren't good, or if their models were good, and they were just accepting a high level of risk?
- medo-bear 5y agoi wonder if these kind of things happen within the cardano ecosystem given their focus on peer reviews
- javert 5y agoAs someone who spent many years in academic computer science, I have zero confidence in the peer review system. Zero. Hoskinson talking up peer review for Cardano makes him look, to me personally, like more of a fraud. My micro-specialty was worse than some others, though. The quality of peer review is not a constant across all of computer science.
- mechanical_bear 5y agoComputer Science has a large reproducibility problem.
- 5y ago
- Vladimof 5y ago"The cryptocurrency market isn't pretty right now. Look anywhere and you'll see red"... I saw green today just like on the stock market... and red yesterday just like on the stock market
- codedokode 5y agoGeneral idea of having two balanced cryptocurrencies doesn't look bad by itself. But the promises to pay 20% of interest per year are super suspicious. Where would that money come from? What kind of goods or services do they produce? Do developers of cryptocurrency expect to receive exorbitant fees from users? If there is no valid business model explaining where that 20% come from then it is just a Ponzi scheme.
- redisman 5y agoThere are a ton of these schemes that promise 10-20%. At best it’s like those 2008 loans that won’t be paid back due to the crash, at worst it’s a ponzi. Celsius and Gemini and a hundred others. There’s a lot more tears left to be spilled
- charcircuit 5y agoIt wasn't a guaranteed 20% APY. APY for defi protocols are constantly in flux and change based off how much money it makes and how many people are providing liquidity. APY is typically calculated per block and is based off how much everyone made in that block. It doesn't mean that it will be able to keep up that rate for a year. For a time Anchor was able to make more than enough to pay out 20% APY and it built a fund to pay out when it didn't make enough. There wasn't enough demand for Anchor to support a 20% APY so they were lowering the target over time while the previous profit made up a portion of what was being paid out. >Where would that money come from? The money came from staking rewards from tokens people deposited as collateral and from interest on loans people took out against the collateral they deposited. >it is just a Ponzi scheme Anchor itself was not a Ponzi scheme. You could withdraw your investment at any time. Your money wasn't paying out other people's returns.
- codedokode 5y agoThank you for clarification, but I still don't get this part: > and from interest on loans people took out against the collateral they deposited To be able to pay out 20% interest rate on deposits you need to issue loans at higher rate. But who would take such a loan when they can go to a traditional bank? Furthermore, the borrower needs to provide a collateral. Money cannot appear out of nowhere. There should be somebody buying something, like products or services (not just cryptotokens). Or at least a reasonable expectation of someone buying them.
- mrkramer 5y agoFirst there were MLM, HYIPs and other bullshit and now we have NFTs, Stablecoins, various cryptocoins and cryptotokens. I think this Ponzi crypto assets are something like the evolution of fraud in a sense that scams are no more secretive, obscure and somewhat straightforward investment programs but more wrapped up in a sophisticated talk about cryptography, blockchain and DeFi which should bring you confidence that you should invest in them because they are more technologically advanced. Somebody should write a book about Fraud in Crypto Assets from the more academic point of view and tbh I would very much like to read it. For example explaining the history of crypto fraud and scams, investigating them deeper and dissecting them from economical and financial point of view with the addition of explaining the basics of cryptography, blockchains and DeFi.
- mizzao 5y agoHere's the book you're looking for. It's the same patterns going back to the 1700s, just with different instruments: https://www.amazon.com/Lying-Money-Legendary-Frauds-Workings-ebook/dp/B078WFT5JV https://www.amazon.com/Lying-Money-Legendary-Frauds-Workings...
- xenospn 5y agoRecommend you check out https://web3isgoinggreat.com https://web3isgoinggreat.com.
- lend000 5y agoThe only way a true collapse to zero could happen for any other cryptocurrency is via a similar mechanism (either an unprotected mechanism to mint unlimited amounts of the currency in a rapid manner, which some mid-tier cryptocurrencies do have, or a bug/vulnerability that allows attackers to duplicate/double spend reliably). Luna didn't collapse 99.999% in a matter of days because of a loss of faith in 99.999% of ITS value by speculators, but because of a ~50% loss of faith that triggered exponential inflation (printing of Luna tokens) based on the simple algorithm governing the ex-stablecoin. The fact that the supply of Luna started multiplying exponentially every minute that the stablecoin remained underpriced flooded the market with insane amounts of Luna. By virtue of the total amount of new Luna minted, its market cap is still around 300M (a "mere" 98.5% loss). Bitcoin could go to near zero, but it would take DECADES and be a very drawn out process without SHA-256 breaking or every relevant country jointly criminalizing its existence. You could look at the values of any of the other deflationary early cryptos that clearly are now not going to play a pivotal role in the crypto landscape (e.g. LTC, BCH) and yet have essentially maintained their values and slightly grown with the market, slowly ceding market share to more relevant coins. In reality, coins like LTC and BCH should have lost 99% of their 2017 value, but because they are not inflationary like Luna, it hasn't happened and won't anytime soon. Contrast this with a company that can clearly, unambiguously go bankrupt. These go to zero all the time when their value is essentially nothing by virtue of no longer doing business, they are legally disbanded, and removed from exchanges.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoLTC is down 70% from its 2017 peak, during which time BTC doubled. What will happen to LTC when BTC loses 50%?
- emtel 5y agoBTC already lost 50% from its peak, so I guess this has been answered.
- KVFinn 5y agoA great breakdown of Luna and Terra, notably recorded a week before the collapse. It's very amusing watching the hosts trying to figure out how this coin is supposed to remain stable while promising 20% guaranteed interest. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V16U4J65xkM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V16U4J65xkM
- mmaunder 5y ago“It all started this weekend. Over $2 billion worth of UST was unstaked” Someone with $2B did the math using the new higher rate of inflation and pulled out of an asset that doesn’t produce anything because it has simply become less attractive. This pattern will keep repeating until inflation drops.
- cutler 5y agoI have one message for crypto-addicts - get an 'effing life instead of wasting it trying to get something for nothing. In other news the war in Ukraine rages on, millions of Ukrainians have lost everything and thousands of innocent lives are being lost. Some perspective please.
- vmception 5y agothere are so many crypto projects on hold because their ukranian devs are getting shelled, really stopped me from buying the dip on some the last few days since nobody can answer "wen roadmap"
- cutler 5y agoIf anyone is really serious about creating an alternative currency which is capable of revolutionising finance make it impossible to profit from speculation with it. As it stands cryptocurrency is just more of the same from the little man's perspective - another toy for rich kids to try to take from society without giving anything back.
- electriclove 5y agoHow it broke is pretty well understood. Is there a path forward to save the ecosystem? I think this is the more interesting question
- herbst 5y agoI never owned UST, never got asked if I accept it or anything. I never understood why the currency seems so relevant. Now I know it's because a few big investors. The only stablecoins I see actively used in the real world are Tether and Binance. My point is, nothing changed and nothing of value was lost for a big part of the crypto community.
- mekster 5y agoWhat these smart contracts and whatnot aren't taking into account is that people are dumb. Not sure how many more examples are needed before people realize the rules need to be a bit more flexible to accommodate human mistakes. Those products are meant to cause financial losses on first bug which obviously doesn't work.
- hathym 5y agojust listen to this, it's insane: https://twitter.com/101_buckets/status/1525347695505850368?s=20&t=MmMaa2Q3sK5Q0jQpq3yyEw https://twitter.com/101_buckets/status/1525347695505850368?s...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Linda703 5y ago[dead]
- scotty79 5y agoIs there anyone who understands LUNA/UST setup so well that can explain it without using crypto/fin babble? EDIT: Somebody here posted this: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-05-11/terra-flops https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-05-11/terra-... It's a pretty decent explanation.
- xg15 5y agoThe favourite saying of german milennial teenagers comes to mind again: Eine Dose Mitleid!
- dav_Oz 5y agoStablecoins are the grease for CEXs the gateway (drug) for - since a lot of people trust their keys in the hands of the exchanges themselves - "claims" on listed cryptocurrency tokens. In service of efficiency and maximizing profits: claims on cash with claims on digital tokens. I will leave out the massive inflationary use of cryptocurrencies themselves like CEXs issuing their own tokens as a bonus sideline. At this point one could easily argue that the market cap lists are advertisement panels controlled by CEXs disguised as score boards (filled with "sponsors".) As we know from the practices of centuries old fractional reserving (how much does a bank has to hold on reverseves to create some amount money (credit) out of thin air?) "traditional" stablecoins are most certainly backed by (intransparent) fractional reserves, the most infamous one being Tether. For all we know they could be running at whatever is needed (some percent) to keep the machine barely running by people cashing out. Sooner or later triggering events will briefly pause the music on those merry trips to Jerusalem - but on this scale of course not equally for all so that those at the centralized sources themselves have enough time and the insight to react accordingly by taking everything they can and run; which again leaves the rest with basically nothing. So, in short exactly the opposite of what were/are the stated goal of cryptocurrencies. From that perspective I am eagerly awaiting the next iterations of CEXs and at some point after a lot of financial casualties the growing awareness of their abusive ecosystem of playing into the addictive and destructive nature of gambling fueled by the financial insecurities and disillusionment of social mobility a lot of people are facing in the real world. But I guess, this will be a long fight.
- Lapsa 5y agothis is entertaining
- zby 5y agoWhat is puzzling me right now: Why LUNA is now trading at $0.033 at Bitfinex - but $0.0004 at Kraken? I understand that it is probably impossible to arbitrage it now - but two orders of magnitude? Come on! Why UST is still trading at $0.16 - even without arbitrage mechanism to stabilize it? Some people still have hopes. This might go on for some more time. The revival plan is to emit a new token and give away some of it to UST holders (https://agora.terra.money/t/terra-ecosystem-revival-plan/8701 https://agora.terra.money/t/terra-ecosystem-revival-plan/870...) - even if that new token gets the $1 value (which is probably not possible any more for algorithmic stable coins) - than still the 10% of $1B would mean $100M - that is 20 times less than the current market cap - so the UST price should be about $0.008 assuming that it all works. It is impossible to short it at Bitfinex right now though. There might still be some value of the Terra ecosystem - so many talented people working on it, even a bankrupt startup can get some price via acquihire - but the Terra ecosystem was a ponzi schema maybe its value should be negative? https://twitter.com/zby/status/1525407557371691008 https://twitter.com/zby/status/1525407557371691008
- LeicaLatte 5y agoSoftware was eating the world. So much that it has started to eat itself. How predictable.
- xtat 5y agoOof, not the most unbiased press
- naveen99 5y agoIt would be funny if someone issues a stable coin for usd and then turns around and levers up on treasuries. And then interest rates go up and they get margin called on their treasuries position by their bank, oops !