20 ms·
The strange business of hole-in-one insurance
- _lqaf 5y agoThis seems to get closer to the "is it insurance, or is it gambling?" line than many things.
- Denvercoder9 5y agoWell, that line mostly boils down to whether the expected value of the bet is positive, and the insurer in the article seems to do pretty sound analysis to ensure his expected return is positive. I don't see where it gets close to gambling.
- jimkleiber 5y agoWell, I'd say if the insurer is the house, then the insuree might be the gambler.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThe insuree feels like a gambler to the insurer/house, but they never get the money. Their goal is the exact opposite of gambling, to pay a fixed fee to remove variance.
- rileymat2 5y agoI am not sure insurance v. gambling has anything to do with expected value. Typically, I see the distinction as protecting something you already have compared to getting something new.
- gregplaysguitar 5y agoNeither have a positive return as far as the gambler/insuree is concerned, if they do, they casino/insurer will not stay in business for long! The difference is that one has a potential huge upside, the other prevents a potential huge downside
- genewitch 5y agoOne should keep in mind that the literal "best odds", as far as i know, at any casino are on "Don't" bets on craps, after the shooter lands a number and the button says "ON". With odds on your Don't bet, you can take the house edge down to 0.13%, or 13 cents for every $100 you bet. If you don't feel like "laying odds" you can place "Come" bets with odds behind them for 0.16%. I rarely play don't, but when i do, i'm the shooter!
- sampo 5y ago> the insurer in the article seems to do pretty sound analysis to ensure his expected return is positive Just like casinos ensure their expected return is positive. So?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoMost people don't have that as the distinction. The distinction has tended to be defined around "are you creating new risk?" If yes = gambling. If no = insurance (or hedging).
- joezydeco 5y agoThere's no difference between an actuary working at State Farm and a sports bookmaker at Caesar's. Except for the pari-mutuel aspect.
- yccs27 5y agoI guess the difference is not in the transaction itself. The key part is that insurance counteracts a risk on your part: If it lowers the variance of your final balance, it's insurance. If it raises the variance, it's gambling.
- FireBeyond 5y agoWhen I was at Microsoft about 15-16 years ago there was a fairly big poker setup. Where I was, and I'm sure across the board, the advice that was given was that we were free to have tournaments on company property, however, one of the rules were that you could never actively bet truly blind, i.e. you had to see your cards first. According to whomever decided that, that was sufficient to keep your poker game a game of skill, and not gambling, since if you didn't know your hand, you were just relying on luck, not playing odds.
- adanto6840 5y agoGuessing that there was no rake? How were the dealers being paid, though?
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoI love these longform Hustle articles. A good portion of the time they find something fun that I would have never thought about and have an informative writing style that still keeps it fun.
- dgritsko 5y ago> The cost to insure against a hole-in-one is dependent on 3 factors: > 1. The number of golfers in the tournament > 2. The length (yardage) of the contest hole > 3. The cash value of the hole-in-one prize > Once a client provides this information, Gilmartin plugs it into an algorithm that computes the odds, factors in his risk and margins, and spits out a dollar amount per golfer. This seems like it could work as a simplified example of how all insurance pricing works, although with many, many more variables involved I'm sure. It'd be fascinating to look at the details of one of these algorithms.
- MivLives 5y agoI'd love to see the weird trends they find on some of the bigger more complex algorithms. Like people who drive red cars born July 2000 with a pet bird are 8 times more likely to get in an accident if they primarily drive near Chicago or Miami. I'm sure it's not that granular but I can dream.
- t_mann 5y agoPeople who drive red cars born July 2000 with a pet bird are 8 times more likely to get in an accident if they primarily drive near Chicago or Miami Hopefully they know their stats modelling well enough to know that's not an actual signal.
- PeterisP 5y agoAch, there may well there be signal in there (and the insurance companies do enough stats modelling to tell if there is) - I mean, isn't the car color a well known example where the people's tendency to drive recklessly is correlated with their choice of buying a boring color or a flashy one?
- petercooper 5y agoOne of the things that swings the price a fair bit in the UK is your job title which has always intrigued me as a signal. I could understand if it's someone using their car for deliveries or as a race car, but I'm unsure why a "counsellor" could be paying double the premiums of a "Web developer" on standard insurance.
- t_mann 5y agoI also remember reading about a few sad stories where organisers tried to renege on those prices by changing the terms ('only for registered pros'...).
- joezydeco 5y agoI'd recommend The Man with the $100,000 Breasts by Michael Konik. It's a collection of gambling stories but has a heavy focus on bookmaking and how a lot of these operations work.
- metadat 5y agoWho can resist a title like that? Direct link to PDF: https://www.lasvegasadvisor.com/shop/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/ManBookSample.pdf https://www.lasvegasadvisor.com/shop/wp-content/uploads/2017...
- genewitch 5y agoThere's something about the way books about gambling are written that draws me in. One i picked up at a yard sale or thrift store in the 90s, "How to Win At Cards ("21" and Poker), Dice, Races, Roulette" by Mike Goodman (1967) has a similar feel, although Goodman's book could have used an editor to make sure the storytelling went in a straight line. as an "ok" poker player (Texas hold'em being my favorite), i would host 2 table poker games with $5-$20 buy ins a couple times a month, and I'd generally win. I had clay chips, proper felt, snacks, booze, the works. What i always found funny, though, is if you quizzed me right now about the ranks of hands i'd probably get it wrong. I don't know the odds of an inside vs an outside straight (although with a regular 4 function calculator i could work it out directly), nor do i know what the exact odds are of any hand, really. In person, most of the time, i can tell if someone's holding or bluffing. I even took my game on the road a few times to hang out with dealers from atlantic city in vegas, toured the "Indian Casinos" like Agua Caliente in California, the river boats in Louisiana. But i don't really understand the game. I just like it. So i would get cleaned out in a hurry in any "real" tournament. I don't play poker anymore, no one to play with. I haven't been to a casino since late 2019, even though they've been open; but not because of fear of catching something. I saw a picture of what the casino nearest me had done to their craps tables (my preferred casino game when i'm not too lazy to stand up), they went fully digital! Just give me a pair of dice, not some touchscreen shenanigans. this went long. Oops. I'm gunna find that book and read the rest of it, for sure.
- wil421 5y ago
- dr_orpheus 5y ago"If a sponsor wants contestants to throw a ping-pong ball through a hole in a watermelon, he’ll go outside with his employees and re-create it himself, recording the results." Kind of funny that he ends up doing some "market research" himself. I also wonder what this is like for the employees. If you really want a good statistical average to base it off of how much time do they spend doing it? Is is "yay, we get to have recess and go do some silly activity in the middle of the day" or "come on boss, I've been throwing this ping pong ball at a watermelon for 9 hours, can I go home yet?"
- lordnacho 5y agoPlus the employee will get better and better at it, biasing the insurance towards the conservative side.
- Nextgrid 5y agoIf the activity is easy/cheap to recreate it's probably good to assume that advantage players will also do the same practice to improve their odds.
- myself248 5y agoWell that's also something you want to model. You don't just track the numbers you achieve all day, you track the first minute, the next 29 minutes, the next 7 1/2 hours, and see how it changes. Then that tells you whether someone at home who knows they're gonna be throwing pingpong balls into watermelons tomorrow, and does some practicing today, can measurably improve their chances. So now you price the insurance differently depending on whether the challenge is announced to the contestants in advance, or if it's a surprise when they arrive at the event. How differently? You now have data for that.
- francisofascii 5y ago> A standard tournament with 100 golfers playing a 165-yard hole with a $10k prize sets an event back ~$235. The $235 price just seems like two high a cost. I don't think the hole in one contest adds that much value to the event experience. If you are charging $80-100 per participant, and the course is already charging you $50 per player. You are eating 5 players worth of profit. These contests are always on the hardest, 170+ yard holes, so an ace is more rare than the 1 in 12.5k statistic.
- jpollock 5y agoThink of this as business continuity insurance. It costs you 5 players $100/player - $50/player, sure. However, if you aren't insured and they make the shot, then the tournament is instantly in the red and can't even afford to pay the course fees if it pays the prize. Bankrupt, pick who loses, the course or the player. It might even be fraud, lots of things are fraud. If the tournament is well funded and planning to be around a while, they can self-insure and eat that cost. However, a new tournament, or a non-commercial one isn't likely to have backing like that.
- nkurz 5y agoI think the OP's point wasn't that one should skip insurance, but that one simply shouldn't offer a $10000 prize for a hole-in-one. He's doubting that you would get 5 extra players by offering such a prize, and that the players wouldn't have a sufficiently better experience to justify the event. I'm not sure: your advertising likely becomes a lot easier if you have "$10000 Prize" in big letters at the top of the page, and if someone does win, you probably get all sorts of free press. In the end, it probably all depends on the purpose of the event.
- a4isms 5y agoThe OP may be right in theory: If someone ws just trying to decide whether to play your tournament or stay home, offering a hole-in-one bonus might not have enough of an effect to justify the expense. But in practice, there might be a dozen charity tournaments in the same region as your tournament, and if ten of them offer hole-in-one money, you might be in a race-to-the-bottom to get players to play yours and not one of the others. That’s no different than any other competitive pressure, like whether you offer free valet parking for a restaurant. In theory, it might not pay. In practice, it might be necessary to compete.
- honkdaddy 5y ago“Among the weirder things he’s insured? Cow patty bingo (video here). “It’s big in the Midwest,” says Gilmartin. “You divide a big field into, say, 100 squares, give each one a number, then let a cow loose. If the cow poops on a preselected number, the person wins a prize.”” I burst out laughing at this one. Can any Midwestern HNers confirm? Are people watching the cow with bated breath? Are plots closer to the gate considered better?
- chiph 5y agoThere's also chicken-shit bingo in Austin. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOmQ0WSUuBI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOmQ0WSUuBI
- chuzzle 5y agoI mean, I was introduced to meat raffles since moving more into the Midwest but this is next level to me. Granted I live in a metro region so only turkeys roaming around, no cows.
- shagie 5y agoFor those wondering about meat raffles... https://wisconsinlife.org/story/meat-raffle-a-wisconsin-tavern-tradition/ https://wisconsinlife.org/story/meat-raffle-a-wisconsin-tave... ... and an upcoming calendar https://www.meatraffles.com/calendar/wisconsin-meat-raffles.html https://www.meatraffles.com/calendar/wisconsin-meat-raffles....
- shortstuffsushi 5y agoI can't speak to this particular practice, but as a kid, whenever we would go to the parades, people would organize grids in the street to bet where the horses would poop. And then inevitably try to convince the people on the horses to stop over their square and force their horse to go.
- wuuza 5y agoI was generally not interested in my town parade/party day, but we had cow-chip bingo where I'm from in Iowa. So I don't know the "strategy" but it exists.
- lordnacho 5y agoI actually had a chat with a friend about prize indemnity insurance, he's a Lloyd's guy. In the end it's the law of large numbers, pretty much what a casino does: take lots of small positive bets, don't let one bet dominate. If you do get something too big, syndicate it with some of your competitors to spread the risk. Of course also make sure everyone who comes for insurance is actually what you think, like the guy in the article says it's not necessarily a hugely detailed check but it is enough to stop the worst frauds. You want a model that's robust, and you only have so much data about how often some guy hits a hole in one or a half court shot, and there's only so much you can know about whether they are a pro and the distance to the hole. The big problem seemed to be competition. You only get to write the insurance if you're the best price but the best price is not necessarily one that makes sense for the business. If some guy is buying market share with a loss leader, what do you do? Every segment of the market could be affected by this at a given time.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoThis last part is true of any insurance. And it's not just buying market share which can cause it - pure stupidity can too.
- jaggederest 5y agoEven more subtly, if there is one insurance company that makes a lot of extra return on their "float" (the money that has been paid in premiums but not yet paid out in claims), they may actually sell insurance that is a "bad bet", i.e. is expected to have underwriting losses, but that the time value of money makes profitable for them. In that context other insurance companies can't compete unless they also are making huge returns on their float. It drives risky behavior by insurance companies in exactly the opposite way you'd prefer.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoI tend to put that in the stupid bucket too.
- glonq 5y agoI used to work at a place that ran a hole-in-one competition at many golf courses around North America. Can confirm that we used insurance to cover our ass.
- a4isms 5y agoI used to have a reinsurance company as a client. For those unfamiliar, that’s an insurance company that sells insurance to insurance companies. Example: You buy a $1,000,000 automobile liability insurance policy with a $1,000 deductible. If the insurance company doesn’t sell enough of these kinds of policies to reliably offset payouts with premiums, they might turn around and buy a policy from a reinsurance company with a $10,000,000 limit and a $100,000 deductible against their entire portfolio. Thus, reinsurance companies spend a lot of time thinking about things that don’t happen very often but can be very expensive when they happen. And yes, they had a division that did propositions like hole-in-ones, and also they insured legal betting companies against wild trifectas and that sort of thing. I have a small trove of stories they told me about bizarre accidents that wound up costing enormous amounts of money.
- sharkweek 5y agoI had a friend who dabbled in rare collectables and he told me you can almost always find a broker willing to insure, quite literally, anything.
- FireBeyond 5y agoLloyds of London are quite open and proud of being willing to insure anything - they've insured singer's voices, model's legs, all manner of things.
- johnwalkr 5y agoThe first Xprize was awarded through a hole-in-one insurance policy, sometimes with the monthly fee just barely paid on time out of someone's personal pocket and set to expire shortly after the prize was actually awarded (so there was no simple extension possible).
- 323 5y agoThe best sport event insurance ever: > 2020: Wimbledon to receive $141 million in pandemic insurance payout > For each of the past 17 years, the All-England Lawn Tennis Club has paid for an insurance policy to guard against losses if Wimbledon should have to be canceled in the event of a worldwide pandemic. That preparation will finally pay off this year. https://eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/tennis/2020/04/09/wimbledon-pandemic-insurance-policy-payout-141-million/5123987002/ https://eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/tennis/2020/04/09/wimbl...
- ineedasername 5y agoI'm guessing these insurance premiums are quite a bit higher than they were 3 years ago.
- eru 5y agoProbably yes. Though objectively, they probably shouldn't be? I mean, the world is better prepared now to avoid and deal with pandemics than we were 3 years ago.
- pierre 5y agoMost of the hole-in-one cover payout do not happen for contest, but for individual that are insured against a hole in one. (source: I work for an insurer) It is a common provision on the kind of insurance that come attached to a credit card, and you probably are cover for it if you own a premium card in the US or Europe. It generally come with different variation: only on registered games / all games, fix cash amount or expense of the drinks at the club, ... A common exclusion is that you can not own a professional golf licence. A few examples: A British Bank Travel insurance (page 33) https://assets.ctfassets.net/s0jgb0x75qln/413D8sFB4gVNoNWZXng81r/89479fdd09748f70382ed78d52ca193f/co-op-travel-insurance-policy-document.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/s0jgb0x75qln/413D8sFB4gVNoNWZXn... Amex (page 85) https://americanexpress.com/content/dam/amex/za/network/documents/Bryte.pdf https://americanexpress.com/content/dam/amex/za/network/docu...
- stavros 5y agoWait, I don't understand. They pay you if you get a hole in one?!
- slavik81 5y agoIf you're travelling and play a round of golf at a resort where it is customary for any person who lands a hole-in-one to buy everyone in the clubhouse a round of drinks, then if you land a hole-in-one and have to buy everyone a round of drinks, AMEX travel insurance will reimburse you for the cost of the drinks. It's a completely different thing from the insurance described in the main article.
- bdcravens 5y agoA large furniture store in Houston does this with almost every large sporting event (Super Bowl, World Series, etc) - purchases over $3500 are free if X happens. https://www.galleryfurniture.com/kentucky-derby-wia.html https://www.galleryfurniture.com/kentucky-derby-wia.html
- dwighttk 5y ago> But one entity wasn’t celebrating: the insurance firm that had been hired by the organizers. Only if they are bad at insurance.
- mastazi 5y agoThere was an episode of Adventures In Golf about this topic, it was quite entertaining https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkse_SuJysI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkse_SuJysI
- krisoft 5y ago> Gilmartin has also had to pay out at least 4 $1m prizes, which are typically awarded in annuities. Hargett, who landed that shot in Utah, got $25k/year for 40 years Why would anyone accept that payment schedule? Sure 25k*40 is a million, but there is a non-zero chance that the insurance company will fold in that time. Plus 25k in 40 years is worth a lot less than 25k today due to inflation. If they advertised a million dollar prize, I win it and then they tell me it is actually 25k over 40 years I would be calling my lawyer there and then to negotiate with them.
- etrevino 5y agoI believe they actually buy an annuity with a bank.
- zizee 5y agoThe prize would have been offered as "1 million dollars^" ^ see terms and conditions
- phil21 5y ago> If they advertised a million dollar prize, I win it and then they tell me it is actually 25k over 40 years This is pretty much how almost all of these things go, including the state and multi-state lottery jackpots. You can choose your $300M Powerball payout to be paid over 30-40 years, or you can take $125M (very loose numbers) today. Most recipients choose the cash payout, even though of course the jackpot is advertised at the annuity value.
- a4isms 5y agoAs someone else noted, typically they buy an annuity to pay you out, so risk of non-payment is not a significant factor. The annuity is better for them because they don’t have to carry your payments as a liability. The annuity is often better for the recipient as well if their jurisdiction taxes the winnings. The recipient could be collecting winnings in their retirement when their income including the annuity would be low. I am not an insurer, banker, or tax consultant, so don’t take my word for how to proceed should you win such a thing!
- 5y ago
- doyleb 5y agoFun fact: We use the same kind of insurance for the weekly $10,000,000 sweepstakes at Yotta: https://www.withyotta.com https://www.withyotta.com
- doyleb 5y agoThe insurance companies actually love this since there's no element of skill involved so the odds of winning can be computed exactly
- shepherdjerred 5y agoHow do you make money? It seems too good to be true with all of the bonuses and promotions the site touts.
- doyleb 5y ago"Too good to be true" is definitely a problem we run into. We make money the same way any bank does, via lending out the deposits and via a small interchange fee charged to the merchant when customers use our cards. Our net prizes paid out are comparable with other high yield savings accounts / rewards credit cards but the random reward makes it (hopefully) more engaging
- saganus 5y agoFunny that in one of the info cards it says "MILITARY-GRADE SECURITY" and then inside that same card: "Your account is protected by bank-grade encryption and authentication." A unique marketing model nevertheless.
- heleninboodler 5y agoI wonder how the prices end up for very small groups. It would be amazing to be out golfing with a small group and throw down a $50k bet while standing on the tee of a par 3. There must be some requirements like having a witness, though.
- thatguy0900 5y agoThe example it gives of a million dollar prize was 6 contestents for 1k
- comprev 5y agoSeems most appropriate to mention this film [0] The Man Who Sued God [0] https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0268437/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0268437/
- SteveGerencser 5y agoThe jewelry store I worked at for a decade still sponsors a hole in one at the annual golf tournament next door. Get a hole-in-one on a specific hole and you get a Rolex. We had our own insurance policy for that to cover the cost of the Rolex should someone hit it. Which they did once every few years.
- runnr_az 5y agoThere was a Planet Money about this a few years ago... https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/09/07/645689694/episode-836-the-13th-hole https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/09/07/645689694/epis... ... it talks about what happens when a Hole in One is actually achieved, some of the weirdness that can ensue...
- Esther432q 5y ago
- frogpelt 5y ago"ripe with [competition]" vs. "rife with [competition]" https://afterdeadline.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/08/31/is-it-ripe-or-rife/ https://afterdeadline.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/08/31/is-it-rip... I don't know why I notice these things.
- willejs 5y agoPricenomics (great book too) did an article in 2014 worth a read and seemingly there is a previous HN thread too https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8086288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8086288
- john_cogs 5y agoI was playing golf on Sunday and a player in a nearby group made a hole-in-one. Everyone at the course got a free drink that day. I later found out that the club had insurance. Funny to see this on the HN front page a couple of days later.
- creaghpatr 5y agoThat's nice the club had that, sometimes the player is expected to pay for the drinks!
- abirch 5y agoDo they have a shipped on time insurance?
- kyleblarson 5y agoAs a golfer when I got my first hole in one I was more than happy to spring for everyone's whiskeys and beers at the turn.
- RickJWagner 5y agoJust before college I worked as a greenskeeper's assistant on a golf course. We had a tournament, there was a big prize for a hole in one on a specific hole. On that hole, the boss insisted on setting the pin himself. (Pin placement has a lot to do with the chances of a hole in one.) The boss put it where it was most likely to happen. He explained that the tournament was insured, they wanted somebody to win. The publicity would have been fantastic. Alas, the luck wasn't there. Nobody won the big prize that year.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe most famous example I'm aware of is when Warren Buffet insured the "Billion Dollar Bracket" challenge for QuickBooks, which would pay off if someone had a perfect NCAA bracket. That's 63 correct binary choices, so the odds that anyone gets it are incredibly low. Of course, they were using his fame to help sell the challenge, but I wondered what premium he got.
- Sanzig 5y agoNaively going by expected value, 1e9/2^63 gives about $0.12 per participant as a reasonable starting point. But it is a weird one: the risk is really small but the required payout is massive.
- HWR_14 5y agoA 50-50 result for every sporting event is an absurd assumption. For instance, 4 of those 63 are 1-16 matches of which I think one or two in history have gone the 16's way. I'm guessing they needed to estimate the number of participants, but I don't know that either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- isolli 5y agoFrom what I remember, Buffet stated that the main risk for him was of someone somehow hacking the system and changing their bet after the fact. All without being detected, of course.
- romeo009 5y ago
- stevage 5y agoAnyone else find the numbers in that table strange? Compare the figures for 72 vs 144 golfers: $7,500 vacation: $150 / $250 (1.66 ratio) $60k car: $865 / $1,686 (1.949 ratio) Why would the ratio depend on the cost of the payout?
- psnehanshu 5y agoIs this only me or someone else also experiencing? The page keeps reloading and never stops.
- Intermernet 5y agoI was accompanying a friend of mine around a golf tournament years ago when he got a hole in one. The tournament prize was a brand new Mercedes. Unfortunately, my friend was the trainee golf pro at the club, and was playing as an employee of the club. This invalidated his win. He was actually pretty cool about this, but the tournament sponsors decided that they could then cancel that prize offering for any subsequent players. This was contentious amongst the other players, but no one else managed to get the hole in one, so no one had a valid reason to initiate an official protest. I still wonder about the technical validity of the sponsor's argument.
- 6stringmerc 5y agoI worked in reinsurance. It is an ugly system of regulated 20% profits by law that prey on the least financially stable because by law they must buy it. Then some suit wearing gold Rolex leasing an Audi S7 bundles them at his firm and goes and peddles their book to a bunch of overseas dark money. Like screw bitcoin investigations, there are billions of dirty dollars sloshing around in London, the Caribbean, Europe and I think Macau is getting in on it. The industry should be dismantled and the profiteering white collar not-criminals-because-it’s-legal-and-they-pay-to-keep-it-that-way scum should finish their careers in labor camps to repay their debt to society as a whole. You think I’m kidding.